Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Biotechnology and Agriculture Module
Biotechnology and Agriculture Module
precise genetic changes in agriculture this includes: pest resistance, herbicide resistance
through technology that helps the farmers make their tasks a lot easier and to improve
plays a part in environmental and economic sustainability. And because of this, farmers
often chooses biotech crops for it increases yield and makes a lower production cost.
The main point of our topic is that technology in the form of biotechnology is
being applied to agriculture to address problems and improve resistance to pest and
diseases and also enhance the quality and nutritional content of foods.
This module aims to deliver facts about Agricultural Biotechnology such as its
I
1.1: What Agriculture Really Is?
created food surpluses that enabled people to live in cities. The history of agriculture
began thousands of years ago. After gathering wild grains beginning at least 105,000
years ago, nascent farmers began to plant them around 11,500 years ago. Pigs, sheep and
cattle were domesticated over 10,000 years ago. Plants were independently cultivated in
from ager, "field", which in its turn came from Greek αγρός, and cultūra, "cultivation" or
"growing". While agriculture usually refers to human activities, certain species of ant,
termite and ambrosia beetle also cultivate crops. Agriculture is defined with varying
scopes, in its broadest sense using natural resources to "produce commodities which
maintain life, including food, fiber, forest products, horticultural crops, and their related
II
services". Thus defined, it includes arable farming, horticulture, animal husbandry and
gatherer techniques such as boatmaking, toolmaking, botany, and so forth, but anticipated
changes were taking place: the Ice Age was ending, so ice was disappearing and regions
like mountain ranges became traversable, while ocean levels were rising and inland seas
boundaries between continents. The Fertile Crescent was such an area, located between
Europe, Asia, and Africa. This is where both civilization and agriculture began.
III
Agriculture probably began in areas filled with animal dung, because there were a
variety of seeds there and ample fertilizer for them to grow. The original crops were
nothing like the crops people know today. The plants used were often husky, frail, or
breeding were their nutritional qualities optimized. Therefore, in a very important sense,
The first basic crop was wheat, which has two main forms that still exist today.
The first variety is called emmer, and still grows wild in the region. The second variety is
not wild, but probably emerged from the crossing of emmer with another wild grass. This
is bread wheat, which is still the most important crop on earth. Other plants cultivated
during this time include peas, lentils, barley, linseed, and grapes.
Ancient Origins
IV
By 6000 BC, mid-scale farming was entrenched on
farmers went on to domesticate taro and beans including mung, soy and azuki. To
complement these new sources of carbohydrates, highly organized net fishing of rivers,
lakes and ocean shores in these areas brought in great volumes of essential protein.
Collectively, these new methods of farming and fishing inaugurated a human population
boom dwarfing all previous expansions, and is one that continues today.
the waterway now known as the Shatt al-Arab, from its Persian Gulf delta to the
confluence of the Tigris and Euphrates. Domestication of wild aurochs and mouflon into
cattle and sheep, respectively, ushered in the large-scale use of animals for food/fiber and
as beasts of burden. The shepherd joined the farmer as an essential provider for sedentary
and semi-nomadic societies. Maize, manioc, and arrowroot were first domesticated in the
V
The potato, tomato, pepper, squash, several varieties of bean, tobacco, and several
other plants were also developed in the New World, as was extensive terracing of steep
hillsides in much of Andean South America. The Greeks and Romans built on techniques
pioneered by the Sumerians but made few fundamentally new advances. Southern Greeks
struggled with very poor soils, yet managed to become a dominant society for years. The
Romans were noted for an emphasis on the cultivation of crops for trade.
Middle Ages
machines such as norias, and the use of water raising machines, dams, and reservoirs.
They also wrote location-specific farming manuals, and were instrumental in the wider
adoption of crops including sugar cane, rice, citrus fruit, apricots, cotton, artichokes,
aubergines, and saffron. Muslims also brought lemons, oranges, cotton, almonds, figs and
sub-tropical crops such as bananas to Spain. The invention of a three field system of crop
rotation during the Middle Ages, and the importation of the Chinese-invented moldboard
the end of this period was the discovery and subsequent cultivation of fodder crops which
VI
Modern Era
After 1492, a global exchange of previously local crops and livestock breeds
occurred. Key crops involved in this exchange included the tomato, maize, potato, cocoa
and tobacco going from the New World to the Old, and
important animal exportations from the Old World to the New were those of the horse
and dog (dogs were already present in the pre-Columbian Americas but not in the
numbers and breeds suited to farm work). Although not usually food animals, the horse
(including donkeys and ponies) and dog quickly filled essential production roles on
many times that seen in the Middle Ages. With the rapid rise of mechanization in the late
19th and 20th centuries, particularly in the form of the tractor, farming tasks could be
done with a speed and on a scale previously impossible. These advances have led to
efficiencies enabling certain modern farms in the United States, Argentina, Israel,
Germany, and a few other nations to output volumes of high quality produce per land unit
VII
The Haber-Bosch method for synthesizing
previous constraints. In the past century agriculture has been characterized by enhanced
productivity, the substitution of labor for synthetic fertilizers and pesticides, selective
breeding, mechanization, water pollution, and farm subsidies. In recent years there has
Two early examples of expeditions include Frank N. Meyer's fruit and nut collecting trip
to China and Japan from 1916 - 1918 and the Dorsett-Morse Oriental Agricultural
Exploration Expedition to China, Japan, and Korea from 1929 - 1931 to collect soybean
In 2005, the agricultural output of China was the largest in the world, accounting
for almost one-sixth world share followed by the EU, India and the USA, according to
the International Monetary Fund. Economists measure the total factor productivity of
agriculture and by this measure agriculture in the United States is roughly 2.6 times more
VIII
2.1: What is Agricultural Biotechnology?
