= “e" PRI 17 disturbing things Snowden has taught us (so far) Editor's Note: This artile wos originally published in 2013 ond wos updated in Jonuary 2014. Ithas been updated again. ‘Tne USAPsit cep atidight ae US Senator Rand Pl caning onthe casalieinormaton ‘ert, ‘low enoesmert and anenment agence the power they need tokeep the ned Sere er antral pops clung bukcltion aS phone eas. s)canyouhear me nou? (buna amination enabled he atonal Seay gee oat cae iemain om eon oerent reredveraonts ha ovr califomation cna di bass, nce eosin ncuron fas. The Bis adnan began coecing seh iran Ocoer 20 to rhc) and amend tat was even legatin test pac, national debate quel enue sane amaccey ages) 2veswescan fsesarbingolabecaon wn tze compan ke oe, Spe Google ard ple oes, ple andonaes ches thetechndusty, ameve dened awarenessofthe progam, Pres began in 2007 wth Mose an ead nc Apple n202T besubet 10 PSM survellane here ned enlybereasonabesupicon tat one ofthe suspets scene United ‘Stes: evan cout ordered cobra, thasovermer can aces helfomaton, cos, de chats an! dat rom scl networks recy tush the companies saves witout required canst or ail cor orders. ese pts th cost the program a0 itn er Yar. Domesicaly PSH asters billy to colt ta on US cizers ultatonaly. is, the revelations aces wth meng betaen Chinese President png and Obama aig tension to nated need logue oe cyber sponge Dawe the wo coun, The sumtin Calfoia was focused on Us accusations chinese cybetcks bute US hadley nthewakeot tre nomen, Cina warrants no nate itm US tac EU counts ware roughness Euapean czas now wor they haven spl upon rough he SM tligenc ames Cape. io eames ages Boundless informant sountessformtisatoo hatalostheNsato compte and tock the "metadata around theworé thermore of arco ner bilo pes oineration wereld en US reworks an 3 lion pees wee the Gro eo on Jone tt heat map srs teint sures by coun yp, an volume loin ick ara of hich counien te mon rgted a athe te inlomaton watered. The program = ‘evened petal sezoangtthedocaments ithopetors abet make econo ot Taureimpowenent ‘The consequence cunts formant proveatht despite assranersto Corres theron the NSA oeskep ack ofthe sineionert peomson USetzes. ames Copper recor o natioaineligee, ceeded ‘he gomnnerts une fthe PRIS pgm andconerned Wels conse of etsy mein eaten Clap ramed ne progam publ Theiler ams ei at ‘there once clapper emai adamant ay ounaten teredon Us zee "migra he ent oad surance, itippe opener mages) |) the United tates ackng china Sonn speaking ith The South China tring ost ge fin pein than ale ater tant Guarana esa inl as hesouee cf eens on eZ Nessidhewouldsayis| Hong Rong ntnet seat eve” nda ate taku his peius tie asa carn wh 2oa2 Aen Harton wh te tet of esting sate Sees. (Seowaen woud er yo Nasa ana nite asian appeatons wth mce nan 20 cous many them dere Stowden ao tothe South china Horing Posh the NSA as been hacking mala Chines and HongKong computes ‘nce 20 cine NSA hacked ater oe Chinese Ue of ong ong hae tothe ongong net xchange ar HongKong’ mae for aint Vale ‘The consequence snonsers staterentharcees the sande between chins andthe Unite Stes overhang Honk ong Seoetay or Serta Tung announces ta the HongKong tenet rar fs een monitored but appears uate, wile fies ners announced at thas not anderen of ‘The domestc debate nthe United tats began to reach fever ch Aap Fllconducted between June 0 ad sue place support aman aren Snowe acts t 4 pert hex? Decne Sails actions were wrong Stl the pol found hat 5 pect espondens het suppor. ‘hensAsuvelaneeretansaseutine inthe ake documents, We Pee pve (tan weet ages 5) etn targets 620 members another PowePolt presentation aka on June Soothes how te Goverment Comranicatons eadguartars6cHO as equa o the HS, se rea ne surveying oleate phone communicator the Garmin 28 he ent othe sunelanes wast gan elma erage atthe meetings whic cae the woke othe 208 ancl ers Bsn of ould ves pubiemecia ee re ire = a eae au ana B=] spy? acring tthe Gaudin Theses sige! "sero ler” embers goeermentin Goon Bouman Ban's pine miler lth ine ee ae of intellect {Maths ifamaton was paused wa ins The prcetton uo ade sch cnet ‘acviqes bei