Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal APM
Jurnal APM
Jurnal APM
Abstract
Aim: The study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of antenatal perineal massage (APM) in reducing peri-
neal trauma and post-partum morbidities.
Methods: A randomized controlled trial of 108 primigravidae at the University of Nigeria Teaching Hospi-
tal, Enugu, Nigeria, was conducted from January 2013 to May 2014. The intervention group received APM,
while the control group did not receive APM.
Results: Women who received APM were significantly more likely to have an intact perineum after child-
birth [27/53 (50.9%) vs 16/55 (29.1%); RR: 1.75; 95% CI: 1.07–2.86; P = 0.02]. The incidence of episiotomy
was lower in the intervention group [20/53 (37.7%) vs 32/55 (58.2%); RR: 0.65; 95% CI: 0.43–0.98; P = 0.03;
NNT = 5]. Women who received APM were significantly less likely to develop flatus incontinence [4/53
(8.3%) vs 13/55 (26.0%); RR: 0.32; 95% CI: 0.11–0.91; P = 0.03]. However, the incidences of premature rup-
ture of membranes, preterm labor and birth asphyxia were similar between the two groups (P > 0.05).
Conclusion: APM reduces the incidence of episiotomy and increases the incidence of women with an intact
perineum after vaginal delivery. It also reduces the risk of flatus incontinence after childbirth without
increased maternal or neonatal complications. Women should therefore be counseled on the likely benefits
of APM and the information provided during antenatal care. Obstetricians should consider the technique as
routine prenatal care for nulliparous women so as to reduce the incidence of perineal trauma during vaginal
birth.
Key words: antenatal perineal massage, episiotomy, flatus incontinence, perineal trauma, post-partum
morbidities.
operative vaginal deliveries, among others.4–7 Antena- UNTH, Enugu (UNTH/CSA.329/VOL.5; Approval
tal perineal massage (APM) is thought to improve date: 28 December 2012).
perineal outcomes by stretching out the vaginal tis- The minimum sample size (n) for each group was
sues, promoting perineal relaxation and improving calculated to be 61 based on a power of 80, 5% error
circulation to the tissues.8 The overall effect of all margin and an estimated attrition rate of 20%.
these methods is that the parturient is able to ‘push Participants’ randomization was adapted from a recent
her baby out’ more easily, thus reducing the risk of study.12 The randomization of participants was accom-
trauma to her perineum and vagina.9 plished using a computer-based random sequence gener-
Despite the anticipated favorable effects of APM on ator (RANDOM.ORG) developed by a blinded
pregnancy outcome, there is a paucity of research pre- statistician. Sealed opaque envelopes were labeled
senting sound evidence on which to base clinical prac- sequentially from 1 to 122; each numbered envelope con-
tice. According to a recent Cochrane systematic tained a 5 × 9 ×5 cm white paper labeled either ‘A’ for
review on APM for reducing perineal trauma, only intervention group or ‘B’ for control group based on the
one of four studies included in the review examined randomization. The envelopes were given to a medical
the incidence of UI and AI after childbirth.10 It was intern (third party), blinded to the study’s objectives. The
concluded in the review that limited data currently serial numbers 1–122 were consecutively assigned to the
exist on the effects of APM on these conditions.10 Fur- participants as they were being recruited. Participants
thermore, none of the studies included in the randomized to receive APM were asked to perform
Cochrane review was from sub-Saharan Africa where 10 min of daily APM starting from 34–36 weeks of gesta-
the burden of perineal trauma is high because of the tional age (GA) until the delivery of the baby. However,
high fertility rate in the subregion and the aversion to they were asked to discontinue APM should they
caesarean section. A recent study from the subregion develop PROM and to present to the hospital for man-
has also documented a high incidence of UI and AI agement. They were also asked to maintain daily records
following vaginal birth.11 of the performance of the APM in a diary. The massage
This study therefore aims to evaluate the effective- was conducted by inserting the thumb and index finger,
ness of APM in preventing perineal trauma during with or without middle finger, 3–5 cm into the vagina
childbirth and reducing subsequent post-partum mor- either by the pregnant woman herself or by her husband
