12/20/2019 The Basic Laws Pertaining to Cemeteries | Stimmel Law

(/)

Home (/en) /  Articles (/en/articles) /  Basic laws pertaining cemeteries

The Basic Laws Pertaining to Cemeteries

Americans have a hard time dealing with dying and death and often only deal with estate planning, elder care planning and selection of funeral
arrangements when they have no choice, e.g. when death is imminent or already has occurred. The result can be both frustrating and expensive as people
are required to make signi cant economic decisions when emotionally distraught and those decisions can result in tension within the family and long term
economic commitments.

Too often this writer has seen families with few resources end up spending tens of thousands of dollars for funeral or cemetery arrangements when the
deceased would have protested loudly at the “waste” and no one really determined what alternatives were available. No one in the family wants to be the
one to object to the cost with the rest of the family looking on and the professionals in the eld, many of whom are well meaning, are certainly not going to
suggest less expensive alternatives.

Selecting cemeteries, indeed, knowing how they work and are regulated, is another area few people wish to confront, but the wise family will understand
both the commitment and the legal protections inherent in utilizing the services of a cemetery.

It is not only expense. Occasionally, scandalous information comes out as to failure to bury the right person in the right plot or, even worse, selling the
same plot over and over, the bodies literally piled upon each other. Is that merely breach of contract? Is it a violation of the law? This article discusses
those issues and more.

De nitions:

A cemetery is a place where dead bodies and cremated remains are buried. It is a locale set aside, either by governmental authority or private enterprise.
A public cemetery is open for use by the community at large while a private cemetery is used only by a small segment of a community or by a family.

Cemeteries can be the place where the nal ceremonies of death are observed. These ceremonies or rites di er according to cultural practice and
religious belief. The establishment of a cemetery involves the process of formally designating a tract of land for use for the burial of the dead. It must be
set apart, marked, and distinguished from adjoining ground as a graveyard.

A cemetery is not only subject to the laws of ordinary property due to their inherently di erent nature. Most states have established rigorous laws that
speci cally apply to cemeteries. Private interests in the place of burial are subject to the control of public authorities, which have the right to require the
disinterment of bodies if deemed necessary.

A columbarium is a building containing niches in which urns containing the ashes of the deceased after cremation are placed.

The law contemplates generally two categories of cemeteries, public and private. A public cemetery is one used by the general community, a
neighborhood, or a church, while a private cemetery is one used only by a family or a small portion of the community. However, actual public use rather
than ownership determines whether a cemetery is public. Thus, a cemetery, though privately owned or maintained, may be deemed a public cemetery if it
is open, under reasonable regulations, to the use of the public for the burial of the dead. A cemetery, though privately owned, is properly classi ed as a
“public cemetery” where it consists of a great number of burial plots or sites sold and for sale to the public. Conversely, a family burying ground has been
de ned by statute as one in which no lots are sold to the public and in which interments are restricted to a group of persons related to each other by
blood or marriage.

Note that a municipal corporation may hold property in trust for a public burial ground or in a private or proprietary character as a private corporation.
The Federal government provides burial locales for military and other selected federal personnel.

In Garland v. Clark, 264 Ala. 402, 405-406 (Ala. 1956), the court held that for a place to be called a public cemetery, “…the intention of the owner of the land
to dedicate it for a public cemetery, together with the acceptance and use of the same by the public, or the consent and acquiescence of the owner in the
long-continued use of his lands for such purpose, are su cient.”

Statutory Regulations:

Cemeteries are normally regulated on the State level.

https://www.stimmel-law.com/en/articles/basic-laws-pertaining-cemeteries 1/5
12/20/2019 The Basic Laws Pertaining to Cemeteries | Stimmel Law
There are normally statutory provisions which apply to privately operated cemeteries. For instance, Section 5 of the Act of 1903, Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 21, para.
39 (1951), provides that when a cemetery is a privately operated cemetery, as de ned in § 2 of the Cemetery Care Act, Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 21, para. 64.1 et
seq. (1951), enacted by the Sixty- fth General Assembly, then such a cemetery association shall also comply with the provisions of the Cemetery Care Act.
See Union Cemetery Ass’n v. Cooper, 414 Ill. 23 (Ill. 1953).

