Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Infestation Control in Stored Spices and Spice Powders - An Overview
Infestation Control in Stored Spices and Spice Powders - An Overview
net/publication/287484766
CITATIONS READS
0 505
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
I am currently Technical Consultant (fumigants ) to UPL Ltd, Mumbai. I am not involved in any research program now. View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Somiahnadar Rajendran on 28 January 2016.
N. GUNASEKAR1\.NAND S. RAJ""ENDl{AN
f'vorl Protectant.'i Gnd Tn(estation COIttrol Department, CentrCtl."'t.;od1'echnolcgical Rescarl.h f,tsli/llte,
Mysore-570 013, I1tdia.
-L1BSTRACI
Spices are high value ingredients used in a wid~ variely of food preparations. During
storage, spices and sj:'ice products are attacked by insect pests, which consume, cc'ntaminate
and make the producis favourable for olher spoilage organisms leading to quality deteriorution.
Control measures cl.lrrt~nlly adoplod, i.e., fumigation, irradiation and heat treatmerll and
their relative merits are discussed. Tile effect~ of the chemicul und physical treatmenls on
chemical constituents, colour, sensory and organoleptic quaiilies of spices and spice products
have been examined. The advantages ot carbon dioxide-rich atmosphere for disinfesltliion
and :;torage of spices are also discussed.
16
PESTOLOGY VOL. XXIII NO. 12 DECEMBER 1999
17
PESTOLOGY VOL. XXIIII,jO. 12 DECEMBER 19f}9
}{eccntl",
.. tile coll1pound '1as 1'(~eJ)idl':llifietl
a~; a ..,erious ozone de! lelur \vill1 all OZOll,:
Depleting Polellliul (aDP) of 0.7 (UNI~P 1995).
I{l'peatcd lre.llmCl!t:., of spice jJrOdllct... with tl1('
fumigant (;auscs di~;coJouralion allu loss of
-18
PESTOlOGY VOL. XXIII N.J. 12 DECEMBER 1999
essential oils (Pruthi, 1980). Spices fumigated animal origin. (2) to inhibit sprouting of tuber
under atmospheric conditions with methyl and bulbs. (3) to deja)' rip,,'nin~ of fruIts and (1)
hromicle at 90 g/m3 for 12 hr showed inorganic to extr:nd the shelf-life of food commodities
hromicle residues cxcc(~ding the permissible .(Thayer, 1990 and Sjoberg ct. a/. 1991). Irradiation
limits or25 ppm (r~eeves('t. al., 19/1!1). of fipic(~s becomes ('ssl'ntial as tllC)" arc
contalllinllted with spoilagl' organislns SlIl'hllS
J~thylcne oxide is an innammable, colourlcss microbes and insect pests (Pad"',11 DeslIi, et. a/.
gas with irritating odour, which is detectable only 1987).
at hig" concentrations. It is supplied in cylinders
at 1:~1:11109: 1 admixture with carhon dioxide or .' ',bout 30 countries. including I!ldia. have
fr(~on 1,'as.Elhylcnc oxide i:; llSCOprimarily for approved irradiation of spi('('s. allt! abollt 20
sterilisation of spices allhough during the countries are already irr;:ldiating spices on a
treC\tment insects are also controlled (Bond 1984). commercial scale (Prasad, 1995). Gamma
Ethylcnc oxide is sllspcctcd carcinogen and it irradiatioI) of \vhoJe and ground spices \vas
forms chlorohydrin or bromoh):drin residues, effective against insect infestation (Pad\val Desai.
which arc also cal cinog(~nic. Hcl1cc the use of ('t. at, 1987) at 1 kGy. Spices stIch as coriander.
cthylcllc oxide has bccn discontinllcd in mallY cumin, ;t!rmeric and l~hilJics treatet! by gamma
developed nations. radiatioll at 10 k(;y .1nd storcc{ fur G months
proved to retain Goot! microbiological quality
In rare instances, cthyll~ne oxide fumigation (Almn et, 11/, 1992),
affected the volatile oil content of spites.
Fumigation of cloves by ethylene oxide at dosages The effect of irrl1cJiation on the physical
of 550, 750, 1000 g/m3 for 6 hr at 20-25°C, the appearance, chemical ~Jul1lity and sensory
volatile oil content was decreased by 1.7-2.2% chnractcristics has bC'cn c\al11inco b)' man)'
(Coretti and Inal1969). Vajdi and Pereira (1973) "v.orkers ffiachman & Gicszczynska 1973; B),tn N.
observed a similar trend in black pepper and al., 1983; LCSCallOet. (II. 19':)i). In gl'ncral, no
allspice exposed for 16 hr (dosage not clear). The adverse effect has been observed in spiCL j
treatment affected the colour of black pepper. irradiated at the recommended dosage of 10 kGy.
