Lit Guide To Fabricating 2 PDF

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 40

Guide to

Fabricating FRP
Composites
with Corrosion-Resistant Vipel Resins
®

www.corrosionresins.com
Acknowledgments & Credits

Cover photos,
clockwise from upper left:
PITSA
Heil Process Equipment
Belco Manufacturing Co. Inc.
Tri-Clor, Inc

End-use application photos:


Beetle Plastics
Belco Manufacturing
Containment Solutions, Inc.
HEE Environmental Engineering
Heil Process Equipment
JTI Companies
PITSA
Ram Fiberglass
RL Industries, Inc.
Tri-Clor, Inc.
U.S. Composite Pipe, Inc.

Materials & composite
manufacturing photos:
Heil Process Equipment
JTI Companies
Justin Tanks, LLC
Plasteel International, Inc.
RL Industries, Inc.

To the best of our knowledge, the information contained in this publication is accurate. However, we assume no liability for the accu-
racy or completeness of such information. The data in this publication were gathered using generally accepted industry practices and
equipment. Because equipment, material and environmental conditions may not be precisely the same, we cannot guarantee that oth-
ers will achieve exactly the same results. The user of this publication is solely responsible for determining the suitability of the guide’s
information to the user’s particular operation or end-use application.
Table of Contents

1. Introduction............................................................... Page 3

2. Selecting a Corrosion Resin System.............................. Page 4

3. Selecting Reinforcements............................................. Page 12

4. Initiator, Promoters and Other Additives........................ Page 16

5. Resin Quality Assurance and Record Keeping................ Page 20

Table 1. Common Quality Control Tests...................... Page 22

Table 2. Getting Started with


Quality Assurance Equipment................................... Page 23

6. Resin Handling, Safety and Regulatory Issues................ Page 24

7. Composite Processing Guidelines................................. Page 26

8. Appendix

Typical Formulations and Gel Times


of Select Vipel® Resins............................................. Page 32

Trademark Notices.................................................. Page 36

Vipel Corrosion Resin Cross Reference....................... Page 37

1
1
Introduction

Portion of a blower fan


Vipel® K022-CC
Heil Process Equipment
2
1

Depending on the experience and expertise of the reader, this guide can serve as
a reference source, a shop handbook or an educational tool. It has been prepared
primarily for fabricators who may benefit from AOC resin technology to make
fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites that will be used in corrosive environ-
ments. This publication may also prove helpful to engineers, consultants, facility
managers and other decision-makers who recommend, design or use composites
for their corrosion-resistant properties.

In thousands of locations around the world, FRP composites made with AOC res-
ins have been fighting the high cost of corrosion for decades. Vipel® chemistries
have set the global standard for large diameter water and sewer pipes, under-
ground fuel storage tanks and sewer line rehabilitation. Applications using Vipel
corrosion-resistant resin technology are also found in chemical processing plants,
mineral solvent extraction operations, power generation sites and food processing
facilities.

AOC continues its leadership in corrosion-resistant composites with a wide range


of Vipel thermoset resins designed to resist corrosive attack from chemicals, mois-
ture, thermal cycles and fatigue-stress. Certain Vipel products are also designed
for food contact, potable water, pharmaceutical and other applications requiring
regulatory compliance from such authorities as the U.S. Food and Drug Admin-
istration (FDA) and the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA). For specific re-
quirements, there are Vipel resin grades for flame retardance, low smoke, higher
temperature resistance and higher mechanical properties.

You can use this manual to determine which Vipel corrosion resin from AOC meets
specific performance requirements without over designing – or overpricing – the
application. Because Vipel resin technology is part of an engineered material
system, this guide also covers: reinforcement selection, catalysts and related chem-
istries, performance additives, quality checks and record keeping. In addition, the
guide covers important issues related to fabri-
cation, the environment, health and safety.

Scrubber
Vipel® K022-CC
HEE Environmental Engineering

3
2
Selecting a
Corrosion
Resin System

Stack liner rib section


Vipel® K022-AC
Tri-Clor

4
Fabricator responsibility
Most fabricators warrant materials, workman-
ship and compliance with referenced standards.
Material warranties generally exclude corrosion
resistance or performance. The chemical make-
up and process are controlled by the user, not the
fabricator. While most users accept these condi- 2
tions, the fabricator has the ultimate responsi-
bility for proper resin selection. Resin manufac-
turers provide critical resin physical property,
regulatory, laminate corrosion resistance and
laminating process and cure system data.

AOC is committed to providing the fabricator


and his customer the best information possible
to guide the selection of resin systems with
ultimate confidence in equipment performance.
Rinse tank design
PITSA
What the fabricator needs to know
Reliable resin selection demands accurate and
The chemical environment and service temperature complete information about the application and
typically govern the selection of resins for corrosion use of the proposed equipment. When the cus-
resistant equipment. Other factors which may influ- tomer is depending on the fabricator to make
ence the selection include: the resin selection, detailed service information
is needed. The fabricator should demand the
• Knowledgeable users specify particular resins or data even when the customer clearly specifies
generic resin types based on past experience with a particular resin and inquires about the accept-
FRP equipment in their plants. ability of alternate resins.
• Engineering firms tend to specify several resins Frequently the user will identify a resin system by
based on guidance from resin suppliers and fabri- name and provide detailed laminate construc-
cators when generating specifications for particular tions for particular applications. These require-
industries and processes. ments may be based on past experience, resin
manufacturer recommendations, the supplier of
• Mechanical and structural performance require- the chemicals being handled, or the manufac-
ments may be more significant than the chemical ex- turer of an equipment package.
posure.
The fabricator should always verify the source
• If historical chemical performance or published of the selection and the acceptability of alter-
exposure data is not available, laboratory testing of nate systems. In the absence of clear informa-
candidate resins is dictated. tion from the user, the fabricator should confirm
the user’s stipulation in writing and absolve
• Economic considerations are more important to his/her company of any selection responsibil-
the decision-maker than long-term performance or ity. The conscientious fabricator wants to do
life cycle cost. the best possible job for the customer. It can
only be done with thorough and accurate
• The fabricator controls the selection based on the information about the chemical service and the
user’s inexperience, or satisfaction from prior pur- process conditions.
chases.

• The fabricator’s compliance with U.S. Environ-


mental Protection Agency (EPA) Maximum Achiev-
able Control Technology (MACT) standards for the
reinforced plastic industry dictate accountability of
resin consumption by Hazardous Air Pollutant (HAP)
content. For corrosion resins, the regulated HAPs are
styrene and methyl methacrylate monomers.

5
Fabricator recommendation

When the user, specifer or owner depends on the • Flow rates – range of inlet and outlet flows.
fabricator to make a recommendation for selection
of the resin system, be certain the user states all • Fire retardancy, where applicable. This must
aspects of the application and service. Some infor- be clearly stated, including flame spread rating
mation in the following checklist of application and and smoke requirements.
service factors does not directly impact resin selec-
tion but clearly influences the acceptable design. To • Installation location (indoors or outdoors). If
select the proper resin system, determine: outdoors, annual ambient temperature ranges,
local wind, snow load and seismic requirements
• The common name and, when possible, the are needed.
chemical name of the substance to which the com-
posite will be exposed. For example, muriatic is a • Insulation and heating requirements.
common name for hydrochloric acid. This type of This is particularly important when freeze protec-
information is generally contained in the Material tion or other temperature maintenance is dictated.
Safety Data Sheet for the medium. When heating coils are used, adequate clearance
at coil entry and exit nozzles must be provided to
• The concentration of each of the chemical com- prevent localized overheating.
ponents. In waste streams or other mixtures, it is
imperative that every component be identified by • Agitation and/or re-circulation re-
chemical name and concentration. quirements. Tank supported agitation
equipment can significantly impact design
• Specific gravity of each chemical solution considerations. All loads must be provided
or mixture. including dead weight, horsepower, and imposed
torque and bending moments. Side entry mixers
• pH, if it is an aqueous system. should be independently supported. Re-circula-
tion should not interfere with normal fill, outlet or
• Normal operating temperature range. overflow openings.
Include any anticipated temperature excursions due
to process upset or other abnormal condition. • Other mechanical loads – such as platforms or
walkways that may need to be supported on the
• Maximum use temperature – not maximum de- equipment.
sign temperature. Refer to AOC Resin Data Sheets
for specific information about resin heat deflection • Food and drug requirements. Use in food
temperature. and drug applications must be identified where
applicable.Cleaning and sterilization techniques
• Pressure and/or vacuum conditions. For tanks can be more severe than the chemical exposure.
it is also important to know if filling will be by pres- Composite applications in food and pharmaceu-
sure such as from a tank truck. Closed vent systems tical processing must meet requirements for food
must be clearly identified with a statement of pres- contact and resistance to specific cleaning and
sure drop to be applied to the equipment. sterilization materials and techniques. AOC offers
resins that comply criteria of the U.S. Food and
• Length of exposure to the medium if less that Drug Administration (FDA). Refer to AOC resin
continuous. In unusual cases, only a short period data sheets for specific information.
of exposure is to be expected. For example, the
laminate may need to only withstand occasional
splashes.

