Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Final Research Papeeeeeeeeer
Final Research Papeeeeeeeeer
Second Semester
URBAN PLANNING
Submitted by:
Arche, Alliza C.
Espino, Jericho A.
Undag, Mhellever G.
Grade 12 STEM-C
To
March 3, 2018
1|Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABSTRACT ………………… 3
INTRODUCTION
OBJECTIVES ………………… 5
METHODOLOGY ………………… 27 - 29
CONCLUSION ………………… 30
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ………………… 31
REFERENCES ………………… 32
APPENDICES
2|Page
ABSTRACT
Traffic has been a big problem in the Philippines ever since. There are lots
of causes why we are facing this and there are lots of effects to the citizens and
the community too. The researchers came up in proposing this project to lessen
the traffic we are facing, they noticed that there a lot of projects that can be
objective is to help in the lessening of the traffic along the road of Shaw boulevard
and also to avoid accidents. The researchers want to make a project that will be a
big help to the citizens and also to the community. What can be concluded in this
project is there are a lot of ways to help the community, there might be lots of
3|Page
INTRODUCTION
a route, while a traffic jam is a situation in which a long line of vehicles on a road
have stopped moving or are moving very slowly. Of course, traffic is a sign of
progress, but when traffic jams increase, there is no progress. It is a sign of bad
urban planning. As of 2015, 2.4 billion pesos (around $48 million) every day is
being lost to traffic in Metro Manila alone, and it is expected to increase to 6 billion
problems. But what are the solutions that can be proposed to lessen this problem?
The researchers come up to the study as they’ve noticed the traffic on the
roads of Mandaluyong City such as traffic jams during rush hours, reckless driving,
and ignoring the designated loading and unloading zones. The researchers’
motivation for the study is their daily experiences of heavy traffic in Mandaluyong
City as they are students that need to attend classes on time, and not being on
The study only covers the community of Mandaluyong City. It includes the
improper loading and unloading area that can be seen along Shaw Boulevard. The
study targets to help the citizens working and residing in the community. Aside
4|Page
from putting new loading and unloading zones, the project also includes the
improvement of the old loading and unloading areas that stood along Shaw Blvd.
The researchers want to come up with a project that will be a big help to the
project’s objectives are to lessen the heavy traffic along the said road, to develop
a proper loading and unloading zone for people to be organized when waiting for
vehicles and also to avoid road accidents, both minor and major.
City. The importance of the study is also for the people who are experiencing these
issues not just in PUJs, and PUVs, but also to private vehicles complaining about
the problem. Other than that, is to prevent vehicular accidents that causes so much
commotions.
and to make a solution out of it. The researchers came up on studying about the
traffic that Mandaluyong is facing on the past years up to the present. This study
seeks to answer the following questions: 1.) What are the factors that affect the
traffic? 2.) What are the possible solutions to solve the problem that can be drawn
in the community? 3.) What are its significance to the people residing and working
5|Page
DEFINITION OF TERMS
❖ PUJs and PUVs – Public Utility Jeepneys and Public Utility Vehicles
6|Page
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
area or a route, while a traffic jam is a situation in which a long line of vehicles on
It was during the Spanish colonial period when Manila began to grow into
the metropolis it is to this day. The Spanish saw a city of around 4,000 inhabiting
a vast expanse of land by the bay, adequately watered by the Pasig River and its
adjacent waterways. As they built Intramuros, the walled city, they never thought
the new capital city would be filled up during their administration of the archipelago.
