Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Caregiver Perception of Music Therapy PDF
Caregiver Perception of Music Therapy PDF
Abstract
Background: Despite pharmacological and psychosocial support, pediatric blood and marrow transplant (BMT) recipients
typically experience heightened levels of somatic and psychological distress while undergoing transplant. Although clinicians
have used psychosocial interventions to target distress, there are gaps in the literature concerning music therapy for children
recovering from BMT. This is especially the case among younger children and those affected by rare genetic or metabolic
disorders.
Objective: As caregivers are the primary decision makers for minor children, there is a need to understand their prefer-
ences and values as this constitutes a component of evidence-informed practice. Therefore, the purpose of this interpretivist
investigation was to explore primary caregivers’ perspectives and experiences with music therapy for their children during
hospitalization for BMT.
Methods: The researchers conducted semistructured phone interviews with 15 primary caregivers of children who had
received music therapy services while hospitalized for BMT. Member checking was used to ensure accuracy of the transcripts
and experiences, while trustworthiness was used to verify themes.
Results: Fifteen caregivers of 14 pediatric BMT recipients were interviewed by phone. The following four themes emerged:
(1) music therapy motivated patients to physically engage their bodies despite symptoms; (2) music therapy elevated patients’
moods; (3) caregivers benefited from seeing their child engaged in music therapy; and (4) caregivers were appreciative for the
opportunity and requested additional music therapy services.
Conclusions: Caregivers perceived music therapy to be a positive and beneficial experience for pediatric patients while
hospitalized for BMT. Implications for clinical practice, limitations, and suggestions for future research are provided.
Keywords
pediatrics, blood and marrow transplant, caregivers, experiences, integrative, music therapy
Received March 1, 2018. Received revised June 7, 2018. Accepted for publication June 12, 2018
Introduction
Pediatric blood and marrow transplant (BMT) recipients
experience significant emotional and somatic distress 1
Masonic Children’s Hospital, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis,
related to transplant, which may impact functioning for
Minnesota
years following BMT.1–5 Nonpharmacological interven- 2
Earl E. Bakken Center for Spirituality and Healing, University of Minnesota,
tions targeting distress following BMT can include Minneapolis, Minnesota
humor therapy,1,6,7 massage therapy,1,6,7 and music ther- 3
School of Music, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
apy.8 Due to the high involvement levels of caregivers of Corresponding Author:
pediatric BMT recipients, caregivers often function as Greta J Yates, 2512 S 7th Street, Minneapolis, MN 55454, USA.
advocates and decisions makers for their children, and Email: Gyates1@fairview.org
Creative Commons CC-BY: This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License (http://www.crea-
tivecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) which permits any use, reproduction and distribution of the work without further permission provided the
original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access pages (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/open-access-at-sage).
2 Global Advances in Health and Medicine
there is a need to understand their perspectives and communication during the most acute phase of trans-
experiences with nonpharmacological interventions such plant, more intensive treatments, and the child’s
as music therapy. In understanding caregiver preferences cognitive, behavioral, and social functioning predicted
and experiences, music therapists can be better equipped lower quality of life ratings.4,13,14 Pediatric oncology
to advocate, meet the needs, and provide better quality programs may offer a variety of nonpharmacological
services to children and their caregivers. As patient values interventions, including acupuncture, aromatherapy,
and preferences constitute an integral component of evi- massage, music therapy, and supplements, as part of
dence-informed practice, caregivers can represent an their standard of care.15 The contemporary literature
extension of their children as the primary decision base suggests that nonpharmacological interventions,
maker and may provide valuable insights into their chil- such as music therapy, may lessen emotional and somatic
dren’s values and experiences. Therefore, the purpose of distress post BMT.1,2,8,16
this interpretivist investigation was to explore primary Music therapy is the ‘‘use of music interventions to
caregivers’ perspectives and experiences with music ther- accomplish individualized goals within a therapeutic
apy for their children during hospitalization for BMT. relationship by a credentialed professional who has com-
pleted an approved music therapy program.’’17 Among
the 7642 board-certified music therapists represented
Literature Review globally in 2017, it is estimated that approximately
In 2014, there were over 21,000 pediatric and adult BMTs 10% of therapists are employed within pediatric hos-
in the United States.9 Side effects of treatment and the pitals.18 Music therapy is a professional field consisting
standard confinement to a HEPA air filtration room to of a plethora interventions based on the individual
prevent infection can make BMT a stressful event for assessment and strengths of each patient. BMT music
pediatric BMT patients and their caregivers.1–4 therapists emphasize the importance of rapport and
Although some BMTs are curative treatments, others flexibility through various interventions to promote
aim to halt disease progression, decrease symptom structure, autonomy, and engagement to provide an
burden, and enhance quality of life. Depending on the opportunity for expression that may result in enhanced
diagnosis, patients will receive an autologous transplant coping skills and recovery.8,16,19–21 As the number of
of their own cells or an allogenic transplant harvested music therapists grows and services expand to broader
from umbilical cord blood or a donor following 7 to 10 patient populations, there is a need for ongoing research
days of preparative conditioning regimen of myeloabla- regarding if and how music therapy can enhance quality
tive chemotherapy and/or radiation specific to their dis- of care and delivery of clinical services.