• Process description – where a reaction such as


neutralization takes place in the tank. Exothermic re-
actions must be described with detailed temperature
range from the start to the maximum with control
methodologies to insure operating temperature lim-
its are not exceeded. Time range may also be impor-
tant to avoid thermal shock.

6
Short exposure periods at higher temperatures
usually do not affect product integrity if the heat
distortion temperature of the cured resin is not
exceeded. However, the highest temperature
reached and exposure duration at this tempera-
ture should be indicated when making inquiries.
2
In those instances where the specific applica-
tion is not listed, the fabricator is encouraged to
contact AOC. The checklist information above
should be included and should be directed to:

Corrosion Product Leader
AOC
950 Highway 57 East
Collierville, TN 38017
Phone: (901) 854-2800
Fax: (901) 854-2895

The “Corrosion Advisor” button on the AOC cor-


rosion website (www.corrosionresins.com) pro-
vides a direct link to send an e-mail message with
this information to the Corrosion Product Leader.

Resin Selection Options


AOC Corrosion Resistant Resin Guide The fabricator has a number of options that can
AOC has a Corrosion Resistant Resin Guide both in influence the resin selection process. Less aggres-
print form and on its dedicated corrosion resins Web sive chemical environments result in a broader
site www.corrosionresins.com. Normally a suitable range of possible resins. More aggressive ser-
resin can be selected from the Corrosion Resistant vices typically leave fewer choices. Furthermore,
Resin Guide based on the information covered in the the selected resin system must have reasonable
previous section. processing characteristics in the various molding
and fabrication operations to be used.
The temperature data presented in the guide repre-
sent the highest temperature at which the individual AOC Vipel resins listed in this guide are suit-
resin has demonstrated acceptable service in either a able for typical hand lay-up, spray-up and fila-
laboratory environment, other similar service or actual ment winding processes, principally used in the
field use. Refer to AOC Resin Data Sheets for specific manufacture of tanks, pipe, duct and other cor-
information about resin heat deflection temperature. rosion resistant equipment. Brief descriptions of
Environments not tested may be done at customer re- available resin technologies follow. To assist the
quest. Serviceability should not be interpreted to mean fabricator with more detailed resin information,
the full retention of all visual and mechanical proper- typical formulations and gel times of select Vipel
ties, but rather an expectation of how a properly de- resins are listed in the Appendix of this guide.
signed and fabricated structure will perform. AOC technical support can also help fabricators
develop formulations for closed mold processes
The resistance of Vipel® resins to the chemical envi- such as resin transfer molding, resin transfer
ronments listed in the guide has been established ac- molding light and resin infusion.
cording to ASTM C581 or in actual use. The ASTM
C581 immersion test is generally more stringent than CAUTION: Many applications and chemical
actual service conditions. The list does not apply to services listed in the guide make reference to
mixtures of different media unless explicitly stated. It NOTES in the column adjacent to the chemical.
contains chemically declared media and some brand These notes are an integral part of the listing rec-
name chemicals, which were not precisely identified ommendation and must be strictly followed. The
with respect to chemical composition. notes indicate application-specific requirements
7
for veil materials, cure systems, liner construction,
thickness and post cure.

® Resin Technologies
AOC manufactures a wide range of corrosion resis-
tant products comprised of vinyl esters and polyesters.
Vinyl ester resins include bisphenol A epoxy and ep-
oxy novolac products. Polyesters include isophthalic,
terephthalic and chlorendic products. Vinyl esters are
sold to the chemical, pulp and paper, pharmaceutical,
mining, power, food and high purity markets. Vinyl
esters and polyesters are used for municipal water and
waste treatment and a wide range of general chemical
and food processing applications. High tensile elon-
gation properties of bisphenol A vinyl esters provide
superior toughness for improved impact resistance. High-strength HVAC ducting
Vipel® K022-AA
Vinyl Esters Ram Fiberglass
Most vinyl ester resins are provided unpromoted to
Vipel F007 has an even lower styrene content and is a
give the fabricator maximum flexibility in formulaing
possible alternative. Vipel F010 will have better corro-
to meet in-shop process and cure requirements. Less
sion resistance in most harsh chemical environments.
experienced fabricators are urged to carefully study
the formulations provided
Vipel F017 is an elastomeric epoxy vinyl ester used
and consult the AOC
for bonding primer applications and where inherent
Product Leader for guid-
toughness is required.
ance in developing pro-
moted cure systems.
Vipel K022 fire-retardant bisphenol A epoxy vinyl
esters are for fire and corrosion resistant service.
Bisphenol A epoxy vi-
Vipel K022 series includes several technologies:
nyl esters are well suited
• Vipel K026-AA series meets Class I flame spread
to all processes and are
and smoke development code requirements as tested
compatible with most veil
per ASTME 84 without the use of synergists. This ver-
and reinforcement ma-
sion is the highest in specific gravity.
terials. These resins also
• Vipel K022-AC series meets Class I flame spread
have the greatest range
code requirements as tested per ASTM E84 without
of promoter and initiator
Dual laminate tank the use of synergists. It is suggested for chimney liner
system flexibility. Special-
Vipel® F010 applications.
RL Industries ized systems like BPO/
• Vipel K022-CC series meets Class I flame spread
DMA cures for sodium
code requirements as tested per ASTM E84 with the
hypochlorite service work reliably with these resins.
addition of 1.5% antimony trioxide. It is suitable for a
Other systems are available for thick parts and thin
wide range of applications.
parts where gel time and exotherm temperature flex-
• Vipel K022-CN series meets Class I flame spread
ibility is important.
code requirements as tested per ASTM E84. It does
contain synergistic antimony products. The primary
Vipel® F010 series resins are the most commonly used
use is for structural parts.
resins for corrosion service. The styrene content of Vi-
• Vipel K022-E series meets Class I flame spread
pel F010 is relatively low which helps fabricators meet
code requirements as tested per ASTM E84 without
MACT requirements.
the addition of synergists. The product is designed for
infusion processes.

8
High cross-linked bisphenol A epoxy vinyl esters are
unique variations of the basic vinyl ester chemistry.

Vipel F080 series are high performance epoxy


vinyl esters that provide superior corrosion resistance
to both acidic and alkaline environments and have 2
good thermal mechanical values.

Vipel F083 is a low styrene (<35%) version providing


outstanding corrosion resistance to oxidizing chemi-
cals such as acids at elevated temperatures.

Vipel K023 series meets Class I flame spread code Wet-scrubbing tray tower
requirements as tested per ASTM E84 without the use Vipel® F085
of synergists. It is a fire-retardant low styrene (<35%) Heil Process Equipment
product.
Vipel F086 provides the same corrosion-resistant
performance at a HDT of 330°F (166°C)

Vipel K095 series meets Class I flame spread and


smoke developed code requirements as tested
per ASTM E84 without the use of synergists..

Unsaturated Polyesters
Bisphenol A fumarate polyesters, such as
Vipel F282, have been widely used in corrosive
service. Many users have successful applications
of these types of resins with over 30 years service
and favor them over vinyl ester alternatives. Heat
distortion temperatures are marginally higher
than basic vinyl esters with a trade off in lower
tensile elongation.

Chlorendic fire retardant polyesters such


as Vipel K190 are designed for excellent corro-
Odor control ducting
sion and thermal resistance to wet chlorine and
Vipel® F010
JTI Technologies oxidizing acids. Vipel K190 series meets Class I
flame and smoke developed code requirements
Epoxy novolac vinyl esters offer unique perfor- as tested per ASTM E84 with the addition of 3%
mance in aggressive applications where conventional antimony trioxide. Chlorendic resins are NOT
vinyl esters have restricted serviceability. Vipel® epoxy recommended for caustic environments.
novolac vinyl ester resins are highly reactive and very
sensitive to cure system variables. While they are com- Isophthalic polyester resins are gener-
patible with most veil and reinforcement materials, the ally suitable in mild chemical service with
reactivity and exotherm temperatures require greater continuous operating temperatures below 180° F
skills and workmanship of the laminator. (82°C). Vipel isophthalic polyesters are suitable
for weak acid and caustic solutions with a pH
Vipel F085 provides elevated temperature capabil- ranging from 2 to 10 at various temperatures.
ity with a heat distortion temperature (HDT) of 300°F These resins are suitable for many water and
(149°C) and better resistance to some solvents. waste treatment applications such as alum, fer-

9
ric chloride, coagulant aids, potable water, municipal Vipel K733 series are fire retardant isophthalic resins.
waste water and water-based polymer emulsions. Re- Vipel K733-A series meet Class I code flame spread
fer to the AOC Corrosion Resistant Resin Guide for requirements when tested per ASTM E84 without the
specific recommendations. use of synergists. Vipel K733-B series require addition
of 1.5% antimony trioxide to meet Class I code flame
Isophthalic resins are considerably less expensive than spread requirements when tested per ASTM E84.
vinyl esters and are easier to work with in some fabri-
cating operations. Because of the lower cost, for less
demanding environments, these resins are often used
in the structural layers behind inner corrosion barriers
constructed with premium corrosion-resistant resins.
Isophthalics are usually pre-promoted and provided
with reasonable gel times for most hand lay-up and
spray-up using conventional room temperature MEK
peroxide cure systems. The absence of fabricator
measuring and promoting requirements enhances the
savings.

