Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Power Plant Chemistry Measurement Advancements Orp PDF
Power Plant Chemistry Measurement Advancements Orp PDF
Power Plant Chemistry Measurement Advancements Orp PDF
Measurement Advancements:
Oxidation Reduction Potential
Abstract It is important to understand that these methods all measure the
Measurements which show the potential for corrosion of a plant’s oxidizing or reducing potential of the system with respect to the
metallurgy due to interaction with the system water have gained water. However, each of the listed names above specify a
in importance within the last two decades. Among the most method of obtaining the oxidation/reduction potential in a slightly
successful of these measurements are those which measure an different manner.
actual potential which is based upon the oxidation/reduction
reactions taking place. The measurement of Oxidation Reduction ORP, also called redox, utilizes a platinum measuring electrode
Potential (ORP) has been used extensively in both nuclear and with a Ag/AgCl reference electrode to measure the potential.
fossil fuel power plants to show the potential for corrosion in a Most fossil plants and the secondary side of some pressurized
system. Optimum ORP levels are dependent upon system water reactor (PWR) nuclear plants make this measurement at
metallurgy and water chemistry treatment. The system reaction, ambient temperature through a sampling system, similar to the
and thus the ORP response, will vary depending upon a number measurements of pH, dissolved oxygen, or conductivity. Other
of factors, such as oxygen, hydrogen and oxygen scavenger nuclear plants, especially those with a boiling water reactor
concentrations. Comparison of the oxidation/reduction potential (BWR), make this measurement either in-situ (directly in the
at various points in the system is useful for observing total process) or in a high flow, at-temperature autoclave system
system response to variations in chemical addition and system which provides a sample which is exactly representative of the
transients which can lead to more corrosive conditions in the process water.
water.
The ECP measurement typically utilizes a Ag/AgCl reference
Corrosion Potential electrode and the system metallurgy itself as the measuring
electrode. By doing this, the “actual” potential of the system itself
Within the last 15 to 20 years, extensive work has been done in
is determined. This measurement is utilized extensively within
both the nuclear and fossil fuel power industries to determine the
the nuclear industry. BWR plants often use the ECP as a control
response of system metallurgies to water chemistry conditions.
point for the addition of hydrogen, and as such have found that
Perhaps the most successful type of measurement used for
this is a more accurate method for ensuring the correct dosage
determining the corrosivity of the water to the system metal has 6,11
into the system. PWR plants often use the ECP on the
been the measurement of corrosion potential. This potential has
primary side to observe variations in the primary water during
been observed to be affected by a number of factors, including 6
startup, steady state, and shutdown conditions.
the activity of the oxidizing species (oxygen, copper), activity of
the reducing species (oxygen scavenger, hydrogen), type of
1-11 The measurement of corrosion potential utilizes a Ag/AgCl
oxide layers present, temperature, and flow rate.
reference electrode and a measurement electrode of the same
metallurgy as that of the system metal (usually some form of
This method for obtaining a measurement of the potential for
steel alloy). In theory, utilizing a measuring electrode similar to
corrosion utilizes a reference electrode, typically a silver/silver
the system metal, rather than platinum, should produce a
chloride (Ag/AgCl) half-cell, and a measuring electrode, typically
potential more representative of the system metal itself.
platinum or some form of metal which is similar or identical to the
However, many plants have found the platinum electrode to
system metallurgy (such as a steel alloy). The names given to
actually be equally or even more responsive and sensitive to
this particular measurement vary extensively – corrosion 1,2,5,6,8
system changes.
potential, oxidation/reduction potential (ORP), electrochemical
potential (ECP), or redox (another name for ORP).
