Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Forensic Radiology An Amerging
Forensic Radiology An Amerging
228]
Review Article
ABSTRACT
In any mass disaster condition, identification of the person is most important. For this purpose, the forensic investigators
use different methods for identifying the dead. They consider skeletal remains of the dead as the initial step in identification.
Radiographs carry great evidence to act as antemortem records and also assist in identifying the person, age, gender,
race, etc. Forensic dentistry is also emerging as a new branch in forensics. So, the forensic dentist must be aware of
different techniques, developments, and resources to incorporate the technology in order to achieve success in human
identification. So, our aim of the present review is to focus on different radiological techniques and new developments
available for successful identification of the dead.
Key words: Antemortem, forensic radiology, identification, postmortem, radiographs
I
n spite of the fast growing technology and modern bones are resilient and withstand the decompositional/
advancements, human race is still facing problems destructional forces well even under extreme forces and/
due to natural disasters (earthquakes, tsunamis), or temperature variations. As radiographs are able to
medical breakthroughs, crime, and violence, taking capture their distinct anatomical features, they become
many lives. Very little can be done to repair such an invaluable tool in forensic sciences. Radiographic
damage. The main motto of identifying the dead identification has long been in use and the technique is
is for personal, social, and legal purposes. Forensic efficient, comparatively easy, records can be obtained
science deals with the identification of the dead using in both living and dead, and is economical than DNA
numerous techniques. Forensic odontology has a lot of technology. [2] So, expertise knowledge and proper
scope in human identification. Methods like rugoscopy, application of maxillofacial radiological techniques has
bite marks, palatal rugae, photographs, lip prints, etc. a valuable role in forensic identification and solving
are used for identifying the individuals.[1] medico-legal cases.[3,4] Now-a-days, forensic radiology
Most of these methods rely largely on the preservation of This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0
soft-tissue components of the body in question and cannot
License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the
Access this article online work non-commercially, as long as the author is credited and the
new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
Quick Response Code:
Website: For reprints contact: reprints@medknow.com
www.jiaomr.in
Address for correspondence: Dr. Sunil Kumar K., Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, DJ College of Dental Sciences
and Research, Modinagar - 201 204, Uttar Pradesh, India. E-mail: drsunilkarumuri@gmail.com
Received: 29-07-2015 Accepted: 17-11-2015 Published: 25-11-2015
416 © 2015 Journal of Indian Academy of Oral Medicine and Radiology | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow
[Downloaded free from http://www.jiaomr.in on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 46.25.104.228]
is evolving as a branch of forensic dentistry, in which Following are the various methods of identifying the
radiographs play a vital role in identification of the person using dental/oral radiographs as a main tool.
dead. In this review, the authors attempt to sensitize
the readers regarding the scope of oral radiology in Dental Identification
forensic science.
When a body of a person is available in a burned,
Historical Milestones in Forensic Radiology decomposed state, any dental remains of the person,
such as restorations, teeth present, any missing teeth,
• 1895 – Discovery of X-rays by Wilhelm Conrad and prosthesis, play a major role in identifying the dead.
Roentgen. Teeth (max. 1000°C) and dental restorations (acryclic
• 1896 – Prof. Arthur Schuster used X-rays to visualize 540°C, gold and amalgam 870°C, porcelain 1100°C)
the lead bullets in the head of a dead person.[5] are resistant to destruction by fire and, therefore,
• In October 1898 issue of the American X-ray Journal, useful in identification. Dental identification is based
Dr. Fovau d’Courmelles wrote, “Knowing the on comparison and exclusion of the radiographs
existence of a fracture in a person who has been exposed prior to death (antemortem) to those exposed
burned or mutilated beyond recognition, we can after death (postmortem). This data is assessed based
hope to identify him by the X-ray.”[6] on factors like teeth present, teeth missing, crown
• In 1921, Schuller compared the radiographs of the structure, root morphology, pulp anatomy, occlusion,
frontal sinuses.[7] wear and tear of tooth structure, pathology, different
• In 1927, Culbert and Law described the complete treatment procedures, etc. Proper comparison and
radiological identification of the skull by using interpretation of these factors leads to successful
pneumatic cells of the sinuses.[7] identification.[3,8]
• In 1991, Happonen et al. recommended the use
of orthopantomography in identification, which The American Board of Forensic Odontology (1986)[9]
enables visualization of the jaws and related has given the following four situations regardless of
structures as a single radiograph. In the same the factors and methods used in comparing ante- and
year, Haerting et al. stated that panoramic dental postmortem radiographs:
radiography is the only regularly updated and 1. Positive identification: Comparable items are
“truly reliable identification card” for comparison sufficiently distinct in the ante- and postmortem
radiography. databases; no major differences are observed.
