Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Inventory Management and Sales Performan
Inventory Management and Sales Performan
Inventory Management and Sales Performan
MBARARA MUNICIPALITY IN
MBARARA DISTRICT
BY
TANDEKA EDIN
09/BSU/BBA/236
JUNE, 2012
DECLARATION
I, Tandeka Edin, do hereby declare that this research report is my own composition,
knowledge, effort and it has never been submitted by any other person for degree in any
University or institution of higher level and where the works of other persons have been
used or referred to, and such sources have been duly acknowledged.
Signed………………………………… Date……………………………
TANDEKA EDIN
i
Supervisor’s Approval
This is to certify that this research report study was carried out under strict supervision
and has been approved for submission to the Bishop Stuart University, in partial
fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the Degree of Business Administration.
Signed…………………………… Date………………………………
MR. TUHIRIIRWE JACKSON
ii
Dedication
This work is dedicated to the almighty God for his mercy, guidance and protection, for
seeing me through this programme, most successfully efforts towards my academics.
iii
Acknowledgement
I thank the Almighty God for making it possible for me to complete this piece of work.
Special thanks for the knowledge, wisdom, courage and determination he has granted me.
I am greatly indebted to my parent Mr. George Herbert Kambendyaho, dear mother M/s
merab Kambendyaho for her financial support, parental care, love, prayers and courage; I
am so grateful my dear mother.
Thanks also go to the respondents who sacrificed their time in giving me relevant
information that backed my research especially the Coca-Cola Mbarara plant employees
and its customers who did it whole heartedly.
Table of contents
iv
DECLARATION..................................................................................................................i
Supervisor’s Approval.........................................................................................................ii
Dedication...........................................................................................................................iii
Acknowledgement..............................................................................................................iv
Table of contents..................................................................................................................v
List of acronyms...............................................................................................................viii
v
3.5 Source of Data..............................................................................................................18
3.5.1 Primary Data.............................................................................................................18
3.5.2 Secondary Source......................................................................................................18
3.6 Data Collection methods..............................................................................................19
3.6.1 Questionnaires...........................................................................................................19
3.6.2 Interviewing..............................................................................................................19
3.7 Reliability and validity.................................................................................................20
3.8 Research Procedure.....................................................................................................20
3.9 Data Analysis and Management...................................................................................20
3.9.1 Data processing.........................................................................................................21
3.9.2 Editing.......................................................................................................................21
3.9.3 Coding.......................................................................................................................21
3.9.4 Data analysis.............................................................................................................21
3.10 Ethical Consideration.........................................................................................……21
3.11 Limitations of the study.............................................................................................22
Appendices.........................................................................................................................50
Appendix I: Work Plan.....................................................................................................50
Appendix I1: Budget Plan.................................................................................................51
Map 1: Map of Uganda showing Mbarara district.............................................................56
Map 2: A Map of Mbarara Showing Mbarara municipality..............................................57
Map 3: Map of Mbarara Municipality Showing Coca-Cola Plant.....................................58
List of Tables
vi
Table 4.1 Gender of respondents………………………………………………………...23
Table 4.2 Age of respondents……………………………………………………………24
Table 4.3 Academic background of respondents………………………………………...24
Table 4.4 Departments of the respondents ………………………………………………25
Table 4.5: types of inventory management method used ……………………………….26
Table 4.6 Response patterns on up-to- date stores records………………………………26
Table 4.7 Responses on Good stock plan ……………………………………………….27
Table 4.8 Responses on proper accounting records……………………………………...27
Table 4.9 Responses on surprise checks…………………………………………………28
Table 4.10 Responses on proper stores management……………………………………29
Table 4.11 Response patterns Material valuation techniques……………………………29
Table 4.12 Responses on Inventory valuation…………………………………………...30
Table 4.13 Responses on trial error technique for material control……………………...31
Table 4.14 whether inventory management importance contribute ………………….….31
Table 4.15 Responses on inventory planning and scheduling………………………..….32
Table 4.16 Responses on improved procurement………………………………………..32
Table 4.17 Responses on cost reduction………………………………………………....33
Table 4.18 Responses on effective stores management and internal coordination…..….33
Table 4.19 Responses on Improved customer service……………………………….…..34
Table 4.20 Challenges faced in applying inventory management practices…….…..…..35
Table 4.21 Responses on Bureaucratic constraints…………………………………..….35
Table 4.22 Responses on Cost of carrying inventory………………………………..….36
Table 4.23 Responses on to the type of ordering cost encountered……………………..37
Table 4.24 Responses on Conflict of interest……………………………………………37
Table 4.25 Responses on Poor evaluation and monitoring………………………………38
Table 4.26 Responses on Strains on resources and weak management………………….39
vii
List of acronyms
% Percentage
NY New York
UN United Nations
US United States
viii
Abstract
The study was about the effect of inventory management on the sale performance of Coca
cola enterprises in Mbarara Municipality Mbarara District. It was guided by three
objectives; to find out types of inventory management methods used by Coca cola
business enterprises, to examine the importance of inventory management towards sale
performance of Coca-Cola Business Enterprises and to establish the challenges faced by
Coca-Cola Company Limited Business Enterprises in Mbarara Municipality Mbarara
District. Data was collected using a questionnaire and interview guide and during data
collection purposive sampling was used. In addition, the study employed an exploratory
case study design using both qualitative and quantitative tools as sample size of 100
respondents was selected from the study.
The study concluded that Coca cola enterprises in Mbarara branch use up-to- date stores
records, a good stock plan, Proper accounting and recording, surprise checks, Proper
stores management, different material valuation techniques of inventory management
include last in first out (LIFO), first in first out (FIFO), an inventory valuation, ABC
technique, Just In Time (JIT) Technique, recording stock and security system at the stores
as common inventory management techniques. It is also concluded that there is a
relationship between inventory management and sale performance of the coca Cola
enterprises, Lastly, that the challenges faced by Coca Cola enterprises in Mbarara
Municipality include; load shedding, poor record keeping, high taxes, low sales, negative
cash flows, management problems, and situations, inadequate of stock, lack of business
plan, high fuel prices, low turn up of customers, and sometimes theft among others.