Vipel® F701 isophthalic polyester is a classic 1:1


isophthalic acid/maleic anhydride resin with excellent
Tank section oblated for shipment
handling and processing characteristics. Vipel F701 Vipel® F737
has been used extensively in a variety of mildly corro- PITSA
sive environments for storage vessel, piping, potable
water, food grade, pollution abatement, ductwork and
other applications.

Vipel F701-S series products contain less styrene in


order to address MACT compliance issues.

Vipel F737 and Vipel F739 are resilient isophthalic


polyester resins. These resins also have excellent han-
dling and processing characteristics; are ideally suited
for aqueous environments and are proven products for
many large diameter pipe applications such as intake
and outlet pipes for power stations.
Cooling water pipe header
Vipel® F737
Vipel F707 is a NPG (neopentyl glycol) version that
Beetle Plastics
will adhere to certain grades of PVC. Bonding tests
are needed to confirm that adequate adhesion is ob-
tained.

Vipel F764 is a high cross linked isopolyester resin and


meets Underwriters Laboratories® 1316 and 1746 re-
quirements for underground storage applications. UL
1316 applies to all-composite underground storage
tanks for petroleum products, alcohols and alcohol-
gasoline mixtures. UL 1746, Parts II and III, applies to
steel tanks that are protected with an external polymer
composite laminate.

10
Vipel F774 is a high crosslinked version engi-
neered primarily for composite underground fuel
storage tanks but may be used for any applica-
tion needing resistance to a wide range of sol-
vents and chemicals, including many acidic solu-
tions. These resin technologies meet Underwriters 2
Laboratories® 1316 and 1746 requirements for
underground storage applications.

���������
����������������
�������������������
����������������
��������������
��������������
������������������
����������������
�������������
��������������������� �������������������������������������������������������
������������������ ���������������������������������������������������������
��������������

Section of sewer interceptor


�������������� ���������������������������������������������������
������������������
�����������������������������������������������������������

Vipel® F701
������������� ���������������������������������������������������
���������������������
������������������������� ����������������������������������������������������

U.S. Composite Pipe


�������������� ���������������������������������������������������
��������������
������������������
���������������������������������������������������������
�������������

�����������������������
�������������������������������������������������������
�������������
��������������� ����������������������������������������������������
��������������
����� ������������������������������������������������

��������������
��������������
������������������
����������������������������������������������������� ���������������������������� �������

��������� �������������������������������������������

���������������
���������������������������������������������������
�������������������
���������������������� ������������������������������������������
��������������
��������������
������������������

������������
���������������������������������
������������������
�������������������������������� �����������������������
��������������������������
�������������������
����������������������������������
����������������������� ������������������������������
��������������������������

�������������������
������
�����������������
���������������������
���������������������

���������������������������������
������������������
����������������������
����������������������������

�����������������������
���������������������������������������

���������������������������������������������������

Underground storage tanks


Vipel® F774
Containment Solutions Product Selection Guide
The AOC Product Selection Guide is designed to
Terephthalic polyester resins are chemically similar help fabricators select the optimum Vipel resin that
to isophthalic resins and provide corrosion-resistant meets the needs for value and performance. The
service that competes very favorably with isophthal- Product Selection Guide lists and describes Vipel
ics. Since terephthalics generally have a higher heat resins by resin type and product series designa-
distortion temperature and higher elongation than tion. The Product Selection Guide also has a Cross
isophthalics, terephthalics are generally recommend- Reference to AOC Corrosion Resins that lists simi-
ed over isophthalics except where UV resistance is lar resins from other major corrosion resistant res-
required. The primary chemical difference between in manufacturers. This table can help fabricators
terephthalics and isophthalics is the type of acid – select the appropriate AOC resin or resins where
terephthalic or isophthalic – used to create the base specifications allow “or equal” or “equivalent”
polyester resin. substitution. This Cross Reference is also included
in the Appendix of this publication. If you
Vipel® F713 is a standard 1:1 terephthalic/maleic would like a copy of the most current
resin that also has excellent handling and processing Product Selection Guide, contact your AOC
characteristics. Corrosion Specialist or download a copy from
www.corrosionresins.com.

11
3
Selecting
Reinforcements

Fiberglass woven roving


12
Selection of reinforcements is not as complex as se- cal veils produce [0.010 to 0.015 inches (0.25
lection of resins. Chemical service can influence the – 0.38 mm)] thickness per ply or layer. As noted
selection of veil material for exposed surfaces and the in the Corrosion Resistant Resin Selection Guide,
type of glass for gun rovings and mats used in inte- some aggressive service conditions require two
rior layers adjacent to the surface. Industry standards, (2) plies or layers of the required veil material.
project specifications, fabrication processes and ap-
plication techniques usually include stipulations for the Chopped Strand Mats
other forms of reinforcement to be used.

Surface Veils

Chopped strand mat


The strands in chopped strand mats are typically
1.5-inch (3.8 cm) long Type E or ECR glass fi-
C-glass veil ber. Mats are typically available as roll goods in
weights from 0.75 to 3.0 oz/ft2 (225 to 600 g/
m2) and widths from 3 to 120 inches (7.6 cm to
304 cm). The most commonly used for corrosion
resistant laminates are 0.75 and 1.5 oz/ft2 (225
to 450 g/m2). Binders applied to the chopped fi-
bers to hold the mat together must be compatible
with the resin systems used.

Synthetic veil

Surface veils are intended to provide limited reinforce-


ment to thin [0.01 to 0.03 inches, (0.25 mm to 0.76
mm) thick] resin rich layers on the exposed surfaces
of corrosion resistant equipment to reduce cracking
and crazing of the resin. The most commonly used Hand lay-up of fiberglass mat
veil material is monofilament fiber made from Type C
or ECR glass. Synthetic veils, such as Nexus®, made Some chopped strand mats, while compatible
from polyester or other man made fibers are used in with most corrosion resins, can exhibit a visual
chemical environments that would attack glass fibers. phenomenon in some vinyl ester resins referred
Specialty veils are frequently preferred in some severe to as “glint” and “jack straw.” While this appear-
environments. ance does not impact the laminate structurally,
it may affect long term chemical performance
The weight and thickness of the veil plies dictate the in aggressive environments. Presence of “glint”
thickness of a veil-reinforced layer. The resulting sur- and “jack straw” may be a cause for rejection by
face layer is usually 90 to 95% resin by weight. Typi- some users.
13
Woven Roving, Specialty Fabrics available in a variety of widths from 4 inches to 120
Woven roving [24 oz/yd (814 g/m )] is the most
2 2 inches (10.2 to 305 cm) depending on the type of
commonly used supplemental reinforcement for hand product and the weaving or knitting process and ma-
lay-up and spray-up structural layers in corrosion resis- chinery used.
tant laminates. These materials are usually preceded
and followed by a layer of chopped strand mat or Combination Fabrics
spray-up equivalent to avoid adjacent woven plies. These fabrics are a combination of chopped strand
Accepted industry practice is to alternate mat or chop mat with woven roving or bi-directional fabric on a
plies with these fabric reinforcements. single roll. Numerous weight combinations and widths
are available. The most common combination is a 1.5
oz/ft2 (450 g/m2) mat attached to a [(24 oz/yd2
(814 g/m2)] woven roving or [(18 oz/yd2 (610 g/
m2)] bidirectional fabric. These specialty materials are
convenient for exterior joints in pipe, tanks and duct.
Some specifications restrict or prohibit the use of this
type of reinforcement without prior written approval.

Gun Roving
Gun roving is a continuous fiber suitable for chopping
or cutting with a conventional spray-up chopper gun.
The roving is delivered in a coreless package called a
Woven roving “doff” or ball. The density of the material is typically
given as the “yield” expressed in yd/pound. Typical
gun roving yields are in the 210 to 230 yd/pound
(423 to 463 m/kg) range. Gun rovings are usually
Type “E” glass. Type “ECR” rovings are also available
and provide better chemical performance in aggres-
sive environments.

