Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Case Study On International Construction Projects Stadiums and Arenas
A Case Study On International Construction Projects Stadiums and Arenas
Construction Projects:
1
Table of Contents
1.0 Introduction
Any construction project, despite the scale, has their own risks and can be quite
2
challenging. Each project comes with its own unique challenges, be it management
issues or material problems. These projects need to be planned well to avoid delays
and mitigate risks. Large-scale projects such as stadiums and arenas are something
that need careful consideration because one wrong choice of material could lead to
the collapse of the whole building, which in turn, potentially harm a lot of people
inside.
In addition, projects like these were usually leased before the construction is
completed. In other words, one of the challenges for these kinds of projects is the
importance in completing it before deadline. There will be a big loss if there would be
delays to the project. The pressure in completing it before the deadline proved to be
quite a challenge because the contractor tends to choose the quickest and cheapest
route to complete it on time, which will only leads to the failure of the building. For
instance, one of the reason for the collapse of the roof of Sultan Mizan Zainal Abidin
Stadium in Malaysia was the pressure to have it ready for the upcoming Sukma
steels and concretes, which can be quite expensive and difficult to handle. Not only
that, the procurement method used must be suitable to avoid delays and
unnecessary risks in projects like these. Besides, both a stadium and arena requires
a specific requirement to ensure that the purpose of the building is achieved and
that is the acoustic design. The importance of having a good acoustic design has
“At the same time, careful attention has been paid to acoustics to maximise the
seating plan, excellent acoustic design as well as the ability to withstand high loads.
This report will cover two case studies of a stadium and an arena, where aspects
3
discussed. Other than that, analysis and comparison of the two projects will be
examined. The first case study is the SSE Hydro Arena, which is situated in Glasgow
4
latticed steelwork and the facades’ cladding is the translucent ETFE (Ethylene
illuminated to make the building “glow” at night (Figure 1 and 2). The project is
and removable seating to enable a wide range of different staging and concert
5
Main Contractor : Lend Lease
The ETFE cladding of the SSE Hydro is one of its distinctive features. It is
made up of translucent cushions (seen in Figure 2), which will allow natural light
6
to illuminate the foyers during the day and the arena to ‘glow’ at night and this
unique facade won the 2014 Scottish Design Award for Lighting (Arup, 2015).
Other than that, J&P Building System provided BEAMCON product, which
was used to fix the ETFE ‘cushion’ cladding to the main building (as seen in
Figure 3). They provided the JORDAHL channel welded together to form a grid
of fixing points, which allows for a higher load concentration as well as removing
Figure 3: BEAMCON Fixing used to fix the ETFE cladding (J&P Building Systems, 2013)
Furthermore, the diagrid roof frame was one of the complex geometry
design challenges that they had to resolve. The 1,400 tonne steel diagrid roof is
held aloft by a circular array of angled concrete fins (Panstadia & Arena
then enabled them to resolve potential issues early on in the design workflow
2.3 Sustainability
The Arena was recognised as a sustainable build and was awarded a ‘Very
7
Good’ BREEAM rating. Steps were taken during the construction process to
segregation approach, where over 90% of recycling was achieved (SECC, 2013).
Lend Lease is committed to its waste reduction programme and in 2008, they
set an objective to halve the amount of waste it sent to landfill by 2012 (Waste
“An underlying theme that has helped achieve results is that waste is
Other than that, the building is designed to reduce energy demands, where
it uses both natural and mechanical ventilation. Fresh air is drawn into the
building above the entrances and vented at a high level (Figure 4). The building
fresh air into the building as well as extracting warm air from the building. To
The SSE Hydro Arena was procured under a traditional-fixed price contract
8
to reflect the complexity and completeness of the design (Magazine of the
is also known as the lump sum contract, is the most common method of
procuring a project. Most clients normally chooses this option to reduce design
and contract administration costs. This method will significantly reduce the
client’s risk and the contractor has greater control over profit expectations.