bidities in Nigeria. and then sweeping downward and sideways using a KY
jelly for lubrication until she feels a burning, tingling or
stinging sensation, after which she holds her thumb
Methods steady on her perineum until the area feels numb. The
first episode of the massage was carried out in the ANC
The study was a randomized controlled trial of primi- under supervision, and the procedure was reinforced at
gravida women attending the antenatal clinic (ANC) each antenatal visit. Thereafter, the procedure was under-
of the University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital taken at least once a day at her convenience and at a reg-
(UNTH), Ituku/Ozalla, Enugu, Nigeria, between ular period of time. The participants were telephoned at
1 January 2013 and 31 May 2014. Eligible women interval of 1 week to reinforce compliance. They were
were randomized to either the intervention group also asked to give a call at the onset of labor and then to
(A) or control group (B). The intervention group present immediately to the hospital’s labor ward for their
received APM, while the control group did not deliveries. Following delivery, the labor outcomes were
receive APM. All primigravidae with uncomplicated collected, including incidence of spontaneous perineal
singleton pregnancies in cephalic presentations, at tears (SPT) of any degree and the incidence of episiot-
34–36 weeks gestation, without uterine contractions, omy. The obstetrics care providers were blinded to the
were eligible for the study. Exclusion criteria were participants’ study groups. Upon discharge from hospital
being unsure of date, evidence of any contraindica- after delivery, the participants were followed up at
tions to vaginal delivery, medical diseases in preg- 6 weeks and at 3 months to access for any developments
nancy, vaginal herpes or thrush and premature of UI and/or AI. The AI could be flatus incontinence
rupture of membranes (PROM). Written informed and/or fecal incontinence (FI). Participants’ baseline data
consent was obtained from all eligible women before that were recorded included maternal age, GA at recruit-
recruitment. Ethical clearance for the study was ment and GA at delivery. In order to minimize loss to fol-
obtained from the Institutional Review Board of the low up, participants’ phone numbers and home
Randomized
n = 122
Analyzed Analyzed
Table 2 Association between perineal trauma and antenatal perineal massage after labor
Intervention (n = 53) Control (n = 55) RR CI for RR P value
Rate of episiotomy 20 (37.7%) 32 (58.2%) 0.65 0.43–0.98 0.03
Rate of intact perineum 27 (50.9%) 16 (29.1%) 1.75 1.07–2.86 0.02
Rate of perineal tear
First degree 6 (11.3%) 5 (9.1%) 1.25 0.40–3.84 0.70
Second degree 0 (0.0%) 2 (3.6%) 0.21 0.01–4.22 0.50
Specific location of tears
Lateral 3 (5.7%) 2 (3.6%) 1.55 0.27–8.95 0.59
Posterior 3 (5.7%) 5 (9.1%) 0.62 0.16–2.48 0.41
χ 2 or Fisher’s exact test for categorical variables.
Table 3 Association between antenatal perineal massage and certain maternal and neonatal complications
Intervention (n = 53) Control (n = 55) P value
PROM
Yes 3 (5.7%) 7 (12.7%) 0.32
No 50 (94.3%) 48 (87.3%)
Preterm labor
Yes 3 (5.7%) 2 (3.6%) 0.68
No 50 (94.3%) 53 (94.4%)
Maternal UTI
Yes 2 (3.8%) 1 (1.8%) 0.61
No 51 (96.2%) 54 (98.2%)
Neonatal birthweight 3.14 0.42 3.09 0.52 0.58
APGAR score
<7 at 5 min 8 (15.1%) 6 (10.9%) 0.52
≥7 at 5 min 45 (84.9%) 49 (89.1%)
Neonatal sepsis
Yes 1 (1.89%) 0 (0%)
No 52 (98.11%) 55 (100%)
t test for continuous variables and χ 2 or Fisher’s exact test for discrete variables. and UTI, urinary tract infection.
Table 4 Associations between antenatal perineal massage and mode of delivery, duration of labor and oxytocin augmen-
tation of labor
Intervention (n = 53) Control (n = 55) P value
Method of delivery
Spontaneous 35 (66.0%) 31 (56.4%) 0.78
Induction 4 (7.5%) 5 (9.14%)
Instrumental 2 (3.8%) 3 (5.5%)
Caesarean section 12 (22.6%) 16 (29.1%)
Duration of labor Mean SD Mean SD
Active phase (h) 10.25 1.34 10.27 1.93 0.95
2nd stage (h) 1.25 0.40 1.33 0.48 0.35
3rd stage (min) 17.02 4.98 17.30 6.06 0.90
Oxytocin augmentation 53 (100.0%) 55 (100.0%) –
Table 5 Association between antenatal perineal massage and cummulative urinary incontinence (UI), flatus incontinence
and fecal incontinences (FI) at 3 months post-partum
Intervention (n = 48) Control (n = 50) Relative risk (RR) 95% CI P value
UI 3 (6.3%) 4 (8.0%) 0.78 0.18–3.31 0.74
Flatus incontinence 4 (8.3%) 13 (26.0%) 0.33 0.11–0.91 0.03
FI 2 (4.2%) 8 (16.0%) 0.26 0.06–1.16 0.08
NB: 5 women lost to follow up after delivery in each group were excluded.
