Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Power Research & Development Consultants Pvt. LTD
Power Research & Development Consultants Pvt. LTD
Dr. S. R[dh[krishn[n h[d studied [nd excelled in Indi[n Dr. R . N[g[r[j[ , M[n[ging Director, PRDC
philosophy. He w[s [ strong believer of intuition[l
knowledge or experience r[ther th[n intellectu[l wh[t is import[nt to deb[te is the possibility of producing
experience. He believed th[t te[chers should be the best [bout 10,000 qu[lified personnel for engineering f[culty
minds in the country. Sir M. Visvesv[r[y[ w[s [ gre[t every ye[r who [re dedic[ted [nd h[ve both theoretic[l
pr[cticing engineer. He w[s known for his punctu[lity, [nd pr[ctic[l skill sets. Industries [nd concerned
perfect dressing, fitness, dedic[tion to work, perfection [uthorities h[ve to re[lize th[t it is imper[tive to tr[in
[nd cour[ge, himself being [ fe[rless p[triot. these 10,000 engineering f[culty for imp[rting
knowledge [nd required skills to the 15 l[kh students.
In the p[st, te[ching profession in the engineering field Further, there should be [ mech[nism to improve the skill
w[s t[ken up with lot of devotion [nd interest. At set of the engineering f[culty in the beginning of their
present, for m[ny of the lecturers in the engineering profession[l c[reer in the first 10 ye[rs.
colleges, te[ching profession is more of [ compulsion
th[n the choice. When the qu[lity [nd [c[demic While we h[ve B.Ed progr[m for te[chers in other
excellence of the te[chers go down, qu[lity of the stre[ms, irony is th[t one gets into engineering te[ching
engineers coming out of the colleges [lso suffers. Of the profession just [fter the PG without [ny form[l
existing public [nd priv[te engineering institutions in orient[tion or tr[ining. While there is [ rigorous tr[ining
Indi[, only [ select few [re producing high qu[lity progr[m for IAS officers [t the induction level, I wonder
gr[du[tes. It’s [ known f[ct th[t engineering gr[du[tes why we c[nnot h[ve one such progr[m for the
h[ve [ str[tegic [nd long-term imp[ct on productivity engineering college f[culty [s well. Even in medic[l
growth in industry [nd service sectors. While there is profession, the te[ching f[culty is inv[ri[bly [ pr[cticing
f[irly good underst[nding of wh[t needs to be done in doctor h[ving [dequ[te skills. Suffice to st[te th[t there is
order to signific[ntly improve the govern[nce in [ huge need for f[culty development both in terms of
engineering institutions, I w[nt to focus on wh[t pl[gues ped[gogic[l development [nd engineering dom[in
the qu[lity of te[ching in these institutions tod[y. Let us tr[ining. If one [ssumes th[t [bout two l[kh rupees per
perform [ simple c[lcul[tion to know the requirement of he[d is required to give tr[ining for the engineering
engineering college te[chers in Indi[. As per the AICTE f[culty per ye[r post their PG, the over[ll cost of tr[ining
se[t m[trix of engineering colleges for 2015-16, the would work out to [bout Rs. 200cr. Through this column,
estim[ted number of engineering colleges is [bout 3000, I propose the following [ffirm[tive [ction pl[n to
h[ving [n [pproved int[ke of [bout 15,00,000 students improve the skill set of te[chers in engineering colleges
per [nnum for UG. Assuming th[t [n [ver[ge of 65% of so [s to empower them to serve the society [s per the
the students per b[tch st[y for the entire four ye[r vision of Dr. S. R[dh[krishn[n [nd to produce high qu[lity
dur[tion of the course, over[ll student strength would be engineers who h[ve the skill [nd dedic[tion to
45,00,000. As per the AICTE norms, the student to engineering profession to emul[te the likes of Sir. M.
te[cher r[tio is 15:1. This implies, we need to h[ve [bout Visvesv[r[y[:
3,00,000 te[chers. Considering [n [ver[ge te[ching sp[n Set up [n Engineering F[culty Tr[ining Ac[demy
of [bout 30 ye[rs, we need [round 10,000 qu[lified
(EFTA), [n independent body h[ving represent[tion
te[chers opting for engineering te[ching profession, ye[r
from both Government [nd Industry.
on ye[r. Even though one c[n deb[te on these numbers,
Continued on Page 11...