Other benefits of opting for this method is that the contractor is likely to
complete the project faster, giving him the incentive to maximize its production
and performance. However, the tendering and bidding process might take some
time as seen in the chronology of the project, so it will be a while before the
2001
Planning for the project started
2003
A clear plan for the stadium unveiled
2004
Appointed Forster+Partner as architect
2005
Gain full planning consent
2011
Construction started
2013
Construction completed
9
2.5 Social Values
2013). This helped the local in securing job opportunities as well as improving
One of the challenges that they had to resolve is the seating design. The
viewing angle and the comfort of spectators are their main priority. It became a
challenge because it was hard to balance the need to fit in as much spectators
as possible and their comfort. The seats were also required to have a striking
design and at the same time, allowing different set-ups for different
Thus, the solution to it is to design the seating plan in a way that it wraps
around the stage above ground level and rises towards the front (Figure 5),
optimising the viewing angle (Foster+Partner, 2005). The seat includes the
10
2.7 Incidents
cooperation between SECC and Lend Lease has helped avoid the delay of the
project. They went through the appropriate procedures and took suitable
11
3.0 Kaohsiung National Stadium, Taiwan
which is shaped like a question mark, although it is often compared with the
symbol of a dragon wagging his tail (Figure 6). The stadium earned its status as
one of the greenest stadiums in the world due to the solar panel system used as
its roof, which also gives it a scaly appearance similar to a dragon’s skin (Figure
7). This stadium was built for the purpose of the 2009 World Games, thus it’s
12
Below is the information relating to Kaohsiung National Stadium (Stadium
13
3.2 Technology and Materials
The solar power system of the stadium is one of its significant feature and
system. The Building Integrated Photo Voltaic (BIPV) solar panels (Figure 8)
were designed in a way that they allow 30% of total sunlight to shine into the
stadium, so the spectators can enjoy natural outdoor sunlight (Joanna, 2014).
Besides that, the stadium’s solar power system uses Delta’s energy inverters to
convert DC to AC power and to feed electricity into the grid with inverting
Besides that, to maximise the daylight exposure on the panels, four sided
structural sealant glazing was used to bond the glass solar panel to the
aluminium sub-frame. Each unit of the roof facade system has three glass
panels, including two solar glass panels (containing solar cell and low-iron glass
panels) and one blue tinted tempered glass pane, where Dow Corning 983
Structural Glazing Sealant was used for bonding of the solar panels (Dow
Corning, 2011).
14
3.3 Sustainability
The roof of the stadium is made up of exactly 8844 solar panels, which
generates 1.14 MWh of electricity per year that covers 75% of the stadium’s
energy needs, avoiding 660 tonnes of annual carbon dioxide output (Ipeck,
2011). Besides that, to fulfill the latest criteria of Taiwan Green Building
the main stadium is made from 100% reusable local material (MAA Group,
2010).
Other than that, the roof also collects rainwater, where a system of pipes
conveys the water to holding tanks underground where it’s sterilised and reused
maximise the effect of natural cooling wind patterns, where the sides and roof
of the stadium are not closed in a circle (Figure 9), but rather create a tunnel
through which air passes during the summer (Callahan, 2013). Thus, it does not
need any air-conditioning during the summer and save up a lot of energy
consumption.
Figure 9: Design of the stadium creating a tunnel for the wind (MAA Group, 2010)
15
3.4 Procurement method
Kaohsiung City Government was appointed by the Sports Affairs Council (SAC)
and was responsible for all the planning and construction of the main stadium.
tender documents and handling tender process. After a detailed study and
contract is put up in 2005 and was awarded to a Japanese architect, Toyo Ito.
One of the benefits of opting for this particular procurement method is that
it is a quick alternative (as seen in the chronology of the project) due to the
overlapping design and construction processes. It also transfers most of the risk
to the main contractor. However, it is not suitable for projects that requires
design flexibility because any changes made will have cost or time implications.
2005
Awarded the D&B contract to Toyo Ito
2006
Design plans started
2007
Construction started
2009
Completion of construction
16
3.5 Social Values
On days when the stadium is not used, the extra energy is sold to Taiwan
Power Company and feeds the local grid, that helps power up surrounding
million kilowatt-hours per year, and at the current cost of electricity in Taiwan,
NT$3 per kilowatt-hour, the structure will save NT$3.3 million (roughly £ 85,000)
Other than that, this project only utilises local raw materials to support their
(Figure 10), which also serves as a living classroom open year-round to the
community. In addition, its green building is a conduit for teaching people about
17
3.6 Challenges and Restraints (Solutions)
Using solar panels is one of the building specification and Toyo Ito, the
architecture, planned on using the solar panels as the stadium’s main roof
“Since solar panels were required for this project, I thought to use them to
cover almost the entire stadium seating roof. The climate in Kaohsiung is
panels are also used as a shading device to block direct sunlight.” - Toyo Ito
(Breyer, 2009)
BIPV solar panels. They created new materials during construction and fit the
panels together using the technologies mentioned above. Besides that, they
earthquakes and typhoons could have on them (Callahan, 2013). Other than
that, it was also challenging because each solar panel had to be fitted to the
18
4.0 Comparison / Analysis
Both of the projects are similar in terms of the scale and the cost. However,
each of the project was executed very differently, in terms of procuring it, the design
as well as the materials used. Below is a thorough analysis and comparison of the
two projects.
