Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Management of Acute Bronchitis in Children: Review
The Management of Acute Bronchitis in Children: Review
The Management of Acute Bronchitis in Children: Review
2. Diagnosis
Acute bronchitis is one of the most common infections reported in children
3. Epidemiology under 5 years of age, and is a leading cause of hospitalisation. In general prac-
4. Pathogenesis tice, confusion surrounds the clinical diagnosis of acute bronchitis, especially
5. Disease management when distinguishing it from asthma. The microbiological causes are mostly
known, but the contribution of each is much less clear, and they are non-spe-
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
6. Organism-specific treatment
cific in their clinical expression in individual cases. Viral pathogens, particularly
7. Disease prevention
respiratory syncytial virus and rhinoviruses are cited as the leading agents in
8. Expert opinion the development of serious episodes, but other pathogens may also be impor-
tant. This article covers a range of issues surrounding acute bronchitis, includ-
ing epidemiology and pathogenesis, as well as the management, prevention
and treatment of disease in children.
Keywords: acute bronchitis, children, cough, respiratory syncytial virus, rhinovirus, wheeze
1. Introduction
For some, such as Bordetella pertussis, the overwhelming focus International Classification of Diseases volume 9 (ICD9) classi-
on a particular region of the respiratory tract (in this case the fies acute bronchitis as an acute respiratory infection specifying
larynx) completely dominates issues surrounding management. neither the lower nor the upper respiratory tract. In ICD9,
Other pathogens, for example respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), acute bronchitis is classified in the same three-digit category as
are known to cause extensive damage to the lining of the entire acute bronchiolitis, although these two conditions are more
respiratory tract, although the clinical significance of damage to clearly separated in ICD10. Acute bronchitis is specified sepa-
the lower airways in infants considerably outweighs its rately from COPD and from asthma, but general practitioners
significance as a cause of upper airways infection. often report the diagnosis ‘bronchitis not otherwise specified’
The adjective ‘acute’ differentiates bronchitis from a (ICD9 490), that is grouped together with COPD. It is unwise
chronic condition, and in this context, implies a condition to consider statistical data on exacerbations of asthma separately
from which complete recovery is to be expected, at least in the from acute bronchitis. Most exacerbations of asthma in young
majority of cases. However, it is not uncommon for children children occur as a result of viral respiratory infections [10].
to experience frequently recurring episodes of respiratory tract Clinically, it is not always possible to distinguish an attack of
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
infection, and these call for special consideration. For practi- asthma from an infection labelled as acute bronchitis. Indeed, it
cal purposes, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is common for a diagnosis of asthma to be made as a result of
is not a numerically important problem in children, although apparently frequent attacks of acute bronchitis in which wheez-
the potential for recurring acute infections giving rise to irre- ing is prominent. In the Oxford Textbook of Medicine, acute
versible damage must not be overlooked. RSV in particular bronchitis is classified as a lower respiratory tract infection,
has long been incriminated as a determinant of asthma, an opinion that has been accepted for the purpose of this
although the available evidence is conflicting [6-9]. This issue article [15]. As a precaution, when considering published mate-
was reviewed by Message and Johnston [10]: as compared with rial on respiratory infections that purport to distinguish upper
controls, wheezing at ages 3 and 6, but not by 11 years, was and lower respiratory tracts, it is important to be clear in which
more likely in hospitalised children, because of RSV infection category acute bronchitis is placed.
in infancy. However, it is not clear whether the association is There is no satisfactory clinical distinction between asthma
For personal use only.
causal, or is found because of selection bias for hospitalisation. and acute bronchitis when it first appears. Although the pres-
In a comparison of the impact of influenza and RSV on respi- ence of wheeze, particularly if found consistently during epi-
ratory diagnoses made in primary care, exacerbations of sodes of respiratory infection, does provide a clue to the
asthma occur during periods of RSV activity much more fre- likelihood of asthma, its absence does not deny this possibil-
quently than in periods of influenza virus activity [11]. Our ity. Wheeze may be present at the time of clinical assessment,
understanding of the link between recurring viral infections and may be a feature of the presenting history, but equally, it
and long-term respiratory disease is limited by the quality of may not be present at all. Persistent nocturnal cough is con-
virological investigation and the limited numbers of infected sidered a hallmark symptom of asthma even though it is often
children who are investigated. In epidemiological studies reported in the absence of wheeze.
undertaken during the last 15 years, there has been increasing A number of conditions cause airways obstruction at the
recognition of the role of respiratory viruses as a cause of larynx, and it is important to recognise these promptly. Epi-
asthma exacerbations [12,13]. glottitis is a particularly dangerous condition because of the
Despite these comments on the relative infrequency of rapidity with which patients deteriorate and may die. This is
chronic respiratory disease in young children, it is essential to rec- usually caused by Haemophilus influenzae, and prompt treat-
ognise those children presenting with recurring acute respiratory ment in intensive care facilities is needed [16]. Other causes of
infections who have pre-existing respiratory disease that has not laryngospasm include croup (commonly associated with
always been diagnosed prior to presentation. In this regard, parainfluenza infection) and whooping cough. In the latter
pre-existing lung diseases, such as cystic fibrosis, congenital cardi- case, laryngeal stridor usually appears some days after onset. It
opulmonary malformations, situs inversus and tracheo-oesopha- is particularly important to make this diagnosis in infants, as
geal fistula must be considered when infants and preschool the effects of recurring laryngeal stridor can be serious.
