Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Comanche Flyer 112008
Comanche Flyer 112008
The International
Comanche Society
You Fly
The
Plane...
UBG-16
Programmable Redlines
Shock Cooling Alert
Differential Alarm
Trend Analysis
True Lean Detection
Data Recording...
and so much More!
We’ll
Watch
The Engine
FP-5L
Electronics International
63296 Powell Butte Hwy
Bend, OR 97701
(541)318-6060 WWW.Buy-EI.Com
Unparalleled Customer
Service Since 1979
The Comanche Flyer
is the official monthly member
publication of the
International Comanche Society
P.O. Box 1810 Volume 35, No. 11 • November 2008
Traverse City, MI 49685-1810 www.comancheflyer.com
U.S.: 888-300-0082
Other: 231-946-3712 Published By the International Comanche Society, Inc.
Fax: 231-946-6180
Email: ICS@villagepress.com
Contents
www.comancheflyer.com
ICS President
Dave Fitzgerald 2 Letter from the President Dave Fitzgerald
(330) 484-4609
Cell: (330) 936-7979 Cover Story: Comanche Spirit
E-mail: aaviator@neo.rr.com 4 The Resuscitation of N6272P – by Marvin Wade
Managing Editor A 13-year Project
Kim Blonigen
E-mail: kblonigen@cox.net 10 ICS Board of Directors & Tribe Chiefs
Display Advertising Manager 2007-2008 ICS Standing Committees
Genevieve Lyon ICS Past Presidents
(800) 773-7798
Fax: (231) 946-9588
E-mail: glyon@villagepress.com
11 ICS Technical Directors
Trading Post & Classified Advertising
ICS Tool Loan Program
Nancy A. Whitten CFF-Trained CFIs
(800) 773-7798
Fax: (231) 946-9588 Technically Speaking
E-mail: nancy@villagepress.com 12 Engine Longevity
Graphic Design
Brandon Hoffman Feature
E-mail: bhoffman@villagepress.com 16 The Killough Manuals by Bill Creech
Printer
Village Press Feature
2779 Aero Park Drive 20 21st Century Capability for a ’65 Classic by Jay Hulbert
Traverse City, MI 49685-0629
www.villagepress.com 23 ICS Membership Renewal Form
ICS Technical Directors
Bill Creech 25 ICS Items for Sale
Tel: (915) 581-3401 (9:00 a.m.-9:00 p.m. MST)
Fax: (915) 581-6168 Feature
E-mail: BJC1946@aol.com
Zach Grant
26 Buying a Comanche by Dave Pyle
Cell: (317) 201-4293 (Calls accepted all hours From the Logbook
on his cell, he’ll return call if message left)
E-mail: L1011jock@sbcglobal.net 28 From New York to Alaska … and Back by Dwight Coombe
ICS Tool Loan Program 38 ICS Name Badge Order Form
Matt Kurke
10340 Regent Circle
Naples, FL 34109 40 From the Tribe Chiefs
Ph: (239) 593-6944
mkurke@comanchegear.com Fly-In Report
The Comanche Flyer (ISSN 08994223, 44 European Tribe Enjoys a Fly-out by Harvey Crush
USPS 2-324) is available to members; to Bergen, Norway
the $25 annual subscription rate is included
in the Society’s Annual Membership dues 46 Comanche Classifieds
in US funds below. Comanche Flyer is
published monthly by Village Press 47 Advertiser’s Index
U.S., Canada, Mexico
One year $66, Two years $120 Last Laugh
Europe and South Africa 48 High Flight Parody with FAA Supplement
One year $89, Two years $166
Australia, All other countries
One year $79, Two years $146
Spousal Members
$33 per year
Cover Photo
Marvin Wade’s newly refurbished 1959
PA-24-250 Comanche.
Copyright Notice
The act of making a submission for publication is an
express warranty that such contribution does not infringe
on the rights or copyright of others. Nothing appearing
in the Comanche Flyer shall be reproduced or distributed
without the express permission of the publisher.
INTERNATIONAL
Postmaster
Send address changes to the above address. COMANCHE
Periodical postage paid at Traverse City, MI 49686
SOCIETY, INC.
O
ur oldest Comanches are now Question One: Who can do this work
approaching 51 years, with and what are the rules governing the
our youngest going on 37. making of an owner-produced part?
The availability of replacement parts Answer: FAR 21.303 (b) (2) pro-
is crucial to maintaining our airplanes, vides for an aircraft owner or operator
keeping them safe and preserving to produce parts for maintaining or
their value. Fortunately, many altering his or her own aircraft. Under
Comanche parts can be purchased this provision, the owner-produced
from Piper, Lycoming or one of many part can only be installed in an air-
vendors in the aviation industry. craft owned or operated by that per-
However, as the fleet continues to son, and the owner-produced part
age, some parts may become increas- cannot be created for sale to others.
ingly difficult to find. What options do Question Two: Does the owner
we have in the event we cannot locate have to make the part himself?
a particular part or, worse yet, if it is Answer: The answer can be found
no longer being produced? in a FAA Memorandum dated August
First, let’s examine the rules govern- 5, 1993, in which the Assistant Chief
ing the general privileges and limitations Counsel for Regulation makes the fol-
of a maintenance technician or certified lowing interpretation:
A&P mechanic to make or repair A part does not have to be solely
parts on your certified aircraft. Under produced by the owner to be consid- Question Three: Can the owner
FAR 65.81 and FAR 145.51, a technician ered an owner-produced part. contract out the manufacture of the
or repair station may perform mainte- However, the aircraft owner must par- part and still have a part that is con-
nance, preventive maintenance, and ticipate in the manufacture of the sidered, “owner produced?”
alterations on an aircraft or appliance part in at least one of five ways for it Answer: Yes, as long as the owner
for which he is rated. A maintenance to be considered “owner produced.” participated in one of the five functions
technician or repair station can make 1. The owner provides the manufac- listed in the answer to question two.
patch plates or reinforcement splices turer of the part with the design or Question Four: Can the owner
and incorporate them into the repair performance data. contract out the manufacture of the
of a part. A technician or repair 2. The owner provides the manufactur- part to a non-certificated person and
station cannot, however, make new or er of the part with the materials. still have a part that is considered
replacement parts for a certified air- 3. The owner provides the manufac- “owner produced?”
craft. Since mechanics cannot legally turer with fabrication processes or Answer: Yes, as long as the owner
make parts for your plane, and assum- assembly methods. participated in one of the five functions
ing that a PMA, TSO, standard, or 4. The owner provides the manufactur- listed in the answer to question two.
production holder replacement part is er of the part with quality control Question Five: If an owner par-
no longer available, what can you do? procedures. ticipated in one of the five functions
An option often overlooked is an 5. The owner personally supervises listed, is the part considered FAA
“owner-produced part.” the manufacture of the new part. approved?
