Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sintering - Piezoelectric
Sintering - Piezoelectric
Sintering - Piezoelectric
LITERATURE REVIEW
from a powder processing and compacting through mould or casting which then will be
cook under high heat temperature is called piezoelectric ceramic (Levinson, 1988). The
categorization of piezoelectric ceramic comes from three main classes which are metals,
organic and inorganic which later further divided into three subcategories of ceramics,
glass and single crystal according to their macroscopic and microscopic structure
(Buchanan, 1991). The sub class categories is illustrated as shown in figure 2.1.1..
Piezoelectric materials are known to be categorized under the smart materials in which
they react to counteract the changes according to the changes of the surroundings
7
Inorganic
nonmetallic
materials
Polycrystalline
Single crystals
materials
Electronic
ceramics
Ferroelectrics
Electrooptics Piezoelectrics
density along with direction (Sen, 1992). According to Sōmiya et al. (2003), what
barium titanate, BaTiO3 when it is above 120°C, it belongs to cubic system and it has a
8
2.1.1 Barium Titanate ( BaTiO3) material ceramic
where the pure ceramic crystal has a major peak permittivity at ≈ 130℃ and 10℃ at the
(Buchanan, 1991). In early years, barium titanate has the best piezoelectric properties
piezoceramic material such as Rochelle salt(Sen, 1992). The crystal structure and polar
characteristic of BaTiO3 has high affect upon temperature exposure (Richerson, 1992).
The phase transition of BaTiO3 at different temperature is shown as the figure 2.1.1.1
below.
In the past, the properties of PZT ceramics had come to known to with its
capability to deliver stress signals to optical signals without any outside power supply
and this enables it to become the power supply for ECD and ELD (Xu, Akiyama,
9
Nonaka, & Watanabe, 1998). Lead zirconate titanate (PZT) ceramic is the most
properties (Sōmiya et al., 2003). Further explanation from Sōmiya et al. (2003), the
PZT ceramic structure able to exhibit tetragonal and rhombohedral phase through a
morphotrophic phase boundary (MPB) lines that lies between the two phases by means
(a) (b)
Figure 2.1.2.2 PZT piezoelectric ceramics application in (a) sensor and (b) actuator
10
Both lead zirconate titanate (PZT) ceramic and barium titanate (BaTiO3)
ceramic are popular and known for their good piezoelectric properties and so in table
2.1.2.1 will show the comparison between the two ceramics along with validated data
values.
𝑘𝑝 - 0.33 0.58
QM >105 - 500
Table 2.1.2.2 Advantages and disadvantages of Lead Zirconate Titanate (PZT) ceramics
Advantage(s) Disadvantage(s)
2010).
11
Unfortunately the PZT based ceramics is hazardous to human welfare and
environmental issues comes from the lead content in the PZT ceramics during its
operation which release poison lead gas, numerous research had been done in attempt to
modified bismuth had been extensively done as it has the advantage over other lead-free
materials that prominently can replace the commercial PZT ceramic such in KNN based
ceramic material with its responsive piezoelectric response and along with high Curie
(K,Na,Li)(Nb,Ta,Sb)O3 ceramics, there had been a report saying that the ceramics
commonly reported with ranges between 100 to 250-300 pC/N as compare to the
commercial PZT ceramic which has a value of 200-600 pC/N (Damjanovic, Klein, Li,
& Porokhonskyy, 2010). Palei, Pattanaik & Kumar (2012) also reported that only hot
pressed samples are able to be adequately densified since they are very delicate and
There had been plenty numbers of studies and research done to enhance the
KNN piezoelectric ceramic microstructure and its properties in which comes along in
establishment of its grain structure enabling it to almost achieve the MPB phase through
a different chemical modification alternative (Wang, Lu, Wu, Wang, & Li, 2012). There
had been lots of different procedure in various environment and in synthesizing KNN
12
ceramics as there are complications had been identified as it mainly made up of alkali
oxides which makes them volatile thus resulting less homogenous, poor densification
and phase instability (Vats & Vaish, 2014). Any sintered KNN-based ceramics is