Open collaboration allows the planning and prediction of future outcomes, risks
and gains, which leads to shorter construction time as well as errors and
disputes reduction. This is why the SECC and Lend Lease still managed to
The cost of construction for both of the projects is slightly similar, which is
around £125 million each and both of them had the same building area (around
25,000 m2). Even so, the Kaohsiung National Stadium project should have cost
more due to the fact that it used a total of 8844 solar panels as a roofing system,
which can be quite expensive. This might mean that the other materials used
for the project is bought at a cheaper price, where the quality of the materials
is debatable, thus, explains the infrastructure problems that they had after the
cheap local materials and cheap labourers due to its high population (Ofori,
2011). This might also explain why the cost of building a stadium with solar
19
panels in China is considerably cheap.
The Hydro Arena project used the traditional procurement method whereas
(D&B). D&B method is a lot faster than the traditional method. This is because
the design and construction process overlaps each other in the D&B. This is
suitable for the Kaohsiung National Stadium project because it has limited time
to construct for the 2009 World Games. The Hydro Arena project took their time
designing and building falls under the contractor, which also means that the
client has lower risks since most of the risks have been transferred to the
takes the cheapest route to meet contract specification (Designing Building Ltd,
2016).
One of the advantages of opting for traditional method is that the client will
have control over the design before putting it out to tender. Although, the client
cannot tender for main contractor until the final design is finalized, which means
Therefore, the client should consider the cost, time and quality for a project
20
4.4 Contribution to the Community
Each of the project contributes to the society. For example, the contractor,
Lend Lease, involved in the Hydro Arena project ensured that there were
apprenticeship and job opportunities opened for that particular project. Other
than that, they were committed in reducing waste during the construction
contributes the s. This is because they used the solar panels to reduce the
carbon dioxide output. Other than that, they sold the excess energy that was
produced by the solar panels and feeds the local grid. This greatly helped the
society to reduce the cost of generating electricity. They also landscaped the
agencies were recognized, which also shows that it influences project cost, time
and environmental sustainability (Zou et al, 2007). Besides that, the research
also identifies that most Chinese contractors does not buy insurance for major
will need to have permits and licenses before they can start doing projects in
21
5.0 Conclusion
affects the time, cost and quality of the project, which is considered as the three
biggest aspects in the business. Other than that, integrated project delivery (IDP) is
one of the key success in managing a large-scale projects such as stadiums and
arenas. IDP ensures a smooth process through collaboration and more, which can
be seen in the Hydro Arena project. Besides, contributing to the social and economic
environment is one of the most important things to consider in a project. Both of the
In addition, both of the projects used the recent software (BIM) to help reduce
risk and ensure a safe and smooth construction process. Nowadays, BIM has been
greatly used by contractors all over the world and its usefulness has been proven as
seen in the projects studied above. Other than that, as the world grows, more and
As a whole, the SSE Hydro Arena project was greatly executed because they
managed to complete on time despite the fire incident and there was no problem
after its completion. The Kaohsiung National Stadium project, on the other hand,
was fairly executed because there were infrastructure problems after a year of
completing it, but this is due to the pressure of needing to complete it on time for
the 2009 World Games. Therefore, aspects such as the procurement methods,
technology and materials used, management (IDP) as well as the social value
22
6.0 Bibliography
http://www.arup.com/news/2013_09_september/30_september_scotlands_l
2017).
2. Aumiller, A. (2009) Sultan Mizan Zainal Abidin stadium roof collapse. Available
at:
https://failures.wikispaces.com/Sultan+Mizan+Zainal+Abidin+Stadium+Roof
Available at:
https://www.bentley.com/en/project-profiles/foster-partners_sse-hydro
4. Breyer, M. (2009) The greenest, coolest stadium: Toyo Ito on his sun-powered
http://www.treehugger.com/about-treehugger/the-greenest-coolest-stadium-
2017).
http://architectuul.com/architecture/kaohsiung-stadium (Accessed: 15
January 2017).