The Resuscitation
of N6272P –
A 13-year Project
I
n August of 1995, I bought N6272P
– a 1959 PA-24-250 – in my home
state of Texas. On the ferry flight
home, the heater was stuck full on.
Good thing I didn’t have to worry
about getting frost bite on the short
25 nm flight! I started to work on the
airplane as soon as I got her home.
The first thing I did was a triage
check, system by system, and found gear system, is it? It was time for all They put them in radios in the 20th
the landing gear was the worst safety new fuel bladders and fuel system century, and the radios only use half
problem. When we started to work on rebuild. More fuel is better, yes? the gigawatts, but you lose the heat-
each system, we didn’t just repair it, Unless you’re on fire, so a new aux aft ing system for the back seat and all
we updated it to the “latest and great- baggage fuel tank STC from Merlin that aft ballast to hold the tail down
est” that was available. So, it was time Simon was the ticket. When all of that and keep the speed under control. I
for a single fork gear mod, gear lobe was done, it was time to fly it some guess you can’t have everything, or
speed fairings, new brake system, toe more. We soon discovered that frost- can you? We put a S-Tec 60-2 auto-
brakes system, new tires and wheels, ed glass may be okay for a shower pilot, electric trim, GPSS, altitude
hub caps, new flap gear alert warning stall, but not so good for a windshield. selector, Garmin 300 IFR APP
system, new gear cables, motor, trans- Also, trying to talk on the old Marconi’s approved, Mark 12D+ Kns 80 IFR
mission, switches, repaired wiring was like trying to talk with two cans APP approved, KT76C, PS6000M/S,
and lights, all new bushings, bearings, and some string; the tubes must had Argus 5000CE, NSD360 HSI, electric
and all ADs were also completed. been getting awful weak, so it was time and vacuum attitude indicator, two
Fuel is not supposed to come out for some new upgrades. Bell Labs altimeters one drum, one three hand,
on your head while you work on the invented something called transistors. and much more.
Engine Longevity
The following is from a series of not know it well enough to know no idea how the engine performed
online postings from the Comanche about the cranks or the case, but if after that.
Owner’s Forum. These postings are pro- the case does not have any history of I conclude that there is no fixed
vided for informational purposes only. (fretting), it could be original. rule – if the case isn’t cracked and the
The views expressed in these postings Bill Wenkman cam and crank are recoverable, then
represent the opinions of individual _________________________________ why not continue?
Comanche owners and have not been Pat
vetted by the ICS technical committee. Recently I requested a quote through _________________________________
As a responsible pilot and aircraft Aviall on Lycoming rebuilds of IO 320
owner, you should always seek the engines that were from 1965. They I was talking to an FBO friend of
advice from an experienced, trusted had been overhauled as field overhauls mine the other day about just this
source, such as your A&P or CFF- probably three times and were due for issue. After 25 years of paying for
approved CFI, before applying any of a fourth. Aviall called Lycoming, since overhauls on 150s, 172s and
the techniques or recommendations the inquiry was to have them actually Cherokees on his training and rental
presented in these postings. rebuild the existing engines, and line, he thinks that 4,000 hours is the
The postings are printed as they Lycoming indicated that they would limit for cranks and cams, but he has
appeared in the Forum. Due to space junk engines of that age and supply no particular limit for cases. Just one
considerations, we are publishing only exchanges. I was surprised. I asked for person’s opinion.
selected posts. clarification as to whether the recom- If I know the entire history of an
_________________________________ mendation was age or engine time and engine, I feel much more comfortable
I was told age. Why, I don’t know. about running up hours. What both-
The thread on narrow deck engines They are wide deck engines. ers me is an engine that “starts life” in
got me thinking about the practical life Our engines are relatively low com- logbook terms as a factory reman,
limits of our engines. Mine have 4,000 pression and are 1:7 where only three where you don’t know how many
hours TT and have been overhauled Lycomings are 1:7 and the rest are 1:8, hours were on the parts to start with.
twice. I am sure that they are good for so they go for a very long time. Since I’m not sure that even the factory can
at least one more overhaul, but an engine rebuild only leaves the answer that question.
beyond that I don’t have any data. case, cam and crank as original (and So, if I had factory reman engines
Who has the highest time engines the cam and crank can have metal at TBO, I’d be thinking new engines. In
in terms of TT? When should we be added), there doesn’t seem [to be] a my case, the engines were new from
thinking about getting a zero time or lot of merit in junking an engine due Lycoming when they went on the air-
even a new engine? Does anyone to age, but the propensity for cracking plane, so I’m thinking overhaul. YMMV.
know if Lycoming retires cases and does increase with engine life. _________________________________
cranks at some point? I helped with a removal of an
Kristin engine from a Cessna 180 about 15 Pat,
_________________________________ years ago and the owner said it was I am aware that there is no fixed
2,000 [hours] since last overhaul (when rule. There is likely a point of eco-
About seven years ago, I spoke with he bought the plane) and that it was nomic life, however. A cracked case
a Lycoming Sales rep. I wanted a making heat in climb – obviously the at mid-time is rather expensive.
quote on a Lycoming factory overhaul bearings were worn and making heat. Corrosion and stress increases the
(not a reman) and wanted to trade in When we took the engine apart, the chance of cracking, both in the case
my narrow deck for a Lycoming over- bearings showed so much wear that and in the crank.
haul with a wide deck case. They said they obviously had not been replaced Mine will be about 5,500 TT when
(no extra charge), we just throw away – they were original on this 4,000 TT they come up next for an overhaul. As
the narrow deck case. It is now my engine, the seller had lied about the they are the original engines, I am
understanding that they will no longer overhaul, yet the engine had great more likely than not to overhaul, but
exchange with a narrow deck. compressions and had flown with that isn’t really a concern at this
I personally know of a friend who minimal maintenance for all of that point. I am just curious as to how long
has a 1967 PA-30 that has over 9,000 time. He had the engine overhauled these engines will go.