children present. Prematurity presents its own set of problems, In hospital-based emergency rooms, oximetry and chest
and is particularly known to predispose children to serious infec- X-rays assist in making management decisions. Assessment of
tions caused by RSV [14]. Issues relating to the management of expiratory peak flow may also assist in older children, but with-
premature infants are not considered in this paper. out a record of comparative readings from previous occasions,
the value of first time measurement in a child may be seriously
2. Diagnosis limited. Although the identification of the causative pathogen is
important both for surveillance and in cases in which the infec-
The diagnostic term ‘acute bronchitis’ is not used consistently, tion is persistent, this exercise is less useful in the acute phase of
which causes confusion when considering the results of research the illness as most management decisions have to be made
on various aspects of this condition. There is first a distinction promptly before the results of such tests are available. The
between upper and lower respiratory disorder. The expansion of investigation using PCR techniques and near
patient tests may eventually lead to more widespread respiratory tract infections (8 or more episodes per year in chil-
investigations, even in the acute phase of the illness. dren < 3 years, and 6 or more episodes in older children), and
found causative pathogens in 199 cases, of which 58 were Myc-
3. Epidemiology oplasma pneumoniae and 16 were Chlamydia pneumoniae [5].
Interestingly, the symptoms in both instances embraced both
The incidence of acute bronchitis has been recorded by gen- upper and lower respiratory tracts (although for M. pneumo-
eral practitioners reporting to the WRS for 35 years. During niae, there was increased emphasis on the lower tract
this period, incidence in children 0 – 4 years of age has symptoms). Wangroongsarb et al. identified 37 (27%)
remained relatively constant. There was a marked increase in C. pneumoniae infections in 135 children who were < 5 years
incidence that peaked in the early 1990s, since then, it has old, and who had a range of respiratory infections [32]. Bacterial
been steadily falling. Annual incidence registered in children causes of persisting bronchitic symptoms in the elderly are more
0 – 4 years of age was ∼ 20 episodes per 100 population in common than in children, and a wider range of pathogens is
1995, and this fell to 12 per 100 in 2004 [101]. Systematic involved. Secondary bacterial infection is an uncommon com-
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
microbiological studies of children consulting with acute res- plication in RSV bronchiolitis in children [33,34]. The consistent
piratory infections have found organisms in 50 – 90% of seasonal epidemics of acute bronchitis in children are more
cases, depending on the severity of illness, the type of patient consistent with a viral than bacterial cause.
investigated and the method of investigation: viral pathogens
are always found more frequently than bacteria [17-21]. RSV is 4. Pathogenesis
the most common cause of acute lower respiratory tract infec-
tion in young children [22]. The annual seasonality of acute Acute bronchitis arises as a result of damage to the epithelial
bronchitis/bronchiolitis (the most common lower respiratory cellular lining of the respiratory tract, although some of the
tract infection) follows the same seasonal pattern as RSV symptoms associated with respiratory infection are attributa-
activity, monitored by laboratory reporting (Figure 1). Clinical ble to cytokine response. Many viruses replicate in these cells,
incidence data for the years 1999/2000 to 2003/2004 show but in doing so, they destroy them. Viral replication within
For personal use only.
that acute bronchitis in children aged 0 – 4 years peaks during the cells of the respiratory tract is usually rapid, and from the
weeks 49 – 51; and the peak recorded in the elderly occurs evidence of experimental infection, commonly peaks within
during weeks 1 and 2 (i.e., children peak in the weeks prior to 2 or 3 days for most diseases [35]. The natural course of the
Christmas, and the elderly in the weeks following Christmas; disease involves replacement of the damaged epithelial lining.
Figure 2). It is apparent that the traditional social mixing that The time taken will relate to the extent of the damage, which
occurs during this holiday period provides the ideal opportu- is the function of the virulence of the virus and the host
nity for the spread of infection from the younger to older gener- response. Extensive damage to these cells results in sloughing
ations. In young children, acute bronchitis and exacerbations of of the superficial epithelial cells, and creates a favourable envi-
asthma are reported more frequently in males than in females, ronment in which bacteria may subsequently multiply. In per-
and boys are hospitalised more frequently [22-25]; this gender sons with a healthy respiratory tract, bacterial complications
difference is not present in adult cases [24]. This pattern has are unlikely, although they are not necessarily insignificant. In
not been explained adequately, but may reflect differences in persons with COPD, there are always many bacteria present
bronchial responsiveness to pathogens or differences in the in the respiratory tract (predominantly H. influenzae, Morax-
immune reactions between boys and girls triggered by viral ella catarrhalis and Streptococcus pneumoniae [36]), which
infections [25]. The difference is also seen in infant deaths due readily colonise the desquamating epithelium. Bacteria may
to respiratory disease and, interestingly, is similar in sudden also be primary causes of acute bronchitis, although from sur-
infant death syndrome (SIDS; Figure 3). veillance data in the WRS, seasonal trends in the diagnosis of
Parainfluenza and rhinoviruses are other major causes of acute bronchitis in children particularly follow the identifica-
acute respiratory infection in both children and adults. These tion of RSV (Figure 2). At the outset, the pathogenic process
are more particularly associated with upper respiratory usually involves a considerable part of the respiratory tract.
illnesses, such as common cold and otitis media [26,27], Therefore, specimens taken from the nose or throat can be
although they also sometimes cause more serious lower respi- used to investigate the causative organisms.
ratory illnesses. They are associated with asthma attacks and Viral pathogens including influenza, parainfluenza, rhino-
wheezing [20,28], with bronchiolitis in young children [29,30], virus, adenovirus, coronavirus, metapneumovirus and boca-
and are a significant cause of deteriorating pulmonary virus are responsible for large numbers of childhood
function in children with established respiratory disease [31]. respiratory infections, but diagnoses of acute bronchitis are
There are also bacterial causes of acute bronchitis. Although particularly likely during periods of RSV activity [11]. Most of
these may arise as complications of viral infection, they are these viruses are present throughout the world, and when new
sometimes the primary causal agent. Bacteria are more often viruses are identified, there is rarely much delay before they
identified in cases of recurrent infection. Esposito et al. studied are found in other countries, as documented in recent years
a group of 352 previously healthy children with recurrent with the human metapneumovirus [37-39] and human
A. 1400 1400
1200 1200
Laboratory reports
Rate per 100,000
1000 1000
800 800
600 600
400 400
200 200
0 0
40 42 44 46 48 50 52 02 04 06 08 10 12 14 16 18 20
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
Week
B. 1000 1000
800 800
Laboratory reports
Rate per 100,000
600 600
400 400
For personal use only.