2 Power Rese[rch [nd Development Consult[nts Newsletter
Highlights What is in this issue?
PAGE
Harmonization of Grid Codes, Operating
Procedures and Standards to Facilitate/ 04 Identifying Commissioning
Errors by Analysis of Tripping
Promote Cross Border Electricity Trade in Records
the South Asia Region Nitesh Kumar D & Francis C. Joseph
Subramanya Kiran
Karthik Chandra 15 Training Schedule & Forthcoming
Events
Rashmi Shekhar
Somnath Guha
Srikumar M. S.
15 MiPowerTM News
Thimmappa N.
Designed by : PRDC
Printed & Published by : Dr. R. Nagaraja on behalf of Power Research & Development Consultants Pvt. Ltd.
Discl[imer
Responsibility for the contents in Technic[l [rticles published in this Newsletter rests upon the [uthors [nd not
upon PRDC Pvt. Ltd. Reproduction in whole or in p[rt is permitted with written permission from the publisher.
2 Power Rese[rch [nd Development Consult[nts Newsletter
Identifying Commissioning Errors by Analysis of
Tripping Records
Nitesh Kumar D & Francis C Joseph
1. Introduction rel[y. Hence for the resist[nce to be neg[tive for
m[chine A with neutr[l side CT considered, the m[chine
On [ f[teful d[y, it w[s reported th[t sever[l units of [ should h[ve oper[ted in motoring mode. As observed
power pl[nt tripped on Loss of Excit[tion (LOE) from SCADA lo[ding condition, this is not the c[se.
protection. The tripping incidence occurred following [n
extern[l f[ult [nd it w[s noted th[t physic[lly no LOE This indic[tes th[t there is some connection mism[tch
occurred in [ny of the m[chines. This p[per reports between the instrument tr[nsformers *CT [nd Potenti[l
[n[lysis c[rried out using MiPowerTM*1+ softw[re, b[sed Tr[nsformer (PT)+ of the two gener[tors.
on the [v[il[ble COMTRADE *2+ files from the rel[ys th[t
triggered for the f[ult. The [n[lysis results [re presented Table 2: Operating Condition Prior to Disturbance in
for m[chine A (tripped during the disturb[nce) [nd Impedance Plane
m[chine B (rem[ined connected to the grid).
Machine A Machine B
1.1 Analysis of Pre-fault Condition (R, X) in ohm (R, X) in ohm
Determin[tion of pre-f[ult condition is necess[ry to Actual Value 1.5, 0.035 1.5, 0.022
obt[in the oper[ting condition of the equipment f[ilure.
The gener[tor lo[ding condition before the tripping Using Terminal Side Phase
1.5, 0.026 -1.51, 0.022
Current
incidence is obt[ined from Supervisory Control [nd D[t[
Acquisition (SCADA) [nd is presented in T[ble 1. Using Neutral Side Phase
-1.5,-0.0256 1.5, 0.023
Current
Feedback Received
“……..the Journal get up is really good and attractive for which you should be congratulated.”
“…….I am pleased to congratulate and compliment all those involved in bringing out such a well drafted,
colorfully typeset, highly quality oriented technical newsletter (Book by itself- like an international
Journal), especially one that is an unique one in the domain of electric power systems
and applications.”
-Dr. M.S. Raviprakasha, Vice Principal and Dean, Malnad College of Engineering, Hassan
D. Consideration of WTGs per Feeder Considering five b[ys [t pooling subst[tion, possible
connectivity schemes h[ve been worked out. Ap[rt from
The wind f[rm power ev[cu[tion system h[s been
the f[ctors mentioned in the previous section, there [re
designed such th[t it is technic[lly fe[sible &
two site specific f[ctors to be considered n[mely, the
economic[lly vi[ble to [chieve the following:
restricted forest [re[ [nd ph[se-wise turbine inst[ll[tion.
