Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal Supportive Edu 1
Jurnal Supportive Edu 1
Jurnal Supportive Edu 1
Aims and objectives. The aim of this study was to assess the effect of a supportive
educational intervention developed based on the Orem’s self-care theory on the What does this paper contribute
self-care ability of patients with myocardial infarction. to the wider global clinical
Background. Patients with cardiovascular disease suffer from the lack of knowledge community?
about the disease and consequently are not able to fulfil their own self-care needs. • The supportive educational inter-
Design. This was a randomised controlled trial conducted in 2012. vention developed based on the
Methods. We recruited a random sample of 66 patients with myocardial infarc- Orem’s self-care theory can
improve patients’ self-care abil-
tion who had been recently discharged from coronary care unit. The study setting
ity.
was two university hospitals located in Khorasan, Iran. Patients were randomly • Cardiac patients need self-care
allocated to either the experimental or the control groups. Patients in the experi- support. The supportive educa-
mental group received education, support, and counselling while patients in the tional intervention developed
control group received no intervention. We employed a demographic question- based on the Orem’s self-care
naire and the Myocardial Infarction Self-Care Ability Questionnaire for data theory can help health care pro-
fessionals identify and fulfil
collection and SPSS version 16.00 for data analysis.
patients’ self-care needs.
Findings. After the study, patients in the experimental group had higher levels of
self-care knowledge, motivation and skills compared to the prestudy readings and
the control group.
Conclusion. The supportive educational intervention developed based on the
Orem’s self-care theory can improve nonhospitalised patients’ self-care ability and
positively affect public health outcomes. Consequently, using the developed pro-
gramme for providing follow-up care to nonhospitalised patients is recommended.
Relevance to clinical practice. Having the ability to develop caring systems based
on the nursing theories is a prerequisite to standard nursing practice. Identifying
patients’ educational needs is a fundamental prerequisite to patient education.
Our findings revealed that the supportive educational intervention developed
based on the Orem’s self-care theory can help health care providers identify and
fulfil patients’ self-care needs.
Authors: Ali Mohammadpour, BSN, MSN, PhD in nursing, Asso- bad, Iran; Ali Alami, MD, PhD, Assistant Professor, Department
ciated Professor, Department of Nursing, Social Determinants of of Health School of Public Health; Social Determinants of
Health Research Center, Gonabad University of Medical Health Research Center, Gonabad University of Medical
Sciences, Gonabad, Iran. Narjes Rahmati Sharghi, BSN, Student Sciences, Gonabad, Iran; Majid Akhond, BSN, Student in Master
in Master of Nursing Education, Student Research Committee, of Intensive Care Nursing, Mashhad University of Medical
Gonabad University of Medical Sciences, Gonabad, Iran; Shahla Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
Khosravan, BSN, MSN, PhD in nursing, Associated Professor, Correspondence: Narjes Rahmati Sharghi, Student in Master of
Department of Community and Mental Health Nursing, Faculty Nursing Education, Student Research Committee, Gonabad University
of Nursing and Midwifery, Social Determinants of Health of Medical Sciences, Gonabad, Iran. Telephone: +98 09173000878
Research Centre, Gonabad University of Medical Sciences, Gona- E-mail: narjes.rahmati.sharghi@gmail.com
Key words: clinical trial, Orem’s self-care theory, patient education, self-care
ability
based on the Orem’s self-care theory on self-care ability of ability, we developed the 47-item MI Self-Care Ability
patients with myocardial infarction. Questionnaire (MISCAQ). The MISCAQ consisted of three
dimensions including self-care knowledge (13 items), self-
care motivation (12 items) and self-care skills (22 items).
