Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal
Jurnal
net/publication/330983753
CITATIONS READS
0 41
4 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohamed Taha El Sayed on 09 February 2019.
Evaluation of the clinical efficacy of Fractional CO2 laser combined with topical
antifungal in the treatment of onychomycosis using SCIO (Score clinical index of
onychomycosis)
Norhan K.M. Ali Al-Meligi; Maha A. Shaheen; Mohammed T. Mahmoud; Rania M. Al
Husseiny
Dermatology, Venerology and Andrology Department, Faculty of Medicine - Ain Shams University
Corresponding: Norhan K.M. Ali Al-Meligi, norhankhaledderma@gmail.com, Tel: +202 01099978172
ABSTRACT
Background: Onychomycosis, a fungal infection of the nail, is considered one of the most prevalent disorders
of the nail. Score clinical index of onychomycosis (SCIO) enable comparison of the severity of
onychomycosis between nails despite differences in the clinical presentation. Recently fractional CO2 laser
and topical antifungal were found to be effective in treating onychomycosis.
Aim of the Work: To evaluate the clinical efficacy of fractional carbon dioxide laser combined with topical
antifungal in treatment of onychomycosis.
Patients and Methods: The present study included 20 patients with toenail and fingernail onychomycosis of
all age groups. The affected nails received 3 sessions of laser therapy (Fractional CO2 laser) at 4 weeks
intervals and once daily application of topical antifungal (Oxiconazole) available at the market under the name
tinox cream.
Conclusion: We concluded that fractional carbon-dioxide laser therapy, combined with a topical antifungal
agent, is effective in the treatment of onychomycosis. It can treat different types of onychomycosis safely and
effectively, and is especially suitable for older patients with low immunity or liver and renal dysfunction who
are not appropriate candidates for systemic antifungal agents. Thus, it could be considered as an alternative
treatment modality.
Keywords: CO2: Carbon dioxide; DLSO: Distal-lateral subungual onychomycosis; SCIO: Score clinical
index of onychomycosis
INTRODUCTION Clinical pattern component based on (1)
Onychomycosis, a fungal infection of the clinical form, (2) depth of nail involvement and,
nail, is considered one of the most prevalent disorders (3) thickness of subungual hyperkeratosis.
of the nail. It occurs after primary infection of the nail Growth pattern component based on
bed, which may lead to subungual hyperkeratosis (1). location of the onychomycosis, digit number and
Primary caused by dermatophytes such as age of the patient.
Trichophyton rubrum and Trichophyton Photodynamic therapy is considered to be
mentagrophytes (2). Other causative organisms are a new non-traditional method for treatment of
non-dermatophyte molds (3). Candida albicans onychomycosis (8). Photodynamic therapy offers a
accounts for approximately 70% of onychomycosis number of advantages over traditional
caused by yeasts. Direct microscopic examination antimicrobial therapies as it has a broad spectrum
after (KOH) preparation and fungal culture are action and is effective independent of patterns of
commonly used to confirm the diagnosis (4). antimicrobial resistance (9). Laser-based treatments
The classical treatment modalities for have been explored as a possible alternative
onychomycosis include oral as well as topical treatment for onychomycosis. Long pulse 1064-nm
antifungal, however, the cure rate is considered to neodymium: yttrium-aluminiumgarnet (Nd:YAG)
be low and regression rate is found to be high laser, diode laser and Q-switched Nd:YAG laser
(5).
Topical antifungals are often ineffective because have all been studied and found to be safe and
of their inability to penetrate via nail plate. effective for treating onychomycosis.
Systemic treatments, although effective, have The fractional CO2 laser systems were
limited application because of adverse effects such developed to maximize the effect of ablative laser
as hepatotoxicity, potential drug interactions (6). therapies and minimize side effects (10). Recently
Score clinical index of onychomycosis fractional CO2 laser and topical antifungal were found
(SCIO) enable comparison of the severity of to be effective in treating toenail onychomycosis (4).
onychomycosis between nails despite differences
in the clinical presentation, The SCIO may prove
AIM OF THE WORK
to be an accurate indicator of therapeutic
effectiveness (7). It has: To evaluate the clinical efficacy of fractional
carbon dioxide laser combined with topical antifungal in
treatment of onychomycosis.
4313
Received:7/4/2018
Accepted:16/4/2018
Evaluation of the clinical efficacy of Fractional CO2 laser combined …
4314
Norhan K.M. et al.
nail involvement and, (3) thickness of subungual SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 20.0.
hyperkeratosis (Table 1) (7). Armonk, NY: IBM Corp). Data was presented and
Table (1): The clinical pattern component of the suitable analysis was done according to the type of
SCIO (7). data obtained for each parameter.
Key Factor Grade 1 Grade 2 Grade 3 Descriptive statistics: Mean, standard
Clinical form (f) DLSO SWO PSO deviation (± SD) and range for parametric
Depth of involvement (d) <1/3 1/3 to 2/3 >2/3 numerical data, while median and interquartile
absent or<
Degree of hyperkeratosis (h) 1 – 2 mm > 2 mm range (IQR) for non-parametric numerical data.