200 200
0 0
40 42 44 46 48 50 52 02 04 06 08 10 12 14 16 18 20
Week
Figure 1. Acute bronchitis and respiratory syncytial virus laboratory reports. Weekly incidence rates of acute bronchitis per
100,000 population in children aged 0 – 4 years are contrasted with laboratory reports of RSV submitted to the Health Protection Agency
Centre for Infections during winters A.1996/1997 and B. 2003/2004.
bocavirus [40-43]. The annual appearance and circulation of the bronchioles and alveoli are involved. Some organisms are
each virus is entirely dependent on the pathogen in question more likely to cause obstruction in the lower airways than
(Figure 4): RSV in particular is known for its constant season- others: RSV is particularly (although not exclusively)
ality [44,45], whereas influenza can vary from season to season associated with bronchiolitis.
in relation to the start and duration of seasonal epidemics [46].
The seasonality of the virus may, nevertheless, be specific to a 5. Disease management
particular part of the world; influenza occurs as a winter epi-
demic in countries distant from the equator, but in equatorial The management of acute bronchitis is based primarily on the
countries it is endemic rather than epidemic [47,48]. Most of assessment of impairment to airflow and oxygen transfer.
these disorders are spread by respiratory droplets, but some, Examination of a patient therefore is directed towards the rec-
including RSV, are also preferentially spread by hand carriage ognition of such impairment. Extreme signs of impairment
of contaminated secretions and fomites [49]. include tachypnoea, exhaustion, rib recession, difficulty in
The consequence of infection in the bronchial lining is air- breathing and, sometimes, dehydration. A high pulse-rate is
ways restriction, which occurs as a result of mucosal oedema, part of the response to an infection causing fever.
mucus plugging from excessive airway mucus gland secre- Dehydration, especially in very young children, is a
tions and bronchospasm. The impact of this restriction of the manifestation of severe disease. A recent increase in the availa-
airways is greater where the lumen of the airways is small, as bility of inexpensive equipment to assess oxygen saturation
in the cases of young children. The effect, particularly in suitable for use in primary care (pulse oximetry) presents an
terms of oxygen interchange, relates to the extent to which opportunity to refine patient management [50].
1200
1000
800
> 65 years
Rate per 100,000
0 – 4 years
600
400
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
200
0
40 42 44 46 48 50 52 02 04 06 08 10 12 14 16 18 20 40 42 44 46 48 50 52 02 04 06 08 10 12 14 16 18 20
Week
Figure 2. Seasonality of acute bronchitis in the young and old. Weekly incidence rates of acute bronchitis per 100,000 of the
population are plotted for five winter seasons 1999/2000 to 2003/2004 in the 0 – 4 years and > 65 years age groups. The vertical dashed
line represents the Christmas/New Year period before which children peak, and after which the elderly peak.
1.0
Male
Rate per 1000 live births
0.8
Female
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003
Year
Figure 3. Sudden infant death syndrome. Rate of sudden infant death syndrome per 1000 live births are presented for the years
1995 – 2003 for males and females.
Data obtained from National Statistics Online [103].
Emergency measures appropriate to persons with appropriate inhalant device and suitable mask should be
substantial airways impairment include the use of supple- supervised. Hospital admission needs to be considered in
mental oxygen [51], bronchodilators by nebulised inhalation these cases, although in most cases, the decision can be
(or intravenous administration) [52], intravenous steroids deferred for a short period to evaluate response. Subsequent
when asthmatic broncho-constriction is considered likely management of a hospitalised patient may involve admis-
[53] and, in the most severely distressed, consideration of sion to an intensive care facility, and management of these
mechanical ventilatory support [54,55]. The use of an cases is outside the scope of this review.
300 900
Laboratory reports
200 600
150 450
100 300
50 150
0 0
7 8 9 10 11 12 13 1 2 3 4 5 6
4-week period
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
Figure 4. Seasonality of respiratory viral pathogens. Average number of laboratory reports (made to the Health Protection Agency)
of common respiratory viruses in 4-week periods, centred over the mid-winter 4-week period (13) over the years 1993 – 2001.
RSV: Respiratory syncytial virus.
Regardless of the causative organism, children with acute were demonstrated over nebulised delivery in children wheez-
bronchitis are likely to require antipyretics (paracetamol pre- ing at presentation [58]. Some studies have shown additional
ferred). Acute bronchitis is not a condition that causes pain benefits by supplementing a β2-agonist with an antimus-
For personal use only.
and there is no good evidence to support the use of paraceta- carinic inhaler in the treatment of asthma exacerbations [59,60];
mol combined with an NSAID when used for antipyretic pur- there are no data relating to use in the absence of wheeze.
poses. Antitussive preparations should generally be avoided Corticosteroids are available as intravenous/muscular, oral
because expectoration of respiratory secretions should not be or inhaled preparations. They are used to suppress the inflam-
discouraged. However, children experiencing difficulties matory response in the cells of the airways thereby minimising
expectorating because of viscid sputum may benefit from a the intensity of the cellular reaction and consequent local
mucolytic agent [102]. These products have not been shown to oedema, bronchospasm and airways obstruction. Their use is
have demonstrable benefit in terms of accelerated patient established in asthma, both as part of a preventive manage-
recovery, but persistent coughing can be distressing, and some ment programme, and in the management of acute episodes.