The Spanish urban planners laid out the city in grid pattern, a conventional method
during the 16th century. However, they could have not been more wrong. By the
19th century, the narrow streets of Manila are full of calesas (horse-drawn calash)
Spaniards. The government center itself moved from Palacio del Gobernador
called Extramuros). By this time, the colonial government had been investing more
in war than infrastructure, and thus, relying more on unpaid forced labor to maintain
7|Page
The Philippine Revolution and the Philippine-American War managed to
destroy much of the Manila suburbs (arrabales), the neighboring areas outside the
walled city, giving leeway for Americans to implement their own urban planning
Burham, an American architect who drafted the urban planning for Chicago. His
plan for Manila, known as the Burnham Plan, was to concentrate key government
buildings in the city while keeping a wide open field that is Luneta (later, Rizal
Park). The Spanish managed to create an open field in Luneta, but this was not
out of urban planning. It was done because of military convenience, for their
experience during the British invasion in 1762 showed the Spanish how vulnerable
the area is to artillery fire. Burnham planned to enlarge Luneta, following the
example of New York's Central Park and Washington, D.C.'s Capitol Hill. In
addition, he planned a radial or circumferential pattern for the city, deviating from
the Spanish grid pattern. In this 1905 plan, Burnham anticipated a city of 800,000
Even so, the plan went on, until the Commonwealth period. President Manuel
Quezon halted funding for the implementation of the plan, and opted to move the
capital elsewhere. This new capital would be named after him, and thus, Quezon
City. Meanwhile, only three of the 16 planned government buildings were finished,
and among the roads completed was the seaside Dewey Boulevard (later, Roxas
Boulevard). As for traffic, Manila was not as congested as it is later on. Of course,
cars soon replaced the calesas. However, around 40% of passengers were carried
8|Page
kilometers around the city and its suburbs.
Harry Frost and Juan Arellano. Like the Burnham Plan, it would use a radial
pattern. However, Quezon City would have an elliptical circle as the central point
of the radial pattern. This would become the Quezon Memorial Circle. Such a circle
cannot be realized in Manila because it faces the bay. Even Luneta, the central
point of the plan, was not circular, but rectangular in shape. Circumferential roads
such as Luzon Avenue (extending to San Jose del Monte in Bulacan), Visayas
(extending to La Mesa Dam) were included in the plan. Of course, these were not
would contain the "Central Park" as its heart, which was actually located in Diliman,
where the University of the Philippines currently stands. The remaining quarters of
the quadrangle would also contain parks and zoos. However, this was not
completely realized. The roads on this quadrangle have been named after the four
West Avenue (in the west), East Avenue (in the east), and Timog Avenue (in the
south of the quadrangle). All of these roads are part of what is now Epifanio de los
Santos Avenue (EDSA), which finished construction in 1940. However, the Frost-
9|Page
Arellano Plan was not completed as well because the Second World War opened
in the Asia-Pacific in 1941. Still, with slight modifications, this was carried over in
the 1949 Master Plan for the Capital City. Among the modifications include the
which was located in the circle in the 1941 plan, was moved to Constitution Hill in
the 1949 plan. This is where Batasan Hills currently stands, replacing what is
Pambansa itself would not be completed until 1978. By this time, when Quezon
City was designated as capital by President Elpidio Quirino (Republic Act No. 333),
Manila had a population of around 1.6 million. This is already double the capacity
estimated by Burnham in 1905. With the stoppage of the tranvia after the war, no
replaced as the main vehicle for passengers was the jeepney, which was
Whether it was the postwar conditions of the country or not, the Philippine
government did not come up with another major plan, nor implemented any, for
the rapidly urbanizing Manila, Quezon City, and their neighboring areas. By 1960,
President Ferdinand Marcos when a plan would be drafted. Initially, Marcos did a
political reorganization. This formed the region now known as Metro Manila in
1975, and Manila became capital once more. Following this, the MMetroplan,
of the new capital region. This plan takes a step further from the radial pattern by
10 | P a g e
expanding eastward. Since Burnham, the radial pattern of urban planning for
Manila was supposed to go eastward, since the bay hinders further expansion to
the west. However, by 1977, Metro Manila has a population of more than 6 million.
accommodate expansion, which would later become C-5 and C-6. The plan also
provided for areas where urban expansion would be restricted because it is not
suitable. Evidently, among the restricted areas was Marikina Valley, which was
east of Manila. At any rate, the plan was much larger in scale than that of Burnham
or of Frost and Arellano. Another innovation that is otherwise absent in the 1941
plan was the utilization of mass transit. More people, complemented by a growing
economy (the Philippine economy was growing at a modest rate of 5% yearly since
systems of other metropolitan systems (Tokyo alone has more than a hundred
lines). However, when Marcos was removed from power by People Power, only
one of these lines were built: the Manila Light Rail Transit (LRT) 1. The line began
operations in 1984. Two other lines were built after the Marcos administration.
