Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Essay City of Glass
Essay City of Glass
Essay City of Glass
Secondly, Barthes wrote an essay in which he stated that the author is a new
concept of the western world. Roland Barthes argues that literary pieces should
not be analyzed together with the biography and context of the writer; the
reader must interpret the meaning of that piece of writing. Previous experiences
will also help to the understanding of a text. In addition, he says that writers are
like musicians, they only put together a series of pre-existing chords or notes.
Finally, J.L. Borges wrote the short story, which appears in ‘Ficciones’,
called Pierre Menard, author del Quijote. The story is about Pierre Menard who
wrote his own exact version of The Quixote. Borges wants to highlight the idea
that no matter how identical the works can be if two different people utter the
same words, the meaning will not be the same. The narrator of the story also
emphasizes that the question of authorship is not something to worry about
“Menard, acaso sin quererlo, ha enriquecido . . . el arte detenido y rudimentario
de la lectura”13 (Borges 59). Thus, the reader is the one who gives sense to a
text; a reader from the eighteenth century did not have the same experiences of
a contemporary reader while reading The Quixote.
Sources
Barthes, Roland. “Le mort de l‟auteur.” Oeuvres Complètes. Tome II. Ed. Éric Marty. Paris:
Éditions du Seuil, 1993.
Print.
Brandon, M. (n.d.). Whose words?: Text and Autorship in Pierre Menard: Autor del Quijote.
Open Journal Systems. York University.
Lamos, I." The Death of The Author: Roland Barthes and The Collapse of Meaning". Filmslie.
Retrieved on April 8, 2018 from: http://filmslie.com/death-of-the-author-roland-barthes-
meaning/