TT hours on the same engines. [I] do but passed away soon after, so I have Kristin
12 • Comanche Flyer NOVEMBER 2008
Jay, Kris and all, Zach,
You and I think alike. What is Am I missing something here? I I don’t think you are missing any-
running through my mind is to run don’t think a data plate ever wears thing, but there is still probably a
my original engines, overhauled as out. You can replace EVERY compo- point at which the economics of over-
many times as is necessary, until nent on the engine except the data haul become problematic. I would
such time that I begin to question plate (and you can replace that too, in imagine that if you send an engine to
the fatigue limits of the major com- some cases, as long as the information the shop and they say that the case
ponents. Then I would pony up the continues), and as a matter of fact, and crank are scrap, the cost of both
big bucks for brand new, and start many engines are exactly that way as new from Lycoming, plus the rest of
all over again. the crank was replaced this overhaul, the overhaul, might be a bit more
That is why I am curious to see the cases were replaced the next over- than a whole new engine.
how many hours people are success- haul, and it has new cylinders, cam, Kristin
fully running their engines. bearings, accessories ... so as far as _________________________________
Kristin continuing in service, I expect that
_________________________________ could be done this way indefinitely. Hi Matt,
The catch is that for Lycoming, or For the record accuracy, I have
Bill, other overhaulers, to have something owned and operated my PA 30 for
My understanding is that the time for their core credit, they don’t want 41-plus years. My engine experience
on an exchange engine only applies, you to give them overworked junk, so is as follows: Bought airplane with 375
reliably, to the case. The rest is a they put a limit on the age of the hours TT on engines and airplane;
mystery. I prefer knowing. Call me a engine, as well as saying it has to be overhauled at 2,000 hours-plus by
control freak, but there you have it. I assembled, operable, running within Western Skyways of Troutdale,
am inclined to wear out the set I have, the last 12 months, etc. Case in point Oregon; spun a bearing on one crank-
and start over. But then, I use my is the Zephyr overhaul with all NEW shaft about 350 hours after this over-
aircraft for business, and I need some parts except the data plate that they haul, due to small pins holding bear-
level of reliability. are currently advertising in the Flyer. ings (later AD was issued on this
Kristin Zach problem to increase size of pins), and
_________________________________ _________________________________ crank and bearings were replaced.
CUSTOM ENGINE
OVERHAULS
(and exchange)
(800) 397-8181
www.poplargroveairmotive.com
E-mail: dallen@poplargroveairmotive.com
11619 Rt. 76 Poplar Grove, IL 61065
-P1SFTUJ
&îDJFODZ
&OIBODFNFOUT
,FFQJUDMFBO
'"45&3XJUI
4QFFE$PBU
5IF8PSMET-FBEJOH1SPWJEFSPG"WJBUJPO1&3'03."/$&4PMVUJPOT
XXX-P1SFTUJ"WJBUJPODPN
NOVEMBER 2008 Comanche Flyer • 15
Feature
I
was moving some “junk” in my He told me that he was fed up with also loaded with good, mostly general,
office the other day, when I the very incomplete and sometimes type info that we all need for safe
noticed that a paper had fallen inaccurate Pilot Operating Instructions operation of our airplanes. Yes, as is
from my grasp. On picking it up, I was he was forced to use. He was naturally true with most “first copy” attempts,
surprised to find that it was an article referring to the booklet that was pub- it was a bit rough, but after all, this
about Doug Killough, dated August 15, lished by Piper for all Comanches. He was HIS VERY OWN manual, for HIS
1991. As may be seen in the article (shown said that he had gathered up a lot of Comanche 250. At this point in time,
right), it was all about Doug and his information about his airplane and there was no talk about the scope of
Comanche Pilot Operating Instructions had made his very own personal POI. coverage he ended with.
manuals. When I mentioned my find His next question really intrigued me. Doug continued work on his manual
to Editor Kim Blonigen and Tribe He asked, “Bill, would you like to see and we talked frequently about his
Chief Bruce Thumann, they suggested what I’ve done?” I naturally said, progress. He was insatiable about
that I do a bit of reminiscing. “Yes, you bet!” accuracy and completeness. He even
I had met Doug a number of times The manual that I received in a few contacted some of the original test
at fly-ins but we weren’t close friends. days was a real eye opener. It con- pilots who did the very first flight
One day he called me. I think it was tained all the mandatory information tests on the airplane. As it progressed,
during my presidency of ICS in 1990. contained in the official POI, but was it became more and more evident
that copies should be made available
to any Comanche owner. No, it was
not to be just a general reference
manual either, but a manual
SPECIFICALLY written for the model
of Comanche being represented. This
was phase one and it goes without
saying that it went over like gang-
busters. He sold a lot of copies and it
was gratefully received.
There was one big problem with it
in Doug’s eyes, however. It wasn’t a
legal replacement for the original
Piper produced booklet. Not to be
dismayed, Doug simply went to the
FAA and convinced the “powers that
be” that his manual was, in fact,
much more complete than was the
original manual. This action made his
manual a legal replacement for the
original and ended the requirement to
possess BOTH manuals.
All of us in the ICS owe Doug’s
memory a tremendous vote of thanks
for his untiring efforts in producing
this manual. In addition, we owe a
debt of thanks to Doug’s heirs and to
those in the ICS who were responsible
for salvaging the publishing rights for
our latter day Comanche pilots. This
manual is a real treasure.