The Cemetery Care Act enacted in that state provides that these cemeteries are required to secure a license from the Auditor of Public Accounts before
acquiring care funds. In order to secure such a license, detailed information as to personnel and nances must be given and the license may be refused if
certain speci ed conditions are not met. A privately operated and licensed cemetery must le an annual report with respect to its care funds. This report
must show the income to and disbursements from the fund and list the securities in which the fund is invested. The books of such cemeteries must be
open at all times to inspection. In the administration of care funds, privately operated cemeteries are subject to examination, supervision, and regulation
by the Auditor who may, upon certain conditions, revoke the license to handle care funds either temporarily or permanently. Before accepting care funds
in connection with the sale of a burial space, a private authority must specify in writing the nature and extent of the care to be furnished, for which it must
require the deposit of a given amount based upon the sale price or the size of the burial space. Except where excused by the act, these private
associations are required to post a bond to insure the proper handling of care funds. Other states have similar laws.

A state may regulate the location of cemeteries through the exercise of its police power by statute directly regulating the location of cemeteries. In
California, see Laurel Hill Cemetery v. San Francisco, 216 U.S. 358 (U.S. 1910). Such police power may be delegated to and exercised by political subdivisions
or subordinate public corporations of the state, including municipal corporations or health authorities. See Seale v. Masonic Cemetery Asso., 217 Cal. 286
(Cal. 1933).

With respect to governmental regulation of the location of cemeteries, aesthetic, health and property value considerations are of importance. Put simply
having a cemetery next door can radically reduce the value of property since many buyers do not want to live next to cemetery. Often, the right to prohibit
or limit the location of cemeteries within a certain district or area rests on the proposition that a burial within such district would be injurious to the public
health. Some additional reasons for exercising the police power regarding the regulation of cemetery locations are:

the public welfare in general.

whether the establishment of a cemetery might disarrange the location of streets and highways and adversely a ect civic enterprise.
the prosperity of the community.
the adequacy of existing cemetery facilities within a county.
the character of the community in general. See Laurel Hill Cemetery v. San Francisco, 152 Cal. 464 (Cal. 1907); Alosi v. Jones, 234 Ala. 391 (Ala. 1937); Scovill
v. McMahon, 62 Conn. 378 (Conn. 1892); Gordon v. Commissioners of Montgomery County, 164 Md. 210 (Md. 1933).

The right to prohibit or limit the location of cemeteries within a certain district or area often is claimed to rest on the proposition that a burial within such a
district would be injurious to the public health. The regulations prohibiting the creation of new cemeteries or the interment of human bodies in
established cemeteries located within a densely populated city area are generally valid, if they do not operate unreasonably or arbitrarily. However, similar
regulations in sparsely settled localities have been held or recognized to be invalid, where it was not shown that the burials were calculated to impair the
public health through their close proximity to housing. The permission to establish a cemetery cannot be made dependent on the arbitrary will of the
o cers or governing body of that particular place. The principles upon which a decision is to be made must be clearly established.

Regulations as to the location of cemeteries are valid if they do not constitute an impairment of the obligation of contract, do not constitute a violation of
the constitutional guaranties of due process or equal protection of the laws, or against the taking of private property for public use without just
compensation, or constitute improper delegation of authority.

Abandonment of Cemetery: Legal E ect

A property which has been dedicated or used for cemetery purposes may be abandoned so far as such purposes are concerned, apart from any rights of
interested parties to have a cemetery continued as such. See Mayes v. Simons, 189 Ga. 845 (Ga. 1940). The question of abandonment can be inferred from the
acts or recitals of the parties, interpreted in the light of all the surrounding circumstances. However, a cemetery is not abandoned as long as it is kept and
preserved as a resting place for the dead with anything to indicate the existence of graves, or as long as it is known and recognized by the public as a
graveyard. The fact that for some years no new interments have been made and that the graves have been neglected does not operate as an
abandonment and authorize the desecration of the graves, where the bodies interred in a cemetery remain therein and the spot awakens sacred
memories in living persons. See Danger eld v. Williams, 26 App. D.C. 508 (D.C. Cir. 1906).