netherngrecedented a uaeThereetionsietedie om Rusa Turkey and South ics, a ouch ad lamas ety tage atvroutines using the sum Mlethere conection ngs 0 ‘Sac sonage he pul ne antl damaging toe Uk garnet span, The ews adedtomovntng oneness cma atk teen GCM athe NssSPRsu progam. e Famer ener vain Alesance | nd Sean Joye, cept etre a Loenety Images) Wan process ‘une 2 the Guan rae moe documents ined by omen enable eae). ‘Sg y Ate Gel Esc olen 2008, he documents sigh on procedure scone bythe Foti naligence uvelane Cou cago the document he SAan he and make se) Inooration nave gered on US zens a perodor upto eats wc waaR— ety theo mation deemed beeen preventing toa securty teats orto futher Insesigains The rtornaton canbe sett aes goverment org ants, solongasthe ers’ anonymous. ‘The consequence nite the gocures ote the crarstancss the NSA ust sve data cole fo US ten. 35 ‘ells the iorous eps nas ae supposed take to make sue a get soutien Unite tes, they aaarevel sever nay eka can contin edt cole on US. Teens appear core serentsby Obama are erste HSAconet acess dso Scien Pati Mtaan, ptr generar the US Ofc f Pesoael Managenet nana, announced anongoing ree iso whter proper bacgourd check ws conde blr Sane ashen 2 Top seact/serstve Conpartrete formation evel dara. ‘he imestistion focused onthe oertonsof Us mvestitlon sevies (UI Vs based information are security conpany employed byte government to cant backround checks US erent oct came uncer fir dringa Senate subcrenteheinginvesgting hy te NSA ed Stouton Seite acepnceson hare Sor Abe Hamiton pte peti aes at aed ‘oat and USS, whch scene Snoaen for hi goverment sect cearane before is okt Boos Alen Harton, sini unaueesin eign ary spins lee e (reer wocsamiacey mages ‘Tends who hace ogee stay together ‘Te Gurion reveled on June 2 crete Usp agency Gt ties heMneingthe Interne” ap Cla Telcos Explain” Theses tne eporanIBmontol prgrame i er tostoe mena for opto 3 ey andcanten carp ttre da loan the aerey tosmovoughieanseromaton esa ‘medocurentsshow teeter to whey he GOHO hasbeen bets tap 200 fhe pic ada bene th Atari son, potently accessing "21 ptabeso! ommursstiors ted Te sidesincate tht pate compares ae requredto pve GCM diet asta tap the cables The UnteaHingon share that information wth theSADepningin 01, gteUS5py Beney unite eso GoM data, Theses show that "859500 SA employes aS phate conUacs th op see cerance had acs to GOHD databases” ‘The consequence: omcatsang pate ctzes aed cncenson btn sdestthe Ath te suet erga intedrestictons onthe URS epic suvelance sytem, Teco Hn esonsp betentheUSand UKinteligence agencies, a5 elas the SAS etered accesso Basar leaingeyer-suveltnce sores, came unde eigen cn. Sm dpomss wore tat he revelations cul negate inpactEv-US rae dscasons, an that Chinas eybeseciy al, eayon a tate tig cult a wl ‘NSA targets chines largest research ub and mar eecommunicaton provider Spetigo tha South chins ong os Saowde ako ure 23 thane NSA as ackeints computer neti igh erst an unkno aumber tines Stowen sidan aig doy “aary6compites andres wee ached, Sowden agua the esl and oer dese ile coud oly cme om ackingor phys accesstothe compas. ‘Theft 2 Tshnphua Une ones backbone networks that comps the china Edcatlon and each Network (ERNET, trough Whi net dao malons of Chinese an be assed Me system wsthe ist os nd ard sow th age steal scart ub inthe word Roane ye Mintzryof eeationandmttainecy theunersty acter clears. ‘Thesouth hina Moming Post ako pushed the alegton om Sone that US agetshckehe Hongkong bedqurton f acne patlpownedconpary ht provides the jy fier ie‘wand he Unite Sates, wheresomect he wages loud comput apo seach nahes reba “Th consequence Following Sno’ evans, ins Minty of faen thin reste ew oie for ang "plac acttesinohing per sey Cine diplomats China as ben the ac oS acing ary nerfed thal he te woud be cr pat of China lege an sec alge Dept ance tn thea col dea ay progestin ron er ‘ese sues alts beeen he aco woese conte. e ‘sovecorornatonatiretgece hn Neopets Aer Wongety rages) a) False switch enn Geena he Guarana who recived Sowden’ ft alt The Daly Bact ht he Somer rena pred, ote Wlamason lea beled osnmaldsi tat ugh