Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Applied Automation - 2019 08
Applied Automation - 2019 08
Applied Automation - 2019 08
ControlENGINEERING
Engineering
PLANT ENGINEERING
and Control magazines
Engineering magazines
Your Success is Our Success
AutomationDirect is your trusted source for cost-effective control solutions
Jesus Chavez
Service and Test Engineer
Vacuum Technology Inc. www.vacuumtechnology.com
T
he cover story in this issue of maintenance: “The onus is on the safety profes-
AppliedAutomation, which focuses on sional, who along with their staff, must have a
gas burners and valve safety trains, is a core level of knowledge regarding safe practices
departure from the usual article that typi- of valve safety trains, even if a contractor will be
cally appears in the publication. You may ask, doing the preventive maintenance work. Most
“What do gas burners and valve safety trains accidents and explosions are due to human
have to do with industrial automation?” That’s error and a lack of training when an unknowing
a fair question, and a good one. As the author employee, for example, attempts to bypass a
Jack Smith states in the article, “A multitude of sensors with- safety control.”
Editor in the valve safety train — pressure switches, While the cover story is different from what
flame detectors, position indicators — and isola- usually appears in these pages, the other
tion and relief valves work together in concert to story featured in this issue is a familiar topic:
prevent accidents.” The automation comes into Choosing a controller for industrial applications.
play by logically linking these safety components The author lists and defines the most popular
to the burner management system. controller categories for operations technology
Throughout the article, the author describes (OT) projects and suggests criteria for selection:
the types of thermal processes that use burners “When choosing a controller for an applica-
and valve safety trains, describes their function- tion, there’s often more than one right answer.
ality, explains the dangers of how they can fail Choosing the correct controller requires evaluat-
and offers alternatives to traditional solutions. In ing several characteristics and perhaps consid-
addition, he advocates training and preventive ering multiple applications.”
CONTROL
YOURSELF
WITH HELP
FROM TRIDENT. For complete product and service information,
visit tridentautomation.com
or call 920.759.7477
We’ve seen it before: your DCS needs an upgrade, but you
don’t want to call the vendor for every little tweak. That’s why
Trident designs systems on an open platform philosophy: easy
enough for your plant to make adjustments without calling us
in. As a top DCS designer and integrator, we create customized
operating systems you and your team can understand. We’re
proud to be control freaks, but we also give control to you.
seweurodrive.com / 864-439-7537
Contents
A6 Prevent burner fuel
delivery accidents
Valve safety trains require regular
inspections, maintenance and training
A9 Evaluate controller
options for industrial
applications
Choosing the best industrial controller
requires evaluation of automation,
A6
ON THE COVER: A valve safety train is a fuel distribution device that
communication and security needs maintains consistent conditions for gas delivery into furnaces, ovens, dryers
and boilers, making them crucial in assuring safe ignition, operation and
shutdown. Courtesy: Rockford Systems
Robert Sanderson, PE safe ignition, operation and shutdown. They also keep gas
Rockford Systems LLC out of the system whenever equipment is cycled or shut off.
T
A valve safety train isn’t a single piece of equipment.
Instead, it has many components including regulators, inline
hermal processes alter the physical, and some- strainers (sediment traps), safety shutoff valves (SSOV),
times chemical, properties of a material or coat- manual valves (MV), pressure switches and test fittings
ing. Examples of thermal processing are high- logically linked to a burner management system. Flame-
temperature operations such as heat-treating sensing components ensure flames are present when they
furnaces and kilns, and lower-temperature oper- are supposed to be, and not at the wrong time. Other com-
ations such as drying or baking (see Figure 1). ponents may consist of leak-test systems, gauges and pilot
Heat treating involves the use of heating materials, gas controls.
usually metal, to extreme temperatures and then quickly At a minimum, there are two crucial gas pressure
chilling or quenching to modify its physical properties, switches in a valve safety train — one for low pressure
making it harder or softer (see Figure 2). and one for high pressure. The low gas pressure switch
Many industries use baking, drying or other lower tem- ensures the minimum gas pressure necessary to operate
perature heating processes to modify aspects of a material is present. It will shut off fuel to the burner if the gas pres-
or coating. Facilities may also have incinerators for oxi- sure is below the setpoint. The high gas pressure switch
dizing pollutants, or air heaters for tempering climate air. ensures an excessive pressure is not present. It will shut
Applications for thermal processing are almost endless. off the fuel supply if the gas pressure is too high. Both
A valve safety train is at the heart of all thermal pro- switches must be proven safe to permit operation. There
cesses. (see Figure 3). These fuel delivery devices maintain also is an air pressure switch to ensure sufficient airflow is
consistent conditions of gasses into furnaces, ovens, dryers present to support burner operation. Some systems have
and boilers, among others, making them crucial in assuring supplementary pressure switches such as a valve-proving
Figure 1: Kilns are used in curing ceramics, drying wood, crema- Figure 2: Heat treating involves the use of heating materials, usu-
tions, drying malted barley for brewing and other fermentations ally metal, to extreme temperatures and then quickly chilling or
and agricultural grains. Gas-fired kilns must comply with the same quenching to modify its physical properties, making it harder or
valve safety train safety requirements as other thermal processes. softer. Courtesy: Rockford Systems
Courtesy: Rockford Systems
D
electrically work where they need to operate. Added to
these requirements are more advanced criteria: program-
elivering reliable real-time control functionality ming options, networking connections, security, commu-
has traditionally been a goal for those tasked nications protocols, flexibility and scalability. This article
with automating machinery, equipment and compares several popular controller technologies based
processes. If designers and engineers could on these factors, helping designers focus on what is
pick a digital control platform, integrate it with important to their applications.