Unidirectional fabric

Bi-directional fabrics are similar to woven roving ex-


cept that the rovings are held together with a non-glass
knitted stitch yarn. This keeps the rovings straight in
the finished laminate and tends to increase the physi-
cal properties in comparison to woven roving.

Uni-directional fabrics are used to impart strength in


one direction. Uni-directional fabrics generally have Gun roving
the glass fibers in the fill direction (across the width of
the roll) and the knitting yarns in the weft direction (the As with chopped strand mat, the binder on the roving
length of the roll). These fabrics are frequently added must be compatible with the resin system being used.
to filament wound structures to add longitudinal or The binder or sizing on the roving also impacts the
axial strength, particularly where the winding angle processing attributes such as choppability, fiber fall-
is shallow (nearly circumferential). These materials are out from the resin glass stream, degree of static build-
up and catenary.
14
Probably most important are the wet out and roll out glass. Type “ECR” rovings are also available and
characteristics after the roving has been chopped and provide better chemical performance in aggres-
sprayed onto the part with the resin. The ultimate qual- sive environments. Binders or finishes on winding
ity of the laminate is a function of the degree to which rovings must be compatible with the resin system
entrapped air is removed. Ease of air removal dur- being used. The binder impacts the wet-out, pro-
ing rollout will directly impact the workers ability to cessing and handling characteristics.
achieve acceptable quality.

Filament winding process

Winding rovings need to be resistant to fiber


breakage as they are pulled from the package in
a creel through various guide eyes to the wet-out
bath or applicator head. Some systems pre-wet
Automated spray-up process the roving in a resin bath while others apply resin
to the mandrel. In either case the handling char-
Filament Winding Rovings acteristics from the roving package to the part
are very important. Once the roving is on the
part, the wet-out, ribbon tension and uniformity of
the multi-roving band influence the thickness, den-
sity and glass-to-resin ratio in the cured laminate.

Filament winding roving on creel

Filament winding rovings, like gun rovings, are con-


tinuous fibers provided in doffs or balls. Roving weight
is measured as “yield” and expressed in yd/pound.
Typical yields are from 113 to 675 yd/pound (227 to
1,359 m/kg). Winding rovings are usually Type “E”
15
4
Initiator,
Promoters
and Other
Additives

Adding promoter to unpromoted resin


16
Open molding processes typically utilize room tem- suppliers is typically in the area of 9%. The active
perature cure systems. Catalyst is added to resin that oxygen content of organic initiator peroxide var-
is pre-promoted as purchased or blended by the fab- ies by geographical region. Fabricators should
ricator using promoters, accelerators and other addi- check with their local organic peroxide initia-
tives to provide specific process curing characteristics. tor supplier for specific active oxygen content
Gel time, gel to peak exotherm time and temperature guidelines. MEKP is typically used with cobalt
can be selectively tailored by careful knowledgeable napthanate (CoNAP) promoter and DMA/DEA
use of these additives. accelerators for room temperature curing of most
polyester and vinyl ester resins. Concentration of
Typical Vipel® resin gel times in the Appendix of this isomers/active oxygen variations of MEKP can
guide gives detailed formulations for various resins to provide additional cure flexibility with some resin
provide the fabricator maximum flexibility in dictating and promoter systems. There are several versions
cure behavior. Each formulation listed identifies the of MEKP. For example, some have low dimer con-
catalyst, promoter, accelerator and any other additive tents and others have high dimer contents. For
preferred to achieve the indicated gel and cure times. vinyl ester resins, MEKP initiator with a high di-
mer content is the preferred initiator. Examples
of MEKP products that are high in dimer content
are Hi Point® 90, Lupersox® DHD 9 and Norox®
MEKP 925 H. Examples of MEKP that are low
4
in dimer content are Luperox DDM-9 and Norox
MEKP 9.

CHP (cumene hydroperoxide) is principally


used with high reactivity vinyl ester resins such as
Vipel F085 to provide lower exotherm tempera-
tures and reduced shrinkage. CHP performs well
with CoNAP/DMA formulations. CHP is also suit-
able for some other resins where slower cures
are required or thicker laminates are made in a
single pass without intermediate cure and exo-
MEKP catalyst with dispenser therm stopping points.

Initiators BPO (benzoyl peroxide) is available in powder


Initiators, frequently referred to as catalysts, start the form, as a paste or in a liquid emulsion. Powders
gelling process. Initiator is mixed into promoted resins and pastes are difficult to use and control. When
immediately prior to use or are injected by spray gun. BPO is required, emulsions with 40% active BPO
When practical it is best to pour additives into the content are preferred for use with Vipel vinyl es-
vortex so that they do not cling to the side wall of the ter resins. When determining BPO additive con-
container. Initiator is injected into the promoted resin centration take into account the dilution factor.
stream in spray-up equipment systems. CAUTION: (Gel time tables are based on 98% active BPO.)
Initiator is NEVER mixed with promoters or accelera- BPO initiator with DMA accelerator is preferred
tors. The best procedure is to add initiators to resin for laminates in sodium hypochlorite service in
that already contains promoters or accelerators. Di- place of conventional MEKP/CoNAP/DMA cure
rect contact of an initiator with a promoter or accel- systems. The ratio of BPO to DMA is critical to
erator can create an explosive condition or cause a avoid gel and cure inconsistencies. Post curing
fire. Consult the MSDS for each of these materials for is required to achieve complete cure with BPO/
safe handling and storage. DMA.

MEKP (methyl ethyl ketone peroxide) is the most


commonly used organic peroxide initiator. In North
America, active oxygen content of MEKP provided by
17
Blended initiators tics may be altered. TBC as purchased is usually 85%
Trigonox® 239A is an example of a proprietary blend active inhibitor and should be used very carefully. A
of initiator that may reduce foaming in some vinyl es- very small amount of TBC can have a significant and
ter resins. inconsistent impact on gel and cure. Addition of small
quantities is best controlled using a 5 or 10% solu-
Promoters and Accelerators tion in styrene and adjusting formulations accordingly.
CoNAP (cobalt naphthanate) promoter is typically CAUTION: Care must be taken to prevent TBC solu-
a 6% solution in an organic solvent. Other versions tions from contacting the skin. Refer to the MSDS.
such as 12% are available. The formulations provid-
ed in the Appendix of this guide are based on 6% 2,4-pentanedione (2,4-P) is a gel time extender or
CoNAP solutions. retarder for vinyl ester resins; however, it is also a pro-
moter for polyester resins. 2,4-P is recommended for
DMA (N,N di-methylaniline) is used as an accelera- long gel times because it has minimal effect on the
tor in conjunction with CoNap promoter when using ultimate cure. It is effective for MEKP and CHP initiator
MEKP or CHP initiators or by itself with BPO. DMA is systems but is not effective with BPO initiator systems.
normally provided as a 100% active liquid however Caution is needed using 2,4-P. Refer to the MSDS for
10% active versions are available. handling instructions. Several of the tables in the Ap-
pendix of this publication demonstrate formulations
DEA (N,N di-ethylaniline) can be substituted for where gel times have been adjusted through the use
DMA in some systems to extend gel times and reduce of 2,4-P.
exotherm temperatures in highly reactive systems.
With respect to health safety, DEA is marginally safer Other Resin Additives
than DMA. Consult the MSDS for current status Other chemicals and materials may be added to the
resin formulation to achieve specific end-use require-
ments. Fabricators should review the appropriate lit-
erature and check with an AOC technical representa-
tive and the additive supplier to see how a particular
additive’s use may affect resin processing or perfor-
mance. Here are the more widely-used resin additives
that unlike catalysts, promoters and inhibitors, are not
directly related to resin cure:

Ultraviolet absorbers are typically added for appli-


cations that must resist the degrading effects of long-
term exposure to sunlight. UV absorbers are used
on the exterior portion of the laminate and where
specified by the buyer. Most specifications define the
amount and type of UV absorber. Alternatively, the
recommendation of UV absorber manufacturers can
be followed. UV absorbers are most commonly added
to the top coat but may be added at a lower loading
Resin bath for filament winding
to the structural layer.