For thousands of years, humans have manipulated nature to grow the best crops
and livestock. By matching together various strains of crops or animals, we've guided the
developmental path of countless organisms. If you were to step back in time thousands of
years, the crops you'd see would look very different -- in some cases, they'd be
unrecognizable!
science involving the use of scientific tools and techniques, including genetic
one aspect of agricultural biotechnology which has been greatly developed upon in recent
times. Desired trait are exported from a particular species of Crop to an entirely different
species. These transgene crops possess desirable characteristics in terms of flavor, colour
of flowers, growth rate, size of harvested products and resistance to diseases and pests.
function. Genes determine everything from the color of your eyes to whether or not you
IX
As we learn more about which genes affect different aspects of an organism, we
can take steps to manipulate that feature or function. One way to do this is to take genetic
information from one organism and introduce it into another -- even if that organism
belongs to a completely different species. For example, if you found out that a particular
bacterium had a resistance to a certain herbicide, you might want to lift those genes so
that you could introduce them into crops. Then you could use herbicides to wipe out pest
While some people might think that changing organisms at such a fundamental
level is unnatural, the truth is that we've been using a much cruder method of shaping
organisms for centuries. When farmers crossbreed plants, they are engaging in a primitive
form of this methodology. But with crossbreeding, all the genes of one type of organism
are introduced to all the genes of the second organism. It's not precise, and it can take
Agricultural biotechnology lets scientists pick and choose which genes are
introduced to an organism. Let's take a look at some of the benefits of this technology.
X
2.2: Uses and Benefits of Agricultural Biotechnology
World Hunger
world suffer from chronic food shortages, and millions more could go hungry due to
current and future food crises. Crops improved through biotechnology are producing
in that community also benefit with a safe, nutritious and sustainable food supply. For
example, in Argentina, the economic gains resulting from a 140 percent increase in
soybean area since 1995 are estimated to have contributed towards the creation of
XI
Increased Production and Plantings
Since the first commercialized crop in 1996, the world’s farmers have consistently
increased their plantings of biotech crops by double-digit growth rates every year. The
increase of 12 million hectares between 2005 and 2006 was the second highest in the last
five years and equivalent to an annual growth rate of 13 percent in 2006. The global area
of approved biotech crops in 2006 was 102 million hectares. Biotechnology helped
increase U.S. agricultural production yields by 8.34 billion pounds of corn and soybeans
on 123 million acres in 2005. Biotech plants that resist pests and diseases, tolerate harsh
growing conditions and reduce spoilage prevent farmers from losing billions of pounds of
and 2004. It is noteworthy that farmers in developing countries captured the majority of
the extra farm income from biotech crops. The largest gains in farm income have been in
the soybean sector, largely from cost savings. For example, the $3 billion additional
adding 6.7 percent to the value of the crop in the biotech-growing countries or adding the
equivalent of 5.6 percent to the $55 billion value of the global soybean crop in 2006.
XII
Cost Savings from Decreased Pesticide/Herbicide Use
Because small farms around the world are hampered by the same pests, international
farming communities benefit when U.S. farmers are able to save on pesticide/ herbicide
costs and reinvest their funds into technology improvements. Increased productivity is a
benefit to any farmer, but tremendously enhances quality of life when a small-scale
Safety
Most foods we eat today come from plants or animals that farmers have
species have been crossbred to develop useful new varieties with beneficial traits, such as
are different and substantially improved from traditional crossbreeding because they
XIII
Biotechnology Provides Nutritional Benefits
the world. As the technology developed, the first generation of agricultural biotechnology
products were focused more on input traits, which means these modifications made
insect, virus and weed control easier or more efficient for farmers. These first products
have been rapidly adopted by U.S. farmers, and now account for the majority of
soybeans, cotton and corn grown in the U.S. Agricultural biotechnology varieties focused
on consumer benefits are often called output traits. These products spent much more time
in development, but are moving towards commercial availability. Many of these would fit
into the category of “functional foods” because they provide added nutrition compared to
the pipeline.
