Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Running Head: Sexual Health Education For College Freshman 1
Running Head: Sexual Health Education For College Freshman 1
Kayla A. McKean
June 2019
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 2
Abstract
According to the Center for Disease Control (CDC, 2017) youth between the ages of 15 and 24
make up half of all new sexually transmitted infection cases, and youth 18 to 19 have the highest
rates of unplanned pregnancies. The researcher seeks to study the effect Vision of You (a self-
paced online sexual health program developed at James Madison University) could have on
college freshmen’s attitude and intended use of safer sex practices as well as perceived
usefulness of online learning. The proposed research uses the Theory of Reasoned Action to
develop appropriate methodology for determining participants’ attitudes and intended behaviors
in regards to their sexual health. The researcher proposes using a mixed method approach to
gauge participant attitude and perception with an expected sample size of around 200
participants.
Keywords: sexual health education, college freshman, online learning, intended behavior
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 3
Introduction
There is a need to evaluate the effectiveness of the Vison of You program with college
freshman who remain at a high risk of STI contraction as well as unplanned pregnancy. Research
has not been previously conducted on Vison of You with college freshman participants. This
new research would provide the team with a broader understanding of the program’s
effectiveness across the stage of adolescence. The researcher currently works as a data specialist
on the Personal Responsibility Education Innovative Strategies (PREIS) grant funded through
the Family and Youth Services Bureau, Adolescent Pregnancy Prevention Division. The PREIS
grant was awarded to the Teen Pregnancy Prevention (TPP) program housed at the Institute in
Innovation in Health and Human Services (IIHHS) at James Madison University (JMU) in 2015.
TPP focuses on sexual health education in the city of Harrisonburg, Rockingham and Page
Counties, but was awarded the PREIS grant to work with participants across the state of
Virginia. The researcher, as part of the PREIS team, has several years of experience teaching
sexuality education courses in middle school and high school before their transition into data
collection and evaluation. Through a randomized control trial design the PREIS team is
researching the effectiveness of the online sexuality education program, Vision of You. Study
participants include students in alternative education programs, juvenile detention centers, and
students referred to community services boards. These populations were chosen due to the lack
According to the Center for Disease Control (CDC, 2017) people between the age of 15
and 24 make up half of all new sexually transmitted infection (STI) cases in the United States
each year. This could be due to a lack of education around using protection (like condoms), how
STIs are contracted, and how often or where to go to get tested. The state of Virginia currently
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 4
only funds abstinence only education with which the main focus is to stress not engaging in any
type of sex including oral, anal, or vaginal sex. In abstinence only education if methods of
protection like condoms or birth control are incorporated into the curriculum – it is often only to
stress their failure rates. Upcoming college freshman may not have had exposure to sexual health
education in their high schools. This is especially concerning considering the risk of contracting
an STI for young people. The average age for an unplanned pregnancy to occur is also between
the age of 18 and 19 (CDC, 2017) making this post high school age group especially vulnerable.
The online sexual health program, Vision of You, was designed at James Madison
University for high school aged youth with the goals of reducing the frequency of sexual activity,
reducing the number of sexual partners, and increasing contraceptive use among participants. As
upcoming freshman are similar in age and experiencing similar risk factors to high school
students, the researcher proposes studying 1) if the Vision of You program could be effective in
increasing intended safer sex practices among college students as well as 2) understand college
students’ perception of usefulness of the online program compared to sexual health education
they received before arriving to college. This focus was defined not only by examining the risk
of the age group, but also considering what sexual health resources look like for college students.
entering college are often required to complete trainings or modules on substance abuse
awareness, but are not required to take sexual health education courses. Those courses may be
offered to students as electives, but they are not a requirement. According to research done by
Lechner, Garcia, Frerich, Lust, and Eisenberg (2013) when asked about who’s responsibility it
was to ensure access to sexual health resources college students believed that their school had the
whether or not they used the resources. Providing sexual health as an elective may not be
accessible for students who have a rigid course structure or who need to choose electives more
closely related to their major. Another study by Franklin and Dotger (2011) found that college
seniors tested significantly higher than college freshman on birth control, sexual relations, and
reproduction knowledge even though there was no specific effort to educate students in these
areas over their four years. If more research existed about what students already know about
sexual health as they enter as freshman, it may help guide colleges on what education should be
provided by the college and also how it should be delivered to the students.
Intervention
The Vision of You program includes gamified learning elements like avatars, a point
system, goals, and trophies. It also utilizes videos, games, and interactive activities for learning.
Vision of You consists of nine online modules that students can complete at their own pace.
