Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Statistical Process Control (SPC) : K. N. Rai
Statistical Process Control (SPC) : K. N. Rai
Control
(SPC)
K. N. RAI
Quality Growth Services Pvt. Ltd.
H-13, Kirti Nagar, New Delhi, India
E-mail: qgs@qgspl.com,
Website: www.qgspl.com
Phone: +9111-25431737 / 25918332
1
ULTIMATE GOAL OF AN ORGANIZATION
Profits, Survival and Growth: How?
Products & Services must be preferable to
Customers over Competitors
Organization must continually meet Needs &
Expectations of Customers
i.e. Voice of Customers also called QUALITY
QGS/SPC Rev 01 3
Voice of Customer:
How to meet?
Must understand voice of customer
Must deploy it in
Voice of Design (Design Width) and
2
Process Control System
PRODUCT
THE
or
PROCESS
SERVICE
QGS/SPC Rev 01 5
Traditional Philosophy
– Goal Post Mentality
LSL USL
2 1 4
5
3
6
Is there a meaningful
difference between
kicks 2 and 6?
QGS/SPC Rev 01 6
3
Traditional Philosophy
LSL USL
Anything outside
the specification limits
represents QUALITY LOSSES
Goalpost Mentality
QGS/SPC Rev 01 7
4
PROCESS CONTROL: A BETTER APPROACH
M ethod
E nvironment PRODUCT
THE
P eople or
E quipment PROCESS
SERVICE
M aterial
Act Record
Analyze
VOICE OF THEQGS/SPC
PROCESS Rev 01 9
M ethod
E nvironment PRODUCT
THE
P eople or
E quipment PROCESS
SERVICE
M aterial
Data collection ,
Analysis &
Collect feedback to
Control Process
Act Record Inputs is a key
Analyze to Defect
Prevention.
VOICE OF THE PROCESS
QGS/SPC Rev 01 10
5
LEARNING
VOICE OF
PROCESS
THROUGH SPC
QGS/SPC Rev 01 11
SPC HISTORY
Developed By
Dr. Walter A. Shewhart
During 1920’s in Bell Lab
QGS/SPC Rev 01 12
6
SPC : Biggest Mis-concept:
SPC requires an in-depth and vast
STATISTICAL KNOWLEDGE
QGS/SPC Rev 01 13
14
7
GAINS OF SPC
1. REDUCES REJECTION
2. PARTS CAN BE EASILY ASSEMBLED
3. PARTS-CAN BE EASILY CHANGED IN THE FIELD
4. PERFORMANCE OF PRODUCTS IS IMPROVED
5. REDUCES COMPLAINTS OF CUSTOMERS
6. INCREASES PRODUCTION
7. REDUCES COST
8. REDUCES WASTAGES OF TIME
9. INCREASES CONFIDENCE OF CUSTOMERS.
15
8
1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8
VARIATION:
The basic principle of SPC
QGS/SPC Rev 01 17
VARIABILITY
• No two people are same…
• Temperature changes continuously…
• The products we produce change
continuously…
QGS/SPC Rev 01 18
9
VARIABILITY
All processes display variation e.g.
Aeroplane never lands or takes off at Dot
scheduled time (Variations from schedule )
Train Never comes / departs at scheduled
Dot time (Variation from schedule)
We never reach office / factory at Dot
scheduled time (Variation from Specs)
QGS/SPC Rev 01 19
VARIABILITY
Output Y= f(Inputs “x”);
So, Data in general, fluctuates because of :
Changes in Process Inputs e.g.
• Material Differences
• Equipment Differences
• Human Performance Differences
• Power Fluctuation, etc.
• And Many other variable Inputs
QGS/SPC Rev 01 20
10
Let us Watch Coin Game
Distance
QGS/SPC Rev 01 21
Distance
QGS/SPC Rev 01 22
11
Distance
QGS/SPC Rev 01 23
Common Causes
• Common to all individual readings in
time periods.
12
Special Causes
• Sudden in nature
• Usually attract the attention of local
people associated with the process.
Prediction
Prediction???