known for its unsatisfactory density and has low sinterability because of its volatility
properties when treated under certain temperature and thus its microstructure tends to
deviate which resulting the ceramic to develop secondary phase among the grains
In order to produce a finer powder , Schey (1987) stated that the grain size
reducing process happens when the particles are in the way between colliding adjacent
solid metal or ceramic grinding media balls. A good performance and desirable
piezoelectric ceramic feature is the one with an orderly grain structure (Buchanan,
1991). Physical properties of a ceramic such as the strength, hardness and brittleness
depends highly on the grain sizes (King, 2002). Good powder preparation method will
results desired ceramics properties in terms of the size of the particle in the selected raw
13
Figure 2.2.1 Interrelation between processing, properties and microstructure
Drying of the raw material prior to mill process is the most common steps before
mixing the powders together. This process is usually done to obtain stoichiometry the
pure KNN ceramic materials. In order to achieve high dielectric constant and
piezoelectric constant, the ceramic ball milling is known for the most used method of
getting the desired particle size in which the process in categorized under mechanical
Moreover, he also states the advantage of using milling process is they are
affordable and has a vast applicability in the ceramic manufacturing industry. The
process in order to obtain an average uniform powder particle size, d50 from a raw
material ranging around 0.6 and 3𝜇𝑚 is called the milling process (Rubio-Marcos,
Romero, Martín-Gonzalez, & Fernández, 2010). Table 2.1.4.1 shows how such different
techniques comes with different milling action that works as just the same in size
reduction process
14
Table 2.2.1.1 Milling techniques with different milling action (Lee & Rainforth, 1994)
Attrition
Attrition
Ball
Impact
Planetary
Impact
Attrition is also known as turbo milling where it has capability to produce finest
along with high purity powder without existence of other impurities through a high
speed wet grinding from coarse to fine powder fraction in an intense turbulence between
the powder and milling media in the cylinder (Schwartz, 1992). Ball milling process
15
works by placing the powdered particles along with grinding ball media in a horizontal
1992). He also added that a parameter such as specific gravity, relative size and
hardness of both grinding media and the particles affects the grinding rate in ball
milling. The physical setup of planetary mill with four small and balanced mill jar on
planetary platform enables the process to take place at shorter time with immense
The impact in some milling technique can be considered as equal as crushing the
particle between the balls but the technique can wear out as the powders is milled for
certain period of time where the particles are only able to receive enough impact just to
break some each particle on their surface (Lee & Rainforth, 1994). There are two types
of milling which are wet and dry milling. According to King ( 2002), sometimes dry
milling is an alternative process performed to skip the drying process and prevent the
formation of hard clumps in the powder without presence of any liquid. As for the wet
milling, he also states that this process best practiced to obtain both coarse or fine
grained slip in the laboratory work. Table 2.2.1.2 below shows the advantages and
Table 2.2.1.2 Advantages and disadvantages of wet milling and dry milling
16
Before milling, there are some steps that need to be taken into considerations
which are the ratio of ball and the powders, the diameter of the balls and the power load
of the mill. Those are the parameters that need to be analyse and pre-determined in
If the number of balls are more than the powders, the ball will get jammed
and packed as not much movement of the powder particles. Thus, there will
When the ratio of the balls is equal to the powder amounts, the milling
If the amount of powders are more than the number of balls, the balls may
not be able to grind all the powders and thus the milling will not be efficient.