While its effectiveness is still being tested, other similar intervention strategies have shown
positive outcomes for youth. Through a scope review of digital intervention (defined as programs
that provide sexual health information) for sexual health Mann and Bailey (2015) found that
online programs not only reached people who were less likely to engage with mainstream
services, but they allowed participants to access information when it was convenient to them.
Getting access to sexual health resources can be difficult for students who are in classes during
regular clinic hours. Many college freshman rely on public transportation which may or may not
get them to or from a clinic and their classes on time. If they have chosen to take an elective on
sexual health, they will likely have a better knowledge than their peers who are not in the
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 6
elective, but may still lack a space or opportunity to ask more personalized questions about their
own health.
Another study by Jackson, Ingram, Boyer, Robillard, and Hunhs (2016) developed an
online app to decrease sexual risk behaviors among young college students. While they did not
find a significant change in student’s intention to reduce sexual risk behaviors, students did have
Scull, Malik, Kupersmidt & Keefe (2018) evaluated “Media Aware” a self-paced, on demand,
multimedia, web based curriculum for 18 and 19 year olds. As compared to the control group,
the intervention group in this study reported higher levels of using dental dams and
communicating about sex as well as higher levels of using protection for oral sex. Participants in
the intervention group developed skills for deconstructing media by exploring gender
stereotypes, comparing the media norm to the social norm, searching for the missing messages in
media, and comparing the effectiveness of birth control and condoms that is reported in media
versus what is medically accurate. Results showed that instances of oral, vaginal, and anal sex
were fewer in intervention participants as well as instances of sex under the influence of drugs or
alcohol. Acceptance of rape and rape myths was also lower for students in the intervention group
In a study done by McGinn and Arnedillo- Sánchez (2015) a virtual learning environment
was used to support communication between teachers and students. A four week study included
3 teachers and 28 students in a curriculum covering friendship qualities, self-esteem, and sexual
behavior. Activities were designed to prompt discussions and included quizzes, videos, podcasts
and fact sheets. Students could engage with peers and their teacher anonymously, or not, through
email, chat, or discussion boards. The majority of the students stated that they felt less
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 7
embarrassed to ask questions and engage with the material in the class. McGinn and Arnedillo-
Sánchez (2015) noted increased attention that they attributed to the novelty of an online course
for students or just the familiarity of using applications similar to those that students already
used. Again, the anonymity of the application put the user more at ease which made them feel
more comfortable to engage with the sensitive subject matter. An evaluation of the HEART
(Health Education and Relationship Training) curriculum with 10th grade females showed that
after engaging with 5 modules on safer sex motivation, HIV and other STIs, sexual norms and
attitudes, safer sex self-efficacy, and sexual communication skills participants in the intervention
group showed better assertiveness skills and knowledge of HIV/STIs than that of their peers in
the control group. The online program ensured that each student was receiving the same
information and they each had the opportunity to practice communication skills. Through the
online program students who may have felt too shy or embarrassed to practice communication
with a partner were given the opportunity to practice without the pressure of a watching
audience.
performance,” (Subhash & Cudney, 2018, p. 205). Promoting competition and fun through
games encouraged students to continue learning more material and moving forward.
Furthermore, online sexual health curriculums ensure fidelity of the content delivered to
students, they are easier to update with current medical findings, and they offer more
opportunities for user interactivity (Widman, Golin, Kamke, Burnette, Prinstein, 2018).
According to a special report by Lieberman (2018) it is difficult for the field of sexual
health education to randomly assign or conduct research of one program against another, but
rather programs are typically evaluated against a nonintervention group. A study that did manage
sexual health used a mixed method research approach by pre-testing and post-testing students’
knowledge using the Adolescent Sexual Health Literacy Test (ASHLT), following up with
focus group (Haruna, Hu, Chu, Mellecker, Gabriel, Ndekao, 2018). Participants were selected
from a secondary school in Tanzania and divided into groups of 40. The researchers used IBM
SPSS Statistics to analyze quantitative data from the MAKE and ASHLT tests. More than one
study around sexual health used anonymous online surveys to gather data about participants’
sexual behaviors (Yadlosky, Aubin, Mosack, & Devine, 2017; Wyatt & Oswalt, 2014).
Researchers in both studies recruited students through university email and used online surveys
that asked students to identify demographics and listed specific sexual behaviors for students to
indicate if they had engaged in or not. Tingey, et al (2015) developed a questionnaire that asked
participants to identify what behaviors they had engaged in or planned to engage in in the future.
