Comparative Study :

Alternative Malunggay as Cleaning Agent

Vs
Commercial Cleaning Agent

Submitted By:

Sophia Kate Arceo

Nathaniel Dionisio
James Harry Dumalaga
 Findings and Analysis of Data

Subject Color Smell Effectiveness

Zonrox Transparent It smells It is more

Cleaning bleach. effective.
Agent

Malunggay Dark Green It smells Still need to

Cleaning Herbs. improve.
Agent

Upon conducting the two Cleaning Agents, The researchers add an

additive which is baking soda because it is a mild alkali and can
cause dirt and grease to dissolve easily in water for effective
removal. Baking Soda is a pure, natural product that is also a food,
it is non-toxic, unlike many other household cleaners. To be able to
compare Zonrox and Malunggay as Cleaning Agent, The
researchers have compare their color, smell, and lastly their
effectivity.
In the data given above, The researchers can already see that
Zonrox is really effective than Malunggay as Cleaning Agent but the
researchers can also tell that it is harmful to our environment
because it contains chemical. Malunggay as Cleaning Agent still
needed improvement but the researchers can already tell that it is
eco-friendly because it doesn’t contain any chemicals harmful to our
environment also all of people can do this because materials is not
that hard to find. It is also affordable.

The researchers recommend that let the product dry for minimum
of five to ten minutes and maximum of 30 minutes for you to see the
better results of Malunggay as Cleaning Agent.

The researchers therefore conclude that Malunggay leaves with

baking soda can remove stains on common household stains, but
Malunggay as Cleaning Agent really needs improvement because it
can only remove mild stains not those stains who needs a
commercial cleaning agent that contains a chemical and also it is
only effective if you let it soaked for a long time.The researchers also
conclude that the Commercial one is still better than the product.
Experimentation
Before

After
 Activity Target Date Remarks
1.Submission of Problem Dec.10

2.Writing of Proposal Dec.11

3.Submission of Proposal Dec.13

4.Investigation Jan. 2-5

5.Submission of Jan.7-8
Findings and Analysis od
Data
6.Writing of Written Jan.10
reports
7.Submission of Written Jan.11
reports
8.Oral Defense Before
Foundation day
9. Submission of revise 2nd Week of
Written Reports February
10. Poster Presentation 3rd Week of
February
 Methodology

1. Prepare all the materials needed for the

experiment.
2. Get the Malunggay and get the leaves out of the
stem.
3. Put 5 cups of Malunggay Leaves to the Mortar.
4. After putting Malunggay Leaves to the mortar,
pound the Malunggay Leaves using Pestle to get the
extract of it.
5. Then after that, Mix the pounded Malunggay
Leaves with 2 ½ tsp of Baking soda and 5 tsp of
water.
6. After mixing, place the mixture on a container.
7. Using the sponge, apply the mixture on stained
areas.
8. After applying the mixtures on stained areas, wait
for 10 or more minutes and observe for the result.