rate of 7.1%. Specifically, six women (6/98, 6.1%) were 5.1% (5/98) and 3.1% (3/98), respectively. Over-
reported stress urinary incontinence (SUI), while one all, 27 women reported involuntary passage of flatus
(1/98, 1.0%) reported urgency urinary incontinence and/or feces, giving a cumulative incidence rate of
(UUI). None of the women experienced overflow uri- 27.6% for AI. Specifically, 17 women (17.3%) reported
nary incontinence (OUI) or vesicovaginal fistulous flatus incontinence, and 10 (10.0%) reported FI. The
(VVF) incontinence. Of the seven women with UI, five incidence of AI at 6 weeks and 3 months post-partum
(5/7, 71.4%) reported a mild degree, and two (2/7, were 23.5% (23/98) and 17.3% (17/98), respectively.
28.6%) reported a moderate–severe degree. The inci- Furthermore, two women reported both UI and AI
dence of UI at 6 weeks and 3 months post-partum incontinence, giving a cumulative incidence rate of
2% for the combined forms. The incidence of com- and AI after childbirth, the present study found that
bined UI/AI at 6 weeks and 3 months post-partum APM significantly reduces the incidence of flatus
were 2.0% (2/98) and 0% (0/98), respectively. incontinence. The increased incidence of flatus incon-
tinence in the control group could be due to the
adverse effects of perineal trauma on the pelvic floor
Discussion musculature and nerves. No doubt, episiotomy can
extend to involve the anal sphincter or decrease the
The results of this study demonstrated that APM can integrity of the perineum, thereby predisposing the
prevent perineal trauma during labor and decrease clients to fecal and or flatus incontinence.17,18 The
the incidence of episiotomy in nulliparous women. observed incidence of UI, AI and their distributions at
The incidence of episiotomy in the APM group was various post-partum periods are similar to that of a
significantly lower than the incidence in the control recent study from the study area.11
group. This significant reduction in episiotomy rate APM does not seem to predispose to any adverse
may likely reduce post-partum maternal pain and, thus, effects, including caesarean section, PROM, preterm
improve maternal bonding with the neonates. It also labor or birth asphyxia, similar to observations in a
suggests that the need for post-partum analgesia would recent Cochrane systematic review.10
be decreased, and extra costs for procuring analgesics Despite the randomized design of this study, there
would be saved. This advantage is very important in were some limitations. APM is a blind procedure, and
low-income countries where payment for maternal and hence, the level at which the finger is introduced into the
neonatal healthcare services is often out of pocket. Inter- vagina could not be standardized despite specifications,
estingly, the study also shows that only five women and this could have affected the results obtained. The
need to receive APM in order to prevent a case of episi- procedure was not conducted by one person; hence, this
otomy (numbers needed to treat (NNT) = 5). This inter- might have affected the extent of the massage and the
esting observation will be useful in counseling women outcome of the study. Furthermore, as the massage was
on the effectiveness of APM in preventing perineal performed at home, the consistency and compliance
trauma during childbirth. The technique will therefore might not have been as directed. The very small frequen-
be useful for all women who cherish or desire an intact cies and wide confidence intervals obtained in some of
perineum after vaginal birth. the outcome measures of interest in the study suggest
The technique is also capable of reducing the incidence that a larger sample size would have improved the
of flatus incontinence after childbirth. This significant study’s precision and external validity. Training of the
observation is probably due to the increased incidence of participants, interviewers and other quality control strate-
intact perineal structures and the reduction of adverse gies noted in the study’s methods ruled out substantial
effects of trauma on the nerve endings. measurement bias. The strength of this study, however,
Reports from previous randomized studies on the lies in the fact that it was robust and prospective in
effect of APM on perineal trauma during childbirth have design, with reduced likelihood of bias, which limited
been conflicting. While a previous study in 20088 con- most previous studies on APM. The study also accessed
cluded that APM started between 34–36 weeks gestation the effect of APM on UI and AI, which was lacking in
has no clinically important benefit but is harmless, recent most previous studies. It also appears to be the first RCT
reviews10,16 showed that APM reduces perineal trauma, on APM in Africa where the burden of perineal trauma is
including episiotomy and perineal tears, and recom- expected to be high due to high fertility rate and aversion
mended its worldwide application, even in primary to caesarean section.