1mm
Frequency and percentage of non-numerical data.
Growth component:
Analytical statistics: Student T Test was
The SCIO has a growth component in used to assess the statistical significance of the
addition to the clinical index component, and this difference between two study group means. Mann
is based on the location of the onychomycosis Whitney Test (U test) was used to assess the statistical
(fingernail or toenail, digit number) and the age of significance of the difference of a non-parametric
the patient. (Table 2) (7). variable between two study groups. Correlation
Table (2): Growth component of the SCIO (7). analysis (using Pearson's or spearmen method): To
Key Factor Grade 1 Grade 2 Grade 3 assess the strength of association between two
II – V Thumbnail or Big quantitative variables. The correlation coefficient
Location
fingernails II – V toenails toenail
Age of patient, years (a) <25 25-60 >60
denoted symbolically "r" defines the strength and
direction of the linear relationship between two
The growth component reflects the amount variables. The Friedman test was used to assess
of therapy required for onychomycosis. A higher statistical significance of the difference of a non-
SCIO index suggests that the onychomycosis may parametric variable measured more than two times for
be more severe and thereby require more the same study group. P- value: level of significance: -
prolonged treatment (7). P>0.05: Non significant (NS). -P< 0.05: Significant
Laser Machine: (S). -P<0.01: Highly significant (HS).
The fractional CO2 laser used in this study
was BISON Fire-Xel Fractional CO2 laser, (made RESULTS
in Korea) (Figure 1). I- Clinical evaluation:
Demographic data: The present study
included 20 patients with toe nail or finger nail
onychomycosis attending the Dermatology
Outpatient Clinic of Ain Shams University
Hospitals from July 2017 to January 2018. The age
of patients ranged from 12 to 55 years old with a
mean age of 33 years ± 12.4 SD. The females
represented the majority of cases (95%) (Table 3).
Table (3): Description of demographic data
among study cases.
Mean ±SD Minimum Maximum
Age 33.0 12.4 12.0 55.0
Figure (1): BISON Fire-Xel Fractional CO2 laser. N %
Male 1 5.0%
The parameters used were (scanner mode: Gender
Female 19 95.0%
pulse width 4,000 ms, repeat delay single, overlap
Clinical disease characteristics among
3 times, density 0.5 mm, energy 180 mj/cm2 and
study cases: The disease duration among study
spot size of 3 mm x 3 mm).
cases ranged from 2 months to 5 years with a mean
Data Management and Analysis: The of 1.8 ± 1.4 years SD. The main site of fungal
collected data was revised, coded, tabulated and infection was finger nail (15 cases), (75 %). The
introduced to a PC using statistical package for main clinical type of onychomycosis was distal and
social science (IBM Corp. Released 2011. IBM lateral subungual onychomycosis (19 cases) (95.0
4315
Evaluation of the clinical efficacy of Fractional CO2 laser combined …
%). The causative organisms of onychomycosis culture at the end of laser sessions). While 6 cases
was Aspergillus species (14 cases) (70.0 %) and (6 (30 were KOH and culture positive for Aspergillus
cases) of candida species (30 %) (Table 4). niger, Aspergillus glaucus, Aspergillus versicolor,
Table (4): Description of clinical disease candida and cladosporium) after 3 months of
characteristics among study cases. treatment (Table 7, Figure 3).
Mean ±SD Minimum Maximum
Disease duration 1.8 1.4 0.2 5.0
N %
Finger nail 15 75.0%
Site of infection
Toe nail 5 25.0%
DLSO 19 95.0%
Clinical Type
SWO 1 5.0%
Aspergillus 14 70.0%
Type of organism
Candida 6 30.0%
the end of laser sessions (P= 0.090) and after 3 months Also, there was no significant correlation
of treatment (P= 0.152) after treatment (Table 9). between Site of infection and patient's satisfaction
Table (9): Correlations between of age of patients (P =0.661).Table (13).
and SCIO at baseline, at the end of laser sessions Table (13): Comparison between Site of infection
and after 3 months of treatment. and patient's satisfaction.
SCIO (at SCIO (after 3 Patient satisfaction
SCIO at P* Sig
end of laser months of Mean SD
baseline
sessions) treatment) Site of Finger 7.93 2.15
r 0.384 0.389 0.333 >0.05 NS
infection Toe 8.40 1.52
Age P 0.095 0.090 0.152
Sig NS NS NS *student t test
between SCIO at baseline and at the end of laser Zhou et al. (12) studied 2 groups of patients with
sessions with lower levels at the end of laser onychomycosis. The first group only received 12 sessions
sessions (P value =0.001) (90 % of cases showed of fractional CO2 laser treatment at 2-week interval for 6
clinical improvement with only 70 % of cases months. The second group received 12 sessions of laser
showed mycological cure (negative culture and treatment combined with luliconazole 1% cream once
KOH) seen at that time. Similarly, there was a daily for 6 months. The second group showed both
highly significant difference between SCIO at significantly higher clinical efficacy rate (69.6% vs
baseline and after 3 months of treatment with lower 50.9%) and mycological clearance rate (57.4% vs 38.9%)
levels after 3 months of treatment (P value =0.001) compared with 1st group 3 months after the treatment.