Methods The MISCAQ items included patients’ self-care knowledge,
motivation, and skills in areas such as the symptoms of MI,
Design cardiac drugs and their side effects, healthy diet for patients
with MI, permitted level of sexual activity and heart disease
This was a randomised controlled trial conducted in 2012.
risk factors (such as obesity, hypertension, and emotional
and mental stress). The MISCAQ consisted of both multi-
Participants ple-choice and Likert-type questions. The possible ranges
for the scores of the knowledge, motivation and skills
The study setting was four coronary care units affiliated to
dimensions of MISCAQ were 0–52, 0–48, and 0–88,
two university hospitals located in Southern Khorasan, Iran.
respectively. The items of MISCAQ were generated based
The study population consisted of all patients with myocar-
on an extensive literature review and the researchers’ clini-
dial infarction (MI) who had been recently discharged from
cal and teaching experiences. Moreover, we invited nine
the study setting. The inclusion criteria were having an age
nurse educators, four cardiac care nurses and two cardiolo-
of less than 70 years, having a history of previous hospitali-
gists to confirm the content validity of the questionnaire.
sation, having a definite diagnosis of MI—as established by
We included their comments in the final version of the MI-
a cardiologist and documented in patients’ medical records
SCAQ. The reliability of the MISCAQ was assessed using
—, and having no history of speech and hearing impair-
the test–retest method. Accordingly, we asked 20 patients
ments and physical and mental disabilities. We referred to
with MI to respond to the questionnaire. Two weeks later,
the medical records units of the study setting and listed the
we asked the patients to complete the questionnaire for the
names of all patients with MI who had been discharged
second time. The inter-class correlation coefficient between
during the two years preceding the study. The list included
test and retest readings was 0758.
80 patients meeting the study inclusion criteria. Then, we
recruited a random sample of 66 names from the list. Intervention
Thereafter, we phoned the recruited patients, provided
Initially, we performed a pretest to assess the patients’ self-
them with information about the aim and process of the
care ability and to identify their educational needs in terms
study, and invited them to the study. All the invited
of MI self-care. Then, based on the identified educational
patients agreed to participate in the study.
needs, we provided the patients in the experimental group
We used the results of Mehri et al. study (2008) and
with information regarding the functions of cardiovascular
the following formula for calculating the sample size,
þ ðZ1 bÞÞ2 system, aetiology and risk factors for MI, management of
n ¼ 2ððZ1 a=2Þ
ðl1l2Þ=S . Accordingly, with a confidence level
MI risk factors, and the importance of adherence to treat-
of 95% and a power of 80%, the sample size was deter-
ment and dietary regimens. Educations were provided in
mined to be 31 patients in each group. We employed the
three 45-minute sessions. Moreover, during the first
coin-tossing method to randomly assign the patients to
45 days after the educations, we made frequent phone calls
either the control or the experimental groups. We asked
to the patients in the experimental group and provided
the patients to refer to the study setting to receive the
them with the required counselling services in terms of MI
study intervention.
self-care. The patients were also able to make phone calls
to or visit the researchers to receive further education. On
Instruments
the other hand, the patients in the control group received
The study instrument consisted of a demographic question- no intervention.
naire and the MI Self-Care Ability Questionnaire. The Finally, we performed a post-test to re-assess the patients’
demographic questionnaire consisted of questions regarding self-care ability.
patients’ age, gender, educational status, weight, height, his-
tory of previous MI, family history of MI, and systolic and
Data analysis
diastolic blood pressures.
To assess the patients’ universal, developmental and We employed the Statistical Package for Social Sciences ver-
health deviation self-care requisites as well as their self-care sion 16.0 (SPSS version 16.0; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA)
to analyze the study data. We described the study data characteristics. The results of the independent-samples t
using indices such as mean and standard deviation. More- and the Fisher’s exact tests revealed that before the inter-
over, we employed the independent- and paired-samples vention, there was no statistically significant difference
t-tests to compare the study groups in terms of self-care between the study groups in terms of characteristics such as
ability. The level of significance was set at below 005. age, gender, education, body mass index, mean arterial
blood pressure, number of MIs, and family history of MI
(Table 1).