• Radiology was also applied in the identification 2. Possible identification: Commonalities exist among
of celebrities like Theodore Roosevelt and Adolph the comparable items in the ante- and postmortem
Hitler. databases, but enough information is missing from
• Forensic radiologists had been using the either source to prevent the establishment of a
traditional methods for capturing the images. positive identification.
With the advancement of technology, newer 3. Insufficient identification evidence: Insufficient
armamentarium like NOMAD (portable hand supportive evidence is available for comparison and
held X-ray generating device manufactured definitive identification, but the suspected identity of
by Aribex, Charlotte, North Carolina, USA), the decedent cannot be ruled out. The identification
computed tomography (CT), cone beam computed is then deemed inconclusive.
tomography (CBCT), multidetector CT (MDCT), 4. Exclusion: Unexplainable discrepancies exist among
and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) are comparable items in the ante- and postmortem
gradually replacing the traditional ones. databases.
Journal of Indian Academy of Oral Medicine & Radiology | Jul-Sep 2015 | Vol 27 | Issue 3 417
[Downloaded free from http://www.jiaomr.in on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 46.25.104.228]
Table 1: Skeletal anthropologic variations associated with racial characteristics of the skull
Parameter White Black Asian/native American
Width Narrow Narrow Broad
Height High Low Intermediate
Profile Straight Prognathic Intermediate
Orbit Triangular/tear drop Square Circular
Shape Rounded Narrow and elongated Square
Face Small Maxilla and mandible prognathic Large and flattened
Nasal opening Tapered Wide Rounded
Palate Narrow Wide Intermediate
Inter-orbital distance Narrow Wide Intermediate
418 Journal of Indian Academy of Oral Medicine & Radiology | Jul-Sep 2015 | Vol 27 | Issue 3
[Downloaded free from http://www.jiaomr.in on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 46.25.104.228]
injuries. The method has limitations compared presented to the English parliament.[24] Age estimation
with clinical application, such as the inability can be done by various factors like:
to use contrast to better distinguish among soft • Jaw bones.
tissues and vascular structures. MDCT is usually • Tooth germs.
performed in the supine position, which can affect • Process of mineralization.
projectile tracks and organ shifts. However, the • Stages of crown development, completion and their
technique is noninvasive and potentially can enhance eruption into oral cavity.
investigations. [23] • Volume of pulp chamber.
• Third molar development and eruption pattern.
Digital Radiography in Forensic Odontology • Root morphology.
Digital radiography when used along with dental Age estimation methods may be classified as:[25]
matching software fastens the forensic victim’s 1. Age estimation methods for the forming dentition.
identification. Also, digital radiography reduces the 2. Age estimation methods for the adult dentition.
exposure times by requiring 90% less radiation than that
Methods of age estimation may also be classified based
required to expose a standard type D film radiograph
on the techniques used:
and 50% less radiation than that required in exposure
1. Clinical or visual examination.
of type E film radiographs.