Editor’s Note: For more information
on how to order your own copy of the
Killough manuals, go to page 19.
Singles:
01.) 180 2550 1957-64 1047 24-1 3687
02.) 250 2800 1958-60 997 103 2298
03.) 250 2900 1961 1127 2299 2843
04.) 250 2900 1962-64 1179 2844 3687
05.) 250 2900 1962-64 1220 (FI) 2844 3687
06.) 260 2900 1965 1334 4000 4299
07.) 260 2900 1965 1333 (Carb) 4000 4299
08.) 260B 3100 1966-68 1359 4300 4803
Not Avail 09.) 260B 3100 1966-68 1358 (Carb) 4300 4803
10.) 260C 3200 1969-72 1545 4804 5028
11.) 260T 3200 1970-72 1640 (Turbo) 4901 5028
12.) 400 3600 1964-65 1295 26-3 148
Twins:
13.) PA30 3600 1963-68 1269 30-2 1744
1969 1515 1745 2000
14.) PA30T 3725 1964-68 1269 (Turbo) 143 1744
1969 1515 (Turbo) 1745 2000
15.) PA39 3600 1970-72 1605 39-1 155
16.) PA39T 3725 1970-72 1605 (Turbo) 1 155
21st Century Capability
for a ’65 Classic
by Jay Hulbert, ICS #15334
W
hen I bought my Twin have the same minimums as Category I cross country and approach with John
Comanche (02Y) in 2004, ILS approaches. So, while the Runway in his magnificently equipped PA30, I
the airplane had beautiful 17 Localizer offers minimums of 380 decided that the GNS 480 was the
paint, a great interior, and an okay and 1, the Runway 35 RNAV/GPS is unit with the best IFR cross-country
panel of mid-90s vintage centered good for 301 and 1 with prospects for capability, and that was the unit I
around a KLN 90B GPS with King it to be 200 and one-half within a year bought. This actually took place just
Silver Crown radios and a Century or so. It was time to update the panel as Garmin was discontinuing the 480,
2000 autopilot. The 89B served our to WAAS capability. but I figure that by the time they dis-
dis
purposes admirably for quite a while. John van Bladeren of Ron and John’s continue support years from now we’ll
I fly a lot for business, which inevi- Comanche Service was my consultant all be on to new technology anyhow.
tably means coming home after dark. on picking new avionics. For those
With our Pacific Northwest climate, who haven’t had the pleasure, John The Upgrade Process
that also means coming home after runs a consulting engineering firm Given my limited budget, we decided
dark in bad weather. For about a year for his “day job.” Selling custom on a two-step upgrade process. Step
I’ve been based at Aurora airport, laser cut panels and doing avionics one would be to pull out the KLN 89B
which has a localizer approach includ- installations mainly in Comanches and my number one comm, a KY 97,
ing an approach lighting system, but is a sideline job and, I think it’s fair out of the existing panel and replace
no glideslope. I was resigning myself to say, John’s passion. John has them both with the 480. A Century
to doing “dive and drive” arrivals seen the inside of more Comanche GPS Steering unit would be added
when I realized that the Aurora GPS panels than anyone alive and has that would allow the 480 to drive the
approaches had been upgraded to installed every kind of avionics autopilot through complete flight plans
WAAS approaches with LPV (Localizer equipment that exists. For anyone and approaches. We’d hold off on a
Performance with Vertical Guidance). even THINKING about a panel upgrade, new laser cut panel and a multifunc-
multifunc
The FAA considers this to be a call John first! tion display until I could re-charge my
finances. John thought this would be
a simple, one weekend job and gener-
gener
ously made time in his schedule.
However, as we got into the job,
things got to be a bit more complex, as
they tend to sometimes do. We found
that the previous owner, when install-
install
ing the KLN 89B and the KN 53 Nav,
had used an unbelievably complex
system of relays in order for the KN 53
to be able to drive both the number 2
nav display and the HSI (when the HSI
was switched to “nav”). Some 20 relays
were installed on a custom-built circuit
board in the nose that talked to the
panel through a pair of cannon plugs
that would have been at home on a
Boeing airplane! The radios were wired
individually, using, as our Australian
friends would say, a dog’s breakfast of
different wires, connectors and relays.
02Y’s old panel Not a good thing for reliability, and a
real challenge to try to put a new GPS/
non-precision approach, but in practice I had three choices – a 530W, a Comm into such a messy system.
it is flown pretty much exactly like an 430W or a GNS 480. I played with the
ILS. The intention is (once sufficient simulators of all three, flew or observed John with the relay board. All this
operating experience is gained by the approaches with all three, and flew a for one Nav! (opposite page)
feds and pilots) for LPV approaches to simulator equipped with a 430. After a 02Y’s new panel (below)
Address:_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
E-Mail:_ _______________________________________________________________________________________________________
Spouse’s Name:__________________________________________________________________________________________________
Address:_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
E-Mail:_ _______________________________________________________________________________________________________
Spousal Membership
One year – $33 Two years – $60
Authorized Signature:___________________________________________________________________________________________
The Brebner Family
British
Lodge “The Flying Fisherman's Paradise”
Excellent
!
Fishing!
www.tsuniahlakelodge.com
(250) 392-5612
P.O. Box 4685, Williams Lake, B.C. Canada V2G 2V7 Fax: (250) 392-4959
Call Today
for Advertising
Opportunities
in
The Official
Membership
Publication of
The International
Comanche Society
Name: ICS #:
Street Address:
BUYING A
COMANCHE
By Dave Pyle, ICS #730
W
hile this experience may Without hesitation we traveled four We drafted a sales agreement with
not be typical, it shows hundred miles to see the Comanche. To conditions that included a prop overhaul,
that when a serious buyer my practiced eye, it was better than adver- pre-buy inspection and two-week closing.
and willing seller come tised. The test flight confirmed that it was The reason for the prop overhaul is that it
together with a very good airplane, there is smooth and quiet. Everything worked. was the only item that didn’t meet our cri-
cri
a happy ending. Perhaps not perfect, but a forty-year air- teria of 1,000 hours or 10 years since over-
over
plane rarely can be no matter how well haul. We might have let that go and paid a
We’ll not identify the buyer except that
cared for. A review of the logbooks and lower sales price. However, as it turned out,
he is a new pilot and this is his first air-
secondary records uncovered a few anoma- the overhaul required new blades (2) that
plane. Likewise the seller is a serious pilot
lies, but again some of that background was cost the owner $5,000 instead of $2,500.
who has taken very good care of his 1967
now ancient history. Importantly the last Buying lesson learned. Don’t compromise.