Power Plant Chemistry Measurement Advancements: Oxidation Reduction Potential 2
Testing at BWR plants employing hydrogen water chemistry have Testing was done at this plant to observe the relationship
shown a direct relation between hydrogen and the corrosion between higher oxygen levels and the ORP value. The ORP
potential as well. It is important to note that the complexity of the value was relatively low (-300 mV SHE) during normal operation
reactions associated with these parameters is such that a change of oxygen concentrations of less than 5 ppb. As the oxygen level
in any of the concentrations can potentially cause a variation in was increased, the ORP level quickly increased to almost +75
the concentration of another. mV SHE by the time 25 ppb oxygen was present in the system.
At 100 ppb of oxygen, the ORP value had leveled off at around
Dissolved Oxygen +100 mV SHE. Further increases above 100 ppb showed little
Dissolved oxygen plays an important part of the corrosion increase in the ORP.
process on metal surfaces in power plants. Oxygen is an
oxidizing substance, so it will directly affect the ORP levels in the From the previous two examples it can be observed that oxygen
system water. Control points of the oxygen concentration vary directly affects the ORP of a system, as would be expected since
among different water chemistry treatments, but can typically be oxygen by definition will increase the oxidizing activity of the
summed up in two methods. The first method attempts to system. ORP will therefore become more positive at higher
remove as much oxygen as possible (typically down to 5 ppb or levels of oxygen. Figure 2 shows a theoretical example of what
lower) through some form of mechanical and/or chemical means. might be expected from ORP readings in the condensate when
The second method maintains a higher level of oxygen (typically oxygen is introduced into the condenser. Notice the direct
50 to 200 ppb). The type of method chosen will determine the relationship between oxygen and ORP. Notice also that as
expected potentials. oxygen levels exceed 100 ppb, the ORP does not increase much
further. This graph does not represent actual data at a plant;
At one PWR nuclear plant, oxygen concentration was maintained however, it does represent results of the oxygen vs. ORP
6
below 10 ppb in the main condensate. Shutdown of two relationship that have been observed at numerous plants.
condenser halves was done for cleaning purposes. This resulted
Oxygen Scavenger
in an increase in condensate temperature which in turn caused
an increase in the oxygen content of the condensate. The initial Oxygen scavengers, such as hydrazine, serve a primary purpose
increase in oxygen was from about 10 ppb to as high as 50 ppb. of chemically removing oxygen from the system. However, they
ORP measurements in the downcomer tube bundle were seen to can also be useful for corrosion prevention since the presence of
increase from -200 mV SHE to -100 mV SHE. ORP most oxygen scavengers will create a more reducing
measurements at the high pressure feed water heater were seen environment in the system. The results of testing performed at a
to increase from around -50 mV SHE to as high as +100 mV number of power plants, both nuclear and fossil based, show the
SHE. When the condenser was returned to normal operation, response of ORP to changing oxygen scavenger concentrations.
the condensate oxygen concentration dropped back down to
about 20 ppb. The downcomer ORP dropped down to around - At one nuclear PWR plant, hydrazine transients were observed
1,10
150 mV SHE, and the high pressure feedwater heater ORP when flow was lost from the injection pumps. Hydrazine
dropped down to about +10 mV SHE. However, the measured injection took place in the feedwater system, immediately after
oxygen at the feedwater remained constant at 2 to 3 ppb, and the the point where the condensate demineralizers can be inserted
measured feedwater hydrazine concentration was seen to remain into the lineup. The highest levels of hydrazine were observed in
constant at 130 ppb. The ORP was thus much more sensitive to the feedwater system before there could be much reaction of
system changes at the feedwater and downcomer area than the hydrazine with oxygen or other oxidizing contaminants, and
oxygen or hydrazine measurements. before there could be any appreciable thermal breakdown of
hydrazine. During this time, the ORP of the feedwater varied
The relationship between ORP and oxygen concentration was only by 10 mV, while a large change was seen in the downcomer
2
observed at one fossil fuel plant. Oxygen excursions occurred portion of the steam generators (see Table 1). The effect that
due to an air ingress, with the oxygen level spiking from 10 ppb hydrazine had on the ORP of the downcomer water was directly
to around 1 ppm, and then leveling off to 150 ppb for about 4 related to the length of the excursion and the change in
hours. The feedwater ORP levels were seen to rise sharply two hydrazine level. The relationship between more positive ORP
and a half hours later. The ORP increased 200 mV within about readings and lower hydrazine concentrations was obvious. Note
half an hour, and then slowly decreased over the next six hours. that the hydrazine levels are given for feedwater hydrazine.
