Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dossier - The Future of Health Data
Dossier - The Future of Health Data
Dossier - The Future of Health Data
Health Data
Foresight Studio Dossier
1
2
The Future of
Health Data
Foresight Studio Dossier
Part 1
Signals and trends
page 5
Part 2
Scenarios
page 53
Part 3
Innovation Strategy: Fitbit
Excerpts from Strategy Development Final Documents
page 79
Part 4
Designed Future: Immersive Scenario
page 119
3
R S E
NU XA
ALE f He
ion o ngs
a lt hcare i
nt o the
g r a t
Inte t of T
hi Treatm
er n e
Int
ex tra
using
of incre
h y b ridity cking
wa y tra
the 3- ized health normality
polat
s o n Sma
pend onal ing es,
i s tre nd de rise of pers th the grow smart hom to h
i
+
Th the w nd on
ining bined ings a binati mig
overv
comb tment com ernet of Th . The com to the
ions
ea nt le d sig
and tr t objects, I r care peop s could lea ith
a r fo m w
of sm nd robots s and syste art homes, M
I a i e
i ew
A l o g o s m
and hno int
se tec thcare
of the ion of heal
at
integr tance.
is
AI ass
,6,7,8
1,2,3 g5 em
hcare rackin
l healt lth data t
Virtua h hea s”
9,10,11
le tec tioner
signa
earab cti
and w
T e d i cal “pra
I o ers/m
/A I caretak
i c
robot
ls
s,
e m o te area or
se in r port f
c a re to tho hysical sup
acces
s to e or p e home.
gnitiv h
Better quiring co l to leave t
r e i l ) for in
implic
thos e to o
i l i t y, those p i t a l , time
mob a
nity, c s.
t (o p portu taker need
r c o s c a re es.
Lowe ealth care/ diseas
ation home
h
conta
g i o u s
s p re ading
isk of
Less r
s
ct 1 Sig
· Proje
tudio
ores ight S
6021 -001 F
w· SFIN-
trieve
d
ie Sha
a c k Side.j
pg. Re -En-
lex a Jacqu
al, B 18/A
harco 92020 e.jpg
Plus, C 17/176060/0 ack%20Sid
.) . Echo L / 2 0 B
c. (n .d O
les/IR Charcoal, % com/
om In dia_fi .flickr.
4 Am azon.c -ir.net/me 20Plus,%2
0
ttp s ://www
es : te o% om h
Sourc orpora s/Ech ved fr h.
Image p://media.c cho%20Plu Retrie nsplas
tt E hoto]. ps://u
from h mazon%20 II nu rse s [P
e d fr om htt
/A a r iev
abled orld W 9762916/ g. Retr
10). W playin
Part 1
Signals and trends
6
Process
The first part of this foresight project began with scanning and captur-
ing signals of change related to the general topic of healthcare. To do
this, the students in the Foresight Studio course pulled articles, videos,
podcasts, and other forms of media that were indicative of changes that
may occur in the future. These signals were sorted using the STEEPV tool
(social, technological, economic, environmental, political, and values)
and each signal was classified based on the level of maturity (emerging,
growing, peaking, declining). Following this, a process was undertaken to
review these signals and recombine them into trends with information
about implications and extrapolations for each trend.
7
Signals
“Black Museum”
Black Mirror Episode 6 Series 4
Author: Charlie Brooker (Writer) poisoning Rolo, Nish transfers Rolo’s consciousness into
Clayton’s head, much like Carrie was transferred into
Source: Show available on Netflix
Jack’s head, forcing him to live through the last electro-
Published Date: December 29, 2017 cution which overloads Clayton’s synapses and wipes the
Abstract: digital copies of them both. Rolo’s agony is captured in
a souvenir keychain which Nish takes along with the doll
Nish stops to recharge her car and enters the nearby with Carrie’s consciousness and shorts out the museum’s
“Black Museum”, owned and run by Rolo Haynes. Rolo electricity, starting a fire. Nish drives off with her moth-
shows her various artifacts, all related to illicit technolo- er, her consciousness living within Nish, tells her Clayton
gy that he had been involved with. He describes several would be proud of her. (Wikipedia)
stories connected to them. One involves Dr. Peter Daw-
son, a doctor who developed a device that allowed him Keywords/Tags: Biotech, pain management, medical
to experience the pain of his patients to aid in diagnosis, ethics
but soon found pain giving way to addictive pleasure, Implications:
and eventually killed a man to experience the sensation.
• Psychological considerations on practitioners sharing
Another case involves Carrie, a comatose woman whose
pain with patients
consciousness was transferred into her husband Jack, but
when Jack started seeing another woman, he forcefully • personalized health care and diagnostics
transferred Carrie into a plush monkey for their son Park-
• Believing the pain of patients
er who soon discarded the toy as he grew up; Carrie still
is alive within the plush at the museum. Rolo shows Nish Maturity: Emerging, Growing, Mature, Declining
the star attraction of the museum, a holographic repre- Future impact (on the lives of audience):
sentation of the consciousness of convicted murderer high, medium, low
Clayton Leigh that Rolo bought just prior to his electro-
cution, allowing visitors to electrocute him repeatedly. Impact time: 5y, 10y, 20y
Nish reveals that her visit was not incidental, as she is the Certainty (of assessment of future impact):
daughter of Clayton, who was wrongfully convicted. After high, medium, low
8
Care Work:
Dreaming Disability Justice
Author: Kyla A.McKay, Kaarina Kowalec, Fiona Brinkman, B. Keywords/Tags: Microbiome, Immunology:
Brett Finlay, Marc Horwitz, Amee R. Manges, Lisa Osborne, Multiple sclerosis
Helen Tremlett
Implications:
Source: Multiple Sclerosis and Related Disorders
• Growth of understanding of holistic brain health ap-
Volume 12
proaches
URL/Attachment: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
Maturity: Emerging, Growing, Mature, Declining
msard.2016.12.007
Future impact (on the lives of audience):
Published Date: Feb 2017
high, medium, low
Abstract:
Impact time: 5y, 10y, 20y
Knowledge surrounding the trillions of microbes that in-
Certainty (of assessment of future impact):
habit the human gut has bloomed exponentially in recent
high, medium, low
years, and the emerging concept of a gut-brain axis rep-
resents a major shift in how we think about neurological
health.
A recent workshop at the University of British Columbia,
Canada brought together multi-disciplinary leaders in the
field of microbiomics and brain health and aimed to serve
as a springboard for future combined endeavors in these
areas.
This article provides the motivation for, and overview
of, the workshop, and the next steps in establishing
a cross-disciplinary initiative on Brain Health and
the Microbiome.
9
Is salad a luxury food? One writer argues it’s
time to rethink leafy greens
Author: CBC Radio - The Current Keywords/Tags: Food systems, food distribution, E. Coli,
Farming
URL/Attachment: https://www.cbc.ca/radio/thecurrent/
the-current-for-november-22-2018-1.4915910/is-salad- Implications:
a-luxury-food-one-writer-argues-it-s-time-to-rethink-
• “having all these conversations about how we’re going to
leafy-greens-1.4916002Published Date: Jan 19th 2019
feed a growing population responsibly”
Abstract:
• Examine food distribution costs vs. nutritional value
Lettuce is not particularly nutritious for the cost
Maturity: Emerging, Growing, Mature, Declining
of growing
Future impact (on the lives of audience):
“resource intensive and maybe a luxury food”
high, medium, low
E. coli outbreak in 2018 affected over 50 people
Impact time: 5y, 10y, 20y
in the US and Canada
Certainty (of assessment of future impact):
E. Coli linked to water from resevoir. water came from
high, medium, low
a canal, irrigation canal, that flowed near a feed lot that
had a 100,000 cattle on it.
Molecular You
Woebot
Author: Alison Darcy, PhD (and woebot team) Keywords/Tags: Mental health; chatbots; depression;
anxiety; Cognitive behavioural therapy
URL/Attachment: https://woebot.io/about
Implications:
Abstract:
• Accessible mental health care using clinically proven
Mental Health Chat bot
approaches
Users can talk to woebot 24/7 in 130 countries for free
Maturity: Emerging, Growing, Mature, Declining
Woebot uses Cognitive Behavioural Therapy to assist with
Future impact (on the lives of audience):
mental health challenges
high, medium, low
CBT is a talk therapy that is highly structured and prac-
Impact time: 5y, 10y, 20y
tical. Considered to be the most rigorously studied and
most effective treatment for mental health problems Certainty (of assessment of future impact):
high, medium, low
Does not replace the need for human intervention
10
The Multibiome: The Intestinal Ecosystem’s
Influence on Immune Homeostasis, Health, and Disease
Author: Heather A Filyk, Lisa C Osborne Keywords/Tags: Microbiome; Autoimmune disease; In-
flammatory bowel disease; immunotherapy
Source: The Lancet Volume 13
Implications:
URL/Attachment: https://www.sciencedirect.com/sci-
ence/article/pii/S2352396416304625 • Holistic view of immunity and intestinal multibiome
Published Date: November 2016 • Lead to more understanding of holistic/personalized
healthcare
Abstract:
• “ advance our understanding of multibiome-host interac-
new insights into multibiome-host interactions in the
tions and the development of effective treatment strate-
context of host-protective immunity
gies for multiple human diseases”
Mammals evolved alongside a complex and biodiverse
Maturity: Emerging, Growing, Mature, Declining
multibiome.
Future impact (on the lives of audience):
The intestinal multibiome is composed of bacteria, virus-
high, medium, low
es, fungi, and eukaryotes.
Impact time: 5y, 10y, 20y
Cross-talk between the multibiome and the host regu-
lates immunity and inflammation. Certainty (of assessment of future impact):
high, medium, low
11
3-D printed food could change how we eat
13
The Griefbot That Could Change How We Mourn
14
Our Cities are Designed for Loneliness
Author: Ankita Rao these areas, qualities such as social interactions, life
purpose, and lifestyle factors are critical to their
Source: Vice
emotional and physical health
Published Date: December 11, 2018
Keywords/Tags: community, mental health, built envi-
Abstract: ronment, loneliness, social isolation, intergenerational
Social isolation is a public health problem - it makes peo- housing, community gardens
ple more susceptible to disease, decreases life expec- Implications:
tancy, and increases the chances of being diagnosed with
As we face an increasing population of older adults, the
mental health conditions such as depression
Government of Ontario has put forth a recommendation
Loneliness or social isolation is pervasive as well and encouraging seniors to age in place (i.e. at home instead
young adults between 18-22 have been found to be the of institutional living such as long-term care homes). But
loneliest of all as society becomes more lonely, there are potential
This reality is a symptom of the built environment we all negative implications on seniors’ health and well-being if
live in. There is a scarcity of public space where people they are not able to socialize and interact with others
can bump into each other and catch up as well as the There are also mental health and wellbeing implications
continuation of urban sprawl which encourages living in for an entire generation of people who are more vir-
isolated communities in suburbia. tually connected than ever but are increasingly finding
Community gardens are increasing in popularity as a way themselves more lonely. This could place a burden on
to bring people together and inject nature into our daily an already strained mental health care system as well as
routine at the same time have more wide-ranging economic costs due to missed
time at work, etc.
