Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EffectofIntegratingVariableIntakeRunnerDiameter PDF
EffectofIntegratingVariableIntakeRunnerDiameter PDF
net/publication/324189821
Effect of Integrating Variable Intake Runner Diameter and Variable Intake Valve
Timing on an SI Engine’s Performance
CITATIONS READS
3 471
2 authors, including:
S. Bari
University of South Australia
80 PUBLICATIONS 1,758 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by S. Bari on 01 June 2018.
AffiliatioCitation: Ghodke, S. and Bari, S., “Effect of Integrating Variable Intake Runner Diameter and Variable Intake Valve Timing
on an SI Engine’s Performance,” SAE Technical Paper 2018-01-0380, 2018, doi:10.4271/2018-01-0380.
Abstract encountered by a routine driver demand the best torque from an engine
at all speeds. For instance, in slow city traffic conditions, one needs
good torque at lower engine speeds, on the other hand cruising on
Design of the intake system of an internal combustion (IC) engine is
highways requires good torque at higher engine speeds. Hence, to
one of the critical parameters to improve the performance of an engine.
provide such flexibility and best possible torque at all engine speeds,
Induction pressure waves (compression and rarefaction waves) are
various tuning methods have been evolved that includes variability in
created in the intake runner due to valve operations. If the intake runner
manifold length, manifold diameter, valve timing, variable valve
is tuned correctly, a compression wave can boost the intake air flow
duration, valve lift etc. [5-12]. These measures do not prove to be as
improving the volumetric efficiency which increases the torque and
effective as supercharging or turbocharging, yet provides comparable
power of the engine. In this research, the intake runner diameter and
benefits with their limitations eliminated.
valve timing were varied individually, after which both were varied
together to achieve optimum volumetric efficiency. A single-cylinder, There are numerous studies made in the past that show the importance
four-stroke spark-ignited 510 cc naturally aspirated engine was used of intake runner diameter affecting the performance of an engine [13-
for the analysis. Simulations were carried out using engine simulation 16]. These studies support their resulting relationships based on two
software Ricardo Wave to find the effect of intake runner diameter and major principles: Resonator Wave Theory and Helmholtz Resonator
timing on the engine performance. A chassis-dyno test was made on Theory. According to Resonator Wave principle, Wave Resonance
the engine to know its factory state performance and compared the theory is used to predict the effects of pressure wave moving through
torque and power with the simulation data. As a result, the validated the compressible air in the intake system [16, 17]. On the other hand,
model is found to have a deviation of around 10.0 % from the actual Helmholtz’s Theory explains this by considering air as incompressible
chassis dyno test. Gains achieved upon combined effects of variation and phenomenon of internal sloshing in runners.
of both intake runner diameter and intake valve timing across the
engine speed range were appreciable. It was observed that when only The variations in diameter vary the inherent energy of air-fuel flow
the runner diameter was varied, the improvement in volumetric harmonics in an intake manifold which effects the mixture mass flow
efficiency was approximately 8.5%. Similarly, when only the valve delivered to the cylinder, in turn, affecting volumetric efficiency.
timing was varied, around 3% improvement was seen. However, upon These flow harmonics of the air can be termed better as rarefaction and
varying both the intake runner diameter and intake valve timing for compression waves [18]. The rarefaction wave propagates through the
each speed simultaneously, an average increment of 12% was noted. intake manifold when the piston moves from TDC to BDC, reducing
the pressure at intake valve relative to the manifold’s other end. Once
these waves reach the other end, it returns back as a compression wave
Introduction towards the intake valves. This reciprocation of pressure waves can be
“tuned” to gain a positive effect by adjusting the geometry of manifold
Performance of an engine directly depends upon the mass flow rate of relative to the speed of engine such that the compression wave reaches
air and fuel going into the cylinder. The increased mass flow rate of air the inlet valves while opening. This will aid the pressure of the
increases the breathing capacity or volumetric efficiency of an engine incoming charge resulting supercharging.
that determines the torque and power produced by an engine [1-4].