The study recommended businesses always to forward planning, centralize the purchase
and store function, carry out stock taking exercise, continuous stock control system, and
that business inventories to be stored under conditions to protected from being damaged
due to physical causes, for example heat, and cold. Lastly, that the effect of inventory
management on the employees efficiency in small and medium enterprises in are
suggested areas for further research.
ix
CHAPTER ONE
1.0 Introduction
This chapter comprise of background of the study, statement of the problem, purpose of
the study, objectives, research questions and significance of the study.
The inventory management is much more complex than the uninitiated understand. In
fact, in soft drinks industry the inventory control department is perceived as little more
than a clerical function as it is probably not very effective. The result of this to inventory
management is lots of material shortages, excessive inventories, high costs and poor
customer service. Too much inventory and not high enough customer service is very
common, but unnecessary. There are proven techniques that can help accurately industry
customer demand and to calculate the inventory needed to meet defined level of customer
service (Briers, 1995).
1
In Africa, companies are facing a problem of poor inventory management and this has
increased their production costs. For example coca cola plants among others are facing
such a consequence. This poor inventory management is always from top management to
the lower level management. It’s from poor managerial skills that have affected so many
companies to accomplish their development trends, (J.S Charndan 2004).
Using the right techniques for sales forecasting and inventory management help to
monitor changes and respond to alerts when action needs to be taken in running the
business. The right approach to inventory management can produce dramatic benefits in
customer service with lower inventory (Kreg, Christine, 2007). Modern inventory
management in business organizations utilize new and more refined techniques that
provide for dynamic performance of inventories to maximize customer service with
decreased inventory and lower costs. These improved approaches to inventory
management are of major consequence to overall competitiveness where the highest level
of customer service and delivered value can favorably impact market share and profits.
However Alvesson (2001) argued that cycle inventories arise because of management
decision to purchase, produce or sell in lots rather individuals units or continuously.
Cycle inventories accumulate at various points in operating systems. The size of the lot is
a tradeoff between the cost of handling inventory and the cost of making more frequent
orders and set ups. A mathematical description of this relationship, the economic order
quantity is very vital. In JIT the need for cycle inventory is reduced by set up cost and
time reduction.
Performance improvement is the concept of organizational change in which the managers
and governing body of an organization put into place and manage a programme which
measures the current level of performance of the business like inventory management and
then generates ideas for modifying organizational behavior and infrastructure which are
put into place to achieve higher output. The primary goals of organizational inventory
management are to increase organizational effectiveness and efficiency to improve the
ability of the organization to deliver goods and or services (Ronald, H 1999). Sale
2
Performance improvement at the operational or individual employee level usually
involves processes such as statistical quality control. At the organizational level,
performance improvement usually involves softer forms of measurement such as
customer satisfaction surveys which are used to obtain qualitative information about
performance from the viewpoint of customers. Many Coca-Cola enterprises in Mbarara
Municipality manage their inventories in different ways to improve on the performance
of such businesses
Though most of the Coca-Cola businesses in Mbarara Municipality apply the above
inventory management techniques, but it has not always achieved its performance
standards and business growth (Opio, 2012 and Nanyonjo, 2011) much is needed for
improved performance. This is because most of the small scale business enterprises do
not show growth as years go by. These was the main reason have prompted the researcher
3
to establish the effect of inventory management on Coca Cola Business Enterprises
Performance.
4
1.7 Scope of the Study
It is hoped that study findings was used as basis for further research and investigations in
form of literature to other upcoming researchers.
5
The findings provide information to managers in different business enterprises especially
on knowing how to compare actual performance and inventory management.
The study may further encourage government to set up educational institutions to provide
training on how to manage inventory in business environment for improving
performance.
6
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.0 Introduction
This part of the study tackled the review of literature related to inventory management
and sales performance. The sub themes that form this section will be developed and
arranged basing on the study objectives to find out types of inventory management
methods used by Coca-Cola business enterprises, to examine the importance of inventory
management towards sale performance, and to establish the challenges faced by Coca-
Cola Business Enterprises in Mbarara Municipality Mbarara District
7
Drury (1996) defined inventory as a stock of goods that is maintained by a business in
anticipation of some future demand. This definition was also supported by Schroeder
(2000) who stressed that inventory management has an impact on all business functions,
particularly operations, marketing, accounting, and finance. He established that there are
three motives for holding inventories, which are transaction, precautionary and
speculative motives. The transaction motive occurs when there is a need to hold stock to
meet production and sales requirements. A firm might also decide to hold additional
amounts of stock to cover the possibility that it may have under estimated its future
production demand is uncertain. The speculative motive for holding inventory might
entice a firm to purchase a larger quantity of materials than normal in anticipation of
making abnormal profits. Advance purchase of raw materials in inflationary times is one
form of speculative behavior
8
Inventory models aim at minimizing materials costs. The order quantity that
minimizes the cost of holding stock is determined. The key issue is the determination for
when to order and how much to order. Materials models range from those concerning
stock files and investment or stock records to economize costs calculated according to a
number of formulas (Holstein 19681).
Inventory control: Inventory control is the activity which organizes the availability of
items to the customers of the organization. It co-ordinates the purchasing, manufacturing
and distribution functions to meet the marketing needs. This role includes the supply of
current sales items, new products, consumables, spare parts, obsolescent items and all
others supplies (wild, 2002) Lysons and Gillingham (2003) write that inventory/stock
control refers to the techniques used to ensure that stocks of raw materials, WIP and
finished goods are kept at levels which provide maximum service levels at minimum
costs.
Trial and error technique; According to Pandey (1995), this is the simplest method of
material control. In this case, management determines the level of inventory basing on
the prices, orders and value of items of inventory. Material controlling is to understand
the need for material and then taking appropriate action to meet this need (Lau A., and
Snell, 2006).
9
Two Bin System; the two-bin system involves the storage of each item in two storage
bins. In case the first bin is emptied, an order must be placed for re- supply. The second
bin will contain sufficient quantities to last until fresh delivery is made. However, since
this is not based on any analysis of stock usage, it may result in holding too much or too
little stock.