Intergenerational housing is also being examined as a
solution to curb loneliness in both young people as well Maturity: Emerging
as older adults Future impact (on the lives of audience): Medium
Research looks to so-called “Blue Zones” which are the Impact time: 5-10y
places in the world where people live the longest lives. In
Certainty (of assessment of future impact): medium
Author: Shayla Love young. There is not a good enough answer to what is
being done to help this population when they realize they
Source: Vice
need professional assistance
Published Date: December 12, 2018
Self-care can only go so far. The mental health care
Abstract: system needs to be adapted so that it meets the needs of
Self-care is becoming increasingly popular and includes those with mental health problems.
many behaviours including eating well, getting enough Keywords/Tags: self-care, mental health, mental health
sleep, meditating, yoga/exercise, and more treatment
Self-care itself is not the problem since these behaviours Implications:
are conducive to a healthy lifestyle. Rather it is the com-
• Self-care is a trend that will continue to grow but what
modification of these behaviours and the fact that entire
may be even more long-lasting is the idea that individu-
industries are selling this idea of self-care which is the
als are responsible for treating their own mental health
problem
conditions. How will this impact mental health care and
Underneath all of that, there is the reality that mental treatment in hospitals, doctors offices, and therapist
health problems are increasing with anxiety and depres- offices?
sion being the most prevalent mental health conditions
• Because many these self-care products are marketed
worldwide. In the US, this increase has not been met with
as being luxury items, the associated cost is high. What
the appropriate increase in psychologists and psychia-
happens to those who this self-care movement excludes
trists and instead, their numbers are dwindling
most notably, those with less disposable income? Will
The self-care phenomenon is seen as a canary in the coal mental health care become more exclusively for those
mine of mental health coverage. Instead of giving people that are most well-off?
the help they need - through therapy and treatment -
Maturity: Mature
the health care system is choosing not to intervene and
Future impact (on the lives of audience): High
instead feeding into the self-care trend and “outsourcing
public health care” Impact time: >5y
Alongside this explosion in self-care, there is a large, Certainty (of assessment of future impact): high
help-seeking, undiagnosed population that is largely 15
87 days of smog: Southern California just saw its
longest streak of bad air in decades
Author: Tony Barboza lems”, even at levels that are lower than the regulatory
limits
Source: LA Times
Health impacts of high ozone levels include asthma at-
Published Date: September 21, 2018
tacks, missed school days, emergency room visits, prema-
Abstract: ture deaths
LA region violated federal smog standards for 87 consec- Keywords/Tags: air quality, healthy air, smog, asthma,
utive days lung diseases
Exceeded federal health standard of 70 parts per billion Implications:
from June 19 - Sept 14, 2018
• Growth in health conditions related to poor air quality
“The bad air spell follows an increase in smog over the last
Maturity: Mature
few years that has bucked a long-term trend of improving
air quality…” Future impact (on the lives of audience): High
There is more and more research “linking ozone and other Impact time: Current
regional air pollutants to a wider array of health prob-
Certainty (of assessment of future impact): medium
16
Let’s make 2019 the year Canada finally
gets pharmacare
Author: Globe Editorial The real challenge will be with disrupting the status quo. It
is not a matter of whether people want drug coverage or
Source: Social Policy in Ontario
not. Rather, the question is if citizens are willing to adopt
Published Date: January 11, 2019 a new system
Abstract: Keywords/Tags: Pharmacare, pharmaceuticals, universal
Pharmacare is going to be coming to Canada soon, most health care, Canadian health care system, coverage
likely sometime before the next election Implications:
Most Canadians have some sort of drug coverage through Changes to provincially provided health insurance cover-
workplace insurance but that is tied to keeping their jobs age as well as private drug insurance
and can sometimes come with expense co-pays and
Maturity: Mature
annual limits
Future impact (on the lives of audience): Medium
One of the biggest opportunities pharmacare offers Can-
ada is a huge savings in the money the country spends on Impact time: 2-5y
medication. Canada’s per capita spending on drugs was
Certainty (of assessment of future impact): high
43 percent above the OECD average in 2011
17
Indoor air quality: The hidden threats
Author: Panasonic Malaysia a complete and holistic indoor air quality solution that in-
cludes air intake, filtration, cooling, circulation, ionisation,
Source: Edge Prop
exchange and exhaust is the way forward
Published Date: January 18, 2019
Keywords/Tags: indoor air, pollution, clean air, plant
Abstract:
Implications:
The average person breathes in 18kg of air daily
increase of the number of deaths associated with indoor
People notice the poor air quality when outdoors air quality
Six million deaths were associated with outdoor and in- Restrictions of materials and components of household
door air pollution (World Health Organization 2016 report) products and items
It is estimated that we spend about 90% of our time Maturity: Growing
indoors
Future impact (on the lives of audience): High
Sources of indoor air pollutants are various and insidious
Impact time: Current
- from chemicals in wood products and furniture, house-
hold chemicals, mildew, mould and bacteria Certainty (of assessment of future impact): high
18
A breathalyser test could revolutionise
cancer diagnosis
19
BELIEVING
PATIENTS
The rise of several different health care trends
leading to better healthcare advocacy and access.
overview
could exist, further diversification of those in the
medical and research field and the lessening of stig-
matization of illness could lead to a more inclusive
system of healthcare. Currently, studies show that
healthcare continues to perpetuate racialized, sex/
gendered, and sexuality based myths resulting in a
lower quality of healthcare for racialized persons,
women, and members of the LGBTQ+ community.
Disability/Feminist/Queer/Indigenous/Race
signals
advocacy and diversity in healthcare. 1,2,3,4
implications
of their ailments and personal healthcare needs,
through data tracking are given better tools and
information for self-advocacy.
Image Sources: Eletu, A. (n.d.). Man looking at marketing analytics [Digital Photograph]. Reduction of risk of misdiagnosis, no diagnosis,
Retrieved from https://unsplash.com/photos/unRkg2jH1j0 and human/practitioner error.
Unknown. (3rd Century BC). Terracotta nude female statuette, perhaps Aphrodite.
Retrieved from https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/248606
FitBit. (n.d.). Fitbit Ionic Charcoal Fitbit Developer Clock Face Apps Drink Counter.
Retrieved from https://s2.q4cdn.com/857130097/files/doc_downloads/ionic/large/Fit-
bit_Ionic__Charcoal_Fitbit_Developer_Clock_Face_Apps_Drink_Counter.png Jacquie Shaw · SFIN-6021-001 Foresight Studio · Project 1 Signals
20
21
1) Adler, K. W. (2017, April 25). Women Are Dying Because Doctors Treat Us Like Men. Retrieved 7) Preventive Health Assessments | Molecular You. (n.d.). Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https://
January 31, 2019, from https://www.marieclaire.com/health-fitness/a26741/doctors-treat-women- molecularyou.com/
like-men/
8) McCarthy, C. (2018). Black Museum. Black Mirror. Endemol UK.
2) Billock, J. (2018, May 22). Pain bias: The health inequality rarely discussed. Retrieved February
1, 2019, from http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20180518-the-inequality-in-how-women-are-treat- 9) Keshavan, M. (2015, June 11). Measuring pain: Device objectively tells you how much it
ed-for-pain hurts. Retrieved January 31, 2019, from https://medcitynews.com/2015/06/objectively-measur-
ing-pain-device/
3) Kiesel, L. (2017, October 9). Women and pain: Disparities in experience and treatment.
Retrieved January 31, 2019, from https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/women-and-pain-dispari- 10) Limón, J. L. M., Collazo, J. S., & Staff, B. (2017, November 8). The Teen Who Developed a
ties-in-experience-and-treatment-2017100912562 Breast Cancer-Detecting Bra. Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/
article/evbpan/breast-cancer-detecting-bra-eva
4) Study: Oncologists Want More Education About LGBTQ Issues. (2019, January 22). Retrieved
February 1, 2019, from https://www.cancer.org/latest-news/study-oncologists-want-more-educa- 11) Mandavilli, A. (2019, January 23). Your Sweat Will See You Now. The New York Times. Re-
tion-about-lgbtq-issues.html trieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/18/health/wearable-tech-sweat.html
5) Biohackers Are Implanting Everything From Magnets to Sex Toys. (2018, October 19). Retrieved 12) The Canadian Press. (2018, October 10). Burnout, depression and even suicidal thoughts
from https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-10-19/biohackers-are-implanting-every- reported in survey of Canadian doctors. CBC. Retrieved from https://www.cbc.ca/news/health/
thing-from-magnets-to-sex-toys canadian-doctors-burnout-depression-1.4856875
6) Cullis, P. (2015). The Personalized Medicine Revolution: How Diagnosing and Treating Disease 13) The Supply of Physicians in Canada: Projections and Assessment. (2018, January 18). Retrieved
Are About to Change Forever. Vancouver: Greystone Books. February 1, 2019, from http://bit.ly/2FPFGeH
(non-intersectional research).
growing
extrapolations counter trends
NURSE
ALEXA
+ Integration of Healthcare into the
Internet of Things
overview
combining the rise of personalized health tracking
and treatment combined with the growing normality
of smart objects, Internet of Things and smart homes,
and AI and robots for care people. The combination
of these technologies and systems could lead to the
integration of healthcare into smart homes, with
AI assistance.
signals
IoT and wearable tech health data tracking 5,6,7,8
Image Sources: Amazon.com Inc. (n.d.). Echo Plus, Charcoal, Back Side.jpg. Retrieved
from http://media.corporate-ir.net/media_files/IROL/17/176060/09202018/Alexa-En-
abled/Amazon%20Echo%20Plus/Echo%20Plus,%20Charcoal,%20Back%20Side.jpg
team, O. (2010). World War II nurses [Photo]. Retrieved from https://www.flickr.com/
photos/timefornurses/5129762916/
V., F. (2018). Keyboard, robot, instrument and playing. Retrieved from https://unsplash.
com/photos/U3sOwViXhkY Jacquie Shaw · SFIN-6021-001 Foresight Studio · Project 1 Signals
22
counter trends extrapolations
emerging
Maturity: 10 – 20 years
increase my IV dosage”
23
GENDER VARIAN
POST-GENDER C
Wider understanding and acceptance of transgend
diversification of healthcare for trans/non-cis pers
overview
of non-cisgender (including trans, intersex, non-
binary) identities and bodies could lead to better
understanding of trans and intersex bodies. This
understanding could lead to less medical barriers
— personal, mental, and systemic — to care for
non-cisgender bodies, earlier recognition of
non-cisgender identities. With further acceptance
and knowledge of non-cisgender identities more
specific healthcare needs can be researched
and addressed.
signals
persons from celebrities to politicians.1,2
implications
individuals and communities. 6
Image Sources: Allen & Ginter. (1889). Plate 9, from the Fans of the Period series (N7) for
Allen & Ginter Cigarettes Brand [Commercial Color Lithograph]. Retrieved from https://
www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/406989
Fortuny, M. (1869). Victory: a naked youth standing facing left holding a statue of winged
Victory in his right hand. Retrieved from https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/
search/656644
Lee, K. (2018). Flag, gay parade, gay flag and rainbow. Retrieved from https://unsplash.
com/photos/bdAcC3_OTTA
Library, B. (2013). Image taken from page 163 of “A magyar nemzet története. I. kötet
írta Bodon J. és Dr. Szalay J. (II.-IV.) kötet, írta Dr. Szalay J.) [With portraits.]” [Photo].
Retrieved from https://www.flickr.com/photos/britishlibrary/11272653806/
Unknown. (1500). Figurine [Ceramic Sculpture]. Retrieved from https://www.metmuseum.
org/art/collection/search/324302 Jacquie Shaw · SFIN-6021-001 Foresight Studio · Project 1 Signals
24
counter trends extrapolations
emerging
der identities,
sons & bodies
CARE
through culture.
NCE &
Maturity: 10 – 20 years
1) Blitz, E. (2019, January 16). Bangladesh Parliament to have first transgender MP. Retrieved Feb- 7)For nonbinary patients, seeking health care can be a painful task. (n.d.). Retrieved February 1,
ruary 1, 2019, from https://www.weeklyblitz.net/news/bangladesh-parliament-to-have-first-trans- 2019, from https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/nonbinary-patients-seeking-health-care-
gender-mp/ can-be-painful-task-n941341
2) Transgender Hollywood – Variety. (n.d.). Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https://variety.com/t/ 8)Miller, S. (2018, November 29). California becomes first state to condemn intersex surgeries
transgender-hollywood/ on children. Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/na-
tion/2018/08/28/intersex-surgeries-children-california-first-state-condemn/1126185002/
3)Murphy, J. (2018, December 21). One country’s push to ban “gay cures.” Retrieved from https://
www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-46562130 9)News, & Canada. (2019, January 18). Who gets to decide when a 14-year-old wants to change
gender? The child, the hospital, the battling parents? | National Post. Retrieved February 1, 2019,
4)BC Government News. (2018, November 2). ‘X’ gender identity now recognized on government from https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/who-gets-to-decide-when-a-14-year-old-wants-to-
ID. Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https://news.gov.bc.ca/releases/2018HLTH0079-002116 change-gender
5) Sonde, K. (2018, June 22). These states are driving the charge toward gender-inclusive licenses.
Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2018/06/these-states-
are-driving-the-charge-toward-gender-inclusive-licenses/
6)Avery, A. M., Hellman, R. E., & Sudderth, L. K. (2001). Satisfaction with mental health services
among sexual minorities with major mental illness. American Journal of Public Health, 91(6),
990–991.
