ResearchGate
Effect of Ferrocene as a Fuel Additive on Four Stroke Diesel Engine
Performance
105
‘eomertosonina is pape was une Sh HANHInternational
OPEN @ ACCESS Journal
ISSN: 2249-6645 OfModern Engineering Research (IJMER)
Effect of Ferrocene as a Fuel Additive on Four Stroke Diesel
Engine Performance
Mr M Sarath Chandra’, Mr Madhu $7
*(Mechantcal Engnneenng Department, CMR
College of Engineering and Technology, India
Email: medasamasarath @gmatl com)
** Mechaneal Engneenng Department, CMR College of
‘Engneerng and Technology, Juda
Email stroopakeha25@gnail.com)
ABSTRACT: Ferrocene is used as an antiknock adébtive to replace lead allyls. The Ant knocking and
soot suppressing property of Ferrocene (Fe(CH,)) catalytic ackon, lightened a method for the manual
coke clean up which increase the effective fuel combustion and life time of the combustion parts of the
engine without effecting the process but energiang the purpose. The metastable Ferrocene nucleate
enables further burnout of the carbon deposits in the combustion chamber. This paper presents the
evaluation and postive effect of adding the optimal percentage of ferrocene in the diesel. The performance
of the diesel engine 15 tested and compared vath ckfferent blends of ferrocene in the diesel. The
Experimental results show that the addition of the ferrocene optimal percentage to the fuel val enable to
increase the break thermal efficiency, decrease the specific fuel consumption of the engine and pinking
LINTRODUCTION
Engine techuologies axe increasing very fast and also the education level of the people for a
rofessonal way to operate the engine. The only parameter that cennat be influenced dieetly isthe availbibity
ofa good and economical fel. Eepecielly for modem four suoke engines wath high output, the combustaity of
the fuel is of paramount importance to achieve reliable operation of the engine. One way to improve the
combustion ofthe fuel in the engine, without altering the specification ofthe uel, is to istoduce @ chemical
additive. Fenocene has the fomnula (CsHjFe, « molecular weight of 18604, end is an orange crystalline
substance thats isolble in water but soluble i oxgeni solvents an fuel.
Ferrocene - Preparation:
Fenocene, (C.H,)sFe, was fast discovered in 1951. Until this tine organometallic compounds containing
Métel-Caabon bonds were restricted to Grignaid Reagents (R-MgB), Zrse's Salt anda few miscellaneous
others. Attempting to prepare Fubvelene via a Gngnard Reagent, TJ. Keely and PL. Peulson formed
Dicyelopentadienyiuoa, or Ferocene, instead
2 (CH) MgBr-+FeCy (CoH) + Fe-( CoH); + MgB + MgC
ig I: Image of Cyclapentadienyl zon
Fenocene and its numerous derivatives have no laige-scele applications, but have many niche uses that
exploit the unusual structure (ligand scaffolds, pharmaceutical candidates), robustness (ant-nock formulations,
precursors to materils) and redox (reagents and redox standards)
CMR ENGINEERING COLLEGE, Kandlalaya (7), Medchal Road, Ppdevabad-SO1401 BOT Page2" National Conference On Developments, Advances & Trendsin Engineering Science [NC- DATES?K16]
John J. Kracklauer [I]has observed « method of conditioning diesel engines. The diesel fuel containing
dicyelopentedienyl iron thereof for a period of time sufficient o eliminate cazbon deposits fiom the combustion
surfaces of the engine and to eliminate cazbon deposits fiom the combustion surfaces of the engine and to
deposit a layer oftton oxide on the combustion surfaces, which layer is effective to prevent futher buildup of
catbon deposits. In Effect of Fersocene on ctalysis combustion [] experimental results show that ferocene can
increase the combustion rate effectively and reduce kindling temperature by SO*C. Results (SJobtained with an
acetylene diffusion flame show that iron oxide incorporated in the soot particles acts as catalyst to promote soot
‘bumout atthe tip of the flame. As per the conclusions{4| the addition of fenocene to the laminar jet diffusion
flame acted as expected by reducing the number and mass of soot particulate, The ferocene acted as a catalyst
‘moxidizing the soot and fuel, the more fenocene aded tothe flame the more it aided in oxidation to the pomt
that vintually all hytocaibons end soot had been oxidized
4) Nucleates before andl after soot inception The catalysis combustion process canbe explained as the transition
etal ion Fe” attaches to the surface ofthe coke particles ancl the intemal surface of the tiny holes atthe coke
surface, which makes the coke active swface increasing, The transition metel ion Fe™* reacts withthe oxygen in
the ges flow and forms the metastable oxidized state. The metastable oxicized state acts asa oxygen camer,
letting the oxygen travels to the surface of the coke particle by ebsomption and digression process. The coke
particle breaks fo nano scale carbon clusters and the coke combustion process canbe extremely accelerated end
fons CO, The deoridized Fe element reacts with the oxygen in the flu and again repeats the above catalysis
process. During this reaction cyele, the tition metal ion Fe” as the fumction of oxygen transferring. ti)
Acdition of exomatic rings the remained putt of fenocene (C)H.)' let the engine to decrease the knocking
tendency. Decreasing knocking tendency order is paraffins, napthenes, ancl exomsetic hyerocerbons
‘The complete sef of reecton steps and the kinetic parameters have to be known together with ell partial
yresrmes to predict the exact behavior ofeach individual engine end combustion
Step 1: Combustion of Ferrocene and fuel oil
‘The combustion of fuel el leads to caxbon dioxide, cazbon monoxide and carbon (soot)
CH, +2 0:0 CO, COs, Catton
‘The combustion products of Fertocene are iron oxides and carbon dioxide
Fe(GH); + 00 Fe,0+ CO; ..
