Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Steel Slag in Concrete As Fine Aggregate PDF
Steel Slag in Concrete As Fine Aggregate PDF
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Steel slag, which is produced locally in great amounts, has a negative impact on the environment when
Received 11 March 2008 disposed. Local steel slag has a low CaO content and has no pozzolanic activity.
Received in revised form 2 June 2008 In this research, local unprocessed steel slag is introduced in concrete mixes. Various mixes with com-
Accepted 16 June 2008
pressive strength ranging from 25 to 45 MPa are studied. The slag is used as fine aggregate replacing
Available online 26 July 2008
the sand in the mixes, partly or totally. Ratios of 0%, 15%, 30%, 50% and 100% are used.
Depending on the grade of concrete, the compressive strength is improved when steel slag is used for
Keywords:
low sand replacement ratios (up to 30%).
Aggregate
Concrete
When optimum values are used, the 28-day tensile strength of concrete is improved by 1.4–2.4 times and
Steel slag the compressive strength is improved by 1.1–1.3 times depending on the replacement ratio and the grade
Compressive strength of concrete. The best results are obtained for replacement ratios of 30–50% for tensile strength and 15–
Tensile strength 30% for compressive strength.
Therefore, the use of steel slag in concrete would enhance the strength of concrete, especially tensile
strength, provided the correct ratio is used.
Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Uses of steel slag in concrete Electric arc furnace slag (EAFS) that contains low percentage of
amorphous silica and high content of ferric oxides and conse-
The main properties of concrete, such as strength, durability quently has low, or no, pozzolanic activities in comparison with
and serviceability, depend mainly on the properties and the quality blast furnace slag (BFS), is not appropriate to be used in blended
of the materials that are used in preparing it. Therefore, the use of cement production [5]. Although many studies have been con-
waste materials, such as steel slag, in concrete may have positive ducted on the evaluation of steel slag usage in road construction
or negative effect. and use of blast furnace slag in concrete mixes, few researches
Utilizing steel slag in concrete mixes has proved to be useful in have been performed regarding the utilization of steel slag in con-
solving some of the problems encountered in the concrete indus- crete [5].
try. Steel slag was used in conventional concrete to improve its Alizadeh et al. [4] carried out a research to evaluate the effect of
mechanical, physical, and chemical properties as shown herein. using electric arc furnace steel slag on hardened concrete. Experi-
There is a big difference between steel slag and blast furnace slag, mental results indicated that such steel slag aggregate concrete
the later is produced from the conversion of iron ore to steel, while achieved higher values of compressive, tensile and flexural
the other is produced from the oxidation of old steel during pro- strength and modulus of elasticity, compared to natural aggregate
duction in the arc furnace. concrete.
Slag, the by-product of steel and iron producing processes, was Shekarchi et al. [7,8] conducted comprehensive researches on
used in civil engineering projects tenths of years ago [1–4]. Port- the utilization of steel slag as aggregate in concrete. They con-
land granulated ground blast furnace slag cement, which is pro- cluded that the use of air-cooled steel slag with low amorphous sil-
duced from rapidly water-cooled blast furnace slag, has been ica content and high amount of ferric oxides is unsuitable to be
successfully used in concrete mixes due to the high content of lime used in blended cement. On the other hand, utilization of steel slag
(40–50%), which posses pozzolanic activity [2,3]. ASTM C33 pro- as aggregate is advantages when compared with normal aggregate
vides specifications for the use of blast furnace slag as aggregates mixes.
in concrete, while there is no standard for the use of steel slag in Maslehuddin et al. [9] presented a comparative study about
concrete. steel slag aggregate concrete and crushed limestone concrete. In
the study, only part of the coarse aggregate was replaced by slag
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +962 79 9770092. aggregate. The study concluded that the compressive strength of
E-mail address: qasrawi2@yahoo.com (H. Qasrawi). steel slag aggregate concrete was marginally better than that of
0950-0618/$ - see front matter Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2008.06.003
H. Qasrawi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 23 (2009) 1118–1125 1119
crushed limestone aggregate concrete. Moreover, the improvement In this research, the unprocessed fine material, ‘‘scrape”, has
in the tensile strength of steel slag concrete was not significant. been introduced as fine aggregate in normal concrete mixes in
Manso et al. [10,11] presented a study in which electric arc fur- order to evaluate its suitability for use in normal concrete
nace slag was used to obtain concrete of better quality. It was con- mixes.
cluded that arc furnace slag can be used to enhance concrete
properties. However, according to the authors, special attention
3. Materials
must be paid to the fine aggregate of steel slag concrete mixes,
which can be obtained by mixing fine slag with filler material.
