Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hepatic Tissue Endothelin-1 PDF
Hepatic Tissue Endothelin-1 PDF
1, 2000
© 2000 by Am. Coll. of Gastroenterology ISSN 0002-9270/00/$20.00
Published by Elsevier Science Inc. PII S0002-9270(99)00743-1
OBJECTIVES: Plasma endothelin-1 (ET-1) levels are in- hypertension. (Am J Gastroenterol 2000;95:199 –203.
creased in patients with cirrhosis and ET-1 production is © 2000 by Am. Coll. of Gastroenterology)
increased in the liver itself during experimental injury.
These data suggest a possible role for this vasoactive peptide
in intrahepatic microcirculatory changes that contribute to INTRODUCTION
the pathogenesis of portal hypertension in cirrhosis. There-
The endothelins compromise a family of potent vasocon-
fore the aims of this study were to determine whether ET-1
strictors (1). Three unique endothelin peptides, each con-
levels were abnormal in the livers of patients with cirrhosis
sisting of 21 amino acids, have been identified and termed
and to investigate possible clinical correlates of altered
endothelin-1 (ET-1), endothelin-2 (ET-2), and endothelin-3
hepatic ET-1 in cirrhosis.
(ET-3). The endothelins have been implicated in a wide
METHODS: Liver specimens were obtained from explants at variety of normal and pathological processes. Their different
the time of liver transplantation in 62 cirrhotic patients; 49 effects are in part related to the receptor to which they bind
without pretransplantation transjugular intrahepatic porto- endothelin-A (ETA) or endothelin-B (ETB) (2). Their major
systemic shunt (TIPS) and 13 with pretransplantation TIPS. function appears to be in the local control of vascular tone
The presence of ascites was evaluated by physical exami- (3). ET-1 and ET-3 appear to induce vasoconstriction
nation and ultrasonography. Control specimens consisted of through stimulation of smooth muscle cells and vasodilation
livers with normal morphology obtained from patients who due to effects on endothelial cells, respectively.
died from nonliver-related causes. Hepatic ET-1 was mea- Circulating levels of immunoreactive ET-1 have been
sured by enzyme immunoassay. reported to be elevated in a number of diseases including
hypertension, atherosclerosis, acute myocardial infarction,
RESULTS: Hepatic ET-1 levels in cirrhotics without (0.17
and acute renal failure (1). Current information concerning
pg/mg liver tissue) or with TIPS (0.12 pg/mg) were higher
plasma endothelin levels in cirrhosis is conflicting. During
than in control patients [0.04 pg/mg (p ⫽ 0.02 for ET-1
the past several years, numerous investigators have shown
levels in cirrhotics with or without TIPS vs control)]. In
that both plasma ET-1 and ET-3 concentrations are in-
cirrhotics without ascites who had not had TIPS, ET-1 levels
creased in cirrhotics with ascites, varices, and hepatorenal
(0.07 pg/mg [0.04 –1.00]) were similar to those of the con-
syndrome (4 –14). However, some studies have reported
trols. In contrast, ET-1 content was increased in cirrhotics
both normal (15) and reduced (16) plasma levels in cirrhosis.
with small (0.11 pg/mg; p ⫽ 0.0002) and moderate-to-large
Data demonstrating that ET-1 is overexpressed in differ-
(0.69 pg/mg; p ⫽ 0.0002) amounts of ascites compared to
ent cellular compartments in cirrhotic tissue (17, 18), and
patients without ascites. There was a modest correlation
that ET-1 is higher in the hepatic vein than in portal vein in
between ET-1 levels and Child-Pugh score (correlation co-
patients with portal hypertension (19), have led investigators
efficient 0.32; p ⫽ 0.03) and ET-1 levels were significantly
to postulate that the increased ET-1 levels in patients with
higher in patients with Child-Pugh score of 13 or greater
cirrhosis are related to increased production by the diseased
(0.88 pg/mg; p ⫽ 0.02) than in those with Child-Pugh score
liver. This is supported by the recent demonstration of
of 12 or less (0.16 pg/mg).
