Professional Documents
Culture Documents
016 Developmental-Behavioral Screening and Surveillance
016 Developmental-Behavioral Screening and Surveillance
after-school tutoring, summer school, and quality preschool or daycare). Figure 16-1 Developmental-behavioral surveillance/screening at well-
Use of accurate screens provides a focus for other well-visit activities. visits with children from birth to 6 yr of age: step-by-step. (Adapted
For example, screens relying on parents’ concerns identify specific with permission from Glascoe FP, Marks KP, Poon JK, Macias MM:
topics for developmental–behavioral promotion. The presence of Identifying and addressing developmental-behavioral problems: a
practical guide for medical and non-medical professionals, trainees,
delays prompts clinicians to conduct a particularly careful physical
researchers and advocates. Nolensville, TN, 2013, PEDStest.com, LLC;
exam; repeat hearing and vision screening; thoughtfully observe http://www.pedstest.com. Copyright 2013.)
parent–child interactions; take an especially detailed family medical/
social history; and similar actions.
Deployment of quality screens provides decision support for the establishing two-way consent forms for information sharing), evalua-
types of interventions needed, including whether clinical advice is suf- tion results and recommendations. Implementing quality screens and
ficient, whether more intensive hands-on services are required, and/or patient education in practices requires thoughtful planning and gen-
subspecialty medical referrals are needed. erating enthusiasm among clinic staff who must aid in the process.
Surveillance refers to ongoing monitoring (tracking over time) of Clinic flow templates and implementation worksheets are useful tools
such issues as parental concerns, children’s progress with milestones, for establishing efficient implementation procedures.
psychosocial risk and resilience factors, providers’ efforts to both detect
and address problems, and follow-up regarding child/family outcomes. Evidence-Based Tools
Surveillance also refers to use of clinical acumen in decision making Table 16-1 shows a range of measures useful for early detection of
via the incorporation of screening test results, child/family medical psychosocial risk and resilience, and developmental–behavioral prob-
histories, and the physical exam. Repeated accurate screening also lems, including autism spectrum disorders. Because well-child visits
serves the tasks of surveillance, but with efficiency and effectiveness. are brief and have enormous agendas (physical exams, immunizations,
Informal approaches to surveillance are known to be ineffective and of anticipatory guidance, safety and injury prevention, developmental
little benefit to families. promotion, and developmental–behavioral screening/surveillance),
tools relying on information from parents are ideal because they can
OVERCOMING LOGISTICAL CHALLENGES be completed in advance of appointments, either online or in writing,
IN PRIMARY CARE EARLY DETECTION whether at home, or while waiting for the encounter to begin. If tools
AND INTERVENTION are scored in advance of the patient encounter, clinicians can enter the
The lists of potential developmental-behavioral topics to be covered at exam room armed with needed information (e.g., parenting handouts,
well-child visits are extensive—far more than could be covered in the descriptions of services).
14-18 min allotted for such encounters. It is essential to cull topics to
those of greatest interest to parents so as to create “the teachable A Workable Process: Step-By-Step
moment” wherein parents are primed to learn most from clinicians’ The process of surveillance/screening as drawn from AAP policies is
recommendations. Solutions include posters in waiting rooms listing depicted in Figure 16-1 with a description provided in Table 16-2.
the range of topics on which providers can advise; previsit checklists Many tasks are staggered across visits so that each visit is only mini-
on which parents indicate topics of interest (and which topics have mally burdened with measurement. Red flags are noted in Table 16-3
already been covered in prior visits); and use of use quality screening but are not a substitute for evidence-based screening. Asymptomatic
tests eliciting parents’ specific concerns and providing decision support, children are those most in need of screening. Those with obvious
that is, when advice is probably sufficient vs when referrals are needed. symptoms simply need referral.
Clinicians are not always aware of the plethora of services available Table 16-2 mentions a range of tools by abbreviations as denoted
to families. Approaches to overcome this problem include creating a Table 16-1. The Resources Section (Table 16-4) provides guidance on
list of community programs to post in each exam room so that options finding supportive information, practice tools, and the like.
are visible to parents and providers and encouraging non-medical
services to provide prompt feedback on the status of referrals (e.g., Bibliography is available at Expert Consult.