This tool aligns well with the Theory of Reasoned Action (or Planned Behavior) that is referred
to often in sexual health education design and research. One study that focused more closely on
the effective use of e-learning for university students, rather than just sexual behavior, used a
mix of items from scales developed by Martin and Kellermann (2004) and Saade and Bahli
(2005) to craft a scale that would gauge perception. Due to a small sample size the researchers
used structural equation modeling to analyze their data (Moreno, Cavazotte & Alves, 2017).
Theoretical Contributions
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 9
Activity Theory was used by the researchers Haruna et al. (2018) as a framework to
(stakeholders), division of labor (roles of stakeholders), rules (norms and guidelines), outcomes
(change in sexual behavior), and subjects (school students). They used Activity Theory to engage
their community in their research and to inform their future practice. Researchers Jackson et al.
(2016) used constructs and concepts from the Theory of Reasoned Action as well as the Trans-
Theoretical Model of Behavior Change in the creation of their app. They included things like
comparison statistics on peer norms and attitudes, subjective norms for condom and
contraceptive use, and skill building exercises as part of their intervention to align with their
theoretical framework. The Theory of Reasoned Action is popular in the field of sexual health. It
suggests that “an individual’s intention to perform a specific behavior is a linear function of his
or her affective response to performing the behavior (attitudes) and perceived social norms about
the behavior,” (Baker, Morrison, Carter, & Verdon, 1996, 529). This can be a helpful model in
assessing whether or not youth will be more or less likely to engage in risky sexual behavior
Using the Theory of Reasoned Action, Wulfert and Wan (1995) asked research
participants to indicate how they felt using a condom every time they engaged in sex from
extremely favorable to extremely unfavorable on a seven point Likert scale. They also asked
participants to answer the same question, but from a social norms perspective. They found that
condom use attitude was closely linked intention to use condoms. Muñoz-Silva, Sánchez-García,
Nunes, & Martins (2007) studied condom use prediction differences in gender using the Theory
of Reasoned Action and Planned Behaviour theory. Similarly, to Wulfert and Wan, they asked
participants to indicate their attitude toward condom use as well as perceived social norms of
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 10
condom use using a Likert scale. They found that male participants intended use of condoms was
aligned with their attitude toward perceived social norms, while females showed a closer relation
to intended behavior based on their own attitudes toward condom use (Muñoz-Silva, Sánchez-
The researcher proposes conducting research with college freshman in the Harrisonburg,
VA area. The researcher is an employee of James Madison University with strong relationships
to faculty, staff, and students that will assist in facilitating the study. They propose forming
partnerships with local colleges and universities in the area as well to increase sample size. The
area surrounding James Madison University is also home to Eastern Mennonite University,
Bridgewater College, and Blue Ridge Community College where the desired age group of study
participants are enrolled. In 2019, JMU received 24,449 applications for undergraduate freshman
and accepted 73% of those (James Madison University, 2019). The researcher would not have
the capacity to attempt to recruit all incoming freshman, but a large freshman class provides an
opportunity to reach an appropriate sample size for this research. More research will need to be
done to determine the size of incoming freshman classes at the colleges surrounding JMU.
Participants will be recruited based on their age and year in higher education. Freshman
students are early in their academic career and should be less impacted by sexual health
information they may obtain through their college courses. This will give the researcher a better
idea of participants’ base knowledge coming from high school. Participants will need to be
between the age of 18 and 19, so that they can consent for themselves without reaching out to a
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 11
parent or guardian to obtain consent. Approval will be sought for recruiting students via email
A mixed method approach will be used in this research study to gather data from
participants about their attitude toward safer sex practices and well as their perceived usefulness
of the online sexual health program, Vision of You, compared to what they received in high
school. Pre and post questionnaires will be used to determine participants intended behavior and
attitude toward safer sex practices as well as their perceived usefulness of online learning before
the intervention and after. Questionnaires will be created in Qualtrics, an online survey
management company, which is available to JMU faculty and students. The researcher will be
able to send questionnaire links to participants via email. Qualtrics also provides tools for
analyzing survey data which can be used by the researcher after data collection is complete.