13
Distributions can differ in;
Location Spread
Shape
Or any combination
of these….
QGS/SPC Rev 01 27
SAMPLE :
Portion of Population selected for Analysis
PARAMETER :
Numerical measure that describes a characteristics of
a population
STATISTICS :
Numerical measure that describes a characteristics of
a sample QGS/SPC Rev 01 28
14
“Population Parameters” vs. “Sample Statistics” of
Central Tendency
Population
Sample
µ = Population Mean
Population
= Sample Standard
Standard Deviation
Deviation
MEAN
The Mean of ‘n’ numbers is the total of the
numbers divided by ’n’
15
Measure of Spread or
Dispersion
Range : The difference between the Largest and the
Smallest of a set of numbers. It is designated
by a capital “R”
QGS/SPC Rev 01 31
( x1 x) 2 ( x2 x) 2 ....( xn x) 2
n 1
QGS/SPC Rev 01 32
16
HISTOGRAM
Histograms give a Graphical View of the
distribution of the values
It reveals the amount of variation that any
process has within it.
5
4
FREQUENCY 3
64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72
HEIGHT (mm)
QGS/SPC Rev 01 33
17
• Hence, “Prediction” can be made
about the “Process”
• Mean;
• Standard Deviation; &
• Shape
QGS/SPC Rev 01 35
18
CONTROL CHARTS
• Transformation of a normal distribution curve in the form of 3
parallel lines, where
• The middle line indicates mean and called central line (C.L.)
• The upper line indicates Mean +3 Sigma and called upper control limit (UCL)
• The lower line indicates Mean -3 Sigma and called lower control limit (LCL)
U.C.L.
+3
Mean C.L.
-3
L.C.L.
QGS/SPC Rev 01 37
Types of Data
• Attribute • Variable
Anything that can be Anything that can be
classified measured
Either/Or Height
Pass/ fail Rupees
Good/ Bad Distance
Go/No Go Speed
Discrete Continues, infinite
Detection Oriented Stimulates Prevention
QGS/SPC Rev 01 38
19
Control Charts
Variable
Average and Range ( X-R )
Individual and Moving Range - IMR (X - MR)
Median Range Charts
Attribute
p / np Chart : Unit Nonconforming (Defectives)
c / u Chart : Number of Nonconformities (Defects)
QGS/SPC Rev 01 39
20
CONTROL CHARTS (Variable)
Average-Range ( X-R ) Chart
Precondition:
Measurement must be variable
Situation must be practically feasible to have
at least 2 measurements in short span.
Preparatory Steps
Create a suitable (conducive) environment
Understand the process (e.g CE Matrix)
Ensure Level 1 control i.e. Minimize un-
necessary variations .
QGS/SPC Rev 01 41
Average-Range ( X-R)Chart
Preparatory steps
Select the Subgroup Size
Rational Subgroup: Variability within subgroup should be small
QGS/SPC Rev 01 42
21
CONTROL CHARTS (Variable)
Average-Range ( X-R )Chart
Preparatory steps
Select Subgroup Frequency
Which can “Detect” change in the Process over span
of time.
For initial study, may be consecutive or a very short
interval.