Farmers live off the land, and so they take their environmental stewardship very
seriously. Agricultural biotechnology helps farmers provide a sustainable future for the
world’s agriculture systems. Extensive and repeated studies continue to verify that
biotechnology derived crops pose no risks to the environment unique or different from
XIV
Reduced Pesticide Use
farmers’ needs to use pesticide applications, eliminating 69.7 million pounds of pesticide
use in the U.S. alone. Globally, it is estimated that pesticide applications decreased six
percent in the interval from 1996 to 2004, eliminating 379 million pounds of pesticide
applications.
impact of biotech crops has been the adoption of no-till farming. No-till was made
feasible on many more U.S. soil types and in many more latitudes by herbicide tolerant
soybeans. In 2006, 89 percent (66.68 million acres) of U.S. soybean acreage was planted
benefits in terms of soil health and conservation, improved water retention/ decreased soil
XV
Water Quality
enzymes to degrade this phytate into a form of phosphorus that can be utilized. To
remedy this problem, producers add inorganic phosphorus to the diet. The end result of
the poor phosphorus utilization and the high amount of inorganic phosphorus that must
be added to the diet is that excessive phosphorus is excreted in the manure. This
waterways. A gene for production of phytase has been successfully incorporated into
soybean and wheat, and is biologically active when the plants are used as animal feed. In
soybeans to which the enzyme is added. Biotechnology is also being used in the
development of low phytate soybeans and corn by silencing the phytate gene in the seeds.
The resulting animal feed will allow livestock producers to save money they would have
spent on dietary supplements and it will also reduce phosphorus pollution and improve
water quality. The new soybean seed is expected to be commercially available in the next
decade.
XVI
Reduced Greenhouse Gasses
No-till farming reduces the use of agricultural machinery in fields, which leads to
of carbon dioxide (CO2) into the environment. This reduction in CO2 emissions with
• Reduction in the use of diesel fuel in biotech crops, due to a reduction in pesticide
• An increase in the amount of carbon held in the soil due to a reduction in plowing
14.76 billion kg of CO2 in 2006. This is the equivalent of removing 6.56 million cars
Herbicide tolerant soybeans have limited gene flow risk to nonbiotech varieties.
There are several reasons for this. Soy self-pollinates, which means it is less prone to
gene flow than crops that cross-pollinate. In addition, there are no sexually compatible
wild relatives in North America. It is estimated that outcrossing rates between adjacent
XVII
Pest Resistance
Issuance of formal import approvals for the LIBERTY LINK soybean (which is
that, beginning in 2009, U.S. farmers will have the freedom to rotate between usage of
Biodiversity
varieties of wildlife. For example, studies have shown that songbirds have actually
production practices facilitated by biotech herbicide-resistant soybeans has made the U.S.
XVIII
2.3: Impacts of Agricultural Biotechnology
Agricultural biotechnology can help solve the global food crisis and make a
positive impact on world hunger. According to the United Nations, food production will
have to rise by 50 percent by the year 2030 to meet the demands of a growing population.
tenfold in some developing countries, far beyond the production capabilities of traditional
soybeans, corn, cotton and canola. Eleven million of these were small or resource-poor
farmers in developing countries. Farmers earn higher incomes in every country where
biotech crops are grown. When farmers benefit, their communities benefit as well.
XIX
Beneficial traits include lower saturated fat, increased omega-3 fatty acids and increased
isoflavone content. Consumers can rest assured that agricultural biotechnology is safe.
These crops have been repeatedly studied and declared safe by expert panels the world
over. In the 12+ years that biotech crops have been commercially grown, there has not
been a single documented case of an ecosystem disrupted or a person made ill by these
foods.
Arguably, the biggest environmental impact of biotech crops has been the
farmers to almost completely eliminate plowing on their fields, resulting in better soil
health and conservation, improved water retention/ decreased soil erosion and decreased
herbicide runoff. In fact, no-till farming has led to a global reduction of 14.76 billion kg
of carbon dioxide (CO2) in 2006, the equivalent of removing 6.56 million cars from the
roads for one year. Global pesticide applications decreased six percent in the 10 years
after biotechnology derived crops were first introduced, eliminating 379 million pounds
of pesticide applications. Biotechnology derived crops are improving water quality both
through less herbicide and pesticide in runoff from fields, and in the future through
reducing phosphorus excretion in livestock by using biotech derived feed that contains
reduced levels of phytate. These results show that agricultural biotechnology delivers
tangible and significant benefits for farmers, consumers and the environment. These
benefits add up to a more sustainable future. Consumers benefit with safe, healthy and
XX
abundant food to feed a growing population. Farmers reap the benefits of increased
communities. Perhaps most importantly, biotechnology helps care for the environment by
XXI
3.1: GENETIC ENGINEERING
desired phenotype, genetic engineering takes the gene directly from one organism and
inserts it in the other. This is much faster, can be used to insert any genes from any
organism (even ones from different domains) and prevents other undesirable genes from
replacing the defective gene with a functioning one. It is an important tool in research
that allows the function of specific genes to be studied. Drugs, vaccines and other
products have been harvested from organisms engineered to produce them. Crops have
been developed that aid food security by increasing yield, nutritional value and tolerance
to environmental stresses.
The DNA can be introduced directly into the host organism or into a cell that is
then fused or hybridised with the host. This relies on recombinant nucleic acid techniques
XXII
to form new combinations of heritable genetic material followed by the incorporation of
that material either indirectly through a vector system or directly through micro-injection,
macro-injection or micro-encapsulation.
fertilisation, induction of polyploidy, mutagenesis and cell fusion techniques that do not
breeding. Cloning and stem cell research, although not considered genetic
engineering, are closely related and genetic engineering can be used within
them. Synthetic biology is an emerging discipline that takes genetic engineering a step
DNA as Artificially Expanded Genetic Information System and Hachimoji DNA is made
Plants, animals or micro organisms that have been changed through genetic
from another species is added to the host, the resulting organism is called transgenic. If
genetic material from the same species or a species that can naturally breed with the host
is used the resulting organism is called cisgenic. If genetic engineering is used to remove
genetic material from the target organism the resulting organism is termed
XXIII
engineering while within the United States of America and Canada genetic modification
What is a GMO?
