Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2015 Eduction of Formaldehyde Emission From Particleboard by Phenolated Kraft Lignin
2015 Eduction of Formaldehyde Emission From Particleboard by Phenolated Kraft Lignin
2015 Eduction of Formaldehyde Emission From Particleboard by Phenolated Kraft Lignin
net/publication/277942391
CITATIONS READS
23 188
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
characterization of algerians oak wood by x-ray tomographic scanner and free software image-j View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Hamed Younesi-Kordkheili on 22 January 2016.
To cite this article: Hamed Younesi-Kordkheili, Antonio Pizzi & Ghorban Niyatzade (2015): Reduction of Formaldehyde
Emission from Particleboard by Phenolated Kraft Lignin, The Journal of Adhesion, DOI: 10.1080/00218464.2015.1046596
Disclaimer: This is a version of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service
to authors and researchers we are providing this version of the accepted manuscript (AM). Copyediting,
typesetting, and review of the resulting proof will be undertaken on this manuscript before final publication of
the Version of Record (VoR). During production and pre-press, errors may be discovered which could affect the
content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal relate to this version also.
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the “Content”) contained
in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no
representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the
Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and
are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and
should be independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for
any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever
or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of
the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any
form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://
www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
Reduction of Formaldehyde Emission from Particleboard by Phenolated Kraft
Lignin
Abstract
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
The aim of this study was the reduction of formaldehyde emission from particleboard by
phenolated Kraft Lignin. For this purpose, the lignin was extracted from black liquor and
unmodified and phenolated Kraft lignins (10, 15 and 20%) were added at pH=7 instead of
the second urea. Physicochemical properties and structural changes of resins so prepared,
as well as the internal bond (IB) strength and formaldehyde emission associated with the
panels bonded with them were measured according to standard methods. The Fourier
transform infrared (FTIR) analysis of lignin indicated that the content of O-H bonds
increased in phenolated lignin while the aliphatic ethers C-O bonds decreased markedly
in the modified lignin. Since both synthesis of UF resins and lignin phenolation are
carried out under acid conditions, phenolation is an interesting way of modifying lignin
for use in wood adhesive. The panels bonded with these resins showed significantly
1
unmodified UF resin. XRD analysis results indicated that addition of phenolated lignin
1. INTRODUCTION
About 90% or more of the world’s board production is bonded with urea formaldehyde
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
(UF) resins [1]. UF resins have many advantages such as low cost, ease of use under a
wide variety of curing conditions, the fastest reaction time in the hot press, water
properties and they are colorless [1,2]. However, the main defect of wood based panels
even in small amounts it can cause serious health problems. The formaldehyde emission
from wood-based panels depend on numerous factors such as wood species, type of
treatment and the age of the material [4]. Thus, the reduction of formaldehyde emission
from wood based panels has been pursued by researchers in the adhesive and wood-based
materials industries for many years [5–7]. So far several ways has been reported for
reducing formaldehyde emission from wood-based materials bonded with UF resins such
parameters (wood species, layers of the panel, moisture, pressing conditions), application
2
systems and storage of the wood-based materials [8,9]. However one of the best reported
methods for reduction formaldehyde emission from wood based panels is the addition of
(such as phenol and resorcinol) are an important group of UF resins scavengers [11].
Conversely, Lignin is one of the major components of lignocellulosic materials which are
a complex heterogeneous phenolic polymer presenting structure. The lignin molecule can
be used in composites, fuels and chemicals production [13–15]. This fact in combination
with the actual environmental pressure on synthetic resins might be the chance for a more
work, for the first time, lignin has been used for the reduction of formaldehyde emission
Although the sources of lignin are different such as wood or bark, the pulp and paper
industry is the main source of lignin. More than 50 million tons lignin is produced
annually in the pulp and paper industry [16]. Since technical lignins (Soda, Kraft, Sulfite
and organosolve) originate from different sources and separation processes, they are
different from each other to a significant extent. Previous study indicated that alkali
lignins (soda and Kraft) among the various resources of lignins yielded better results than
synthetic wood adhesives [17]. Because Kraft lignin is the one produced in larger
3
amounts in the world, this type of lignin has been selected as a UF resins scavenger in
this work.
The main obstacle to using lignins in synthetic resins is related to their sites being less
reactive than those of phenol and resorcinol [18]. Some efforts have been made to
improve the reactivity of lignin molecules [19,20]. Phenolation (adding –phenolic groups
to lignin by reaction with phenol in the presence of catalyst) was reported as one of the
most interesting modification methods of lignin for use in wood adhesive [18].