Inhibitors and Gel Time Extenders Synergists may be added to added to fire retardant
TBC (tert butyl catechol) is an inhibitor frequently resins to meet specifications calling for code flame
added to styrene monomer to provide longer shelf life spread requirements. The most commonly used fire
when the monomer is purchased in drum quantities. retardant synergist fillers are antimony oxides. These
When any styrene containing TBC is added to promot- products are used with halogenated resins to enhance
ed resin mixes, the resin gel time and cure characteris-

18
the fire retardant properties. Addition of these prod- Thixotropes such as Cab-O-Sil® TS-720 or Aero-
ucts to non halogenated resins does not improve the sil® R 202 can be added for viscosity control or
flame resistance significantly. Antimony trioxide has making putties and pastes. However, it is recom-
been the most common product, and it should be in- mended that they not be used in corrosion liner
corporated with a high shear mixer in order to ensure resins as they will reduce chemical resistance.
that the particles are suitably dispersed into the resin.
Frequent mixing is recommended to prevent settling in Abrasion resistant additives such as aluminum
the resin. oxide, silica and silicon carbide can be added
to resin to improve the abrasion resistance of the
Liquid dispersions of antimony products are also composite. Other fillers are generally prohibited
available and preferred by many fabricators. Since in many corrosion-resistant equipment specifica-
the liquid dispersions such as Nyacol® APE3040 are tions. Occasionally, inert conductive fillers such
only 40% active, this dilution factor must be taken into as graphite or carbon black will be added to
account. Nyacol is a dispersion of the synergist in a a resin to meet electrical conductivity require-
non corrosion-resistant resin. This should be taken into ments. Abrasion resistance of the composite can
consideration for some severe corrosion applications. be improved through the use of hard, inert fillers
Generally, antimony oxides are not incorporated into such as silicon carbide.
the corrosion barrier, so this is not normally a concern.
Some grades of antimony trioxide fillers and disper- Defoaming agents are occasionally needed to
4
sions have been known to cause gel drift. Thus any enhance release of air bubbles that form in the
antimony oxide product should be added to the resin resin when cobalt and MEKP initiators are used.
just prior to use and the gel time checked daily. Foaming is less common when high dimer initia-
tors are used than when low dimer imitators are
One significant advantage of using a liquid disper- used. Examples are BYK®-A 555 and Foam Kill.
sion such as Nyacol® APE3040 is that the laminate is
less opaque. Thus the removal of air bubbles from a Vapor suppressants can be added to resins
resin containing Nyacol APE3040 is easier. to reduce styrene and other monomer emissions
and are becoming a more important part in emis-
sion compliant issues. Resins containing these ad-
ditives must be tested per the MACT specified
test method to determine the particular emission
reduction index for each additive in each resin.
Fabricators also need to be aware that these
additives can affect secondary bonding and in
many cases this will need to be tested also. If
secondary bonding is not an issue, paraffin wax
can be used. For some applications where sec-
ondary bonding is necessary, BYK-S 740/750
have been used. However, acceptable second-
Three specimens of Vipel® K022-C series resin show the effect of ary bonding can never be assured when prod-
synergist addition on translucency. The clear one has no syner- ucts such as these are used. It is always best to
gists. The middle one contains 2.5% Nyacol® APE3040. The
most opaque one contains 1.5% antimony trioxide.
grind before applying secondary laminates.

Pigments add inherent color to the finished part. Pig-


ments are not widely used in the fabrication of corro-
sion resistant equipment and are prohibited in the cor-
rosion barrier by many specifications except by user
fabricator agreement. AOC’s Chroma-Tek® pigment
dispersions are recommended if color is desired.

19
5
Resin Quality
Assurance &
Record
Keeping

Gel time test

20
Good recordkeeping is the essential first step to ensur- 3) Type and quantity of catalyst used
ing the quality and consistency of corrosion resistant in the resin to manufacture the corrosion
parts. From incoming raw materials to finished parts liner, structural layer and the topcoat.
shipment, the fabricator should keep a record of any
variables that may affect the part’s ability to meet me- 4) Ambient temperature and the temperature
chanical and physical property targets. The fabricator of the resin used for all fabrication steps.
should keep the quality control information provided
5) Viscosity and gel time of the resin.
by material suppliers.
Gel times should be checked periodically
for each application process.
The quality assurance measurements in Table 1. “Com-
mon Quality Control Tests” are conducted, using prop- 6) Quantity of resin used in the manufac-
erly maintained and calibrated equipment. A step-by- ture of the corrosion liner, structural layer
step protocol for each of the AOC test procedures is and the top coat.
available on request and can also be obtained from the
AOC Corrosion Specialist for your region. In addition 7) The quantity of reinforcement should be
to those pre-shipment tests performed by AOC, several recorded. If glass reinforcement is used, a
tests that should be routinely checked by the fabricator close approximation the glass content
are also listed. Table 2. “Getting Started with Quality would be an ash content.
Assurance Equipment” is intended for composite manu-
facturing operations that may need help in selecting 8) AOC certificate of analysis and the
equipment for these measurements. fabricators comparative data.

9) Post cure temperature and time.


Quality Assurance
Quality control testing guidelines on incoming raw ma-
terials are listed in detail in ASME RTP-1. This is an
10) Mechanical testing on finished com-
posites. Examples are flexural strength,
5
excellent reference document for all corrosion fabrica- flexural modulus, tensile strength, ten-
tors. An AOC certificate of analysis should accompany sile modulus, glass resin ratio (by burn-out)
every batch of resin. If the certificate is lost in transit, and Barcol hardness.

fabricators are encouraged to obtain replacement cer- 11) Other records should be kept such
tificates from the producing AOC plant or the distribu- as the thickness of the corrosion barri-
tor as needed. Fabricators who have quality control er and the structural portion, hardness
testing capability can compare their test results with the measurements, cut outs, acetone sensitiv-
AOC results. If there is a significant variation between ity, visual effects, etc.
the two values, fabricators should contact the technical
service lab at the AOC producing plant.

Record Keeping
ASME RTP-1 is also an excellent reference document
for record keeping guidelines. Basic resin information
that is useful for record keeping follows:

1) Identification of the resin used in the corrosion


liner, structural layer and the topcoat. Include the
batch number.
2) The amount and type of promoter, thixotrope,
monomer, inhibitor, UV additive, styrene sup-
pressant and other additives included in the
resin formulation.

21
Viscosity test Barcol hardness test

* A step-by-step protocol of AOC test procedures is available upon request.

22
1 2

Barcol impresser No. GYZJ 934-1 (hard) Gardco (800-762-2478)

Beakers - 100, 250, 400 & 800 ml,


tri-cornered polypropylene 02-593-50B, -C, -D & -E Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Blender (commercial mixer) HA908 Hamilton Beach (800-572-3331)

Desiccant bags 08-594-17B Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Desiccator 08-595D Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Disposable transfer pipettes 13-711-5A Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Gel timer 22A Sunshine (800-343-1199)

Glass rods 11-380A Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Lubricant 14-635-5D Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Muffle furnace 10-750-14A Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Oven 13-247-826F Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)


5
Pipette 2 ml 13-671-108B Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Pipette bulb 13-681-102A Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Scale (gram triple beam) Ohaus 710-00 Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Scale digital Model# PR2003DR Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)


Cat# 01-918-29

Spatula - 4 inch blade 14-365B Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Specific gravity cup CB-1130 BYK-Gardner (800-343-7721)

Stopwatch 14-648-1 Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Test tubes 19x150 cat 14-925K Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Thermometer digital (pyrometer) MP20700 Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Thermometer Infrared U-35629-10 Cole-Parmer (800-323-4340)

Thermometers (standard glass:


-10 to 260°C range) 15-041-4F Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Tongue depressors 01-346 Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

Viscometer Brookfield RVF Brookfield (800-628-8139)

Water bath 15-460-6 Fisher Scientific (800-766-7000)

1 Manufacturers may change product designation or replace models with new versions.
2 Specific manufacturer names are provided as a starting point and do not constitute an endorsement by AOC.

23
6
Resin Handling,
Safety and
Regulatory Issues

Resin storage area

24
Storage Resin selection is usually a significant variable in
Ideally, vinyl ester and polyester resins should be developing and implementing a MACT compli-
stored out of direct sunlight at below 77°F (25°C). ance strategy. For years, AOC has maintained
Temperatures above 77°F (25°C) will shorten the us- a leadership position in the development of low
able working life of a resin. Generally, non-formu- styrene resin systems that offer processability
lated resins (ones without thixotrope or promoters) that is as good as, and in some cases better
are much more stable than formulated resins. Bulk than, that offered by higher styrene-content res-
storage tanks should either be stainless steel or car- ins. AOC is committed to providing resins en-
bon steel. Drums should have bungs closed to keep gineered to offer the optimum combination of
moisture out. Inventory of resins should be rotated so processability, end-use performance and regu-
that the first in is the first used. latory compliance. In addition, AOC offers the
industry’s best technical support for helping
Safety fabricators achieve the highest levels of quality,
Safe procedures must be followed in using vinyl ester consistency and regulatory compliance.
and polyester resins, promoters, iniators and other
additives. For example, promoters or accelerators OSHA
(such as cobalt naphthanate) must never come in di- Exposure to styrene in the workplace is regulat-
rect contact with any catalyst such as MEKP. A violent ed by the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health
explosion and fire can occur. Thus promoters or ac- Adminstration (OHSA). Industries producing
celerators must be completely mixed into the resin and using styrene agreed to establish a volun-
before any catalyst is added. A complete review of tary program with the OSHA to limit workplace
MSDS information on all raw materials used to make inhalation exposures to styrene to 50 ppm on an
composites is necessary. 8-hour Time Weighted Average (TWA), and a
100 ppm 15-minute Short Term Limit (STL). One
Regulatory Issues of the best sources for more details on this issue
is AMCA whose website is www.acmanet.org.
MACT
Composite fabricators must comply with Maximum State and Local
Achievable Control Technology (MACT) regulations Fabricators should check with their state and lo-
established by the U.S. Environmental Protection. For cal government agencies to determine if they are
subject to emission standards that are in addi-
composites fabrication, styrene (the principal mono-
mer in polyester and vinyl ester resins) and methyl tion to those established by the EPA and OSHA. 6
methacrylate (frequently used monomer in gel coats A listing of significant state and local regulations
and some resins) are listed as Hazardous Air Pollut- is maintained by ACMA.
ants (HAPs).