25
PERSONALIZED
PREVENTION
Following the holistic model focus on healthcare, t
preventive/maintenance for the general populatio
focus in healthcare.
so
re
cial
a
f-c Non-pharmaceutical preventative care begins to
overview
int
l
se take precedence in day-to-day health care. With
er
ac
signals
Changing diets and food production 4,5,6
Image Sources: Alpha Stock Images. (2015). Apple. Retrieved from http://www.picserver.
org/a/apple.html
Internet Archive Book Images. (1891). Image from page 140 of “Medical symbolism in con-
nection with historical studies in the arts of healing and hygiene” (1891) [Photo]. Retrieved
from https://www.flickr.com/photos/internetarchivebookimages/14576988048/
Monroy, V. (n.d.). Opioid-therapy.ashx [Digital Photograph]. Retrieved from https://www.
health.mil/-/media/Images/MHS/Photos/Opioid-therapy.ashx
pngimg.com. (n.d.). DNA PNG. Retrieved from http://pngimg.com/download/48593
Rawpixel. (n.d.). Infographic, graphic, mobile and graph. Retrieved from https://unsplash.
com/photos/EspXDd5Gu-c Jacquie Shaw · SFIN-6021-001 Foresight Studio · Project 1 Signals
26
counter trends extrapolations
emerging
on becomes a
tech enabled
Maturity: 5 – 20 years
1) Cullis, P. (2015). The Personalized Medicine Revolution: How Diagnosing and Treating Disease 7) Gillies, T. (2018, April 22). Why health care costs are making consumers more afraid of medical
Are About to Change Forever. Vancouver: Greystone Books. bills than an actual illness. Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/22/
why-health-care-costs-are-making-consumers-more-afraid-of-medical-bills-than-an-actual-ill-
2) Preventive Health Assessments | Molecular You. (n.d.). Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https:// ness.html
molecularyou.com/
8) Malito, A. (n.d.). Rising health-care costs are eating away at your wages and you may not even
3) Smith, F. (2019, January). How personalized medicine is transforming your health care. realize it. Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-hidden-ways-
Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2019/01/person- rising-health-care-costs-affect-you-2018-10-10
alized-medicine-transforming-your-health-care/
9) Love, S. (2018, December 12). The Dark Truths Behind Our Obsession With Self-Care. Retrieved
4) Are Pills and Powders the Future of Food? (2017, August 10). Retrieved February 1, 2019, from February 1, 2019, from https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/zmdwm4/the-young-and-the-uncared-
https://www.thefoodrush.com/articles/are-pills-and-powders-the-future-of-food/ for-v25n4
5)’Planetary health diet could help save lives and the planet - CNN. (n.d.). Retrieved February 1, 10)Clarke, P. N., & Bleich, M. R. (2018). Holistic Leadership—Nursing’s Unique Contribution to
2019, from https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/16/health/new-diet-to-save-lives-and-planet-health- Healthcare. Nursing Science Quarterly, 31(2), 134–138. https://doi.org/10.1177/0894318418755744
study-intl/index.html
6)Plant-based proteins as a future nutrition and opportunities for food startups. (2017, October
25). Retrieved February 1, 2019, from https://www.foodinnovationthinktank.com/2017/10/25/plant-
based-proteins-as-a-future-nutrition-and-opportunities-for-food-startups/
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
Planetary Health
Implications & Extrapolations
The connections between As the health impacts of climate change increase, there may
be a cultural and societal value shift towards taking better
health concerns and care of the natural environment. As stronger environmental
policy could follow this shift, there may be a responsibility of
environmental health are all industries to follow the principle of the triple bottom line:
people, profit, and planet. This could result in a new definition
becoming more prominent. of wealth and the destruction of current consumption habits.
In the healthcare industry, doctors will also be treating more
health issues that stem from the impacts of climate change. As
science shows that humanity can prevent some of the impacts
on climate change to some degree, healthcare practitioners
may take on a of advocacy focused role against climate
Description change in order to prevent many of these looming diseases
As the impacts of climate change and humanity’s negative and conditions. This may result in the healthcare industry
impact on the planet become more severe, these impacts taking a role as doctors for our planet and our environment,
are beginning to have increasingly detrimental effects on our as well as for human conditions, as the two will become more
health. Doctors are raising awareness about climate change intertwined with the rise of climate change.
and environmental health in relation to how it impacts human
health and well-being. The health impacts of climate change
will be felt first and hardest by individuals who lack the ability References
to access proper sanitation and medical treatment, and those 1. Christensen, J. (2019, January 16). 250,000 deaths a year from climate
that lack the resources to relocate to avoid climate impacts. change is a ‘conservative estimate,’ research says. CNN. Retrieved from
https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/16/health/climate-change-health-emergency-
study/index.html.
2. Odriozola, V. (2015, April 17). Nine Healthcare Institutions Pledge to Reduce
Signals Carbon Footprint. Philanthropy News Digest. Retrieved from https://
philanthropynewsdigest.org/news/nine-healthcare-institutions-pledge-to-
• Scientists suggest that 250,000 deaths per year due to reduce-carbon-footprint.
climate change is a conservative estimate and that climate 3. Azad, A. (2018, October 12). How climate change will affect your health.
change could pose a threat to the gains made in human CNN. Retrieved from https://www.cnn.com/2018/10/12/health/climate-
longetivity.1 change-health-effects/index.html.
4. Barboza, T. (2018, September 21). 87 days of smog: Southern California
• In the lead up to the 2015 UN Conference on Climate just saw its longest streak of bad air in decades. LA Times. Retrieved from
Change, nine healthcare institutions around the world https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-smog-streak-20180921-story.
pledged to reduce their carbon footprint, noting the html.
5. Carrington, D. (2019, January 11). Air pollution ‘as bad as smoking in
impacts of climate change on public health.2 increasing risk of miscarriage’. The Guardian. Retrieved from https://www.
• Research shows that climate change could cause in theguardian.com/environment/2019/jan/11/air-pollution-as-bad-as-smoking-
increase in disease, including bacterial infections, mental in-increasing-risk-of-miscarriage
health concerns, and respiratory problems.3
6. Trend provided by Kathryn Cramer.
• Scientists suggest doing more to fight poor air quality and 7. Trend provided by Asia Clarke.
ozone levels as more evidence shows it can lead to asthma 8. Trend provided by Karli Ferriolo.
attacks, premature deaths, and miscarriages.4, 5
Photo by Alex Gindin on Unsplash.
36
S T E E P V
Maturity: Growing
Related Trends
• “Climate Change and Mortality”: Climate
-
change will increase the mortality rate and
reduce longevity in vulnerable populations.6
Riley McCullough
37
Increasing Equity
Implications & Extrapolations
There is an increase in medical This may lead to an increase in health service providers
representation of groups that that have more specialized service offerings, based on
demographics. This trend is driven by changes in society
have been historically under- related to acceptance and tolerance, and could play out in the
science role in a meaningful way in the near future as more
represented or marginalized. research will clearly demonstrate the importance and success
of specialized care.
Signals References
• Bangladesh will have a transgender Member of Parliament 1. Weekly Blitz News Team. (2019, January 16). Bangladesh Parliament to have
first transgender MP. Weekly Blitz. Retrieved from https://www.weeklyblitz.
for the first time in the country’s history, providing the trans net/news/bangladesh-parliament-to-have-first-transgender-mp/.
community with a voice in a country where many of the 2. Ventura, J. & Rueter, A. (2018, May 20). Indigenous health care workers
laws are still hostile towards the LGBTQ community.1 use language to build trust and break down barriers. CBC. Retrieved from
• In British Columbia, Canada, indigenous healthcare workers https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/indigenous-language-health-care-
workers-1.4660009.
are using the language and culture of their patients to build 3. Das, R. (2018, April 12). Women’s Healthcare Comes Out Of The Shadows:
trust and provide better healthcare.2 Femtech Shows The Way To Billion-Dollar Opportunities. Forbes. Retrieved
• There is a rise in women’s health clinics and a growing from https://www.forbes.com/sites/reenitadas/2018/04/12/womens-
healthcare-comes-out-of-the-shadows-femtech-shows-the-way-to-billion-
industry in femtech to invest more in solving women’s dollar-opportunities/#46a09fe66159.
health needs beyond pregnancy and gynecology.3 4. Xu, G. (2016, December 18). Marginalization in health care. UBC Medical
• There is an increased awareness of the struggles of Journal. Retrieved from https://ubcmj.med.ubc.ca/marginalization-in-
marginalized communities in the healthcare sector, with health/.
Canada Health noting that these communities often 5. Trend provided by Harmon Kaur.
“receive treatment that does not adequately meet their 6. Trend provided by Jacquie Shaw.
needs, or [are] less satisfied with healthcare services than 7. Trend provided by Samantha Matters.
the general population”.4 Photo by Hush Naidoo on Unsplash.
38
S T E E P V
Maturity: Emerging
Related Trends
• “Cancer Care for LGBTQ”: Cancer care in the
LGBTQ community is largely ignored and
LGBTQ patients report higher dissatisfaction
with cancer care treatment.5
Riley McCullough
39
Burnout Generation
Implications & Extrapolations
A bigger emphasis on work If continued, this could lead to an overall decrease in
and personal excellence has productivity as individuals experience more burnout, an
increase in the suicide rate, and a decrease in population
led to increased burnouts growth as individuals choose to forgo having children in order
to focus on their careers.
and mental health problems.
On the other end of the spectrum, it could also lead to an
increased acceptance of a work and personal life balance on
a cultural and societal level. It could create a better sense of
mindfulness and destroy the current wok standard of a 9-5 job
It may also change society’s perception of success and value.
Description This societal shift could be reinforced by broad policy changes
Milennials have higher expectations of themselves and have that help nudge individuals to have a better mental health
increased pressure placed on them. As a result, they are balance with their professional lives. This could be a restriction
working longer hours and to an increasingly unhealthy state in working hours allowed, a shortening of the work week, or
more often as they feel the need to take everything on. This even arguments in favour of universal basic income.
has lead to an increase in burnouts, depression, anxiety and
other mental health complications. A main driver of this is
the current tumultuous climate, an uncertain future, and the
inability to afford basic costs with one job. References
1. Petersen, A.H. (2019, January 5). How millennials became the burnout
Signals generation. BuzzFeed News. Retrieved from https://www.buzzfeednews.
com/article/annehelenpetersen/millennials-burnout-generation-debt-work.
• Recent financial crises have led to lasting financial 2. The Canadian Press. (2018, October 10). Burnout, depression and even
insecurity and a competitive economy that has led to a suicidal thoughts reported in survey of Canadian doctors. CBC. Retrieved
from https://www.cbc.ca/news/health/canadian-doctors-burnout-
culture of overworking and burnouts.1 depression-1.4856875.
• The concept of burnout is being seen in the medical 3. Morris, D. (2017, January 1). New French law bars work email after hours.
field, with at least 25% of doctors reporting symptoms of Fortune. Retrieved from ttp://fortune.com/2017/01/01/french-right-to-
disconnect-law/.
burnout, depression or suicidal thoughts in a survey.2 4. Folk, J. & Folk, M. (2019, January 1). Why Is Mental Illness On The Rise?
• A law in France requires employers to identify times in AnxietyCentre.com. Retrieved from https://www.anxietycentre.com/FAQ/
which their employees are not responsible for responding why-is-mental-illness-on-the-rise.shtml.
to work-related emails or calls in an attempt to decrease
5. Trend provided by Angie Fleming.
burnout and ensure employees are fairly paid for their 6. Trend provided by Liin Nur.
work.3 7. Trend provided by Liin Nur.
• Research shows that increase in societal pressures and 8. Trend provided by Karli Ferriolo.
norms, including increased performance pressure, have
Photo by JESHOOTS.COM on Unsplash.
taken a heavier toll on our psychological and emotional
health.4
40
S T E E P V
b.
Maturity: Peaking
Related Trends
• “Optimal Burnout”: A high effort to live a
health life is causing burnout, stress and
anxiety.5
Riley McCullough
41
(Once) Illegal Drugs
Implications & Extrapolations
Drugs that were once With the legalization of cannabis in Canada, and in turn the
classified as illegal are reduction of stigma surrounding a once illegal drug, there may
be a societal or cultural shift that takes a more accepting view
becoming more popular for of certain drugs, particularly psychedelics and similar drugs or
substances that have promising health benefits.
medical treatment.