In a research journal done by Hyuno Shin, Sangwook Lee, Hyun Suk Jung,
Joon-Bong Kim where they did an experiment to study the effect of ball size and
powder loading on the milling efficiency of a laboratory-scale wet ball mill upon 10 g
of alumina powder with an average diameter of 6.0 𝜇m. They will observe the effect on
the average diameter of the powder after milled with five different zirconia balls
diameter which are 1,2,3,5 and 10 mm in polyethylene for 12 hours period with variable
rotation speed. Their experiment is done as they reduce the ball diameter from 5 mm to
17
Figure 2.2.1.1 Graph of average particle size against ball diameter at different rotation
Their experiment concluded that the optimum ball diameter decreases as the
rotation speed increases which they had performed analysis in light of the competition
between the reduced kinetic energy of the smaller diameter balls and the increased
number of contact points of the small diameter balls. From the analysis, they discovered
that the kinetic energy of the balls increases which on the other hand the optimum ball
diameter reduces. Eventually the effectiveness of the milling reduces constantly as the
powder load increases from 5 to 35 g along with the average particle size as shown in
18
Figure 2.2.1.2 Particle size distribution (a), percent passing (b), and average particle
size (c) of milled powder for varying powder loading. Ball size and rotation speed
Figure 2.2.1.3 Particle size distribution (a), percent passing (b), and average particle
size (c) of milled powder for varying powder loading. Ball size and rotation speed
19
2.2.2 Suitable powder preparation and calcination temperature for homogeneity
whether it will cause the powders to react in such ways to form coarser grain or
eliminating carbon ores, the process is called calcination ( Richerson, 1992). Sometimes
powders that had been calcined offers variety level of porosity where they often
produced during elimination of other side chemicals or impurities in the powder. (Lee &
Rainforth, 1994).
Figure 2.2.2.1 is the result of XRD pattern of KNN powders from the studies
done by Chen et al. (2011) after they had calcined their powders. Initially their studies,
they prepare their powders firstly by drying the raw materials prior to mixing at 200℃
for 2 hours in which they will be later mixed according to the stoichiometry ratio. Their
powders are then milled in planetary ball with Zirconia grinding balls ranging 3-10 mm
in diameter mixing with the powders mixed with ethanol solution for 5 hours at the
speed of 300 rev/min to be dried in an oven at 100℃ after the milling process.
They did their calcination process in a preheated alumina crucible where the
powders are divided into three batch for each will be calcined at 830℃, 850℃ and
870℃ at sintering rate of 3℃/min for 5 hours. The results shown in figure (a) is that
there are no signs of raw materials exist in the powders and only the orthorhombic
phase crystal. By them enlarging the XRD pattern between 20° and 35°, they discovered
that there are presence of secondary phase in the powders at which batch of the powders
that are sintered at 850℃ and 870℃. They concluded that the suitable calcining
temperature is 830℃.
20
Figure 2.2.2.1 (a) XRD pattern of KNN powders after calcined at 830℃, 850℃ and
870℃ (b) Enlarged XRD pattern between 20° and 35° (Chen et al., 2011)
characterizing of KNN ferroelectric ceramics near 50/50 MPB in which they obtain the
addition, their SEM characterization of sintered KNN ceramics revealed dense and
homogenous packing of grains. First of all, their raw materials were to ball milled in
21
zirconia balls separately in distilled water for 14 hours. The slurry formed were then to
be dried in an oven for 130℃ for 1 hour. In order to obtain three different stoichiometry
which are x=0.48, 0.50 and 0.52 with chemical equation of KxNa1-xNbO3, The powders
are prepared by mixing the K2CO3 and Na2CO3 with amount of stoichiometry with
distilled water through stirring until a transparent solution is formed. Nb2O5 powders
with amount of stoichiometry were then weigh and poured into the transparent solution
to be further mixed and heated. After the powders had been completely dissolved, the
solution is then next to be dried in an oven of 130℃ for 10 hours to obtain the desired
stoichiometry KNN powders. The powders then calcined at 700℃ for 6 hours. Figure
2.2.2.2 shows the XRD pattern after the powders had been calcined from which they
observed that all the sharp peaks shows that the powders had been properly prepared
22
In other research done to improve the piezoelectric and ferroelectric properties
of KNN ceramics, Na Wei, Jin Wang, Bo Li, Yu Huan and Longtu Li process their
KNN powders by two step calcination-milling in which powders undergoes milling and
Figure 2.2.2.4 (i) XRD pattern of P1 and P2 (ii) Particle size distribution of P1 and P2
23
Figure 2.2.2.5 SEM images of (a) Powder 1, P1 and (b) Powder 2, P2 (Wei et al., 2015)
From their report result shown in figure 2.2.2.5.(i), the diffraction pattern of P1
and P2 are almost the same which means that the formation of phase almost completed
in the first calcination process and they also confirmed that they are no other phase
transition occurred in the second calcination process. Most of the sharp peaks which are
very much close to each other from the figure 2.2.2.5.(ii) indicates that the particle sizes
of both powders are arranged almost close enough with other subsequent particles. The
structural difference can be visually seen from figure 2.2.2.6 through SEM images at
1𝜇m resolution.