Power Plant Chemistry Measurement Advancements: Oxidation Reduction Potential 4
A previous check of hydrazine levels had given downcomer It should be noted that an increase in ORP with increasing
hydrazine levels of 54 and 79 ppb where feedwater was 100 ppb. hydrazine dosage is not normal, and could possibly indicate
something other than hydrazine affecting the ORP reading.
It was noted at one fossil plant that sample locations with higher
hydrazine residuals experienced more reducing (more negative) It is important to understand that when no oxygen scavenger is
4,12
potentials. The hydrazine concentration was initially 40 ppb present, the ORP value of the water is largely dependent upon
and was reduced over a period of time to zero. The ORP was the oxygen concentration in the water. However, when the
seen to have a direct correlation with the level of hydrazine. oxygen concentration drops much below 5 ppb due to oxygen
While the level of hydrazine was at 40 ppb, the ORP reading was scavenger addition, the ORP value becomes more of a function
approximately -340 mV. When the hydrazine feed was stopped of the oxygen scavenger concentration. Figure 3 shows a
completely, the ORP was seen to rise to about +80 mV, where it theoretical example of what might be expected from ORP
leveled off. Large step changes of the hydrazine concentration readings in the final feedwater when hydrazine concentration is
correlated to large step changes in the ORP. At another fossil varied in the feedwater. Notice the inverse relationship between
plant, the ORP levels at the economizer inlet were recorded hydrazine and the ORP value. Notice also that as hydrazine
before and after hydrazine feed was cycled on and off. An levels exceed 100 ppb, the ORP does not decrease much
excellent correlation of ORP vs. hydrazine was observed, with further. This graph does not represent actual data at a plant;
ORP readings of around -80 mV with hydrazine and +60 mV however, it does represent results of the hydrazine vs. ORP
4
without hydrazine. relationship that have been observed at numerous plants.
An interesting effect of the oxygen scavenger and ORP Hydrogen Water Chemistry
relationship was noted at a few nuclear PWR plants. (Note: In BWR nuclear plants, hydrogen is often added to the feedwater
Although reported as ECP, both plants tested ORP as well and to avoid stress corrosion cracking of stainless steel piping. It has
reported qualitatively similar results. As such, the actual been shown that the intergranular stress corrosion cracking
potentials were somewhat different in magnitude, but the (IGSCC) of sensitized stainless steel can be minimized by
response was basically the same.) In the secondary side of one maintaining the ECP below the critical potential, typically -230
plant, the ECP values were observed in the final feedwater for mV SHE in high purity water.
6,11,13
Hydrogen addition to the
8
various concentrations of hydrazine residual. The ECP was feedwater decreases the amount of oxidizing species in the
approximately -100 mV SHE when there was no hydrazine reactor water by recombination in the downcomer, and thus
present in the water. As the hydrazine residual increased, the reduces the production of oxidizing species from the radiolysis of
ECP value dropped exponentially until it leveled off at water in the core.
11,13
The addition of hydrogen to the feedwater
approximately -500 mV SHE at 100 ppb of hydrazine. Increasing creates a more reducing potential (more negative) due to
the hydrazine concentration beyond 100 ppb did not serve to decrease of oxidizing species which results from the increased
reduce the ECP any further. A similar test was performed in the hydrogen concentration. The potential of BWR water with
5
secondary side of another plant. At two of the sample points “normal” hydrogen water chemistry has been observed to be
(condensate pump discharge and low pressure feedwater pump typically in the range of +50 to +200 mV SHE.