Volumetric efficiency can be increased using superchargers and The intake valve events play a significant role in optimizing the peak
turbochargers. Increasing volumetric efficiency with supercharger torque and power at a particular engine speed [19]. Usually, to cause
comes at a cost of power utilized from the engine, though the gains are valve overlap (as shown in Figure 1), the intake opening event occurs
still high. In the case of turbocharging, there exists limitation of turbo- around 50 BTDC and exhaust valve closes around 30 ATDC [1, 20-
lag which does not meet the adequate acceleration requirements during 22]. This overlap aids in improving volumetric efficiency as well as
varying driving conditions. These technologies are also expensive reducing NOx emissions. Volumetric efficiency increases because of
apart from being complex. Hence, a majority of small to medium size better scavenging of exhaust gases and also leads to a slight boost in
production vehicles are not equipped with these. incoming charge due to the momentum of the exhaust gases [1].
Nevertheless, this may also be a cause of decreased volumetric
To overcome these obstacles encountered in the above-mentioned efficiency reason being increased internal exhaust gas residual (EGR)
technologies to increase volumetric efficiency, intake tuning is a better in the cylinder, flowing back into the intake manifold. Increased
approach. Conventionally, engines are optimized to yield the best internal EGR limits the peak temperatures during combustion by
torque at a specific speed range, while varying traffic conditions reducing the number of moles of oxygen available in the cylinder.
Page 1 of 9
Though, when emissions are concerned this actually serves as a boon Bore 95 mm
against severe pollutant, NOx, which is a by-product of the combustion
when temperatures are high. This may seem to be a promising Stroke 72 mm
approach but not at all engine speeds. Consequently, when operating
under low-speed range not only excess internal EGR trapped in the
Length of Connecting Rod 122.4 mm
intake manifold decreases the torque, but also becomes a major cause
for increased CO emissions. The in-cylinder pressure drops after piston
descends from TDC due to this increased valve overlap, hence the Compression Ratio 11.9:1
efficiency of the engine to draw intake charge reduces. Therefore,
controlling the valve overlap period with changing RPM is vital that Number of Valves 2
decides volumetric efficiency and power of an engine.
Valve Diameter 40 mm
Figure 1. Minimum and maximum valve overlaps
Valve Lift 9.62 mm
The number of crank angle degrees past BDC when the intake valve is Intake
being closed decides another essential phenomenon to improve Runner Length 460 mm
volumetric efficiency known as Ram Effect [1, 6]. Momentum in
incoming flow of air/fuel is automatically increased with increase in
Stock Runner
42.86 mm
Diameter
Number of Valves 2
Valve Diameter 33 mm
Exhaust
Valve Lift 8.58 mm
engine speed and as piston moves from TDC to BDC, and by closing Air/Fuel Ratio 14.7
the intake valve past BDC, the charge can be allowed to continue to
fill the cylinder using this momentum. To achieve most out of the ram IVO 13° BTDC
effect, the valve closing event should be delayed more at higher engine
speeds. However, at lower speed range the same amount of delay may Valve
hurt the effective compression ratio by reversing the flow of charge IVC 72° ABDC
Timings
back to the intake manifold. Hence, the intake valve closing timing
needs to be varied with respect to engine speeds to achieve maximum EVO 109° ATDC
performance.
EVC 36° ATDC
The specific focus of this paper is to find out optimum intake runner
diameters for the operating range of the engine, and further obtain Woschni Heat
Heat Transfer Model
optimum intake valve timings at those diameters. This would help in Transfer
investigating how the integration of variable intake manifold diameter
and variable valve timing contributes to volumetric efficiency and SI Wiebe
hence, the torque and power of the engine by comparing such an Combustion Model
Combustion
arrangement with another where there exists only one of the two.
Methodology
previous FSAE team. The specifications of the engine are given in
The engine used for this research was a KTM-500 EXC® which was Table 1 and Figure 2 shows the KTM-500 EXC® engine installed into
available at the Department’s research facility through the courtesy of a dirt bike with intake and exhaust runners which were used for the
FSAE car. The engine was tested on a chassis dynamometer operated
Table 1. Engine specifications
within a speed range of 1000 to 8000 RPM with increments of 500
RPM to find out the performance of the stock engine which was used
Number of Cylinders 1 to validate the model as shown later. The speed range was broad
enough to replicate both slow traffic as well as highway cruising
situations and capture corresponding performance parameters. To
Page 2 of 9
further expedite the research and reduce its cost, Ricardo Wave Build® combustion model, heat-transfer model and associated temperature
software was utilized as an engine simulator. This software simplified values for liner, head, piston, valves, etc. with respect to the speed.
the three-dimensional simulation into multiple one-dimensional
simulations. The intake and exhaust runners with the cylinder head The software manipulates the user fed data using those into pre-
shown in Figure 2 are modeled in Ricardo Wave software. The post- programmed equations and governing laws of physics like momentum,
processing was achieved using WavePost allowing detailed analysis of energy, and mass transfer and then, different performance parameters
the simulated engine operation. of the particular engine were solved. Figure 3 shows the model of the
engine, modeled as per its stock dimensions.