increased production of ET-1 (preproET-1 mRNA and pep-
CONCLUSIONS: Hepatic tissue ET-1 levels are increased in tide) in the liver during experimental injury (18), and in-
the liver of patients with cirrhosis. This increase appears to creased hepatic levels of ET-1 mRNA and ET-1 in cirrhotic
be proportional to the severity of both liver disease and rats with ascites (20). However, hepatic endothelin levels in
ascites. These data raise a possible role for ET-1 in modu- patients with cirrhosis have not been reported. Therefore,
lation of intrahepatic resistance in cirrhotic portal the present study was undertaken to determine whether
200 Alam et al. AJG – Vol. 95, No. 1, 2000
ET-1 levels were abnormal in the livers of patients with Table 1. Clinical Characteristics of the Study Group
cirrhosis, and to establish potential clinical correlates of Without TIPS With TIPS Controls
altered hepatic ET-1 in cirrhosis. Variable (n ⫽ 49) (n ⫽ 13) (n ⫽ 8)
Median age (yr) [range] 49 [28–68] 43 [29–61] 50 [27–60]
Gender (%)
MATERIALS AND METHODS Male 69 77 100
Female 31 23 0
Liver specimens were obtained consecutively from explants Etiology (%)
at the time of orthotopic liver transplantation in 62 patients Alcohol alone 12 31
HCV ⫾ alcohol 43 31
with cirrhosis during the period July 1993 to August 1995. HBV 16 8
Thirteen of these patients had undergone a prior transjugular Cholestatic 20 20
intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) procedure. The di- Others 9 10
agnosis of cirrhosis was based on histological findings. Child-Pugh class (%)
Patients with alcoholic liver disease had a longstanding B 57 23
C 43 77
history of alcohol abuse, i.e., a consumption exceeding 50 Ascites (%)
g/day for ⬎5 yr. They had all abstained from alcohol use for None 24 38
at least 6 months before transplantation. Patients with Small 37 31
chronic liver disease secondarily to hepatitis C virus (HCV) Moderate–large 39 31
and hepatitis B virus were anti-HCV antibody and hepatitis Patients with alcoholic liver disease had a long-standing history of alcohol abuse,
(⬎50 g/day for ⬎5 yr), but had abstained from alcohol use for at least 6 months before
B surface antigen positive, respectively. Patients who had transplantation. Ascites was evaluated by physical examination and confirmed (and
nonalcoholic, nonviral cirrhosis were classified as choles- quantitated) by ultrasonography. HCV ⫽ hepatitis C virus; HBV ⫽ hepatitis B virus;
TIPS ⫽ transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt.
tatic (secondary to primary sclerosing cholangitis or primary
biliary cirrhosis; with a total bilirubin of ⬎3 mg/dl) and
others, which included genetic hemochromatosis and auto- interassay variability for determination of ET-1 were each
immune hepatitis. The presence of ascites was evaluated by routinely ⬍10%.
physical examination and roughly quantitated (none, small, Because the distribution of ET-1 levels were skewed and
and moderate-to-large) by ultrasonography or CT before included several high level outliers, we reported ET-1 levels
transplantation. The cirrhotic patients did not have hepato- by using the median and range. Furthermore, statistical
cellular carcinoma, as assessed by ultrasound or CT and differences between subgroups were tested using the non-
histology. All cirrhotic patients were on a low salt diet and parametric Wilcoxon two-sample and Kruskal-Wallis tests.
the majority were receiving oral diuretics. Patients were Exact p values for these tests were calculated whenever one
excluded if they had no pretransplantation ultrasound or CT, of the groups being compared contained fewer than five
or if complete clinical data were not available. Indications subjects. Spearman rank correlations were calculated to
for TIPS were variceal hemorrhage (38%), refractory ascites measure and test the association between ET-1 and Child-
(54%), and hepatorenal syndrome (8%). Pugh score (21). A p value of ⬍0.05 was considered sta-
Normal hepatic tissue was obtained from patients who tistically significant.
