Stanzas :
Word a and Phantasm
in| Western Culture
Giorgio Agamben
Translated by Ronald L. Martinez.
ot 9, he ker of Pars: Bae 718 he 2
vole nace engi of Tony ss 71. me 2 Fhsiy sa Tis of Caatne Vom
ese i mi i ta rr a ae aaa iterature,
Yotme 6, east he ager Peete
‘shoe ei woe tae
me er ale Sci 807-5
University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis and Londonep 1 He Rg a ety eM
ity ora Se Lae en mar ts Ce AE
Meare. Nope ptm ei tn ae ye
Sot uy tomes see eh ag we
‘Shonen ae oro po epee
sy any tne
some
Se em rterentn/teiemin
Eo ae wna on
Sane eee
‘mete cc ant
In memoriam Martin Heidegger‘Ant ere ne mast hs erm sae) as Ben
‘hen or ecialraoecae 0 hcntal
‘heer at ofthe coon sdb alle ana, han
clus veg or espace or the ene cet Fort
she canzone the coer tral lop o ob) of
seta 0 the vnc el teesContents
ist oe tions
ote and Ackles
Intodueton x
1. The Phat of rot
‘the Noon Demon 3
‘elnchole ot 16
‘he Los Objet 19
‘The Phnom of ge 22
1, tne War of Odrades The Work a Are
‘Canned it the Crm
6, Fron Ps Ames Ost 3
1 Mrs The User Esperiion 36
ew Brome The Apropo ot Ueaty 47
Mine Pnckost: Tae Ty ary 36
“The Wr andthe Phuntaan The They ofthe Phono
in the Lane Petry f the Peto
1. Nacsa an Pygmaioe 6
12 Err atthe Mir
10, Spt pharteus 90te
i
Sie of Love 192
Between Nac and Pyaion 141
They Tat Never Ene 124
IN. The ererse Inge: Senn fom
the Plat of Vi of the Spon
ipa athe Sphinx 138
‘he oer ed te ope
‘The Bar an he Fd 2
eg 130
Illustrations
1, Dor, Melee
2 Veer to) in Osi Arins Nii, De scission tn
she
2. Rates, Herts ao Melo, Mai, Pra,
‘wea gson of Loedon, SL
61. Gant, Hato fo intr mde (Antes wo,
1 Gani, me cd rir Theater Few), ra mn
‘ay moi.
9. Grae, ston fm Petter mise de a vie humane (sal
srs o ora
‘io Brame.
gare imine of chic Cine wb
“he Leer tthe amo of Riis (1259, fa, 120). ai Bi
teteqe Raton
Norns Me fe 1259, fo. 120). Paci,Milhique Nate
Prgmation at Malar (MS. Douce 195, fl 194), Oxted, Boden
‘ater.
16, Pomalion and de Image(s. Bowe 198 fl. 10). Oxf, Baan
Liar.
"ea Pmt 1972 2). a
18, The Lover an the fae MS 38710 146).
iBonhige Nation:18, Venta se Image Ms 387 144) Yes
2. Vows and the mage (ef 580, fl 1359), Pais, ba Now|
te
21 The Laver, he ge an te Rose M387, f. 15). ae
22 "Folanrar dl, tal from he et siete na prt
{Cathal of Note Dae, Pat,
2, Los Ilr, ih sae 8 the Miser Sn Matin,
Pe Lowe
24.28 Tons Ma The Fre Wook fo Oi Apel Ni, De
‘srs Agora nes, 157,
26, What Gre, Delights nb C0, Protease, 1627
BY Low the Fae of Beane, fen Ca, Proves
Notes and Acknowledgments
‘Thee “The Phen En appear na sxe vero i Parone
(ag 197. Th rina mses of "In the Wed of Oto an pit
Ss the ye fic (Th day ao he fh ae
Foy 1972).
