Project 2.

4 Pull Toy Construction Rubric

Element 5 Points 4 Points 3 Points 2 Points 1-0 Points

Design brief is
completed
and includes
all required
information,
including
Design brief Design brief is
client,
Design Design brief is Design brief is is less than less than 25%
designer,
Brief 80% complete. 50% complete 50% complete or
problem
complete missing.
statement,
design
statement,
constraints
and
deliverables.
The design
The project
The project process
includes a
design process Some design notes do not There is little
Design detailed step-
notes do not process notes describe or no evidence
Process by-step
explain all are missing or work done at of design
Notes description of
steps incomplete. each step of process notes.
the design
thoroughly. the design
process.
process.
Research is
Research is
documented
documented on
with There is no
some topics.
appropriate Research is research
One or two do
citations. randomly other than There is little
not have
Research completed what is or no evidence
Research proper citation
shows a with little or no available of research in
information.
variety of documentation from the the notebook.
Research is
resources and of sources. textbook or
limited to two
is not limited lecture notes.
or three
to one or two
resources.
sources.
One or two
Three
sketches are
sketches are
incomplete and Sketches are
complete and
are missing missing more Sketches are
annotated to
important than half of the not complete.
show all
information, identification Heading
important
such as of the information is There is little
information.
Design measurements. components. not complete or no evidence
Heading
Sketches Some heading More than half and is not of sketches in
information is
information is of the heading accurate. the notebook.
complete and
incomplete or information is Sketches are
accurate. All
inaccurate. All not complete not created
designs are
designs are or is not with pencil.
unique and
unique and are accurate.
are completed
completed in
in pencil.
pencil.
The decision
The decision matrix is
The decision
matrix is The decision The decision missing both
Copyright © 2017 Project Lead The Way, Inc. All rights reserved.
 complete with matrix does not matrix criteria criteria and matrix is
all criteria evaluate the are evaluations excessively
Decision listed and required incomplete. of drawings. incomplete or
Making each drawing number of The option The final missing. The
Matrix evaluated. drawings. The selected is not project final project
The student student can clearly justified decision decision
can effectively justify the final using the cannot be cannot be
justify the final decision. matrix. justified justified using
decision. using the the matrix.
matrix.
A significant
A significant difference
difference exists
A slight
exists between between the
The final difference The pull toy
the final final product
product exists between model is
product and and the final
Prototypes exactly the final excessively
the final design. No
matches the product and incomplete or
design, but an apparent
final design. the final is missing.
attempt was attempt was
design.
made to follow made to
the design. follow the
design.
Students test
Students test
and evaluate Students test Students test
and evaluate
their and evaluate and evaluate
their
prototype, their prototype, their prototype
prototype, Students do
make make and some
Test and modifications not test and
modifications modifications if modifications
Evaluate are not evaluate their
if necessary, necessary, but are completed,
completed, prototype.
and changes are but changes
and changes
thoroughly not are not
are not
document documented. documented.
documented.
changes.
The student The student
The student does not does not
consistently always listen to other
The student
listens to all effectively team
generally
team listen to team members,
listens to team
members, members or does not
members,
respects show respect show respect The student
respects
varying for varying for varying shows little to
varying
opinions, opinions. The opinions, and no evidence of
opinions,
communicates student does does not communication
communicates
ideas and not always effectively or cooperation.
Teamwork ideas and
opinions communicate communicate Student does
opinions
effectively, ideas and ideas and not complete
effectively, and
and engages opinions or opinions or their portion of
engages in
in engage in engage in the project on
compromise.
compromise. compromise. compromise. time.
Student
Student Student Student
completes their
completes completes completes
portion of the
their portion of most of their some of their
project on time.
the project on portion of the portion of the
time. project on project on
time. time.

Copyright © 2017 Project Lead The Way, Inc. All rights reserved.