patients experience a benefit from them. Their use in acute respiratory infections is less clear: they have
Bronchodilators, mainly belonging to the β2-agonist class, not been associated with benefit in acute bronchiolitis [61].
have been used extensively for these disorders. They are avail- They have been helpful when given early to treat croup [62]. In
able as orally-administered syrups, dose-metered inhalers children aged 6 – 35 months presenting with viral lower respi-
commonly used in association with spacer devices and neb- ratory infection, a 3-day course of oral steroids reduced the
ulised aerosols. Bronchodilators are important for children severity and duration of illness [63]. There is no basis for their
who are asthmatic, but because it can be difficult to distin- use in simple acute bronchitis, in which wheezing is not
guish between underlying asthma and the symptoms of acute evident on initial examination. However, uncertainties at
bronchitis in the acute stage, it is often worth giving bron- presentation (such as the confusion between acute bronchitis
chodilators to children suffering from acute bronchitis. How- and early asthma) often prompt a management programme
ever, in the absence of evidence of airways obstruction, two based on the possibility of acute asthma.
clinical trials in children (both using syrups) have not shown Treatments using Chinese herbal remedies [64],
any benefit [56]. Their use in acute bronchiolitis is also Echinacea [65] and homeopathic regimens [66] have been
unclear: some clinical trials have suggested short-term clinical advocated to limit the symptoms of acute respiratory infec-
benefits, but these have not been reflected in measurements of tions. Although some symptomatic benefits have been
oxygen saturation [52]. The use of adrenaline for acute bron- reported both from the use of herbal remedies and from
chiolitis has also been the subject of a Cochrane review, and treatment with Echinacea, their use remains controversial
although the authors concluded against its use among hospital and should not be encouraged because of inconsistencies in
in-patients, they felt there was some evidence of benefit for different trials, and also because these products have not
use among out-patients [57]. The mechanism of delivery is been fully evaluated for safety [65]. Vitamin C supplements
important, and in a systematic review of devices involving are used by many adults to ward off colds, but there is no
metered-dosage with a valved holding chamber, advantages evidence to support this belief [67,68].
should alert the consideration of underlying asthma. If at tion and treatment: reduced viral shedding and some diminu-
presentation the child had already experienced symptoms for tion of symptoms have been observed, but the results have not
≥ 4 days, and is still experiencing constitutional symptoms led to formal clinical trials in children. Amongst the
such as fever, bacterial causes should be considered. Similarly capsid-inhibiting compounds, plecanoril has shown most
in patients experiencing particularly frequent respiratory promise, and has been the subject of several clinical trials in
infections, there is increased likelihood of a bacterial cause [5]. adults with acute respiratory infections, mostly showing bene-
Organism-specific treatments are available for illnesses fits over placebo, particularly in relation to viral shedding and
caused by influenza, RSV and bacteria. earlier symptom relief [86]. These drugs have not yet come in
Although acute bronchitis is not the classical presentation of to the market as a treatment for common respiratory
influenza, reports of acute bronchitis are substantially increased infections in adults or in children.
during influenza active periods [11]. Antivirals are available for For bacterial conditions, antibiotics are available, and when
For personal use only.
the prevention and treatment of influenza infections: there are a cough has persisted for 4 days and the patient is showing
two classes of drugs, the adamantanes and neuraminidase systemic features or suggestive clinical signs on auscultation of
inhibitors (NIs). Adamantanes (amantadine and rimantadine) the chest or on X-ray, bacterial infection needs to be consid-
have been available for several decades, but have recently ered. Bacterial causes of acute bronchitis do not show the
declined in importance compared with the NIs as they treat same rapid and even dramatic onset of viral infections. Apart
only influenza A and are associated with rapid emergence of from Bordatella pertussis, it is difficult to guess the causative
viral resistance [69-71]. In older age groups, though not in chil- organism other than on the basis of probability from consoli-
dren, these drugs are associated with neurological and gastro- dated knowledge obtained from aggregated laboratory data. A
intestinal side effects, however, rimantadine has been shown to 7-day course of erythromycin has been shown to be beneficial
have a decreased incidence of adverse effects over aman- in pertussis infections, provided it is given within a week of
tadine [72]. There are two NIs currently available for prophy- illness onset; it also reduces the infectious period and thus the
laxis against and treatment for influenza A and B infections; risk of spread [87]. There is a case for giving this antibiotic as
zanamivir (available by inhalation) and oseltamivir (available by prophylaxis where a baby or unvaccinated child has been
oral administration; in doses of 150 mg b.i.d. in adults and exposed to pertussis [88]. Bacteria such as H. influenzae have
10 mg/kg b.i.d. in a child). NIs have been shown to be effective been isolated from persons with acute exacerbations of
in shortening the course of influenzal illness and reducing the chronic bronchitis in 22 – 58% of cases [36,89,90] and for these,
complications [73-76], but only if medication is commenced amoxicillin is the preferred first-line drug; COPD in children
within 48 h of symptom onset. NIs have not been associated is extremely rare.
with the emergence of resistant viral variants of clinical impor- M. pneumoniae infection is a significant cause of bacterial
tance [77]. However, healthy children are not included as risk infection in all age groups [5,91]. There is some evidence of a
groups to be targeted for treatment with NIs in the UK because 3 – 4 year epidemic cycle [92,93] and thus, awareness of this
the potential benefits are not considered worthwhile [78]. This is diagnosis can be heightened. The tetracycline group of drugs
a subjective judgement, and is based on accumulated evidence is the treatment of choice for confirmed M. pneumoniae infec-
of influenza mainly over the last 10 years, during which time tion, although macroloides may also be used. Both drugs are
there has not been a serious outbreak of influenza in western also effective against C. pneumoniae.