PA24 260 (B) in the six years he has owned
20 years included well-documented
and flown it. As expected following our due diligence,
improvements. The recent annual was
the pre-buy was routine supporting our
My role was to help the buyer find the comprehensive by a well-respected shop.
belief this was a fine airplane and a good
airplane that best suited his interest and We discussed it with the shop and got a
value. Still no matter the history, an inspec-
inspec
proposed use. That search actually started copy of the work order.
tion is good insurance.
with Bellanca Vikings; led to a (rejected) Let’s take a minute to say why this late
offer on a Meyers 200D, and jelled when model Comanche won top spot in the Happy Ending
the subject Comanche was listed for sale. I sweepstakes. The 1966-72 260s are truly The seller and buyer made the three-
follow the market for the later model modern airplanes. I consider them the most hour flight to bring the “new” Comanche to
Comanches, and this one was posted on versatile of all complex older airplane choices Houston, its new home. The process took
the Trade-A-Plane website. It looked good, … stable, comfortable, great payload, long just over two weeks, from start to finish …
the specs met our criteria and the price range with 90 gallons of fuel, and reasonable good people and a good airplane.
reflected the current market. (These days maintenance. Performance matches newer
this is not always the case.) airplanes at far more affordable prices.
bogert-av.com 800-627-8088
I
think we all dream of flying our air- age 10) were finally ready for this If you were to ask either one of
planes on long vacations with great “once-in-a-lifetime” adventure. We them about this vacation, their
sites and exciting things to do. After had waited a couple years to make faces would light up as they shared
ten years of discussing the possibility sure Dustin was mature enough to their favorite parts. I am confident
and then careful planning, my family cooperate on this type of vacation; that if asked, either of them would
and I finally enjoyed a trip we will and we didn’t want to wait any lon- tell you that they are looking for-
always remember. I hope this account ger as Myles was getting to where he ward to going on similar trips again.
of what we did on our vacation inspires wanted to stay home with friends. Some folks would wait until the
you to make a similar journey. kids are out of the house. We
At the time of our trip (July 18 to wouldn’t leave without our young
August 8, 2007), my wife, Ginger, and men. The adventure was enhanced
two boys (Myles, age 14 and Dustin, greatly with their presence.
St. louis
St. Louis is a great city. The
Gateway Arch is something every-
one should experience. From the
museum, to taking the elevator to
the top, this is a special piece of
American history. The building of
the arch was clearly an exciting
project for St. Louis and our great
country. No, we did not fly under
the arch like my sons requested.
Keeping my pilot’s license is still
more important than doing every-
thing my kids ask. I am sure that
flying under the arch would be fun
… once.
While in St. Louis, I visited my
good friends at Travers Associates.
Working with them throughout the
year writing aviation insurance is a
real pleasure. These high quality,
professional people help me better
take care of my client’s aircraft and
aviation business insurance. A visit
while in town to express my thanks
for their exceptional work ethic and
Cliff trail near Logan Pass. Sun Road below.
communication was imperative.
AIRCRAFT
COVERS
& ENGINE PLUGS
TOLL FREE:
800.777.6405
FUEL
BLADDERS
BUY DIRECT FROM
THE MANUFACTURER
AND RECEIVE
DISCOUNTED
PRICES
Certified F.A.A. Repair phone: 408.738.3959 fax: 408.738.2729 e-mail: bruce@aircraftcovers.com
Station AL4R054M
WWW.AIRCRAFTCOVERS.COM
800-842-9387 Bruce’s Custom Covers, 989 E. California Ave. Sunnyvale, CA 94085
www.aerotechservicesinc.com
30 • Comanche Flyer NOVEMBER 2008
We really enjoyed the hiking. At descriptions I can offer and the pic- tablet computer with the lodging infor-
one point (as was the case more tures we took do not come close to mation and on with the phone calls.
often than Ginger would have liked) how exceptionally incredible these I accidentally scrolled down our alpha-
the boys and I hiked off the trial and sites were. We circled some areas betical list for the Valemount area and
found a valley with a great deal of for more pictures, then eventually the first call I made was to Stonehaven
snow, still un-melted, spanning well flew north over the Canadian border Inn. A fine young man (Clint) answered
up the side of the steep mountain. It and into Cranbrook, BC for our the phone. I let him know our inten-
was too good to pass by without get- scheduled customs time. tions and asked if there were rooms
ting on the snow – up the boys went. From Cranbrook, we proceeded available and if someone could pick
The fairly hard snow wasn’t bad for north and enjoyed more amazing us up at the airport. It turns out
climbing; however when it came time Canadian Rockies. We liked what we that Clint was watching his mother’s
to slide back down, they quickly saw so much that we decided to stay a Bed & Breakfast while she was on
learned that the scalloped firm sur- few days in the area. So out came our vacation and that week was very quiet.
face of the snow was not too kind.
• ENGINE MOUNTS
Repair yours or Buy from Stock
NEW STAINLESS Repaired – Yellow Tagged
STEEL DUAL White Tag for Exports
OAT
Outside Air
44 Years Specializing in:
Temperature
gauge
l Structural
Repair
l Routine Maintenance l Inspections
Replace your present
stem thermometer with lModifications l Engine Overhauls
a new digital read-out Extensive Comanche Experience since
• New features: night light, auto-power shut-off, the days of old Bill Piper. Annual Inspections,
stand-by battery, push button switches.