ease.10 Common adverse effects of transplant include Music therapy can serve a variety of psychosocial
mucositis, pain, nausea and vomiting, insomnia, physical functions depending on the context and the individual’s
deconditioning, infection, and bleeding.11 Symptom needs. For example, music therapists can help an indi-
burden and side effects of treatment range in intensity vidual work through conflict, lead to insightful reflection
depending on the type of transplant and the preparative of an event, or simply invoke pleasure.22 Studies on
conditioning regimen. Allogeneic BMTs typically result patients with cancer have shown that music therapy
in greater symptom burden and longer length of hospital interventions, including listening to live preferred
stay. Symptoms typically begin to alleviate following music, have physiological benefits of decreasing pain,
white blood cell count recovery, referred to as engraft- heart rate, respiratory rate, and blood pressure.23,24 In
ment. BMT recipients are hospitalized for preparative child-focused interventions including songwriting,
conditioning and are not discharged until white blood improvisation, singing, and instrument play, music ther-
cell recovery is achieved, typically 14 to 28 days after apy increased child attention, affect, and autonomy as
transplant. Children are hospitalized for approximately well as social integration and overall self-concept.8,25,26
4 to 6 weeks for the initial BMT stay. BMT-related com- Within a BMT population with cancer, adolescents and
plications within the first 100 days are common and may young adults (AYAs) participated in songwriting lyrics
result in readmissions and frequent clinic appointments.10 and melody and then created a music video of their
BMT hospitalization and the standard confinement to composed song set to preferred photos. Participants
a HEPA air filtration room to prevent infection often experienced improved courageous coping and parents
cause increased stress and anxiety to pediatric patients found enhanced understanding of the AYA’s emotions
and their caregivers that peaks during preparative con- and connectedness with the child through listening to the
ditioning and often does not return to baseline until composed lyrics and observing their child’s responses.8,21
6 months posttransplant.1–5,12 However, many pediatric Although music therapy can be beneficial for AYAs
BMT recipients report continued anxiety and feelings of undergoing BMT for cancer diagnoses, there is a lack of
vulnerability during survivorship.5 Compromised emo- research pertaining to music therapy with children under
tional functioning, high levels of worry, reduced the age of 12 or among children undergoing BMT for
Yates et al. 3
times of increased symptom burden, but caregivers noted On average, patients received music therapy 2 times a
that it also elevated their child’s mood. Music therapy week while hospitalized. BMT requires a long isolating
provided patients and their families the opportunity to hospital stay, which precludes participation in hospital-
engage in a more typical childhood experience that was wide activities for patients. Therefore, participants noted
perceived as enjoyable despite being hospitalized. that the need for stimulation and engagement is impera-
Caregivers described music therapy as a ‘‘highlight’’ of tive. As such, caregivers requested additional music ther-
the hospitalization that the patients looked forward to apy services for their child, not only due to isolation, but
despite symptoms. Music therapy provided the oppor- also for the child’s enjoyment, quality of life, and level of
tunity to ‘‘reset’’ a child’s day and redirect them from engagement in music therapy.
pain, nausea, fatigue, or unpleasant procedures by creat-
ing a calm and engaging environment. Now that we’re back in our apartment, we sing. We
dance. It made singing fun again... It brought music
I think it was always, no matter how she was feeling, it back to us. We will forever be grateful that she came
was always a little bit of an escape for her... It got her to to see us... Sometimes, it’s hard to know, I would have
a different place I think. It got her to someplace else. It even said, ‘‘She could come in every day.’’ I know that’s
snapped her out of the funk she was in or whatever... not fair. I know there’s other little boys and girls and
A lot of times it felt like a reset button. It was changing there is only one of her. It’s hard, but it would have been
course of our day... It would just shift her mood in to a nice to see her more. She was just so happy when she was
different direction. (Participant 6) there. (Participant 12)
existing literature concerning the impact of music ther- pediatric BMT and integrative health. Thus, it would
apy on decreasing pain, heart rate, respiratory rate, and be impossible to separate these clinical experiences
blood pressure are congruent.23,24 from the researchers’ way of knowing, interpreting,
Music therapy also provided patients and their care- and understanding the data.