Metro Rail Transit (MRT) 3 began operations in 1999, and Light Rail Transit (LRT)
2 in 2003. This doubled the mileage of existing rail in the region (20 kilometers to
50 kilometers). The idea was to transport more people by rail than any other modes
of transportation, which was a feat once achieved by the tranvia. However, even if
one thinks our trains are already packed, only 1.5 million people have used mass
11 | P a g e
transit as of 2012, or around 6% to 9% of total passengers travelling Metro Manila
roads.
tried to implement them until the year 2000. However, as the Philippines entered
the 21st century, the 1977 plan seemed to fall apart. In the first place, it was not
seemed to lag behind. Road mileage increased by a measly 1.5% annually since
Net result? Worse traffic. Despite all government efforts to reduce the suffering of
the populace, such as truck ban, extended number coding hours, and intelligent
traffic systems (CCTV, interactive signs, etc.), there are no signs of improving. In
10th in the world). Five years later, in 2017, Numbeo had Manila at 58 minutes
(ranked 5th). Not only has there been a slight difference, Manila actually went up
the global rankings. It can be inferred that while other urban centers worldwide
have been working upon their traffic woes, the Philippines has not done as much
12 | P a g e
Recommended as a solution to this grave situation is the Roadmap for
Transport Infrastructure Development for Metro Manila and Its Surrounding Areas
(Region III and Region IV-A), also known as the Metro Manila Dream Plan.
in cooperation with the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), the plan
called for massive infrastructure investment to ensure better traffic by 2030. Metro
Manila alone has 36% share of the national economy. Better movement in this
region would result to faster economic growth. The Japanese input was their
during the 1980s. Technopolis provided for the creation of 19 science cities
them by road and rail networks. This meant relieving major urban centers such as
Tokyo. One of the more prominent science cities was Tsukuba, which had more
than 200,000 people as of 2010. The Tsukuba Science City was conceived in 1963
and became the foundation of the Technopolis. In the Philippine setting, the Dream
Plan proposes the development of locations north and south of Manila, such as
neighboring regions, and relieving the pressure in Metro Manila as the only center
in the region. The Dream Plan also proposes eleven (11) transit lines, including
expansions, more than the 1977 plan of seven lines. If completed, it would total to
318 kilometers of rail, more than six times the current capacity. The target is to get
more than seven (7) million people commuting by train, an expected share of
13 | P a g e
around 30% to 40%. Tokyo, which was indexed by Numbeo at 41 minutes of one-
way transport, has 62% passenger share for its railways. Hong Kong, indexed at
42 minutes, has 25% share. Singapore, indexed at 43 minutes, has 20% share.
Besides mass transit, the use of rapid bus transit (BRT) is also included in the plan.
The expected number of passengers using BRT by 2030 would be around two
million. Upgrading existing roads and building new ones are also proposed. The
plan calls for a ladder pattern, with urban expansion both going eastward and
towards the north-south axis. Again, the point is to create multiple urban centers
(sub-centers) north and south of Metro Manila. The plan also called for the
there would be ample space for parks and zoos. To date, some components of this
have already been underway, but the Dream Plan itself would cost a lot for the
government. A total of 2.6 trillion pesos until 2030 has to be spent. Of course, there
is ample justification for the expenses. By 2030, a 42% decrease in traffic costs is
expected (from 2.4 billion pesos per day in 2015 to 1.4 billion pesos per day).