100 Hr. Inspections and 1000 Hr. Inspections
• Reads F° or C° in large, easily read numbers.
on All Piper Models.
• Tiny no-drag outside fairing. Go faster!
• Designed by Comanche owner for Comanches.
• Models for Brand X low and high wing planes.
ILIFF Aircraft Repair
• No wiring. Accurate to 1°; Resolution, 0.1°
• Contains 2 easily replaced 5000 hour batteries.
& Service Co., Inc.Hangar 17
Tulsa International Airport
$79.98 + 4.95 S&H (CT add 6% tax)
Tulsa, OK 74115
Send check or money order & plane make and model to:
Questair, Inc. PO Box 1225, Orange CT 06477 Phone: (918) 835-5554 Chuck Iliff
Fax: (918) 835-9572
Tel: 203-795-0611 Fax: 203-795-3291 E-mail: iliff@iliff.com
PropellerS
F Dowty
Large Inventory
F
F Hartzell
FSame Day Shipping
F McCauley
F Uncompromised Quality
F Rapco Distributor
F Factory Trained Technicians
F Woodward PT6A
http://www.rockyprop.com
e-mail: rockyprop@rockyprop.com
GovernorS
NOVEMBER 2008 Comanche Flyer • 35
The following day we went out Myles and Dustin each caught hali- often indescribably beautiful amongst
kayaking. Two of us to a sea kayak in but among other strange creatures like the various clouds and mountain peaks.
a guided tour with a stop for lunch. a basket star fish and a sculpin. Ginger Each evening we would eat at a different
This was a good chance to see more had something heavy on the line and place. Several of the B&Bs also had small
wildlife and learn more about the area when we finally got it in, it was a five- restaurants. If we got back early enough
from our guide. The amazing part was foot octopus! It stayed on the boat we would walk or bike to the local hot
the lunch. We were out in the middle with us for a little while, and then we spot for ice cream. We could have stayed
of nowhere, on a shore of various size put him back. That was exciting! in Gustavus for the rest of the summer
rocks, and this young lady pulls out of Upon our return from fishing, we and been really happy. You have to go!
her kayak a folding table, smoked met up with everyone that was fishing
Fairbanks
salmon, and all the fixings for great that day at 4:00 p.m. on the pier. This
sandwiches and snacks! was the time that local girl Pep (Laura) After a week at Gustavus, we flew
north over beautiful mountains and
The next morning we got a ride out Coby comes to pick up any fish for
glaciers and stopped for fuel in the
to the pier where we met up with cutting, packing and freezing. Pep’s
awesome valley of Gulkana on our
Mike Halbert for a day of fishing off Packing also shipped our frozen fish
way to Fairbanks. The morning after
his boat. This was the only other home to us. What great people!
getting to Fairbanks, we flew to Denali
thing we had to book early. Mike is One afternoon we biked down to for flight seeing. We did it that morn-
excellent at his work of finding good the Great Alaskan Husky Ranch where ing because the weather predictions
places to fish, helping us with the the boys were able to run their own for the following day were not good.
equipment, and sharing information dog sled with trained sled dogs. This As it was, clouds shrouded the peak of
about the area. He is a friendly, pro- turned out to be a highlight of the trip Mt. McKinley. The views around the
fessional fisherman and guide. With for both of them. area were still amazing – we were able
the way he treated us, we felt at home We rode bikes and walked the area to see just about everything north and
on his boat. Mike worked in getting us enjoying the spectacular views in west of the mountains. Glaciers and
in good places to watch hump back every direction. During the after- high mountain snow pack were beau-
whales making it unnecessary to take noons, the boys would walk or bike tiful with the varying sunlight as we
that trip separately. out to fish off the pier. Sunsets were flew around the park.
“A top-rated shop”
Aviation Consumer April ‘05
WE OVERHAUL ALL INSTRUMENTS
WE OVERHAUL P/N 21286-000
GEAR MOTOR AND OTHER
STC Oil Temperature Coupler Kit, ALH-I-005
GEAR AND FLAP MOTORS FOR
Approved for Piper Models PA-23 PA-24 PA-30-39 OTHER AIRCRAFT
GPI
After a few days in Fairbanks, we
loaded up and flew an IFR flight plan
to Sitka by way of Anchorage and
Valdez. Passing Denali again, as the
clouds started to break up, gave us
more opportunities for pictures. We
stayed one night in Sitka and flew out
the next morning to Prince George,
BC for fuel and Canadian customs.
Fairbanks reminded us of other We visited the new Museum of We spent one night with our new
small cities in the lower 48. It just so Alaskan history. This building was friends at Stone Haven Inn in
happened that the county fair was shaped to look like glaciers and snow- Valemount, BC before flying to Glacier
going while we were there. If it wasn’t drifts – very interesting architecture. Park International in Montana. We
for the native Alaskan vender tents Inside were high quality exhibits borrowed the courtesy car at GPI and
and products, it could have been any clearly showing the great history of went out for lunch and to retrieve
county fair in the U.S. People of all Alaska. We could have spent a whole some souvenirs that the boys had
walks of life, rides, concessions and a day and still not learned everything eyed earlier during our visit. A final
complete agricultural exhibit made this place had to offer. It is definitely trip to the UPS store and everything
for a great county fair. a must-see in Fairbanks. was shipped home.