Affected composites manufacturers must demon-


strate compliance in accordance with options pro-
vided in the final EPA National Emissions Standards
for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP), codified in
40 CFR Part 63 Subpart WWWW. The American
Composites Manufacturers Association (ACMA) is
an excellent source of information and guidance
about the rule. ACMA also provides MACT com-
pliance calculators for member companies and
links to EPA documents. Generally, detailed MACT
information is not available for non-members. For
more information about AMCA, go to www.acmanet.
org. Copies of the MACT rule, revisions and other re-
Storing resin behind a dam prevents spread
lated documents are is available on the EPA web site
of accidental spills.
at http://www.epa.gov/ttn/atw/rpc/rpcpg.html

25
7
Composite
Processing
Guidelines

Fiberglass roving conveyed through guides

26
The following rules, principles and recommendations the corrosion liner within 24 hours. In this case
are based on shop experiences and in many cases grinding is normally not required. Other cases
reflect practices outlined in industry standards. For involving grinding are:
more details on the manufacture and fabrication of
fiber-reinforced polymer composites for corrosion- 1) Resins Containing Wax. Very few
resistant service, contact the AOC Corrosion Team. Vipel® resins contain wax or wax type
To find the team member for your geographical re- products but sometimes the fabrica-
gion, go to Corrosion Team on the homepage menu tor may add wax to minimize styrene evapo-
of www.corrosionresins.com. ration and or facilitate the fast cure of the
resin. When wax is used, the surface
Post Curing should be ground with a coarse (16 or 24
To ensure that the final composite will meet fire retar- grit) grinding disc.
dant and corrosion resistant expectations, post curing
is recommended. In addition, post curing is required 2) Novolac Resins. Novolac resins are
on any composite that will be used for food/drug ap- highly reactive and present more of a
plications and aggressive chemicals such as sodium challenge with respect to secondary
hypochlorite. Post curing vinyl ester options are: bonding. Before applying a secondary
bond, the surface should be ground with a
1) Two hours at 200°F (93°C) grinding disc, as mentioned above. Re-
2) Four hours at 180°F (82°C) move all dust and debris after grinding
Depending on the chemical environment, novolac prior to the application of the secondary
resin composites may need to be post cured for four laminate.The secondary bonding should
hours at 212°F (100°C). Depending on the heat dis- be started within 2 hours from the time the
tortion temperature of the isophthalics or terephthal- surface preparation was completed. Oth-
ics, post cure is generally accomplished by heating erwise, foreign material may get on the
for four hours at 160°F (71°C) to 180°F (82°C). Ide- surface that could interfere with the bond.
ally, laminates cured with BPO should be post cured
within one week of lamination. This is not neces- Test Patches
sary with composites cured with MEKP. Temperature Test patches may be used when making repairs
should be closely monitored during ramp-up, at peak to interior surfaces that have been exposed to
temperature and during cool down. Direct any ques- chemicals that reduce adhesion. Primer coats
tions on this procedure to AOC’s Product Leader for with Vipel F017 are recommended to improve
Corrosion Resins. the adhesion with or without the test patch result.
If you need assistance in the proper preparation
Secondary Bonding of a test patch, contact an AOC Corrosion Spe-
Secondary bonds can easily be applied to most com- cialist.
posites manufactured with Vipel products. Laminates
are typically ground prior to secondary bonding
operations. The structural layer is usually applied to
Top Coats
A top coat of 0.002 - 0.004 inches (0.05-0.1 7
mm) is used to protect the glass fiber content
below. Paraffin wax is often added to improve
cure on the air-exposed surface. Achieving the
optimal coating thickness is important. A thin-
ner coat usually cures poorly; a thicker coat is
more prone to cracking.

Small batches and short gel times are preferred


techniques for preventing the top coat from run-
ning off the surface.

Bonding composite to composite

27
It is important that a top coat gels and cures quickly. Formulating Topcoat Resins
The potential for entrapment of foreign materials on Formulation and gel time of topcoat resins are criti-
the surface increases as the gel time is extended. cal for optimum cure and performance of coated
Polyester and vinyl ester laminates that are exposed surfaces. The required paraffin content is generally
to air during cure in an open molding process re- 0.05-0.20 % by weight depending on the generic
main tacky due to air inhibition of the resin on the resin type. Since the paraffin is insoluble in the resin,
surface. Degree of inhibition varies depending on a solution of paraffin wax in styrene is added to the
the generic resin type. Air-exposed surfaces will not resin.
reach complete cure over time or with post curing.
• Resin and paraffin solution temperatures should be
Paraffin wax is added to resins to reduce air inhibi- at least 70°F (21°C) when preparing the topcoat mix-
tion and improve the cure of these surfaces. Sec- ture.
ondary bonding is impaired when paraffin has been
added to laminating resins. • Paraffin solution should be slowly added to the
resin after mixing has been started.
Paraffin Wax – Styrene Solution
A ten percent (10%) solution by weight of paraffin • Addition of thixotropic agents should be avoided.
wax dissolved in styrene is added to laminating res-
ins in the formulation of topcoat resins systems. The • Topcoat resins should be thoroughly re-mixed im-
solution may be purchased from a fiberglass materi- mediately prior to use. Mixing action should be mild
als distributor or can be prepared by the fabricator. to avoid generation of air bubbles.
When the fabricator chooses to make the solution,
several precautions are important: • Batch size should be dictated by estimated needs
for use within one day of preparation.
• The paraffin wax used must have a melting point
of 118 -122°F (48-50°C). • Initiator level should be such that the exotherm tem-
perature is reached in a relatively short time after
• Warming of the solution is required to dissolve the gelation to insure complete cure of the thin topcoat
paraffin. layer.

• Equipment used for warming must be explosion • Gel time of the topcoat resin should be 5 to 10
proof. minutes at the application temperature.

• Solution should be re-heated immediately prior to For recommended promoter, paraffin solution and
use to insure that the paraffin is not crystallized or initiator formulations, contact a member of the AOC
solidified when added to the resin. Corrosion Team or your AOC technical representa-
tive.

Left: improperly applied wax topcoat


Right: properly applied wax topcoat

28
Application of Topcoats
Surface preparation: Surfaces should be clean,
dry and free of dust and other foreign matter. When
applying the topcoat to the air inhibited side of pri-
mary laminates the surface to be coated should be
lightly sanded or scuffed to remove loose fiber and
any other blemishes. For fresh (recently laminated,
exothermed and cooled) secondary surfaces sand-
ing should only be necessary to remove loose fiber
and any other blemishes. Solvent wiping should be
avoided to prevent contamination of the prepared
surface.

Applying a topcoat

Brush or roller application: Where practical


the topcoat should be poured on the prepared
surface and then spread with a brush or roller.
Strokes with the brush or roller should be mini-
mized. Excessive brushing or rolling can pre-
vent the paraffin from surfacing and leave the
exposed surface shiny and tacky. Avoid disturb-
ing adjacent surfaces that have already been
coated. Use care to insure coverage of all pre-
pared areas with as little overlap as possible
onto unprepared surfaces.

Spray application: Spray-applied topcoats


should also have relatively short gel times. Light
brushing or rolling shortly after spraying will as-
sist in spreading the topcoat uniformly and pro-
Surface grinding mote the release of any froth or foaming from
the initiator. As with brush or roller application,
Catalyzing topcoat resin for brush or roller appli- it is important not to disturb the paraffin on ad-
cation: The quantity of topcoat resin to be catalyzed jacent wet surfaces.
should be approximately the amount of resin that
can be applied before it gels in the container. Since Appearance: Properly topcoated surfaces will
the mix has been formulated for a relatively short have a dull hazy surface that is not tacky after
gel time, the amount may be small. After thorough
stirring to ensure complete mixing of the initiator, al-
complete cure. Shiny or streaky areas will likely
be tacky and are indications that the paraffin
7
low the mixture to rest for a moment to allow froth did not come to the surface or was disturbed.
or foaming to dissipate before applying the topcoat.