6,11
Only at
discharge), a similar effect to that seen at the other plant was increased dosages of hydrogen will the potential be seen to drop
observed. The condensate sample point’s ECP did not vary from down to well below the -230 mV range.
6,11,14
It has been
around +200 mV SHE until the hydrazine concentration was observed that the potential can only be accurately measured in-
increased to above 15 ppb. When the hydrazine concentration situ for proper hydrogen dosage control.
11
A change in chemistry in one portion of the system may cause no The second transient was characterized by an inleakage of
change in the ORP at one point and drastically alter the readings oxygen from systems connected to the feedwater line after the
5
at another point. This has been observed at many plants. condensate pumps (and after the first point of ORP monitoring).
Although the majority of the ORP measurements have been A decrease in hydrazine concentration was also noticed during
made in the feedwater or economizer, other points in the process this type of transient. Each measuring point had a significant
are also important to monitor for better characterization of the increase in potential during the time of the transient, with the
overall system response to varying changes, such as load second point showing the most noticeable increase. The
increases, leaks, or excursions. increase at points 1 and 3 were about the same. The same
8
effect was noticed at another plant. In both plants, the dissolved
At one nuclear plant utilizing a Pressurized Water Reactor oxygen monitor for the feedwater showed no appreciable
(PWR), readings were taken at various points on two redundant increases, while the potential measurements were seen to
1,10
systems on the secondary water. These points included the increase at multiple points.
Feedwater, Downcomer, Hotleg, Coldleg, and Demineralizer
Influent. An example of varying system responses can be seen Locational testing during changes of hydrazine dosage was also
5
by examining Table 1. Testing of ORP response of the system to performed at this plant. The hydrazine was dosed from after the
hydrazine excursions revealed an interesting system response condensate pump, at a location immediately after the first
between the feedwater and the downcomer portions. As can be sampling point. An immediate change was noticed in the second
seen from Table 1, feedwater hydrazine levels dropped sampling point, as the potential dropped linearly from
considerably during excursions. The ORP response at the approximately 0 mV SHE down to -350 mV SHE as the hydrazine
downcomer sample point was significant, typically rising by as concentration was increased from 0 to 15 ppb. As the hydrazine
much as 100 mV during each excursion. However, the effect of concentration was continually increased to as high as 150 ppb,
loss of hydrazine flow on ORP was minimal in the feedwater the potential slowly increased from -350 mV SHE to about -300
system. ORP readings differed by no more than about 10 mV mV SHE. The third sampling point remained at approximately -
each time. 400 mV throughout the range of 0 to 150 ppb hydrazine. The
first sampling began at approximately +200 mV SHE and
Another PWR-based nuclear plant measured the ORP response remained constant until about 15 ppb of hydrazine had been
at the outlet of the condensate pumps (point #1), the outlet of the introduced. At that dosage point, the potential began to drop in a
feedwater pumps (point #2), and the outlet of the high pressure slow, exponential fashion to a final potential of around -50 mV
5
heaters (point #3). During steady state conditions, the potential SHE at 150 ppb of hydrazine.
after the condensate pumps was typically -150 to -100 mV SHE.
The potential after the feedwater pumps was typically -350 to - Another nuclear plant utilizing a Boiling Water Reactor (BWR)
200 mV SHE. The potential at the outlet of the high pressure experienced high potentials (typically between 0 to +200 mV
11
heaters was typically -550 mV SHE. SHE) during normal hydrogen water chemistry conditions.
These potentials did not vary at different points in the system.