Europe. This issue will certainly be revisited in the event of a For management purposes, the critical decision concerning
pandemic, or even in the case of a serious epidemic due to a the use of antibiotics needs to be taken at the initial presenta-
drifted variant of an existing strain. Oseltamivir is the only drug tion. As the available evidence strongly favours a viral cause,
licensed for use in children who are ≥ 1 year of age. These drugs patients with acute onset illness of < 2 days duration are
are also available for prophylaxis, but are not licensed for generally unlikely to benefit from antibiotics, and this is
prophylactic use in children [79]. borne out by randomised clinical trials in adults, but has not
been adequately investigated in children. There has been a potential for confusion with a new onset or exacerbation of
recent fashion to issue ‘a delayed prescription’ – a prescription asthma is considerable, and management is sometimes driven
made available to patients only to be dispensed if there is by this possibility. Acute bronchitis is almost always virologi-
further deterioration [94,95]. Although this may achieve a bene- cally determined, although secondary bacterial infection may
fit in reducing the number of antibiotics consumed, there is occur. Many viruses can cause acute bronchitis and other
little evidence to support a therapeutic benefit from this related disorders, and there is often little distinction between
method of management. The presumption of bacterial aetio- the clinical syndromes they cause. Among all of the potential
logy is a reasonable basis for management in circumstances in viral causes, RSV is probably the most important. Existing
which the patient remains constitutionally ill 4 days after knowledge of the contribution of several viruses towards the
onset, and is not simply complaining of a persistent cough. burden of illness attributable to acute bronchitis in children is
limited as routine virological investigation of respiratory
7. Disease prevention illness is not practiced. Although such an investigational pol-
icy is unrealistic in terms of total care, it should nevertheless
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
It is appropriate to consider ways in which the spread of be seen as a desirable target within sentinel practices dedicated
infection can be reduced. There are several environmental to the task. The contribution of rhinovirus in particular is
factors associated with increasing risk of respiratory infec- seriously underestimated.
tions and of asthma exacerbations in children. Reducing the In the initial assessment of cases, recognition of specific
exposure of children to tobacco smoke in the household clinical syndromes such as croup, epiglottitis and pertussis is
setting is perhaps the most readily achievable target. How- essential. However, immediate management depends mainly
ever, this should not detract from the need to reduce over- on the existence and extent of airways obstruction, and this
crowding and the general effects of deprivation [96,97]. Many assessment needs to be objectively made, if possible. Simple
viral pathogens are aerosol spread, and thus, air pollution devices to measure oxygen saturation will improve manage-
with high particulate content may favour certain types of ment decisions. Vaccination against preventable causes is an
spread. For some other pathogens, spread by personal contact important element of treatment, but there are few organ-
For personal use only.
is frequent (RSV for example), and high standards of hygiene ism-specific treatments available. Clinical trials in children
(regular hand washing) are desirable [98]. The incidence of often pay insufficient attention to the route of administration.
acute bronchitis recorded in children just before Christmas, For example, the role of β2-agonists is said to be doubtful on
and in the elderly just afterwards, suggests that close personal the basis of existing evidence; however, this statement is
contact with sick children should be minimised (Figure 2). mainly based on research involving oral preparations. The
Palivizumab has already been mentioned in the context of value of nebulised or inhaled formulations has not been
preventing infection due to RSV, but its use is confined to adequately tested. The significance of reduced viral shedding
premature children. Even in these cases, its value is limited. As in treated persons should not be underestimated. Reduced
influenza can cause acute bronchitis, primary prevention of potential for spreading infection may dramatically change the
influenza is likely to reduce the number of children with acute burden of illness in the community.
respiratory infections, although in comparison with RSV, the
contribution of influenza to acute bronchitis is less [11]. In many 8.2 Immediate future
countries, primary annual vaccination against influenza is An effective vaccine for general use against RSV infection is
encouraged in children at risk, particularly those with asthma. needed, and it is hoped that this will materialise in the next
In the US, vaccination of all children aged 6 – 59 months is 10 years. Equally, there is a need for an effective treatment;
recommended [99]. Two doses of trivalent split virus vaccine are NIs have been introduced for the treatment of influenza,
recommended: live attenuated cold adapted vaccine may be an which is one cause of clinical acute bronchitis in children.
alternative, especially as for some children nasal administration Given the stimulus of a pandemic threat, revised management
may be preferred, and there is a suggestion from clinical trials guidelines on the optimum use of NI antivirals are likely to
that the immune response following live attenuated cold emerge in the next 3 years. There are some promising advances
adapted vaccine is better than that following trivalent split in the development of antiviral drugs for rhinovirus infection.
vaccine [100]. Effective immunisation of young children against Effective treatments for viral respiratory diseases will have
pertussis is particularly important if deaths from this condition added benefits in decreasing the problems of otitis media.
are to be prevented [87].
8.3 Towards optimum management
8. Expert opinion The management of acute bronchitis will be advanced by a
better knowledge of the causative organisms. Background
8.1 Current knowledge predisposition to attacks is relatively insignificant, but until
Acute bronchitis in children is very common. It is a confusing we are clear about the cause, organism-specific treatments
diagnosis and is better viewed as a manifestation of acute will not be developed, and advances in treatment will not
respiratory infection rather than as a distinct entity. The be made. With this objective in mind, high quality
virological investigation of many more cases is needed. The Finally, in the medical and clinical profession, we must
greatly increased use of PCR technology will speed up this move away from the notion expressed in the catchphrase ‘it is
process. Improved knowledge will stimulate vaccine and only a virus’. The total burden of illness due to common
therapeutic research. respiratory infections in children should be seen as a challenge
Management decisions at the initial presentation for care to medicine, rather than an acceptance of the inevitable.
will always be critical, and the ready ability to distinguish an
acute asthmatic episode from an uncomplicated acute infec- Disclosure
tion will enhance management decisions. The development of
simple tests to detect impaired oxygen transfer for use in DM Fleming has received financial support from the pharma-
routine primary care and for routine monitoring of progress ceutical industry in matters relating to influenza prevention and
during the illness will make for specific benefits in the treatment. AJ Elliot is jointly funded by the Royal College of
decision to hospitalise patients. General Practitioners and the Health Protection Agency.