‘The main combustion product of Fenocene is ion oxide Fe2O3 (and slight amounts of FeO),
Step 2: Soot reduction activity of Ferrocene
Jhon oxides and soot rect to cezbon monoxide or carbon dioxide and iron
2Fe,0)+3C0 4Fe+3COy
Fe0+C0 CO+Fe
Step 3: Reactivation ofthe catalytic activity
Thon and oxygen reac to iron oxide
4Fe+30,0 2Fe,0;
and the catalytic eyele can start again. The mechanism described above indicates thatthe active compound is
Fe203 thats the base of the catalytic cycle can start again.
Ignition quality is a measure of the sbility of fuel to ignite promptly after injection. A fuel which ignites
slowly causes diesel knock. The Chemical structue desired in petroleum fuels for Cl engines is opposite to that
of desivable for spark ignition engines. The best fuels for the CI engine are highly paraffinic with average
nolecular weights greater than those of gasolines. The enfiknock quality and ignition quality are opposed to
each other. There seems to exist a simple, liar relation between the charactenstic numbers, octane number
(ON) and cetane number (CN) is given
ON=120-26N
ON=150-2.5CN
and it varies around S74. Gasoline has got antiknock qualities, but does not ignite readily. As such, gasoline is
not suitable for use in diese] engines. Sharp oscillations of jresswe are noted duing combustion With the
addition of ferrocene the calculated cetane index is getting decreased with the increase in percentage of
fenocene
‘Therefore a nunber of additives axe added to improve its combustion characters prevents engine Inocking
by increasing octane number, reacts with eazbon and sulphur residue and removes fiom the cylinder, as an
antioxidant prevents gum formation, overcomes catalytic effects of dissolved copper, prevents commosion impart
color for identification The addition of ferrocene will increase the combustion rate, decrease the knocking
tendency. It is vapoutised above 100°C and hence can be easily added into industrial installations. [tis one of
the most stable organic metal complexes at high temperatwes, which will not be decomposed til 400° C.
According to some previous report [], ferrocene and deuvatives axe very effective in catalysis of liquid and
solid fuel It is nontoxic, which is not common in most organic metal complexes. Compared to other orgenic
aetal complexes, its relatively cheaper.
CMR ENGINEERING COLLEGE, Kandlakoya (V7, Medchal Road, Fhderabad- 501401 Bil Page2" National Conference On Developments, Advances & Trendsin Engineering Science [NC- DATES?K16]
Il. MATERIALS AND METHODOLOGY
Solubility of ferrocene in diesel:
‘The samples of fermocene axe 0.15g, 0.20g, 025g, 0.30g, 0-40g, 0.50g aze mixed to 10n diese individually.
‘The mixtue is sized and left fore day. At atmospheric temaperatuze the diese dissolves tll 3% of fertocene
completely, for 4% and above the precipitate of fenocene is observed Hence the satwated dissolving
percentage of ferrocene in diesel is inbetween 3-4% only
ee — me
Fig 2: Image of Solubility of Ferrocene igh Image ofeaturaeddisering
-entage of Ferrocene in diese
‘The Gross calorific values for different blends of ferrocene were observed tobe decreasing from 1% of
fenocene blend to 3% of ferrocene blend in diesel which does not affect the engine performance
Fig 4: Tabular form of calorific values for the blends.