Morcover, ethylene cilloroh)'drin r(~sidue is Nevcrthcles$, there i\rC a f(',,' rl'rort~ anollt
formed in treated spices (Gerhardt and Ladd- changes in the quality of ~piccs follo,ving
l~ffio I ~)!!3).Kuruppu ct. rll., (1985) in their study treatment rfuble 3).
fotlnd tllat the anti ,xidativc properties of the
spices such as nlarjoram, nutmeg, paprika and
black pepper \\'crc not affected by ethylene oxide
trcatl11cnt. In addition to the use of these
fumigants whole spices like coriander seeds are
treated wilh sulfur dio;,ide for hl(;aching. There
is very little information about Ihc effect of
fumigi11ion on the physical and scnsoryqualities
of spices. The drawbacks of the fumigants
currently used for disinfestation and disinfection
of stored spices include residue problems, insect
resistance and adverse effect on environment.
Muthu et. at. (1984) has tested ethyl formate as
an effective fumigant for the disinfestation of
spices at a dosage of300 g/m3 for 72 hr.
19
PESTOLOuY 'J~)t.. XXIii I~O. 1:? DECf.~A8ER 1999
For instance, iliC yi\.-,!rj of voli:1.tile oil aroma (LeU("1992.).Sub.sequently, the sl)iceS1ICC(1
constituents in spice mixtures, \"Jhite pepper, to be dried to eliminate moisture absorbed by thl'
nutmeg and ginger increased after the irradiation steam treatment. l)ellI1e and Bugi (1993)
at 2,.25 kGy (Tjaberg. et. al. 1972 Bachman and reported that pasteurisation of spices c()uld bl'
Gieszczynska 1973) and y-terpene content done by high frcqtl~llCY and microwaVl'
increased in dried th}'me treated at 30 kGy treatments as an alternative to irradiation ant!
(Venskutonis et. al. 1996). Loss of major flavour fumigation. Following high frequency treatment
components such as aI1etho)e. anisaldehyde and at 30KW, 27.12 MHz for 15:30 mill, loss in
chavicol in anise, anisaldch)'de in fennel and essential oil content rIoted in ~rour.~1 C:IIll,."'fJn,
lP-pincnc and cll1eol in black pepper occurred crushed white and blal-k pepper, caraway
after 10-kGy irradiation (l-:araget. al. 1996). (whole), and marjoram leaves. The loss \\"as murt'
in groulld spices than in whole ones.
In tile black pepper irradiation resulted in
conversion of mono terpene hydrocarbons to TIlermal regulating methods gellerally cause
fQrpelles. Lcscal1o ct. af., (1991) observed that tIle one or the other ullclesirable chan!~(~s in till'
pH of the ground ginger. turmeric and garlic treated products. I Iellce heat treatmellt can be
powder \\'as affected by irradiation treatment at supplemented or combu1cd with other control
10-30 kG~'. measures. Thakur and Siilgh (1995) suggested
that irradiation COUll! be used in comhination
(~olotlr pla}'s a vital roJ(' ill detcrmilling the \vith tile other In(~lhuds SllCh as cr~'ogenic
consum(~r acceptance of spices. Studies so far temperature, modificd atmosphere or vacuum
have indic;llCd that the appearance and sensory packing. However all these processes are labour
qualitil~S or irradial.~d spices/spice products intensive. tinlC cOilsuming .1I1dexpensive.
remain unaiJi:i::lea (Nar\'aiz et. al. 1989 Szabad
and Kiss; 1~J79J_C'Sc'".llO et. al., 1991 and !nal et. A!ternates : Due to rc:.;idue pr()blcms,
al. 1975). Ncv!.'r!!lclrss, consumer una\varcness, regulatory restrictiol1S and consumer aversion
lack of\\'ell-dcfi1l(~d st:lndards, lack of significant tow;lI"ds pesticides there is an mcreas(~demphasis
data on \\'holesom~nes$ of iuiJdi;.1ted foods. and on non-chclnical methods of preserving food
cost of tile process art' saine of the limiting commodities. The 11011nal composition of
factors, affecting the \vide use of the process atmospheric air i.e. 21% Ox)'!{cn, O.O3';J;)CO;! and
('lnakur al1d SiI1~1),I ~)~5). 78gb nitrogen is altered ap!)ropriat(~ly for the
col..trol of insect Lind olhcr pests. Accordillg1y all
ileat TreatJnent : Insect disinfestation by heat atmosphere containinl~ more than :j~)'}o CO;!