"The speings “phantom, “eas and “pana” Crh he
wc nee the etal pace wea the ers
‘omsons da ate wx dct 2 plished Eagis-anguage soace
ty be ued 0 be the ators oa
"The shoe wines thank rans Yates fhe Witbry osie of Led,
nko cours ma pose for im to pore ech the ary
Tritt: Hes thnks he erst te ii Roe Pa
hd Pros lof he Cae fd of he Weary ofthe Academie Nac
sede it
alae sitaoe wih te astonIntroduction:
‘isp, pesp, nacht nel sy neve actly reso the try
{tu omic ntl. Bur common tn cng vl nko icin,
aes argbl pions sys, ky hypothess Ye! when
tem "rk apie In the veal of Ween pny gies
tater guy ce nits foe ut pecs at which cn en
te pol or gape rin, mr ites he eto thr
{poe of "re amelie el nar ha eck! thin
‘moable Pons.” fs bs rein open to he Fain ato
Sls es sx that de ior eee oman vente
ows nat a to rare ey ever ig me
“Tse Jaa gp, which atenyed eh he ret of 2 “enversl
propemive pty 0 aul he diction pty and he res
Finnie, nite wort worthy of tne aoe at nde
Slay nt cd mot ents The ers he Ean rie a te
[reser cnr pos meson sa pete eving asa work ay
1S very absence moet comple” that of Ten Ten, cell gl
lence the who ences) tre sey Soaking pts aly a sgl ok
desert be led ea he Lng de detache ner! Te
‘gin of Gera ape dea) a We Benj
‘Neer sgn oh ection of sh ers hiking i th arg se
sho tay dae i ary mre fs fo th me ran ee oe
‘any wh rock te eae chase of cca —pecicly when heave fr wae ne rename al pce mt resi. he Ker of “ha
oetanterte” (pte aa ties) apple rhe fst tei ag
[ihe Alscnian pot iso Pl, may ce sin eve a an het
Bly dt of he er rt, an eco oy tly Mens
The work of wt fie meanest Tlf faa era.” at a)
Irs iia ha rm fea Cal tg at
fan the proceso ou ina stig: pely a "ani
fething oxen at steess” went w Heel pote,
tiled dfnon, Hep csto, eat "Mer rec Yom Selege
Sole Noval un te hortistns of fny veined tle tale
int epaulets are"
tre pine ot" marsing "the unespse he Bt ig,” ee
hist he ney of oy a he poss esa 9 ect,
Iie he ge man sn lho) is als akeady the at of
Tandon to nv bt tet and cole nett ta dos
‘fra, roo vag Te mth poste sein pb
‘Spb and ste ohh spoil a eel peta Id a
es puis, ng eer hing) are fs oman wry rece wh
the Seeger ob pete fn et of the spect fr gig
‘cal foto pte Ma scces. For i the a hes so
‘ht object ners been ened tho the es fm cence itech
it pt pron ut erage he mses ak ta ea
uted otha it on in. Wet ht re od ee feet ceed
yen sharpening kaon bal ress ih hing
‘casey the eatin that the cbt fae Been are a aly
‘rodney cia i om speci cee
ter Sexi cliptenme het rot poe lcm oes ot ae
‘Seis sige. Like al thee qu, he gues fein cna at
‘Seoerng ts jet hatin aig the Sern nen.
‘copes post f the hirenth cnt called he seal mes fi yo
say the on hat 4 eapius den, eel bec te
[ud lan thal fra ment th cate, oo that
these pot crane opty ts neo But Wit abject To
tat eject does poy ge estan a th reap wom oF
‘ie a What he nobus econo?
Accesso i pebematie tes qustogs bared by th frst
o¢acsog ta dees om be rig af a cle ad ht stall
ee the est stra og Du os ees, wins saying—when|
Inc the omy thing lyr erin Ta oem action
'nd pibsopy, between the pete word tnd he word of
yaaa or cola ion tha at col
‘ey declare "a ance." acre accep ha ey in
ily one inh oi ee of pty Bt adem
Sowtied a teenoaie haere so ofthe wod ls coneect meae
Shr pet pases objet tt sing tw pg Kno
‘je wiht possessing Inte Wes, he wn ssid between ond
tht is nsware i fen hy enjoys th es hae 9
repressing in bene rs wer th a al aos td co
‘sts for ielbat es no coy is objet sae tds nat Eno
“The i benween pocky and piouphy eis tHe iii, or
‘ser ele, of tly pss th oes themed arte poe
Snoeledge 1 ple of pss, al evry pom of pose
from noice Ino ere. bree ard
fg an stiomy that Ay Waters ape oe "ren of Wo
cate vie Renee spect and roracomtns pole,
tet eve seceding wy Teng er na ey
oer hve sel ace avn, pier a nel ctor
opr, si the cul ea eal ol 0 Na ee th
Ihelem fi rpeettn, ah pty as deve th 9 mt ot
Sei-consouss, What tsk et at ey ate ore
Poste este ard ele, tase) tet sy
Sve eaed wa Te nrc HOLrin of apts oom
Peety was ahve pronatendwbo ten ped wee a 0
the level he macho (ecient) these so te
eines old eke a eta he og tw wer
‘bege thnke who ont desates i om en wth hee
"peop" ae mole hte owt te warn. fr ural, ei
coinguy of or om agen wor.