Matters going to the question of abandonment are:

the actual condition of the cemetery,

whether the identity of the cemetery has in fact been destroyed, and
whether the cemetery is recognizable and known to the general public.

Where the family has ceased to visit the cemetery and they have so long neglected to care for it that the ground is no longer recognizable as a cemetery,
the family burial ground has been abandoned. Merely because further interments in a cemetery become impossible, it does not lose its character.

However, a private cemetery may be considered abandoned, where through changed conditions or the passage and ravages of time, its identity is
destroyed. Tracy v. Bittle, 213 Mo. 302 (Mo. 1908)

This issue can become critical for developers who wish to use the land for new purposes and confront the question as to whether they have the right to
alter its use despite its past status.

https://www.stimmel-law.com/en/articles/basic-laws-pertaining-cemeteries 2/5
12/20/2019 The Basic Laws Pertaining to Cemeteries | Stimmel Law

There is a presumption in favor of leaving the cemetery undisturbed on an application for cemetery relocation. The governing authority must balance the
applicants’ interest in disinterment with the public’s and the descendants’ interest in the value of the undisturbed cultural and natural environment. See
Hughes v. Cobb County, 264 Ga. 128 (Ga. 1994).

By the claim of a burial lot owner that he/she has a freehold interest in the lot, a cemetery owner will not necessarily be prevented from abandoning its
cemetery and from removing the remains of deceased persons buried therein. Petition of First Trinity Evangelical Luthern Church, 214 Pa. Super. 185 (Pa.
Super. Ct. 1969). To preserve the cultural heritage of the county and the cemetery, evidence of a lack of maintenance and inappropriate surroundings will
support the relocation of a cemetery site.

The right to occupy land with a cemetery and maintained as such is subject to the reasonable exercise of the police power. However, where land becomes
no longer suitable for the cemetery use to which it was dedicated because of the surrounding circumstances or changed conditions, the discontinuance of
such use may be required by the legislature or a municipality. As a good example, in large cities it becomes necessary to prohibit further interments in
certain cemeteries on account of their menace to the public health and also to require the removal of the bodies interred therein. In the abolishment of
cemeteries, the legislature has the same power as it has in their establishment. Whenever it becomes necessary, the legislature may by statute direct the
discontinuance of a cemetery and the removal of the bodies. It may delegate its power to a municipality, which may enact an ordinance to e ect the same
result. See Masonic Cemetery Ass’n v. Gamage, 38 F.2d 950 (9th Cir. Cal. 1930).

In this regard, the police power must not be exercised arbitrarily or unreasonably. Where there is a public necessity for the discontinuance, the power to
require the discontinuance of the use of a cemetery, necessarily includes the power to determine whether such public necessity exists. The determination
of the legislature is conclusive upon the courts.

When the use is terminated and the cemetery abandoned, there is a reverter to the original donors or their legal representatives, free of such use. This
rule applies to both statutory and common-law dedications. Reinterments in land that have once been de nitely abandoned as a cemetery do not have
the e ect of preventing a reverter. However, a di erent situation exists where there is an actual conveyance of lands. In such situations, whether the land
reverts to the grantor on the abandonment of the cemetery depends on whether the conveyance was absolute. If so, there is no right of reverter or it
constituted a conveyance on condition that the use of the premises for a cemetery be continued. Thereafter, the grantor or one succeeding to his/her
rights is revested with title on a breach of the condition.

All this necessarily means that the average family confronting the issue of the permanence of their loved one remaining in the plot face the question of
what rights they really have.

Rights to Lots and Vaults

A cemetery lot owner’s rights are contractual and subject to the ordinary rules of contract law. In nearly all jurisdictions, one who purchases and has
conveyed to him/her a lot in a public cemetery does not acquire the fee to the soil. He/she acquires only a right of burial therein which has been variously
designated as an easement or as a license or privilege. Ebenezer Baptist Church, Inc. v. White, 513 So. 2d 1011 (Ala. 1987).