treatmentll;.lS bl'l'11 coJ\sidl'red since long time. knO\Vll as carbon dioxide atmosphere a/ld the
Ilo\Vt'\'l"!r. till' in.o;\llatillg ellt'ctof .o;picesin lJulk atmosphere colttainillg less than 1'70oxy~ell i.e.
greatly increases tht~ time requiicd for heat low oxygen .ltInosphere .ire lethal to insl'cls.
treatment .\nd lhereforc is expensive.
Furthermore. the lrt~atment lime is criticalns This modified atmosphere (MA) storag(! has
excess hl'a! l11ayafrt~ct the q\laJily of spice, for beell shoym to be promising in creatil)~ JetJIal
examplt' colour ;lnd pungency in capsicum conditions for insects and fungi ill stored
(Go\rindarajan, 1985;. Faraget.n.l. (199G)ho\vever commodity. This n1c:thod is already b('il)!~ used
noticed that in spices such as black pepper, to control insect infcstation in large-sl'alc grain
fennel. coriander, anise and turmeric heal storage in AI\str,uia and IndoJ1esia (Anllis, 1987;
treatment at 70°C for 15 min did not affect the llipp et. ai., 1990). I-Iu\'.'l'ver, carbon dioxide-rich
quality ailli microI1i.t! load ,vas reduced p3rl!y. atmosph(~re for storage of spices has n()t been
c:I(tensivel)' studied.
St~rilisation of spice~ \\ ith pulsed steam, in
which actually the steam LuJldenses on the spice CONCLUSION
particles, helped to elimin;1te microorgalusms
with millimllm adverse effects on flavour or Fu!11if~ants currently used for coJltrolling
20
PESTOLOGY VOL. XXIII NO. 12 DECEMBER 1999
insects and r11icroorganisms in spices have Bufani, O.K. (j98~) Spiccs :Inti pcsf prohlcms:
prohlcms such as insect resistance, residues, Cori:lntlcr. Pe.flicidt.'s 18(9) 15-17.
c.lrcirl()r~cnicity and (~nvironm(~ntal hazards.
"yun, M.\V. K,vom, .r.ll. IIn!! Cho, 11.0. (IQ8J)
Irraui;rlion, though accepted by regul~tory Stcrilis:ltwn an!! storllgr ofspicl's hy irradillt: '11.
authorities, is nut widely used due to constraints I. Sfcrilis~tioll of po\vtlcrcd hot pcppcr pastc.
in terms of economic costs and consumer K()rel1l1 .'()rtrlltr! ()I fo()t! ,)('iCIICI.' a1lt! Tecl:rro!tlgr
acceptance. Carbon diox.ide treatment though 15(4), J.~9-363.
adopted for storage" and preservation of other
Corcfli, K. :Inti In~J, T. (19li9) Rcsiduc Problcms in
agrictlltural commndities, the technique is yet to
cold stcrilis:lfinn of spkcs. F!ei~ch,,'irt~chalt -19(5),
;", app~iec for tl)~ protection of spices. In general,
599-609.
studies on pest control of spices are very limited,
COmlJared to other food commodities such as Dehnc, L.I. and nngi, K.N. (I °93) Paste!Jrisation of
cereals, pulses and oil seeds. Application of CO2- spices by micrmv3ve arId high frequency. Food
rich atmospheres for disinfestation and MarketiflC afld Techn%!.'J 7 (5). 35-38.
disil1f(~ction of stored spices needs .detailed Farag Z. S.E.A., Aziz. N.II. :Ind Ali. ,.\.1\1. (1996)
investigation. C()mp:lrin~ efrccts of \..'nshing. thcrmal
trcntmcnts alicl gamm:l irra<li:ltio!! quality of
spices. NahrltnK 40 (1). .:'2-36.
Gcrh:!r(lt -{J. and Ln<ld- F:flin -.J.C' (IQ.I\_') Ethylrne
oxitlr residurs in spirr~. f1rhl.h','irl,\'t'/r,'/t 6_'(-I).
TIJ(~authors thank Director, Cf'TnI [or IJis
606-608.
encouragement.