Limestone normal aggregate of local sources has been used in
Ramachandran [6] stated that air-cooled slag is suitable as an
the preparation of all mixes. The gradation of this aggregate was
aggregate in concrete. Also, slag fines may be used as a substitute
obtained following ASTM C136 standard procedure. Sieve analysis
for sand without any deleterious effect. Furthermore, volume sta-
results are shown in Table 1. The aggregate was found to be well
bility, good sulphate resistance, and corrosion resistance to chlo-
graded and within ASTM C33 grading requirements for coarse
ride solutions make reinforced slag concrete suitable for many
aggregate of nominal maximum size 25–4.75 mm.
applications.
Silica sand of natural sources, known locally as desert sand, has
been used. Sieve analysis was carried out on both the natural sand
2. Importance of the research and the fine slag according to ASTM C33. The results of the sieve
analysis of both the fine aggregate and the fine steel slag are shown
Locally, waste materials the steel industry is produced in high in Table 2; in addition, ASTM C33 and BS 882 grading limits are
amounts and shapes ranging from large boulders to dust. Since also shown.
large quantities of these wastes are generated daily, they are con- Although the sand is relatively fine, it has good properties and is
sidered problematic and hazardous for both the factories and the commonly used in concrete mixes. The fineness modulus of sand
environment. The factories have to pay huge amounts of money and slag are 1.56 and 1.50, respectively. As shown in Table 2, both
for the disposal of these materials, which in addition have a nega- sand and slag do not meet ASTM C33 standard limits for fine aggre-
tive impact on the environment. Locally, the steel industry is not gate. However, the sand is within the limits of BS 882: 1992 stan-
mainly based on using ‘‘steel ore” as a base material, because it dards and is classified as ‘‘BS-F” (fine aggregate). As shown in Table
is not available. Instead, ‘‘old steel” is brought from various 2, the slag contains high amounts, about 40%; of material passing
sources, melted and shaped. Therefore, the waste material is char- sieve # 100; however, only half of this value is retained on sieve
acterized by its high content of iron oxide, Fe2O3. # 200. Therefore, the slag meets neither ASTM C33 nor BS 882
The slag produced from local resources is divided into three grading limits.
types: In order to reduce costs, it was decided to use the slag ‘‘as re-
ceived” from the factory without any further screening. Also, it
1. The coarse materials (boulders) that need to be crushed into was intended to use the locally available desert sand from nearby
smaller particles in order to be suitable for reuse. sources. This choice would be the most economical for use in con-
2. The fine material, which is locally called ‘‘scrape”. This type of crete mixes when accounting for the costs of transporting and
slag will be used directly in concrete mixes (without any mod- screening.
ification) in this research in order to evaluate its suitability for Specific gravity and absorption of the aggregates were mea-
concrete mixes. Ramachandran [6] used air-cooled slag as a sured using ASTM C127 and ASTM C128. In each case, three repre-
substitute to fine aggregate. sentative samples were taken and tested according to the
3. The very fine materials, dust, which may need further process- corresponding ASTM standard. The average of the three obtained
ing before being used in concrete. values was calculated and presented in Table 3.
Table 1
It is clear from Table 3 that the specific gravity of the steel slag
Sieve analysis of coarse aggregates is higher than that of normal aggregate. Also, it is clear that the
absorption of both sand and steel slag is smaller than 1%. These re-
Sieve size (mm) ASTM designation % passing ASTM limits 25 to 4.75
sults are acceptable for use in concrete structures, keeping in mind
37.5 1½00 100 100 that higher density is expected.
