Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Naval War - Battle of Jutland
Naval War - Battle of Jutland
Naval War - Battle of Jutland
BATTLE OF JUTLAND
INTRODUCTION
1. During World War One Germany faced an age-old problem. How does a land
power can defeat a sea power? Two thousand years earlier, the Spartans
faced the same problem with the Athenians. After 30 years of fighting the
Spartans finally defeated the Athenians, not on land but on the Aegean Sea
and Athens fell. A land empire can only defeat a sea empire at sea. For land
power like Germany the loss of her Navy would be a setback, but not a
serious defeat. For sea power like Britain the loss of her navy would mean
complete and utter defeat. This strategic thought process worked as the main
essence of German’s sea war plan in WWI.
2. When the war broke out between the British and the German Empires in
1914, the world had been in a state of uneasy peace for many years. The all-
powerful British Empire had seen with mounting alarm how the confident young
German Empire was growing in power and ambition. As the interests of these two
great powers clashed in different places, it became obvious that war, the
traditional way of settling rivalries between the empires would soon be called for.
Events following in the wake of the assassination of the Arc Duke Ferdinand in
Sarajevo brought these tensions to a head and the WWI was declared.
1
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
- It was the last sea battle in which all types of classic ships like
battle cruisers, battle ships, armoured cruisers, light cruisers and
destroyers played their parts.
- It was also the first sea battle in which air power in the form of aerial
reconnaissance made its debut in the maritime environment.
AIM
5. With this little bit of introduction, gentleman the aim of our presentation is
to analyse the ‘Battle of Jutland’ with special emphasis on maritime strategy,
leadership trend, tactical implication and technological perspective of sea warfare
and to derive lessons for future.
SCOPE
6. The presentation will be covered in the sequences as you can see in the
slide:
7. The background of the battle, Command and Force Structure and the
Sequences of the Battle will be covered by Major Baquing and the Outcome of the
battle, Battle analysis on maritime strategy, tactics and leadership trend will be
covered by Lt Cdr Habib. The analysis on war technology, application of principle
of war and the Lesson learnt will be discussed by me. At the end of our
presentation there will be also a question and answer session, where we will be
clearing your doubts.
2
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
9. There was a faction inside the German navy, who wanted a more positive
policy. In February 1916, Vice Admiral Reinhard Scheer was appointed to
command the High Seas Fleet. He planed to reduce the numerical superiority of
Grand fleet by a new method of offensive technique. Unfortunately the British
Admiralty since 1914 had been deciphering the majority of German messages.
When, it was realised in London that the High Sea Fleet would be at sea, Admiral
Jellicoe the commander Grand Fleet was ordered to take his fleet out. Thus, the
scene was set for the first and last battle between large fleets of dreadnoughts.
BATTLE PLAN
3
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
11. British Plan. The British had their own plan too. For the last 250 years
British had been successfully using the tactics of close blocked against French,
Spanish and Portuguese. However, the British Admiralty was astute enough to
realise that the nature of the sea warfare had changed and that a close blocked
would not be effective because steam ships of British would require a fleet at
least three times as large as the Germans. This was obviously very costly and
inefficient. However, the British fleet based at Scapa Flow had effectively imposed
distance blockade in the North Sea. However, the ‘Hit-and-Run’ tactics of German
ships was really bothering the British fleet during that time. Grand fleet was
looking for an opportunity to level the score with the High Sea Fleet. On receiving
the decipher messages of the High Sea Fleet’s plan, Admiral Jellicoe was ordered
to take the Grand Fleet out to attain the objectives as you can see on the slide:
COMMAND STRUCTURE
12. Grand Fleet. Now, let’s have a look to the command structure of
both the forces. Firstly, The Grand Fleet was positioned in three different places
namely, Scapa Flow, Invergordon and Rosyth. The detailed Command structure of
Grand Fleet is shown on the screen.
4
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
Grand Fleet
(C-IN-C Admiral Jellicoe)
1st & 4th Battle Sqn 5th Battle Sqn 2nd Battle Sqn
2nd Cruiser Sqn 1st & 2nd Battle Cruiser 1st Cruiser Sqn
Sqn
3rd Battle Cruiser Sqn 1st, 2nd & 3rd Light Part of 11th Torpedo-boat
Cruiser Sqn destroyer Sqn
4th Light Cruiser Sqn Part of 1st, 9th, 10th, -
and 13th Torpedo-boat
destroyer Sqn
4th, part of 11th and 12th - -
Torpedo-boat destroyer
Sqn
13. High Seas Fleet. On the other hand, gentleman, the scouting group
and the main battle squadron of high sea fleet was stationed at willhelmshaven.
The command structure of the High Sea Fleet is shown on the screen.
