:, For clarification inthe Memorandum: | i A. Discrepancies in the figures contained in th¢ Comment and those in the monthly reports | PARTICULARLY ON ANNEX 4 |) B. IED incidents that did not identify the perpetrators ~ request is to inform the Court who the perpetrators arp, if they have been subsequently identified. I DATE OF INCIDENT | TYPE OF ATTACK | LOCATION January 21, 2018 IED Patikul, Sy February 1, 2018 IED Isabela City, Basilan February 16, 2018 IED Patikul, Sulu April 11, 2018 IED Isabela City, Basilan May 11, 2018 IED Jolo, Sulu June 30, 2018 IED Patikul, SUlu October 12, 2018 IED Jolo, Sulu C. Reports where statements to the effect tha an investigation on the incident — reques' results of these investigations, if any. PNP would conduct to furnish the DATE OF INCIDENT | TYPE OF ATTACK LOCATION February 1, 2018 Ambuscade Patikul, Sulu February 4, 2018 Murder gao, Tawi-Tawi March 7, 2018 Kidnapping Maimbung, Sulu June 25, 2018 Kidnapping Tanduba, Tawi-Tawi August 16, 2018 Kidnapping blo, Sulu D. In the following, the perpetrators were either “unidentified” or none was indicated - request is to inform the Court if the perpetrators have subsequently been identified. “DATE OF INCIDENT | TYPE OF ATTACK I LOCATION I January 21,2018 | IED Patikul, Silu February 1, 2018 | Ambuscade Patikul, Splu February 1, 2018 | IED Iabela Cy, BasilanFebruary 4, 2018 Murder Bongao, Tqwi-Tawi February 16,2018 | IED Patikul, Sulu February 17, 2018 _ | Harassment Indanan, Splu March 7, 2018 Kidnapping Maimbung,| Sulu March 22, 2018 Kidnapping Patikul, Sulu April 5,.2018 Kidnapping Patikul, Sulu April 11, 2018 IED iabela City, Basilan ‘April '16, 2018 Grenade Throwing Igabela City, Basilan April 22, 2018 Harassment Ungkaya Plikan, Basilan April 28, 2018 Murder Tipo-Tipo, Basilan May 11, 2018 IED Jolo, Sulu May 28, 2018 Ambuscade Tipo-Tipo, Basilan june 20, 2018 Kidnapping Thiipao, Solu june 25, 2018 Kidnapping Tandubas,| Tawi-Tawi June 27, 2018 Kidnapping Sirawai, Zamboanga del Norte June 30, 2018 IED Patikul, Sylu july 15, 2018 Kidnapping Kabasalan} Zamboanga Sibugay July 31, 2018 Bombing Lamitan, fasilan ‘August 16, 2018 Kidnapping Jblo, Sulu ‘August 31, 2018 Kidnapping Sirawai, Zpmboanga del Norte September 22, 2018 | Kidnapping Jl, Sulu October 12, 2018 IED Jolo, Sulu November 14, 2018 | Harassment Talipao, Shlu December 30, 2018 | Shooting Lantawan] Basilang or “suspected ASG” or “undetermined nu r of ASG” — E. Entries that indicate that perpetrators number ieved to be ASG” request is to confirm, by furnishing|the fai were indeed committed by the ASG, ual basis, if they ‘DATE OF INCIDENT TYPE OF ATTACK i LOCATION Harassment Patikul, Sulu January 7, 2018January 31,2018 | Ambuscade Lamitan, Basilan February 24, 2018 | Ambuscade Hadj Mohammad Adjul, Basilan March 5, 2018 Shooting Patikl, Sulu April 5, 2018 Kidnapping Patikul, Sulu + uly 29, 2018 Liquidation Sumisip, Basilan F. Incidents where the motive was a provided or the report nly said that it “was not established” or “yet to|be determined” — request is to inform the Court of the motives behind these attacks, if they have been so identified. DATE OF INCIDENT | TYPE OF ATTACK | | LocaTION January 7, 2018 Harassment Patikul, Sull January 21,2018 | IED Patikul, Sul February 1, 2018 IED Tsabela Cit}, Basilan February 4, 2018 | Murder Bongao, Tawi-Tawi February 5, 2018 Liquidation Patikul, Sulu February 8, 2018 Harassment Patikul, Sulu February 16, 2018 _ | Attempted Hadji Mohdmmad Adjul, Basilan ‘ Seajacking || February 16, 2018 | IED Patikul, Sulu February 17, 2018 _ | Harassment Inganan, Sulu February 24, 2018 _ | Ambuscade Hadji Mohdmmad Adjul, Basitan February 24, 2018 __| Liquidation Hadji Mohdmmad Adjul, Basilan ‘March 5, 2018 Harassment Patikul, Suju ‘March 20, 2018 Harassment Patikul, Suju ‘March 22, 2018 Kidnapping Patikul, Su March 31, 2018 Liquidation Patikul, Sulu April 3, 2018 Kidnapping Bray. Poblacion, Zamboanga Sibugay April 11, 2018 IED Isabela City, Basilan April 28, 2018 Murder Tipo Tipo, |Basilan ‘April 29, 2018 Kidnapping Patikul, Stu “May 11, 2018 TED Jolo, Suluz May 22, 2018 Kidnapping Patikul, Suly May 28, 2018 Ambuscade Tipo Tipo, Basilan june 2, 2018 Kidnapping Patikul, Sul june 4, 2018 Liquidation Patikul, Sul june 7, 2018 Kidnapping Patikul, Sul June 16, 2018 Harassment Pdrang, Sul! June 20, 2018 Kidnapping Tatipao, Sulu June 27, 2018 Harassment Patikul, Sul june 27, 2018 Kidnapping Sitawai, Zafnboanga del Norte june 30, 2018 