Govind:lraj:ln, V.S (1985) C:lp~icllm -production,
Irchn()lo~y, chrmi~try nlJd I]u:llity. CI{C Crifical
Rel.ie'I'.~in Fllod Scirnce Ilnll ,\Ilfrition .22 (2),
109-176.
1\1.:11I:lrl<(;r:,lIc 199~ (I\~rirllllllr:ll Prollllt't' (;r:lllill~
:11111Marking) spcciric:llions ror spirt's. Spiccs
Innl, T., Kr~'{ilJ, S.. Tolgny, Z. nnd Tl'Il'!IIJ. I (11175)
Stcrilisation of ~piccs hy y rays. nei.~('hH'irt.~('haft
I~o:lrd India.
5S (5), 675-677.
AI:lm, M.K., Choudhury, N.A. nnd Youssmlr, Q.M.
Kurllppu, D.P., Schmidt, K., Lancrak. D.I., Durcnmda
(1992) Decontamin:ltion or spiccs by gamma
-Van and Farkas,.1. (1985) Effrcls ofirradi:1lion
1':ldin/ion. Lctt/'r\, ill ,""plied Microhiolog.. 14 (5),
and fllmigation on thc antioxidnli,'c proprrtics
199-202.
of sollIe spices. "fcta -"llimentllrill 14(4),343-353.
Annis, P.C. (1987) to\v:ll'lis controlled ntmosphcre
Lcfkovitch, L.P. (196i) ,\ 1:llJornlory study of
dosngcsschcdnles: a I'cvie,v or current knmvledge.
In Procecdings ofthc 4th International ,,'orking .S'tegobiunl panicellnl (I..) Coleoptera:
(Anobiidac). Journal of,-'ifllredPrlllluct Re.\"earch ,
conrerence on stored product protection. Tel-
3: 235-249.
A,'iv. Israel, 128-149.
Leire, A. (1992) Sterilisation oj Spiccs ,,'ith pulsed
Ash"'ol'th, .f.R. (1993) The biology of LiI,t;oc!crllli1
stram, Lil'smedelstl'/inik .~4(1/2), 2~-25.
Jl'rricorne .)IJllnral ofS;ore(1 Proc!lIct Re,\'cilrc!: 29
(4)291-303. Lcscnno, G., Narvaiz, P. DIIU Kairi}:Jm:1, E. (1991)
Stcrilisation of spices nnd Vcgclnblcs seasoning
Rachm:ln, S. and Gicszc;~.vnska,.J. (1973) Sflldics on
by gamma radiation. ,fctn uliini.'ntaria 20(3/4),
somc microbial and chemic:11aspcctsofirradiatcd
233-242.
~piccs. (In: Aspcct~ of introduction of food
irradiation in dcvcloping c()untric~) C()lIfcrcncc Mnltillllrll, S.N. (11)94. 1\1:1nll:II of 1IIIIian spices.
procccdings pp.33-~I. Ac:lllrl1lic Fr'""U~ltioll. Nl'\v Orlhi liP 380.
Rond E.J. (1984). M:lnnal of fumigation for inscct Muttlll, M. and Majllmdl'r. S.K. (1974) Inscct control
control. FAO PI:lnt Production :lnd Protcction in spices. III prpccl'lIings of symposium on
P:lpcr, 54. Food anI! Agricultural Organization "Dcvclopment :11111
prospl'cts of spice industry in
(If thc Unitcd Nations, I{omc. pp 432. India". AFST. P 35.
21
PESTOLOGY YOLo XXIII NO. 12 DECEMBER 1999
Muthu, 1\1., I~ajendr:ln, S., Krishnamurthy, T.S., Sccnllppa, 1\1.L. Stobbs, L. \Y. and Kcmploll, A.(;.
N:lr:lsim hall, K,S., Rangas\vamy, J.I~., Jayaram, (1979) Thc role of insccts in thc biodetcriora tion
1\1. and 1\lajumder, S.K. (1984) Controlled of Indian red pcppcrs by fungi. /lIfe.~ttltioll
Atmosphcre and Fumigation in Grain Storages. Biodeterioralioll Bullelill 15, 96.
rrocccdiu~s of an International symposium Sjobcrg, A.i\I., ManniclI, 1\1. I'illnioja, S. HolikaliclI,
..Practical Aspects of Con troll cd Atmosphere and E. alld Llltva -Kala, K. (1991) Irradialioll uf
Fumigation in Grain Storages" held from 11 to spices alltl its dct~ction (rc,'icw.) Fo()tlllel'iew
22 April 1983, in Perth, Western Australia. Edited /lIten,otiliJ'.,! 7(2),233-253.
by Ripp el. uL pp 369-381.