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
Bibliography 8. SIGURS N, GUSTAFSSON PM, 16. HEATH D, KAY JM: Respiratory System.
Papers of special note have been highlighted as BJARNASON R et al.: Severe respiratory In Muir's Textbook of Pathology. Anderson
either of interest (•) or of considerable interest syncytial virus bronchiolitis in infancy and JR (Ed.) Edward Arnold, London (1980):
(••) to readers. asthma and allergy at age 13. Am. J. Respir. 17. CHKHAIDZE I, MANJAVIDZE N,
Crit. Care. Med. (2005) 171(2):137-141. NEMSADZE K: Serodiagnosis of acute
1. FLEMING DM: Weekly Returns Service of
the Royal College of General Practitioners. 9. WELLIVER RC: RSV and chronic asthma. respiratory infections in children in
Commun. Dis. Public Health (1999) Lancet (1995) 346(8978):789-790. Georgia. Indian. J. Pediatr. (2006)
2(2):96-100. 10. MESSAGE SD, JOHNSTON SL: Viruses 73(7):569-572.
For personal use only.
2. FLEMING DM, CROSS KW, in asthma. Br. Med. Bull (2002) 61:29-43. 18. HIJAZI Z, PACSA A, EISA S,
BARLEY MA: Recent changes in the •• A comprehensive and valuable review of EL SHAZLI A, ABD EL-SALAM RA:
prevalence of diseases presenting for health the role of viruses in precipitating wheezy Laboratory diagnosis of acute lower
care. Br. J. Gen. Pract. (2005) episodes in infants and exacerbations of respiratory tract viral infections in children.
55(517):589-595. asthma in older children. J. Trop. Pediatr. (1996) 42(5):276-280.
series analysis of asthma hospitalisations in infections. Arch. Pediatr. Adolesc. Med. 46. FLEMING DM, ZAMBON M,
Ontario, Canada: 1988 to 2000. (2002) 156(4):322-324. BARTELDS AI, DE JONG JC: The
BMC Health Serv. Res. (2001) 1(1):7. 35. GENTILE D, DOYLE W, WHITESIDE T duration and magnitude of influenza
24. MORRISON DS, MCLOONE P: et al.: Increased interleukin-6 levels in nasal epidemics: a study of surveillance data from
Changing patterns of hospital admission for lavage samples following experimental sentinel general practices in England, Wales
asthma, 1981-97. Thorax (2001) influenza A virus infection. Clin. Diagn. and the Netherlands. Eur. J. Epidemiol.
56(9):687-690. Lab. Immunol. (1998) 5(5):604-608. (1999) 15(5):467-473.
25. NAGAYAMA Y, TSUBAKI T, 36. BALL P, MAKE B: Acute exacerbations of 47. CHEW FT, DORAISINGHAM S,
NAKAYAMA S et al.: Gender analysis in chronic bronchitis: an international LING AE, KUMARASINGHE G,
acute bronchiolitis due to respiratory comparison. Chest (1998) 113(3 LEE BW: Seasonal trends of viral
syncytial virus. Pediatr. Allergy Immunol. Suppl):199S-204S. respiratory tract infections in the tropics.
(2006) 17(1):29-36. Epidemiol. Infec.t (1998) 121(1):121-128.
37. REGEV L, HINDIYEH M,
26. MAKELA MJ, PUHAKKA T, SHULMAN LM et al.: Characterization of 48. NICHOLSON KG: Human Influenza. In
Textbook of Influenza. Nicholson KG et al.
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
27. PITKARANTA A, VIROLAINEN A, 38. STOCKTON J, STEPHENSON I, 49. HALL CB: Nosocomial respiratory
JERO J, ARRUDA E, HAYDEN FG: FLEMING D, ZAMBON M: syncytial virus infections: the "Cold War"
Detection of rhinovirus, respiratory Human metapneumovirus as a cause of has not ended. Clin. Infect. Dis. (2000)
syncytial virus, and coronavirus infections community-acquired respiratory illness. 31(2):590-596.
in acute otitis media by reverse transcriptase Emerg. Infect. Dis. (2002) 8(9):897-901. • Stressing the importance of RSV
polymerase chain reaction. Pediatrics (1998) nosocomial infections and barrier controls
39. VAN DEN HOOGEN BG, DE JONG JC,
102(2 Pt 1):291-295. by which these infections can be prevented.
GROEN J et al.: A newly discovered human
28. NICHOLSON KG, KENT J, pneumovirus isolated from young children 50. INGRAM G, MUNRO N: The use (or
IRELAND DC: Respiratory viruses and with respiratory tract disease. Nat. Med. otherwise) of pulse oximetry in general
For personal use only.
exacerbations of asthma in adults. BMJ (2001) 7(6):719-724. practice. Br. J. Gen. Pract. (2005)
(1993) 307(6910):982-986. 55(516):501-502.
40. ALLANDER T, TAMMI MT,
29. HAYDEN FG: Rhinovirus and the lower ERIKSSON M et al.: Cloning of a human 51. BAJAJ L, TURNER CG, BOTHNER J:
respiratory tract. Rev. Med. Virol. (2004) parvovirus by molecular screening of A randomized trial of home oxygen therapy
14(1):17-31. respiratory tract samples. Proc. Natl. Acad. from the emergency department for acute
• A comprehensive review covering all areas Sci. USA (2005) 102(36):12891-12896. bronchiolitis. Pediatrics (2006)
of infection and treatment of rhinovirus 117(3):633-640.