The optimum model: According to Van Horne (1989), a company should introduce
policies to reduce lead time, regulate usage and thus minimize safety status. Therefore the
finance manager should ensure that only an optimum amount is invented in inventory to
achieve the trade of between profitability and liquidity (Pandey, 1995). Materials
management is therefore a managerial process of counting, planning, coordinating,
control, monitoring and motivation.
Just in Time Purchasing; It means the uninterrupted flow of 100% acceptable materials
delivered on due date as option cost 100% of time. Jordan (1997) relate this definition for
dozens of techniques including supplier certification materials, requirements planning,
(MRP) manufacturing resources planning, (MRP) bar coding systems, contracting,
electronic data interchange (EDI) value analysis and work simplification. This type of
purchasing production and inventory control has the great advantage of locating and
fixing quality problems immediately.
10
Inventory Planning and Scheduling: This is how units of stock are required by an
organization in a given period to enable smooth business operations. A good stock plan
set in advance will enable planners to set procurement/ purchase dates and quantities that
are consistent with the plan to avoid disruptions due to inventory shortages (Dilworth
1992).
Virtually every enterprise finds it necessary to hold stocks (or inventory) of various items
and materials. That is because it would be practically impossible to operate with only one
of each item to be sold or used in manufacture or used in office work. A reserve or a fund
or inventory of each item or material used or sold frequently is therefore maintained, so
that as items or materials are sold or used they can be replaced or replenished from the
stocks held in reserve. Due to uncertainty in future demand, and because of the
unguaranteed availability of supplies, stock is therefore held to ensure an availability of
goods to minimize the overall costs associated with the management of stock (Drury,
2000)
Inventory management is primarily about specifying the size and placement of stocked
goods. Inventory management is required at different locations within a facility or within
multiple locations of a supply network to protect the regular and planned course of
production against the random disturbance of running out of materials or goods (Malcom,
11
2005). The scope of inventory management also concerns the fine lines between
replenishment, lead time, carrying costs of inventory, asset management, inventory
forecasting, inventory valuation, inventory visibility, future inventory price forecasting,
physical inventory, available physical space for inventory, quality management,
replenishment, returns and defective goods and demand forecasting. Balancing these
competing requirements leads to optimal inventory levels, which is an on-going process
as the business needs shift and react to the wider environment (Malcom, 2005).
According to Gary (1997), there are three basic reasons for keeping an inventory: Time -
The time lags present in the supply chain, from supplier to user at every stage, requires
that you maintain certain amounts of inventory to use in this "lead time." Uncertainty -
Inventories are maintained as buffers to meet uncertainties in demand, supply and
movements of goods. Economies of scale - Ideal condition of "one unit at a time at a
place where a user needs it, when he needs it" principle tends to incur lots of costs in
terms of logistics. So bulk buying, movement and storing brings in economies of scale.
12
many strides have been taken to reduce inventories through Just In Time, time
compression and quick response purchases applied throughout the supply channel, the
annual investment in inventories by manufacturers, retailers and merchants wholesalers
to improve sale performance.
Inventory management process is the science-based art of controlling the amount of stock
held in various forms, within a business to meet economically the demands placed up one
that business. The aim of inventory control system is to maintain the quantities of stock
held by a business at a level which optimizes some management criteria such as
minimizing the costs incurred by the whole business enterprise for improved performance
(Halachmi and Bouckart, 2005).
Malcom, S. (2005) says that uncertainty or safety stocks exist as a result of uncertainties
in demand or supply. Raw materials, purchased parts or maintenance, repair and
operations. buffer stocks give some protections against the uncertainty of supplier
performance due to shut down, strikes, led time variations, late deliveries to and from
suppliers, poor quality units that can not be accepted and so on. Work in process buffer
inventories protect against machine break down, employee illness and so on. Finished
goods buffer protect against unforeseen demand or production failures. Management
efforts to reduce supply uncertainty may have substantial pay off in reduced inventories.
According Halachmi and Bouckart (2005) inventory management has the following
purposes including: to provide and maintain good customer service; to smooth the floor
of goods through the productive process, to provide protection against the uncertainties of
supply and demand and to obtain a reasonable utilization of people and equipment.
Transit or Pipelines Inventories are used to stock the supply and distribution pipelines
linking an organization to its suppliers and customers as well as internal transportation
points. They exist because of the need to move materials from one point to another.
Obviously transit inventories are dependent on location and mode of transportation. A
decision to use a distant supplier will rail transport will probably create a far larger raw
13
materials transit inventory than one to use a local supplier with truck delivery. In Just In
Time production a variety of means are used to reduce transit inventories including the
use of local supplies, small batches in special containers and trucks specifically designed
for side loading in small quantities (Ronald .H, 1999).
Sale Performance involves organizational change in which the managers and governing
body of an organization put into place and manage a programme which measures the
current level of performance of the organization like inventory management and then
generates ideas for modifying organizational behavior and infrastructure which are put
into place to achieve higher output. The primary goals of organizational inventory
management are to increase organizational effectiveness and efficiency to improve the
ability of the organization to deliver goods and or services (Ronald, H, 1999).
This is a stock management technique, which involves controlling the amount of stock
held by an organization. The main aim of this technique is to strike a balance between
profitability and liquidity to ensure that there is no under or over stocking. According to
Kamukama, 2006, short adherence to stock control should be established in order to
minimize the costs associated with stock. Firms should therefore determine the level of
stock they require so that excess or inadequate stock is avoided. Several Authors indicate
that firms should establish the following practices in order to avoid undesirable stock
14
levels i.e. the re-order level, average stock level and maximum stock level, minimum
stock level of safety stock.
In the United States, some of the largest concerns of small business owners are insurance
costs (such as liability and health), rising energy costs and taxes. In the United Kingdom
and Australia, small business owners tend to be more concerned with excessive
governmental red tape. Another problem for many small businesses is termed the
'Entrepreneurial Myth' or E-Myth. The mythic assumption is that an expert in a given
technical field will also be expert at running that kind of business (Ronald, 1997).