25 1.000 98.7 95–100
3= 00
Dry-rodded (compacted) unit weight of the coarse aggregate
19.6 4 85.2 –
12.5 ½00 28.3 25–60 was obtained using ASTM C29 specifications and was 1528 kg/m3.
9.5 3/800 19 – Chemical analysis of steel slag is shown in Table 4. It is clear
4.75 #4 0.8 0–10 that the slag has very low CaO content indicating that no pozzola-
2.36 #8 0.4 0–5
nic activity is expected.
Table 2
Sieve analysis of fine aggregates
Sieve size (mm) ASTM designation Sand Slag ASTM limits BS grading requirements
% passing % passing BS–C BS–M BS–F
00
10 3/8 100 100 100 100 100 100
5 #4 99.9 99 100 89–100 89–100 89–100
2.40 #8 99.6 95.6 95–100 60–100 65–100 80–100
1.20 # 16 98.9 85.4 80–100 30–90 45–100 70–100
0.600 # 30 91.3 72.1 50–85 15–54 25–80 55–100
0.300 # 50 45.1 56.2 25–60 5–40 5–48 5–70
0.150 # 100 8.6 40 10–30 0–15* 0–20a 0–15* 0–20a 0–15* 0–20a
0.075 # 200 1 20.5 NA NA NA NA
*
Natural aggregate.
a
Crushed aggregate.
1120 H. Qasrawi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 23 (2009) 1118–1125
5.1. Workability
4. Experimental program
Fig. 1 shows the relationship between the slump of concrete
In order to study the effect of the use of steel slag as fine aggre- and the ratio of slag. It is clear that the use of slag reduced the
gates, several concrete mixes have been prepared and tested in the workability of concrete. As shown, replacement ratios up to 50%
laboratory. The following steps summarize the program that has have only marginal effect on the workability and the concrete
been followed: can still be classified as concrete of medium workability. The mixes
containing 100% slag were sticky rather than dry. All these mixes
1. Conventional concrete mixes of 25, 35 and 45 MPa cube lacked mobility and hence resulted in low slump values. The
strength were designed, fabricated and tested in the laboratory. reduction in workability is attributed to the fact that the sand
In addition to the strength requirement, all mixes were pre- has been replaced by a finer and a more absorbing material. The
pared and adjusted to obtain concrete of medium workability higher the percentage of the fines, the less the workability is, as
(slump 8–12 cm). This workability is the most desired one in shown in Fig. 1. Moreover, the slag particles have more angular
local concrete sites, especially during hot summer. The mix pro- shapes when compared with normal sand particles. In order to
portions are shown in Table 5. The normal concrete mixes were check the last assumption (angularity), the loose unit weights of
proportioned, tested and adjusted according to the ACI 211.1. both natural sand and fine slag were measured according to AASH-
ACI 211.1 suggests using a water content of 195 kg/m3 in order TO T304. To eliminate the effect of aggregate gradation, only sin-
to obtain a slump of 8–10 cm. Trials were carried out in the lab- gle-sized aggregates were compared. The sizes tested were
oratory and ended by using a free water content of 205 kg/m3 in between 0.15 and 0.30 mm, and 0.30 and 0.60 mm. The voids ratio
order to arrive at a slump of about 12 cm. in the slag was found to be higher than that of natural sand. Hence,
2. All mixes were tested for workability using the slump test it was concluded that the loss of workability is due to two factors:
described in ASTM C143. the increased fines and the increased angularity.