A more positive cultural viewpoint and increasing scientific
research on the benefits of certain drugs will feed into each
other, prompting more research and wider acceptance among
the population, potentially eventually leading to policy
changes allowing certain drugs and substances for medicinal
Description purposes, or full legalization. The research of these drugs and
There is increased discussion around the legalization of certain their policy approvals could lead to new treatments of diseases
drugs and substances that show promising effects when and disorders, and new markets and business opportunities.
used for medicinal purposes. In the case of cannabis, it was It could destroy society’s current understanding of and
legalized for medicinal use only first, before being brought relationship with drugs like psilocybin.
onto the legal market for recreational use. As banned drugs
and substances are becoming more common in medical
communities, much of the stigma surrounding them is also
reduced, sometimes leading to full legalization. References
1. Rense, S. (2019, January 9). How Psilocybin—A.K.A. Shrooms—Could
Become the Next Legalized Drug. Esquire. Retrieved from https://www.
Signals esquire.com/lifestyle/health/a25794550/psilocybin-mushrooms-legalization
medical-use/?utm_medium=social-media&src=socialflowTW&utm_
• In several states in the U.S., there is a push for the source=twitter&utm_campaign=socialflowTWESQ.
legalization of psilocybin (the active substance found in 2. Burns, J. (2018, September 17). Coca-Cola Is Considering CBD For Infused
“shrooms”) as research shows possible applications for the Beverage Line. Forbes. Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/
janetwburns/2018/09/17/coca-cola-is-considering-cbd-for-its-infused-
treatment of depression.1 beverages/#4ffb6f851aab.
• Coca Cola is considering the development of a CBD infused 3. Dyck, E. (2018, August 17). Psychedelic drugs are making a medical
drink. CBD is the non-psychoactive cannabinoid chemical comeback over 50 years after the heyday of research on them — here’s wha
that often helps its users find relief from anxiety and changed. Business Insider. Retreived from https://www.businessinsider.com/
psychedelic-drugs-making-comeback-medical-science-research-2018-8.
depression.2 4. Flaccus, G. (2018, December 2018). Legal marijuana had an exceptional
• There is a rise in research on the medical effects of year in 2018 - and not just in Canada. Global News. Retrieved from https://
psychedelic drugs such as LSD, mushrooms, and peyote globalnews.ca/news/4795826/marijuana-legalization-2018-canada-world/.
cactus.3
5. Trend provided by Samantha Matters.
• After being legal for medicinal purposes in some places 6. Trend provided by Lisa Taylor.
for several years, cannabis is now being legalized for 7. Trend provided by Angie Fleming.
recreational use across the world at a growing rate.4
Photo by Thought Catalog on Unsplash.
42
S T E E P V
Maturity: Emerging
Related Trends
• “The Non-Drug (Counter)Revolution”: A shift
n- in multiple areas indicates a growing trend
toward a more natural approach to healthcare,
for better or worse.5
Riley McCullough
43
THE POWER OF BREATH
STEEPV
TEC HN OLOGY
SIGNALS IMPLICATIONS
• “A breathalyser test could revolutionise cancer • A non-invasive and cheaper method of spotting di
diagnosis”2 - A breath biopsy device designed to detect at an early stage which can maximize cure and ra
cancer hallmarks in molecules exhaled by patients is currently reduce costs of treatments. This trend may impact
being trialed in the UK. The concept behind the test is that public policies related to health care and data col
cancer can cause noticeable alterations in the pattern of vol-
atile organic compounds exhaled. Scientists hope the use of it • Diet adjusted to daily and personal needs may pr
will allow both simpler and cheaper method of spotting can- better health.
cers at an early stage, which can maximize cure and reduce • Different relationships between patients and health
costs associated with the disease. titioners. Adittionally, this may impact how we inte
• “I tried the keto diet that’s sweeping Silicon Valley with the government, for example, police asking u
with help from a gadget that tracks your prog- a breathalyser may provide more data than we w
ress”3 - With the rise of ketogenic diets, which involve eating like to give.
foods that are high in fat and protein, while keeping carbo-
• A new way to connect with the health care system
hydrates to a minimum, a startup called Keyto launched a
the latest technology may disrupt the current medi
device and app. Its goal is to measure through breath the
ketones within the body, produced when the body burns system.
stored fats instead of recently eaten carbs, and therefore a
EXTRAPOLATIONS
Strategic Foresight - Winter 2019
44
r in
eased
oals.
iseases
adically
current
llection.
romote Emerging Growing Peaking Declining
Figure adapted from Güntner et al. J Mater Chem B 2016, 4: 5358. Published by the
Royal Society of Chemistry. Retrieved from https://phys.org/news/2017-10-blood.html
o their 1
Bergamin, F. (2017, October 10). Breath instead of a blood test. Retrieved from PHYS
en auto- ORG: https://phys.org/news/2017-10-blood.html
2
Morrisson, S. (2019, January 3). A breathalyser test could revolutionise cancer
diagnosis. Retrieved from Evening Standard: https://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/can-
cer-breathalyser-test-set-to-revolutionise-diagnosis-launches-in-uk-a4029226.html
st food 3
Farr, C. (2019, December 22). I tried the keto diet that’s sweeping Silicon Valley with
help from a gadget that tracks your progress. Retrieved from CNBC: https://www.cnbc.
com/2018/12/21/ketogenic-diet-christina-farr-tries-with-keyto-device-to-track-progress.html
aceuti- 4
FoodMarble. (2018, December 4). FoodMarble launches world’s first personal digestive
t de- tracker. Retrieved from CISION PR Newswire: https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releas-
es/foodmarble-launches-worlds-first-personal-digestive-tracker-300759518.html
d par- 5
Nedashikivska, T. (2018). Lumen: The first device to hack your metabolism and lose
weight. Retrieved from Spinoff: https://spinoff.com/lumen
45
STEEPV
ECON OMIC
ENVIRONMENT HOME CLEAN AIR AFFORDABILIT
Indoor air pollution might become a significant health issue
without effective and available solutions suitable for all.
From gases and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that escape from carpets and furniture to eve
day activities producing chemical mixtures, the indoor air pollution may severely affect our lives. A
from respiratory conditions, indoor air pollution can also cause heart disease and cancer1.
Currently, smart air quality monitoring devices measure environmental conditions inside a home b
not treat the air, only give recommendations and by a high price. Additionally, many of the house
items are sources of VOCs2 and not every family can pay for safer alternatives or even know that
SIGNALS IMPLICATIONS
• “Scientists participate in month-long experiment • More diseases may happen due to VOCs and oth
to study indoor air pollution”3 - Most Americans pollutants in our homes due to the lack of awaren
spend 90 percent of their time in indoor environments. solutions.
Previous researches focused on the presence or absence
of the radioactive gas radon and on VOCs that escape • Public policies may become more strict regarding
from carpets and furniture. But everyday activities pro- ing materials and designs, and products compositi
duce chemical mixtures that can vary and transform in • Relationships with family and friends may be impa
response to light, temperature and air flow. for example, if we do not live in a “clean air home
some people might not want to visit me.
• “Indoor air quality: The hidden threats”4 - With
the sources of indoor air pollutants being various, the • Manufacturing of products may change to accomm
way forward is a complete and holistic indoor air qual- pollutant free approaches.
ity solution that includes air intake, filtration, cooling,
circulation, ionisation, exchange, and exhaust. Addition- • Challenge of home as a safe place, and disruption
ally, the awareness of indoor air pollution is low among cleaning industry.
Malaysians, often considering, as usual, the smell of
EXTRAPOLATIONS
Strategic Foresight - Winter 2019
46
TY
e
ery-
Apart
but do
eholds
t.
her
ness or
this Panasonic Malaysia. (2019, January 18). Indoor air quality: The hidden threats.
4
47
PRECISE DRUG DELIVERY
STEEPV
TEC HN OLOGY
SIGNALS IMPLICATIONS
• “Smart microrobots that can adapt to their sur- • With a maximization of cure and reduction of side
roundings”1 - Researches developed biocompatible fects, the trend may impact the science environmen
microrobots that are highly flexible and able to swim how religions perceive these treatment options.
through fluids and modify their shape when needed.
Thus, they can pass through narrow blood vessels and • Our relationships with doctors and health care ma
intricate systems without compromising on speed or ma- change due to a more efficient approach and the
neuverability and deliver drugs directly to diseased tis- bility of remote treatments.
sues or organs. Inspired by microorganisms that change
shape as their environmental conditions change, the • The way in which the health care systems manufac
scientists are working on improving these microrobots their treatments may shift more to nanotechnology
performance for swimming through complex fluids like
those found in the human body. • With an innovative drug delivery, the trend may d
and challenge the current pharmaceutical industry
• “Flexible drug delivery microdevice to advance
precision medicine”2 - A Korea Advanced Institute of EXTRAPOLATIONS
Strategic Foresight - Winter 2019
personalized medicine, a step toward theragnosis which ticular type of disease may be followed by a micro
is an advance precision medicine with simultaneous diag- vice implant to monitor the area and treat in adva
nosis and therapeutics. This microdevice is flexible allow- reducing the risk of developing the disease.
ing the application, for example, to smart contact lenses
or brain disease drug delivery implants. Additionally, • Powered wirelessly microdevices may allow the ad
when powered wirelessly, it will represent a platform for tration of exact dosages at desired times, which m
personalized medicine by carrying out exact dosages at fect our need to go to hospitals or doctors appoin
desired times. in order to be monitored and treated.
48
duce
s
he
ef-
e ef-
nt and
RELATED TRENDS
cture
• “Smart pills/Ingestible Sensors” may contribute with this
y.
trend.
destroy
Image retrieved from École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne:
y. https://actu.epfl.ch/news/smart-microrobots-that-can-adapt-to-their-
surround/
1
Pessina, L.-A. (2019, January 2019). Smart microrobots that can
adapt to their surroundings . Retrieved from École Polytechnique
a par- Fédérale de Lausanne: https://actu.epfl.ch/news/smart-microrobots-
ode- that-can-adapt-to-their-surround/
ance, 2
KAIST. (2018, August 14). Flexible drug delivery microdevice to
advance precision medicine. Retrieved from PHYS ORG: https://phys.
org/news/2018-08-flexible-drug-delivery-microdevice-advance.html
dminis-
may af-
ntments
49
CONNECTED, BUT LONELY
STEEPV
SOCIET Y
SIGNALS IMPLICATIONS
• “Combatting the Epidemic of Loneliness in Se- • The loneliness may contribute to other healt
niors”1 - Despite communications tech, we are loneli- sues affecting, even more, the physical cond
er than we have ever been. With age, several changes
of seniors.
may contribute to a more solitary life: physical condi-
tions, shrink of social circles and limited mobility. Sad- • The role of the family may continue to be es
ly, many seniors experience a decline in the number
sential to reduce loneliness in seniors. The s
and quality of their relationships as they age, whether
it is self-imposed or due to outside forces. importance may rely on relationships with e
• “Smart home tests first elder care robot”2 - A • The way elders connect with others and spa
robot created by Washington State University scientists es may need to facilitate physical connectio
uses sensors to determine where residents are, what
through communities, areas, mobility and tr
they are doing and when they need assistance with
daily activities. The robot navigates within the house to portation design.
find people on its own, provides video instructions on
EXTRAPOLATIONS
Strategic Foresight - Winter 2019
50
Y
ot
imit-
isola-
th is-
dition
51
52
Part 2
Scenarios
53
54
Process
We positioned these two themes on the two axes with one being Indi-
vidual Control of Data and Corporate Control of Data, and the other
being No Climate Action and Strong Climate Action. We then used the
ideas generated in the Manoa method and mapped them against the 2x2
to built our four futures. As all our futures were predicated on the idea
that biodevices would be commonly used, we discussed the possibility
of our matrix being a 2x2x2 matrix with the third axis representing the
availability or non-availability of biodevices. As our research showed that
biodevice development was highly likely and that there was a low possi-
bility that biodevices would not be adopted commercially, we opted to
remain with a 2x2 matrix.
After developing the themes for the four scenarios, we gave them
working titles and assigned one scenario to each member of the group.
Individually, we each began backcasting exercises to understand the
processes and events that would need to occur in order for our future
scenarios to exist. We then merged our independent research and did
a group backcasting exercise to ensure that we were bringing different
perspectives and more insight into the exercise. From this point, we then
split up again and each independently generated our scenarios, meeting
at multiple points in this process to discuss each scenario and help build
them out as a team. Our four finalized scenarios are outlined below.
55
individual owned data
climate action
no
56
scenario overviews
• Wanting to be more proactive on monitoring • twenty years have led to increased climate
public health, and after substantial lobbying from stability and less environmental degradation.
the health and pharmaceutical industries, the gov-
ernment of Canada began funding the development
of commercial biodevices, implantable technology
that monitors all aspects of an individual’s health.