the tect dct rer Sond Das made ranges Tore passwords reach thse wines eisurablet acess he Pisa reals si stowden gee him many more documentsthan hosesofatelease and bleves Somdenhasevesnae on pots. The cunt ae sel obe stored ono asin Some’ pases, reel sid edoesnotwsh push ary tals te HSA survellance ster that ‘oul ester rena secu breaches, nor des Snowe, ‘The consequence: ‘etc nat Sven made lp copes he asad inteigece ecries cresteaenewed ange berong US MIs Neu questions wee aed sto Whether he US wellgznce comunity cn deqaely stem the cient ek and prevet tre treacestom eng ® (Donhiquerageusety nag) 0) usa cuve rope Geman news again De Spleerevsladon June 29M hod seen aot 2019 document bana by Saomen Shouing at he NSA sped on Cuopean izes and Cafe. ‘Te document eprtedy species urpean “locaton tage with anmansshged ut a9 major focus US evescopaing Me dcument also mets teconmniatonshacking—fstepatedy ofl he yess gp ofthe EU Counc of Mister the turapean ound tess Upaee sulngin suse cas tom an nseocaped ulig at theRATO headquarters oubideo ruse, ecncngt the document, wee toed he pes aug opens erp nang verte ne ations. Geman sce Minster Sabie Leute Sennen sla" the masa repotste acca, ten hecls the mathods sed by enemies Cvingtne cota war? erences wh he US sul program wer partly een Germany whee er 2 ak convesadon betwee German chanel Angel Mera Obama dung sito ern carr the ron cerseunty wash epk. ® TTowanlan resident ata Gast et and rench Peden anes Holand Lacques Deaton mages) 1) bozensofembasstes hacked ‘Juv The uaan ead 2207 docurent that ramed 38 embassies andmisons that were “org of Ussuvelone ncudingthe Ey embasy nvastnon nas msn nar. was une ccoingt The un wheter to et wee tags NE HSA on ot gence he CA and were abo wating ther Te ocumentcescbedbugbng fx maces th isting eles ands the names popamslike"Wabash an operation ected atthe rench vase n sing, ‘The tofnurs get wasnt ined EY membesor the adona enanies ote United states. buna nudes the es ofl na Hanks wea reece and Tre. ainasde ‘noni of peas ration etvcen tetra stats andthe Une Sats Was the inary sat thet The Gosan epaed ‘Th consequence Theinttigene leak my haope help typed etre pemennthe wrth Pessions betwee he ard Uied States scto begin ly in Waring OC ona ew fe {age pc Fench resign: Fanos lane rade pubic hisage othe cover opis, 6 tYatany tre negttons wale cote nthe Ute Slates ca allurauatzedsuvellane ‘of EU ngs nd peor US ics ove ed to smosth over epi, bute succes heFran Presiden Dims Rose an Brack bua a the summa sino Se 6 ewe Smad ety ages) Inu, eGuacan ep that Ba seeondonj oth Une Sates neni comes tothe amen ‘communicton sujet NSA surance, Th NEA ac been ney ying onion ot ‘alr, incu alleged eavestropping on Rouse on ena and phon cal. _ September's 20 raitn si, Sain Present is es ek none om one mecing ith Dbamain which personallyunetookto investigate these report bck he Bt before hg Sateot conga. what Rouse aid around ins esponage ‘Asa vest Rost clatter Ot. 23 vote Wie House demanding asin anda commit fromastngon oop stooping nb county. as seo betes sates bya aan residertnaboutwo decades, ard the only one shedied hyo athe White House tough the (bmadminsration ced the posteenemant vas aol econ nadeby two presides, some nel esas the stent tuk et for enon one NSA es anak sis woustatesapto beak aay om he ein el Tessin Torcing internet compan le Caoglean Facebook ols ide ri sbrdes ott ey re subjecto dation pac avs bldg mre amet charge poste ete Waza aricarcund tential spywaeauenngastaterun emallsericeto at asan tera Gmal Yahoo Mal ond ‘hes ndlying anew underter cae Ewopeso tat ran on connect wth countesthare ety ‘econ the test from shown the US government mows Who youre at (NchOs arse moss) 13) Youraddressbookisthe MS's adress book -Astepated ty th Vashngon Ps, thes Sowden aks reveal that he NSA has serety beenclletingionsot nal and chat ota its sound the werd Te progam reported taken seman 50,00 contacts romemal nines al chat oom ery dy The Pon Sede an 296 (a lalng a fol 444 13 eal adress bok om ao, 10588 Fam Htal, 2837 fom Fsbo, 3607 rom Gmolland 2381 fom inept ther odes” ‘Te consoquence ‘heen nied progam