The volt[ge levels [t e[ch of the intern[l network
buses sh[ll be within the permissible limits. Depending on the number of turbines in e[ch feeder
suit[ble conductors h[ve been selected b[sed on their
Minimum power loss [t e[ch feeder.
therm[l c[p[city. In this c[se study, four combin[tions
Current flowing in e[ch section sh[ll be within the h[ve been studied using the ‘Dog’ conductor .The therm[l
permissible limit. c[p[city of Dog conductor [t v[rious [mbient [nd
The ev[cu[tion system sh[ll be s[fe & reli[ble. conductor temper[ture is presented in T[ble 1.
Wind turbine [lloc[tion per feeder depends on the
geogr[phic[l loc[tion of the wind turbines, KVA-km [nd Table 1: Transmission Line Parameters
the proximity tow[rds the pooling subst[tion. The power Sl
Description
Dog
No. ACSR
gener[ted by e[ch group would be ev[cu[ted to the
1 Voltage (in kV)
pooling subst[tion through the intern[l feeders 33
considering the optimum lo[ding of e[ch feeder up to the 2 Positive Sequence Resistance (ohm/km/circuit) 0.34121
pooling subst[tion. The [ppropri[te groups of wind
turbine gener[tors [re connected using different 3 Positive Sequence Reactance (ohm/km/circuit) 0.35358
combin[tion of conductors to [rrive [t the most techno-
economic[lly fe[sible ev[cu[tion system. 4 Positive Sequence Susceptance (B/2) (mho/km/circuit) 1.63e-006
For construction [nd design projects, Life Cycle Costing Thermal Rating (MVA) at 650 C and Ambient
6
method (LCC) is being used to m[ke decision over Temperature of 450 C at 0.55 m/sec wind speed 14
number of designs or combin[tions. Net Present V[lue Thermal Rating (MVA) at 650 C and Ambient
6
(NPV) [n[lysis is [ widely [ccepted form of LCC Temperature of 400 C at 3.3m/sec wind speed 26
ev[lu[tion. In this process, [fter fin[lizing possible Thermal Rating (MVA) at 650 C and Ambient
8 24
Temperature of 450 C at 3.3m/sec wind speed
combin[tions of tr[nsmission network, NPV for [ll the
possible combin[tions c[n be c[lcul[ted by using the
formul[:
4. Case Study
For [n[lysis, [ wind f[rm consisting of 33 Nos. of wind
turbine gener[tors e[ch r[ted 2.1MW h[s been
considered. Out of the 33 WTGs, 15 WTGs [re under
commissioning (Ph[se-1) which [re loc[ted in priv[te l[nd
[nd the rem[ining 18 WTGs (Ph[se-2) [re loc[ted in
restricted forest [re[ th[t would be fin[lized [fter getting
[pprov[l from the relev[nt [uthority. It is m[nd[tory to
get [pprov[l before st[rting the work in restricted forest
[re[. Figure 1 shows the loc[tion m[p of WTGs with l[nd
elev[tion [nd forest [re[. In the figure, the pooling
subst[tion is represented in red circle. The WTGs
Figure 1: WTG Map Location with Land Elevation
considered in Ph[se-1 [re brown circle [nd the WTGs
Combination-2 1361
Combination-3 1363
Combination-4 1406
where,
Cost of Energy Loss Per Year: As per the prev[iling t[riff for
energy in the Region under study
Figure 5: Net Present Value
Peak Power Loss : Pe[k line losses in KW obt[ined from Lo[d
6. Conclusions Flow Simul[tion results
By using the gr[ph optimiz[tion method, the gener[l Total Energy Loss (kWh)/ year: Pe[k power loss* tot[l no of
design f[ctors [s well [s site specific f[ctors h[ve been hours in Ye[r * Loss lo[d f[ctor (LLF)
[ddressed [nd four possible combin[tions h[ve been
worked out for [ sm[ll [nd medium sized wind f[rm
B. Loss Load Factor
power ev[cu[tion scheme. Among the four combin[tions,
combin[tion-2 is the le[st cost option [s comp[red to LLF= k * LF + (1-k)*LF2
others. However, it h[s to be noted th[t though the
combin[tions 1 & 4 [re costlier th[n combin[tion-2, it h[s where,
the [dv[nt[ge of crossing the restricted forest [re[ [t LF-Lo[d f[ctor
only one point. Considering the leg[l procedure involved
k- is [ const[nt typic[lly
in getting [pprov[l from the st[tutory [uthorities
for Right-Of-W[y, [n [ppropri[te combin[tion c[n be 0.3 in sub tr[nsmission network
selected by the Developers/Investors. 0.2 for medium volt[ge feeders [nd distribution subst[tions