57
58
big brother +
no-climate action; corporate + gov’t owned data
Riley McCullough
To truly understand the evolution of our Fitbit Nanos and our Microp-
2021 was also the year that saw an entire preschool class in Lockport,
Manitoba die after a measles outbreak. The fallout from the Lockport
Crisis was reminiscent of the Walkerton Water Crisis in 2000, with en-
raged Canadians across the country calling on the government to take
stronger action on public health issues.4 These two events, triggered in
2021, along with incredible levels of lobbying from the healthcare and
pharmaceutical industries, led the federal government to invest in the
development of biodevices for commercial use from 2023 to 2030.5
big brother +
the new market of commercial biodevices, but it also allowed for them
to play a pivotal role in the development of rules surrounding their de-
vices. Under the Medical Tracking Act of 2026, companies that develop
your biodevices are permitted to monitor and store your health data, as
well as sell it to their “medical community partners” - big pharma names ≥
trends:
1. Technological advancements leads to implantable biodevices that monitors personal health.
2. The actions needed to prevent major climate changes have not happened.
3. Government and insurance companies play a more active role in monitoring health of the popu-
lation in order to prevent deaths due to climate change or environment-related disasters.
59
like Pfizer, Johnson & Johnson, and Bayer. Additionally, when you opt for
non-generic drugs, many of those same big pharma companies are able
to monitor scrubbed versions of your data to determine how their drug
is interacting with your body.6
In 2028, in the wake Montreal’s Summer of Death which saw the death
of 168 individuals after an incessant heat wave that lasted five weeks, the
federal government realized it was missing an opportunity to monitor
public health and wellbeing through the biodevices that it had funded.
In 2032, the government quietly passed the Healthy Canada Act that
requires any company selling biodevices in Canada to provide all data to
the newly created Ministry of Health Management. By 2035, the informa-
tion provided by the Healthy Canada Act led to a shift of the country’s
medical system away from the traditional model of the 1900’s and early
2000’s, and towards one with less doctors offices and nearly no labs or
clinics.7 Although biodevices were not yet mandatory, it was incredible
difficult to receive medical care the traditional way by the late 2030’s.
Those who had held out on biodevices, and were instead completing the
tedious annual task of manually reporting their health data on the cen-
sus, were beginning to opt in with great reluctance.
no climate action; corporate + gov’t owned data
In recent years, a small group of activists have been pushing for the ban
of biodevices monitoring, or at least the transparency of medical data
derived from biodevices. Critics highlight that most biodevices are not
equipped with the functionality to tell you exactly where your data is
going and how it is being used, and that it is unethical to allow consum-
ers to provide this data at such an unknowing level. On the other hand,
big brother +
trends:
4. Increase of disease outbreaks
5. Biodevice formation is driven by the pharmaceutical and healthcare industries, with government support.
6. The health data industry, driven by companies selling patient data to other companies, continues to grow
7. Healthcare becomes more dispersed and long-distance healthcare becomes more common, especially in rural communities.
8. Employers are actively engaged in the fitness and health tracking of their employees.
9. Employer monitoring of employee health and mental health, and new workplace health plans and incentives
60
Interview from The Economist March 2045
How do you feel about biodevices? How have they impacted your every-
day life?
I’m a huge fan of my Fitbit Nano. I remember the days before biodevices
were on the market and I was in my early twenties. I had so much energy
and I felt so healthy. I lost that as I began to get older, but with my
biodevice, I constantly feel young again. It’s so great to be able to wake
up in the morning and have my biodevice app tell me exactly what my
energy levels are, and have my coffee and breakfast prepped with the
vitamins and nutrients needed to balance my health and body. I have my
biodevice set up to create meal plans for each individual day based on
my macro, nutrient and vitamin levels, and then each meal is 3D printed
and ready to go before I leave for work. My biodevice is also linked to my
calendar, so if it knows I have an incredibly stressful day or week, it will
make sure there is some CBD or psilocybin in my meals. My Nano tells
me everything from how much I should sleep each night to whether my
bowel movements are in order. It’s so great and I have so much energy
now. I always feel like I have that healthy glow of my early 20s - I would
Have you opted to share your biodevice data with your employer?
Yes! I know some people are concerned about the security impacts
but its just data. I think I might reconsider when biodevices are able to
treat you as well as just monitor your health but for now I don’t care. My
employers offers incentives and bonuses for its “elite employees”, the
healthiest in the company. It means we get better offices and working
hours, and we’re first in line for vacation days. I’ll walk to work as much
as possible in the shoulder seasons to keep my step count and heart
rate high. In the winter and summer when the weather is too extreme to
walk, I actually have a bicycle desk installed in my office so I’m constantly
moving.
Your job has been borne out of this biodevice age. Can you tell us a bit
about that?
Although a lot of jobs have been replaced by tech, the Toronto District
School Board has had a recent push to bring a human element back in
to work alongside the technology. There’s been some uproar about the
technology monitoring kids, so this is their attempt to bring balance
back into the picture, and I get to learn from all this advanced software
big brother +
which is really cool. My job is essentially to watch the software scan the
biodevices of everyone who enters the school. If they are unhealthy, the
software automatically determines an action, and my job is to monitori
the software to confirm that the directed action is actually completed.
For example, last week, a fourth grader was showing early signs of the
common cold. Nothing too serious, but we wanted to make sure that ≥ his
61
school lunch was fortified with extra Vitamin C and nutrients. So we were
able to watch the software pull up his biodevice information and see
that he was low in about five different nutrients. This information was
then sent to the 3D lunch printers, and the extra nutrients were then
printed into his lunch. For the duration of the day, my team was tasked
with monitoring his vitamin and nutrient levels to ensure that everything
was going according to plan.
Additional Resources: National Environmental Public Health Tracking Program: Bridging the
Jones, T. (2019, March, 6). Green New Deal Support May Cost Politi- Information Gap. Environmental Health Perspectives. doi: https://doi.
cians Votes: IBD/TIPP Poll. Investor’s Business Daily. Retrieved from org/10.1289/ehp.7144
https://www.investors.com/politics/green-new-deal-ibd-tipp-poll/ Reichel, C. (2019, January 22). The current and project health risks
Nuccitelli, D. (2018, December 5). Trump’s disbelief won’t stop dan- of climate change. Journalist’s Resource. Retrieved from https://
gerous climate change. The Guardian. Retrieved from https://www. journalistsresource.org/studies/environment/climate-change/cli-
theguardian.com/environment/2018/dec/05/trumps-disbelief-wont- mate-change-research-review/
stop-dangerous-climate-change Scott, M. (2018, May 31). Insurers Will Be Hard-Hit By Climate Change
Siciliano, J. (2019, February 13). Coal plant closures need to be “rad- But They’re Not Investing in the Low-Carbon Economy. Forbes. Re-
ically accelerated” to meet climate change, report finds. Washington trieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/mikescott/2018/05/31/
Examiner. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/ insurers-in-the-front-line-of-the-fight-against-climate-change-
policy/energy/coal-plant-closures-need-to-be-radically-accelerated- shoot-themselves-in-the-foot/#4204903a40fa
to-meet-climate-change-report-finds
Watts, J. (2018, October 8). We have 12 years to limit climate change 4. Increase of disease outbreaks.
catastrophe, warns UN. The Guardian. Retrieved from https://www.
62
Supporting Class Trend: Vaccine Hesitancy by Kathryn Kramer thestar.com/news/investigations/2019/02/20/medical-record-soft-
Additional Resources: ware-companies-are-selling-your-health-data.html
Centres for Disease Control and Prevention. (n.d.). What Would Happen Thielman, S. (2017, January 10). Your private medical data is for sale -
If We Stopped Vaccinations? Centres for Disease Control ad Prevention. and its driving a business worth billions. The Guardian. Retrieved from
Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/whatifstop.htm https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/jan/10/medical-da-
Global News. (2019, March 8). Hundreds of children dead after Mada- ta-multibillion-dollar-business-report-warns
gascar measles outbreak. Global News. Retrieved from https://global-
news.ca/video/5036265/hundreds-of-children-dead-after-madagas- 7. Healthcare becomes more dispersed and long-distance healthcare
car-measles-outbreak becomes more common, especially in rural communities.
Healio. (2018, April). US measles outbreak catalyzed by vaccine hes- Supporting Class Trend: The Long-Distance Doctor by Sara Qarizada
itancy. Infectious Diseases in Children. Retrieved form https://www. Supporting Class Trend: Reversing the Flow by Trishia Nashtaran
healio.com/pediatrics/vaccine-preventable-diseases/news/print/
infectious-diseases-in-children/%7B8073077c-43e9-407a-8766- 8. Employers are actively engaged in the fitness and health tracking of
4752884bb162%7D/us-measles-outbreaks-catalyzed-by-vaccine-hes- their employees.
itancy Supporting Class Trend: Population Health Management by Andrew
Krans, B. (2018, December 2). This is What Happens When Children Walls
Don’t Get Vaccinated. Healthline. Retrieved from https://www.health- Additional Resources:
line.com/health-news/this-is-what-happens-when-children-dont-get- Dignan, L. (2018, September 19). Fitbit launched Fitbit Care platform for
vaccinated healthcare plans, expands Humana partnership. ZD Net. Retrieved from
Weeks, C. (2019, February 7). Canada could see large amounts of mea- https://www.zdnet.com/article/fitbit-launches-fitbit-care-platform-
sles outbreaks, health experts warn. The Globe and Mail. Retrieved form for-health-care-plans-expands-humana-partnership/
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-canada-could-see- Lovett, L. (2018, May 3). With sales in decline, Fitbit looks to part-
big brother +
other companies, continues to grow. forbes.com/sites/forbeslacouncil/2018/09/07/the-benefits-of-fit-
Supporting Class Trend: Access to Health Data by Andrew Walls ness-and-activity-trackers-in-the-workplace/#540381f269cf
Supporting Class Trend: Big Pharma Tech by Moritz Miethke Miller, B. (2017, January 30). Avoiding Mental Health Discrimination int
Additional Resources: he Workplace. HR Daily Advisor. Retrieved from https://hrdailyadvisor.
Advisory Board. (2018, April 10). Patient data is a hot commodity. blr.com/2017/01/30/avoiding-mental-health-discrimination-work-
Here’s how third parties (legitimately) get a hold of it. Advisory Board. place/
Retrieved from https://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2018/04/10/ Rise Staff. (2017, March 30). 10 Companies with Amazing Workplace
patient-data Wellness Programs. Rise. Retrieved from https://risepeople.com/
Leetaru, K. (2018, April 2). How Data Brokers and Pharmacies Commer- blog/10-companies-with-amazing-workplace-wellness-programs/
cialize Our Medical Data. Forbes. Retrieved from https://www.forbes. Sharratt, A. (2017, January 17). Growing millennial work force demanding
com/sites/kalevleetaru/2018/04/02/how-data-brokers-and-pharma- different health benefits. The Globe and Mail. Retrieved from https://
cies-commercialize-our-medical-data/#24159ef011a6 www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-investor/personal-finance/geny-
Spithoff, S. (2019, February 20). Medical-record software companies money/growing-millennial-workforce-demanding-more-flexible-cre-
are selling your health data. Toronto Star. Retrieved from https://www. ative-health-benefits/article33631813/
63
Data Over Flowers
no-climate action; individual owned data
When Cape Town declared that they would be reaching “Day Zero” in
April 2018, they had become the first major city in the world to poten-
tially run out of water.1 Although Cape Town was able to postpone this
event for a few more years,2 a severe drought would eventually lead
to the city completely running out of water in 2022. Within five years
following this event, Cairo would become the second city in the world to
run out of water.3 By 2040, 20% of the world’s major cities had either
no water or were projected to run out of water in the next six months.
Since then, we have seen this percentage continue to grow. Around the
globe, countries are reporting new weather phenomena such as days of
drought alternating with days of acid rain. This unpredictable weather
has led to mass migration from countries that are facing the biggest
effects of climate change.
no-climate action; individual owned data
steps and sleep. The challenges with these wearable devices were their
accuracy, limited health information, and the fact that in order to track
information they had to be worn somewhere on the body. However, a
rise of do-it-yourselfers saw the accuracy and increased health informa-
tion available on the CGMs and were intrigued by the prospects.6 What
started as a few people buying CGM devices on Amazon soon turned into
a brand new market. To better meet this emerging need, start-ups like ≥
64
Sano Intelligence partnered with existing wearable device technology
companies to bring ‘invisible’ and more accurate health trackers to the
consumer market.7,8 However, as more and more people purchased
these medical devices for non-medical use, concerns around who owns
the health data being collected grew.