(85 % of cases showed clinical improvement), only Most of the previous studies used clinical
one case showed clinical relapse according to efficacy rate as a method of clinical evaluation while
SCIO (after clinical improvement and mycological Bhatta et al. (4) and our study used instead SCIO. The
cure) 3 months after treatment months, while SCIO enabled comparison of the severity of
mycological relapse could not be detected as onychomycosis between nails despite differences in
fungal cultures were not repeated 3 months after the clinical presentation and demographics.
treatment.
Regarding treatment complications of our
These findings are in agreement with Lim study; the mean of pain score was 5.9± 2.9 SD
et al. (11), Bhatta et al. (4) and Zhou et al. (12). (moderate pain), the age of the patient and disease
A study done by Lim et al. (11) where 24 duration did not affect pain score. These findings
patients treated with 3 sessions of fractional are in agreement with Lim et al. (11) and Zhou et al.
(12)
carbon-dioxide laser therapy at 4 weeks interval . Furthermore, similarly to Lim et al. (11) no
and a topical antifungal cream (amorolfine cream). immediate bleeding or oozing was observed.
Significant clinical improvement was observed
visually as the appearance of most of the treated
CONCLUSION
nails improved substantially compared to baseline.
The overall treatment efficacy was determined by We concluded that fractional carbon-dioxide
comparing the infected area at baseline and 3 laser therapy, combined with a topical antifungal
months using 4 grades scale as follows: complete agent, is effective in the treatment of onychomycosis.
response (fully normal-appearing nail measured It can treat different types of onychomycosis safely
from the proximal nail fold to involved nail), and effectively, and is especially suitable for older
moderate response (20%-60% normal-appearing patients with low immunity or liver and renal
nail), and no response (20% normal-appearing dysfunction who are not appropriate candidates for
nail). Furthermore, direct microscopic examination systemic antifungal agents. Thus, it could be
using potassium hydroxide and fungal culture were considered as an alternative treatment modality.
performed in case of complete clearance. A total of REFERENCES
22 patients (92%) showed a clinical response, 1. Bhatta AK, Huang X, Keyal U et al. (2015):
whereas 12 patients (50%) showed a complete Laser treatment foronychomycosis: a review.
response with a negative microscopic result. Only Mycoses, 57: 734-740.
2 patients (8%) showed no improvement after final 2. Gupta A and Nakrieko K (2014): Molecular
treatment. In all of the patients showing a complete determination of mixed infections of
response, there was no clinical or mycological dermatophytes and nondermatophyte moulds
recurrence at 3 months after the last treatment. in individuals with onychomycosis. J Am
Another study reported by Bhatta et al. (4) Podiatr Med Assoc., 104 (4): 330-336.
where 75 patients received 3 sessions of laser therapy 3. Sreepurna A T, Jishnu B T, Thanneru V et
at 4-week intervals and once-daily application of al. (2017): An assessment of in vitro antifungal
terbinafine cream for 3 months. They reported that activities of efinaconazole and itraconazole
94.66 and 92% of the treated patients showed against commom non dematophyte fungi
negativity for KOH examination and fungal culture causing onychomycosis. Journal of fungi, 3
respectively 3 months after treatment. However only (2): 20.
80% were culture negative at 6 months of follow-up.
4318
Norhan K.M. et al.
4. Bhatta A, Keyal U, Huang X et al. (2015): 9. Robres P, Aspiroz c,, Rezusta A et al.
Fractional carbon-dioxide (CO laser-assisted (2015): Usefulness of photodynamic therapy in
topical therapy for the treatment of the management of onychomycosis. Actas
onychomycosis. J Am Acad Dermatol., Dermosifiliogr, 106 (10): 795-805.
74(5):916-23. 10. Tierney EP, Eisen RF and Hanke CW
5. Gupta AK, Cooper EA and Paquet M (2013): (2011): Fractionated CO laser skin
Recurrences of dermatophyte toenail rejuvenation. Dermatol Ther., 24: 41-53.
onychomycosis during long-term followup after 11. Lim EH, Kim HR, Park YO et al. (2014): Toe
successful treatments with mono- and nail onychomycosis treated with a fractional
combinedtherapy of terbinafine and itraconazole. carbon-dioxide laser and topical antifungal
J Cutan Med Surg., 17 (3): 201-206. cream. J Am Acad Dermatol., 70 (5): 918-23.
6. Scher RK, Rich P, Pariser D et al. (2013): The 12. Zhou B, MD, Yan LU, Permatasari FT et al.
epidemiology, etiology, Pathophysiology of (2016): The efficacy of fractional carbon
onychomycosis.Semin cutan Med Surg., 32: s2- dioxide (CO2 laser combined with luliconazole
s4. 1% cream for the treatment of onychomycosis.
7. Gupta A, Sergeev A, Sergeev Y et al. (2002): Medicine (Baltimore), 95(44):e5141.
The scoring clinical index for onychomycosis.
Skin therapy letter,7: 6-7.
8. Grover C and Khurana A (2012): An update
on treatment of onychomycosis. Mycoses, 55:
541-551.
4319