24
Figure 2.2.2.6 (a), (b), (c), (d), is the SEM images of surface and corresponding cross-
section of SP1 and SP2; (e) & (f) is the SEM images of the polished section
Figure (a), (c) and (e) is the SEM image for sintered powder 1, SP1 and figure
(b), (d) and (f) is the SEM images for sintered powder 2, SP2. Their research concluded
that when KNN ceramics powders were sintered with twice calcining-milling yields
better piezoelectric properties where their able to obtain 96.7% relative density without
add in other sintering aids or dopants. They believe that two step calcined-milled
process had enhanced their KNN ceramic microstructure in terms of homogeneity and
25
2.3 Binders for KNN green body formation
cellulose with their properties as a deflocculants and even soluble organic wax (Sen,
1992). The flexibility and strength of a formed green body depends on the amount and
the selected binder used (King, 2002). For better densification, the selected binder
should provide good grip on the particles of the particle during green body formation
for optimum density and organized particle arrangement (Lee & Rainforth, 1994).
Table 2.3.1 List of organic components of tape-casting binder system (Richerson, 1992)
Plasticizers binder molecules; this makes the tape more pliable, e.g., polyethylene
glycol
26
2.4 Effect of sintering temperature and sintering time on grain growth and
According to King (2002) a crucial steps for development of grain growth and
for sustaining the pores in the ceramics, to is the temperature where as the temperature
increase, the grain growth increases. According to Buchanan (2003), when a dense and
porous material solid are to be placed under a certain amount of high temperature, the
grain growth. The selection of both sintering temperature and time will be made
according to the past research variables that had been done by the past researchers.
From past research study done by Du et al. (2006), their KNN ceramic samples were
calcined at 900°C and sintered at a temperature of 1100°C with various heat rate
temperature and sintering rate upon the grain microstructure of the ceramics. Their
XRD pattern result analysis shows in figure 2.4.1 proves that their powders exist in pure
perovskite phase with common orthorhombic symmetry without any other phase or
Figure 2.4.1 Result of XRD pattern upon KNN powders after calcined at 900℃ and
KNN ceramics sintered at 1110℃ with different heating rate (Du et al., 2006)
27
Through SEM micrograph in figure 2.4.1 of their samples, they had achieved
organized KNN ceramic microstructure which came out dense with good grain
boundary formation and their grain size has an average around 5 𝜇𝑚. They concluded
when heating rate done beyond 5℃/𝑚𝑖𝑛, the microstructure mainly inhomogeneous
with developed pores within the grain boundary of their samples. as shown in figure
2.4.1.
i. ii.
Figure 2.4.2 Sample sintered at 1100°C at a sintering rate of 𝟓℃⁄𝒎𝒊𝒏 (Du et al., 2006)
iii. iv.