1. Nickname_____________________________________________________________________
2. Name________________________________________________________________________
Choice for above badge (circle one) SAFETY PIN ALLIGATOR CLIP
Please make checks payable to Doris Click and send to: 228 Doolittle St., Orlando, FL 32839-1474
Tribe Chiefs
Date Tribe Event/Location Info Source/Host
Aircraft Upholstery
At Same Location Since 1968
The ICS room rate will be valid prior the hospitality room on the third floor. • Complimentary evening carriage rides
and after the function, if available. But The hotel is going to try to put all of with Buddy, a retired Clydesdale Horse
members must contact Christine Dewey our rooms together on the third floor. • Feeding horses in backyard of hotel
(Coordinator) at 1 (352) 873-6447, for The Southeast Tribe sends an open • Two beach sand volleyball courts
any extra days. Cancellations can be invitation to all ICS Members to come
made up to 24 hours before. If you join us in beautiful horse country. • Two outdoor lighted tennis courts
cancel after 24 hours, or are a no show, Mail checks, made out to ICS, • Basketball Courts
you will be liable for one night on your Southeast Tribe with registration form • Putting Green
credit card. Check-in time is 3:00 (above) to Doris Click, 228 Doolittle
p.m. If you require an earlier check-in Street, Orlando, FL 32839, by December • Large outdoor heated pool and whirlpool
time, please advise/request when 24, 2008. Please register with the hotel • Outdoor dining and patio area
making reservations. If your room is direct for rooms. Remember to state
• Full service restaurant, lounge & room
not available before 3:00 p.m., come to ICS for rate.
service
• Complete Business Center
• Wireless high-speed access
Fo r o v e r 2 5 y e a r s , t h e I ndustr y C hoice!
Ocala’s Other Attractions:
adlog MAINTENANCE
THE ™ Silver Springs: Florida’s original attraction,
a national landmark 350-acre nature theme
Record-Keeping System park that features glass-bottom boats,
jungle cruises, jeep safaris and a variety of
shows, attractions and concerts. A day of
fun for the whole family.
FOR VIRTUALLY ALL GENERAL AVIATION FIXED & ROTARY
WING AIRCRAFT plus EXPERIMENTAL and HOMEBUILTS Horse riding, Young’s Paso Fino Farm:
Enjoy a scenic ride through the heart of
horse country on a gentle Paso Fino horse.
14/15 color coded sections, simplify, organize and centralize all data. Various Golf Courses, all nearby.
Provides lightning-fast retrieval of all maintenance ADs, service The Appleton Museum: A fine art museum
bulletins and inspection requirements for your aircraft. Includes of collection of the artwork from Arthur
AD search, text of applicable ADs, and 1 year AD revision service. Appleton reflecting over 5,000 years of
cultural history.
Keeps you on top of all required repetitive activity- annuals, 100
hour inspections, transponder/altimeter checks, VOR checks, etc. The Silver River Museum and
ORGANIZED FOR LOGICAL, STRAIGHTFORWARD UPKEEP. Environmental Education Center
Because adlog saves your maintenance facility valuable time, you World Famous Breeders Horse Farms
save valuable money. E-Mail: info@adlog.com Ocala Civic Theatre
Don Garlits Museum of Drag Racing
1-800-235-6444 FAX: 1-631-765-9359 Ocala National Forest
AEROTECH PUBLICATIONS, INC. P.O. Box 1359, Southold, NY Wild Waters Park
w w w . a d l o g. co m
SALE!!!
from a P-51 to a B-25 Mitchell Bomber,
to a Grumman F6F Hellcat.
In addition, you may wish to display
your Comanche. They are asking that
pilots planning to do so, taxi to the
base of the tower or to the adjacent
ramp area. Display coordinators are NEW G-35 Dry Charged Battery
there from 8:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m.
The first Saturday of the month is
Special Buy — $99
3 Quarts of Acid
Event Day at the museum, where
they have guest speakers and fly an
aircraft from the museum that
matches the theme for the month.
December’s theme is:
Only — $11
GUADALCANAL – featuring the
(battery lists for $331.14)
JAPANESE ZERO
Both the museum and Flo’s Airport We have just bought much of
Cafe are just a short walk from the
base of the tower. According to one of Surprise Valley’s Comanche inventory…
our members based at Chino, it is not
just an airport, it’s a “happening.” More inventory for your needs.
Planes of Fame Air Museum is an
independently operated, non-profit Webco is now repairing fuel valves
aviation museum dedicated to collecting,
restoring, displaying, and preserving under FAA—DER Approval
Webco Aircraft…
aircraft and memorabilia for the edu-
cational benefit of current and future
generations. They house their over
150 aircraft at two locations, the main
facility at Chino Airport in California
Still using the same methods
and a satellite museum near the Grand
Canyon at Valle Airport in Arizona.
that we have used for over 40 years.
General admission is $11, youngsters
who are 11 years old and under are
admitted for $4, and admission is free
for accompanied children under five.
If you’d like more information about
the museum, go to www.planesoffame.org.
For more information or questions
about the fly-in, please e-mail Sandy
Moore at msedith@aol.com.
European Tribe
Enjoys a Fly-out to
Bergen, Norway
by Harvey Crush, ICS #15835 the North Sea which, for those who evening, after a barbecue supper in
did not know, is a minefield of the old part of the city, we were left to
F
aces were serious in the brief- restricted areas reserved for air-to- explore on Friday. Most took our
ing room at Biggin Hill on the air refuelling, combat practice, and hosts’ advice and rode the funicular to
morning of Thursday 3 July as so on. Thus your scribe, who was the top of Mount Fløyen which over-
the group, led by the European Tribe driving as directed by the treasurer, looks Bergen; another fascinating
Chief and treasurer, considered the saw little of the sea, being pinned experience was the Hanseatic
weather. IFR flight plans had been down below 5,000 feet in the clag Museum, restored as a 17th century
filed for the comforting route across most of the way. We tend to think of Hansard merchant’s house where we
to the Netherlands and Germany, Scandinavia as being to the east but had a conducted tour and explanation
then up the Jutland peninsula to a heading of 022 degrees was taking of the way the League had operated.
Esbjerg in Denmark to refuel before us to a place where it was light 24 The highlight of the day was a con-
following more coastlines to our des- hours a day. Not only that, as soon as ducted tour of the city’s aquarium,
tination. Low pressure over the North we were near Norwegian airspace, we where we were served a fine dinner.