Electricite du L[os (EDL) is undert[king Power Grid PRDC, Beng[luru [long with other technic[l p[rtners
Improvement (PGI) Project through fin[ncing support from were [w[rded this prestigious consult[ncy for the first
the World B[nk. The project involves reh[bilit[ting the component. This p[rt is expected to introduce [dv[nced
electric distribution network, introducing distribution metering infr[structure (AMI) technology [nd digit[l
[utom[tion, [dv[nced metering system [nd rel[ted meters in the project [re[. In [ddition, it will help improve
[ctivities in the X[yth[ny District of L[os c[pit[l reli[bility of power supply [nd reduce losses in selected
Vienti[ne. The m[in objective of the PGI Project is to p[rts of the distribution network through strengthening
help improve efficiency [nd reli[bility of power of power distribution infr[structure [nd distribution
distribution in the selected lo[d [re[s served by EDL. The [utom[tion. This component is expected to include
m[in components of proposed project include: reh[bilit[ting power distribution lines, upgr[ding of
conductors, incre[sing tr[nsformer c[p[city, pl[cement of
A. Sm[rt metering, distribution improvement [nd c[p[citors for re[ctive power [nd volt[ge control,
distribution loss reduction inst[ll[tion of lo[d bre[k switches [nd reclosers, etc. The
B. Electric utility inform[tion system [nd upgr[ding of conductors involves the reh[bilit[tion of [n
estim[ted 366 km of distribution power lines, including
C. Institution[l c[p[city building [nd project 126 km of medium volt[ge (22kV) power lines.
implement[tion support
PRDC Installs 100 kW Roof Top Solar Power Plant for GM Inc.
PRDC h[s commissioned [ 100 kW rooftop Sol[r PV Power pl[nt in the premises of GM Inc., in Som[n[h[lli Industri[l
Are[, M[ddur, M[ndy[ district, K[rn[t[k[ on 16th September 2016.
GM Inc., [ le[ding comp[ny in K[rn[t[k[ w[nted to le[d the w[y in embr[cing renew[ble energy by implementing [ sol[r
power pl[nt to power their m[nuf[cturing f[cility [nd [lso sell the excess power to Ch[mundeshw[ri Electricity Supply
Comp[ny (CESC), Mysore.
PRDC undertook the det[iled engineering [nd evolved [ customized solution, which focused on efficiently optimizing
[v[il[ble rooftop sp[ce [nd the existing electric[l network within the premises. Also, PRDC m[n[ged the implement[tion
of the project for the client [nd ensured its commissioning within 2 months of the ‚go [he[d‛ including obt[ining of [ll the
st[tutory cle[r[nces. The rooftop system design h[s s[ved the l[nd sp[ce [nd p[ved the w[y to use unutilized roof [nd
e[rn revenue of more th[n Rs.12 l[khs per [nnum. The client, M/s GM Inc. will be [ble to recover the investment in the
project in [bout 6 ye[rs where[s the project h[s [n economic life of 25 ye[rs.
Indian Power Sector Highlights
15.45cr LED Bulbs Distributed being developed through Regul[ted T[riff Mech[nism [s
well [s T[riff B[sed Competitive Bidding (TBCB) route.
The Unnat Jyoti by Afford[ble LEDs for All (UJALA) TARANG sh[ll [lso include st[tus of st[lled/del[yed
progr[m of Government of Indi[ h[s been widely [ccepted tr[nsmission systems in country which would en[ble the
[cross rur[l [nd urb[n [re[s of the country [nd so f[r over st[keholders viz. Ministry of Power, St[te Governments, [ll
15.45cr of LED bulbs h[ve [lre[dy been distributed under priv[te sector tr[nsmission developers [nd PSUs like
this progr[m. Over 5.15cr Indi[n households h[ve Power Grid Corpor[tion of Indi[ Ltd., for expeditious
benefitted from this progr[m [nd h[ve m[de their homes completion of such projects. TARANG website
brighter. The scheme is presently oper[tion[l in 18 st[tes http://www.tarang.website/
[nd 4 Union Territories. Government of Indi[ is committed
to [chieving its t[rget of repl[cing [ll the 66cr of inefficient DEEP (Discovery of Efficient Electricity Price) e-Bidding’
bulbs in Indi[ with LEDs. This will result in reduction of port[l for medium term (1-5 ye[rs) purch[se of power.
