BEFORE THE HONOURABLE LAHORE HIGH COURT,

RAWALPINDI BENCH, RAWALPINDI

W.P No 2477/2019

Liaquat Ali & others

VS

Assistant Director Land Records Gujar Khan & others

WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 199 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF

ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN 1973

REPORT AND PARA WISE COMMENTS ON BEHALF OF

RESPONDENT NO 1

Report

Respectfully Sheweth
It humbly submitted that under section 42(1 C) of land revenue act 1967 A
person, acquiring a right in an estate by inheritance, purchase, mortgage, gift or
otherwise as a land owner or a tenant for a fixed term exceeding one year, may
report his acquisition of the right to the Service Centre Official of the estate, if the
report is made within one year or the earlier date, as may be notified by the
Board of Revenue after the commencement of operation of the Service Centre of
the estate. Person named Qamer Gull s\o Muhammad ameer , Muhammad illyas
s\o jandad and Muhammad shabbir s/o Muhammad Bashir entered mutation
no.211 offer revenue estate Rakh Gakharan of tehsil Gujar khan. Before service
center official Rana Ishtiaq consisting of 2-2-0 and got the challan fee of mutation
Annexure A. As per the writ petition challan fee was submitted but before the
recording of this statements of Buyer\seller by respondent no. 1 .Status que
issued by the court of learned civil Judge Qamar Abbas (Civil Judge First Class)
restraining from further alienating the suit property till further orders. Dated
26/08/2019 Annexure B. Status que as been granted for the Khewat no. ……. Of
Muza Rakh Ghakharan consisting of _____ Kanal it has only 3 owners but Civil
Court has granted status que on the application of a person not being co sharer in
the respective Khewat .A Civil Court is a competent authority of issuing statues
que regarding the suit property therefor respondent no. 1 did not recorded the
statements more over if the statues que issued by the Civil Court is vacated
respondent no.1 is willing to record statement and sanctioned the respective
mutation.

Para wise comments

1. Para No 1 states facts.
2. In response to para No 2, not rebutted.
3. In response to para No 3 it is submitted that further factual inquiry be
conducted.
4. That the contents of para 4 are against facts hence not admitted.
5. That the contents of para 5 are incorrect hence denied. This para has
already been answered in report.
6. That the contents of instant para are against the facts hence not admitted.
7. That the contents of para 7 are incorrect hence not admitted.
8. That the contents of para 8 are based on facts hence admitted .
9. That the contents of para 9 are incorrect in answer has been given in
report
10. The contents of para no 10 needs no reply.
11. The contents of para no 11 stats effects.

In the light of above submission, it is most humbly prayed that the instant
Writ Petition may kindly be dismissed with heavy cost.

Respondent No 1