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
influencing resin properties differently when incorporated into them. Our previous study
emission of plywood panels bonded with a UF resin [21]. There are some works that have
reported the properties of using phenolated lignin with phenol formaldehyde resin (PF)
resins [22,23]. However, there is no information about the effect of phenolated Kraft
lignin on formaldehyde emission of the panels made with UF resins. The aim of this
2.1. Lignin
Kraft black liquor with pH=12 and 90% solid content as source of lignin was prepared by
Choka Company (Talesh, Iran). Black liquor was acidified to pH=7 by 1mol/L
4
hydrochloric acid (HCL) in order to achieve a pH of the lignin comparable with UF
resins.
A flask provided with thermocouple, mechanical stirrer and condenser was charged with
100 gr melted phenol. 20 g of Kraft lignin (with 50% solid content) was added slowly to
flask. Oxalic acid as a catalyst was added to mixture. The reaction mixture was heated up
to the reaction temperature (130 ◦C) in an oil bath at a reaction time of 50 min. Then the
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
mixture was refluxed at temperature for 1h. Finally, the samples were collected
throughout the phenolation reaction and was acidified to pH=7 by 1mol/L HCL.
spectrometry (FTIR). The unmodified and phenolated lignins were oven-dried and then
reduced to powder by milling before testing by FTIR. FTIR spectra were obtained from
potassium bromide (KBr) pellets with 1 % of the powdered lignins at wave numbers
(PLUF)
After tests of several versions the following method was selected for the preparation of
5
A 500 ml flat bottom flask equipped with a condenser, thermometer and a magnetic
stirrer bar was charged with formalin (37% formaldehyde solution). The pH was adjusted
to the range of 7.5 - 8.5 by adding a few drops of sodium hydroxide (45% concentration).
Then the first urea was added to the solution. After stirring for 30 minutes at 40 ◦C, the
temperature was slowly increased to 90◦C under reflux over a period of 30 minutes; this
temperature was kept constant for 60 minutes. The condensation reaction was started by
adding few drops of formic acid and reducing the pH to 5.0–5.5. After reaching the
intended viscosity the solution was neutralized by sodium hydroxide (40%). Then various
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
portions (10, 15, and 20 mass based on total weight of urea) of unmodified lignin or of
phenolated lignin (instead of a usual addition of second urea when preparing UF resins)
was added to the mixture. The temperature was again increased to 90◦C and the mixture
was refluxed for 90 minutes. Distillation of the mixture was performed using a laboratory
vacuum pump and equipment at 60◦C for one hour. Finally, urea was added at 40◦C.
In this research the pH value of the various resins prepared was adjusted to the same
value (7.5– 8.0). Also the solid content of prepared resins was adjusted to 53% .The
molar ratio of formaldehyde to urea was 1.3 and three resins depending on lignin type
(modified or unmodified) and replacement rate (10, 15, and 20%) were prepared for each
condition.
2.3. UF Resin
6
A commercial UF resin was prepared from Northern Pars Company, Amol, Iran. The
different properties of the resin prepared are reported in Table 1. The formaldehyde to
The solid content of the adhesives was determined according to ASTM D 4426–93. The
density of the liquid resin was obtained by density hydrometer. The viscosity of the resins
was measured at 25◦C using a Ford Cup. pH values were measured with a Hanna pH
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
meter (Romany). In order to determine the gel time, 5 grams of the resin were introduced
into a dry glass beaker. Then 0.5 grams of a 20% aqueous NH4CL solution was added to
the resin. The beaker was then immersed into boiling water and the time until hardening
was measured. Two replicates for each sample were made. The content of free
formaldehyde of the resins was measured by the sulfite method immediately after resin
preparation [24].
A forming mold frame (35×35×1cm) was placed on a stainless steel caul plate to control
thickness. Surfaces of each plate were sprayed with a mineral oil releasing agent to
render adhesion with the surface of the composite. Dried particles were then blended with
prepared resins in a rotating drum-type mixer fitted with a pneumatic spray gun. Then
compounded material was poured into the frame and spread to fill the frame evenly.
When forming was complete, the top caul plate was placed on the top of the mat, and the
entire assembly was placed into an oil-heated press that was used for compression
7
molding. The temperature of the press plates was maintained at 180 ºC at 25 bar pressure.