However Kizito-Mayanja, (1994) argued that finding new customers is the major
challenge for Small business owners. Small businesses typically find themselves strapped
for time but in order to create a continual stream of new business, they must work on
marketing their business every day. Common marketing techniques for small business
include networking, word of mouth, customer referrals, yellow pages directories,
television, radio, outdoor (roadside billboards), print, email marketing, and internet.
Electronic media like TV can be quite expensive and is normally intended to create
awareness of a product or service. For example, if the prospective owner thinks that he
will generate $100,000 in revenues in the first year with $150,000 in start-up expenses,
then he should have no less than $250,000 available. Failure to provide this level of
funding for the company could leave the owner liable for all of the company's debt
15
should he end up in bankruptcy court, under the theory of undercapitalization (Kayumbu,
1994).
Cost of goods sold: This matches our previously computed cost of goods sold figure. To
arrive at the $12,500 ending inventory figure, the 50 unsold ounces was multiplied by the
purchase price of $250 per ounce. In this example, all Janis’ purchases were made at the
same price, $250 per ounce. In the real world, the per ounce cost is likely to fluctuate.
Also, Janis, like many businesses, may offer more than one type of product with
fluctuating prices. In order to accurately compute the cost of goods sold, Janis has to be
able to get an accurate count of unsold inventory on hand and she also has to assign the
“correct” costs to these products. (Henry Fayol 2007).
Finally, according to the U.S Bureau of Census (Ballou 2004:326-328), inventories are
found in such places as warehouses, yards, shop floors, transportation equipment and on
retail store shelves. Having these inventories on hand can cost between 20 and 40 percent
of their value per year. Therefore, carefully managing inventory levels makes good
economic sense.
16
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.0 Introduction
This chapter presents the methodology that was used in the study; it gives a description of
the study area and the methods that used to collect data from the field. It gives a summary
of the research design, sample population and size, data collection instruments, data type,
data processing and presentation and the problems encountered during the process of data
collection and analysis.
17
manage their inventories and the researcher was aware of the contributions of such
inventory management methods applied.
18
subject of the study and these were consulted at length to extract the information required
to support the findings from the study respondents.
3.6.1 Questionnaires
Questionnaires titled “the effect of inventory management and same performance of Coca
Cola Business Enterprise” will be used in the process of collecting data. The researcher
administered questionnaires to selected top employees and management officials of Coca
Cola Business Enterprise in Mbarara Municipality. The relevance of these questionnaires
was convenient and less time consuming. With management staff who would not have
time for an appointment, an email of the questionnaire was sent to them which would
easily be filled. The questionnaire were piloted as recommended by Saunder et al (2003)
who writes that, piloting helps ensure validity and reliability and also said that piloting
helps to refine the questionnaire so that respondents have no problem in answering the
questions and there would be no problems in recording the data.
3.6.2 Interviewing
The researcher use formal interviewing as a method of data collection and the interviews
offered a chance to explore topics in depth and allowed interaction between the
researcher and the respondents such that any misunderstanding of the questions and
answers provided could easily be corrected. The researcher interviewed the lower level
employees of the organization using the interview guide. This was used to tap the vital
information that would not be collected using the questionnaires from the top level and
management employees.
19
3.7 Reliability and validity
Validity of an instrument used in this study was consistent with the definition provided
by Miles and Huberman (1994), as the” extent to which the items in the instrument
measure what they are set out to measure.” The validity of the instruments will be
established by the supervisor.
Reliability, according to Miles and Huberman (1994), has to do with the extent to which
the items in an instrument generate consistent responses over several trials with different
audiences in the same setting or circumstances”. The reliability of the instruments and
data was established following a pre-test procedure of the instruments before their use
with actual research respondents.
20
3.9.1 Data processing
The collect data was edited, categorized or coded and entered into computer using SPSS
for generation of summary frequency tables and graphs. Data collected with interview
guide were edited, categorized according to themes and then summarized into
percentages using a computer spread sheet. This was done by recording data and
organizing it in themes and after which analyze the themes in line to the research
questions. Numbers of response were noted and corresponding percentages determined.
3.9.2 Editing
The collected data was edited for accuracy, completeness. Editing was done to find out
how well the answered questionnaires were done in line with consideration paid to
questions and responses from interview guide answered by the study respondents.
3.9.3 Coding
The edited data were coded. Coding involved assigning numbers to similar questions from
which answers were given unique looks to make the work easier. In this case SPSS (Statistical
Package for Social Scientists) will be used to analyze the code data.
21
3.11 Limitations of the study
The study involves the following constraints;
The time allowed to do this research was not enough to allow exhaustive study and obtain
all the essential information for much more suitable conclusions. The problem was
minimized by putting much effort on this research so as to meet the deadline.
The Researcher was limited by financial resources such as the transport costs and
stationery to carry out her research effectively. In an effort to mitigate this shortcoming,
the researcher was source for funds from a few sponsors.
Slow or non- response: Since the researcher does t know the kind of respondents to deal
with, some of them fail to respond or delay to do so. The researcher makes convenient
appointments with the respondents and encourage them to respond and give true
information in time.
Due to the sensitivity of the study, the respondents might refuse to give some data to the
researcher citing the reasons behind the study. The researcher was however overcome this
by showing an introductory letter acquired from the faculty fully explaining the purpose
of the research. The researcher was also assured respondents that their ideas were treated
with utmost confidentiality.
Bureaucracy delayed the study. From all the procedures, getting data from management
take time. However, the researcher was take time and appeal to the bureaucrats for data.
Time and resources constraints were restrict the scope of the research. Despite the
researcher effort to expand the scope of the research by getting into more in-depth study
of cash management, it may not materialize due to the practical difficulties faced during
the work.
22
CHAPTER FOUR
4.0 Introductions
In this chapter, the researcher presents, interprets the findings of the study and analysis in
line with the set objectives, which include; To find out types of inventory management
methods used by Coca cola business enterprises, to examine the importance of inventory
management towards sale performance of Coca-Cola Business Enterprises and to
establish the challenges faced by Coca-Cola Company Limited Business Enterprises in
Mbarara Municipality Mbarara District. The social characteristics of the respondents are
also considered to establish their relationship with the variables under investigation.
23
Table 4.1, shows that male respondents constituted 55% while female respondents were
45%.