Put simply, this means you do not own the land or have ownership rights of any type to any particular land. Instead, you have an easement or license to
use the land for the purpose of keeping your loved one’s remains there.

It often can only be extinguished by abandonment. When a lot is purchased, the rights of the purchaser are expressed or deemed to be subject to the
charter and the rules and regulations or bylaws of a cemetery association or corporation company. However, the rules and regulations adopted by the
cemetery proprietor must be uniform and reasonable. If regulations are unreasonable, a person’s agreement to be bound by the rules and regulations is
ine ectual. See Hollywood Cemetery Asso. v. Powell, 210 Cal. 121 (Cal. 1930).

To confer an exclusive right to use a cemetery lot, a formal deed is not necessary. Provided the prescriptive holders use the cemetery lot exclusively,
continuously, and uninterruptedly, with the actual or presumptive knowledge of the owner, an easement can even be acquired by adverse possession. A
cemetery lot may be held by two or more persons in common. Provided there is burial space still available, co-tenants of a burial lot hold it with the right
to be buried therein in the order in which they die. The consent of the other co-owners to the burial of their co-tenant therein is not necessary.

Although it is recognized that a stranger to the tenancy may not, as a matter of right, be buried in a lot without the consent of all the co-tenants, where an
interment has been made, the courts are reluctant to order the removal of the body. Usually, a burial lot cannot be made subject to partition after bodies
have been interred therein as a public policy rule. Locke v. Locke, 291 Ala. 344 (Ala. 1973)

In some jurisdictions, after an interment is made in a burial lot held by an individual owner, the lot becomes inalienable, except by speci c devise, or as
provided by statute. Moreover, the rules of the company may provide against alienation or subdivision, or there may be an express provision in a
conveyance of a cemetery lot to the e ect that it may not be transferred except with the consent of the cemetery company. However, an owner may
alienate or transfer his/her rights in a cemetery lot prior to any interment therein, in the absence of any regulations, statutes, or other restrictions to the
contrary. In the absence of an assignment of sites by the purchaser of a family cemetery plot before death, the lineal descendants of the deceased
purchaser have an easement in the unused sites in ground dedicated to family burials. Fraser v. Tenney, 987 S.W.2d 796 (Ky. Ct. App. 1998)

Since the right of the owner of a burial lot has been designated as an easement or license, in the absence of statutory restrictions or contractual conditions
to the contrary, the right is one which is devisable and inheritable. The right to devise a burial lot may be limited by statutory provisions restricting the
right of alienation and providing for the descent of the lot, upon the death of the proprietor, to his/her heirs at law. A burial lot not speci cally devised
does not pass under a general or residuary devise, absent a statute. It passes to the heirs at law of the testator as if the testator had died intestate. If the
result would be the disruption of the character of the lot as a family burial plot, the lot can be deemed not to pass by will. Robertson v. Mt. Olivet Cemetery
Co., 116 Tenn. 221 (Tenn. 1906).

https://www.stimmel-law.com/en/articles/basic-laws-pertaining-cemeteries 3/5
12/20/2019 The Basic Laws Pertaining to Cemeteries | Stimmel Law
Where a lot is not devised, the heir takes such property right impressed with and subject to the use to which the ancestor devoted it in his/her lifetime,
although the title descends to the heirs at law, each of whom takes an undivided interest and the right of sepulture therein. Thus, the heir takes subject to
a trust for the bene t of the family.

A burial lot in which bodies have been interred cannot be subject to a mortgage. Moreover, an equitable lien will not be established against such a lot for
the cost of materials used in improving it. In some jurisdictions, burial lots are exempt from execution or attachment by statute. United Cemeteries Co. v.
Strother, 332 Mo. 971 (Mo. 1933)

Conclusion and Practicalities

Pouring through a contract relating to rights or reading the By Laws of the Cemetery Association are usually not what a grieving family wishes to do. But it
is vital to note that one is not “buying land” with inalienable rights when one obtains a lot or vault. The contract and the bylaws do delineate the rights and
the ability of the cemetery to be altered, to close, or to move one’s loved one.