2. Radiographic examination.
3. Histological and biochemical methods.
Digital Photography
There are different techniques and methods of age
The various digital photography equipment include estimation given by different authors. Here, we discuss
through-the-lens (TTL), light-metering, and single-lens some of the important methods utilizing radiography.
reflex (SLR). The Scientific Working Group on Imaging 1. Schour and Masseler (1941):[26] Their work is based
Technology (SWGIT) provides the imaging guidelines on the studies done by Logan and Kronfield (1933).
for forensic radiologist with information regarding the Schour and Masseler proposed 21 chronological steps
limitations and parameters imposed by the judicial from 4 months to 21 years of age [Figure 1]. They did
system for manipulation of digital photographic not propose any method for males and females.
evidence. 2. Demirjian et al. (1973):[27] They have developed a
system for estimating the chronologic age based on
Age Estimation eight stages of tooth development as follows:
A: Cusp tips mineralized, but not yet closed.
Estimating age is the most important prerequisite for B: M ineralized cusps are united, so the mature
identification of the dead. Historically, the first age coronal morphology is well defined.
assessment using teeth was done by Edwin Saunders C: C rown is about half formed, pulp chamber is
in 1837 in a paper titled “Teeth A Test of Age” that was evident, and dentin deposition is occurring.
Journal of Indian Academy of Oral Medicine & Radiology | Jul-Sep 2015 | Vol 27 | Issue 3 419
[Downloaded free from http://www.jiaomr.in on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 46.25.104.228]
Figure 1: Dental chart given by Schour and Masseler (American Dental Association, 1982)
D: Crown formation is complete up to dentino- where in the following parameters are measured and
enamel junction; pulp chamber has a trapezoid calculated: Maximum tooth length, pulp length, root
form. length on mesial side of teeth, pulp width at level
E: Formation of inter-radicular bifurcation has a [cementoenamel junction (CEJ)], level c (midroot
begun; root length is less than crown length. level), and level b (midpoint of c and a), root width
F 1: Root length is at least as great as crown length; at level a, level c, and level b, root length/tooth
root has funnel-shaped ending. length ratio (T), pulp length/tooth length ratio (R),
F 2: Root length is at least twice the crown length; pulp length/root length ratio (P), pulp width/root
still the root has funnel-shaped ending. width ratio at level a (A), pulp width/root width
G: Root walls are parallel, but apices remain open. ratio at level b (B), pulp width/root width ratio at
G 1: Root walls are parallel, but apices are not entirely level c (C), mean values of all ratios (M), mean value
closed. Periodontal ligament (PDL) space at of width ratios from levels b and c (W), mean value
apical ending is ≥1.0 mm. of length ratios P and R (L), and difference between
H: Apical ends of roots are completely closed and W and L (W – L).
PDL has uniform width around the root. 5. Van Heerden method: [28] This method uses third
Willems,[15] in the year 2001, modified this method. molar for age assessment in adults. He studied
He directly calculated the scores for expressing age mesial root of third molar in five stages [Table 3]
in years and also eliminated the conversion step using panoramic radiographs. Males and females
from maturity index to dental age, making it easier were studied independently with no significant
and simple. differences between them.
3. Nolla’s technique: Mineralization patterns of
permanent teeth were used in 10 stages for assessing Other Uses of Forensic Radiography
the age. Maxillary and mandibular teeth were used
with or without the presence of third molar. As early as the 19th century, the French customs service
4. Kvaal method: This method is based on the ratio of was using fluoroscopy to image contraband in smugglers.
pulp to tooth. Six maxillary and mandibular teeth Imaging may detect packages in body cavities; advanced
were used. The formula given by Kvaal et al. is: techniques, such as CT, have proven more useful in
Age = 129.8 – (316.4 × M) (6.8 × (W − L)) detecting modern packaging.[29] Smuggled drugs may
420 Journal of Indian Academy of Oral Medicine & Radiology | Jul-Sep 2015 | Vol 27 | Issue 3
[Downloaded free from http://www.jiaomr.in on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 46.25.104.228]
be incidental findings when patients who have been diligence of many scientists to follow resulted in X-ray’s
assaulted or victims of motor vehicle accidents are myriad uses. Radiologic imaging is better defined as
imaged. Imaging has also been used to detect other the practice that lies at the many interfaces of medicine
ingested materials and to identify nonballistic material in and law. Radiologic imaging plays a vital role at many
the body, such as knife blades and needles. Radiographic of those intersections, from the identification of dead to
methods also have been used to detect art forgeries. the authentication of priceless art.