4.1.2 Age Brackets of respondents
The researcher explored on the age of the respondents in regard to the effect of inventory
management on the sale performance of Coca-Cola Company limited Business
Enterprises in Mbarara Municipality Mbarara District. The results are tabulated below;
The table presents that 35.0% of the respondents were between 20-30 years, 28.0% were
between 31-40 years, 17% were between 41-50years, while 20% were above 50 years.
24
From the table 26.0% of the respondents had certificates, 45% had diplomas, 24% had
degrees, while 5% had others qualifications
From the table 66.0% of the respondents were from store and marketing department, 34
% were from top management department, 6% of the respondent are from Accounts
Department, 9% were from purchasing and sales department, while 5% were from others
department.
4.2 The Types of Inventory Management Method Used By Coca Cola Business
Enterprise
The study investigated into the types of inventory management method used by coca cola
business enterprise. The reason was to establish the method adopted by the Coca Cola in
its quest to ensure proper sale performance. The findings are tabulated in the subsequent
tables. The researcher first asked respondents whether there are various types of
inventory management method used by coca cola business enterprise. The responses
given by the respondents were inform of strongly agree, agree, not sure, disagree, and
strongly disagree as follow;
25
Table 4.5: Whether there are types of inventory management method used by
coca cola business enterprise
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Cumulative Percent
Valid Strongly agree 35 33.3 35.0 35.0
Agree 53 50.5 53.0 88.0
Not sure 10 9.5 10.0 98.0
Disagree 2 1.9 2.0 100.0
Total 100 95.2 100.0
Source: Primary Data 2012
According to the table, 35% of the respondents strongly agreed and 53% agreed
respectively that types of inventory management method used by coca cola business
enterprise. Accordingly, 10% were not sure, 2% disagreed and none strongly disagreed to
the idea. Types of inventory management method used by coca cola business enterprise
that were established from the study included;
From the table, 56% of the respondents strongly agreed to the notion of up-to- date stores
records as one of the types of inventory management method used by coca cola business
enterprise. 40% agreed, 2% were not sure, while 2% strongly disagreed to the idea.
26
4.2.2 Good Stock plan
It was established that a good stock plan helps in sale performance and is a component of
inventory management. This was cited by the respondents during the study. Respondents’
opinions are expressed in the table below;
Table 4.7 Responses on Good stock plan
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly agree 46 43.8 46.0 46.0
Agree 34 32.4 34.0 80.0
Not sure 6 5.7 6.0 86.0
Disagree 9 8.6 9.0 95.0
Strongly disagree 5 4.8 5.0 100.0
Total 100 95.2 100.0
Source: Primary data 2012
According to the table, 46% of the respondents strongly agreed that stock plan is good
types of inventory management method used by coca cola business enterprise, 34%
agree. 6% were not sure, 9% disagreed, while 2% strongly disagreed to the idea.
27
4.2.4 Surprise checks/ Spot checks
It emerged from the study that positive surprise checks constitutes an important strategy
in types of inventory management method used by coca cola business enterprise. First
and foremost, all employees at the Coca Cola Business Enterprise and more so top
managers should work towards ensuring that all their subordinates comply with the set
rules and standards in the organization. This can be achieved through surprise checks.
This is clearly presented below;
Table 4.9 Responses on surprise checks
Valid Cumulative
Frequency Percent Percent Percent
Valid Strongly agree 36 34.3 36.0 36.0
Agree 48 45.7 48.0 84.0
Not sure 13 12.4 13.0 97.0
Strongly disagree 3 2.9 3.0 100.0
Total 100 95.2 100.0
Source: Primary Data 2012
From the table, 36% of the respondents strongly agreed surprise checks helps in
promoting proper inventory management, 13% were not sure, and 3% strongly disagreed.
28
Table 4.10 Responses on proper stores management
Valid Strongly agree 43 41.0 43.0 43.0
Agree 47 44.8 47.0 90.0
Not sure 1 1.0 1.0 91.0
Disagree 1 1.0 1.0 92.0
Strongly disagree 8 7.6 8.0 100.0
Total 100 95.2 100.0
Source: Primary data 2012
According to the table, 43% of the respondents strongly agreed that proper stores
management is method of inventory management, 47% agreed, 1% were not sure and
disagreed respectively, and 8% strongly disagreed.
29
4.2.7 Inventory valuation
It was established that an inventory valuation in your company an activity which
organized the availability of item to the customer of the organization at least minimum
costs in sale performance and is a component of inventory management. This was cited
by the respondents during the study. Respondents’ opinions are expressed in the table
below;
Table 4.12 Responses on Inventory valuation
Valid
Frequency Percent Percent Cumulative Percent
Valid Strongly agree 46 43.8 46.0 46.0
Agree 34 32.4 34.0 80.0
Not sure 6 5.7 6.0 86.0
Disagree 9 8.6 9.0 95.0
Strongly disagree 5 4.8 5.0 100.0
Total 100 95.2 100.0
4.2.8 Trial error technique for material control & Inventory control systems
Use trial error technique for material control & Inventory control systems have led to
reduction of costs incurred by the used Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise.
Respondents’ opinions on the idea are presented below;
30
Table 4.13 Responses on trial error technique for material control
valid Strongly agree 28 26.7 28.0 28.0
Agree 56 53.3 56.0 84.0
Not sure 5 4.8 5.0 89.0
Disagree 9 8.6 9.0 98.0
Strongly disagree 2 1.9 2.0 100.0
Total 100 95.2 100.0
Source: Primary data 2012
According to the table, 28% of the respondents strongly agreed that Use trial error
technique for material control & Inventory control systems have led to reduction of costs
incurred by the used Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise is types of inventory
management method used by coca cola business enterprise, 56% agree, 5% were not sure,
9% disagreed, and 2% strongly disagreed.
31
According to the table, 21% of the respondents acknowledge the assertion that inventory
management importance contribute greatly to the sale performance of Coca Cola
Company Business Enterprise, 59% of the respondents agree, 15% were not sure, 5%
strongly disagreed with the idea.
32
From the study, 38% of the respondents confirmed the assertion that improved
procurement, 56% of the respondents agreed, and 6% were not sure.