However, this would mean putting as much as 55% to 60% of the total
infrastructure budget in developing Metro Manila alone. The rest of the nation may
be left behind, and traffic is not confined in Manila. Other urban centers in the
Philippines such as Cebu (33 minutes) and Davao (31 minutes) begin to be ranked
globally among cities with the most traffic. With the assumption of Rodrigo Duterte
This meant almost one (1) trillion pesos would be invested in infrastructure in the
next six years (2016-2022). Whether this would be enough to fund the Dream Plan,
14 | P a g e
or the government can ensure implementation would go according to plan, Metro
Manila is and will continue to suffer from the consequences of inadequate urban
planning in the coming years. The government would also have to balance
development in the capital region and the rest of the nation. Nevertheless, the
Filipino people in general can learn from our history with traffic, and move forward
Mandaluyong City is a city that lies at the heart of Metropolitan Manila in the
the early 80’s established the city as one of the most progressive economic centers
areas and for some time, this quiet residential suburb just seemed to passively drift
that way. But events that unfolded in the aftermath of the EDSA Revolution in 1986
saw the dawn of a new beginning for Mandaluyong. With the sense of stability
brought about by a dynamic leadership then under Mayor Benjamin S. Abalos, Sr.,
towards the city, and soon after, this once sleepy town’s landscape dramatically
transformed into one of the most promising business and financial centers in Metro
15 | P a g e
There are lots of sources of where this city got its name. Some claim that
the place got its name from the Tagalog terms “mga” which means many and
“daluy” which means flowing in the reference to the tall grasses that grow in the
land many years ago. Another also claimed that it got its name from the incident
when Acapulco, a navigator, saw that the rolling hills were frequently lashed at by
“daluyong” or big waves from the sea. Hence the residents gave an answer to
those who inquired about the name of the place as “madaluyong”. Later, the
the Spanish conquest, Mandaluyong was already an organized place. It was part
of what was once the Kingdom of Sapa of the Great Madjapahit Empire or “Anka
Widyaya” and was ruled by Prince Balagtas, around 1300. More than a century
later, about 1470, it expanded and was called the Kingdom of Namayan with Lakan
Takhan as its ruler. The kingdom was made up of what are now Pandacan, Malate,
Quiapo, Sta. Mesa, San Miguel, Paco and Sta. Ana in Manila, and Mandaluyong,
Makati, San Juan, Pasay, Taguig, Pateros, Parañaque and parts of Pasig and
Mandaluyong was first known as a barrio of Sta. Ana de Sapa which was
part of the District of Paco, Province of Tondo. It was then named as by the
Spaniards as San Felipe Neri in honor of the Patron Saint of Rome. Year 1841, it
was separated from Sta. Ana de Sapa. When the Americans came, San Felipe
Neri was consolidated with the municipality of San Juan del Monte. For several
months in 1904, San Felipe Neri became the capital of Rizal. After its separation
from San Juan del Monte in year 1907, San Felipe Neri became an independent
16 | P a g e
municipality. It was then renamed as Municipality of Mandaluyong by virtue of the
House Bill No. 3836. It became a city year 1994. Today, Mandaluyong is a bustling
city with vibrant economic activities and among many other city accomplishments.
Transportation
Accessibility
prime advantages. The city is provided with good access roads to and from
de los Santos Avenue (EDSA), Ortigas Avenue and Shaw Boulevard provide inter-
city linkages, while Boni Avenue and Martinez Street (C-3 Road) serve as alternate
routes.
A total of nine (9) concrete bridges (Table 6.01) connect gaps in the road
network while several minor roads provide additional access from the San Juan
Municipality.
17 | P a g e
Table 6.01
Inventory of Bridges
Mandaluyong- No 119.00
Makati data
TOTAL - 342.83
18 | P a g e
All in all, the city has 31 entry and exit points, as can be seen in Map 56. Also
EDSA, as well as existing and proposed rail transport lines traversing the city.
At present, the city is served with a total of 119.813 km of roads (see Table
6.02) classified into four (4) types of administration: national, city, barangay and
private roads. This gives a road density of 10.60 km for every 100 hectares of land,
way above the standard ratio of 1 km/100 ha., making Mandaluyong actually over-
served with roads. This, however, does not ensure efficiency of the road network,
which is also affected by socio-economic factors, land use characteristics, and the
Table 6.02
General Length in % of
Classification km Total
19 | P a g e
Barangay 3.705 3.09
Traffic Management
The city has two offices that ensure the management of the city’s traffic flow:
The TPMO employs traffic aides who direct traffic on congested streets and
intersections. Towing and impounding of stalled vehicles are also carried out by
20 | P a g e
the division to ensure that streets and thoroughfares are free from any obstruction
The PNP Traffic on the other hand takes care of major thoroughfares,
Modes of Transport
Land Transportation
Being an inland city and generally flat but for a few gentle slopes, internal
utility jeepneys, tricycles and pedicabs, private cars and the rail transit system.
Of these, the most popular is the jeepney, considering the income class of
majority of the commuters and its economic advantage over the car in relatively
While jeepneys ply the main city roads, tricycles and pedicabs serve the
interior roads both through zone routes and upon demand of passengers.
Commuters traveling the length of EDSA commonly use the Metro Rail Transit
regular commuter bus. The MRT has three stations in the city: at Boni
21 | P a g e
However, the bus is still preferred by some due to its more direct access to
both origin and destination in the vicinity of EDSA, as well as the fact that buses
are available on a 24-hour basis. The rail transit operates only within a scheduled
When traversing the city, North-South bound and East-West bound buses are
Despite oversupply of roads, the city is not spared from traffic problems
The policy to encourage a more efficient use of land by allowing higher density
activities has also attracted more clients and consumers who, in turn, require
network.