Pressing the compound material was carried out respectively in two stages by hot and
cold presses for 5 min. A 5cm wide edge of each board was trimmed to remove the low
density and poor bonding areas of boards. To provide reproducibility, three panels were
manufactured for each formulation. The nominal thickness and density of manufactured
panels was 16 mm and 0.8 g/cm3, respectively. Preparation of the samples for internal
bond and water absorption measurement was started 24 hours after pressing.
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
internal bond strength of the manufactured panels were measured according to ASTM D
humidity of 60%±5% for two weeks. Five specimens were tested for each resin.
The subsequent formaldehyde emission from the particleboard panels was done using the
flask method according EN 717-3. The Free formaldehyde values were measured after 48
UF resin containing 20% phenolated lignin was selected for further analysis by XRD.
Wide angle X-ray analysis (XRD) was carried out in order to investigate any change in
the crystalline structure of the synthesized resins. XRD samples of UF, LUF and PLUF
resins were hardened by addition of ammonium chloride at 100 °C in an oven and then
8
were powdered by milling and mounted on a Philips XRD powder diffractometer for
analysis. XRD patterns were taken with a Philips X pert MPD diffractometer (Eindhoven,
Powder samples were scanned over a range of diffraction angle 2θ= 10-60°, with a scan
The infrared spectra obtained from unmodified and phenolated Kraft lignin are reported
comparison between the IR spectra of unmodified and phenolated Kraft lignin indicates
that few main peaks varied or appeared when lignin had been modified. In the phenolated
lignin, the intensity of the peak at 3420cm-1 band, which is related to O-H stretching,
clearly increases. This is because of the phenolic hydroxyl groups of lignin could be
increase significantly by phenolation. Compared to unmodified lignin, the 1330 cm-1 band
related to the C-O bond in aliphatic ethers decreased markedly in the modified resin.
Cleavage of ether bonds decreases the average molecular weight of lignin [18]. The FTIR
results indicated that, in general, the amount of ethylene bridges in the cross-linked
network structures of the cured PLUF resin was markedly lower than for the UF resin.
Moreover, a new peak at 880 cm-1 band was detected for phenolated lignin when
compared to the UF resin spectrum. This band probably is due to the reaction between the
ortho and para sites of phenol and the hydroxyl groups in the side chain of lignin.
9
3.2. Properties of the Synthesized Resins
The physicochemical properties of the various synthesized resins are reported in Table 2.
The incorporation of Kraft lignin (both unmodified and phenolated lignins) into the UF
resin increased the gel time. The UF resin containing 20% unmodified lignin exhibited
the longest gel time (85s) among all synthesized resins. Increase in gel time of the resins
containing lignin probably can be attributed to lower free formaldehyde. So far several
researchers have indicated that compared to synthetic polymers, lignins have a longer gel
time [25]. Thus, the long gel time of lignin can influence the gel time of the synthesized
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
resins. Increase in gel and press times of resins by addition of lignin has been reported by
several researchers [22, 25, 26]. This results in a decrease in the rate of crosslink
formation, leading to longer gel times. Table 2 also indicated that the viscosity of the
lignin up to 20%. Regarding the solid content of the resins, at constant values, the
The density of the resin decreases by incorporating lignin into a UF resin. The highest
and the lowest density value among synthesized resins respectively can be observed in
the UF resin (1.238) and the LUF resin with 20% lignin (1.215). From Table 2 it can be
seen that the UF resin with 20% phenolated lignin exhibited the lowest content of free
formaldehyde. The free formaldehyde content of the UF resin was 0.4%. Reduction in
free formaldehyde in the PLUF resin can be related to the lignin component which works
as a formaldehyde scavenger in the resin. Our previous study indicated that lignin can
10
Table 2 also indicates that the PLUF resin exhibits faster gel time, lower free
formaldehyde and higher SPG and viscosity values compared to a LUF resins at constant
solid content. This is because of more reactive groups (phenolic –OH) incorporated into
lignin after phenolation. The higher reactivity of lignin modified by phenolation when
Finally it can be concluded that several chemical reactions probably occur in the
synthesized PLUF resin: I) The reaction of UF–CH2OH with the hydroxyl groups of
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
lignin; II) The reaction of the -OH group of prephenolated lignin with the –NH2 and –
NH- groups of the UF; III) The reaction of free formaldehyde with both the UF resin and
the lignin.