ORBAT
5
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
14. Force Comparison. Gentleman lets have a look to the comparative force
structure of the two belligerents in terms of their various types of ships:
Battle Ship 28 16
(Dreadnoughts)
Battle Cruiser 09 05
Battle Ship (Pre- Nil 06
dreadnoughts)
Armoured Cruiser 08 nil
Light Cruiser 26 11
Destroyer 77 61
Total Ships 148 99
Total tonnage 1,250,000 660,000
Total Crew 60,000 45,000
SEQUENCE OF BATTLE
15. Prelude. On May 30, 1916, Jellicoe received a signal that the German
High Sea Fleet was massing in strength off Wilhelmshaven. That news was
enough to spur Jellicoe into action. He arranged with Vice Admiral Beatty, the
commander of the British Battle cruisers in the Firth of Forth, to rendezvous with
him in a position to the south of Norway, near the entrance to the Skagerrak, by
May 31, afternoon. British fleet thus set the sail at the night of 30 May to
intercept the High Sea Fleet about four-and-half hours before the high sea fleet
had even left the port.
16. First Encounter. On the other hand, early morning of 01 June, Hipper
with his 1st and 2nd Scouting group steered north. By mid day, both Hipper and
Beatty were abreast to the Jutland bank steaming on parallel courses only 50
miles separated out of each other’s sight. The two forces sighted each other for
the first time when coincidentally both the forces sent their ships to investigate a
Danish merchant ship.
17. Germans Drew First Blood. Within one hour of this sighting, the
battle cruisers of both the fleets opened fire. Hipper’s ships had quickly displayed
a gunnery superiority over their opponents who were very slow to find the
accurate ranges. The Lion, Princes Royal and Tiger had been heavily hit before a
6
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
single German ship had suffered any damage. German battle cruisers continued
to shoot with deadly accuracy and were able to sink HMS Indefatigable and
Queen Marry.
18. Grand Fleet Arrival. On receiving the enemy contact report from Beatty,
Admiral Jellicoe had positioned the ships under Admiral Hood and immediately
dispatched to assist Beatty. The sudden appearance of the Grand Fleet took the
Germans by great surprise.
19. British Onslaught. The British Fleet opened fire on the Germans who
were blinded by the setting sun. Lutzow, The Flagship of Hipper was extensively
damaged forcing Hipper to shift to Moltke. During this phase the high sea fleet
was in a severe disadvantage and suffered heavy punishment. Being
outnumbered and out manoeuvred, Scheer realised that night engagement
offered his fleet the only option to getaway from the Grand Fleet.
20. Night Engagements. The British did not favour night engagements
as it would expose their ships to torpedo attacks by the German destroyers and
the British were not trained in night fighting. Admiral Jellicoe had planned to
block the escape of the Germans and strike them again in the morning. The
British battle cruisers had been stationed to cover the escape route and waiting
for daylight to renew the engagements.
22. Battle Damage. At the end of the battle the losses incurred by both
the forces are shown on he screen:
7
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
Battle Cruisers 03 01
Destroyers 08 05
Total 14 11
23. Jutland was undoubtedly a material and moral victory for the German High
Seas Fleet whilst being a strategic victory for the British Grand Fleet. The
Germans had inflicted heavier losses on the numerically superior Grand Fleet and
had escaped near destruction but had failed to break the British blockade or
control of the North Sea and had not altered the balance of power in any
meaningful way. On the other hand, The Royal Navy had failed to achieve a new
Trafalgar, to both it's and the British public's disappointment, although it had
ended the battle in control of the battlefield and with the balance of power
unchanged.
24. The far reaching result of Jutland was that it convinced Scheer and the
German Naval staff that the only way of gaining naval victory was via
unrestricted submarine warfare, and not by defeating the British in battle. By
summer 1916, the German high command decided that a further major naval
battle would involve unacceptable risks. The High Sea Fleet was placed on the
defensive, and their morale suffered badly, which resulted in mutiny in August
1917 and subsequently a major revolt in 1918.
8
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
25. Gentleman now lets analysis the battle from maritime strategic
perspective.
26. British Strategy. British had been successfully using the strategy of close
blockade in the North Sea. British fleet based at Scapa Flow effectively blockaded
North Sea. Distance Blocked proved to be quite effective. British recognised that
the maintenance of the command of the sea was far more vital than the defeat of
the German Fleet. However, Admiral Jellicoe believed that complete destruction of
the High Sea Fleet by decisive battle would ensure the complete command of the
sea. Thus reacted on receiving the news of German’s initiative.
27. German Strategy. German Naval strategy was built on caution and
defensive concepts. They thought the confrontation was unnecessary in any
events since mines and submarines would tackle the toll of British ships. But the
pressure of the British Blockade was becoming painful. In view of their
deteriorating position, The German began to reassess their naval strategy to gain
limited sea use capabilities by adopting Fleet-in –being strategy. This strategy of
the High Sea Fleet is also reflected in Admiral Scheer’s historical speech, “ The
Fleet would strike when the circumstances are favourable,.............Fleet will
therefore, seek battle with the English Fleet only when a state of equality has
been achieved by the method of guerrilla warfare “.