QGS/SPC Rev 01 43
QGS/SPC Rev 01 44
22
Average-Range ( X-R)Chart
Data Collection
On a data collection sheet, called “Control Chart Sheet”
QGS/SPC Rev 01 45
46
23
AVERAGE-RANGE CONTROL CHARTS X-R
47
48
24
AVERAGE RANGE CHART
49
QGS/SPC Rev 01 50
25
TABLE OF CONSTANTS FOR
CONTROL CHARTS
QGS/SPC Rev 01 51
QGS/SPC Rev 01 52
26
DRAW AVERAGE- RANGE CHART
QGS/SPC Rev 01 53
QGS/SPC Rev 01 54
27
QGS/SPC Rev 01 55
QGS/SPC Rev 01 56
28
INTERPRETATION FOR CONTROL CHART
QGS/SPC Rev 01 57
29
Voice of the Process
-3 +3
Process Width
Design Width
LSL T USL
Voice ofQGS/SPC
the Customer
Rev 01 59
PROCESS CAPABILITY
30
PROCESS CAPABILITY
Standard Deviation () = R/d2 USL = 0.900
= 0.169/2.33 LSL = 0.500
= 0.0725
Process Capability
Cp = (USL - LSL) / 6 = (0.900 - 0.500) / 6 x 0.0725
= 0.920
CpkU = (USL - X) / 3 = (0.900 - 0.738) / 3 x 0.0725
= 0.743
CpkL = (X - LSL) / 3 = (0.738 - 0.500) / 3 x 0.0725
= 1.093
Cpk = 0.743
LSL USL
X
1.093 0.743
QGS/SPC Rev 01 61
Process Capability:
Cp Cpk Remarks
Process Capable
Continue Charting
Bring Cpk closer to Cp
X
Process has potential Capability
Improve Cpk by Local action
X X
Process lacks basic Capability
Improve process by Management
action
QGS/SPC Rev 01 62
31
INTERPRETATION FOR CONTROL CHART
Identify any out of control or special cause situation
Any point above UCL or below LCL:
QGS/SPC Rev 01 63
QGS/SPC Rev 01 64
32
INTERPRETATION FOR CONTROL CHART
7 Points in a row on one side of the average (AIAG):
7 Points in a row consistently increasing or decreasing
QGS/SPC Rev 01 65
Tests 1 & 2
Test 1. One Point Beyond Zone A
x
UCL
A
B
Test 2
C Caused by a process
C mean shift
B
A
LCL Test 2. Nine Points in a Row
x on One Side of the Center Line
UCL
Test 1 – Basic Test. A
B
Caused by a large C
change in the process C
B x
Requires immediate A
LCL
action
QGS/SPC Rev 01 66
33
Tests 1 & 2 – Demonstration
X-bar
Rule
#2 Rule
#1
LCL UCL
QGS/SPC Rev 01 67
Tests 3 & 4
Test 3. Six Points in a Row Steadily
Test 4 – Alternating
Increasing or Decreasing Patterns
UCL
A
Over adjustment
B x Shift-to-Shift variation
C
C
Machine-to-machine
B variation
A x
LCL Test 4. Fourteen Points in a Row
Alternating Up and Down
Test 3 – Trends up or UCL
A
down B
x
C
Caused by C
Mechanical wear B
Chemical depletion A
LCL
Increasing contamination
Etc. QGS/SPC Rev 01 68
34
Test 3 – Demonstration
X-bar
Rule
#3
LCL UCL
QGS/SPC Rev 01 69
Test 4 – Demonstration
X-bar
Rule
#4
LCL UCL
QGS/SPC Rev 01 70
35
Tests 5 & 6
Test 5. Two Out of Three Points in a
Row in the same Zone A or Beyond
Test 6
x x Another test for shifts
UCL
A
Test 1, 5, 6 are related
B
C and show conditions of
C high special cause
B
A
variability.
LCL
x
Test 6. Four Out of Five Points in a
row in the same Zone B and Beyond
Test 5 UCL
A
x
Rule
Rule
#6
#5
LCL UCL
How do you calculate the probabilities?QGS/SPC
What are they?
Rev 01 72
36
Tests 7 & 8
Test 7. Fifteen Points in a Row in Zone C
(Above and Below Centerline)
UCL
A Test 8 – Alternating Means
B x Mixtures
C Over control
C Two different processes on the
B same chart
A Test 8. Eight Points in a Row on Both Sides
LCL
of Centerline with None in Zone C
UCL
Test 7 – The Whitespace A
x
Test B
C
Occurs when within subgroup
C
variation is large compared to B
between group variation or, A
Old or incorrectly calculated LCL
limits
QGS/SPC Rev 01 73
How do you calculate the probabilities?QGS/SPC
What are they?
Rev 01 74
37
Interpretation Exercise
Interpret these control
charts according to the
previous eight rules.