This is not inherently unreasonable. Society changes, land use changes, families move away, needs change. Virtually every major city had many cemeteries
on their outskirts that are now, due to the growth of cities, downtown, and with few exceptions, the land is needed for development and the cemeteries
end up being moved.

As the population grows and land becomes increasingly scarce near cities, one can expect this process to repeat and it is unlikely in the extreme that the
cemetery plot you select today will be in existence in two hundred years.

This is di cult for most people and families to confront. We all like to think that the cemetery is forever, that in a thousand years our relatives can still visit
the plot, that the deceased will sleep here forever.

In practical terms, it means read the cemetery documents…all of them…and that includes understanding what rights they have to relocate, close the
cemetery, etc. Find out precisely what you are buying before you buy it and if you are too upset at the time to do that, nd a friend or professional to do it
for you.

Many of our clients elect burial of ashes at sea precisely to avoid this entire issue. When asked how they will visit the grave, one client stated, “Every time I
look at the sunset and watch the waves, I am visiting the grave. That’s what Dad would have loved in any event.”

Article Categories
Wills and Trusts (/en/articles/category/wills-and-trusts)
Family Care (/en/articles/category/wills-and-trusts/family-care)
Trusts and Estate Administration (/en/articles/category/trusts-and-estate-administration)
Duties and Law Regarding Trustees and Executors (/en/articles/category/trusts-and-estate-administration/duties-and-law-regarding-trustees-and-
executors)
Real Property Litigation (/en/articles/category/real-property-litigation)
Property Rights Disputes (/en/articles/category/real-property-litigation/property-rights-disputes)
Consumer Rights and Remedies (/en/articles/category/consumer-rights-and-remedies)
Business, Purchase and Credit Problems (/en/articles/category/consumer-rights-and-remedies/business-purchase-and-credit-problems)

Share this article!

(/#email) (/#google_gmail) (/#yahoo_mail) (/#copy_link)

(https://www.addtoany.com/share#url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.stimme
law.com%2Fen%2Farticles%2Fbasic-laws-pertaining-
cemeteries&title=The%20Basic%20Laws%20Pertaining%20to%20Cemeter

Related Articles
Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care in California - The Law and The Form (/en/articles/durable-power-attorney-health-care-california-law-and-form)

Duties of an Executor in California - You've Been Nominated...Now What? (/en/articles/duties-executor-california-youve-been-nominatednow-what)

Intestate Succession in California or What Happens If You Die Without a Will or Trust (/en/articles/intestate-succession-california-or-what-happens-if-you-die-
without-will-or-trust)

Probate in California - The Basics (/en/articles/probate-california-basics)

Rights and Obligations As To Human Remains and Burial (/en/articles/rights-and-obligations-human-remains-and-burial)

https://www.stimmel-law.com/en/articles/basic-laws-pertaining-cemeteries 4/5
12/20/2019 The Basic Laws Pertaining to Cemeteries | Stimmel Law

(/articles)

Find Articles in our Online Library (/articles)

Find helpful legal articles & summaries on key areas of the law!

Stimmel, Stimmel & Roeser

Home (/en) Cookie Policy (/en/cookies)

Our Firm (/en/about-us) Privacy Policy (/en/privacy)
Firm Overview (/en/about-us) Terms of Use (/en/terms-use)
Attorneys (/en/attorneys) Contact (/en/contact)
Typical Cases (/en/typical-cases)
Videos (/en/videos)
Community (/en/our-community)
Articles (/en/articles)

Founded in 1939, our law rm combines the ability to represent clients in domestic or international matters with the personal interaction with clients that is
traditional to a long established law rm.

Read more about our rm (/about-us)

© 2019, Stimmel, Stimmel & Roeser, All rights reserved  | Terms of Use (/terms-use) | Site by Bay Design (http://www.baydesignassociates.com)

https://www.stimmel-law.com/en/articles/basic-laws-pertaining-cemeteries 5/5