22 | P a g e
Lack of Parking Spaces for Residential Buildings
Highly populated areas in some barangays of the city have also generated
thereby utilizing the streets as parking during night time or even longer. Although
the city has designated areas of tow-away zones, there is still the issue of not
operations listed by the LTFRB with more than 50% having expired franchises
confirming unofficial reports of PUJ’s illegally operating in the city. These “colorum”
driving.
23 | P a g e
intersections in the city are the presence of multiple intersection roads and the lack
1. Pedestrian lane
2. Pavement markings
3. Yellow Box
4. Signboards
A frequent complaint is the lack of discipline among tricycle drivers plying the
drivers. In addition, road courtesy is almost absent among these drivers as can be
Jeepney drivers on the other hand, oftentimes behave like their colorum
24 | P a g e
There are many reasons why we suffer traffic jams every day. One of these is
the rapid growth of the population. As a result of this, the number of cars is
increasing annually. A further point is that there are more women drivers and
younger drivers today than in the past. The increase in the number of trucks and
commercial vehicles also causes traffic congestion. These vehicles move very
slowly, sometimes stopping to unload goods, and blocking traffic. Road works
are another major problem that can lead to streets being very crowded. (Write fix,
n.d.)
(Policy Brief 115 of the Reason Foundation, February 2014), traffic congestion is
a problem not just for individual commuters but for businesses as well. While
commuters are greatly concerned over rush hour traffic, businesses are also
concerned with the off-peak hour (non-rush hour) delivery of goods. It was
pointed out in the research that because businesses are concerned with
congestion during both time periods, their views on traffic congestion differ from
those of commuters. Solving rush hour and off-peak congestion is also more
logistics and distribution, client meetings and other business activities. It also
25 | P a g e
limits worker availability and productivity by affecting employees’ commutes. In
the Philippines, the effects of congestion on workers and employees are a sore
issue. Congestion leads to workers arriving late; commuting hassles for workers,
frustration/stress, long work commutes, long travel time, and loss of personal
time.
customers and other causes of traffic such as safety issues, poor road design,
26 | P a g e
METHODOLOGY
The project will be implemented on the road along Shaw Boulevard, the
project will not just build new Loading/Unloading Zones, but improve the old ones
too. The researchers came up on making a draft for the project proposal.
27 | P a g e
Photo 5. Right Side View
facing big problem when it comes to traffic. The objective of this project is to make
The researchers propose this project for the people and society as well. The
project includes the waiting shed as well. The project proposes a good place for
28 | P a g e
Photo 6. Autocad of the draft
After the approval for the draft, the researchers proceed in the making of
the digitally made draft. The project is a semi-circle that is 180°, the length of the
lot will be 30m, and the radius of the semi-circle is 7m. This Loading/Unloading
zone can provide enough space for 3 jeepneys. This proposal also includes the
29 | P a g e
CONCLUSION
The study concludes that developing a proper terminal for loading and
unloading station can be a way to lessen traffic. This project will perform a big role
in reducing the traffic we are experiencing. Instead of stopping in the middle of the
road, there will be a proper place for the PUVs and PUJs or even Private vehicles
to load and unload passengers. Aside from that is it will help in organizing the daily
commuters when waiting for vehicles. The waiting shed will be the only place
where people can standby to wait for vehicles since no other place will be allowed
for the vehicles to load and unload. In addition to that, accidents can also be
avoided. The vehicles will be much more organized when it comes to loading and
unloading passengers.
30 | P a g e
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
needs in this proposal and also for the moral support they’ve showed while making
this project.
We would also like to acknowledge our beloved Class Adviser Mr. Robert
We would also like to express our gratitude to Mr. Ronnel Usero for staying
with us throughout the whole making of this Project proposal and for guiding us on
And to our Almighty God who’s been there with us throughout the whole
31 | P a g e
REFERENCES
Raposas, A. (2017, February 24). Road Wars: Age of Traffic in the Philippines.
Retrieved from Filipino Historian: https://history-
ph.blogspot.com/2017/02/traffic.html
32 | P a g e