givers the normalizing opportunity to engage in a typical
childhood experience and something to look forward to
Suggestions for Future Research
when the patient was immunocompromised and isolated
in their room. This finding is consistent with previous Given the lack of research with this population, care-
music therapy literature where children experienced givers’ perceptions of music therapy and its benefits are
increased autonomy and improved social integration encouraging about its effects on patients and their care-
and affect.8,25,26 Music therapy also provided the oppor- givers throughout their transplant. This study supports
tunity for caregiver respite and self-care, so caregivers the continued use of music therapy with this population
were not always present during the session. Regardless and pursuit of expanding opportunities for patients and
of their participation or presence, all caregivers families throughout BMT recovery. Research exploring
commented that music therapy enhanced their experi- pediatric patients’ perceptions and the specific effects of
ence during hospitalization even though music therapy music therapy interventions, especially on symptoms and
interventions were directed at their child. psychosocial well-being, is warranted. Future work
should attempt to measure the benefits of music therapy
from the perspective of children less than 12 years of age
Implications for Clinical Practice and further explore the benefits of music therapy on
Results suggested that music therapy was perceived to be physical activity and conditioning among children after
a beneficial and positive experience for pediatric patients BMT. Related to the results of the current investigation,
and their caregivers while hospitalized after BMT. additional research is needed to understand the impact of
As BMT patients are typically hospitalized for longer music therapy on physical and developmental decondi-
durations, unable to participate in hospital wide services tioning that is experienced after a child’s BMT.
due to the standard confinement to prevent infection, Objectivist research with randomization, control
and experience immense symptom burden, it is reason- groups, established psychometric instruments to measure
able to consider that BMT patients should receive psychologic distress and symptom burden, and follow-up
frequent nonpharmacological interventions. Caregivers to determine potential maintenance of treatment gains is
recommended scheduling music therapy services more also necessary to gain a more holistic understanding of
regularly to further enhance the hospital stay and pro- how music therapy might impact BMT patients and
mote the child’s physical activity and mood. Participants caregivers.
spoke positively concerning the music therapist’s flexibil-
ity and ability to work with their child throughout BMT,
regardless of their child’s ability to engage in sessions or
Conclusion
severity of symptoms. The importance of a music The purpose of this interpretivist investigation was to
therapist’s flexibility and scheduling has also been explore primary caregivers’ perspectives and experiences
emphasized by other music therapists working within with music therapy for their children during hospitaliza-
pediatric oncology and BMT.19–21 tion for BMT. This study adds to the literature base
and indicates that music therapy can be a beneficial psy-
chosocial treatment modality for all pediatric BMT
Limitations recipients, regardless of age or diagnoses. This study
Limitations of this study included the interviews being highlights the importance of music therapy in minimizing
conducted by phone and occurring while the caregiver the effects of isolation, negative mood, decreased activ-
was home with their child. Caring for BMT patients after ity, and enhancing normalization of childhood experi-
discharge is stressful and time consuming and requires ences during BMT recovery. Music therapy is valued
many clinic appointments a week. Caregivers were not by caregivers to help mitigate the physical challenges of
always able to talk at length with the interviewer due to BMT and promote both the caregiver and child’s psy-
the extensive needs of their child. Interviews conducted chosocial well-being.
in person without the presence of the child may have
resulted in longer and deeper conversations with care- Acknowledgments
givers. In addition, male caregivers are underrepresented The authors are grateful for the support from John Wagner,
in the sample or research participants. Finally, results of MD, executive medical director of the pediatric BMT program,
this interpretivist study are limited by the makeup of the Children’s Cancer Research Fund and the NVIDIA
research team, which was composed of experts within Foundation, and the staff of the pediatric BMT unit.
Yates et al. 7
27. Braun V, Clarke V. Using thematic analysis in psychology. 29. White AC, Terrin N, Miller KB, Ryan HF. Impaired
Qual Res Psychol. 2006;3(2):77–101. respiratory and skeletal muscle strength in patients prior
28. Romeyke T, Noehammer E, Scheuer HC, Stummer H. to hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation. Chest. 2005;
Levels of patient satisfaction on integrative medicine 128(1):145–152.
before and after implementation of diagnosis-related
groups. Glob Adv Health Med. 2018;7:2164956118759256.