Ethical considerations
On the other hand, the results of the paired-samples t-test
A university-affiliated Ethics Committee and the Clinical showed that in the control group, the levels of self-care
Trials Appraisal Center affiliated to the Iranian Ministry of knowledge, motivation and skills did not change signifi-
Health approved the study. We explained the aim and the cantly after the intervention (p-value >005; Table 2). How-
process of the study to the participants and ensured them ever, the results of this test revealed that in the
that both participation in and withdrawal from the study experimental group, the levels of self-care knowledge, moti-
were voluntary. We also guaranteed the confidentiality of vation and skills increased significantly after the interven-
the study participants’ information. Finally, we obtained a tion (p-value <00001; Table 2).
verbal informed consent from each participant. Moreover, the results of the independent-samples t test
showed that before intervention, the study groups did not
differ significantly in terms of self-care knowledge, motiva-
Results
tion and skills (p-value >005; Table 2). However, the
In total, 66 patients—33 patients in each group—partici- results of this test revealed that the postintervention self-
pated in the study. Table 1 shows the study participants’ care knowledge, motivation and skills in the experimen-
tal group were significantly higher than the control group
(p-value ≤00001; Table 2).
Table 1 Patients’ characteristics
Table 2 The difference between the groups and between the pre- and postintervention readings of self-care knowledge, motivation and skills
(the results of the Independent- and paired-samples t-test)
References
Arlene E & Marjorie I (1996) Effects of Driscoll A, Davidson P, Clark R, Huangd Meleisebrahim E, Translated By: Shokati
Orem-based nursing intervention on N & Ahod Z (2009) Tailoring con- Ahmadabad M, Supervised By: Mo-
nutritional self-care of myocardial sumer resources to enhance self-care hammadi I (2007) Theoretical Nursing
infarction patients. International Jour- in chronic heart failure. Australian Development & Progress. Salemi,
nal of Nursing Studies 33, 259–270. Critical Care 22, 133–140. Tehran. [In persian].
Armer JM, Shook RP, Schneider MK, George JB (2011) Nursing Theories, the Memarian R (2011) Application of Nurs-
Brooks CW, Peterson J & Stewart BR Base for Professional Nursing Prac- ing Concept and Theorist. University
(2009) Enhancing supportive-educative tice. Pearson, Boston. of Modarres, Tehran. [In persian].
nursing systems to reduce risk of Hamidizadeh S, Masoudi R, Ahmadi F Mohammadhassani M, Farahani B, Zo-
post-breast cancer lymphedema. NIH & Mohammadi I (2009) Evaluation hour A & Panahiazar Sh (2010) Self-
Public Access Author Manuscript. Pub- of the effect of self-care program care ability based on Orem’s theory in
lished in final edited form as: Self Care based on the orem framework on individuals with coronary artery dis-
Dependent-Care & Nursing 17, 6–15. the physical Quality of life in multi- ease. Iranian Journal of Critical Care
Barnason S, Zimmerman L & Young L ple sclerosis patients. Journal of Sha- Nursing 3, 87–91[In persian].
(2011) An integrative review of inter- hid Sadoughi University of Medical Najafi S, Vahedparast H, Hafezi S, Sagh-
ventions promoting self-care of Sciences and Health Services Spring afi A, Farsi Z & Vahabi Y (2008)
patients with heart failure. Journal of 17, 20–29. Effect of self-care education on qual-
Clinical Nursing 21, 448–475. Heydari A, Ziaee E & Ebrahimzade S ity of life in patients suffering from
Beyranvand MR, Lorvand A, AlipourParsa (2011) The frecuency of rehospitaliza- myocardial infarction. Journal of
S, Motamedi MR & Kolahi AA tion and its contributing factor in Intensive Care Nursing 1, 35–39. [In
(2011) The quality of life after first patient whit cardiovascular disease persian].
acute myocardial infarction. Journal hospitalize in selected hospitals in Naroei S & Khani V (2010) Nursing Theo-
of Shahid Beheshti University of Med- Mashhad in 2010. OfogheDanesh ries. Nehzate Pooya, Tehran. [In per-
ical Sciences 15, 264–272. [persian]. Journal of Iran University of Medical sian].