Table 16-1 Print and Online Tools for Developmental–Behavioral Screening and Surveillance
The following chart is a list of measures meeting standards for screening test accuracy, meaning that they correctly identify, at all ages, at least 70-80% of children with disabilities while also
correctly identifying at least 70-80% of children without disabilities. All listed measures were standardized on national samples, proven to be reliable, and validated against a range of
diagnostic measures and diagnosed conditions. Not included are measures that fail to meet psychometric standards (limited standardization, absent validation, problematic sensitivity and
specificity) such as Denver-II.
The first column provides publication information and the cost of purchasing a specimen set. The “Purpose and Description” column provides details about content and information on
alternative ways, if available, to administer measures (e.g., waiting rooms). “Scoring” shows the types of results rendered. The “Accuracy” column shows the percentage of patients with
and without problems identified correctly. The “Time Frame/Costs” column shows the costs of materials per visit, along with the costs of professional time (using an average salary of
$60/hr) needed to administer each measure, but does not include time needed for generating referral letters. For parent self-report tools, administration time reflects not only scoring of
test results, but also the relationship between each test’s reading level and the percentage of parents with less than a high school education (who may or may not be able to complete
measures in waiting rooms because of literacy problems and thus will need interview administrations).
SCREENS FOR PRIMARY CARE
BEHAVIORAL AND/OR
DEVELOPMENTAL SCREENS
RELYING ON INFORMATION AGE
FROM PARENTS RANGE PURPOSE AND DESCRIPTION SCORING ACCURACY TIME FRAME/COSTS
Ages & Stages Questionnaires, Third 1-66 mo Purpose: Screening and surveillance of Cutoff scores set at 2 By age: Scoring time: 2 min
Edition (ASQ-3) (2009). Paul H. developmental milestones SD below the mean, Sensitivity: 82-89% Scoring cost: $2.40
Brookes Publishing Co., Inc., P.O. Description: Parents indicate children’s in 5 developmental Specificity: 77-92% Materials: ~$0.36-$0.48
92 Part II ◆ Growth, Development, and Behavior
Box 10624, Baltimore, MD 21285. developmental skills on 30 items plus overall domains; indicate By domain: Total Self-Report: $2.76-$2.88
(800-638-3775) ($295.00) concerns. The ASQ has a different form (5-8 need for referral or Sensitivity: 83% Interview Time: 12 min.
www.agesandstages.com. pages) for each age interval. Written at the monitoring Specificity: 91% Interview Cost: $14.40
Training Options: DVDs for purchase, 4th–6th grade level. Can be used in mass By disabilities: i.e., Scoring/Materials: $2.76-$2.88
case examples, and live training mail-outs for child-find programs. Manual cerebral palsy, visual Total Interview: $17.28
Electronic Options: See below contains detailed instructions for organizing and hearing
child-find programs and includes activity impairment:
handouts for parents. The ASQ-3 is available Sensitivity: 87%
in English and Spanish; the ASQ-2 is also
available in French and Korean with additional
translations underway. The ASQ-3 Learning
Activities kit is helpful for developmental
promotion
Parents’ Evaluations of Developmental Birth-8 yr Purpose: Screening/surveillance of Identifies when to By age: Scoring time: 1 min
Status (PEDS). (2013) PEDSTest.com, development/social–emotional/behavior/ refer and what Sensitivity: 91-97% Scoring cost: $1.20
LLC, 1013 Austin Court, Nolensville, mental health via parents’ concerns types of referrals Specificity: 73-86% Materials: $0.39