29
Bonding to Concrete
The following guidelines are for applying an FRP
laminate to concrete. For specific questions, contact
your AOC Corrosion Team member.

• For best results the concrete should be at least one


month old.

• Grind or sandblast the surface to remove loose


concrete and oil spots.

• Pits or cracks should be repaired with a putty and


sanded.

• Wash the surface of the concrete with 10:1 muri-


atic acid.

• Rinse the surface with tap water starting 20 min-


utes to 45 minutes after the muriatic acid is applied.

• Allow the concrete surface to thoroughly dry.

• Apply 0.002-0.003 inches (0.05-0.08 mm) Vipel®


F017 primer. Vipel F017 is supplied unpromoted and
thus a promoter and initiator must be added for the
primer to gel and cure properly. The recommended
initiator for Vipel F017 primer is Methyl Ethyl Ketone
Peroxide (MEKP).

• The temperature of the concrete surface must be


over 65°F (18°C).

• Inspect to make sure no foreign material such as


dirt or water landed on the primer. If so, clean up
and spot repair primer, as needed.

• Apply the composite after the primer has cured


and plan to lay up on the primer within 3 days of the
primer being tack free.

• Apply a top coat onto the final cured composite as


described above.

30
Applying composite to steel.

Bonding to Steel
The following guidelines are for applying an FRP
laminate to steel. For specific questions, contact a
member of the AOC Corrosion Team.

• Sandblast or grind the surface to white metal con-


forming to NACE No 1 or SSPC-SP-5.

• Fill holes, pits or defects with a putty.

• Fill in sharp radius surfaces with a putty. This ap-


plies to all bolts, overlapping plates holes, etc. Allow
the putty to cure and sand to a smooth surface.

• Vacuum the surface to remove any dust.

• Apply 0.002-0.003 inches (0.05-0.076 mm) Vi-


pel® F017 primer. Vipel F017 is supplied unpromot-
ed and thus a promoter and initiator must be added
for the primer to gel and cure properly. The recom-
mended initiator for Vipel F017 primer is Methyl
7
Ethyl Ketone Peroxide (MEKP).

• Apply composite as soon as possible after the prim-


er has cured and plan to lay up on the primer within
3 days of the primer being tack free. The choice of
specific resin will depend on the chemical environ-
ment that the composite is exposed to, temperature,
specific mechanical stresses, etc. Avoid contamina-
tion of the primer surface prior to the application of
the composite.

• Grind off stray fibers with an 80 grit abrasive.

• Apply a top coat onto the final cured composite as


described above.
31
8
Appendix

Interior of a scrubber in the shop


Vipel® K022-CC
Heil Process Equipment
32
Typical Formulations and Gel Times 3)
Extra care must be taken to
of Select Vipel® Resins handle tertiary butyl cath-
ecol (TBC) because it can burn
The information contained in the following tables is the skin upon contact. The higher the con-
a guide for promoting and inhibiting non-promoted centration, the more likely TBC will burn.
Vipel® resins. The recommended method of making TBC will inhibit any initiator system but
additions is: its use should not exceed 0.05% of
the 85% version. TBC is best
1) After the mixer is turned on, drop the used as a 10% solution in sty-
additive onto the surface of the resin in such rene. The solution can be prepared
a way as to minimize the possibility of the from solid TBC or an 85% concentrated so-
product clinging to the top edge of the lution depending on availability.
container.
4)
Methyl Ethyl Ketone Peroxide (MEKP) is
2) Mix until uniform. available in many different raw material
components. By varying the concentration
3) Repeat for each additive and beware that of the components, many different version
promoters or accelerators must never of MEKP are available. High dimer versions
come in direct contact with initiators. are suggested preferred for vinyl esters.

It is usually a good plan to prepare a small sample Care must be used in handling these chemicals
and check the gel time before proceeding to make a from a health and safety perspective. Review
larger production quantity. information available in the MSDS document
before using the product.
Cobalt solutions, tertiary butyl catechol (TBC) and
benzoyl peroxide (BPO) are available in several con-
centrations. The concentrations of these products in
this guide are 6, 85 and 98% respectively. In many
cases, adjustments will be needed to account for the
concentration of the product in hand.

There are advantages and disadvantages to some of


these additives as described below:

1)
N,N-Diethylaniline (DEA) is a slightly
safer product to handle than N,N-Dimethyl-
aniline (DMA). Gel times with DEA are
longer (about twice as long) than when
DMA is used at the same concentration.

2) 2,4-Pentanedione (2,4-P) is the preferred


inhibitor because there is minimal effect on
the gel to peak and the peak temperature of
vinyl esters. 2,4-P is not effective when
benzoyl peroxide is used as an initiator.
2,4-P acts as a promoter for polyester resins, 8
thus it can only be used as an inhibitor in
vinyl ester resins.

33
Typical Formulations and Gel Times of Select Vipel® Resins
Gel Times for Vipel® F010–CNL, CNM and CNT series
Cobalt Naphthenate (6%) & DMA and alternate DEA with 1.25% Hipoint 90 – MEKP Catalyst
DMA DEA
Resin
Temperature 60s 70s 90s 60s 70s 90s
(°F)
10 – 20 min. 19 16 13 18 17 15 12 15
MEKP,% 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25
CoNAP,% 0.3 0.3 0.1 0.1 0.3 0.3 0.1 0.1
DMA,% 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05
DEA,% 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.1
2,4-P,% 0.01 0.01
TBC,% 0.01 0.005
.
20 – 40 min 26 32 29 25 38 32 29 36 34 27 29 30
MEKP,% 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25
CoNAP,% 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1
DMA,% 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05
DEA,% 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1
2,4-P,% 0.02 0.05 0.05 0.02 0.05 0.04
TBC,% 0.01 0.015 0.025 0.01 0.015 0.02

40 – 60 min. 43 43 50 52 51 46 47 49 44 51 48 51
MEKP,% 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25
CoNAP,% 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1
DMA,% 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05
DEA,% 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1
2,4-P,% 0.05 0.08 0.1 0.05 0.07 0.06
TBC,% 0.017 0.03 0.04 0.016 0.03 0.035

Typical Formulations and Gel Times of Select Vipel® Resins


Gel Times for Vipel® F010–CNL, CNM and CNT series
Benzoyl Peroxide Catalyst (BPO) with DMA and alternative DEA
[For laminates less than 3/16 inches (4.8 mm) thick]
Resin Temperature (°F) 60s 70s 90s
10 – 20 min. 17 16 17 18 13 13
BPO,% 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
DMA,% 0.3 0.2 0.1
DEA,% 0.6 0.45 0.3

20 – 40 min. 36 35 27 30 38 25
BPO,% 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
DMA,% 0.1 0.1 0.05
DEA,% 0.3 0.25 0.15

40 – 60 min. 54 44 57 52 48 52
BPO,% 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
DMA,% 0.07 0.05 0.04
DEA,% 0.2 0.15 0.1

Legend for abbreviations


2,4-P: Pentanedione
CoNAP: Cobalt Naphthanate – 6% solution
BPO: Benzoyl Peroxide – 98% active
(Adjust addition level for other concentrations)
DEA: N,N Diethylaniline
DMA: N,N Dimethylaniline
TBC: Tertiary Butyl Catechol – 85%
THQ: Toluhydroquinone – 10% solution in styrene
(Available from AOC as “Inhibitor A”)

34
Typical Formulations and Gel Times of Select Vipel® Resins
Gel Times for Vipel® K022-AC, CCC , CCL, CNC series
Cobalt Naphthenate (6%) & DMA and DEA alternative with 1.25% Hipoint 90 – MEKP Catalyst

DMA DEA
Resin
Temperature 60s 70s 90s 60s 70s 90s
(°F)
10 – 20 min. 20 13 17 16 17 13
MEKP,% 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25
CoNAP,% 0.2 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3
DMA,% 0. 2 0.15 0.05
DEA,% 0.5 0.3 0.2

20 – 40 min. 24 32 36 27 31 30 28 35 36 33
MEKP,% 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25
CoNAP,% 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2
DMA,% 0.1 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05
DEA,% 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1
2,4-P,% 0.05 0.08 0.05 0.08
TBC,% 0.0075 0.01 0.004 0.017

40 – 60 min. 44 52 48 50 46 55 44 45 48 56 52 43
MEKP,% 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25
CoNAP,% 0.2 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2
DMA,% 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05
DEA,% 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1
2,4-P,% 0.04 0.075 0.1 0.04 0.06 0.1
TBC,% 0.007 0.015 0.02 0.005 0.01 0.025