IED Patikul, Sulli July 4, 2018 Harassment N/A July 15, 2018 Kidnapping Kabasalan,|Zamboanga Sibugay July 29, 2018 Liquidation Sumisip, Basilan July 31, 2018 Bombing Lamitan, Bosilan August 18, 2018 ‘Ambuscade Ungkaya Pykan, Basilan ‘August 31, 2018 Kidnapping Sitawai, Zdmboanga del Norte September 9, 2018 | Harassment Patikul, Sulu September 11, 2018 | Kidnapping ‘Sémpornal], Sabah September 22, 2018 | Kidnapping Jolo, Sulu October 12, 2018 IED Jolo, Sulu November 14, 2018 Harassment Talipao, Sulu November 23, 2018 | Carnapping Talipao, Sufi November 30, 2018 | Arson Ungkaya Phan, Basilan November 30, 2018 | Harassment Patikul, Suu December 5, 2018 | Kidnapping Ldhad Dath, Sabah December 12, 2018 | Kidnapping nan, Gulu December 12, 2018 | Murder Abela City, Basilan December 13, 2018 | Shooting N/A December 30, 2018 Shooting Lantawan,|BasilanG. Incidents without any stated motive or perpptrator — request is , to furnish further information on the incidents, if available. *DATE OF INCIDENT TYPE OF | LOCATION B ATTACK I January 21, 2018 | IED Patiklt, Sulu February 1, 2018 | 1ED Isabela City, Bpsilan February 16, 2018 | IED Patikul, Sulu February 17, 2018 Harassment Indahan, Sulu) March'22, 2018 Kidnapping Patikul, Sulu ‘April 3, 2018 Kidnapping Bray! Poblacioh, Zamboanga a sibugay T ‘April 11, 2018 IED Isabela City, Gasilan May 11, 2018 IED Jolo,|Sulu ‘May 28, 2018 ‘Ambuscade _| Tipo Tipo, Bagilan June 30, 2018 IED Patikul, Sulu July 15, 2018 Kidnapping Kabdsalan, Zamboanga Sibugay July 31, 2018 Bombing Lamitan, Basifan ‘August 31,2018 | Kidnapping Sirawai, Zamboanga del Norte September 11, Kidnapping Sempornah, gabah 2018 | September 22, Kidnapping Jolo,|Sulu \2018 | October 12, 2018 IED 3olo,|Sutu ‘December 30, 2018 | Shooting Lantawan, Basilan H. For the following incidents, the request ip clarify their fel connection with the supposed on-gjing reHellion i. Harassment incident dated February 4, ean Harassment incident dated February 28, 3018 Harassment incident dated March/30, 201B; Shooting dated June 17, 2018; i ve Kidnapping dated Sept. 11, 2018; vi. Arson dated Nov. 30, 2018; i vii. Kidnapping dated Dec. 5, 2018; | I. In the following, the request is to provide further informationDATE OF INCIDENT TYPE OF ATTACK || |Locatfon Sumisip, Basilan January 6, 2018 Liquidation = January 31, 2018 Ambuscade I Lamitan, Basilan February 1, 2018 Ambuscade | | patikul, Sulu || Tisabetd city, Basilan were either unidentified or merely suspect information to the Court if the perp I suppl identified. April 16, 2018 Grenade Throwing April 29, 2018 Kidnapping | | patikuf, Sulu August 18, 2018 Ambuscade | Jungkala Pukan, Basilan ) October 12, 2018 IED || [Jole, Gulu December 13, 2018 _| Shooting | | *noneindicated* | request is to rators have been . The following are kidnapping incidents a the perpetrators DATE OF INCIDENT | LOCATION February 14, 2018 Jolo, Sulu March 7, 2018 Maimbung, Sulu March 22, 2018 Patikul, Sulu April 5, 2018 Patikul, Sulu June 25, 2018 Tandubas, Tawi-Tawi June 27, 2018 Sirawai, Zambpanga dl Norte July 15, 2018 Kabasalan, Zamboangb Sibugay August 31, 2018 Sirawai, Zamboanga dpl Norte September 11, 2018 Sempornah, Sabah September 22, 2018 Jolo, Sulu PARTICULARLY ON ANNEX 5 K. There are 51 entries which were claim initiated but the perpetrators were not ide| attacks. Request assertion that rebellion continues to per: to explain how these d to also be BIFF- tified — request is to h incident as BIFF- r this assertion. ents support the in Mindanao? i hs the motive for theA | PARTICULARLY ON ANNEX 6 | M.In the following incidents, the perpetrators|were not identified = request is to explain how these are attributable to DI. DATE. TyPEOF |NO.OF | | LOCATION : ATTACK | CASUALTIES [august 28, 2018 IED 2 dead, 37| | Isflan, Sultan Kudarat wounded | % September 2, 2018] IED 14 “casualties” Isiilan, Sultan Kudarat “| September 16, JED 8 wounded | Brby. Apopong, 2018 i Gdneral Santos December 31, | IED 2dead, 32) | Cqtabato City, 2018 wounded Maguindanao i N. In these entries, the encounters wete between and among MILF, BIFF, ASG, and DI — request is to clarify hpw these constitute rebellion against the government. | DATE OF INCIDENT TYPE OF ATTACK Tocariol November 10, 2018 | Harassment Marogong, Lanao del Sur May 7, 2018 Harassment Datu Salibo, Maguindanao October 15, 2018 Firefight Maguindgnao, Maguindanao October 18, 2018 Firefight Mamasarano, Maguindanao June 17, 2018 Shooting indanan Sulu