3. The fresh density of all mixes was measured according to ASTM
C138. 5.2. Fresh density
4. Several cubes of 100 mm side length were prepared and cured
in the laboratory in a water bath under a temperature of Fig. 2 shows the relationship between sand-slag replacement
20 ± 2 °C; then tested at the ages of 3, 7, 28, 90 and 180 days ratio and the increase in the density of fresh concrete. As expected,
Table 5
Mix Proportions
Strength (MPa) Cement (kg) Free water (kg) 20 mm aggregate (kg) 10 mm aggregate (kg) Sand (kg) Scale (kg)
15% Replacement
25 330 205 339 792 512 90.5
35 427 205 317 740 510 90
45 536 205 290 677 510 90
30% Replacement
25 330 205 339 792 422 181
35 427 205 317 740 420 180
45 536 205 290 677 420 180
50% Replacement
25 330 205 339 792 302 302
35 427 205 317 740 300 300
45 536 205 290 677 300 300
H. Qasrawi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 23 (2009) 1118–1125 1121
20 50
Average values
Min. Values
Max. values
16
40
30
Slag Percentage
20 0 % Slag
4 15 % Slag
30 % Slag
50 % Slag
100 % slag
0 10
Fig. 1. Relationship between the slag percent and the slump of concrete. Fig. 3. Relationship between age of concrete and its compressive strength for
various slag replacements (25 MPa concrete).
50
120
Average Values
Range (Max or Min)
Increase in Density (kg per cubuc meter)
40
80
30
40 Slag Percentage
0 % Slag
15 % Slag
30 % Slag
50 % Slag
100 % slag
20
0
10 20 30 40 50
Slag Ratio
Fig. 4. Relationship between age of concrete and its compressive strength for
various slag replacements (35 MPa concrete).
the use of slag in concrete increased the density of concrete be-
cause it replaced sand which has a lower specific gravity. However,
the increase in the density is small (less than 5%) because the 5.3. Compressive strength
amount of slag used is small. In all cases, concrete is considered
normal-density concrete when compared to the limits given in Figs. 3–5 show the relationship between compressive strength
ACI 304.3 ‘‘Heavyweight concrete: measuring, mixing, transporting, and age of concrete for all samples. From Figs 3 and 4, the following
and placing”. observations are obtained:
1122 H. Qasrawi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 23 (2009) 1118–1125
60 50
50 40
Compressive Strength (MPa)
Strength (MPa)
40 30
Slag Percentage
0 % Slag
15 % Slag
30 30 % Slag 20 25 MPa
50 % Slag 35 MPa
100 % slag 45 MPa
20 10
0 40 80 120 160 200 0 20 40 60 80 100
Age of Concrete (Days) Slag Ratio
Fig. 5. Relationship between age of concrete and its compressive strength for Fig. 6. Relationship between the slag ratio and the compressive strength of
various slag replacements (45 MPa concrete). concrete at the age of 28 days.
Fig. 10, shows the relationship between slag ratio and the ratio
of the strength to zero-slag strength for the three grades of con- Referring to the tensile strength plots in this figure, the follow-
crete at the age of 28 days. ing are observed:
H. Qasrawi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 23 (2009) 1118–1125 1123
2.4
Flexural Tensile Strength (MPa)
3
1.6
25 MPa
35 MPa
2
45 MPa
1.2
1
0 20 40 60 80 100
Slag Ratio
Fig. 8. Relationship between the slag ratio and the tensile strength of concrete at 0.8
the age of 28 days.
0 20 40 60 80 100
Slag Ratio
8 Fig. 10. Relationship between slag ratio and the ratio of strength to zero-slag
strength for the three grades of concrete.
70 70 70
60 60 60
Strength (MPa)
50 50 50
40 40 40
30 30 25 MPa 30
25 MPa 25 MPa
35 MPa
35 MPa 35 MPa
45 MPa
45 MPa 45 MPa
20 20 20
Fig. 11. Relationship between slag ratio and the compressive strength of concrete made with coarse slag as fine aggregate.
such aggregate produces compressive strengths higher than those increases the tensile strength of concrete by 1.1–1.3 times the
concretes made with gravel and crushed limestone. Moreover, slag strength of normal concrete, depending on the used ratio.
fines may be used as a substitute for sand without any deleterious Therefore, special care should be taken when designing mixes
effect. or when batching the material at site when using the slag ‘‘as
However, when the amount of slag increases, the amount of received” from the factory.
