Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Comments For PHD Work Done

    Uploaded by

    Jitender Singh
    10 views1 page
    The thesis comprehensively studied piled raft foundations, raft foundations, and raft foundations reinforced with geogrid and geocell through experimental testing and numerical modeling using neural networks. Extensive experiments were conducted and results were compiled efficiently. Neural networks were used to develop mathematical equations to understand complex behaviors and allow future experiment design without extensive testing. The thesis validated results using field situations but needs to address questions on calculation of raft stiffness, foundation type comparisons, experiment design, material choices, performance comparisons, implementation of results, neural network usage, algorithms, and error corrections.

    Original Description:

    vjvhjb

    Original Title

    Comments for Phd Work Done

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The thesis comprehensively studied piled raft foundations, raft foundations, and raft foundations reinforced with geogrid and geocell through experimental testing and numerical modeling using neural networks. Extensive experiments were conducted and results were compiled efficiently. Neural networks were used to develop mathematical equations to understand complex behaviors and allow future experiment design without extensive testing. The thesis validated results using field situations but needs to address questions on calculation of raft stiffness, foundation type comparisons, experiment design, material choices, performance comparisons, implementation of results, neural network usage, algorithms, and error corrections.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    10 views1 page

    Comments For PHD Work Done

    Uploaded by

    Jitender Singh
    The thesis comprehensively studied piled raft foundations, raft foundations, and raft foundations reinforced with geogrid and geocell through experimental testing and numerical modeling using neural networks. Extensive experiments were conducted and results were compiled efficiently. Neural networks were used to develop mathematical equations to understand complex behaviors and allow future experiment design without extensive testing. The thesis validated results using field situations but needs to address questions on calculation of raft stiffness, foundation type comparisons, experiment design, material choices, performance comparisons, implementation of results, neural network usage, algorithms, and error corrections.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 1

    The thesis titled ‘Comparative study of piled raft foundation and raft foundation on reinforced

    sand bed’ by Research Scholar from NIT Jalandhar covers a problem from all aspects of work
    undertaken viz. experimental, numerical and modern tools application.

    The thesis is complete and is a good one in many aspects which are highlighted below:

    The thesis has been written in a complete and comprehensive manner and chapters had been
    properly introduced and summed up. The experimental work has been done extensively as it
    includes tests series on raft, piled raft foundation and raft reinforced with geogrid and geocell.
    The number of experiments conducted to understand each of the type is highly appreciated.
    The compilation of extensive multiple results from different experiment series was a difficult
    work which has been compiled efficiently. The use of modern tools like Neural networks for
    geotechnical engineering problems solution and understanding is very new and this thesis has
    explored the possibility of these methods. Use of Neural networks to develop mathematical
    equations for understanding of complex phenomenon in case of piled-raft foundation and also
    for geogrid and geocell in itself is a very important work done. This will help in designing of
    experiments in near future without much investment on experiments. The quantification of
    contribution of different factors over behavior of piled-raft, geogrid and geocell was very
    interesting which has been done using neural networks. Use of on field situation to
    implement the work done was very well presented and it shows the results have been
    properly validated.

    Besides the above points, the research scholar needs to address the following points for the
    final compilation

    1. How the stiffness of raft is calculated?


    2. Why the comparison has been done among piled-raft foundation, geogrid and geocell?
    3. How the experiments for different foundation types had been designed?
    4. Why the steel piles are used in the study?
    5. Why geocell has been said to be better than geogrid?
    6. How experimental results have been implemented in real field problem?
    7. Why Neural network is used for the study.
    8. What algorithm has been used in developing neural networks?
    9. Why BPNN and GRNN are used and which one is better?
    10. Some typing errors need to be corrected.

    You might also like