33
According to the table, 61% of the respondents said that effective stores management and
internal coordination in Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise is a result of proper use
of inventory management, 30% of the respondents agreed, and 9% were not sure.
4.3.5 Improved customer service and Inventory help in the growth and survival of
an organization
`It emerged that Improved customer service can be realized with inventory management
and Inventory help in the growth and survival of an organization in the sense that failure
to an effective and efficient management of inventory was being improved as a result of
inventory management at the Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise. This was through
accomplishment of the planned projects due to good inventory practices. Responses are
presented below;
Table 4.19 Responses on Improved customer service and Inventory help in the
growth and survival of an organization
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly
28 26.7 28.0 28.0
agree
Agree 66 62.9 66.0 94.0
Not sure 6 5.7 6.0 100.0
Total 100 95.2 100.0
34
aware that Challenges faced in applying inventory management practices greatly affect to
the sale performance of Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise. The results are
presented below;
Table 4.20 Whether Challenges faced in applying inventory management
practices greatly affect to the sale performance of Coca Cola Company Business
Enterprise.
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Cumulative Percent
Valid Strongly agree 21 20.0 21.0 21.0
Agree 59 56.2 59.0 80.0
Not sure 15 14.3 15.0 95.0
Strongly
5 4.8 5.0 100.0
disagree
Total 100 95.2 100.0
Source: Primary data 2012
According to the table, 21% of the respondents acknowledge the assertion that
Challenges faced in applying inventory management practices greatly affect to the sale
performance of Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise, 59% of the respondents agree,
15% were not sure, 5% strongly disagreed with the idea.
35
From the table, 28% of the respondents strongly agree noted that Bureaucratic constraints
in Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise hinders the operation of inventory
management systems, 66% of the respondents agree, 6% were not sure.
36
show problem of Ordering cost encountered by the transportation, costs are
administrative in nature, transportation Import Duties as well as administrative costs
being problem in inventory management. Their opinions are presented below;
Table 4.23 Responses on to the type of ordering cost encountered
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Cumulative Percent
Valid Strongly
41 39.0 41.0 41.0
agree
Agree 56 53.3 56.0 97.0
Not sure 3 2.9 3.0 100.0
Total 100 95.2 100.0
Source: Primary data 2012
According to the table, 41% of the respondents noted that Ordering cost encountered by
the transportation; costs are administrative in nature, transportation Import Duties as well
as administrative costs has problem of inventory management, 56% of the respondents
agreed, and 3% were not sure.
According to the table, 61% of the respondents said that Conflict of interest in Coca Cola
Company Business Enterprise is a result into poor inventory management, 30% of the
respondents agreed, and 9% were not sure.
37
4.4.5 Poor evaluation and monitoring
`It emerged that Poor evaluation and monitoring hinders inventory Management practices
in Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise a result of poor inventory management at the
Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise.. Responses are presented below;
38
Valid
Frequency Percent Percent Cumulative Percent
Valid Strongly agree 61 58.1 61.0 61.0
Agree 30 28.6 30.0 91.0
Not sure 9 8.6 9.0 100.0
Total 100 95.2 100.0
Source: Primary Data 2012
According to the table, 61% of the respondents said that strains on resources and Weak
management systems in Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise is a challenge to in
Inventory Management practices , 30% of the respondents agreed, and 9% were not sure.
CHAPTER FIVE
39
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONLUSIONS, RECOMMENDATIONS AND
SUGGESTION FOR FURTHER STUDIES
5.0 Introduction
This chapter contains summary of the study findings, conclusions, recommendations and
suggestions for further studies. The summary of the study findings, conclusions and
recommendations were done in accordance to study objectives.
These study findings can be compared with Pandey (1995) who argued that since most
organizations maintain different types of materials with different value, minimum
attention is devoted to different items with the highest value. The difference involves of
the different classes of inventory leads to the inventory control model by importance and
exception or ABC analysis (Rich mond 1969). The ABC analysis involves the following:-
Classify the items of inventory determining the expected used in units and price per unit
40
for each item, determine the total value of each item by price and units, rank items
according to value, and determine percentage ratio or units of each item to total items and
value.
Also, Wood Frank (1996), the way materials are valued has amplification on the firms
reported profit and the material usage and balance therefore different inventory profit
reported by firms. The different materials valuation techniques include Last in First out
(LIFO), First in First out (FIFO), average cost method and net realizable value.
According to the study findings as in table 4.15, 21% of the respondents noted that
inventory planning and scheduling had improved as a result of good inventory
management practices, 59% of the respondents agree able to say that inventory
management influence on sale performance level of Coca Cola Business enterprises in
Mbarara Municipality positively. 41% of the respondents noted that Ordering cost
encountered by the transportation; costs are administrative in nature, transportation
Import Duties as well as administrative costs has problem of inventory management, 56%
of the respondents agreed, These same respondents indicated that inventory management
involves a lot of costs that reduce on the sales performance of the businesses for reduced
profits by the same business enterprises.
However, further study findings from table 4.17 38% of the respondents confirmed the
assertion that improved procurement, 56% of the respondents agreed the study showed
inventory management influence on the performance level of the Coca Cola Business
enterprises in Mbarara Municipality as the respondents believed that employment of JIT
had helped small and medium enterprises in Mbarara Municipality to reduce on the
transport costs and that JIT was employed in the study area during the process of getting
stock for the business and that had helped to reduce on the ordering costs. This can mean
that proper use of JIT reduces on ordering costs such as air time costs, transport costs in
organizations when employed. From table: 4.23 say that 41% of the respondents noted
that Ordering cost encountered by the transportation; costs are administrative in nature,
transportation Import Duties as well as administrative costs has problem of inventory
41
management, 56% of the respondents agreed This was further evidenced by one of the
study respondents who was able to say that employment of JIT had improved on the sale
performance of the business products making such businesses to improve on their profits.