𝜕𝜌 𝜕(𝜌𝑢)
+ =0 (1)
𝜕𝑡 𝜕𝑥
𝜕(𝜌𝑢) 𝜕 𝜕 4 𝜕
+ (𝜌𝑢2 + 𝑃) = ( 𝜇 ) (2)
𝜕𝑡 𝜕𝑥 𝜕𝑥 3 𝜕𝑥
𝜕(𝜌𝑒𝑟 ) 𝜕 𝜕 4 𝜕𝑢 𝜕𝑇
+ 𝜕𝑥 (𝜌𝑢𝑒𝑟 + 𝑃𝑢) = 𝜕𝑥 (3 𝜇𝑢 𝜕𝑥 + 𝑘 𝜕𝑥 ) (3)
𝜕𝑡
Figure 2. The KTM-500 EXC® engine with intake and exhaust runners
1348∗𝐶𝑠 𝐴 𝑅−1
𝑁𝑠 = √( ) × (𝑅+1) (2)
𝐾 𝐿×𝑉
Where,
Ns = Speed at which resonance occurs
k = A constant (2 to 2.5 depending on the valve timing)
Cs = Speed of sound (m/s)
A = Cross-sectional Area of the intake manifold (cm2)
L = Length of manifold (cm)
V = Effective resonator volume (cm3)
R = Compression ratio
From equation 2, it is clear that the resonance effect strongly depends
on the volume and cross-sectional area of the manifold, hence is
affected by the diameter of the intake runner. Therefore, altering the
diameter relative to the engine speed will provide the necessary tuning. Figure 6. Peak volumetric efficiency in low-speed range
Throughout the research, the length of the intake manifold is kept
constant in order to isolate the effect of diameter on tuning.
Page 4 of 9
Figure 9. Optimized diameters for various speeds
Figure 7. Peak volumetric efficiency in medium-speed range From the figures, it can be observed that at lower speeds the diameter
required to attain the best performance is smaller compared to higher
speeds. At lower speeds, a lower diameter will increase the velocity of
the same mass flow of charge which increases the momentum of the
charge. Higher momentum will increase the volumetric efficiency [27,
28]. A higher velocity will increase the friction, however, the pipe
internal surface area for lower diameter will be lower. The combined
effect shows that at a lower speed small diameter improves the
volumetric efficiency. On the other hand, at higher speed, a larger
diameter decreases the velocity for a particular mass flow rate which
decreases the momentum of the charge [27]. A lower velocity
decreases the friction but larger diameter increases the internal
frictional area. Again, the combined effect is at a higher speed, larger
diameter shows better volumetric efficiency. On average, the
improvement in volumetric efficiency over the stock engine, by
varying the diameter over the entire speed range was around 8.5%.
The intake valve opening times variations were made in the range of
290 to 370 crank angle, keeping the runner diameters optimized for
each speed. The angles yielding peak performance for a particular
speed were noted and shown as red spots in Figures 10, 11 and 12. The
best valve timings obtained giving the maximum performance are
shown in Figure 13.
Page 5 of 9
Figure 12. Peak volumetric efficiency in high-speed range
Figure 10. Peak volumetric efficiency in low-speed range
Figure 15. Comparison of brake torque for all engine speeds for stock
engine and both variable intake runner diameter and valve timing tuned
engine
References
[1] J. B. Heywood, Internal combustion engine fundamentals.
New York: Mcgraw-Hill, 1988.
[2] I. Saad, S. Bari, and S. N. Hossain, "In-Cylinder Air Flow
Characteristics Generated by Guide Vane Swirl and Tumble
Device to Improve Air-Fuel Mixing in Diesel Engine Using
Biodiesel," Procedia Engineering, vol. 56, pp. 363-368,
2013.