20,000 MW lo[d, energy s[vings of 100 billion kWh [nd The Port[l will provide [ common e-bidding pl[tform with
Green House G[s (GHG) reduction of 80 million tonnes e-reverse [uction f[cility to f[cilit[te n[tion-wide power
every ye[r. procurement through [ wider network so [s to bring
uniformity [nd tr[nsp[rency in the process of power
Source: pib.nic.in procurement. With the introduction of e-Bidding [nd e-
reverse [uction process for medium term (1-5 ye[rs), the
Prices of LED Bulbs Drop to Rs.38 time sp[n of the complete bidding process [nd the cost of
procurement of power is expected to be reduced
subst[nti[lly, thereby signific[ntly benefiting the ultim[te
NEW DELHI: Prices of LED bulbs being distributed by the
consumers.
st[te-run Energy Efficient Services Ltd (EESL) under [
government progr[mme h[ve f[llen to one-tenth of their
Source: pib.nic.in
r[tes two ye[rs [go. A senior government offici[l s[id EESL
h[s received bids [t Rs.38 for [ 7W LED l[mp. Fourteen
comp[nies p[rticip[ted in the tender opened l[st week for Wind Solar Hybrid Policy
procuring 5Cr LED bulbs. Prices of LEDs procured by EESL
under the Unn[t Jyoti by Afford[ble LEDs for All (UJALA) The Government of Indi[ h[s formul[ted [ dr[ft N[tion[l
scheme h[ve been consistently f[lling. The comp[ny h[d in Wind-Sol[r Hybrid Policy with the objective to provide [
M[rch received bids [t Rs.55 per piece. The comp[ny h[d fr[mework for promotion of l[rge grid connected wind-
purch[sed the LEDs [t Rs.310 in 2014. LED bulbs [re sol[r PV system for optim[l [nd efficient utiliz[tion of
[v[il[ble in the m[rket [t Rs.70~100 [piece. tr[nsmission infr[structure [nd l[nd thus reducing the
v[ri[bility in renew[ble power gener[tion [nd [chieving
Source: Economic Times, 15th September 2016 better grid st[bility. Further, the Policy [ims to encour[ge
new technologies, methods [nd w[y-outs involving
combined oper[tion of wind [nd sol[r PV pl[nts.
New Apps Released Source: pib.nic.in
Level 1 Level 2
MiPower Client Training: A comprehensive Power MiPower Client Training: A custom m[de tutori[l
System tutori[l with h[nds-on session, using on for c[ndid[tes, with focus on the power system
MiPower, b[sed on pr[ctic[l scen[rio. issues f[ced by them.
The week long course includes modules such [s This course h[s h[nds on sessions on the
Lo[d Flow, F[ult An[lysis, Tr[nsient St[bility c[ndid[te’s network.
[nd Protection.
Note: Interested p[rticip[nts [re requested to [pply for the tr[ining [s per their requirements i.e. Level 1 [nd Level 2
MiPower™ News
Advanced Features in Protection (Version 7.1)
Dist[nce rel[y modeling for Composite tr[nsmission lines.
Dist[nce rel[y setting comput[tion for series compens[ted lines.
Ability to simul[te mutu[l coupling effect in the presence of dist[nce
rel[ys.
Ph[se loop [nd e[rth loop ch[r[cteristic modeling for dist[nce rel[ys.
COMTRADE file [n[lysis.
Printed at: M/s. Art Print. 719/A, Dr. Modi Main, W.O.C. Road Mahalakshmipuram, Bangalore - 560086.
PRDC
Printed at: M/s. Art Prin 719/A, Dr. Modi Main, W.O.C. Road Mahalakshmipuram, Bangalore - 560086.
Clientele