This creates combinations of plant, animal, bacteria, and virus genes that do not occur in
Most GMOs have been engineered to withstand the direct application of herbicide
and/or to produce an insecticide. However, new technologies are now being used to
artificially develop other traits in plants, such as a resistance to browning in apples, and
to create new organisms using synthetic biology. Despite biotech industry promises, there
is no evidence that any of the GMOs currently on the market offer increased yield,
XXIV
EXAMPLES OF GENETICALLY MODIFIED CROPS
Maize
herbicides. Maize strains with both traits are now in use in multiple countries. GM maize
has also caused controversy with respect to possible health effects, impact on other
insects and impact on other plants via gene flow. One strain, called Starlink, was
approved only for animal feed in the US but was found in food, leading to a series of
Soybean
durability. By doing this the soybean will be resistant to several chemicals and
attacks from other organisms. These genetically modified soy beans are found in
several different types of aliments because modifying them has become such a great
XXV
success, of course there are several people against the idea of modifying a plant and
they believe that it can be harmful while others fully support it.
Pigs
The "Enviropig" has been genetically modified in such a manner that its
urine and feces contain almost 65 percent less phosphorus than usual. That could be
good news for lakes, rivers, and ocean deltas, where phosphorous from animal waste
Chickens
the potential to stop bird flu outbreaks spreading within poultry flocks. This would
not only protect the health of domestic poultry but could also reduce the risk of bird
flu epidemics leading to new flu virus epidemics in the human population.
XXVI
3.3: CROP MODIFICATION TECHNIQUES
Traditional Crossbreeding
For millennia, traditional crossbreeding has been the backbone of improving the
genetics of our crops. Typically, pollen from one plant is placed on the female part of the
flower of another, leading to the production of seeds that are hybrids of the two parents.
Then, plant breeders select the plants that have the beneficial traits they are looking for to
go on to the next generation. Apple varieties such as the Honeycrisp apple were
developed in this way – thousands of hybrid trees were made, grown, and tested to find
just one great new variety with a combination of genes that has never existed before.
Modern plant breeding often uses genetic markers to speed the selection process, and
may incorporate genes from wild varieties and closely-related species. Here are some
videos about the different techniques that plant breeders use. Crossbreeding can only
XXVII
make use of desirable traits if they are in the same or closely-related species, so
additional techniques have been developed to create new traits for plant breeders to use.
Mutagenesis
In nature, new traits often arise through spontaneous mutations. In the past
century, this process has been mimicked by scientists, who have used mutating chemicals
and subsequently screening for new or desired traits. For more information on
mutagenesis, please view this post. The Ruby Red and the Star Ruby varieties of
grapefruits were developed using ionizing radiation. The mutations that they carry give
these fruit their characteristic deep red color. This article from the New York Times
provides many additional examples of crops that have been developed using this
technique.
Polyploidy
Most species have 2 sets of chromosomes: one set inherited from each parent.
chromosomes. It can occur naturally, but polyploidy can also be induced through the use
of chemicals. This crop modification technique is usually used to increase the size of
fruits or to modify their fertility. For example, the seedless watermelon has 3 sets of
XXVIII
another watermelon that has 2 sets, making a sterile watermelon with 3 sets of
chromosomes, much to the delight of picnic lovers throughout the globe. Potato species
also have many different number of chromosome copies, and potato breeders commonly
have to change the copy number of their varieties to breed new traits into them.
Protoplast Fusion
When sperm cells in pollen combine with the ova in the ovaries of a flower, this is
a fusion of two cells into one. Protoplast fusion is an artificial version of this process.
Beneficial traits can be moved from one species to another by fusing the protoplasts
(‘naked’ cells without the cell walls that give plants their structure) together and growing
a plant from the newly fused cell. One of the most commonly used traits that has been
developed with this process is the transfer of male sterility between species. If you have a
male sterile plant, you can more easily make hybrid seeds – especially for plants that
have small flowers and are difficult to cross. Male sterility was introduced to red cabbage
from daikon radishes, making it easier to produce hybrid seeds of this crop.
Transgenesis
Transgenesis is the process by which you introduce one or more genes into an
organism from another organism entirely. This usually involves handling and modifying
the DNA itself in a test tube, and then packaging it to insert it into the new organism.
There are several ways to introduce the new gene or ‘transform’ a plant such as biolistics
XXIX
(the “gene gun”), using Agrobacterium – a naturally occurring organism that inserts DNA
have been generated with many useful traits, some of which have been commercialized.