Sea and an occluded front on our found ourselves in hot sunshine The 100-year old steamer, Oster,
chosen route changed all that and which continued for three days. had been reserved for us two years in
the decision was to go direct in com- Sweltering in unaccustomed heat, advance and was our transport for all
pany straight across, leaving England we were glad of the generous hospital- of Saturday, taking us on inland seas
from the VOR at Ottringham in ity of the local ICS and Bergen Flying so sheltered that the ride was smooth-
Yorkshire. Flight plans were can- Club in plying us with refreshments er than a train, while we sat in sun
celled and we re-filed VFR. The route during the long wait for the bowser to and enjoyed a plentiful supply of
involved various changes in altitude fuel 15 aircraft before taking us in waffles and other refreshments all
to avoid controlled airspace as we their own cars to our hotel by the day long. Our first stop was Herdla,
headed north but particularly over World Heritage Site of Bryggen. That an island where the Nazis had an
Trading Post
4 headsets. 1 PC wndshld. 5 seats, White w/gold
COMANCHE’S WANTED: All models, runouts trim, 8/8 paint/interior. Montana. $119,000
OK, needing P&I/Radio upgrades OK, fast SVSTARR@AOL.COM (406) 652-2500. 1/2
Trading Post is a non-commercial, member to discriminate transaction on your ramp 20 years
member service provided free of charge, one experience/references. Call Jim, (760) 930-9300.
time per member, per year. The sale of aircraft avloc@yahoo.com 2/2
is not permitted in the Trading Post.
• Ads must be submitted in writing only
(fax or E-mail OK). Comanches For Sale
• Free ads may not be placed by phone.
• First 25 words are free. PA24-250
• Extra words are $0.40 per word.
1958 PA24/250. IFR, GPS, King Radios, shoulder
Fax: (231) 946-9588
E-mail: nancy@villagepress.com harnesses, digital fuel and temp, NDH. TTAF 5712. PA30
SMOH 1570 (2000 HR TBO). $39,000. (541)740-
7633 Email: rnorton@preappinc.com 2/2 1963 PA-30, TT 4300, RT 250 SMOH, LT 375
For Sale: Tail fairing 21786-03 (upper) like new SMOH by Lycoming. over $100,000. spent in
$100; left rear baffle 21596-09 (260 injected) like 1961 PA24-250, N7621P, TTAF 5500, 370 SMOH complete refurbishing including new R & J
new $75; voltage reg. 450-392 (Delco 9000590) w/new cylinders, 370 since new McCauley panel, S-Tec 50, Garmin 430, King HSI, WX-10a
NEW! $80; Delco starter, great shape $50; Nose 3-blade. Too many upgrades to list. Hangared, storm scope, IFR, Shadin fuel computer, new fuel
gear drag link cross brace 26807-00 NEW! $50; excellent condition. Contact John or Sharon pumps and many other mods and equipment.
OAT 99479-02 $30. Don (248) 625-6118. 2/2 (951)203-7333. 1/2 E-mail and will send a list with pictures. Asking
$99,500.00, OBO. Emil at e-mail comadco@aol.
For Sale: Two blade spinner assemblies, standard 1958 Comanche PA250 in excellent condition. com, phone (941) 360-9282. 2/2
$150, chrome $200, from 1959 250 Comanche. New engine with 150 hours, new 3 blade prop
Converted to three blade. Ted (217)355-3484, with 17 hours, tip tanks, natural wood instrument PA-30 TTAF 5550, LE/RE 96/755 SFRM, L/R 96
tedg@comcast.net 2/2 SPOH, new Giotto interior, good paint, always
panel, GPS, leather seats, hangared, and very
well maintained. Asking $65,000. Call Scott at hangared, King Silver Crown stack, same owner
Piper Kit 760 914 complete to eliminate AD since ‘85, medical issues. $74K Pilot@oxygenfire.
#77-08-01 aileron outboard hinge replacement (650) 996-0869 or email sbull1@prdus.jnj.com
for pictures. 1/2 com, (858) 722-2735 2/2
$250. Wanted STec single axis autopilot for
PA24-250. Contact Tom (775)250-8462 or 1966 PA30T,w/ tips, 3400tt, 200s Mattituck
t_hegge@op-dundas.com. 1/2 OH, new Knots2U props, new Garmin Pkg, 530
TCAS, new interior. Spent $220,000. In annual
now. Make reasonable offer. www.DubeAir.com
High Flight
1. Pilots must insure that all surly bonds have
been slipped entirely before aircraft taxi or
flight is attempted.
2. During periods of severe sky dancing, crew
Parody
and passengers must keep seatbelts fastened.
Crew should wear shoulder belts, as provided.
3. Sunward climbs must not exceed the maxi-
maxi
mum permitted aircraft ceiling.
with FAA
4. Passenger aircraft are prohibited from joining
the tumbling mirth.
5. Pilots flying through sun-split clouds under
Supplement
VFrr conditions must comply with all applica-
ble minimum clearances.
6. Do not perform these hundred things in front
of Federal Aviation Administration inspectors.
7. Wheeling, soaring, and swinging will not be
attempted except in aircraft rated for such
O
activities and within utility class weight limits.
h, I have slipped the surly bonds of earth(1), 8. Be advised that sunlit silence will occur only
And danced(2) the skies on laughter silvered wings; when a major engine malfunction has occurred.
Sunward I’ve climbed(3) and joined the tumbling mirth(4) 9. “Hov’ring there” will constitute a highly reliable
Of sun-split clouds(5) and done a hundred things(6). signal that a flight emergency is imminent.
Y
10. Forecasts of shouting winds are available from
ou have not dreamed of – wheeled and soared and swung(7), the local FSS. Encounters with unexpected
shouting winds should be reported by pilots.
High in the sunlit silence(8). Hov’ring there(9)
I’ve chased the shouting wind(10) along and flung(11) 11. Pilots flinging eager craft through footless
halls of air are reminded that they alone are
My eager craft through footless halls of air.
responsible for maintaining separation from
Our support
program for
“Your Comanche”
• Annual/100 hour
inspections
• Routine Maintenance
• Minor/Major Repairs
• Dynamic Propeller
3-blade High Performance Propeller
balancing
• The BEST engine Boost the
rebuilds for your dollar performance
• Engine removal and of your 250/260
replacement Comanche with
• comanche Modifications a modern good
• Weight and balance 2-blade High Performance Propeller looking propeller.