had died from nonliver-related causes (motor vehicle acci-
dent or in whom liver tissue adjacent to cancers was ob-
tained) (n ⫽ 8). There was no evidence of liver abnormality
RESULTS
in the control patients, as determined from histological Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of the study
examination. This study was approved by the Committee on group are shown in Table 1. The median (range) age of
Human Research of the University of California, San Fran- cirrhotic patients without pretransplant TIPS was 49 yr
cisco and fulfilled criteria for research as put forth in the (28 – 68 yr); 31% were women; 43% were Child-Pugh class
Declaration of Helsinki. C and 43% had hepatitis C virus ⫾ alcoholic liver disease.
Hepatic tissue ET-1 (picograms per milligram) was mea- The median (range) age patients with pretransplantation
sured by enzyme immunoassay (Peninsula Laboratories, TIPS was 43 yr (29 – 61 yr); 23% were women; 77% were
Belmont, CA). In brief, tissue samples from flushed livers Child-Pugh class C and 31% had hepatitis C virus ⫾ alco-
were snap frozen in liquid nitrogen. From these samples, holic liver disease. The median age of the controls was 50
250 –500 mg were individually sonicated in 0.1 mol/L hy- yr (27– 60 yr) and all were men. There was no evidence of
drochloric acid (HCl), boiled for 10 min at 1000°C and then diffuse parenchymal liver disease in any control subject as
centrifuged at 7000 g for 10 min at 40°C. Tris-HCl (1 assessed by routine histological examination of livers.
mol/L; 2:1 volume) was added to supernatants, which were Hepatic ET-1 levels in the patient groups and controls are
then subjected to enzyme immunoassay as described by the shown in Table 2. ET-1 levels were significantly higher in
manufacturer. Known concentrations of ET-1 were used to cirrhotics without (0.17 pg/mg [0.04 –2.9]) or with TIPS
generate a standard curve, which was used to determine (0.12 pg/mg [0.04 – 0.7]) than in the control patients (0.04
peptide concentrations in unknown samples. The intra- and pg/mg [0 – 0.1]; p ⫽ 0.02 for both comparisons). ET-1 levels
AJG – January, 2000 ET-1 Levels and Disease Severity and Ascites 201
Table 4. Child-Pugh Score and Hepatic Endothelin-1 (ET-1) unknown, but could be related to factors that stimulate ET-1
Levels in Cirrhotics Without Transjugular Intrahepatic production. For example, cirrhotic patients with ascites have
Portosystemic Shunt
high concentrations of endotoxin, angiotensin II, and anti-
Hepatic ET-1 Levels (pg/mg) diuretic hormone (32) and elevated ET levels could be
Child-Pugh Score Median Range related to an increased intrahepatic synthesis promoted by
Controls (n ⫽ 4) 0.05 0.04–0.1 these substances (24, 33). Finally, we cannot exclude the
ⱕ12 (n ⫽ 45) 0.16 0.04–1.26 possibility that ET-1 contributes to ascites formation, such
ⱖ13 (n ⫽ 4) 0.88* 0.48–2.9 that patients with high intrahepatic ET-1 levels are more
Liver tissue was snap frozen after explant removal at the time of surgery and ET-1 was likely to develop ascites.
measured by EIA as described in methods. The severity of cirrhosis was classified
according to Pugh’s modification of Child’s classification (21). Values in parentheses Although statistical differences could not be detected
indicate the number of patients in each group. * p ⫽ 0.02 vs cirrhotic patients with
Child-Pugh score ⬍12.
