Understanding The Depth of Historical Study: The Historian Is Not A Judge, Still Less A Hanging Judge

You might also like

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 3

HISTORY and of society; and it is in this twofold light that

the student of history must learn to regard him


Record of the past of mankind
3. According to Creighton
a. Thematic b. Chronology
• 'an arbiter of controversy, a guide of the
Historical Records wanderer, the upholder of that moral standard
a. Documents b. Artifacts c. Digital which the powers of earth and of religion itself
tend constantly to depress
Aims:
Understanding the depth of historical study
a. Descriptive b. Interpretative
The historian is not a judge, still less a hanging
What is history judge.
 It is a continuous process of interaction History is a process of struggle, in which results,
between the historian and his facts, an whether we judge them good or bad, are
unending dialogue between the present and achieved by some groups directly or indirectly -
the past. and more often directly than indirectly - at the
 The historian without his facts is rootless expense of others. The losers pay. Suffering is
and futile; the facts without their historian indigenous in history. Every great period of
are dead and meaningless. history has its casualties as well as its victories.
Importance of History PRIMARY SOURCES

 Allows us to master and understand our  Immediate, first-hand accounts of a


past, which in turn allows to understand our topic, from people who had a direct
present. ´ connection with it.
 Provide us with insight into our cultures of  Original records created at the time
origin as well as cultures with which we historical events occurred, or well after
might be less familiar, thereby increasing events occurred. Primary sources may
crosscultural awareness and understanding. include: Letters, manuscripts, diaries,
 Helps us to appreciate the essential nature journals, oral histories, newspapers,
of the differences between his own society speeches, interviews, memoirs,
and outlook and those of other periods and government documents, photographs,
other countries ´ audio recordings, video recordings, and
 Let us to evaluate what was significant artifacts
about selected events, people, and  These sources serve as the raw
developments in the past. ´ material to interpret the past. When they
 Helps us understand why we live the way we are used along with previous
are living and why we are where we are as a interpretations by historians, they
species and country. ´ provide the resources necessary for
 Allows us to learn from the mistakes of our historical research.
ancestors so we do not do the same things SECONDARY SOURCES
they did and work to become a better place.
 Build from primary sources with
Understanding History
more extensive and in-depth
1. Before you study the history study the analyses.
historian.  They summarize, evaluate, and
analytically interpret primary
2. Before you study the historian, study his material, often by offering a
historical and social environment. The historian, personal perspective.
being an individual, is also a product of history
 Published works with list of sources 4. Autobiographies by Jose Rizal,
of information which can be used to Antonio Luna, and Corazon Aquino
locate additional information for
research or unexplored topics. 5. Lecture paper that examines Henry
Scott’s writing style
 Use to see what others have
discussed. They can be a good 6. Presentation of Manila city landscape
place to gather background using “reduccion” plan of theAugustinian
information on a particular topic.
 General examples: Textbooks, 7. Paper discussion on Juan Luna's
monographs (books), techniques in painting Spoliarium
encyclopedias, analysis, review 8. Criticism or review of Felix
articles, dissertations, thesis. Resureccion Hidalgo’s Virgins Expose
TERTIARY SOURCES to the Populace

 They are distillations and 9. News commentaries on the 2018


collections of primary and SONA of President R. Duterte
secondary sources. The information 10.Physician’s account on Dengvaxia
is compiled and digested into vaccine
factual representation, so that it
does not obviously reflect points of 11.Narration of Col. E. Abulencia’s
view, critiques or persuasions. experience as a soldier during WW2 in
 Tertiary sources are typically the the Philippines
last to be published in the
12.Comfort Woman: A Filipina's Story of
information cycle. Because it has
Prostitution and Slavery Under the
been filtered through by many
Japanese Military by Maria Rosa
reviewers, it tends to consist of
Henson
highly reliable and accurate
information, plus contain broad When is a Primary Source aSecondary Source?
perspectives of topics.
 Use for a general overview of topic Whether something is a primary or
and for background information for secondary source often depends upon
research. the topic and its use.
 General examples: Encyclopedias, ´ Paul’s Epistle to the Galatians was
directories,dictionaries, handbooks, written contemporaneous to Simon
guides, classification,chronology, Peter’s actual existence thus primary
and other fact books. source
Identifying what type of source ´ The author of 2 Peter refers to Noah, 2
1. Debut memoir “Somewhere in the Peter was written circa 60AD ,whereas
Middle: A journey to the Philippines in Noah lived – assuming he lived at all –
search of roots, belonging, and identity circa 2304 thus secondary.
on March 11, 2019” by Deborah SIGNFICANCE OF HISTORICAL
Francisco Douglas CONTEXT IN ANALYSIS AND
2. Article analyzing Rodrigo Duterte’s INTERPRETATION
speech The background information
3. Book recounting battle history of surrounding a subject
INWW2 in the Philippines  Refers to the social, religious,
economic, and political
conditions that existed during a certain economic environment related to
time and place. historical moments, events, and trends.
Historical artifacts and sources were
 Details that surround an occurrence, created within particular worlds and are
it's all the detailsof the time and tied to the political, social, and
place in which a situation occurs, economic conditions of those worlds.
and those details are what enable us  WHY: Often students have difficulty
to interpret and analyze works or differentiating how modern thinking
events of the past, or even the does not always apply to the traditions,
future, rather than merely judge them politics, economics, understandings,
by contemporary standards. and technology of the past.Therefore, it
 ”Context" is the environment in is important to help students place
which action and outcome occurs. them in the “shoes” of those who came
 In analyzing historical events, before us.
context can help us understand what  1. Help students differentiate between
motivates people to behave as they the causes of an event and the context
did of anevent.
2. Help students get “the whole picture”
SIGNIFICANCE OF HISTORICAL
CONTEXT that surrounds an event from the past.
3. Guide students in interpreting
Without the historical context, we are only documents such as speeches and
seeing a piece of the scene and not fully political cartoonsby using historical
understanding the influence of the time context
and place in which a situation occurred.  WHEN: Use Historical Context every
time students study an event from the
o Scholars and educators rely on past or present and/ or working with
historical context to analyze and primary documents.
interpret works of art, literature,
music, dance, and poetry.
1. Architects and builders rely on it when
designing new
structures and restoring existing
buildings.
2. Judges may use it to interpret the law
3. Historians use to understand the past.
o Any time critical analysis is required,
you may need to consider historical
context as well.
o Thus, context allows the student to
have a fuller grasp of the situation by
knowing the political, cultural, and
social condition at the time the
primary source was written and
eliminate the struggle to see the
connection of the past to present.

 Historical context can be defined as


the political, social, cultural, and

You might also like