‘SNo._| Test Pate Diesel OF Tafemocene Wfenocene | W7efenocene
T [Density at 150] 08264 OSs Osasa OST
(lec)
T | Gross Calonifie value | T0230 TOIT TOO 9950
(Ecalllg)
J] Calculated —Cetane a0 3 7
Index
‘On dbserving thee ura slightunciease in denaily, decrease in ie gross calorific and caleulated cetene index,
Itindicates clearly thatthe blends withthe higher percentages of ferrocene are not suitble because there is @
rnuch decrease inthe calorific value that of from diesel
Experimentation
‘A.single cylinder fow stoke diesel engine (SHP, 1500 rpm) of kvloskar was run with different peroentages
of ferrocene from 0% to 3% by weight. The performance of the engine is observed. The Breek thermal
efficiency, specific fuel consumption and brake power are compared with each blend including diesel
‘The above mentioned fou stroke diese] engine is run with diesel, 1%, 2% and 3% of ferrocene blends. The
Load (EW), speed (rpm), time taken for 10ce of fuel consumption were taken atthe variation of the loads fiom
O to 10ig and the Break: Thermal Efficiency, Specific fuel consunption and break power axe calculated and
tabled, based on the formulae
O+a
2nNewe
1)B.P= KW
0
Whee edie ofbreakdrum=0 246m,
din of rope “0020
W=9 Sines
spa)
2) SFC= Me/BP
3) Break thermal efficiency= BP/heat input
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Break Power:
‘The break power ofthe diesel and 1%ferrocene blend axe competitive whereas that of and 3% ate having,
lower power because the calonific value of the fenocene blended diesel are decreasing with the increase in
femocene percentage. And Calculated Cetane Index is also decreasing indicating dectease in ignition quality. As
result 1% fenocene blend is better and suggestible for use
CMR ENGINEERING COLLEGE, Kandlalaya (7), Medchal Road, Ppdevabad-SO1401 BIT Page2" National Conference On Developments, Advances & Trendsin Engineering Science [NC- DATES?K16]
3
2 —diesel
14 —1%ferrocene
0. —2%ferrocene
0 2 4 6 8 10—3%ferrocene
Fig 5: Break Power vs Lead (X axis Load, V axis Break Power)
Specific fuel consumption:
‘The order of decreasing specific fuel consumption is cbserved tobe 2
catalytic action of ron oxide improves the effective fuel combustion. But in the case of 2 and 3% blends is
Iaving high SFC because the calonfic value of the fuel is low that of from diesel. The cetane index i also low
hich decrease the Ignition Quality of the fue.
15 5 —diesel
14
—1%ferrocene
05 ~
2%ferrocene
0+
— 3%ferrocene
0 2 4 6 8 10
Fig 6: SEC vs Load ( axis- Load, Vaxis- SFO)
Break Thermal Efficiency :
‘The Break themual efficiency of 1Ysferrocene blend got the highest value near to 30% followed by 2% 3%
Dlenls and diesel. And the input power follows the reverse order,
————
—diesel
20 5 1%ferrocene
04 —2%ferrocene
0 2 4 6 8 10 —3%ferrocene
Fig 7: Break Thermal Efficiency vs Lead (X axis- BTE, V axis- Break Power)
IV.CONCLUSION
‘The experimental results and discussions shows that there is a positive effect of adding the optimal
percentage of ferrocene inthe diesel. For 1% ferrocene blended diesel has more thermal efficiency (29.77%) and
the specific fuel consumption is lower compared to other is 0.283 Kg/KCW-lx. Therefore the optimal percentage
is between 1% to 2% that is 1Oppm to 20ppm of ferrocene inthe fuel. Not only it umproves the effective fuel
combustion but also decreases the knocking tendency due to the presence of aromatic molecules. The knocking
tendency decreases with the increase in the ferrocene percentage. The Break Thermal efficiency improves and
the specific fuel consumption decrease
CMR ENGINEERING COLLEGE, Kandlalaya (7), Medchal Road, Ppdevabad-SO1401 BT Page2" National Conference On Developments, Advances & Trendsin Engineering Science [NC- DATES?K16]
REFERENCES:
Journalpapers:
1] A Patent on Method of Conditioning diesel engine: US 4880220 A-by Jobat Kracklaner
D2} dian Jounal of Heat and Mass Trevufer:Efet af Ferocene on Catalysis Combuston'oy Min Xo, Ying Zou &
Hsing
[) The afect of Foracene addition on partile formation and buenout in combustion process by M Kasper, Sate,
KSiegmam ad Uimated
[A] Berg Counal: A Comparision ofenlne backpass cleaning teclnologies: Detonation Acoustic aud Comentonal
‘Sieamor Air Sootblovngby A, Tofa Me Conmiek.
[5] Antes on The soot and sale Probleme by Dz Albrencht Kanpp
[6] Review on catale scavenging eféct ful conination, by Madiu S. PG Scholar
Books
(7) ermal combustion engines by KK Ramalingaan
CMR ENGINEERING COLLEGE, Kandlalaya (7), Medchal Road, Ppdevabad-SO1401 Sa Page