For instance, papayas were transformed with a gene from the virus that infects the plant
to make it resistant to the virus. Other traits include insect resistance, herbicide tolerance,
and drought tolerance, and more. The creation of these ‘transgenic’ crops works even
though the genes can from from any other species because the genetic language is
universal to all life on this planet. Genes that originated from the same species can be
Genome Editing
Genome editing consists of using an enzyme system to change the DNA of a cell
at a specified sequence. There are different systems that can be used for genome editing,
the most promising of which is the CRISPR-Cas9 system (for more information on
genome editing and how it works, please view this post). The sulfonylurea (SU) herbicide
tolerant canola was developed to enable farmers to better control weeds and to enable
crop rotation. The crop was created using a patented genome editing system known as
Rapid Trait Development System (RTDS). You could conceivably edit the genome of
any crop to alter any gene you wanted, from introducing new genes to restoring ‘natural’
XXX
4.1: Is it Environment Friendly?
agriculture, thereby increasing global food security without the need for increased land
clearance. Insect resistant crops offer an alternative to chemical inputs on some crops and
have allowed development of more targeted, flexible, effective and sustainable integrated
measured by the indicator, the Environmental Impact Quotient (EIQ)) by 18.4%. The
technology has also facilitated important cuts in fuel use and tillage changes, resulting in
a significant reduction in the release of greenhouse gas emissions from the GM cropping
area. In 2016, this was equivalent to removing 16.7 million cars from the roads.(Brookes
XXXI
In 1950, the world population was 2.5 billion people. It is currently 7 billion, and
projections are that it will reach 9 billion by 2050. It is estimated that the world needs at
least 70% more food by 2050. Improvements in agricultural practices and technologies
have achieved huge successes in helping to meet the food, feed and fibre needs of this
environment, and much work and research is now taking place to limit and decrease the
in several ways. Biotech crops have helped reduce the use of pesticides for several
that are eliminated from the manufacturing, distribution and application processes.
Higher yields mean farmers can produce increasing amounts of food without increasing
arable land and this has a major impact on protecting wildlife habitats.
contributor to sustainable agriculture. Zero-tillage means sowing seed directly into the
XXXII
field, without first plowing to remove weeds. By leaving the soil undisturbed, more
moisture is retained, which is good for water conservation. Other indirect benefits of
zero-tillage are improved conservation of beneficial soil insects and earth worms. By
using fewer fuel powered agricultural machines, carbon dioxide emissions to the
atmosphere are decreased and fossil fuels are conserved. Less tractor traffic also causes
indirect benefits to soil quality, and hence a reduced contribution towards global
warming.
more with less. More than a third of the world’s potential crop production is lost each
year to pests, such as weeds, insects and diseases. Biotechnology and GMO crops — like
from pests, and grow more food without bringing more land into
production.
2. Enhancing Biodiversity
XXXIII
make fewer pesticide applications, which protects beneficial organisms. And better water
tillage, turning over the top layer of soil to uproot the weeds, which leaves a field open to
erosion and run-off, and releases carbon dioxide. Conservation tillage is a practice
farmers can use to till the soil less often. Advances in biotechnology, particularly the
and resulting improvements in soil health. Here’s how conservation tillage works: instead
of tilling an entire field after harvest, farmers can leave the crop’s residue in the field, and
then plant seeds directly into that residue during the next planting season. This serves as a
“mulch” for the next season’s crop and protects the soil. The result? Improved soil health.
Did you know that while you only need to drink about a
XXXIV
increases soil moisture and water retention and can reduce the need for additional
irrigation. Also, drought-resistant traits help crops withstand times of drought, mitigating
the need for intensive irrigation. Conservation tillage, made more possible by GMO
crops, but plants typically only absorb about half of the nitrogen applied to fields. Plant
researchers have been working to develop Nitrogen Use Efficient (NUE) GMO crops to
help plants more efficiently absorb fertilizers, enabling farmers to purchase and apply
There would be far less fuel emissions in the air. In 2014, 49.4
emissions were reduced by conservation tillage and decreased fuel use made possible by
GMO crops — the equivalent to removing 10 million cars from the road!
XXXV
Crop biotechnology and GMOs have significantly contributed to mitigating the
environmental effects of agriculture while preserving our natural resources. They are one
solution to combating climate change and addressing the world’s most pressing
environmental challenges.
Engineered Foods
Development of US policy
The foundation of the US regulatory system for genetically engineered foods was
laid from the mid 1980s to the early 1990s during the Reagan and Bush administrations.
The Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP 1986) and the Council on
Competitiveness (Council, 1991), both White House agencies, decided early on that GE
crops and foods would be regulated under existing statutes designed for invasive plants,
chemical pesticides and food additives, and that use of recombinant DNA techniques per
se would not trigger any special regulatory consideration. These policy directives led to
the doctrine that later became known as ‘substantial equivalence’ (for more, see below
under Food and Drug Administration). Biotech industry and government officials have
testified to the great influence exerted by industry on the formulation of this policy,
which was designed to speed transgenic crops to market, while at the same time
reassuring consumers that GE foods have passed government review. According to Henry
XXXVI
Miller, in charge of biotechnology at the FDA from 1979-1994: “In this area, the US
government agencies have done exactly what big agribusiness has asked them to do and
been authorized by the USDA. 84% overall, and 98% in 2002, have
1993 (Caplan 2003). Under this system, the crop developer fills out an application,
specifying the plant, the gene transfer method, the transformation vector, the sources of
the foreign genetic sequences, and the size and location of the field trial. USDA then
XXXVII
protein derived from the bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis. In 2003, Bt corn varieties
comprised 29% of all US corn, while 41% of US cotton contained a Bt trait (NASS,
2003). Bt potato plantings shrank from a peak of about 50,000 acres in 1998 and 1999 to
5,000 acres in 2000, due primarily to the decision of fast-food giants McDonald’s and
Burger King to source only non-Bt potatoes (EPA BRAD, 2001d, pp. I24-I25; Kilman,
2000).