Five years after this milestone study, the response has been swift.
The United Nations renewed international talks on climate change and
65
One evening in December 2034 when Fartun was just 2 weeks old, her
parents Adam Duale and Asha Farah were rushing to the hospital. Their
newborn daughter stopped breathing and the terrified parents weren’t
sure what was happening.
“They told us that she was a healthy baby when she was born so this was
completely unexpected”, recalls Farah. After that first visit to the hos-
pital, the family would spend countless days and nights in and out of the
emergency department. As they would later come to understand, Fartun
had a disease that was previously only seen in adults called Chronic Ob-
structive Pulmonary Disease (COPD).
“The doctors said her lungs were blocked which is why she was having
difficulty breathing”, says Duale. They show me a scan of Fartun’s lungs
when she was 2 weeks old and I find it hard to believe that these are the
lungs of an infant. Her dad chuckles and tells me, “That’s exactly what
we said! The doctors said that these lungs looked like they came from an
adult who had smoked 5 packs a day for 40 years.”
no-climate action; individual owned data
Looking at Fartun now, it’s not hard to notice that she isn’t as healthy as
other 11-year-olds. I ask about what a typical day in her life looks like and
the bright-eyed, soft-spoken young girl tells me that there isn’t such a
thing as a typical day. “When I wake up, the first thing I do is check my
phone for my readings. If my lung capacity is green, I make my way to the
bathroom and then downstairs to eat breakfast.” Farah chimes in to clar-
ify that the lung capacity reading is used to determine whether Fartun
can get out of bed or not and that Farah checks air quality once she sees
her daughter having breakfast to determine whether or not she can go to
school. “For example, Fartun hasn’t been able to leave the house since
last Tuesday which is terrible because she should be able to go to school
and see her friends”, says Duale.
But Fartun, the family admits, is one of the luckier children. As soon as
she turned one, she was implanted with an Internal Health Tracker so
that her parents could continually track her vital information. Shortly
after, her parents signed her up for the joint University of Toronto and
the United Nations longitudinal study on the health effects of climate
change. “When the results of the study came out showing that climate
change has had severe effects on our health, even shortening our
data over flowers
lifespan, I can’t say Adam and I were surprised”, says Farah. I ask Fartun,
Asha, and Adam one last question: if you could say anything to the world
leaders gathering in New York a few weeks from now, what would you
say? This time it’s Fartun who speaks up, “I would ask them to consider
saving the planet before there isn’t anything left to save” ≠
66
Trends from the class that informed the development of this scenario dicted Warming: Scientists. Livescience. Retrieved from: https://www.
were: livescience.com/25367-first-ipcc-climate-report-accurate.html
A peek inside by Sara Qarizada
Access to health data by Andrew Walls Dexcom. (2016, November 14). With Health Canada approval, Dexcom
Biohacking for do-it-yourself medicine by Lisa Taylor G5® Mobile CGM System is the First Medical Device in North Amer-
Climate-change mortality by Kathryn Cramer ica for Making Daily Diabetes Decisions Without Painful Fingersticks.
Democratizing healthcare by Moritz Miethke dexcom.com. Retrieved from: https://www.dexcom.com/news/
Do-it-yourself health by Liin Nur health-canada-dexcom-g5-mobile-approval
Planetary health by Riley McCollough Sifferlin, A. (2017, March 16). Why Perfectly Healthy People Are Using
Diabetes Monitors. Time. Retrieved from: http://time.com/4703099/
Additional resources: continuous-glucose-monitor-blood-sugar-diabetes/
City of Cape Town. (2017, November 15). Day Zero: when is it, what is
it, and how can we avoid it? Cape Town Government, Retrieved from: Turton, W. (2017, February 9). Nobody Needs This Silicon Valley-Made
http://www.capetown.gov.za/Media-and-news/Day%20Zero%20 Blood Sugar Tracker for ‘Wellness’ and Lifestyle. Gizmodo. Retrieved
when%20is%20it,%20what%20is%20it,%20and%20how%20can%20 from: https://gizmodo.com/nobody-needs-this-silicon-valley-made-
we%20avoid%20it blood-sugar-track-1791564339
Petersen, T. (2018, June 28). No Day Zero for 2019 – City of Cape
Town. News24. Retrieved from: https://www.news24.com/SouthAfri- Farr, C. (2018, January 5). To catch Apple, Fitbit invests in a company
ca/News/no-day-zero-for-2019-city-of-cape-town-20180628 that makes a small patch to track blood sugar for diabetics. CNBC.
Retrieved from: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/05/fitbit-invests-in-
Zhenmin, L. (2018, October 14). Opening Remarks 1st Cairo Water sano-diabetes-tech-start-up-to-catch-apple.html
Week - “Water Conservation for Sustainable Development”. United
Nations. Retrieved from: https://www.un.org/development/desa/ Katalyse.io. (2018, July 7). Why Blockchain Is The Future Of Data Stor-
Data privacy and rights have been a hot button issue for Prime Minister
Dawson and the Green Party over the last two years following her elec-
tion. Several election platform touchpoints for Prime Minister Dawson
during the 2043 campaign focused on the global trend of data privacy
concerns, the then proposed Bill-H45 was promised to institute policies
to ensure more comprehensive data rights for citizens while protecting
Canadians from hacking and digital terrorism attacks.
The urgency for data protections as Canada prepares to enter the sec-
ond half of the 21st century has only escalated, as the negative effects
of lacking protections have been globally demonstrated over the last
two-decades. Although global shifts over the past 15 years towards
blockchain enabled data encryption have progressed, lessening the
chance of massive data breaches and digital terrorist attacks which
plagued the late 2020s, these anti-hacking and digital security measures
have proven to not be enough to protect people globally from digital
data exploitation by shady actors.
greener on the other side
The amount of data created and recorded has helped define the 21st
century and our current world. As populations continuously create and
share massive amounts of data ranging from entertainment and spending
68
habits, to sensitive and individual biomedical and environmental infor-
mation, they’re also put in more vulnerable and precarious positions
without protections.
This new legislation has not come without its fair share of controversies
and complications. The Data Protections Act has been delayed for over a
year due to a long process of policy consultation and revisions following
concerns of the bill’s implications regarding Canadian health services,
data rights of minors, and the effects on the Canadian sharing economy.
Since it’s first proposal two years ago during the 2043 election, Bill-H45
has received push back from several different parties including health-
care industry workers, parents groups, and members of government.
“It’s been a long process to get Bill-H45 to a place where we feel it best
suits the needs of Canadians as we enter the second half of the 21st
Century,” Minister of Health, Hon. Abel Joseph-Marquéz stated during
a parliamentary meeting yesterday afternoon, “We’re confident that by
taking the time to rigorously consult not only with provincial health min-
istries, but also with the Canadians who work in and use the healthcare
systems, this new legislation works to protects Canadians against data
attacks and exploitation, while granting further access to their health
information with no disruption to the current healthcare system.”
69
A Global Leader in Human Rights
70
Column taken from Afar March 2045 issue
My family and I have been living remotely for about 5 years after moving
back home to the Heiltsuk Territory. I never imagined moving back, but
the vibrancy and growth the area has experienced with investments in
green energy and land and cultural reconciliation makes me proud to call
this place home again. It’s been amazing living back on Heiltsuk Territo-
ry and having my son grow up amongst our culture, while my husband
works along the coast as a tidal energy engineer. But I’m worried that we
might not be able to stay much longer because of Bill-H45.
I’m often running around the community, but I’m also the man who
keeps the house running. I use the data that I collect from my family to
do everything from keeping our medical records up to date, to more
day-to-day tasks like knowing what nutrients we’re missing after a busy
week and pizza dinners, or our in-home air and water quality without me
having to think too much about it.
I just want to know how this new bill will affect running my home, espe-
cially as a parent of a busy 10-year-old, and the child of an independent
but aging mother.
Signed,
Data Dependent Dad
71
Oh Data Dependent Dad,
It sounds like coastal life is not as laid back as many people think it to be,
but like you said, it’s all made easier with the great data-based services
that make remote living just as connected and rewarding. Part of the
remote living movement was definitely made possible because of the ac-
cess to services such as food and healthcare being more affordable with
driverless vehicles, accurate needs data, and digital home assistance.
The DPA shouldn’t affect any of the access you have for your fami-
ly members and the information you need to run your household as a
working father. What you should do though is make sure that you double
check all your sharing permissions! For small things like nutrients and
home air quality it can be done by asking your home assistant, it’ll run
you through the step-by-step process for your integrated life. For more
sensitive data such as medical records (since it sounds like you already
run your family affairs through data), nothing will change.
Just a quick overview of the law as it affects children and minors: Par-
ents are secondary data owners until a person reaches the federal voting
age of 16. This doesn’t mean that you’re privy to all the data (as we know
climate action; individual owned data
being a teen can come with some embarrassing moments), but it does
mean that health and environmental data is easier for you to gain access
to without paperwork.
Don’t worry Data Dad! Your household will most likely keep working just
as smoothly as before, if not even smoother as we see the rollout of
Bill-H45 and the Data Protections Act.
Aiko
72
Trends and resources used to inform the development of scenario: Trends from the class that informed the development of day in the life:
Human Services Data Sharing Revolution by Lisa Taylor Biohacking for do-it-yourself medicine by Lisa Taylor
DNA Dictating Diet and Exercise by Lisa Taylor DNA Dictating Diet and Exercise by Lisa Taylor
Big Pharma Tech by Moritz Miethke Big Pharma Tech by Moritz Miethke
Smart Pills/ Ingestible Sensors Are Offering Access To The Inside Of Our Bodies Like Never Smart Pills/ Ingestible Sensors Are Offering Access To The Inside Of Our Bodies Like Never
Telemedicine Is On The Rise As More Areas Of Healthcare Are Incorporating Digital Systems To Telemedicine Is On The Rise As More Areas Of Healthcare Are Incorporating Digital Systems To
Access to Health Data by Andrew Walls Connected, But Lonely by Igor Bueno
Berti, B. (2015). What are the universal Human Rights. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.
com/watch?v=nDgIVseTkuE
Carrington, D. (2018, July 12). Ireland becomes world’s first country to divest from fossil fuels.
land-becomes-worlds-first-country-to-divest-from-fossil-fuels
Fry, E., & Mukherjee, S. (2018, March 19). Tech’s Next Big Wave: Big Data Meets Biology. Re-
topic.nsf/eng/h_wr02281.html
Government of Canada, I. (n.d.-b). Understand the basics [Reports]. Retrieved March 17, 2019,
from http://www.ic.gc.ca/eic/site/cipointernet-internetopic.nsf/eng/wr03585.html
Kulik, T. (n.d.). A Kick In The Assets: The Big Deal About Big Data & IP. Retrieved March 17, 2019,
from https://abovethelaw.com/2017/11/a-kick-in-the-assets-the-big-deal-about-big-data-
ip/
Marcus, M. (2019, March 5). Invitation to tender: Study of the economic and social returns
of ‘Open standards for data’ – The ODI. Retrieved March 17, 2019, from https://theodi.org/
article/invitation-to-tender-study-of-the-economic-and-social-returns-of-open-standards-
for-data/
Open Data Institute. (n.d.). About the ODI – The ODI. Retrieved March 17, 2019, from https://
theodi.org/about-the-odi/
Patient Data Ownership and Data Property Rights Emerge as a Theme at Leading Pharma Exec-
utive Event. (2019, March 15). Retrieved March 17, 2019, from https://www.businesswire.com/
news/home/20190315005107/en/Patient-Data-Ownership-Data-Property-Rights-Emerge
Right to Privacy in the Digital Age. (n.d.). Retrieved March 17, 2019, from https://www.ohchr.
org/en/issues/digitalage/pages/digitalageindex.aspx
UN environment. (n.d.). What are your environmental rights? Retrieved March 17, 2019, from
http://www.unenvironment.org/explore-topics/environmental-rights-and-governance/what-
we-do/advancing-environmental-rights/what-0
un.org/en/sections/issues-depth/human-rights/
73
Green giant
no-climate action; corporate + gov’t owned data
significantly over the past ten years, the same can’t be said regarding
the public health database. The rich value of vaccination records cou-
pled with a weak data system allowed numerous data breaches and the
emergence of a black market where doctors and hackers faked govern-
ment health data and immunization records upon request. As a way to
crackdown on the black market and increase data security, the govern-
ment implemented partnerships with corporations in the mid-2030s to
intensify the funding of Internal Health Trackers, now commonly known
as Body Bots. After five years, Body Bots were largely available on the
consumer market, with the profit going to the corporations, and the data
jointly owned by the corporations and the government.