TN 37135 (615-776-4121) ($36.00) Description: 10 questions eliciting parents’ (and are needed; advise By disabilities, i.e., Total Self-Report: $1.59
www.pedstest.com providers’) concerns in English, Spanish, parents; monitor learning, intellectual, Interview Time: 2 min
Training Options: offers through its Vietnamese and many other languages. Items vigilantly; screen language, mental Interview Cost: $2.40
website self-training/train-the-trainer written at the 5th grade level. Longitudinal further (or refer for health, and autism Scoring/Materials: $1.59
support via downloadable slide Score and Interpretation Forms, assign risk screening); or spectrum disorders: Total Interview: $3.99
shows with notes, case examples, levels, track decision making and offer reassure Sensitivity: 71-87%
pre-/posttest questions, FAQs, specific guidance on how to address
participant handouts, website concerns. Provides screening, longitudinal
discussion list (covering all screens), surveillance, and triage for both
short videos, with some live training developmental and behavioral/social–
available emotional/mental health problems. PEDS can
Electronic Options: See below be used in conjunction with the PEDS : DM
(below) for compliance with AAP policies on
screening and surveillance, i.e., eliciting and
addressing parents’ concerns and monitoring
milestones
PEDS: Developmental Milestones Birth-8 yr Purpose: Screening/surveillance of Pass/fail cutoffs tied By age: Scoring time:
(Screening Version) (2008) PEDSTest. developmental and social–emotional/mental to performance Sensitivity: 70-94%; 1 min
com, LLC, 1013 Austin Court, health milestones above and below Specificity: 77-93% Scoring cost: $1.20
Nolensville, TN 37135 (615-776-4121) Description: PEDS-DM is designed to replace the 16th percentile By developmental Materials: $0.02
($275.00) informal milestones checklists (such as key for each item and domain: Total Self-Report: $1.22
www.pedstest.com items from other measures) with evidence. It its domain Sensitivity: 75-87%; Interview Time: 3 min
Training Options: offers through its consists of 6-8 items at each age level. Each Specificity: 71-88% Scoring/Materials: $1.22
website self-training/train-the-trainer item taps a different domain: fine/gross Total Interview: $3.82
support via downloadable slide motor, self-help, academics, expressive/ Direct Admin: 4 min
shows with notes, case examples, receptive language, social-emotional. The Scoring/Materials: $1.22
pre-/posttest questions, participant PEDS : DM provides screening, triage, and Total Direct Admin: $6.10
handouts, FAQs, website discussion surveillance via a longitudinal score form for
list (covering all screens), short tracking milestones progress. Written at the
videos, with some live training 2nd-3rd grade level and can be completed by
available. The PEDS : DM manual self-report, interview, or administered directly
includes extensive suggestions for to children. Forms are laminated and
training medical students, residents, completed with a dry erase marker.
and nurses Supplemental measures focused on AAP
Electronic Options: See below policy include the M-CHAT, Family
Psychosocial Screen, Pictorial PSC-17, the
SWILS, the Vanderbilt ADHD scale, and the
Brigance Parent-Child Interactions Scale.
When combined with PEDS, ensures full
compliance with AAP policy. In English,
Spanish, Taiwanese, and Portuguese, with
other languages in process. The PEDS : DM
manual and website contain developmental–
behavioral promotion handouts
Parent-report narrow-band screens (for social–emotional/behavioral/mental health, psychosocial risk, and autism spectrum disorder). These are valuable adjuncts in primary care and in
other settings but only when preceded by a broadband screen. Narrowband tools should not be used as the sole measure of developmental–behavioral status).