Figure 2.4.3 Sample sintered at 1100°C at a sintering rate of 𝟔℃/𝒎𝒊𝒏 (Du et al., 2006)
28
From the findings that had been done by Vats & Vaish (2014) in attempt for
electromechanical properties in KNN ceramics, they had concluded that 1080℃ and
1120℃ to be least favourable sintering temperature. They also added that upon
sensitivity analysis, dielectric loss tangent tan 𝛿 property in the ceramics which are
Figure 2.4.4 (a) Graph relative density of KNN ceramic at different sintering
temperature (b), (c) and (d) microstructure of sintered KNN ceramics at 1075℃, 1100℃
29
In a research journal by Priya & Nahm (2013), they discuss about the
development of KNN based piezoelectric ceramics. Based on the figure 2.4.3 through
conventional sintering, the ceramic only able to obtain 91% density of theoretical
density when sintered at 1100℃. They also report about there are signs of partial melt
down and some deformation among the grains at sintering temperature of 1100℃ and
1125°C since they knew that the melting temperature KNN ceramic is around 1150°C.
30
Figure 2.4.5 Microstructures of KNN-based ceramic samples at different stages of
processing (a) calcined powders at 950°C for 180 min (b) ball-milled powder for 48 h
after calcination (c) sintered at 1,030°C, 0 min (d) sintered at 1,070°C, 0 min (e)
sintered at 1,090°C, 0 min, inset of figure (e) shows KNN specimen sintered at 1,100°C
for 0 min (f) sintered at 1,150°C, 0 min; left inset: schematic diagram (Priya & Nahm,
2013)
Figure 2.4.5.c shows that there are liquid phase present in the KNN ceramics
after it is sintered at the range of 950℃ - 1060℃ and which the authors had mentioned
that the presence of liquid phase is important since it affects the densification of the
KNN based ceramics. It is to be said that good grain arrangement can be more develop
if liquid phase exist at the grain boundaries as it assist the movement of the grains
31
which also helps in reducing porosity in the ceramics. At temperature 1090℃ and
Figure 2.4.6 Density of KNN ceramics at different sintering temperature (Priya &
Nahm, 2013).
From the graph plotted by the author, there result of are almost the same as the
one reported in the case of liquid-assisted sintering which the results shows uniform
microstructure at the grain boundaries. Pure KNN ceramics has maximum density
roughly above 4.0 g/cm3 at sintering temperature between 1130℃ and 1140℃.
32
Figure 2.4.7 FEG-SEM analysis on KNN ceramics sintered at (a) 1050℃ (b) 1100℃
(2014), they had their ceramics sintered at 1050℃, 1100℃ and 1150℃ for two hours
through conventional sintering after being calcined at 800℃ with aims to study the
properties of the KNN ceramic. Since their ceramics were synthesized by colloidal
coating method where sintering them under 1100℃ gives them the best compromising
results. They obtain 92% of 𝜌th density where this means the ceramic develops good
microstructure. It is shown in the figure 2.4.3.(b) that there are less porosity formed and
the grains are in well mannered position. Table 2.3.1 below shows the density, Tporosity,
33
Table 2.4.1 Results of density, 𝜀 observed and 𝜀 corrected to obtain 𝜀′max of different
2.5 Summary
grain growth in the ceramic, good powder preparation and optimum sintering
crystallization. For milling process, parameters such as ball diameter, number of balls
used and ratio between the powder and the ball must be first pre-determined before
proceed with the process for effectiveness as well. It is better to have average ball small
diameter ball with 2 to 3 mm with average 153 rpm based on the findings done by Shin
et al. (2013).
Finer particle sized powders enables the particles to have more compact
ceramics by which means there will be less porosity and better densification when it is
later to be sintered at high temperature. For grain size reduction, planetary milling is
better as it can get the milling process done with liquid within a short time. Better
powder homogeneity greatly affects the piezoelectric properties of the ceramics. The
preparation. From the previous study above, the optimum calcining temperature is
ranging around 830℃ with sintering rate of 3 ℃/𝑚𝑖𝑛 for 5 hours done by Chen et al.,
34
(2011). Binders that will be used must be selected according to its suitable chemical
properties which will not cause the green body come being too stiff. The amount of the
binders should not be too much nor too little either the slurry mixture may took longer
time to sintered to eliminate the binder or it may not enough to aid particle movement
35