fall under the “food additives” provisions of the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act
(FFDCA). Food additives must undergo extensive pre-market safety testing, including
long-term animal studies, unless they are deemed to be “generally recognized as safe”
(GRAS). The FDA has left it up to the biotech industry to decide whether or not a
transgenic protein is GRAS, and so exempt from testing (FDA Policy, 1992). The FDA
has yet to revoke an industry GRAS determination and require food additive testing of
XXXVIII
5.1: Updates About Agricultural Biotechnology
Systems and Nutrition in Asia-Pacific took place on 11-13 September 2017 in Kuala
Lumpur, Malaysia. For this meeting, FAO commissioned Research and Information
System for Developing Countries (RIS), a New Delhi-based policy research institute, to
prepare a regional background study to assess the status of application, capacities and the
enabling environment for agricultural biotechnologies in the crop, livestock, forestry and
document, entitled “The status of application, capacities and the enabling environment
for agricultural biotechnologies in the Asia-Pacific Region” has recently been published,
as well as a related 4-page policy brief entitled “Realizing the potential of agricultural
include the proceedings (organized in eight chapters covering the main highlights) of the
XXXIX
food systems and nutrition” which took place on 15-17 February 2016 at FAO
headquarters, Rome. The 2013 book entitled “Biotechnologies at work for smallholders:
Case studies from developing countries in crops, livestock and fish” which documents a
series of 19 case studies; the "Biosafety resource book", consisting of five modules,
based on materials from training courses organized by FAO from 2002 to 2010 ; and the
documents and five chapters dedicated to the outcomes) of the FAO international
and opportunities in crops, forestry, livestock, fisheries and agro-industry to face the
challenges of food insecurity and climate change" (ABDC-10), which took place in
17th Regular Session of the Commission on Genetic Resources for Food and
Agriculture
The 17th Regular Session of the Commission on Genetic Resources for Food and
Agriculture (CGRFA) took place on 18-22 February 2019 in Rome, Italy. Agenda item 4
was dedicated to “’Digital sequence information’ on genetic resources for food and
“’Digital sequence information’ on genetic resources for food and agriculture and its
relevance for food security”. It also took note of an 86-page background study paper
genetic resources for food and agriculture”, by J.A. Heinemann, D.S. Coray and D.S.
XL
Thaler. The CGRFA is an intergovernmental body established by the FAO Conference in
1983, whose Members include 178 countries and the European Union. It provides the
only permanent forum for governments to specifically discuss and negotiate matters
relevant to biological diversity for food and agriculture, including all plant, animal,
forest, aquatic, micro-organism and invertebrate genetic resources for food and
agriculture.
The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and FAO recently published the
Forster and L. Jankuloski. Following the 2nd edition which was published in 1977, this
299-page book describes advances in plant mutation breeding, including basic irradiation
propagated crops. The manual provides comprehensive overviews and guidelines for new
high-throughput screening methods - both phenotypic and genotypic - that are currently
available to enable the detection of rare and valuable mutant traits and reviews techniques
for increasing the efficiency of crop mutation breeding. It provides practical hands-on
protocols.
XLI
GM Food Safety Assessment in Bhutan
food safety assessment is ongoing in Bhutan. Officials from the Bhutan Agriculture and
"Training on genetically modified (GM) food safety assessment, risk communication and
advocacies programme" which took place on 23-27 July 2018 in Thimphu, Bhutan. A
training workshop on “GM food safety assessment: Using a real case study” also took
agriculture – Implications for health, environment and regulation” took place at the
Paris, France. The conference provided the opportunity to learn and discuss genome
editing techniques, their current development and applications in agriculture, the science-
based safety considerations associated with their use, and the status of related regulatory
XLII
5.2: The Future of Agricultural Biotechnology
prominent in the past decade. Genes were first inserted into corn using molecular
techniques in 1989, and by the late 1990s farmers were growing millions of acres of
transgenic corn. Clearly, the science of biotechnology for agriculture is in its infancy, yet
plant determine its likely environmental interactions; the fact that recombinant DNA
methods were used in its development only indirectly affects these interactions by
influencing the phenotypic characteristics of the transgenic plant. Indeed, the significance
of biotechnology for environmental risk resides primarily in the fact that a much broader
array of phenotypic traits can be incorporated into crop plants than was possible about a
decade ago. As such, our experience with the few herbicide-tolerant and insect- and
disease-resistant varieties that have been commercialized to date provides a very limited
basis for predicting questions needed to be asked when future plants with very different
XLIII
THE NEXT TRANSGENIC CROPS
expected to be commercialized in the next couple of years, others that may reach
commercial status on a midterm horizon sometime during the next decade, and others that
are mere twinkles of ideas for transgenic crops that will require research breakthroughs
before they can reach fruition. It is not possible to characterize the environmental hazards
that may be associated with all such crops in advance of knowledge about their
phenotypic characteristics and the agricultural ecology of the settings in which they will
be grown. However, the second part of this section offers a preliminary discussion of
some representative environmental risk issues that may be associated with these new
transgenic crops.