Advanced imaging techniques not only have improved
forensic investigation, but also have provided more Financial support and sponsorship
powerful and informative exhibits for jurors.[30] Nil.
Journal of Indian Academy of Oral Medicine & Radiology | Jul-Sep 2015 | Vol 27 | Issue 3 421
[Downloaded free from http://www.jiaomr.in on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 46.25.104.228]
15. Shahin KA, Chatra L, Shenai P. Dental and craniofacial imaging 24. Saunders E. ‘The Teeth A Test of Age’ considered with the
in forensics. J Forensic Radiol Imaging 2013;1:56-62. reference to the factory children, addressed to the members of
16. Rocha Sdos S, Ramos DL, Cavalcanti Mde G. Applicability of both Houses of Parliament. London: Renshaw; 1837. p. 1-76.
3D-CT facial reconstruction for forensic individual identification. 25. Whittakar DK, McDonald DG. Age determination from teeth.
Pesqui Odontol Bras 2003;17:24-8. A color atlas of forensic dentistry. England: Wolfe Medical
17. Pretty IA, Sweet D. A look at forensic dentistry- Part 1: The Publications Ltd; 1989. p. 58-66.
role of teeth in the determination of human identity. Br Dent J 26. Schour I, Masseler M. Development of human dentition. J Am
2001;190:359-66. Dent Assoc 1941;20:379-427.
18. Goren AD, Bonvento M, Biernack J, Colosi DC. The British 27. Demirjian A, Goldstein H, Tanner JM. A new system of dental
Institute of Radiology, technical report, radiation exposure with age assessment. Hum Biol 1973;45:211-27.
the NOMADTM portable x-ray system. Dentomaxillofac Radiol 28. Panchbhai AS. Dental radiographic indicators, a key to age
2008;37:109-12. assessment. Dentomaxillofac Radiol 2011;40:199-212.
19. Herschaft EE. Forensic dentistry. In: Neville BW, Damm DD, 29. Brogdon BG. Smuggling. In: Brogdon BG, editor. Forensic
Allen CM, Bouquot JE, editors. Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology. Radiology. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press LLC; 1998. p. 251-6.
3rd ed. Sunders: Philadelphia; 2010. p. 887-916. 30. Brogdon BG, Vogel H. Other modalities, other reasons. In:
20. Kalia S, Shetty SK, Patil K, Mahima VG. Stature estimation using Brogdon BG, Vogel H, McDowell JD, editors. A Radiologic Atlas
odontometry and skull anthropometry. Indian J Dent Res 2008; of Abuse, Torture, Terrorism, and Inflicted Trauma. Boca Raton,
19:150-4. FL: CRC Press LLC; 2003. p. 279-88.
21. O’Donnell C, Woodford N. Post-mortem radiology- A new 31. Appelbaum PS. Through a glass darkly: Functional neuroimaging
sub-specialty? Clin Radiol 2008;63:1189-94. evidence enters the Court room. Psychiatr Serv 2009;60:21-3.
22. Christe A, Ross S, Oesterhelweg L, Spendlove D, Bolliger S, 32. Castillo RF, Ruiz Mdel C. Assessment of age and sex by means of
Vock P, et al. Abdominal trauma-sensitivity and specificity DXA bone densitometry: Application in forensic anthropology.
of postmortem noncontrast imaging findings compared with Forensic Sci Int 2011;209:53-8.
autopsy findings. J Trauma 2009;66:1302-7. 33. Curate F, Albuquerque A, Cunha EM. Age at death estimation
23. Harcke HT, Levy AD, Getz JM, Robinson SR. MDCT analysis of using bone densitometry: Testing the Fernandez Castillo and
projectile injury in forensic investigation. AJR Am J Roentgenol Lopez Ruiz method in two documented skeletal samples from
2008;190:W106-11. Portugal. Forensic Sci Int 2013;226:296.e1-6.
422 Journal of Indian Academy of Oral Medicine & Radiology | Jul-Sep 2015 | Vol 27 | Issue 3