41. ARNOLD JC, SINGH KK,
infections in the respiratory tract. SPECTOR SA, SAWYER MH: Human 52. GADOMSKI AM, BHASALE AL:
30. SCHMIDT HJ, FINK RJ: Rhinovirus as a bocavirus: prevalence and clinical spectrum Bronchodilators for bronchiolitis. Cochrane
lower respiratory tract pathogen in infants. at a children's hospital. Clin. Infect. Dis. Database Syst. Rev. (2006) 3:CD001266.
Pediatr. Infect. Dis. J. (1991) (2006) 43(3):283-288. •• A meta-analysis assessing the effects of
10(9):700-702. bronchodilators on clinical outcomes in
42. MA X, ENDO R, ISHIGURO N et al.:
infants with acute bronchitis.
31. COLLINSON J, NICHOLSON KG, Detection of human bocavirus in Japanese
CANCIO E et al.: Effects of upper children with lower respiratory tract 53. LOWELL DI, LISTER G, VON KOSS H,
respiratory tract infections in patients with infections. J. Clin. Microbiol. (2006) MCCARTHY P: Wheezing in infants: the
cystic fibrosis. Thorax (1996) 44(3):1132-1134. response to epinephrine. Pediatrics (1987)
51(11):1115-1122. 79(6):939-945.
43. WEISSBRICH B, NESKE F,
32. WANGROONGSARB P, SCHUBERT J et al.: Frequent detection of 54. CHAN PW, GOH AY, LUM LC:
GEENKAJORN K, bocavirus DNA in German children with Respiratory failure requiring ventilation in
PEKTKANCHANAPONG W et al.: respiratory tract infections. BMC Infect. Dis. acute bronchiolitis. Med. J. Malaysia
Chlamydophila pneumoniae infection among (2006) 6:109. (1999) 54(4):487-491.
young children with respiratory diseases in 44. GODDARD NL, KYNCL J, 55. LEBEL MH, GAUTHIER M,
Thailand. Jpn. J. Infect. Dis. (2003) WATSON JM: Appropriateness of LACROIX J, ROUSSEAU E,
56(4):146-150. thresholds currently used to describe BUITHIEU M: Respiratory failure and
33. DUTTWEILER L, NADAL D, FREY B: influenza activity in England. Commun. Dis. mechanical ventilation in severe
Pulmonary and systemic bacterial Public Health (2003) 6(3):238-245. bronchiolitis. Arch. Dis. Child.
co-infections in severe RSV bronchiolitis. (1989) 64(10):1431-1437.
45. TERLETSKAIA-LADWIG E,
Arch. Dis. Child. (2004) 89(12):1155-1157. ENDERS G, SCHALASTA G, 56. SMUCNY J, FLYNN C, BECKER L,
34. PURCELL K, FERGIE J: Concurrent ENDERS M: Defining the timing of GLAZIER R: β2-agonists for acute
serious bacterial infections in 2396 infants respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) outbreaks: bronchitis. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev.
and children hospitalized with respiratory an epidemiological study. BMC Infect. Dis. (2004) 1:CD001726.
syncytial virus lower respiratory tract (2005) 5(1):20.
•• A meta-analysis that assesses whether syndromes. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 77. MONTO AS,
β2-agonists improve the symptoms of acute (2006) 3:CD001957. MCKIMM-BRESCHKIN JL,
bronchitis in patients without underlying 67. DOUGLAS RM, HEMILA H, MACKEN C et al.: Detection of influenza
pulmonary disease. D'SOUZA R, CHALKER EB, TREACY B: viruses resistant to neuraminidase inhibitors
57. HARTLING L, WIEBE N, RUSSELL K, Vitamin C for preventing and treating the in global surveillance during the first 3 years
PATEL H, KLASSEN TP: Epinephrine for common cold. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. of their use. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother.
bronchiolitis. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. (2004) 4:CD000980. (2006) 50(7):2395-2402.
(2004)1:CD003123. 68. HEMILA H, DOUGLAS RM: 78. NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR HEALTH
58. CASTRO-RODRIGUEZ JA, Vitamin C and acute respiratory infections. AND CLINICAL EXCELLENCE: Flu
RODRIGO GJ: β-agonists through Int. J. Tuberc. Lung Dis. (1999) treatment – zanamivir, amantadine and
metered-dose inhaler with valved holding 3(9):756-761. oseltamivir: guidance. Publication refrence
chamber versus nebulizer for acute TA05. London (2003).
69. BRIGHT RA, MEDINA MJ, XU X et al.:
exacerbation of wheezing or asthma in Incidence of adamantane resistance among 79. NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR HEALTH
children under 5 years of age: a systematic AND CLINICAL EXCELLENCE: Flu
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
PHIPATANAKUL W: Comparison of influenza outbreak in Japan. Tohoku J. Exp. the lower respiratory tract in infants and
nebulized ipratropium bromide with Med. (2006) 210(1):21-27. young children. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev.
salbutamol vs salbutamol alone in acute (2004) 4:CD000181.
72. JEFFERSON T, DEMICHELI V, DI
asthma exacerbation in children. 82. THE IMPACT-RSV STUDY GROUP:
PIETRANTONJ C, RIVETTI D:
Ann. Allergy Asthma Immunol. Palivizumab, a humanized respiratory
Amantadine and rimantadine for influenza
(2006) 96(5):701-706. syncytial virus monoclonal antibody,
A in adults. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev.
61. PATEL H, PLATT R, LOZANO JM, (2006) 2:CD001169. reduces hospitalization from respiratory
WANG EE: Glucocorticoids for acute viral syncytial virus infection in high-risk infants.
73. HAYDEN FG, OSTERHAUS AD,
bronchiolitis in infants and young children. Pediatrics (1998) 102(3 Pt 1):531-537.