expression of an enzyme involved in fruit ripening (Kramer and Redenbaugh 1994). The
Flavr-Savr tomato was not a commercial success, but the technology was effective
because the fruit not only had a slow rate of ripening but also was less susceptible to
pathogen infection. Other early transgenic products were based on traits influencing
agronomic performance (i.e., pathogen, insect, and herbicide resistance). The rapid and
XLIV
cotton and corn attests to the commercial success of these transgenic crops (James 1998,
USDA-NASS 2001).
throughout the world are now studying a wide variety of traits/ genes that could greatly
expand the spectrum of products from such plants. As was true of the first genetically
engineered crops, the rate at which new transgenic traits can be expected to appear in the
future depends largely on the number of genes encoding them. So traits controlled by
single genes, or traits that can be reduced or eliminated by the loss of expression through
gene silencing of a single gene or group of related genes, are likely to become the first
available. The next logical step for expansion is the integration of single-gene traits.
Crops with a set of single genes for a number of distinct traits already are in use. We can
only speculate about the number of genes controlling the development and architecture of
plants and the various physiological processes impacting yield. It seems safe to assume,
though, that genetically complex traits will require additional years of research to
understand, let alone express and regulate in a genetically engineered crop species.
such as drought and salinity, flowering and reproduction, and hybrid vigor, are being
actively investigated, and it would not be surprising if some of these could be regulated in
XLV
Improved Agricultural Characteristics
Shewmaker 1999). It is estimated that damage to corn roots by this pest result in losses
approaching $1 billion annually. By reducing the impact of this pest, it is expected that
not only will there be better corn yields but also better drought tolerance and fertilizer
utilization due to the healthier root system. Research is also being done to genetically
engineer tree crops to make them resistant to insects and herbicides and to increase their
rate of growth. For example, a Bt gene has been inserted into hybrid poplars to protect
them against defoliation by a leaf beetle. Acreage of hybrid poplars has increased because
impacts that are similar in kind to the present generation of transgenic crops. Their value
accrues directly to the farmer and the seed company and only indirectly to other sectors
of society. Their potential risks, however, are borne by a wider segment of society. Thus,
risk analysis of this next generation of traits is likely to resemble present discussions and
debates about biotechnology. The evaluation of these risks is likely to become more
complicated and difficult as the range of transgenic crops expands from the major grain
crops to the more wild and perennial plants, such as pines and poplar.
XLVI
Improved Harvest Processing
tree species, including poplar, eucalyptus, aspen, sweet gum, white spruce, walnut, and
apple (Kais 2001). The global demand for wood and wood products is growing along
with the human population. To reduce pressure on existing forests, forest plantations that
grow transgenic trees are expected to play an increasingly important role in meeting the
demand for tree products (Tzfira et al. 1998). As mentioned above, the first traits being
genetically engineered into trees are herbicide tolerance and insect resistance, which are
useful for establishing and maintaining young trees. Several traits are under development
to better adapt trees to postharvest processing, and these may become commercially
available in the near future. For example, there is research under way to modify the lignin
content of certain tree species, in order to improve pulping, the process by which wood
fibers are separated to make paper. Reduced lignin may improve the efficiency of paper
production and may reduce environmental pollution from the paper production process.
To restrict the transfer of transgenic traits to wild forest and orchard tree
reproductive sterility. Methods currently exist to do this in crop plants (Mariani et al.
XLVII
likely that this issue will be investigated by a future National Research Council (NRC)
committee.
There is also interest in using genetic engineering technology to turn annual crop
plants into factories that produce valuable chemicals (for a recent review, see Somerville
and Bonetta 2001) and antibodies (Daniell et al. 2001). Plants have the capacity to
synthesize a variety of complex molecules, given the simple inputs of a few minerals,
carbon dioxide, water, and sunshine. It is widely thought that plants could provide a
petroleum. This could also be a mechanism to create new markets for plant products as
years ago (Poirier et al. 1992), but this was not found to be an economically viable
process. Nevertheless, there is excellent potential for mass producing a variety of fatty
acids in plants that serve as precursors for valuable polymers, such as nylon. The
properties of plastics that incorporate starch could also be significantly improved as more
approaches, including genetic engineering, are being applied to reduce the phytate
content of corn.