According to the study findings as in above table 4.8 , 61% of the respondents said that
effective stores management and internal coordination in Coca Cola Company Business
Enterprise is a result of proper use of inventory management, 30% of the respondents
agreed all the study respondents were able to say that inventory management influence on
sale performance level of Coca Cola Business enterprises in Mbarara Municipality as
none of the respondents selected was not able to reveal that inventory management does
not influence on the performance level of the business enterprises. The above findings,
basing on the majority of the study respondents was concluded that inventory
management influence on sale performance level of Coca Cola Business enterprises in
Mbarara Municipality as all the study respondents were able to indicated the same.
The above study findings can be related with Ronald, H.(1999), from table: 4.22 38% of
the respondents confirmed the reveals that costs of carrying inventory that the company
encounters ranges from storage costs, Breakage’s/damages and obsolescence, Insurance
and takes, stock taking, reordering and accounting costs, cost of tied down capital in
inventory, 56% of the respondents agreed, who reported that inventory exists for this
reason alone, the relevance of the decision to be made. Carrying, holding or possession
costs. These include handling charges, labour and operating costs, insurance premium,
breakage, pilferage, obsolescence, taxes and investment or opportunity costs. In short any
cost associated with having as opposed to not having inventory is included. Other costs
may include ordering costs, or purchase costs, set-up costs, stock out and price variation
costs.
However, from 21% of the respondents noted that inventory planning and scheduling had
improved on sale performance as a result of good inventory management practices, 59%
of the respondents agree Halachmi and Bouckart, (2005) say that inventory management
process is the science-based art of controlling the amount of stock held in various forms,
42
within a business to meet economically the demands placed up one that business. The aim
of inventory control system is to maintain the quantities of stock held by a business at a
level which optimizes some management criteria such as minimizing the costs incurred
by the whole business enterprise for improved sale performance.
The study established that load shedding was among the common challenge faced by
Coca Cola Business enterprise in Mbarara Municipality. Interruption in power supply
affected some businesses that use electricity like in reflection of some soft drinks. Such
businesses pointed out that challenge included grain mills, saloons, and soft drinks among
many others. It was argued that the operation of such businesses was entirely dependent
on power and hence any event that cut power supply impinged on the businesses.
The study found out further that high cost of ordering cost and carrying cost remained a
challenge even amidst Micro Financial Institutions. It was noted that from table. 4:22
respondents pointed it out that 38% of the respondents confirmed the reveals that costs of
carrying inventory that the company encounters ranges from storage costs,
Breakage’s/damages and obsolescence, Insurance and takes, stock taking, reordering and
accounting costs, cost of tied down capital in inventory, 56% of the respondents agreed
lead to Finance challenge has remained outstanding though the carrying cost and ordering
cost, so its role is still challenge.
In addition, the study went ahead to discover from table 4:22 indicates that the cost of
carrying inventory in the organization ranges from storage cost, damages/breakage’s and
obsolescence, Insurance and taxes, stock-taking, reordering, accounting cost, cost of tied
down capital in inventory and so on poor record keeping was a challenge to the coca cola
businesses. The researcher established that most coca cola businesses relied on guess
work and memory to settle debts and payments for goods given to clients on credit. The
respondents as well admitted that some colleagues could not document business plans,
incomes and expenditures. Therefore this accidentally has led to high expenditure
considered to cash inflows hence a challenge, the challenge was cited by 38% of the
respondents confirmed the reveals that costs of carrying inventory that the company
43
encounters ranges from storage costs, Breakage’s/damages and obsolescence, Insurance
and takes, stock taking, reordering and accounting costs, cost of tied down capital in
inventory, 56% of the respondents agreed.
The research findings also revealed a significant positive relationship between inventory
management and sale performance. This implies that in order to obtain high levels of sale
performance towards customer satisfaction, there is need for better inventory
management. The research findings further showed significant positive relationship
between inventory management and sale performance towards customer satisfaction. This
implies that increased levels of information sharing among chain partners lead to
improved levels in customer satisfaction.
Lastly, that the challenges faced by Coca Cola Business enterprises in Mbarara
Municipality Mbarara District include; loading shedding, poor record keeping, high
taxes, lack of enough capital, low sales, negative cash flows, management problems,
44
family control, and situations, inadequate of stock, lack of business plan, high fuel prices,
low turn up of customers, competition, perishability of the products and sometimes theft
among others.
The study further recommends the Coca Cola business Enterprise inventories to be stored
under conditions as to get protected from being damaged due to physical causes, for
example heat, cold. To this, special arrangement of stock which is classified as secrete
should made in small and medium enterprises for improving the performance level in
such businesses.
45
Further studies are suggested by the study on the following areas.
The effect of inventory management on the employee’s efficiency in small and
medium enterprises in Uganda.
The relationship between taxation and performance of small and medium enterprises
in Mbarara Municipality
Collaborative Inventory management and customer satisfaction.
Information accessibility, Customer responsiveness and enhanced performance
Supply chain environment and customer satisfaction
Relationship between qualifications and customer satisfaction in the downstream
chain
Relationship between qualifications and inventory management in the downstream
chain
REFERENCES
46
Aaker D A . (2001) John Wisely. USA strategic management. 6th Edition.
Bertolini & Rizzi A. (2002). A simulation approach to manage finished goods inventory
Biggart & Gargeya (2002) Impact of JIP on inventory to sales ratios. Volume
102.Numbers 2002
Bloomberg D J, Lemay S & Hanna J B. (2002). Logistics. Prentice Hall. New Jersey.
USA.
Braglia & Montanari (2004) Multi- attribute classification method for spare Parts
inventory management. Volume 10. Number 2.
Chandra C & Kumars. Taxonomy of inventory policies for supply- chain effectiveness.
Volume 29. Number 4. 2001:3
Colvin, J. G & Slevin, D.P (2007); the Structures in Fives: Designing Effective
Organizations. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.
47
Ellram, L. M., Tate, W. L., & Billington, C. (2004). Understanding and managing the
services supply chain. Journal of Supply Chain Management, 40(4), 17-32.
Gary j. Zenz (1997); Purchasing and the management of materials Florida state
university, 7th Edition, simultaneously, Canada, USA
Hugo, S., Baden W. and Van Rooyen (2002). A systems perspective on supply chain
measurements. International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,
30(10), 847-868.
Kaplan, R. S., Norton, D. P. 1996. The Balanced Scorecard. Translating Strategy into
Action. Boston, Harvard Business School Press.
