Object 1

Middle East Peace Remains Elusive – OpEd

April 2, 2014 Arab News Leave a comment

By Arab News
By Osama Al Sharif
Time is running out for US Secretary of State John Kerry’s peace mediation between Israel and the
Palestinians. Eight months had passed since he convinced the two sides to return to the negotiating
table. The deadline for the conclusion of this round of talks is April 29, but there are few indications
that things are going Kerry’s way. In fact the two sides appeared to be moving away from each
other recently as Israel backed down on its commitment to release the fourth batch of Palestinian
prisoners while President Mahmoud Abbas threatened to walk away from talks if Israel does not
honor its words.
Kerry’s shuttle diplomacy resumed last week after a short hiatus following events in Ukraine and
Russia’s annexation of the Crimea. He met in Amman with King Abdallah and later with President
Abbas. From Paris he called Israeli Prime Minister Benyamin Netanyahu in an effort to convince
him to deliver on his promise to release the final batch of Palestinian prisoners. And by Monday
evening he was back in the region to oversee delicate talks with both sides. Reports say Netanyahu
wants something in return for setting Palestinian priosners free; the release of imprisoned spy
Jonathan Pollard. He also wants the Palestinians to commit to an extension to negotiations in
addition to guarantees that Abbas will not take his case to UN and international organizations.
The Palestinians are clearly frustrated. Israel has accelerated its settlement activities in East
Jerusalem and the West Bank while continuing to negotiate. While refusing to budge on settlements,
it now insists that the Palestinians recognize Israel as a Jewish state, something that Abbas has
refused to do. In the recent Arab Summit in Kuwait, Arab leaders collectively rejected that demand.
Netanyahu has made it clear that failing to recognize Israel as a Jewish state is a deal breaker.
But there are other deal breakers that Kerry has to confront. Although no details have been made
public about his proposed framework of principles, which should pave the way to reaching a final
deal within a year, what has emerged from Palestinian and Israeli officials does not bode well for
the Palestinian side.
Israel rejects the right of return for Palestinian refugees, refuses to negotiate on East Jerusalem, is
about to annex major settlements in the West Bank, demands that it keeps its troops permanently in
the Jordan Valley and wants to have security guarantees from the future Palestinian state. Even then
Netanyahu will not commit to a final deal.
Abbas, on the other hand, will not accept to sign on to a deal that denies the Palestinians almost
every “right” that contributes to a just resolution to decades of injustice suffered by his people. He
is reminded by his aides of the offer, which was delivered to his predecessor, Yasser Arafat, at Camp
David in 2000 and which the Palestinian leader could not accept. Abbas himself failed to embrace
another deal that was offered to him by former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert in 2008.
Failure by both sides to come to an understanding has delayed Kerry’s framework agreement. It is
unlikely that he will be able to bring the two parties closer in the remaining time. His current efforts
will focus on convincing them to negotiate beyond the April 29 deadline. For Israel the extension is
important for several reasons: It relieves Netanyahu from making any commitments at present,
allowing his government to push on with plans to Judaize East Jerusalem further and at a quicker
pace. It also portrays Israel as a peace negotiator while putting the blame for any interruption on the
Palestinians. Most importantly it denies the Palestinian side the opportunity to gain legitimacy and
recognition by international organizations following Palestine’s admittance to the UN as a non-
member state.
Abbas knows that US pressure will fall on him to accept an extension. His threat to go to the UN
and others will cost his flailing Palestinian Authority (PA) dearly in terms of financial and political
support. He risks becoming irrelevant if he challenges the US and Israel.
On the other hand he cannot accept unfair Israeli conditions for a peace accord. His situation has
become worse as his own Fatah movement is now suffering from internal divisions. His foe,
Mohammad Dahlan, has gained the support of some Gulf countries and was recently welcomed in
Egypt. Relations with Hamas have not improved and there is an Israeli veto against Palestinian
reconciliation.
Ironically and for different reasons neither the Israelis nor the Palestinians see any value in reaching
a deal now. But Kerry will push on with his initiative. It is likely that Abbas will cave in and accept
an extension for a small price, such as the release of additional Palestinian prisoners. He will look
for a face-saving gesture and find a way to convince his supporters of the necessity of staying
engaged in peace talks. Sadly this will be beneficial to Israel but will come at a great expense to the
Palestinians.
Email: alsharif.osama@gmail.com