QGS/SPC Rev 01 75
QGS/SPC Rev 01 76
38
INTERPRETATION FOR CONTROL CHART
OUT OF CONTROL / POSSIBLE CAUSES
SPECIAL CAUSE R-Chart X-Bar R Chart
SITUATIONS
Any Point Above UCL -Miscalculated/mis-plotted -Miscalculated / Mis-plotted
control limits / plot points Control Limits / Plot Points
-Measurement System Changed -Measurement System Changed
-Variability increased
Any Point Below LCL -do- -do-
7 Points in a Row above Avg. or -Spread Increased / Increasing -Process Average Changed or
Increasing -Measurement System Changed Changing
-Measurement System Changed
7 Points in a Row below Avg. or -Spread Decreased/ Decreasing -do-
Decreasing -Measurement System Changed
Substantially more than 2/3rd -Miscalculated/Mis-plotted Control Limits / Plot Points.
points in middle 1/3rd region -Process or Sampling method stratified
-Data is edited
Substantially fewer than 2/3rd -Miscalculated/Mis-plotted Control Limits / Plot Points.
points in middle 1/3rd region -Process or Sampling method stratified
QGS/SPC Rev 01 77
PROCESS CAPABILITY
• To measure the ability of the process to meet the specification
(Voice of Customer).
QGS/SPC Rev 01 78
39
PROCESS PERFORMANCE
Standard Deviation s = (xi-X)2
i=1
for n=80
QGS/SPC Rev 01 79
QGS/SPC Rev 01 80
40
STOP LIGHT CONTROL CHARTS
QGS/SPC Rev 01 81
+3
Mean
-3
QGS/SPC Rev 01 82
41
STOP LIGHT CONTROL CHARTS
QGS/SPC Rev 01 83
Destructive testing; or
Homogenous process
QGS/SPC Rev 01 84
42
MOVING RANGE CONTROL CHARTS
QGS/SPC Rev 01 85
QGS/SPC Rev 01 86
43
MOVING RANGE CONTROL CHARTS
QGS/SPC Rev 01 87
TABLE OF CONSTANTS –
CONTROL CHARTS
QGS/SPC Rev 01 88
44
SPC – Charts For All Occasions
%
Variable No Defective or Defects
Data? Defects?
Yes % Defective
No Constant Constant
Rational
I & MR chart Sample Sample
Subgroups?
Size? Size?
No No
Yes Yes Yes
p-chart u-chart
Yes Easy to
Subgroup
Compute
Size >9?
sigma?
np- or p-chart c- or u-chart
No Yes
No
QGS/SPC Rev 01 89
QGS/SPC Rev 01 90
45
CONTROL CHARTS (Attribute)
Select Subgroup Size
For p-chart, sufficiently large so that np>5)
QGS/SPC Rev 01 91
P Control Charts
QGS/SPC Rev 01 92
46
P Control Charts
QGS/SPC Rev 01 93
P Control Charts
Calculate the Proportion Defectives
P= nP/n
n = no. of items inspected
nP = no. of Defectives
Calculate Average Proportion Defectives
47
P Control Charts
QGS/SPC Rev 01 95
np Control Charts
Calculate the Average Number of Defectives
np = (n1p1 + n2p2 + … + nkpk) /k
np = No. of Defectives in Sample Size (n)
k = No. of Subgroups
n = Sample Size
QGS/SPC Rev 01 96
48
Process Capability for Attribute
QGS/SPC Rev 01 97
C Control Charts
QGS/SPC Rev 01 98
49
C Control Charts
QGS/SPC Rev 01 99
C Control Charts
50
C Control Chart
U Control Charts
Calculate Subgroup Proportion Defects
U= C/n
n = Variable Sample Size
51
Other Charts – Good for Operators
Pre-Control
Same as Stoplight but meant for Non-conformance
control instead of Process Control
Based on Process Specifications & not on Process
Variations (i.e. Sigma)
First ensure that Process has Flat Loss Function &
Process Performance is less than or equal to
Tolerance which means :
That all special sources of variations in the process are
being under Control
99.73% of pieces are being produced within specification
without sorting
52
THANK
YOU
53