[3] I. Saad and S. Bari, "Improving air-fuel mixing in diesel
engine fuelled by higher viscous fuel using guide vane swirl
and tumble device (GVSTD)," SAE Technical Paper 2013-
01-0867, pp. 1-10, 2013.
[4] A. Ibrahim, S. Bari, and F. Bruno, "A study on EGR
utilization in natural gas SI engines using a two-zone
combustion model," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-2041,
pp. 1-10, 2007.
[5] V. Gajula and S. Bari, "Performance tuning of an IC engine
Figure 17. Inlet Valve Pressure vs Crank Position for Stock and based on pressure wave propagation with a continuously
Optimized Models variable exhaust runner length and exhaust valve timing
system," in ASME 2017 International Mechanical
These gains can also be bolstered well with the help of pressure wave Engineering Congress and Exposition, Tampa, FL, USA,
phenomenon. Figure 17 illustrates a comparison of inlet valve pressure 2017, pp. 1-10.
at inlet valve openings between stock and optimized simulation at 5000 [6] P. Sawant and S. Bari, "Combined effects of variable intake
RPM. One can observe from this comparison that when the engine was manifold length, variable valve timing and duration on the
optimized using variable runner diameter and variable valve timing at performance of an internal combustion engine," in ASME
the same time, pressure wave was timed in such a manner that the peak 2017 International Mechanical Engineering Congress and
occurred just when the intake valve opened. The pressures at the timing Exposition, Tampa, FL, USA, 2017, pp. 1-10.
of inlet valve opening were 1.18 bar and 1.23 bar, respectively for [7] O. Aradhye and S. Bari, "Continuously varying exhaust pipe
stock engine and tuned engine. length and diameter to improve the performance of a
naturally aspirated SI engine," in ASME 2017 International
Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, Tampa,
Conclusions FL, USA, 2017, pp. 1-8.
[8] D. A. Moster, "Intake Manifold Design for an Air Restricted
This paper clearly depicts the gains in performance achieved by precise Engine," MS Thesis, University of Cincinnati, 2012.
tuning of the intake system of an SI engine over its entire speed range. [9] V. Mariucci, A. Selamet, and K. D. Miazgowicz, "Effect of
A series of simulations were made with variation in intake runner Primary Intake Runner Tapers and Bellmouths on the
diameter and intake valve timing using Ricardo WAVE® software. Performance of a Single Cylinder Engine," SAE Technical
Paper 2007-01-0382, pp. 1-19, 2007.
When intake runner diameter was varied alone and optimized at each [10] G. B. Jagadishsingh and N. P. Jadhav, "Effect of Variable
speed, improvement of around 8.5% was achieved over the stock Length Intake Manifold on Performance of IC Engine,"
engine performance. On the other hand, when only intake valve timing International Journal of Current Engineering and
was varied at each engine speed, roughly 3% improvement was Technology vol. Special Issue - 5, pp. 47-52, 2016.
observed. However, integrating variable intake runner diameter with [11] D. Cleary and G. Silvas, "Unthrottled Engine Operation with
variable intake valve timing yielded best results with approximately Variable Intake Valve Lift, Duration, and Timing," SAE
12% improvement. Technical Paper 2007-01-1282, pp. 1-16, 2007.
[12] S. A. Khan and P. Ayyappath, "Design and Development of
The approach of varying the diameters continuously with varying Variable Valve Timing and Lift Mechanism for Improving
speed ranges can be implemented practically by using butterfly valves the Performance of Single Cylinder Two Wheeler Gasoline
that can direct the charge to separate runners with different diameters. Engine," SAE Techincal Paper 2014-01-1699, pp. 1-8, 2014.
This approach is more suitable to have only 2 to 4 runner diameter [13] G. Sammut and A. C. Alkidas, "Relative contributions of
instead of varying the diameter continuously. Such technologies are intake and exhaust tuning on SI engine breathing-A
available in Mahindra 2 wheelers [12] and Toyota’s Acoustic Control computational study," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-0492,
Induction System (ACIS) [31, 32]. Pipes with a telescopic form that pp. 1-19, 2007.
change pipes with speeds can also be researched. Cam phasing is the
Page 8 of 9
[14] D. N. Malkhede and H. Khalane, "Maximizing Volumetric [31] K. Hiraku, N. Fuwa, H. Yamada, and T. Yamanashi, "Intake
Efficiency of IC Engine through Intake Manifold Tuning," air amount control apparatus and method of internal
SAE Technical Paper 2015-01-1738, pp. 1-8, 2015. combustion engine," ed: Google Patents, 2004.
