Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Flat Plate

    Uploaded by

    mochammad baagil
    11 views1 page
    This document compares the costs of different structural designs for a high-rise building project in Indonesia. It analyzes the costs of a conforming reinforced concrete (RC) design, a post-tensioned (PT) design using RC beams, and a flat plate design. The PT design with RC beams reduces concrete usage by 6% and formwork by 32% compared to the conforming RC design, saving an estimated 27% of costs. The flat plate design further reduces rebar usage by 72% and increases PT usage, saving an additional estimated 27% of costs over the conforming RC design.

    Original Description:

    scheme

    Original Title

    flat plate

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    This document compares the costs of different structural designs for a high-rise building project in Indonesia. It analyzes the costs of a conforming reinforced concrete (RC) design, a post-tensioned (PT) design using RC beams, and a flat plate design. The PT design with RC beams reduces concrete usage by 6% and formwork by 32% compared to the conforming RC design, saving an estimated 27% of costs. The flat plate design further reduces rebar usage by 72% and increases PT usage, saving an additional estimated 27% of costs over the conforming RC design.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as pdf or txt
    11 views1 page

    Flat Plate

    Uploaded by

    mochammad baagil
    This document compares the costs of different structural designs for a high-rise building project in Indonesia. It analyzes the costs of a conforming reinforced concrete (RC) design, a post-tensioned (PT) design using RC beams, and a flat plate design. The PT design with RC beams reduces concrete usage by 6% and formwork by 32% compared to the conforming RC design, saving an estimated 27% of costs. The flat plate design further reduces rebar usage by 72% and increases PT usage, saving an additional estimated 27% of costs over the conforming RC design.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 1

    Conforming RC Design

    2 Reinf.
    Conforming RC Design Floor Numbers Nof Area (m ) Concrete 35 MPa (m3) Formwork (m2) PT (kg)
    fy = 400 MPa (kg)
    CarPark Level 6 - 14 9 1,416 365 2,155 50,856 0
    Low Office Level 16 - 29 14 1,892 446 2,804 65,395 0
    High Office Level 31- 44 14 1,892 450 2,823 65,900 0
    Apartment Low Level 48 - 57 10 1,791 452 2,778 67,604 0
    Apartment High Level 59 - 73 15 1,791 452 2,778 67,604 0
    Total for RC Design 110,491 27,127 167,640 3,985,928 0
    Cost IDR IDR 29,839,285,513 IDR 37,718,939,898 IDR 79,718,552,492 IDR 0
    Cost USD USD 2,057,882 USD 2,601,306 USD 5,497,831 USD 0

    PT Design (RC Beams)


    Reinf.
    PT Design (RC Beams) Floor Numbers Nof Area (m2) Concrete 35 MPa (m3) Formwork (m2) PT (kg)
    fy = 400 MPa (kg)
    CarPark Level 6 - 14 9 1,416 355 1,811 39,193 4,849
    Low Office Level 16 - 29 14 1,892 461 2,353 54,669 5,212
    High Office Level 31- 44 14 1,892 467 2,392 57,554 4,956
    Apartment Low Level 48 - 57 10 1,791 443 2,192 54,949 5,843
    Apartment High Level 59 - 73 15 1,791 443 2,192 54,949 5,843
    Total for PT Design 110,491 27,268 137,528 3,297,581 332,078
    Cost IDR IDR 29,994,415,353 IDR 30,943,823,544 IDR 65,951,617,293 IDR 19,260,505,820
    Cost USD USD 2,068,580 USD 2,134,057 USD 4,548,387 USD 1,328,311

    FLAT PLATE
    Reinf.
    Prelim NEW Floor Numbers Nof Area (m2) Concrete 35 MPa (m3) Formwork (m2) PT (kg)
    fy = 400 MPa (kg)
    CarPark Level 6 - 14 9 1,415 365 1,492 23,695 8,351
    Low Office Level 16 - 29 14 1,891 406 1,936 16,257 9,265
    High Office Level 31- 44 14 1,891 406 1,936 16,257 9,265
    Apartment Low Level 48 - 57 10 1,791 435 1,851 17,397 8,775
    Apartment High Level 59 - 73 15 1,791 435 1,851 17,397 8,775
    Total new Design 62 110,454 25,534 113,924 1,103,367 553,962
    Cost IDR IDR 28,087,047,638 IDR 25,632,957,521 IDR 22,067,347,709 IDR 32,129,775,341
    Cost USD USD 1,937,038 USD 1,767,790 USD 1,521,886 USD 2,215,847

    SAVING using PT Slab (QTY) -1,593 -53,715 -2,882,560 553,962


    SAVING using PT with RC Beams (%) -6% -32% -72% -

    CIPUTRA WORLD 1 Tower D Concrete Formwork Reinf. PT TOTAL (USD) TOTAL (IDR)
    Conforming RC Design USD 2,057,881.76 USD 2,601,306.20 USD 5,497,831.21 USD 0.00 USD 10,157,019.17 IDR 147,276,777,903
    Prelim NEW USD 1,937,038 USD 1,767,790 USD 1,521,886 USD 2,215,847 USD 7,442,560.57 IDR 107,917,128,209

    Option 2 Estimated Potential Cost Saving Due to Utracon’s Alternative PT Design (USD) USD 2,714,458.60 IDR 39,359,649,694.10
    Option 2 Estimated Potential Cost Saving Due to Utracon’s Alternative PT Design (%) 27% 27%

    Unit Cost
    Concrete Formwork Rebar PT 1 USD IDR 14,500

    IDR 1,100,000 IDR 225,000 IDR 20,000 IDR 58,000.00


    USD 75.86 USD 15.52 USD 1.38 USD 4.00

    You might also like