NARROWBAND SCREENS RELYING AGE
ON INFORMATION FROM PARENTS RANGE PURPOSE AND DESCRIPTION SCORING ACCURACY TIME FRAME/COSTS
Modified Checklist for Autism in 18-47 mo Purpose: Screening for ASDs Pass/fail scores based By age and disability: Scoring Time: 2 min
Toddlers (M-CHAT) (1999). Freely Description: Parent report of 23 yes-no on failing at least 2 i.e., autism spectrum Scoring costs: $2.40
downloadable in multiple languages questions written at 4th-6th grade reading critical items, or 3 disorders: Materials: $0.06
along with the Follow-up Interview at level. Screens for ASD. Downloadable scoring or more noncritical Sensitivity: 90%; Total (Self-Report): $2.46
www.mchatscreen.com template and Excel files for automated items Specificity: 99% Interview Time: 5 min (excluding
Also included in print in PEDS: scoring. Requires a follow-up interview for follow-up on any failed items)
Developmental Milestones. failed items (which can be requested by Interview Cost: $6.00
Commercial software vendors must referral sources). Available in multiple Scoring/Materials: $2.46
pay a licensing fee languages Total (Interview): $8.46
Training Options: the site contains a
guide to the needed follow-up
interview for missed items, and
houses research papers and reviews
on autism spectrum disorder (ASD)
screening
Electronic options: see below
Continued
Chapter 16 ◆ Developmental-Behavioral Screening and Surveillance 93
Table 16-1 Print and Online Tools for Developmental–Behavioral Screening and Surveillance—cont’d
NARROWBAND SCREENS RELYING AGE
ON INFORMATION FROM PARENTS RANGE PURPOSE AND DESCRIPTION SCORING ACCURACY TIME FRAME/COSTS
Brief-Infant-Toddler Social-Emotional 12-36 mo Purpose: Screening and surveillance of Cutpoints based on By age and disability: Scoring Time:
Assessment (BITSEA) (2006) Pearson/ milestones in social–emotional and mental child age and sex i.e., internalizing, 3 min
Psych Corp, Inc.19500 Bulverde Road, health show presence/ externalizing, and Scoring costs: $3.60
San Antonio, TX 78259 (800-627-7271) Description: 42 item parent-report measure absence of autism spectrum Materials: $1.56
($113.75) (with separate forms if clinical observation is problems and disorders: Total (Self-Report): $5.16
www.pearsonassessments.com needed). Identifies social–emotional/ competence Sensitivity: 80-95% Interview Time: 6 min
Training Options: none behavioral. problems and delays in Specificity: 80% Interview Costs: $7.20
Electronic Options: None competence. Written at the 4th-6th grade Scoring/Materials: $5.16
level. Can be followed by the more detailed Total (Interview): $12.36
ITSEA. Available in Spanish, French, Dutch,
94 Part II ◆ Growth, Development, and Behavior
Continued
Chapter 16 ◆ Developmental-Behavioral Screening and Surveillance 95
Table 16-1 Print and Online Tools for Developmental–Behavioral Screening and Surveillance—cont’d
SCREENS FOR OLDER CHILDREN (These screens focus on academic skills and mental health, including ADHD screening)
AGE
SCREENS FOR OLDER CHILDREN RANGE PURPOSE AND DESCRIPTION SCORING ACCURACY TIME FRAME/COSTS
Safety Word Inventory and Literacy 6-14 yr Purpose: Screening and surveillance of Single cutoff score by By age/academic Scoring Time: 1 min
Screener (SWILS). From PEDSTest. academic skills age, indicating the deficits: Scoring Costs: $1.20
com, LLC with items courtesy of Description: Children are asked (by parents or need for a referral Sensitivity: 73-88% Materials ~$0.06
Curriculum Associates, Inc. The professionals) to read 29 common safety Specificity: 77-88% Total (Self-Report): $1.26
SWILS is included in PEDS: words (e.g., high voltage, wait, poison) aloud. Administration time: ~7 min
Developmental Milestones The number of correctly read words is Admin/Scoring Costs: $8.40
(PEDS : DM) and is freely compared to a cutoff score. Results predict Materials/Scoring ~$1.26
downloadable at: http:// performance in math, written language, and a Total (Direct Admin): $9.66
www.pedstest.com/TheBook/ range of reading skills. Test content may
Chapter9 serve as a springboard to injury prevention
Training Options: none counseling and can be used to screen for
Electronic Options: none parental literacy. Because even non-English
speakers living in the United States need to
read safety words in English, the measure is
only available in English
Pediatric Symptom Checklist (PSC) 6-18 yr Purpose: Screening and surveillance of For the PSC, a single PSC/Pictorial PSC by Scoring time: 3 min
96 Part II ◆ Growth, Development, and Behavior
(1991). Freely downloadable in emotional/mental health, and conduct. Serves refer/nonrefer disability: i.e., mental Scoring Cost: $3.60