field devices, program it to run as expected
and deliver reliable system operation for years or decades, Who are the players?
it was a job well done. When it comes to automating machines and processes,
Today’s situation is better, but more involved. It’s better industry has benefited from continual progress in digital
because many new control technology options are avail- control platforms. This technical field is often referred to
able; it’s more involved because users want optimized as operations technology (OT). Any OT control platform
operational performance, improved visibility and superior encompasses controllers and associated products like
connectivity to supervisory systems. Basic isn’t always input/output (I/O) modules, operator interface terminals
enough anymore as end users demand more advanced (OITs), human-machine interfaces (HMIs), instrumentation
features. In response, designers and original equipment and other devices (see Figure 1).
manufacturers (OEMs) must evaluate the field of controller For all automation systems, the controller is the brain
options to provide the right mix of characteristics for each and therefore a central component that must be selected
automation application. early, since it sets the detailed design path. While the
product spectrum presents overlapping capabilities, here
are the most popular controller categories for OT projects:
• Programmable logic controllers (PLCs): A rugged and
basic but capable control option, especially for discrete con-
trol applications
• Programmable automation controllers (PACs): Similar to PLCs,
but generally more advanced in the areas of communications, data
handling and process control applications
• Industrial personal computers (IPCs): Ruggedized
full-fledged computers, requiring significant user effort to
integrate hardware, software and remote input/output (I/O)
for control
• Edge programmable industrial controllers (edge con-
trollers): Built in a PLC/PAC form factor, yet incorporat-
ing advanced programming and security options, native
visualization and extensive communication abilities, much
like a PC.
When choosing a controller for an application, there’s
Figure 1: Industrial controllers such as this traditional PLC/PAC, are often more than one right answer. Choosing the correct
typically installed in control panels local to the equipment or pro- controller requires evaluating several characteristics and
cesses they monitor and automate. Courtesy: Opto 22 perhaps considering multiple applications.
PLCs and PACs, the classic choice ing more open as PLCs/PACs are adopting IEC 61131-3
Both PLCs and PACs are built and optimized for the OT programming languages and cross-platform programming
role and represent the classic choice. Certainly, PLCs and environments like CODESYS.
the more full-featured PACs have served as the principal However, the legacy aspect of PLCs/PACs can act as a
control products for most machines and many processes. kind of inertia, resisting adoption of the latest technologies.
They are fast, reliable and affordable – and an exact fit for This inertia is most apparent in generally weak support for
tough environments. Other complementary products like advanced networking and security features. PLCs/PACs
OITs and HMIs are developed in parallel to add visualiza- offer good connectivity at the OT level, but they tend to
tion and other features to these platforms. lack support for IT-centric programming languages and
However, many PLCs and PACs were burdened with protocols such as HTTPS and messaging queuing telem-
proprietary connectivity, specialized software and licensing etry transport (MQTT). For applications requiring built-in
costs. From a field device and I/O networking standpoint, connectivity up to IT-centric enterprise applications and
this situation has improved greatly due to Ethernet and historians, users typically need to integrate extra hardware
standardized industrial protocols. Also, software is becom- and software to bridge the gap.
Security is a similar story. Most modern aspects of IPCs for power users
cybersecurity did not exist when the first PLCs/PACs As PC technology became readily available and afford-
where conceived. Features commonly included with PCs able, many users looked to PCs for industrial control. The
and edge controllers, such as secure user accounts, commercial roots and economies of scale for PCs ensured
encrypted communications and virtual private networks the hardware and operating system platforms were well
(VPNs), must be bolted onto PLCs/PACs, requiring signifi- understood, and a PC solution had plenty of computing
cant end user expense, effort and risk. A better alternative power and display options.
is to make sure any required security features are native However, users soon found out commercial PCs were not
to the control platform. robust enough for many industrial controller applications.
Selecting the right controller for any application requires weighing many criteria. Courtesy: Opto 22
Sigma-7 Unshackles
Automation Productivity
Planning innovations for years to come? Or, are you
more focused on next week’s productivity numbers?
Yaskawa America, Inc. Drives & Motion Division 1-800-YASKAWA yaskawa.com For more info: http://budurl.me/yai1310
CHOOSING A CONTROLLER
mktg@seweurodrive.com
864-439-7537
www.seweurodrive.com
MOVE SECURELY INTO
THE CLOUD %8
, /7ǫ,1
5 ,7<
(& 8
6
WAGO Cloud
Microsoft
Amazon Web
Azure
Services
IBM
Other Cloud BLUEMIX
Services
IIoEATDY
R
www.wago.us/IIoT
Less means more!