At the same plant, some transient conditions were introduced to However, upon addition of hydrogen at what was considered to
5
observe the effects on the potential at the three sampling points. be normal rates for hydrogen water chemistry, the potentials first
The first transient was characterized by an increase in the decreased at sample points distant from the core, while the
condensate oxygen concentration (typically 6 ppb) and a potentials near to the core remained relatively high. The
decrease in the feedwater hydrazine concentration (typically 70 corrosion potential was thus seen to be considerably different at
to 100 ppb). This effect was caused by leakage of oxygen into various points. As hydrogen dosage was increased to much
the condenser or the steam itself. The redox potential at point #1 higher than the normal rate, the entire system eventually dropped
was observed to increase by about 20-100 mV, with the larger to a very low potential (typically less than -300 mV SHE), with
increases seen with larger increases in oxygen concentration and little variance among sample points, although some higher
larger decreases in hydrazine concentration. Point #2 was corrosion potentials were still seen in the core.
observed to increase in potential by about 10-50 mV,
characterized by the same situation as point #1. The third point An interesting phenomenon was observed in measuring different
had no measurable increase in potential for any of the above sample points at one fossil fuel-based plant that converted from
transient conditions. All-Volatile Treatment to Oxygenated Treatment (OT).
Power Plant Chemistry Measurement Advancements: Oxidation Reduction Potential 6
During AVT treatment, ORP readings were taken at the Hotwell (- The primary oxidation reaction on steel surfaces is the oxidation
60 mV), Final Feedwater (-100 mV), Boiler Water (-80 mV) and and dissolution of iron:
Main Steam (-80 mV). Readings differed by more than 100 mV
Fe ⇒ Fe + + 2e
2 -
at various sample points in the plant, and it was observed that (5)
the sample locations of more negative potentials had higher
4
hydrazine residuals. Upon switching to OT, the readings were The two primary reduction reactions on steel surfaces are the
12
about +100 to +120 mV at each point. The resulting common reduction of hydrogen (Equation 6) and the reduction of oxygen
readings were expected, since the water chemistry would be (Equation 7):
similar throughout the system.
+
2H + 2e
-
⇒ H2 (6)
It is obvious from the results seen in the previous examples that
the multiple location measurements can play an important part in O2 + 2H2O + 4e
-
⇒ 4OH- (7)
determining the overall cause and effect of various transients and
variations to water chemistry in the system. It is expected that The reduction of hydrogen is seen to be favored at more
load variations on the system could also generate results that reducing potentials while the reduction of oxygen is favored at
15
vary from point to point. Regardless of the cause for the higher (more oxidizing) potentials. The optimal ORP control
variation, multiple points are useful for sensing overall system point appears to be somewhat dependent upon the pH of the
2,7
response to process changes and upsets. plant water. It has been shown that providing a less reducing
environment in all-ferrous plants at the recommended pH levels
ORP And Corrosion (typically 8-10 pH depending upon the specific water chemistry
3,4,7,9
ORP has a strong relation to corrosion within a system, since the treatment) will minimize corrosion product generation. This
reactions associated with corrosion are oxidation/reduction can be done by lowering oxygen scavenger levels or eliminating
based. Any oxidants or reductants present in the system are the oxygen scavenger levels and adding oxygen. This process
directly linked to corrosion production in a system. Optimal converts the magnetite (Fe3O4) to ferric oxide hydrate (FeOOH),
9
concentration limits of oxidants and reductants vary depending which has a much lower solubility.
upon the type of metallurgy and the type of water chemistry
treatment being done at a plant. Figure 4 shows an example of At one plant, the ORP increased from -340 mV to +100 mV when
the optimal control ranges for ORP at the feedwater sampling the level of hydrazine was reduced from 40 ppb to zero. The
4
point in both nuclear and fossil plants for various water chemistry total iron decreased from 14 ppb to about 5 ppb. At another
treatments. plant, which has an all-ferrous system, hydrazine feed was
discontinued to reduce iron transport. The ORP was observed to
The trend in past years at most plants has been to remove as increase from -125 mV to -50 mV when the hydrazine dosage
much of the dissolved oxygen as possible, which almost always was dropped from 20 ppb to 0 ppb. The feedwater pH of 9.2 to
requires addition of an oxygen scavenger such as hydrazine. 9.6 remained the same during the test period. Iron transport
This can have a detrimental effect in all-ferrous plants, since through the feedwater cycle did decrease from an average of
removing oxygen by oxygen scavenger will lead to a strongly about 3 ppb to less than 1 ppb within an 8 month time period
10
reducing environment (-300 mV or lower), which has actually following the change in treatment.