Szabad, J. alld Kiss,!. (1<)79)Comparative stlltlics on
Nan'aiz, P., Lcscano, G., Kairiyama. E., and Daupert, the sanitising cffccts of cthylcnc oxide anti j!amlnll
N. (1989) Dccontamination of spices by radiation ill paprik:l. ..1c/(1
,.tlililelltaria S.3S3-395.
irradiation, }ourIII1/ciflllCld,\'a/l?ly .10(1),49-61.
ThaklJ r, B.I"{. alld Sillgh, ,~.K. (' 995) Com hin,ll illn
Pad"al -Desai, S.I~., Sharma, A. aud Amuukar, S.V. process ill food irradiatj"II. Trcnds ill ';000
(1987) Disinfestation of "hole and ground spices Science alltl Techllology. 6, p.7-1 !.
by gamma radiation. ./(/uf/la/(ifFood~'ciel/ceulld
Thayer, D.\Y. (1990) Food irradi:ltioll : 8cllcrils and
Techll(//(/.~I', India 24{6), 321-322.
co/lccrlls. Jill/nl(;! ~r rl)()(1 Q./IIJlil)' .13 (.'), ,..;-
Prasad, A.N. (1995) Rolc of food irr:ldiation in 169-
emerging nl"" ()pportullitie5 for the Illdiall Spice
Tjabrr:r, T.B., Unerdal, U. und Lundc, G. (1972) Tllc
__Industry. B..tRC,\'ek'.\ ,132,1-4.
effect of ionising radi;ltion 011the microbiologiC:11
Pre,"enlion of Food Adulteration Act 1954. EDC contcnt und volatile coli~tituenls of spices. J/ilifl/a/
Publishing Pvt. J~td.,34, Lalb:lgh, Lucknow. pp of ,1pp/ied Hilcteri%J,'J' .35 (3), 473-478.
244.
UNEP (Unitcd Nations I~n~'ironmcntul Protl:ction)
Pruthi. J.S. (1980) Spices and Condiments -Chemistry, (1995). Muntreal Protocol on Substancl:s th:lt
Microbiology and Technology. Acadcmic Press. dcpletc thc Ozone Luycr: 199-1, Report of thc
Inc. Nc\" Yorl;. Mcthyl Bromide Tcchnical Options Committcc-
Rahman Rczaur, 1\1ainuddim Ahmcd, Mosharraf 1995 Asscssmcnt.
Hossain and Gulnahar (1982) A Preliminary Vujdi, M. und I'crcira, R.I1.. (1973) Comparativc crfccts
reports on the problems of dried spice pcsls and of ethylene oxide, gulnma irradiation and
their cOlit rol. BallKladesh Joufllal (if Zoology microwu\'c treatment on sclcctcd spices. J"lIfllal
10(2),1"1-1"". of f(Jild Scii!//ce 38: 893.
Ret'\'cs, 1't.G., 1\1<."
Daniel, C.A. and Ford, J.II. (1985) Venskutonis, 11.., Poll, L. und L:lr~cn, 1\1. (1996)
Org:lnie :Ind inor~;lnic bromilic resiliucs ill spices Inflllcncc of dryin~ and irradiation Oil 1111:
fumigatcli \,ith methyl bromide. Joufnalof compositiUII or vol:ltill: compounds of "'lIyml:
,.f;:ril'ulturallllld Food Chemiftt;1' 33(5),780- 783. (ThY//Ie I'll/Karis L. ) /:Il/vollr ////:1 Fr//Krll//l'('
Ripp, B.S., dc Largic. T.A. and Harry, C.D. (1990' ,,' jollfl/a/. 11,123-128.
Ad\'anccs in the practical application of Yudav, T.D. (19H9). Insect illfcstatioll ill storl:d SplCt'S
controllcd atmosphere for thc prcscrv:ltion of (wllolc arId ground) und its control. In:
graill ill !\IJ~il..iiil. ill: Caldcron, M. anu uarkai- i'rocccdillgs of sympt;sium on "'I~ccellt Trcllds
Golan, l't., ld., Food Prcservalion by modilicd and Devclopmcnt ill P~st-l;ur"c~t and
atmosphercs. Boca I{aloll, Florid:l, CI'tC press, Tcchnolugil:~ for Spic!:s" at C~VI1{I. Mysorc. 1-1tll
;.ug, 1989, pp 78-83. "
151-187.
22