‘ila tbr theme en te eo ah exon
is ced where Western are he mor comes nga or ale a
ins ea ree fh eps. ma itary st rte
Serace, From te one sition of conan he eee he
fers acto wich ik resents re at Ko
‘set opin nit cons a oe
tenant ei pins the nyt of what ere posed and
the pression of wt eat be ene In thi way cian ines he
Precept of Omg: "Sch wiht omen ahi at of
Hsu” Wit sce nh ocr fice ig iting
‘ae approaiy a set snes ps,
Inte ftiowing pus, we wil purse mee ftw oer such
ite stn ic nh be Yogesh thee
‘se eer in which dst sinned ts is
‘lt oats ince it lien wih sone a hese Wohave teen vet to appropiate o xy. The he med a as po
‘ety, alfresco aor ho aay emblems on
tn hes (oro) ofthe Sins, nl iin that wg ce the
Isinavion of sgt and pitied hat dines Weer rele
om tis pensive, rec rp be rp ning fhe
fh pret ity th recent of he hy of he Pa
I saben he aie pec oct hel by trad Ss
‘vit Ile 0 Eun culoe am!) whic, deh the dee text
‘ebescanon Geri erwin) panto, desea nord ety
Eons som hry Romig ll, he ele thee
Tes joy gee man fn) fens esperience
ch ofthe eye pte here hs ces, iin hermetic cre,
lop of op aio, ofthe sae ah Wi te amas pe
‘pos od impose ak of apropratng what asin every cab esi
Ahonen pth he ane the hy, adn nthe heart of
‘ton toot distance, isthe stl eel rote of aman tr and
ropa maaan hao) tod ol foe whic aly do ln
re thio of vew cue a eae ato eld "acu a
‘end exacts eesti ol a ecko" omer tha an
fe ths gv nt sng nt ecw arate tps
fb. Tihs hes ih pest i objet eer ae mas
{erwin snp neat the act of enjopment ne Ie he le wo wos
‘ih anor it he eral of ei: perio er, |
lites tv, fomor hat once eye and ee, opis an ae,
‘Sect ant repels an ony aly te ewe won "qa
Traum ear ee Bo bose cna set (hat hep ap |
rene Fn hes hs re a win ait thee (Aa
ani camo "En cet set cola eer” ws 44-5)
From his vantage one can pak of tpoly oh mel gs th os,
TorAistoe "fica 6 wasp bt he power sarees ad ee
‘Sehr aml which nthe Sop, secs ae "hid gem
ine, nt esr omen ea i ene a ake ses Be
sen ta fre ps nh orth ook i Pls "Whee eh
stg eet sp?” or xt restos Re pine The awe 0
ese nowt pers coy cas he rm in estinn e then
Ssver poi We mut el enone urcves to i of he “ple” ta
Sothing pt bet «thing oil han ss. Pee, long
Pinto’ sugesin, we sould nk of as pre lcs eee vente
In certain see te Only aksptieatpngy. aaa co at
Ios defies a an ts sms ox 8) 5 pon
i gets (nis of mail) wos te equ te
‘utp, he plas place woe emer Kn we he te
thes pgs The pt atone cmsany ene the at
sit ota ne
is one yy ital pot pity ly ioe ep at
ring inelain sito nd msc aesc et
{Ne art er a epee me eke
ist, ate flow wae te poe ta Reet Nast
essa whl wea peta fen spiny wes
SE; melee hh "Wei be ly