been seen to increase the erosion/corrosion of iron-based
materials as well as increasing the transported feedwater Some plants with all-ferrous metallurgy have begun switching to
corrosion products.
3,4,9
It has been observed that high levels of an Oxygenated Treatment (OT) in which a small concentration of
flow-accelerated corrosion (FAC) occur in all-ferrous plants when dissolved oxygen, typically 30-150 ppb, is maintained in order to
the ORP is less than -300 mV due to either an oxygen level of minimize corrosion. Conversion to OT will correspond to an
less than 1 ppb or oxygen scavenger level of greater than 20 oxidizing environment typically on the order of +100 mV or
3,4
ppb, or both.
9 more. This has been shown to eliminate flow accelerated
corrosion by forming a protective oxide layer on the material
9
surface.
Power Plant Chemistry Measurement Advancements: Oxidation Reduction Potential 7
This effect was observed at one plant which has a copper nickel
10
condenser and all-ferrous feedwater heaters. Hydrazine
injection had been terminated in an attempt to reduce the
potential for erosion/corrosion and iron transport through the
boiler cycle. A slow loss in turbine efficiency was observed after
the change. It was theorized that oxygen in the boiler water
converted copper in boiler deposits allowing it to volatize and
deposit on the first stages on the HP turbine. Hydrazine
injection was then re-established with a goal on maintaining a
more reducing environment in the feedwater and boiler water.
Saturated
Steam
H-P Turbine
Chemical I-P Turbine
Feed ORP
Condenser
Drum Cooling Water
ORP
Hotwell
Super
heater
Economizer
Blowdown Reheater
Boiler Deaerator
ORP Condensate
ORP Polishers
ORP
ORP
Chemical
Feed
200 200
180
150
160
100
140
ORP, mV SHE
50
Oxygen, ppb
120
Oxygen, ppb
100 0
ORP, Condensate
80
-50
60
-100
40
-150
20
0 -200
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Time, hours
* Note: This graph does not contain actual data from plant results. It represents an example of typical results that have been observed in a number of
plants
Power Plant Chemistry Measurement Advancements: Oxidation Reduction Potential 9
160 100
50
140
0
120
-50
100
Hydrazine, ppb
ORP, mV SHE
-100
Hydrazine, ppb
80 -150
ORP, mV SHE
-200
60
-250
40
-300
20
-350
0 -400
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Time, hours
* Note: This graph does not contain actual data from plant results. It represents an example of typical results that have been observed
in a number of plants.
Range 3
Range 2
Range 5
Range 4 Range 6
Range 1
Range 1: Pressurized Water Reactor Nuclear Plant, Primary Side (mV, SHE)
Range 2: Boiling Water Reactor Nuclear Plant, High Hydrogen Addition (mV, SHE)
Range 3: Boiling Water Reactor Nuclear Plant, Normal Water Chemistry (mV, SHE)
Power Plant Chemistry Measurement Advancements: Oxidation Reduction Potential 10
Range 4: (a) Pressurize Water Reactor Nuclear Plant, Secondary Circuit (mV, SHE)
(b) Mixed Metallurgy Fossil Fuel Plant, Oxygen Scavenger Addition (mV, Ag/AgCl)
Range 5: All-Ferrous Fossil Fuel Plant, No Oxygen Scavenger Addition (mV, Ag/AgCl)
More Information
For more information on ORP, visit
www.honeywellprocess.com, or contact your
Honeywell account manager.