[15] R. Margary, E. Nino, and C. Vafidis, "The effect of intake [32] P. J. Grutter, D. J. Lipinski, J. A. LoRusso, D. R. Nowland,
duct length on the in-cylinder air motion in a motored diesel E. C. Prior, and J. D. Robichaux, "Air induction control
engine," SAE Technical Paper 900057, pp. 1-14, 1990. system for variable displacement internal combustion
[16] D. Chalet, A. Mahe, J. Migaud, and J.-F. Hetet, "A frequency engine," ed: Google Patents, 1995.
modelling of the pressure waves in the inlet manifold of
internal combustion engine," Applied Energy, vol. 88, pp.
2988-2994, 2011.
[17] D. Saravanan, A. Gokhale, and N. Karthikeyan, "Design and
Development of a Novel Charge Boosting System for a
Single Cylinder SI Engine," SAE Technical Paper 2014-01-
1707, pp. 1-10, 2014.
[18] R. J. Tabaczynski, "Effects of inlet and exhaust system
design on engine performance," SAE Technical Paper
821577, pp. 1-12, 1982.
[19] S. H. Khudhur, A. M. Saleh, and M. T. Chaichan, "The effect
of variable valve timing on SIE performance and emissions,"
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research,
vol. 6, pp. 173-179, 2015.
[20] A. Ibrahim and S. Bari, "Effect of varying compression ratio
on a natural gas SI engine performance in the presence of
EGR," Energy & Fuels, vol. 23, pp. 4949-4956, 2009.
[21] A. Ibrahim and S. Bari, "An Investigation on Using EGR in
Natural Gas SI Engine," in International Conference on
Mechanical Engineering, Dhaka, Bangladesh, 2007, pp. Th-
23.
[22] S. Bari and I. Saad, "Effects of guide vane swirl and tumble
device (GVSTD) to the air flow of naturally aspirated CI
engine," in 9th International Conference on Mechanical
Engineering (ICME), 2011, pp. FL-019: 1-6.
[23] M. Claywell, D. Horkheimer, and G. Stockburger,
"Investigation of intake concepts for a formula SAE four-
cylinder engine using 1D/3D (Ricardo WAVE-VECTIS)
coupled modeling techniques," SAE Technical Paper 2006-
01-3652, pp. 1-26, 2006.
[24] H. W. Engelman, "Design of a tuned intake manifold," in
ASME Paper, 1973.
[25] M. Claywell and D. Horkheimer, "Improvement of Intake
Restrictor Performance for a Formula SAE Race Car through
1D & Coupled 1D/3D Analysis Methods," SAE Technical
Paper 2006-01-3654, pp. 1-27, 2006.
[26] R. McKee, G. McCullough, G. Cunningham, J. Taylor, N.
McDowell, J. Taylor, et al., "Experimental Optimisation of
Manifold and Camshaft Geometries for a Restricted 600cc
Four-Cylinder Four-Stroke Engine," SAE Technical Paper
2006-32-0070, pp. 1-9, 2006.
[27] I. Saad and S. Bari, "CFD investigation of in-cylinder air
flow to optimize number of guide vanes to improve CI
engine performance using higher viscous fuel,"
International Journal of Automotive and Mechanical
Engineering, vol. 8, pp. 1096-1107, 2014.
[28] S. Bari and I. Saad, "Performance and emissions of a
compression ignition (CI) engine run with biodiesel using
guide vanes at varied vane angles," Fuel, vol. 143, pp. 217-
228, 2015.
[29] H. Hong, G. Parvate-Patil, and B. Gordon, "Review and
analysis of variable valve timing strategies—eight ways to
approach," Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical
Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile Engineering, vol.
218, pp. 1179-1200, 2004.
[30] M. P. Thompson, "Non-mechanical supercharging of a four-
stroke diesel engine," The Ohio State University, 1968.
Page 9 of 9