The internal bond strength of the panels made from the synthesized resins is presented in
Fig. 2. This Figure indicates that the panels bonded with the modified UF resin exhibit
weaker internal bond strength than those bonded with UF resin. It can also be seen that
the samples prepared from phenolated lignin (PLUF) exhibited higher internal bond
strength value than those made from unmodified lignin (LUF). Among the modified UF
resins, the PLUF resin containing 10 % phenolated lignin exhibited the highest internal
bond strength (1.88MPa) and the LUF resin containing 20% of unmodified lignin
exhibited the weakest internal bond strength (1.21 MPa). This is supported by the
2). Adhesive penetration plays an important role in wood adhesion, since wood is a
11
porous material. The degree of penetration mostly depends on wood factors, resin type,
physicochemical properties of the resin and the processing parameters [27]. The wood
species and the processing parameters used were identical for all panels, hence the
differences in the panels made from LUF and PLUF resins can be attributed to
differences in resin properties. Several researchers indicated that the viscosity and the
resins molecular size are important factors influencing mechanical strength of wood
based panels [28]. Compared to LUF resins, PLUF resins have higher viscosity and
density which prevented too much penetration of the resin into the wood surface. Fig. 2
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
also indicates that there are no significant differences between the internal bond strength
results of the panels prepared with PLUF resins containing 10% phenolated lignin and
unmodified UF resins. Previous researches have shown that particleboards prepared from
physical and mechanical properties than those made from commercial PF resins [22].
Formaldehyde emission differs greatly among the cured resins. It can be observed that if
lignin is incorporated into the UF resin, the formaldehyde emission from the panels
decreases independently if the lignin component as such is modified or not (Fig. 3).
emission from the panels. Theoretically, releasable formaldehyde can exist in several
12
wood. However, a common theory on feasible causes of formaldehyde emission from
particleboard is that the cured UF resin gradually undergoes hydrolytic degradation [29].
Lower formaldehyde emission from the panels made from UF resin modified with lignin
more stable than pure UF methylene bridges against hydrolysis. The physicochemical
properties of the synthesized resins indicated also that the free formaldehyde content of
the resins modified with lignin is lower than for the control resin (UF resin). For these
reasons, the lignin based resins yield lower formaldehyde emissions compared to UF
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
resins.
The results also indicate that the panels made from PLUF resins exhibited lower
formaldehyde emission than those made from LUF and UF resins, respectively. This is
because of the presence of more reactive sites in phenolated lignin which can react with
X-ray diffractograms of cured UF and PLUF resins are illustrated in Fig. 4. As shown,
the UF resin has a single sharp peak at a 2θ angle of about 21˚. Compared to the UF resin,
the PLUF resin exhibited a weaker peak at 19˚. In addition, wide peak appeared in the
PLUF resin, indicating different crystalline regions for these types of resin. The height of
13
the peaks (intensity) in the UF resin depends upon a number of factors [30]. The
crystallinity is the main factor influencing the height of the peaks. A comparison
between UF and PLUF resins indicated that the crystallinity of the cured PLUF resin is
lower than that of the UF resin. The measured decrease in the PLUF resin crystallinity is
probably related to the amorphous structure of the lignin incorporated into the UF resin
[31]. The previous study indicated that the crystalline regions of cured UF resins with
lower F/U mole ratio contribute partially to the improved hydrolytic stability of the cured
resin [24].
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
4. CONCLUSIONS
The aim of this research was to reduce formaldehyde emission from particleboard bonded
with UF resin by phenolated Kraft lignin. In summary, the following conclusions can be
According to the FTIR spectra, compared to Kraft lignin spectra, a new peak at a
920 cm-1 band was detected for phenolated lignin. The phenolated lignin exhibited also
higher amounts O-H bonds and lower C-O bonds compared to unmodified lignin.
The physicochemical several tests (gel time, viscosity and free formaldehyde
content) of the lignin based resins indicate that the reactivity of lignin in UF resins
14
The panels made from the phenolated Kraft lignin resin presented lower
formaldehyde emission and higher internal bond strength than those made from the
XRD analysis indicated that the crystallinity of the UF resin decreased with
Finally it can be concluded that since both synthesis of UF resins and lignin
phenolation are carried out under acid conditions, phenolation is an interesting way of
modifying lignin. Besides, unreacted phenol would not need to be removed from the
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
REFERENCES
[1] Boran, S., Usta, M., and Gumuskaya, E., Int. J. Adhes. Adhes. 31, 674–678 (2011).