multiple languages in its 30 question as a necessary prescreen for sorting attention score; for the problems of any kind, Materials ~$0.06
version at http://psc.partners.org problems from competing conditions PSC-17/Pictorial across numerous Total (Self-Report): $3.66
The Pictorial PSC is useful with Description: Administered by youth/parent PSC-17, cutoffs for studies: Interview Time: 3 min
low-income Spanish and English self-report or by interview. The PSC/Pictorial attention, Sensitivity: 80-95% Interview Cost: $3.60
speaking families and is included in PSC are 35 short statements of problem internalizing, and Sensitivity: 68-100% Materials/Scoring: $3.66
its 17 item factorable version in behaviors capturing various mental health externalizing factors PSC-17/Pictorial Total (Interview): $7.26
PEDS: Developmental Milestones challenges. PSC-17 by specific
and is available at http:// The PSC-17/Pictorial PSC-17 are 17 item disability: i.e., ADHD:
www.pedstest.com/TheBook/ versions producing cutoffs for attentional, Sensitivity: 58%
Chapter9 internalizing (meaning depression or anxiety) Specificity: 91%
Training Options: none and externalizing problems (conduct, Internalizing Disorders:
Electronic Options: see below impulsivity, etc.) Readability is ~2nd grade. In Sensitivity: 52-73%
English, Spanish, Portuguese, Chinese, Dutch, Specificity: 74%
Filipino, French, Somali, and several other Externalizing Disorders:
languages Sensitivity: 62%
Specificity: 89%
CRAFFT (Car, Relax, Alone, Forget, Adolescents Purpose: To identify substance use (tobacco, For scoring, refer to Sensitivity: 76-93% Scoring time: 1-2 min
Friends, Trouble): (2009). Freely (11-21 yr) alcohol or other drug abuse) in adolescents “description” Specificity: 76-94% Scoring cost: $1.20-$2.40
downloadable from the Center for Description: self-/youth-report questionnaire Note: The AAP has (positive predictive Materials ~$0.06
Adolescent Substance Abuse that contains 3 initial screening questions (A1, published a value [PPV] 29-83%) Total (Self-Report): $1.26-$2.46
Research http://www.ceasar- A2, A3). If the first 3 questions are all recommended (negative predictive Interview time: 3 min
boston.org answered “no,” then providers should algorithm for value [NPV] 91-98%) Interview cost: $3.60
Training options: none routinely ask 1 more question (B1). If 1 or substance abuse However, there is no Materials/Scoring: $3.66
Electronic options: none more of the first 3 screening questions is screening, cross cultural data Total (Interview): $4.86-$6.06
positive/answered “yes,” then the provider assessment and (similar to the PSC but higher if further counseling
should ask 6 more questions (CRAFFT: B1, B2, intervention. and Pictorial PSC) and intervention is needed
B3, B4, B5 and B6). If the CRAFFT score is 0 Must be completed
or 1 (0 or 1 item answered “yes”), then give by youth
brief advice only. If the CRAFFT score is >2, confidentially
then this is a positive screen and a brief
assessment is needed
ELECTRONIC RECORDS OPTIONS FOR SCREENING AND SURVEILLANCE WITH QUALITY TOOLS
Essential definitions are:
Tablet PC—approaches that typically require a stylus to select among multiple-choice answers only;
Keyboards—approaches enabling users select multiple-choice responses but also type in text-based answers to questions
Touch-screens applications—these often allow parents to listen to questions and response options and then touch a simple response box (e.g., yes/no) thus reducing literacy demands;
Online—meaning hosted on a website and thus requiring an Internet connection, preferably high speed;
PDA—personal digital assistant such as a Palm Pilot or Blackberry usually requiring users to be online, with or without a keyboard
CD-ROM—offline but still electronic, and requiring installation on the user’s computer;
Parent Portal—online applications wherein parents can complete measures but do not see results; instead, these are sent to a different office computer for retrieval/inclusion in electronic
records
Telephony—automated calling, often along with appointment reminder systems through which multiple-choice screens can be administered;
Data Aggregation—almost all electronic applications create a database either online or on individuals’ computers (in the case of CD-ROMs) where all administered screens can be viewed,
overall results summarized, etc. Some web-based scoring services provide exported files; (e.g., Excel compatible) to allow users to view overall results. In all such applications, an
administrator of multiple sites can view all results
Webcasts/webinars—These are training options online, either live on a specific day and, eventually constantly available on publishers’ websites.