6. Designing Buildings Ltd (2016) Procurement route pros & cons - designing
https://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/Procurement_Route_Pros_%26_C
7. Dow Corning (2011) Dow Corning provides solutions for 2009 world games
23
https://www.dowcorning.com/content/publishedlit/63-1199-01.pdf (Accessed:
14 January 2017).
9. Figueras Internation Seating (2005) The SSE Hydro arena - case studies -
Available at:
http://www.figueras.com/uk/projects/large-multi-purpose-venues/284_the-s
10. Foster + Partners (2005) The SSE Hydro | foster + partners. Available at:
http://www.fosterandpartners.com/projects/the-sse-hydro/ (Accessed: 6
January 2017).
http://www.building.co.uk/foster-%20-partners-the-hydro/5061062.article
12. J&P Building Systems (2013) BEAMCON at the SSE Hydro in Glasgow – case
http://www.jp-uk.com/blog/beamcon-at-the-sse-hydro-in-glasgow-case-stud
13. Joanna, C. (2014) National stadium (2009 world game main stadium).
Available at:
https://twgreentrade.com/2014/01/22/national-stadium-2009-world-game-m
14. Kao, Y.L. (2009) Kaohsiung main stadium management likely to face financial
woes | full index search | FOCUS TAIWAN - CNA ENGLISH NEWS. Available at:
http://focustaiwan.tw/search/200910010036.aspx?q=Asian%20games
15. lpeck (2011) International solar energy: Kaohsiung world stadium (Taiwan).
Available at:
24
https://www.solarenergyworld.com/2011/07/07/international-solar-kaohsiun
16. MAA Group (2010) MAA GROUP consulting engineering. Available at:
http://www2.maaconsultants.com/en/projects/detail.php?dpid=388
17. Magazine of the Chartered Institute of Building (2012) The Hydro Arena.
Available at:
http://www.constructionmanagermagazine.com/on-site/now-its-scotlands-tur
18. McDonald, C. and McPherson, L. (2013) Welder’s torch blamed for starting huge
fire at Glasgow’s new £125m Hydro arena which puts opening in doubt.
Available at:
http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/welders-torch-blamed-star
Available at:
http://www.cio.com.au/article/311263/computer_modeling_helps_build_sun-
21. O’Young, M. (2014) Taiwan national stadium sculpted from concrete, steel, and
http://www.gabreport.com/2014/01/taiwan-national-stadium-sculpted-from-
22. Panstadia & Arena Management (2014) Glasgow adds 12,000 seat arena to
24. Passivent (2016) The SSE Hydro entertainment venue, Glasgow Passivent,
25
natural ventilation system for the SSE Hydro arena, situated in Glasgow.
Available at:
http://www.passivent.com/uploads/e73d9248ff0496a1215efdaf46c42ba0.pdf
https://www.architecture.com/explore/stories/thearchitectureoffootballstadiu
26. Pooran, N. (2014) £5million blaze at Glasgow’s Hydro arena was sparked by
http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/5million-blaze-glasgows-h
https://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/search-judgments/judgment?id=b152dda6-8
http://www.secc.co.uk/media/165867/secc_corpreview_2012.pdf (Accessed:
6 January 2017).
29. Shan, S. (2010) Sports affairs council accuses Kaohsiung over stadium.
Available at:
http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiwan/archives/2010/09/07/2003482305
31. Toyo Ito (2009) Toyo Ito & associates, architects. Available at:
http://www.toyo-ito.co.jp/WWW/Project_Descript/2005-/2005-p_15/2005-p_
32. Toyo Ito (2011) Projects in green architecture & building. Available at:
http://www.solaripedia.com/13/346/taiwan_stadium_100_percent_solar-pow
26
33. Waste & Resources Action Programme (2011) Targets, policy and processes
implementation monitoring and reporting benefits and next steps. Available at:
http://www.wrap.org.uk/sites/files/wrap/2011_08_Lend_Lease_FINAL.5a18a
34. Zou, P.X.W., Zhang, G. and Wang, J. (2007) ‘Understanding the Key Risks in
27