[2] Zhang, J., Wang, X., Zhang, S., Gao, Q., and Li, J., Bioresource. 8, 5500-5514
(2013).
[3] Salem, M.Z.M., Bohm, M., Berankova, J., and Srba, J., Environ. 46, 1946-1953
(2011).
[4] Roffael, E., Johnsson, B., and Engstrom, B. J., Taiwan. Inst. Chem. E. 45, 2029-2038
(2014).
[5] Uchiyama, S., Matsushima, E., Kitao, N., Tokunaga, H., Ando, M., and Ostubo, Y.,
[6] Mansouri, H.R., Pizzi, A., and Leban, J.M., Holz. Roh. Werkst. 64, 218–220 (2006).
[7] Park, B.D., Kim, Y.S., Singh, A.P., and Lim, K.P., J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 88, 2677–
2687 (2003).
15
[8] Kim, S. J., Hazard. Mater. 176, 14–29 (2010).
[9] Wolkoff, P., Clausen, P.A., and Wilkins, C.K., Nielsen, G.D., Indoor Air. 10, 82–91
(2000).
[10] Abdullah, Z.A., and Park, B.D. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 117, 3181-3186 (2010).
[11] Zhao, C., Pizzi, A., and Garnier, S. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 74, 359–378(1999).
[12] Pizzi, A., and Mittal, K.L., Handbook of Adhesive Technology, (Marcel Dekker,
[13] Rozman, H.D., Tan, K.W., Kumr, R.N., Abubakr, A., Mohd, Z.A., and Ismail, H.,
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
[14] Torre, M.J.D.L., Moral, A., Hernandez, M.D, Cabeza, E., and Tijero, A., Ind. Crop.
[15] Doherty, W., Mousaviouna, P., and Fellows, C., Ind. Crop. Prod. 33, 259-276
(2011).
[16] Mai, C., Milstein, O., and Huttermann, A., J. Biotechnol. 79, 173-83 (2000).
[17] Mansouri, N.E.E.l., and Salvado, J., Ind.Crop. Prod. 24, 8–16 (2006).
[18] Hu, L., Pan, H., Zhou, Y., Zhang, M., Bioresource. 6, 3515-3525 (2011).
[19] Alonso, M.V., Oliet, M., Rodriguez, F., Garcia, J., Gilarranz, M.A., and Rodriguez,
[20] Mancera, C., Ferrando, F., Salvado, J., and Mansouri, N.E.E.l., Biomass. Convers.
[21] Younesi- Kordkheili, H., Kazemi-Najafi, S., Behrooz, R., and Pizzi, A., Holz. Roh.
[22] Cetin, N.S., and Ozmen, N., Int. J. Adhes. Adhes. 22, 477-480 (2002).
16
[23] Vazquez, G., Gonzalez, J., and Antorrena, F.G., Bioresource. Technol. 60, 191-198
(1997).
[24] Park, B.D., and Jeong, H.W. Int. J. Adhes. Adhes. 31, 524–529 (2011).
[25] Tejado, A., Kortaberria, G., Pena, C., Labidi, J., Echeverria, J.M., and Mondragon,
[26] Khan, M.A., and Ashraf, S.M., Indian. J. Chem. Techn. 13, 347-52 (2006).
[27] Gavrilovic-Grmusa, I., Dunky, M., Miljkovic, J., and Djiporovic-Momcilovic, M. J.,
[28] Christjanson, P., Suurpere, A., and Siimer, K., E-polymers. 4, 398- 407 (2004).
[29] Que, Z., and Furuno, T., Wood. Sci. Technol. 41, 267-79 (2007).
[30] Levendis, D., Pizzi, A., and Ferg, E., Holzforchung. 46, 263-69 (1992).
[31] Sevastyanova, Q., Qin, W., and Kadla, J.F. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 117, 2877-2881
(2010).
17
Table 1. FTIR assignment of lignin
18
Table 2 Physicochemical Properties of resins
formaldehyde
(%)
19
Figure 1. FTIR spectra of unmodified and penolated Kraft lignins.
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
20
Figure 2. Internal bond strength (IB) of the manufactured particleboard made from
synthesized resins.
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
21
Figure 3. Formaldehyde emission from manufactured particleboards made from
synthesized resins.
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
22
Figure 4. XRD analysis of UF and PLUF resins.
Downloaded by [Antonio Pizzi] at 10:51 07 June 2015
23