COMPANY/OFFERINGS TRAINING/SUPPORT OPTIONS DESCRIPTION AND PRICING
CHADIS: http://www.chadis.com Downloadable guides, live training at CHADIS includes decision support for more than 75 both diagnostic and parent/family focused
ASQ, M-CHAT, PSC, and other measures exhibits, and other training services measures, such as the Vanderbilt ADHD Diagnostic Rating Scale, and various parent and
online for touch-screen, tablet PCs, on request adolescent depression, substance abuse, domestic violence and other inventories. CHADIS offers
keyboards, telephony and parent portal integration with existing electronic healthcare records (EHRs), works with a range of equipment/
methods). Spanish language applications applications, and automatically generates reports. Pricing is via site license and ~$695 per year
coming soon per full-time provider. Includes options for Maintenance of Certification (MOC), quality
improvement (QI) credit, and e-chapters for clinicians
PEDS Online: http://www.pedstest.com/ Slide shows, website FAQs, email This site offers PEDS, PEDS:DM, and the MCHAT for keyboard applications (allowing for actual
online support, online videos, discussion list comments from parents). Offers a parent portal (wherein families do not see the results). Scoring
PEDS, PEDS : DM, M-CHAT online (for is automated as are summary reports for parents, referral letters when needed, and ICD-9/
keyboards) in English and Spanish procedure codes. In English and Spanish. Health Level Seven (HL7)/Health Insurance Portability
and Accountability Act (HIPPA)/Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) compliant
integration with electronic records is available as is data export and aggregate views of records.
$2.00-$2.75 per encounter (depending on volume)
Patient Tools: http://www.patienttools.com Webcasts/webinars, live support by Patient Tools offers the ASQ (with audio option), ASQ : SE (with audio option), MCHAT, PEDS (in a
(M-CHAT, ASQ, ASQ : SE and other measures phone, email survey version, i.e., closed-ended questions), PSC, the Vanderbilt ADHD Scales and a wide range
online for tablet, i.e., touch-screen PCs) of behavioral/mental health measures in multiple languages for adolescents and adults. A
practice-based approach provides access in the office via dedicated Survey Tablet equipment,
wireless tablet PCs and kiosk PC; or online from home with results available in the office. Access
fees are $58.00/mo for ongoing hosting, data storage, reporting, custom programming, telephone
technical and installation support. Uses client’s PCs or alternately Survey Tablet equipment,
including rentable docking stations, lease-purchasing arrangements, or software purchase ($1,525)
plus hosting and installation ($58.00/mo) with additional licensing fees for some measures
Ages and Stages-3 and ASQ : SE: Live training, online training Web-based management system offers automated scoring, reporting, referral tracking, and
http://www.ASQonline.com customizable letters for parents/providers for ASQ-3 and ASQ : SE. ASQ Pro is designed for
Online administration and separately on a single-site programs ($149.95 annual subscription, plus quarterly billing for screens used) and ASQ
CD-ROM for offline administration with Enterprise is designed for multisite programs ($499.95 annual subscription, plus quarterly billing
keyboards and tablet PCs for screens used). Online questionnaire completion available through ASQ Family Access ($349.95
annual subscription). ASQ Family Access provides secure, customizable website for parent
completion of questionnaires, i.e., a parent portal ($349.95 for an annual subscription plus $79.95
for annual support)
Adapted with permission from Glascoe FP, Marks KP, Poon JK, Macias MM. Identifying and addressing developmental-behavioral problems: a practical guide for medical and non-medical professionals, trainees,
researchers and advocates. Nolensville, TN, 2013, PEDStest.com, LLC; http://www.pedstest.com. Copyright 2013.
Chapter 16 ◆ Developmental-Behavioral Screening and Surveillance 97
98 Part II ◆ Growth, Development, and Behavior