Kenneth Lysons and Brian .Farrington Seventh Edition (2006). Purchasing and supply
Chain management
Lau A., & Snell R. (2006); Structure and growth in small Hong Kong enterprises.
International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & research.
Leenders/ Fearon (1997); purchasing and supply management 11th edition, Rob Zunettler,
48
Lei, D, Slocum, J.W., & Pitts, R.A. (1999); Designing Organizations for Competitive
Advantage: The Power of Unlearning and Learning. Organizational Dynamics, winter.
Malcom Saundrers (2005); strategic purchasing and supply chain management 2nd
edition, Pittman publishing, 128, long acre London wc2e 9an
Moberg, G. C., Cutler, B. D., Gross, A., & Speh, T. W. (2002). Identifying antecedents of
information exchange within supply chains. International Journal of Physical Distribution
& Logistics Management, 32(9), 755-770.
Appendices
49
Data Analysis
Data Presentation
Dissertation
50
Appendix I1: Budget Plan
Item Quality/quantity Unit cost Total cost
1. Proposal Writing
Stationary
Ruled Paper 2 reams 10,000= 20,000=
Note book 4 2,500= 10,000=
Printing 30 pages 500= 15,000=
Photocopying 30 pages 100= 3000=
Pens 1 box 3,000= 3,000=
Box file 2 5,000= 10,000=
Clip board 2 3,500= 7,000=
Subtotal 68,000=
2. Data Collection
Allowance 6 days 20,000= 120,000=
Subtotal 188,000=
3. Data Analysis
Transcription Allowance 6 days 20,000= 120,000=
Analysis Allowance 6 days 20,000= 120,000=
Subtotal 240,000=
4. Report writing
Secretarial services
Typing 50 pages 500 per page 25,000=
Printing 50 pages 500 per page 25,000=
Photocopying 50 pages 100 per page 5,000=
Binding 4 books 20,000= each 80,000=
Subtotal 135,000=
Appendix III: A QUESTIONNAIRE FOR STAFF OF COCA COLA BUSINESS
ENTERPRISE
Dear respondent,
I am TANDEKA EDIN, a student of Bishop Stuart University -Mbarara offering
Bachelor’s in Business Administration. Iam carrying out my research on “the importance
of inventory management on the sale performance of Coca Cola business enterprises
in Mbarara Municipality Mbarara District”. I kindly request you to provide me the
necessary information having been chosen to be one of the respondents to enable me
complete my research project successfully.
51
Please answer the following questions about the general climate in your organization in
terms of how it really is, not how you would prefer it to be. Please be as candid as
possible; remember, all your responses will remain strictly anonymous and confidential.
Please indicate the extent to which you agree with each of the following statement about
your organization by indicating with a tick in the box of your choice. Use the scale below
on each of the sections and indicate on the answer sheet next to the number of the
corresponding statement the number which best represents your answer.
Use the key below answering the following questions: Apply a tick where applicable
using the following key. SA – Strongly, A – Agree , NS – Not Sure, D – Disagree SD
– Strongly disagree
2. Age: 20 – 30 years
31 – 40 years
41 - 50 years
51 – 60 years
60 and above
3. Marital status:
Single
Married
Separated
Divorced
4. Level of Education:
Primary
Secondary
Diploma
Degree & post -graduate
52
others (specify) …………………………
5. Which department do you belong to?
Top management
Stores & Marketing
Purchasing& sales
Accounts
Please specify…………………………………………..
SECTION B: THE TYPES OF INVENTORY MANAGEMENT METHOD USED BY
COCA COLA BUSINESS ENTERPRISE
1 2 3 4 5
SA A NS D SD
There are various types of Inventory management method used
by Coca Cola Business Enterprise
Accurate and up-to- date stores records is an Inventory
management practices used Coca Cola Company Business
Enterprise
Good stock plan is an inventory management practices used by
used Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise
Proper accounting and recording is a means of inventory
management in used Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise
Spot checks/surprise checks help in inventory management in
local governments
Proper stores management is a form of inventory management in
used Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise
They are different material valuation techniques of inventory
management include last in first out (LIFO), first in first out
(FIFO), average cost method and net realizable value are used by
used Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise.
Is inventory valuation in your company an activity which
organized the availability of item to the customer of the
organization at least minimum costs
Does your company use trial error technique for material control
& Inventory control systems have led to reduction of costs
incurred by the used Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise
53
SECTION C: IMPORTANCE OF INVENTORY MANAGEMENT PRACTICES ON
THE SALE PERFORMANCE OF COCA COLA COMPANY BUSINESS
ENTERPRISE.
1 2 3 4 5
SA A NS D SD
Inventory Management practices contribute greatly to the sale
performance of Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise
Inventory Management helps in inventory planning and
scheduling in Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise
Procurement/purchase dates and quantities are improved by
inventory management practices
Cost reduction in Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise is a
result of inventory management practices
Inventory Management helps in effective stores management of
Coca Cola Company Business Enterprise
Internal coordination in Coca Cola Company Business
Enterprise can be improved by inventory management
Improved customer service can be realized with inventory
management
Inventory help in the growth and survival of an organization in
the sense that failure to an effective and efficient management of
inventory
Stock help to ensure an availability of goods to minimize the
overall cost associated with the management of stock
54
Poor evaluation and monitoring hinders inventory
Management practices in Coca Cola Company Business
Enterprise
Strain on resources by Coca Cola Company Business
Enterprise is a challenge to inventory Management practices
Weak management systems in Coca Cola Company
Business Enterprise is a challenge to in Inventory
Management practices
Bureaucratic constraints in Coca Cola Company Business
Enterprise hinders the operation of inventory management
systems
Does your company incur ordering costs are such as
transportation, import duties and administrative costs.
Does your company incur holding or carrying costs are such
as storage, handling, insurance, taxes, obsolescence, theft
and interest on funds financing the goods.
55
Thank you for sparing your precious time and God bless you
56
Map 1: Map of Uganda showing Mbarara district
57
Map 2: A Map of Mbarara Showing Mbarara municipality
58
Map 3: Map of Mbarara Municipality Showing Coca-Cola Plant
59