TREANOR JJ et al.: Efficacy and safety of
Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. (2004) 83. FELTES TF, CABALKA AK,
the neuraminidase inhibitor zanamivir in
3:CD004878. MEISSNER HC et al.: Palivizumab
the treatment of influenzavirus infections.
62. RUSSELL K, WIEBE N, SAENZ A et al.: GG167 Influenza Study Group. prophylaxis reduces hospitalization due to
Glucocorticoids for croup. Cochrane N. Engl. J. Med. (1997) 337(13):874-880. respiratory syncytial virus in young children
Database Syst. Rev. (2004) 1:CD001955. with hemodynamically significant
74. WHITLEY RJ, HAYDEN FG,
63. CSONKA P, KAILA M, LAIPPALA P et al.: congenital heart disease. J. Pediatr.
REISINGER KS et al.: Oral oseltamivir
Oral prednisolone in the acute management (2003) 143(4):532-540.
treatment of influenza in children.
of children age 6 to 35 months with viral Pediatr. Infect. Dis. J. (2001) 84. HANDFORTH J, SHARLAND M,
respiratory infection-induced lower airway 20(2):127-133. FRIEDLAND JS: Prevention of respiratory
disease: a randomized, placebo-controlled syncytial virus infection in infants. BMJ
75. MAKELA MJ, PAUKSENS K,
trial. J. Pediatr. (2003) 143(6):725-730. (2004) 328(7447):1026-1027.
ROSTILA T et al.: Clinical efficacy and
64. WU T, CHEN X, DUAN X et al.: safety of the orally inhaled neuraminidase 85. ROTBART HA: Treatment of picornavirus
Chinese medicinal herbs for acute inhibitor zanamivir in the treatment of infections. Antiviral Res. (2002)
bronchitis. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. influenza: a randomized, double-blind, 53(2):83-98.
(2005) 3:CD004560. placebo-controlled European study. •• Reports on the recent progress successes
65. LINDE K, BARRETT B, WOLKART K, J. Infect. (2000) 40(1):42-48. reported towards the development of
BAUER R, MELCHART D: Echinacea for antivirals for the treatment of picornavirus
76. NICHOLSON KG, AOKI FY,
preventing and treating the common cold. infections.
OSTERHAUS AD et al.: Efficacy and
Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. (2006) safety of oseltamivir in treatment of acute 86. HAYDEN FG, HERRINGTON DT,
1:CD000530. influenza: a randomised controlled trial. COATS TL et al.: Efficacy and safety of oral
66. VICKERS AJ, SMITH C: Homoeopathic Neuraminidase Inhibitor Flu Treatment pleconaril for treatment of colds due to
Oscillococcinum for preventing and Investigator Group. Lancet (2000) picornaviruses in adults: results of 2
treating influenza and influenza-like 355(9218):1845-1850. double-blind, randomized,
placebo-controlled trials. Clin. Infect. Dis. 94. DOWELL J, PITKETHLY M, BAIN J, recommendations of the Advisory
(2003) 36(12):1523-1532. MARTIN S: A randomised controlled trial Committee on Immunization Practices
87. CROWCROFT NS, PEBODY RG: of delayed antibiotic prescribing as a (ACIP). MMWR Recomm. Rep. (2006)
Recent developments in pertussis. strategy for managing uncomplicated 55(RR-10):1-42.
Lancet (2006) 367(9526):1926-1936. respiratory tract infection in primary care. 100. TREANOR JJ, KOTLOFF K, BETTS RF
Br. J. Gen. Pract. (2001) 51(464):200-205. et al.: Evaluation of trivalent, live,
88. TIWARI T, MURPHY TV, MORAN J:
Recommended antimicrobial agents for the 95. LITTLE P, RUMSBY K, KELLY J et al.: cold-adapted (CAIV-T) and inactivated
treatment and postexposure prophylaxis of Information leaflet and antibiotic (TIV) influenza vaccines in prevention of
pertussis: 2005 CDC Guidelines. MMWR prescribing strategies for acute lower virus infection and illness following
Recomm. Rep. (2005) 54(RR-14):1-16. respiratory tract infection: a randomized challenge of adults with wild-type influenza
controlled trial. JAMA (2005) A (H1N1), A (H3N2), and B viruses.
89. ALVAREZ-SALA JL, KARDOS P,
293(24):3029-3035. Vaccine (1999) 18(9-10):899-906.
MARTINEZ-BELTRAN J, CORONEL P,
AGUILAR L: Clinical and bacteriological 96. GERGEN PJ, FOWLER JA,
MAURER KR, DAVIS WW, Websites
Expert Opin. Pharmacother. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by RMIT University on 08/01/13
cefditoren-pivoxil versus cefuroxime-axetil. environmental tobacco smoke exposure on Royal College of General Practitioners.
Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. (2006) the respiratory health of children 2 months Birmingham Research Unit. Accessed
50(5):1762-1767. through 5 years of age in the United States: 22 Dec 2006.
Third National Health and Nutrition 102. http://www.clinicalevidence.com/ceweb/cond
90. SETHI S, ANZUETO A, FARRELL DJ:
Examination Survey, 1988 to 1994. itions/rda/1508/1508.jsp
Antibiotic activity of telithromycin and
Pediatrics (1998) 101(2):E8. BMJ clinical evidence.
comparators against bacterial pathogens
• A study that reinforces the need to reduce
isolated from 3,043 patients with acute 103. http://www.statistics.gov.uk
the exposure of young children to tobacco
exacerbation of chronic bronchitis. National Statistics Online.
smoke.
Ann. Clin. Microbiol. Antimicrob.
97. LI JS, PEAT JK, XUAN W, BERRY G:
(2005) 4:5. Affiliation
For personal use only.