fine material (less than 0.15 mm) becomes high (about 40% of 4. Regarding the compressive and tensile strengths of concrete,
the slag is finer than 0.15 mm). Since the fines require more ce- steel slag is more advantageous for concretes of lower
ment to be effectively coated, high amounts of slag may adversely strengths, i.e., the lower the grade of concrete, the better the
affect the strength of concrete. In order to support this assump- enhancement in the compressive and tensile strengths.
tion, new mixes containing steel slag only retained on sieve # 5. The use of steel slag in normal concrete mixes is beneficial for
100, to remove excess fine material, were prepared using the the enhancement of the tensile strength for all replacement
same ratios and tested for compressive strength at the ages of ratios. However, the best results were obtained when the
28, 90 and 180 days. Fig. 11 shows the results of the test. It is replacement percentage is about 50%. When optimum values
clear from the plot that the strength of concrete increases by are used, the use of steel slag increases the tensile strength of
the increase in the slag ratio. This supports the assumption men- concrete by 1.4–2.4 times the strength of normal concrete,
tioned before. depending on the ratio used.
This finding is somewhat compatible with Manso et al. [10] who 6. Better results can be obtained when the material finer than
noted that special attention must be paid to the mixes of concrete 0.15 mm is eliminated. In this case, the strength increases by
having slag as fine aggregate in order to achieve a suitable fine the increase in the amount of slag replacing sand.
aggregate.
References
6. Conclusions and recommendations
[1] Geiseler J. Slag-approved material for better future. In: Proceeding of
Based on the study presented in this research, the following international symposium on the utilization of metallurgical slag (ISUS 99),
conclusions and recommendations can be drawn: Beijing, China; 1999.
[2] Neville A, Brooks J. Concrete technology. 2nd ed. UK: Longman; 2002.
[3] Neville AM. Properties of concrete. 4th ed. UK: Longman; 1996.
1. The use of steel slag as fine aggregate has a negative impact on [4] Alizadeh R, Chini M, Ghods P, Hoseini M, Montazer Sh, Shekarchi M. Utilization
the workability of concrete especially for replacement ratios of electric arc furnace slag as aggregates in concrete – environmental issue.
CMI report, Tehran 1996.
above 50%. However, this problem can easily be taken care of [5] Kamal M, Gailan AH, Haatan A, Hameed H. Aggregate made from industrial
by the use of admixtures. unprocessed slag. In: Proceeding of the 6th international conference on
2. The use of steel slag as fine aggregate in concrete mixes has a concrete technology for developing countries, Amman, Jordan; 2002.
[6] Ramachandran VS. Waste and by-products as concrete aggregates. CBD-
positive effect on both compressive and tensile strengths; hence
215. NRCC: Canadian Building Digest; 1981.
introducing it in concrete will eliminate one of the environmen- [7] Shekarchi M, Soltani M, Alizadeh R, Chini M, Ghods P, Hoseini M, Montazer Sh.
tal problems created by the steel industry. Study of the mechanical properties of heavyweight preplaced aggregate
3. Best results for the enhancement of compressive strength are concrete using electric arc furnace slag as aggregate. In: International
conference on concrete engineering and technology, Malaysia; 2004.
obtained when the replacement percentages are between 15% [8] Shekarchi M, Alizadeh R, Chini M, Ghods P, Hoseini M, Montazer S. Study on
and 30%. When optimum values are used, the use of steel slag electric arc furnace slag properties to be used as aggregates in concrete. In:
H. Qasrawi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 23 (2009) 1118–1125 1125
CANMET/ACI international conference on recent advances in concrete [10] Manso J, Gonzalez J, Polanco J. Electric furnace slag in concrete. J Mater Civil
technology, Bucharest, Romania; 2003. Eng ASCE 2004:639–45.
[9] Maslehuddin M, Alfarabi M, Shammem M, Ibrahim M, Barry M. Comparison of [11] Manso J, Polanco J, Losañe M, González J. Durability of concrete made with EAF
properties of steel slag and crushed limestone aggregate concretes. Constr slag as aggregate. Cement Concrete Compos 2006;28(6):528–34.
Build Mater 2003;vol. 17:105–12.