The adoption of Body Bots was significant in its early years, surpassing
all forecasts. Body bots were marketed as the most effective way to
track personal health and they did away with the annoyance commonly
observed with other trackers, smartwatches, biodevices or home-based
voice controlled devices, such as the need to keep a full battery or re-
membering to actually input or record your data.
But how did this health data evolution support environmental action?
green giant
Many analysts say that it all started with the new Green Deal signed by
the United States in 2025. This event triggered other countries to follow
suit and begin to gradually shift away from fossil fuel use and increase
their incentives for the sharing economy. This led to a reduction in re-
source use and an increase in “green” companies. Green innovation
74
funding hit its peak in 2035, coinciding with the government’s increased
role in health data security and tracking. Thus, Body Bots incorporated
capabilities such as payment abilities and GPS location that could inform
the government of citizens actions and impacts on the environment. In
2040, when Body Bots were readily available, the government began of-
fering incentives to individuals whose Body Bots reported that they were
using green products or contributing to greener ways of living.
Nowadays, some analysts say the green cities model linked with Body
Bots may collapse in the future if people begin to care less about the
benefits provided by making green choices. However, proponents of
Body Bots reinforce that the data sharing from these devices goes be-
yond government’s incentives to sustainable purposes, it also allows ac-
cess to education and health systems and allows employers to assess the
health and other data generated by the devices. Finally, the convenience
of having a Body Bot and the ease of life that comes along with it, in
addition to the health gains and positive environmental impact, remain
significant reasons as to why individuals continue to use and endorse this
technology. ≠
WHILE SEARCHING for a new job on LinkedIn, Mark Smith noticed that
his Body Bot was no longer helping him pursue his career goals. Three
years ago, when he bought his current Body Bot 3S, he did not have the
money to upgrade to the better version with capabilities to follow daily
glucose and blood pressure. Now, he is missing the ability to track this
data and it is required to be a perfect match for a position at the LCBO.
The data requirements for new jobs attracted both positive and negative
feedback on social media, with many Canadians arguing that it is impos-
sible to upgrade to a new Body Bot to apply for new jobs if your current
job doesn’t pay you enough to have money leftover at the end of the
month.
We contacted the LCBO who explained that the lack of data require-
ments does not mean that a candidate would not be considered for the
position. Moreover, the company said that in the case of hiring a candi-
date lacking data requirements, the company can provide funds to allow
for a Body Bot upgrade.
no climate action; corporate owned data
76
Trends that informed the development of this scenario:
Counter-trends:
79
Strategy
+ Innovation Portfolio
80
For the Strategy Development course, we developed an innovation
strategy for Fitbit. Our process to develop this strategy began with an
in-depth analysis of Fitbit’s current strategy. To do so, we began with
an exploration ofthe industry as well as a competitive analysis of Fitbit
in this space. We also used the Strategic Choice Cascade and Porter’s
Five Forces in order to determine whether the choices Fitbit was making
were strategic and to better understand the company’s competitive en-
vironment. After this analysis, we concluded that Fitbit is currently mak-
ing good choices, but they are not strategic choices. Instead, we found
that these choices were obvious responses to the changing environment
and not proactive enough. Furthermore, in an attempt to diversify their
business, some of Fitbit’s choices, such as moving into the headphones
space, were confusing. Overall,we determined that Fitbit’s current
strategy was struggling with four tension areas. These were: 1. Delivery of
Fitbit Health Solutions is unclear; 2. Fitbit Health Solutions doesn’t have
a streamlined approach; 3. Fitbit lacks a strongtarget audience; and, 4.
Fitbit’s future business model is based on sharing the data of users.
We developed two to three initiatives for each of these focus areas and
we used the benchmark for a mid-stage technology firm to distribute
these initiatives across the Ambition Matrix. Therefore, the innovation
portfolio of activities contains 45% core initiatives, 44% adjacent initia-
tives, and 12% transformational initiatives. These were then prioritized
on an Impact/Effort Matrix and sequenced over the 15-year timeline so
those that were High Impact and Low Effort were done within the first
five years of the strategy. For this Dossier we have included excerpts
from our final strategy and innovation portfolio.
81
Fitbit’s Current Strategy
Fitbit’s Current Strategy
ations
der in
ing.
How Will We Win?
er living In the health tracking
e. wearables space, in the
smartwatch space, and in the Capabilities
corporate wellness space. Capabiliti
the Provide solutions to personal
health management across a
Fitbit’s products are sold in
spectrum of needs - from Processes and Systems
stores and online in 86
providing you with your
different countries.
exercise levels to connecting Method for users to access
Method for users to
you with health solutions. data (software).
Fitbit is targeting casual Manufacturing data
and (software).
users or those involved in distribution partnerships.
Full integration with all Physical stock and places to
fitness for health Physical stock and
smartphones through the sell products (both brick-
maintenance, not sell products
Partnership strategy for (both
Fitbit app. and-mortar and online).
professional trainers. and-mortar
corporate wellbeing and onl
program.
ll We Win?
Goals and Aspirations
83
Current Strategy Assessment:
Porter’s 5 Forces
THREAT
THREAT OF NEW ENTRANTS
OF SUBSTITUTES THREATPOWER
BUYER OF SUBSTITUTES
THREAT OF NEW ENTRANTS SUPP
84
POWER BUYER POWER SUPPLIER POWER SUPPLIER POWER COMPETITIVE RIVALRY
COMPETITIVE RIVALRY
85
The Future Landscape for Fitbit
86
87
Innovation Intent
88
89
Fitbit’s Future Strategy Fitbit’s Future Strategy
90
re Strategy
ll We Win?
new forms of
th tracking.
How Will We Win?
n new ways that
understand and
heir health Capabilities
By developing new forms of
personal health tracking.
he middleman Processes and Systems
nts and
By focusing on new ways that
actitioners.
our users can understand and An innovation strategy that
interact with their health permeates all levels of the
into everyday Research and Development
data. organization.
he Internet of partnerships and
methodologies.
By acting as the middleman A governance structure that
between patients and encourages both internal and
Partnerships with Internet of
healthcare practitioners. external collaboration.
Things players.
91
Focus Areas
92
Development of Health Understanding Everyday
Tracking Health Data
Providing users with the ability to Using data analytics from our broad
monitor their personal health base of users, expanded individual
information on a regular basis health data can be analyzed to
without the need for doctors visits provide easy-to-understand insights
and lab tests. about users’ health compared to
baseline health information.
93
Development of Health Tracking
94
cking
95
Understanding Everyday Health Data
96
alth Data
97
The Medical Middleman
98
TO BELIEVE FUTURE GLIMPSES HEAD STARTS
the gap of health There is an increase in digital Fitbit Care health coaching designed
on that exists between healthcare and the number of health for employee wellness programs.
nd heal practitioners companies investing in it.
f traditional medical Fitbit and Google have collaborated
ments can improve the Technology is enhancing the to accelerate innovation in Digital
t of chronic diseases. accessibility of healthcare and is Health and wearables.
contributing to more user-centred
g more sophisticated care healthcare.
tion can be a win-win for
ents and clinicians: The accuracy of diagnostics will
tion of time and effort, improve with the increased
n of follow-ups, increase in availability of AI and data.
loyalty, increase of revenue.
Trends include:
portals as they currently The Long Distance Doctor by Sara
present a number of Believing Patients by Jacquie
ns: portability of data, The Healthscare System by Moyee
enerated health data Dial-a-Doc by Patricia
or a single episode of care, Reversing the Flow by Trishia
ability challenges Nurse Alexa by Jacquie
ng systems. AI in Diagnostic Health by Harman
Precise Drug Delivery by Igor
a low adoption rate of Using Tech to Sense Anxiety by Karli
ortals among some patient
nd the systems are largely
n place.
99
Internet of Health
Trends include:
The Healthscare System by Mo
Big Pharma Tech by Moritz
Nurse Alexa by Jacquie
Using Tech to Sense Anxiety b
Dial-a-Doc by Patricia
AI Diagnosis by Sara
A Peek Inside by Sara
100
TO BELIEVE FUTURE GLIMPSES HEAD STARTS
ternet of Things (IoT) Integration of healthcare and health, Integration of Amazon Alexa and
ontinues to grow , we’ll fitness and wellness tech in the IoT. Google Home with Fitbit allowing for
to see the importance of smart home assistants to read out
acking integrated into smart Enabling the use of personalized health statistics.
health data in the future smart some,
and with healthcare professionals. Fitbit Aria 2 smart scale signals the
market is expected to double start of Fitbit branded IoT objects.
reaching $520 billion. There will be a continued evolution
of health tech in the home and
en That (IFTTT) applets digital healthcare services with
tegrating Fitbit devices with changing models of access to care.
nching health and fitness
hundreds of other services. Potential rise of in home and smart
home health assistants using the
continuous flow of data from fitness
and health trackers.
Trends include:
The Healthscare System by Moyee
Big Pharma Tech by Moritz
Nurse Alexa by Jacquie
Using Tech to Sense Anxiety by Karli
Dial-a-Doc by Patricia
AI Diagnosis by Sara
A Peek Inside by Sara
101
Innovation Initiatives
102
Development of Health Understanding Everyday The Medical
Tracking Health Data
Development of implantable
1.c bio-devices
Curated and shareable health Curated medical research Actionable smart home
management system
3.b platform
4.b synchronization
103
Research and Development for Line of fitness wearables for
1.a 1.b 1.c
internal, continuous health monitors health tracking
104
elines Curated and shareable health
2.b
management system
105
Electronic Health Record software Curated medical research platform
3.a 3.b
for doctors
106
Formal relationships with Actionable smart
4.b 4.a 4.b
Actionable smart
IoT partners home synchronization
home synchronization
grows, As numerous
With the the internet of things
offerings (IoT) grows,
and With the numerous offerings and
he the market
integrations for smart
into smart objects
homes, the
FitBit integrations into smart homes, FitBit
o shouldwork with the IoT
be preparing is expected to
for integration should be preparing for integration
by grow
of health to aas$520
data a waybillion industry by
to create of health data as a way to create
ng 2021.integration
actionable With this quickly
between expanding actionable integration between
to market
users and theirFitBit should and
IoT objects be looking to users and their IoT objects and
and Smartpartner
home. and develop products and Smart home.
ly services for FitBit that more fully
al integrate
ex. When showing into the of
signs IoTover
and digital ex. When showing signs of over
healthaservices.
caffeination smart home being caffeination a smart home being
able to lock down a coffee maker. able to lock down a coffee maker.