between hepatic ET-1 levels in patients with and without a
previous TIPS procedure, there was a trend toward a de-
crease in ET-1 levels in patients with a TIPS. Parallel
Therefore, these results suggest that the increase in intrahe-
findings were reported by Martinet et al. (34), who reported
patic ET-1 level is, at least in part, related to the underlying
that shunting for refractory ascites induced a marked de-
severity of cirrhosis. A similar observation has been previ-
crease in ET-1 and big ET-1 in portal and renal veins. The
ously reported by Tsai et al. (6) for plasma ET-1 levels. In
their study, plasma ET-1 concentrations in Child class C mechanism by which TIPS could lead to decreased produc-
patients were much higher than in Child class A or B tion of endothelin is not fully understood, but may be related
patients, and there was a significant positive correlation to a reduction in pressure within the liver. Future work
between plasma ET-1 levels and Child-Pugh score. including study of increased numbers of patients should
Potential mechanisms responsible for increased ET-1 pro- provide a clearer understanding of the complex nature and
duction in chronic liver disease include endotoxemia (12, effect of TIPS on ET-1 production after portal decompres-
24) and shear stress in response to altered blood flow (25, sion with TIPS.
26). Endotoxemia is common in patients with cirrhosis (27, The data presented in this study have important implica-
28) and Lin et al. (28) recently demonstrated that plasma tions for the pathogenesis of portal hypertension. Because
endotoxin levels progressively increased in relation to the ET acts principally as a local paracrine or autocrine agent
severity of cirrhosis as assessed by Child-Pugh score. En- (35), it is possible that locally produced ET contributes to
dotoxin has also been shown to enhance ET-1 production increased intrahepatic vascular resistance and concomitant
from cultured thoracic endothelial cells and hepatic endo- portal hypertension typical of patients with cirrhosis. Cur-
thelial cells (24, 29). It has also been suggested that hemo- rent evidence indicates that hepatic stellate cells may con-
dynamic forces have important effects on the structure and tribute to increased intrahepatic resistance by perisinusoidal
function of vascular endothelial cells. Shear stress stimu- contraction and constriction of the sinusoid (36, 37). Given
lates ET production (25, 26) and in the setting of a hyper- data demonstrating that all hepatic cell types (hepatocytes,
dynamic circulation, which is most prominent in those with endothelial cells, Kupffer cells, and stellate cells) express
advanced disease (30, 31) and could contribute to increased ET receptors, but are most abundant on stellate cells (38)
production of ET-1 in patients with cirrhosis. and that ET-1 induces potent contraction of stellate cells
We found that hepatic ET-1 levels in cirrhotic patients (36), it appears that stellate cells are a major target of ET
with ascites were higher than in patients with cirrhosis (37, 39). Therefore, overproduced ET after hepatic injury
without ascites. The increase in hepatic ET-1 content in
and cirrhosis may play an important role in the genesis of
cirrhotics with ascites compared to those without ascites is
increased intrahepatic resistance.
consistent with the finding that ET-1 levels were increased
in proportion to the severity of cirrhosis. The 14-fold rela-
tive increase in hepatic ET levels observed in patients with
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
moderate-to-large ascites as compared with healthy subjects
is greater than that reported in the plasma of cirrhotic This study was supported by grants to I.A. from the National
patients with ascites studied by Asbert et al. (10) and Uchi- Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, (T 32 DK 07007), to the
hara et al. (12). The higher value in our study may be due UCSF Liver Center (P30 DK26743) and to DCR (DK 50574
to the fact that we measured intrahepatic levels, whereas the and DK 02124). We thank Tamara Ryan for assistance in
latter studies measured circulating levels (and did not quan- collecting the liver tissue specimens used in this study.
titate the amount of ascites). Recently, Leivas et al. (20) also
reported a selective increase in ET production in the liver of
cirrhotic rats with ascites (but not in animals without as- Reprint requests and correspondence: Don Rockey, M.D., Liver
cites), indicating a possible link between ET and develop- Center Laboratory, Duke University Medical Center, Sands Build-
ment of ascites. The mechanism that accounts for increased ing, Room 336, Research Drive, Box 3083, Durham, NC 27710.
hepatic production of ET-1 in cirrhotics with ascites is Received Nov. 9, 1998; accepted July 7, 1999.
AJG – January, 2000 ET-1 Levels and Disease Severity and Ascites 203