Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Taft equation: Polar substituent constants, σ
Taft equation: Polar substituent constants, σ
Taft equation: Polar substituent constants, σ
The Taft equation is a linear free energy relationship (LFER) used in physical organic chemistry in the
study of reaction mechanisms and in the development of quantitative structure–activity relationships for Constants used in the Taft
equation[
organic compounds. While the Hammett equation accounts for how field, inductive, and resonance effects
influence reaction rates, the Taft equation also describes the steric effects of a substituent. The Taft
t Substituent Es σ*
equation is written as:
–H 1.24 0.49
–CH3 0 0
where is the ratio of the rate of the substituted reaction compared to the reference –CH(CH3)2 –0.47 –0.19
Due to the similar tetrahedral intermediates, Taft proposed that under identical conditions any steric factors should be nearly the same for
the two mechanisms and therefore would not influence the ratio of the rates. However, because of the difference in charge buildup in the
rate determining steps it was proposed that polar effects would only influence the reaction rate of the base catalyzed reaction since a new
charge was formed. He defined the polar substituent constant σ* as:
where log(ks/kCH3)B is the ratio of the rate of the base catalyzed reaction compared to the reference reaction, log(ks/kCH 3)A is ratio of a rate
of the acid catalyzed reaction compared to the reference reaction, and ρ* is a reaction constant that describes the sensitivity of the reaction
series. For the definition reaction series, ρ* was set to 1 and R = methyl was defined as the reference reaction (σ* = zero). The factor of
1/2.48 is included to make σ* similar in magnitude to the Hammett σ values.
From comparing the Es values for methyl, ethyl, isopropyl, and tert-butyl, it is seen that the value increases with increasing steric bulk.
However, because context will have an effect on steric interactions[7] some Es values can be larger or smaller than expected. For example,
the value for phenyl is much larger than that for tert-butyl. When comparing these groups using another measure of steric bulk, axial strain
values, the tert-butyl group is larger.[8]
Sensitivity factors
Polar sensitivity factor, ρ*
Similar to ρ values for Hammett plots, the polar sensitivity factor ρ* for Taft plots will describe the susceptibility of a reaction series to polar
effects. When the steric effects of substituents do not significantly influence the reaction rate the Taft equation simplifies to a form of the
Hammett equation:
The polar sensitivity factor ρ* can be obtained by plotting the ratio of the measured reaction rates (ks) compared to the reference reaction (
) versus the σ* values for the substituents. This plot will give a straight line with a slope equal to ρ*. Similar to the Hammett ρ value:
If ρ* > 1, the reaction accumulates negative charge in the transition state and is accelerated by electron withdrawing groups.
If 1 > ρ* > 0, negative charge is built up and the reaction is mildly sensitive to polar effects.
If ρ* = 0, the reaction is not influenced by polar effects.
If 0 > ρ* > −1, positive charge is built up and the reaction is mildly sensitive to polar effects.
If −1 > ρ*, the reaction accumulates positive charge and is accelerated by electron donating groups.
A plot of the ratio of the rates versus the Es value for the substituent will give a straight line with a slope equal to δ. Similarly to the Hammett
ρ value, the magnitude of δ will reflect to what extent a reaction is influenced by steric effects:
A very steep slope will correspond to high steric sensitivity, while a shallow slope will correspond to little to no sensitivity.
Since Es values are large and negative for bulkier substituents, it follows that:
If δ is positive, increasing steric bulk decreases the reaction rate and steric effects are greater in the transition state.
If δ is negative, increasing steric bulk increases the reaction rate and steric effects are lessened in the transition state.