107
Innovation Portfolio
Innovation Portfolio
TRANSFORMATIONAL
12
Where to Play | Market & Customers
NEW 4.b %
TRANSFORMATIONAL
12 %
Where to Play | Market & Customers
4.b
NEW
ADJACENT
44 %
3.b
ADJACENT
3.a
ADJACENT
44 %
3.b 1.a
ADJACENT
3.a 1.c
44 %
EXISTING
2.b
1.b 2.a CORE
4.a
44 %
EXISTING
2.b
2.a
4.a EXISTING INCREMENTAL NEW
108
Initiative Prioritization
TIONAL
15 % In order to determine which initiatives to
prioritize, we looked at them in terms of three
Benchmark:45 %
After prioritizing the initiatives based on their
impact and effort, we then mapped the initiatives
109
Development of implantable bio-devices 1.c
Line of fitness wearables for health tracking 1.b
Actionable Smart
Home synchronization
4.b
110
CORE ADJACENT TRANSFORMATIONAL
2.a User-generated health baselines
INTERNET OF HEALTH
Development of implantable bio-devices 1.c
Line of fitness wearables for health tracking 1.b
1.a 1.c
2.b
4.a 3.a
4.b do with support
Impact
Actionable Smart
3.b Home synchronization
4.b
1.b
LOW
Effort HIGH
112
devices 1.c
2.a User-generated
Sequencinghealth baselines
1.b
Curated and shareable health
2.b management system
a 2020 2025 2030 2035
Time
1.a 1.b
1.a 1.b
1.c
1.c
2.a
DATA
2.b * **
2.a 3.a 3.a
allows 3.b
b CURATED AND 2.b Electronic Health Record software
SHAREABLE 3.a* **
for health practitioners
3.a 3.a
INFORMATION
4.a 4.b
3.b
MEDICAL
tners 4.a 3.b INTEGRATION
Curated medical research platform
supports enhances
DEVELOPMENT OF HEALTH TRACKING
UNDERSTANDING EVERYDAY HEALTH DATA
THE MEDICAL MIDDLEMAN
CORE ADJACENT 4.a 4.b
TRANSFORMATIONAL * development ** adoption INTERNET OF HEALTH
facilitates
INTERNET
OF HEALTH DEVELOPMENT OF HEALTH TRACKING
allows
UNDERSTANDING EVERYDAY HEALTH DATA
DEVELOPMENT OF HEALTH TRACKING
UNDERSTANDING EVERYDAY HEALTH DATA
THE MEDICAL MIDDLEMAN
THE MEDICAL MIDDLEMAN
NAL CORE ADJACENT TRANSFORMATIONAL * development ** adoption INTERNET OF HEALTH
INTERNET OF HEALTH
113
Capabilities & Roadmap Capabilities & Roadmap
Organization Approach
Resources & Capabilities Organization
Metrics &Resources
Incentives& Capabilit
114
Capabilities & Roadmap
internal committee with Build a culture of collaboration, Create metrics using the
tation from different transparency, partnership and innovation intent and roadmap in
and different innovation the innovation strategy
ents
en internal collaboration Select and master the innovation Work towards becoming a market
f and external tools required to carry out leader to create prestige and
ation with healthcare planned and future initiatives recognition as an innovative
company
115
2020 2025 2030
Time
1.a 1.b
2.a
2.b * **
3.a 3.a
3.b
4.a 4.b
116
2035
1.c
117
Date
: Apr
Prep il 9 th,
ared 2045 BRIE
Prep f o r: At FING
ared tend NOT
by: T ees E
he O of th
ffice e Co
I. of th nfide
PUR e Mi ntial
POS niste Mee
r o ting
The E : f Heal of th
purp t h Ma e Mi
ose n nistr
proc o f a g e m y of
eed this b ent Heal
on th riefin th
e inc g no
II. reas te is
BAC ingly to pr
KGR urge ovid
OUN n t ma e op
Follo D: tter o tions
wing f the and
I
Man t h e ev M a rec
agem ents anns omm
ent w of th v ille, A enda
form as fo e 20 lbert
T
ation rmed 2 8 Mo a heat
their , the ntrea w
bodi majo to m l Sum
e rity o onito m
and s . Wit f Can r the h er of
N
real- h the adia ealth Deat
is re t i m e he p assin n s ha and h, th
spon alth g of v e op w e l e Mi
sible data the H ted t l bein nistr
there f o g o y of
E
may f or m o r 95. e althy i mpla f Cana He
be a o nitor 3 % of Ca C a nada n t I ntern d i a
n iss ing t al He ns. S
III. ue. his in nadi Act i i
CUR form a ns. T n 2032 a lth Tr
D
REN a tion h e Div , the a ck
T SIT and ision Minis
I
The UTA a l e rting o f On t r y no
Divis TION goin
in M ion o : the M g
anns f On iniste Heal
F
ville, goin r and th
exha A g H e h
ustio l berta a lth M e r Offi
grow n for on F onito c
. The 2 5% o e brua r ing fi
N
Minis f the ry 15 th rst a
confi t e p o , 2 lerte
dent r adv p ulatio 0 45. T d the
Man i a lity. S ised n an he IH Minis
nsvil ince the D d pro T rep ter a
O
le ar t h e ivisio jectio o r t nd h
e ex n , the n to n s s s h o er O
IV. p ecte num cont i n dica w ed e ffice
OPT d t b e r i n u e t e d a r l of a
IONS o die b s have to cl that y sign
C
y De cont o sely t his n s of
The cem inue mon umb he
optio b e r d t o i t o r e r w
1. E n s on 2 045 wors t his m a s go
ngag how if ac en a atter
e the t o pro t i o n is n n d all 20 a nd s
of th Disa ceed ot ta 0 0 tre
e Tow s t e a re : k e n . re s i d
2. D n of r Ass ents
o no M a istan o
t inte n nsvil c e Re
publ r vene l e to s pons
ic se in th Edm e Tea
rvice is ma onto m (D
V. a n t t e r n w h ART
REC n o unce ; cont e re the ) to f
OMM men i n ue to r e are orcib
The E N t s e n m o c o ly ev
Minis DAT cour nitor oling acua
ION a ging the i cent te th
try o resid s sue e rs (P e res
f Hea e nts t a n d inc rotoc iden
lth M o tak r ol 20 ts
anag e e a s e 4 5
eme caut the f ).
nt re ion in requ
com the h e ncy
men eat of
ds th
e im
med
iate
enac
tmen
t of P
rotoc
ol 20
118 45.
h Ma
L
nage
men
t
IA
ation
on h
wave ow to
s.
ealth
ince
its
kers
(IHTs
ow o ) into
ngoi
h Mo ng Part 4
nitor Designed Future: Immersive Scenario
ce w ing
hen
an is
sue
eat
oing
to
esse
d
of
119
120
121
122
123
124
BRIEFING NOTE
L
I. PURPOSE:
The purpose of this briefing note is to provide options and a recommendation on how to
proceed on the increasingly urgent matter of the Mannsville, Alberta heatwaves.
A
II. BACKGROUND:
TI
Following the events of the 2028 Montreal Summer of Death, the Ministry of Health
Management was formed to monitor the health and wellbeing of Canadians. Since its
formation, the majority of Canadians have opted to implant Internal Health Trackers (IHTs) into
their bodies. With the passing of the Healthy Canada Act in 2032, the Ministry now ongoing
EN
and real-time health data for 95.3% of Canadians. The Division of Ongoing Health Monitoring
is responsible for monitoring this information and alerting the Minister and her Office when
there may be an issue.
IV. OPTIONS
The options on how to proceed are:
O
1. Engage the Disaster Assistance Response Team (DART) to forcibly evacuate the residents
of the Town of Mannsville to Edmonton where there are cooling centers (Protocol 2045).
2. Do not intervene in this matter; continue to monitor the issue and increase the frequency of
C
V. RECOMMENDATION
The Ministry of Health Management recommends the immediate enactment of Protocol 2045.
125
126
Designed Future Script
script outlining the Big Brother+ Scenario
Roles:
Minister of Health (Riley)
#1 Assistant to the Minister of Health Management (Igor)
#2 Assistant to the Minister of Health Management (Grayce)
Minister of Energy (Liin)
Documenter/photographer (Jacquie)
_______________________________________________________________________
Once they arrive, they are greeted by Grayce & directed to the meeting
room. Grayce also asks the class to put their cell phones into the basket
once they arrive.
Class has the opportunity to get snacks and mingle, review their
briefs, etc.
Igor: Hello everyone and thank you for attending this emergency meeting
of the Ministry of Health Management. We’d like to remind you that this
meeting is top-secret and what is said in this room is to remain in this
room. If you haven’t done so already, please drop off your phones in the
basket that my colleague Grayce is carrying. Don’t worry, you will be able
to retrieve your device at the end of the meeting.
Igor: Thank you very much. Now without further ado, I am pleased
to welcome our Minister of Health Management, Riley McCullough.
Riley: Thank you Igor and thank you all for coming together with such short
notice. I’m sure you must all be curious about what we will be discussing
and we will get to that in a moment. But before we talk about the matter
at hand, it is critical that we first take a few cues from our past.
Riley: Our Ministry emerged from a time of crisis. The 2028 Montreal
Summer of Death took the lives of over 4,0000 Canadians. The heat
wave seemed to come from nowhere but it killed our neighbours,
families, and friends. In the short span of 1 month, we watched
Montreal change from a place full of life and culture to a place of death. ≥
127
As has become our country-wide practice, I’d like to take a few
moments of silence to remember this tragedy.
Riley: Thank you. As a nation, we were left with many questions: “How
did we let this happen”, “Is this the beginning of the end?”, “Is there
anyway we could prevent this from happening again?”.
We were all filled with grief and fear of what would happen next and the
Great Riots of 2029 pushed our country into action. Luckily we had a
wonderful Prime Minister who lead the country and helped to bring an
answer to some of these questions. Prime Minister _______ introduced
the Healthy Canada Act which was eventually passed and is now law.
From that law emerged our Ministry, the Ministry of Health Management.
To prevent a tragedy like the Montreal Summer of Death, the Ministry
of Health Management was tasked with having oversight over the data
collected by the biodevices that live and breath in our bodies. Those tiny
little robots have lots of information to tell us what’s happening inside
our bodies. So in this Ministry, we can see the population health data for
ALL Canadians.
This brings me to the reason I have asked you all to join me for this
meeting. The Montreal Summer of Death is in our past but a new threat
is silently emerging.
Right now, as we sit here today healthy and happy, the people of Mann-
ville in Northern Alberta are under attack.
128
Using the information from the biodevices, we know that this number
could grow to 7 in 10 by the end of next month.
As you can see, these numbers are grim. If we project into the future
using the numbers from now, we can expect this entire community of
2000 people to die from the heat by December. But we can intervene
before things get any worse and save the lives of 2000 people.
The facts and figures I read out moments ago, along with the drought
conditions in the area surrounding Mannville has led us to believe that we
have a necessity, as a government, to enact Protocol 2045. This Proto-
col proposes a forcibly evacuation of the entire town of Mannville. Once
moved, we will relocate the residents of this town to Edmonton where
we have cooling centers already set up.
We have the to make sure this isn’t a repeat of the Montreal Summer of
Death. This is the first instance that we as a government are taking action
on forcible evacuation, and if, with your support, this process is a suc-
cess, this plan could be implemented in the future to save more Canadi-
an lives. We have the Disaster Assistance Response Team on the ground
in Alberta ready to move in on Mannville and begin the evacuation as
soon as our vote here is complete.
129
Liin: I think I speak for many of us when I say that we have quite the
problem in our hands. I lost close friends to the Montreal Summer of
Death and I would like to avoid a repeat of that tragedy as much as
possible. But as the Minister of Energy, I am particularly interested in this
relocation as it would open the area around Mannville, which is now in-
capable of supporting its traditional farming practices, for additional oil/
gas drilling. We would have done this long ago but the local community in
Mannville has been opposed to this.
With this forcible evacuation you are proposing, I wanted to hear your
thoughts on additional benefits to enacting this Protocol?
Riley: Thank you for the question, Minister. You’ve caught on to one of
the many opportunities we see for this move. There is the obvious one
which is saving thousands of lives and what you’ve already mentioned
but I want to point out another opportunity. Mannville is a small town
with a large budget. As I am well aware, many of you are worried about
how we are going to keep our cities from crumbling under the pressure
of overpopulation and increasing debt. Redistributing the budget of
Mannville to the cities is something I implore you to consider when mak-
ing your decision today. The safety and security of the residents is top of
mind for my Ministry but I can see many opportunities that would benefit
each and every one of us in the room today.
Riley: Okay let’s put Protocol 2045 to a vote. Igor, if you may.
Igor: The procedure to pass this protocol calls for a simple majority of
votes in the room. All in favour of saving 2000 lives in Mannville, Alberta
and implementing the protocol for a mandatory, permanent evacuation
to Edmonton please raise your hands. All against?
Riley: We’ve made the right decision here today. We’ve made the de-
cision to save 2,000 Canadian lives. Let’s dial in the DART team and let
them know that they have the green light.
[Phone rings]
Riley: Lieutenant, we’ve come to a decision. You are good to go. Please
begin the evacuation of Mannville, but do so with a delicate touch.
130
Stress levels are already high due to the heat, so we don’t want to send
anyone into shock. We will be monitoring all health data here and re-
porting to you if anything is alarming.
[Lights are dimmed. Message comes on screen: “You have just experi-
enced the scenario, Big Brother +. Thank you for participating”]
[Message comes on screen: “You have just experienced the scenario, Big
Brother +. Thank you for participating”] ≠
131
Image taken from April 9th, 2045 meeting of the
Canadian Ministry of Health and Welfare. Minister
McCollough presents the dire health statistics of
Mannville, AB to meeting attendees.
132
After briefing the meeting was open to discussion
by attendees. Some ministers in attendance were
given directives to represent either a strong for,
or against stance during discussion. These directives
were included in their breifing packets. Concerns
were raised by attendees regarding the perceived
motives of expanding mining, and reducing rural
infrastructure and towns.
138
139
140