As noted in the literature review findings, the Theory of Reasoned Action is commonly
used in sexual health education and indicates that intended behavior is associated with attitudes
toward that behavior. Figure 1 shows an example of questionnaire items using the Theory of
Planned Behavior to assess college students’ intentions to stay in their courses (Deberry &
Jackson, 2018). While these exact items will not be used, their grouping of items which includes
attitudes, self-efficacy, norms, and intention will be used to create appropriate items for
Figure 1. Theory of Planned Behavior Questionnaire items and categories. This example
The researcher will use Likert Scale questions to assess the attitude the participant has
toward safer sex practices like abstaining from sex, using a condom, getting tested for STIs,
using hormonal birth control, and limiting their number of sexual partners. Participants will then
be asked about which of the safer sex behaviors they intend to practice if the opportunity to
engage in sexual activity arises. These questionnaires will be confidential and matched through
share their sexual behaviors or obligated to say they will adhere to social norms. Participants will
be given similar questions in style to gauge their perceived usefulness of taking the online sexual
health education course. These questions will provide quantitative data for the researcher. Open
ended responses will allow participants to indicate what they felt was most helpful to their
decision making in sexual health as well as what was most and least relevant to them in the
online program. This will provide qualitative data for the researcher that should give a clearer
perspective of the participants’ experience and capture any missing information not obtained
This research will comply with James Madison University’s IRB protocol. Consent will
be collected from study participants before any data is collected. Only the most necessary
participant identifying information will be collected and used by the researcher. Information will
be used to contact the study participants about their completion of the intervention and
questionnaires. Identifying information will not be stored along with questionnaire responses. All
needed participant info will be kept protected on a JMU owned and encrypted computer.
Participant information and consent will only be kept on file by the researcher for as long as IRB
This research will be important to the Teen Pregnancy Prevention program at IIHHS at
JMU. Teen pregnancy rates are highest among youth between the age of 18 and 19 (CDC, 2017).
For this reason, it is important that sexual health education be implemented with youth not only
at the age of puberty, but throughout their adolescence which extends into their college years.
Despite the name, TPP is concerned with all aspects of sexual health education including STIs,
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 14
sexual orientation, and healthy relationships as they all contribute to an individual’s overall
health. Vision of You covers all of these topics. TPP will be interested in data from this research
as it will highlight the need for further sexual health education for youth.
James Madison University may be interested in this data to further their understanding of
the health care needs and educational needs of incoming freshman. This data could help plan for
prevention services that would lower sexually transmitted infection rates as well as provide
resources to students about the range of other topics covered in Vision of You.
While this research will help to meet a program requirement of the Masters in Education
Technology at JMU for the researcher, it will also contribute to the understanding of online
learning for college students. The Vison of You curriculum incorporates gamification through
the use of avatars, a point system, and trophies. It also includes videos, games, and interactive
activities to engage learners. These elements are of interest to Ed Tech professionals as they
study and design curriculum to engage learners through effective and meaningful technologies.
Technology should not be incorporated into learning just for the sake of having it, but rather
applied research will be data on student perceptions of effectiveness of the online learning
Finally, this research will contribute to the professional development as well as the
graduate level learning for the researcher. This research experience will lay the groundwork for
developing further research initiatives in their professional setting. The ability to conduct
research can lead to more grant funding opportunities that will allow staff to increase their
Limitations
A limitation of the research conducted so far in this proposal is that there is not much
research about sexual health curriculums that look like Vision of You. Though the program may
not look the same as other available and tested programs, the material is the same and uses
elements of similar theories like the Theory of Reasoned Action. Another limitation of this paper
is that it does not provide an overview of what sexual health resources are required and available
to students in college in the state of Virginia currently. This could provide a greater
understanding of the need for education. Overall, research conducted so far will help inform
professionals about the need for research in sexual health education for young college students. It
will help to inform future research on the effectiveness of the sexual health program, Vision of
You.
Envisioned limitations of this study include a small sample size as well as the likelihood
that the sample will be homogenous. University campuses tend to be predominantly white and
female which is not presentative of all college freshman. Another limitation is the scope of this
study will not allow for longitudinal data to be collected. That data would allow the researcher to
understand the impact of receiving sexual health education on a person’s behavior over a longer
Planned dissemination
federal grant in 2015 called the Personal Responsibility in Education Innovative Strategies
(PREIS) to further develop and study the effectiveness of the existing Vision of You curriculum.
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 16
Programs that receive state and federal funding for sexual health education are required to
choose from a list of evidenced based curriculums to then implement with their youth. Programs
that receive this funding cannot chose to implement a sexual health curriculum that is not
evidenced based and still receive their funding. The overall goal of this project from the
perspective of TPP is to study the effectiveness of Vision of You and then be able to offer the
program as an evidenced based curriculum. In addition to the data being collected by the TPP
team, the researcher hopes to provide data from a new demographic of youth completing the
Vision of You curriculum. The researcher will offer findings from this study to accompany
findings gathered from the TPP team as it will provide a broad view of the Vision of You
curriculum and its impact on youth in Virginia. Study findings and methods may be presented by
the researcher alongside the TPP data to the Family and Youth Services Bureau.