sxpandon the HSA racheven jon aendy mans PREM and ‘esa popes ich ge the ovement the ait fo aces gl communication, spokesman with the ganization responsible or then the Ofceofthe Dor ofNtona Inge, <3," wearenotreestdinpasorlIformaton abot orcnry Anais" Ann une, Dbamasad hes torts to acre ctl ermine dl ot py pen vn inthe Une states auth atest reveabon sues ote ‘Geman non pages, Oc 25, 20 (een GapiGety age) 14) No excepions US ale tangled pan lue Aner urd of elation, courtesy of Sane, aks on Oct 2focwsedonthescipe of ead ‘States sping omnes, eng Garman, ance and Spain deciding tomes, then tappa the ones of somes woiendes ining dose German Choncatar angele to ane th snooping unacceptable between Mens Spanch Nala Son up forthe ean repostiatine NSA mentored 6 milion phanecasin Spin none month, aceaingtothe eran emat onsen ‘The consequence euraome Asa rent elon ae sing between the US an varlousales. Marl petsnaly called Obama on OtFane aso calle hits Hee conn’ Obama abot epost re Awash matephane calls and et meses millon French pepe ‘me unc says net's ofan utr in spa thin ther Crops counts ough Spanish newspaper Mucospressingthe goverment charge the Nah sping which sale rempd moe of response om he Spansh autores eal he eavesdopping "appropiate and tmacepble™ “ul .Richardsiarrceny moses) 15) The future of spying ithe Quantum computer ‘re Weingtn Pot spot on 2,204 that — as away, acocgt acumen ey Ssomen the NSA sracrgo tuldasocaled quatum corte whch wold be aus oom acd metals that asthe aio bes encxptos used pte everthing fom bankingt> nea recor The nem quart computer's ato 331 min propa suggested rearing Had Ts Many inthe scl omuniy have lnabean tying te ul quantum compuersandiesurcer how ‘ch hither lonane HS projets compared to any ces "TheN Sh appease renee at running neckanneck wth ant computing is sponsored the European ion andthe Ss Wosingan Po ‘The consequence: Ieesimpl ray The NSAcllate andere dt So at any point tcantunt tht asta ta oact Information about travel plans, cera, racial vansocns ad somuchrore—allonpeeple wre re oner no sco files ay. ccs he Awol able reason omns. plc ncyftion cing tone usc a otc ate eres ound te od Pra megan aun compe web abe a thea tig Asneypion whchscanbles comatose anyone neo tinned et To beak Soneane wouldhoeiotacor the produto wolage us. a ay compute atts today, ta roces wd ean reasonable aunt ote years ond yea Aquat computer would meatal beable toa sun numbers exponen as. ‘Tonaones seer images) 16) "0a" LoL, ‘The Guan poten Jn. 14th te NSA cole 20 ion en essa dey ound he Wot The SA Den used themes eta! ton tomato colar abd es cre east modieuser Anda te sp hang, he NSA prouGed Wshinelgence wth allo at ‘iawn the sncepion of he actual core tet eseages our embarassing saree, Uke evening me HSAs, th progrannas2 col name DSH He The consequence es spl aly Snethe NS calls andstores alts kfm, at any pa caret yor pt trl pans Franca taneatone ane contact nomater vou re under sepcon ales 2 ore Sound tg Unetea These revltions eam wo dys blr Present ack Oba gave9 ‘nnrspeeeh heel feo ed needa quant compete dephera utinng Proporedpolicy changes neocon Sroudenshisedoungandthe semen NSA scan (Prope Humennrncetyimases) 27) sy, ns Inova rughingpins vay pein pce phones a besking tar SM cade noite pieces. The Snowden ek teaches shat we sha probalyal be dig that. thetine. ‘The ltrepeprtad in ebruay 215th Sowden rode acumen tha showed he NSA and the ccnghadhaced no the etvorkof Gara uth company that manufactures two ion SA‘ards per ysrandsvaples AT, veran, Mobile nd many others Providers Acodngt the Intec, theRackoulshave vente ances sere theblions of nig encypon eye tht aaa anti that tad eon he tant ot att paca opine tins and ‘Siiewas tel then SAand Conghad ben espns, Butt eiethenacks wold ave ie he agence acest the encryption es The consequence It devons wheter Gematomich ides tel onbing the "wo leaerin etal secu sight owt the hack’ speneration The tres foo, and telnet i the RSA [20a cane tone neytion toby pss ln provide and mart the ica dt Spout ily eke 18 CF THEWORLD nd ether sensi ning sere wanztbep Tukeysimaconet imesrecae Sune sings Sse sie Miho Eka