Bolourchifard F, Neishabory M & Abed- Sciences 17, 65–71. [In persian]. Olivella-Fernandez MC, Bastidas-Sanchez
Saeedi Z (2009) The effects of group Jaarsma T, Philipsen H, Kastermans MC & CV & Castiblanco-Amaya MA (2012)
and individual education on the level Dassen T (1994) Information needs Adherence to self-care among persons
of the knowledge, attitude and prac- and problems of patients with myocar- with cardiovascular disease: an
tice of self care in patients with dia- dial infarct and coronary bypass. approach based on the orem model of
betic foot ulcer. Iran Journal of A study of information needs and prob- nursing. Aquichan 12, 53–61
Nursing 22, 33–41. lems from the viewpoint of Orem’s (Abstract).
Brunner L & Suddarths D, Translated by: theory. Verpleegkunde 8, 233–242. Rafieifar SH, Atarzadeh M & Ahmadzadeh
Mohammad- Alayha J, Asemi S. MangolianShahrbabaki P, Farokhzadian bJ M (2005) Comprehensive System of
(2011) Medical- Surgical Nursing, & Hasanabadi Z (2012) Effect of self- Empowering People to Take Care of
Cardiovascular and Blood. Salami care education on patient knowledge Your Health. Ghom University of
Publication, Tehran. and performance with heart failure. Medical Sciences, Ghom, pp. 30–37.
Costa F, Ferreira J, Aguiar C, Dores H, Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sci- [persian].
Figueira J & Mendes M (2012) ences 31, 918–922. Rostami M, Baraz P, Farzianpour F &
Impact of SC/ACCF/AHA/WHF uni- Mehri Najafi S, Vahedparast H, Hafezi S, Rasekh AAR (2009) Effect of oremself
versal definition of myocardial infarc- Saghafi A, Farsi Z & Vahabi Y care model on eideries quality of life
tion on mortality at 10 years. (2008) Effect of self-care education on in health care centers of masjedsolai-
European Heart Journal 33, 2544– quality of life in patients suffering man in 2007-2008. Arak Medical Uni-
2550. from myocardial infarction. Journal of versity Journal 12, 51–59.
Daryabygi R & Jalili Z (2003) Knowledge Nursing care special 1(1), 35–39. Sahebalzamani M, Zamiri M & Rashvand
of self-care of patients with congestive [In persian]. F (2012) The effects of self-care train-
heart failure patients admitted to pub- Meleis AI (2012) Bond Simon Dean. Theo- ing on quality of life in patients with
lic hospitals in Isfahan. Research in retical Nursing (Development & Pro- multiple sclerosis. Iranian Journal of
Medical Sciences 7, 23–25. [In per- gress). Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Nursing and Midwifery Research 17,
sian]. Philadelphia. 7–11.
Shahsavari-Esfahani S & Peirovi H (2010). ences (Pyavarde Health) 2, 43–55. [In Thygesen K, Alpert J, Jaffe A, Simoons M,
Nursing Theories & Their Applica- persian]. Chaitman B & White H (2012) Third
tions. Boshra, Tehran. Taherian A, Mohammadi F, HOsseini M, universal definition of myocardial
Shojaefard J, Nadrian H, Baghianimoghad- Rahgozar M & Fallahi M (2007) infarction. Circulation 126, 2020–
am M, Mazlomi S, Sanati H & Asgar- The effectiveness of patient education 2035.
shahi M (2008) The effect of and home-based follow up on Woods S, Sivarajan E & Motzer S (2004)
education on self-care behavior and knowledge and health behaviour in Cardiac Nursing. Philadelphia: Phila-
the benefits and barriers In patients the patients with myocardial infarc- delphia: 506.
with heart failure in Tehran. Journal tion. Iranian Journal of Nursing
of Tehran University of Medical Sci- Research 2, 7–13.