Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3

ABHAY ROOFING SOLUTIONS

Property PEB Buildings Conventional Buildings


STRUCTURE WEIGHT 1) Pre engineered buildings are on 1) Primary steel members are
the average 30% lighter because of selected hot rolled “T” sections.
the efficient use of steel. Primary Which are, in many segments of the
framing members are tapered built members heavier than what is
up section. With the large depths in actually required by design?
areas of higher stress. Members have constant cross
section regardless of the varying
2) Secondary members are light magnitude of the local stresses along
weight roll formed “Z” or “C” shaped the member length.
members.
2) Secondary members are selected
from standard hot rolled sections
which are much heavier.
DESIGN 1) Quick and efficient: since PEB’s are 1) Each conventional steel structure
mainly formed by standard sections is designed from scratch with fewer
and connections design, time is design aids available to the engineer.
significantly reduced. Basic design
based on international design codes 2) Substantial engineering and
are used over and over. detailing work is required from the
very basic is required by the
2) Specialized computer analysis consultant with fewer design aids.
design programs optimize material
required. Drafting is also 3) Extensive amount of consultant
computerized using standard detail time is devoted to the alterations
that minimize the use of project that have to be done.
custom details.
4) As each project is a new project
3) Design shop detail sketches and engineers need more time to
erection drawings are supplied free develop the designs and details of
of cost by the manufacturer. the unique structure.
Approval drawing is usually prepared
within in 2 weeks.

4) PEB designers design and detail


PEB buildings almost every day of
the year resulting in improving the
quality of designs every time they
work
DELIEVERY Average 6 to 8 weeks Average 20 to 26 weeks
FOUNDATIONS Simple design, easy to construct and Extensive, heavy foundation
light weight. required.
ERECTION SIMPLICITY 1) Both costs and time of erection 1) Typically, conventional steel
ABHAY ROOFING SOLUTIONS
are accurately known based upon buildings are 20% more expensive
extensive experience with similar than PEB in most of the cases, the
buildings. erection costs and time are not
estimated accurately.
2) The erection process is faster and
much easier with very less 2)Erection process is slow and
requirement for equipment. extensive field labour is required.
Heavy equipment is also needed.

SEISMIC RESISTANCE The low weight flexible frames offer Rigid heavy frames do not perform
higher resistance to seismic forces. well in seismic zones.
OVER ALL PRICE Price per square meter may be as Higher price per square meter.
low as by 30 % than the conventional
building.
ARCHITECTURE Outstanding architectural design can Special architectural design and
be achieved at low cost using features must be developed for each
standard architectural details and project which often require research
interfaces. and thus resulting in higher cost.
SOURCING AND COORDINATION Building is supplied complete with all Many sources of supply are there so
accessories including erection for a it becomes difficult to co ordinate
single “ONE STOP SOURCE”. and handle the things.
COST OF CHARGE ORDER 1) PEB manufactures usually stock a 1) Substitution of hot rolled sections
large amount of that can be flexibly infrequently rolled by mills is
used in many types of PEB projects. expensive and time consuming.

2) Change orders are easily 2) Change orders that are made after
accommodated at all stages of the the dispatch of hot rolled sections
order fulfilment process. Little or no result in increasing the time and cost
material is wasted even if a change involved in the project.
order is made after fabrication starts.
BUILDING ACCESSORIES Designed to fit the system with Every project requires different and
standardized and inter changeable special design fro accessories and
parts. Including pre designed flashing special sourcing for each item.
and trims. Building accessories are Flashing and trims must be uniquely
mass produced for economy and are designed and fabricated.
available with the building.
FUTURE EXPANSIONS 1)All project records are safely and 1) It would be difficult to obtain
orderly kept in electronic format project records after a long period of
which makes it easy for the owner to time. It is required to contact more
obtain a copy of his building record than one number of parties.
at any time.
2)Future expansion is most tedious
2) Future expansion is very easy and and more costly.
simple.

SAFETY AND RESPONSIBILTY Single source of responsibility is Multiple responsibilities can result in
there because all the job is being question of who is responsible when
done by one supplier. the components do not fit in
properly, insufficient material is
supplied or parts fail to perform
particularly at the
supplier/contractor interface.
PERFORMANCE 1) All components have been 1) Components are custom designed
specified and designed specially to for a specific application on a specific
act together as a system for job. Design and detailing errors are
maximum efficiency, precise fir and possible when assembling the
ABHAY ROOFING SOLUTIONS
peak performance in the field. diverse components into unique
buildings.
2)Experience with similar buildings,
in actual field conditions worldwide, 2) Each building design is unique, so
has resulted in design improvements predication, of how components will
over time, which allow dependable perform together is uncertain.
prediction of performance. Materials which have performed well
in some climates may not do well in
other conditions.

You might also like