XLVIII
Improved Food Quality and Novel Products for Human Use
Corn and soybeans are two of the most important food and feed commodities in
the United States and worldwide. Most (65 to 70%) of the 9 billion to 10 billion bushels
of corn produced annually in this country are used for livestock feed; about 25% is
exported, and the remaining 10% is processed into food ingredients, nonfood coatings
and adhesives, and ethanol (Corn Refiners Association 1999). In addition, approximately
20% of the dietary calories (of people) in the United States come from lipids obtained
from plant seeds, with soybean oil accounting for about one-third of the total. By altering
the lipid, protein, and carbohydrate composition of these seeds, it may be possible to
create more nutritious food and obtain byproducts with improved functional
characteristics. Several of the transgenic products discussed below are in field trials or
Corn seed has a high caloric density because of its high starch and oil content, but
the protein it contains is deficient in several amino acids (lysine, methionine, tryptophan)
essential for swine, poultry, and human nutrition. Transgenic corn lines that contain
higher than normal levels of these amino acids and/or that produce proteins with higher
contents of these acids have been created, although they are not yet in commercial
technology, but transgenic technology is also being used to increase the quantity and
quality of corn oil. As is also true of soybean oil, the stability and nutritional value of
XLIX
corn oil could be improved by increasing the proportion of monounsaturated fatty acid,
fatty acids (linoleic and linolenic), and although these unsaturated fatty acids are
generally considered healthier to eat than the saturated fatty acids found mainly in animal
fat, they have a tendency to oxidize and become rancid. These unsaturated fatty acids are
also liquid at room temperature, which limits their functional properties for making
certain types of foods, such as margarine. The stability of soybean oil and its functional
properties are improved by hydrogenating the oil. This reduces the double bonds in the
unsaturated fatty acids have been consumed for many years, there is increasing evidence
that they are unhealthy (Taubes 2001). To address this problem, soybean was genetically
(oleic acid; Mazur et al. 1999). This was achieved through genetic engineering by
silencing the genes that produce linoleic and linolenic acid from oleic acid by a
desaturation reaction. The new product is soybean oil with approximately 85%
monounsaturated fatty acid, which has good stability, and reduced off-flavor and is
healthier to consume.
L
Appendix
LI
LII
LIII
Bibliography
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture
https://www.crystalinks.com/agriculturehistory.html.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agricultural_biotechnology
https://science.howstuffworks.com/life/genetic/agricultural-biotechnology.htm
Benefits-of-Biotechnology
LIV
Genetic engineering. (2001, October 21). Retrieved from
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_engineering
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/jun/24/genetically-engineered-animals-
the-five-controversal-science
https://biofortified.org/portfolio/crop-modification-techniques/amp/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_maize
Genetically Engineered Pigs, Earth-Friendly Poop. (2010, April 5). Retrieved from
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/genetically-engineered-pigs-earth-friendly-poop/
LV
International, C. (n.d.). Environmental Benefits. Retrieved from
http://biotechbenefits.croplife.org/impact_areas/environmental-benefits/
Answers, G. (2017, April 19). 6 Ways GMOs Make Agriculture More Environmentally
environmentally-friendly-15a9262d4f8d
http://www.centerforfoodsafety.org/files/freese_safetytestingandregulationofgeneticallye
bgineeredfoods_nov212004_62269
http://www.fao.org/biotech/biotech-news/en/
https://www.nap.edu/read/10258/chapter/9#256
LVI
Glossary
Acre - a unit in the U.S. and England equal to 43,560 square feet (4047 square meters).
Biolistics - is a method for the delivery of nucleic acid to cells by high-speed particle
pressurized gun (gene gun) to transfect cells or organelles. It can also be used to deliver
vaccines.
Bt Crops - Bt Crops are named for Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt), a bacteria that naturally
Palindromic Repeats, which are the hallmark of a bacterial defense system that forms the
Cisgenic - Describing a genetic modification in which genes from other species are not
involved.
LVII
Cloning - is the process of producing genetically identical individuals of an organism
Domesticate - to breed or train (an animal) to need and accept the care of human beings.
bacteria or other cells using a pulse of electricity to briefly open the pores in the cell
membranes.
Entrench - to place (someone or something) in a very strong position that cannot easily
be changed.
agent.
LVIII
Flavr-Savr - (also known as CGN-89564-2; pronounced "flavor saver"), a genetically
modified tomato, was the first commercially grown genetically engineered food to be
abnormalities formed in the genome. Most genetic disorders are quite rare and affect one
non-hereditary, meaning that they are passed down from the parents' genes.
of a multicellular organism.
deleting, replacing, or inserting a DNA sequence, typically with the aim of improving a
crop or farmed animal, or correcting a genetic disorder. "gene editing to date has focused
nucleic acid - Molecules that are constructed outside living cells by joining natural or
LIX
In vitro fertilization - a medical procedure whereby an egg is fertilized by sperm in a
droplets are surrounded by a coating to give small capsules, of many useful properties. In
Mono-cropping - is the agricultural practice of growing a single crop year after year on
the same land, in the absence of rotation through other crops or growing multiple crops
LX
Mulch - a protective covering (as of sawdust, compost, or paper) spread or left on the
ground to reduce evaporation, maintain even soil temperature, prevent erosion, control
Pinpoint - a tiny dot or point; absolutely precise; to the finest degree; find or locate
exactly.
giving rise to indefinitely more cells of the same type, and from which certain other kinds
Subsistence - the amount of food, money, etc., that is needed to stay alive
LXI
Substantial - large in amount, size, or number
order to make something new; to make (something) from simpler substances through a
chemical process.
product.
biological parts, devices, and systems, or to redesign systems that are already found in
nature.
biological pesticide.
reservoir to host. Vector (molecular biology), vehicle used to transfer genetic material to
a target cell, such as: Plasmid vector. T-DNA Binary system or binary vector, a cloning
LXII