The researcher will also present findings at the Youth Tech Health conference held
annually in San Francisco, CA that focuses on technologies used to teach sexuality and mental
health practices to young people. The researcher will present at the annual National Sex Ed
Conference held annually in New Jersey that focuses on sex education for all ages and
demographics. The researcher has presented at both of these conferences in previous years and
will have the opportunity to update a captive audience about the findings related to the Vision of
You curriculum. This research may also be presented at higher education conferences as it could
provide insight into the need for sexual health education for college students.
Work plan
comp reviews this research project will take place over the course of the spring 2020 semester.
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 17
The Collaborative Institutional Training Initiative (CITI) training for human subject research has
already been completed by the researcher and will not expire until February of 2021. The
researcher will allow a month of time to complete and submit the research protocol application to
the James Madison University Institutional Review Board (IRB) and an additional two weeks for
needed changes requested by the IRB. Once approved by the IRB, study participants will be
recruited within the first four weeks of the spring 2020 semester. During this time they will be
asked to consent to the study and take the baseline questionnaire. Participants will then be given
four weeks to engage with the intervention. Survey data will be collected for two weeks after the
intervention time has ended. Data analysis will occur within the remaining four weeks of the
spring semester.
The researcher will use a James Madison University owned computer with an encrypted hard
drive. The Vision of You program is owned and managed by James Madison University and the
TPP faculty. Data will be tracked and analyzed using resources available to JMU students and
faculty.
Acknowledgement
While this project will not receive explicit funding, it does have administrative support
from the Teen Pregnancy Prevention program at the Institute in Innovation in Health and Human
Services at JMU.
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 18
References
Baker, S.A., Morrison, D.M., Carter, W.B., & Verdon, M.S. (1996). Using the theory of
reasoned action (TRA) to understand the decision to use condoms in an STD clinic
CDC, (2017, December 7). Adolescents and young adults, prevention, stds. Retrieved June 1,
Dewberry, C., & Jackson, D. J. R. (2018). Theory of planned behavior on student retention in
https://dx.doi.org/10.1037/t68288-000
Franklin, R. M., & Dotger, S. (2011). Sex education knowledge differences between freshmen
Haruna, H., Hu, X., Chu, S.K.W., Mellecker, R.R., Gabriel, G., & Ndekao, P.S. (2018).
Improving sexual health education programs for adolescent students through game-based
Jackson, D. D., Ingram, L. A., Boyer, C. B., Robillard, A., & Huhns, M. N. (2016). Can
technology decrease sexual risk behaviors among young people? Results of a pilot study
James Madison University (2019). Facts & figures. Retrieved May 14, 2019 from
https://www.jmu.edu/about/fact-and-figures.shtml
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 19
Lechner, K. E., Garcia, C. M., Frerich, E. A., Lust, K., & Eisenberg, M. E. (2013). College
Lieberman, L. (2018). Sex ed in the u.s.—a look back (and ahead). (2018). Perspectives on
Mann, S., & Bailey, J.V. (2015). Implementation of digital interventions for sexual health for
young people. In 2nd Behaviour Change Conference: Digital Health and Wellbeing,
Martins, L. L., & Kellermanns, F. W. (2004). A model of business school students’ acceptance
Education, 3, 7–26.
and sexuality education through a VLE. International Association for Development of the
Moreno, V., Cavazotte, F., & Alves, I. (2017). Explaining university students- effective use of e-
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/bjet.12469
Saade, R., & Bahli, B. (2005). The impact of cognitive absorption on perceived usefulness and
Scull, T. M., Kupersmidt, J. B., Malik, C. V., & Keefe, E. M. (2018). Examining the efficacy of
an mHealth media literacy education program for sexual health promotion in older
SEXUAL EDUCATION FOR COLLEGE FRESHMAN 20
165–177.
Tingey, L., Mullany, B., Chambers, R., Hastings, R., Lee, A., Parker, A., Barlow, A., &
Widman, L., Golin, C. E., Kamke, K., Burnette, J. L., & Prinstein, M. J. (2018). Sexual
controlled trial of an online program. American Journal of Public Health, 108(1), 96–
102. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2017.304106
Wulfert, E. & Wan, C.K., (1995). Safer Sex Intentions and Condom Use Viewed from a Health
Belief, Reasoned Action, and Social Cognitive Perspective. The Journal of Sex Research,
32(4), 299-311.
Wyatt, T., & Oswalt, S. (2014). Sexual behaviors of college freshmen and the need for
Yadlosky, L.B., Aubin, E.S., Mosack, K.E., & Devine, J.B. (2017). Sexual perceptions versus
https://doi.org/10.1353/csd.2017.0055