Tactical Analysis
9
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
29. Gun Engagements. The British tactics during the war were to deploy in
the line ahead formation, at right angles to the enemy’s line of bearing so
that heavy broad side could be used to defeat the enemy. This engagement
was only possible if the enemy continued in line-ahead formation. The
British’s always aimed at crossing the enemy’s ‘T’ in order to engage where
as the Germans knowing their limitations avoided direct engagement with the
Grand Fleet.
30. The Battle Turn. The Germans successfully executed the battle turn
and managed to evade the British attacks. In a ‘battle turn’ each ship
wheeled over hard and reversed course in succession beginning from the
rear. When this turn was being executed the German destroyers to hide the
movement deployed smoke screen and subsequently the destroyers would
break out to carry out a torpedo attack on the pursuing enemy.
32. Night Attack. The German organisation at night was very good. Their
system of recognition signals was extremely well practised where as the
British’s had no system of recognition at night. The Germans made good use
of their searchlights, which were superior to the British. Their method of
firing at night produced excellent results. The British were poorly trained in
the night fighting capability.
33. Present Day Implication. The tactical concepts adhered by both the
fleets has little significance in today’s warfare. With the advent of long range
radar’s, air cover and the capability to engage enemy at extended range (BVR)
allows flexibility of operations. The modern day fleet can be further subdivided
into various groups, units and elements. These ships although operating
independently can remain in touch with each other due to modern W/T systems,
which were not available to forces in Jutland. Engaging enemy war ships with
10
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
guns today would be the last resorts. Major of the surface combatants is fitted
with ultra modern surface to surface missiles and fire control systems.
Implication of C3I
34. Grand Fleet. At the beginning of the battle, British Naval Intelligence had
captured German cipher and signal book and square maps of North Sea from the
Russians. The Grand fleet had centralized command and the co-ordination
between various commands and units were not achieved. The British trusted on
visual communication.. As a result C-in-C were unable to keep control of the
comperatively modern high-speed fleet in a smoke filled battle zone. The under
commands did also failed to report the positions and movements of enemy ships
in time to the command ship.
35. High Seas Fleet. Although Germans cipher and crypto system was
disclosed by the British intelligence, German’s were unaware of the fact.
However, German’s centralised command and control was quite effective and
they maintained it all through in the Battle.
Leadership Trend
36. Grand Fleet Commander Admiral Jellicoe. The then First Sea Lord
Fisher used to describe Admiral Jellicoe as future Nelson. With a long and
distinguish career, Jellicoe was a genius in his own way. In addition to his firm
belief in the ’line ahead’ and the’ big guns’ his strategy for the fleet emphasised
defence. However, he was found quite rigid in traditional thinking and not flexible
in some occasions. He also was in favour of centralised command, which proved
ineffective in Jutland.
37. High Sea Fleet Commander Admiral Scheer. On the other hand,
Admiral Scheer was appointed as C-IN-C of High Sea Fleet by replacing Admiral
Phol, a man of ill health and ingrained caution. Scheer was a man, young in
ideas, willing to take risking orders that new methods and inventions might be
tried. He was daring and inventive. In this battle he correctly appreciated his
formidable enemy and took a valuable decision of withdrawal at night through
enemy.
11
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
War Technology
38. Gentleman, let’s discuss the war technology of time. First of all let us see
the ship design philosophy of both the forces.
12
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
Germans. One of the main reasons behind this was the superior range
finder as used by the Germans. The British range finders where co-
incidence was the Germans were stereoscopic. The British range finders
were also of a shorter base (9-foot) than the Germans, which made long
distance range, finding more difficult. So the German range finders were
quicker to find the correct range.
13
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
40. Principle of war followed by the British and the German are mentioned
below:
a. Maintenance of Aim. Both the British and the Germans had
specific and a solid set of aim to achieve national objectives. Due to the
overwhelming concentration of British forces the Germans could not
maintain their aim till the end of the battle. British could maintain the aim
throughout the battle.
14
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
41. Naval warfare has changed over the period of years since the battle of
Jutland. Today, technology is at the forefront of any battle. Modern sensors
and precision weapons have changed the whole perspective of the naval
warfare. The pertinent aspects of Jutland, which deserve attention today, are
discussed below:
c. Numerical achievement does not always reflect the out come of the
battle. German sunk more British ships but the out come of battle was
different.
15
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
e. Sound war plan may get ruined due to lack of information security.
Scheer could not gain success out of his sound war plan, as British could
decipher all German messages.
CONCLUSION
43. The British fleet, though had out manoeuvred the Germans
strategically, its material weaknesses were evident. The German
16
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
44. Both the fleets tried to use the principle of war effectively. Due to
the British overwhelming concentration of forces the Germans could not
maintain their aim till the end.
45. The battle of Jutland gave us a number of lessons for future and till
today adequately draws our attention. The famous historian Captain
Liddell Hart thus appropriately said, “No battle in all history has spilled so
much ink as Jutland did”.
17
RESTRICTED