Typical Formulations and Gel Times of Select Vipel® Resins


Gel Times for Vipel® K022-AC, CCC , CCL, CNC series
Benzoyl Peroxide Catalyst (BPO) with DMA and alternative DEA
[For laminates less than 3/16 inches (4.8 mm) thick]
Resin Temperature (°F) 60s 70s 90s
10 – 20 min. 17 18 18 18 10 15
BPO,% 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
DMA,% 0.35 0.23 0.2
DEA,% 0.8 0.5 0.3

20 – 40 min. 23 27 26 28 26 27
BPO,% 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
DMA,% 0.25 0.12 0.09
DEA,% 0.5 0.3 0.2

40 – 60 min. 49 56 44 55 42 54
BPO,% 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
DMA,% 0.1 0.1 0.05
DEA,% 0.25 0.15 0.1

Typical Formulations and Gel Times of Select Vipel® Resins


Gel Times for Vipel® F085-AAA, AAB. ABB series
Cobalt Naphthenate (6%) & DMA with CHP (90% active)

Resin Temperature (°F) 60s 70s 90s


10 – 20 min. 17 16
CHP,% 1.5 1.25
CoNAP,% No Data 0.4 0.2
DMA,% 0.2 0.02
8
20 – 40 min. 23 29 30
CHP,% 2 1.5 1
CoNAP,% 0.4 0.3 0.3
DMA,% 0.2 0.05 0.05

40 – 60 min. 46 50 43
Alternative #1 CHP,% 1 1 1
CoNAP,% 0.3 0.2 0.15
DMA,% 0.05 0 0

35
Typical Formulations and Gel Times of Select Vipel® Resins
Gel Times for Vipel® F701-BBB series
Cobalt Naphthenate (6%) & DMA with Hipoint 90 – MEKP Catalyst

Resin Temperature (°F) 60s 70s 90s


10 – 20 min. 15 16
MEKP,% No Data 1.0 1.0
CoNAP,% 0.6 0.2

20 – 40 min. 23 24 21
MEKP,% 1.0 1.5 0.75
CoNAP,% 0.6 0.2 0.2

40 – 70 min. 70 43
MEKP,% 1.0 1.0 No Data
CoNAP,% 0.2 0.2
Typical Formulations and Gel Times of Select Vipel® Resins
Gel Times for Vipel® K095-AAA-00
Cobalt Naphthenate (6%) & DMA with CHP (90% active)

Resin Temperature (°F) 60s 70s 90s


10 – 20 min. 20 16
CHP,% 1.5 1.5
CoNAP,% No Data 0.4 0.3
DMA,% 0.1 0.05

20 – 40 min. 35 30 30
CHP,% 2.0 1.5 1.0
CoNAP,% 0.4 0.3 0.2
DMA,% 0.2 0.05 0
2,4-P,% 0 0 0.05

40 – 60 min. 49 45 49
CHP,% 1.5 1.0 1.0
CoNAP,% 0.3 0.2 0.2
DMA,% 0.05 0 0.1

Legend for abbreviations


2,4-P: Pentanedione
CoNAP: Cobalt Naphthanate – 6% solution
BPO: Benzoyl Peroxide – 98% active
(Adjust addition level for other concentrations)
DEA: N,N Diethylaniline
DMA: N,N Dimethylaniline
TBC: Tertiary Butyl Catechol – 85%
THQ: Toluhydroquinone – 10% solution in styrene
(Available from AOC as “Inhibitor A”)

Trademark Notices
Aerosil® is a registered trademark of Degussa Corp. • Aropol® is a registered trademark of Ashland Inc.
BYK® is a registered trademark of BYK. • Cab-O-Sil® is a registered trademark of Cabot Corp.
Chroma-Tek® is a registered trademark of AOC, LLC. • CoREZYN® is a registered trademark of Interplastic Corp.
Derakane® is a registered trademark of Ashland Inc. • DION® is a registered trademark of Reichhold Inc.
Hetron® is a registered trademark of Ashland Inc. • Lupersox® is a registered trademark of Arkema Inc.
Mylar® is a registered trademark of DuPont Teijin Films. • Norox® is a registered trademark of Norac, Inc.
Nyacol® is a registered trademark of Nyacol Nano Technologies, Inc. • Trigonox® is a registered trademark of Akzo Nobel nv.
Underwriters Laboratories® is a registered trademark of Underwriters Laboratories Inc. • Vipel® is a registered trademark of AOC, LLC.

36
Vipel® Corrosion Resin Cross Reference
If you are considering or using resins made by another manufacturer, use this reference to find Vipel® technologies that most nearly
match competitors’ resins. This list is only a guide. Confirm your selection with an AOC Corrosion Specialist before making a final
decision because some environments may require an alternative.

AOC ASHLAND INTERPLASTIC REICHHOLD


Vipel® Derakane® Hetron® Aropol® CoREZYN® DION®
9100
Bisphenol-A Epoxy Vinyl Ester F010 411 922 8300
9102
Bis-A Epoxy VE (higher HDT) F007 441 942 8360
Elastomeric, Bis-A VE F017 8084 8550 9085
Bis-A Epoxy VE 8710
F080 441 980
(higher cross linked) 8770
Bis-A Epoxy VE
F083 441 980/35 8360
(higher cross linked, low VOC)
Fire Retardant Brominated Bis-A
Epoxy VE Class I flame spread
K022-AA
K026-AA 510A 8440
and smoke developed without the
use of synergists *
Fire Retardant Brominated Bis-A
Epoxy VE Class I flame spread K022-AC
without the use of synergists *
Fire Retardant Brominated
Bis-A Epoxy Vinyl Ester Class I
K022-CC 510C FR992 VE8450 FR9300
flame spread with the use of
synergists
Fire Retardant Brominated
Bis-A Epoxy VE containing
K022-CN FR992SB 8440M-AT
antimony products Class I flame
spread *
Fire Retardant Brominated Bis-A
Epoxy VE (higher cross linked)
K023 FR998/35
Class I flame spread without the
use of synergists *
Epoxy Novolac Vinyl Ester F085 470 970 8730 9400
Epoxy Novolac VE (higher HDT) F086 470HT
Fire Retardant Brominated Epoxy
Novolac Vinyl Ester Class I flame
K095
spread and smoke developed
without the use of synergists *
Fire Retardant Brominated Epoxy
Novolac Vinyl Ester Class II flame
510N
spread without the use of
synergists *
Isophthalic Polyester
F764
(rigid high cross-linked)
75-AQ-001, S & W
Isophthalic Polyester 7241
F701 75-AQ-010, S & W 6631
(rigid) 7242 75-AQ-011
Isophthalic Polyester (resilient) F737 7334 75-AQ-610 6334
Fire Retardant Halogenated
Isophthalic Polyester Class I flame
K733-A FR7767
spread without the use of
synergists *
Fire Retardant Halogenated
Isophthalic Polyester Class I flame 604T-20
K733-B
spread with the use antimony 99P

8
trioxide *
Terephthalic (rigid) F713
Terephthalic Polyester
F774 490
(rigid high cross-linked)
Chlorendic Acid Polyester Class I K190 197 16-DA-097 797
flame spread with the use of
antimony trioxide *
Bisphenol-A Fumarate Polyester F282 700 6694
* Tested according to ASTM E84

37
THE WORLD OF Sales Contacts
North America
+1 866 319 8827
Fax: +01 901 854 7277
northamerica@aoc-resins.com
AOC is a leading producer of unsaturated polyester and vinyl
ester resins and is the world leader in innovative resin technology. Latin America
+01 863 815 5016
AOC manufactures its products in facilities strategically located
Fax: +01 863 815 4733
throughout North America and Europe. AOC owned facilities are latinamerica@aoc-resins.com
ISO 9001:2008 certified and use AOC’s proprietary process
control technology to guarantee batch to batch consistency. Middle East
+44 1473 288997
From isophthalic polyesters, and terephthalics, to epoxy novolac Fax: +44 1473 216080
and bisphenol A vinyl esters, AOC offers local availability, middleeast@aoc-resins.com
worldwide, of a broad range of proven Vipel resins through its
Europe
network of distributors and plants. Please contact the AOC
+44 1473 288997
Corrosion Specialists for Vipel resins that meet your corrosion Fax: +44 1473 216080
resistant specifications, and put the technology and service of europe@aoc-resins.com
the AOC Corrosion Team to work for you.
India
CORROSIONRESINS.com +91 20 2547 2011
india@aoc-resins.com
The internet’s best resource on corrosion-resistant composites.
Asia/Australia
+44 1473 288997
Fax: +44 1473 216080
asia@aoc-resins.com

AOC World Headquarters


955 Highway 57 East
Collierville, TN 38017

+01 901 854 2800 +01 901 854 1183 (fax)


corrosionresins@aoc-resins.com

AOC and Vipel are registered trademarks of AOC, LLC.


Printed in U.S.A. Copyright © February, 2012 AOC.

You might also like