health settings. Our findings agree with recent In conclusion, APM in the last weeks of gestation
reviews10,16 that APM reduces the incidence of episiot- reduces the likelihood of episiotomy, thereby increas-
omy and increases the incidence of intact perineum after ing the incidence of an intact perineum after child-
childbirth. The lack of difference in this study regarding birth. It also reduces the risk of flatus incontinence.
the incidence of SPT may be related to the hospital policy, Nulliparous women should therefore be made aware
which prescribes episiotomy for all cases of ‘threatening’ of the likely benefits of this technique and should be
perineal tears in order to minimize the incidence of SPT provided with information on how best to perform
during labor. it. The technique should also be considered a routine
Although a recent Cochrane systematic review10 prenatal care to reduce the incidence of perineal
did not observe any reductions in the incidence of UI trauma and flatus incontinence after vaginal birth.
Disclosure 7. Albers LL, Sedler KD, Bedrick EJ, Teaf D, Peralta P. Factors
related to genital tract trauma in normal spontaneous vagi-
nal births. Birth 2006; 33: 94–100.
The authors report no conflicts of interest.
8. Mei-dan E, Walfisch A, Raz I, Levy A, Hallak M. Perineal
massage during pregnancy: A prospective controlled trial.
Isr Med Assoc J 2008; 10: 499–502.
Author contribution 9. Albers LL, Borders N. Minimizing genital tract trauma and
related pain following spontaneous vaginal birth. J Mid-
Author 1: Conception and design, data collection, data wifery Womens Health 2007; 52: 246–253.
10. Beckmann MM, Stock OM. Antenatal perineal massage for
analysis, manuscript writing/editing and supervision.
reducing perineal trauma. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2013
Author 2: Conception and design, data collection (Apr 30); (4): CD005123. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.
and interpretation, data analysis and manuscript writ- CD005123.pub3.
ing/editing. 11. Obioha KC, Ugwu EO, Obi SN, Dim CC, Oguanuo TC.
Author 3: Data Collection, data analysis and interpre- Prevalence and predictors of urinary/anal incontinence after
vaginal delivery: Prospective study of Nigerian women. Int
tation, manuscript writing/editing and supervision.
Urogynecol J 2015; 26: 1347–1354.
Author 4: Data Collection, data analysis and inter- 12. Ugwu EO, Obi SN, Iferikigwe ES, Dim CC, Ezugwu FO.
pretation and manuscript writing/editing. Membrane stripping to prevent post-term pregnancy in
Author 5: Data Collection, data analysis and interpre- Enugu, Nigeria: A randomized controlled trial. Arch Gynecol
tation, manuscript writing/editing and supervision. Obstet 2014; 289: 29–34.
13. Ezechukwu PC, Ugwu EO, Obi SN, Chigbu CO. Oral versus
vaginal misoprostol for induction of labor in Enugu, Nigeria: A
randomized controlled trial. Arch Gynecol Obstet 2015; 291:
Compliance with Ethical Standards 537–544.
14. Hastings-Tolsma M. Antenatal perineal massage decreases
Ethical approval: All procedures performed in studies risk of perineal trauma during birth. Evid Based Nurs 2014;
involving human participants were in accordance 17: 77. https://doi.org/10.1136/eb-2013-101451.
15. Abrams P, Avery K, Gardener N, Donovan J, ICIQ Advisory
with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or
Board. The international consultation on incontinence ques-
national research committee and with the 1964 Hel- tionnaire on urinary incontinence: Www.Iciq.Net. J Urol
sinki declaration and its later amendments or compa- 2006; 75 (3Pt 1): 1063–1066 discussion 1066.
rable ethical standards. 16. Seehusen DA, Raleigh M. Antenatal perineal massage to prevent
Informed consent: Informed consent was obtained birth trauma. Am Fam Physician 2014; 89: 335–336.
17. LaCross A, Groff M, Smaldone A. Obstetric anal sphincter
from all individual participants included in the study.
injury and anal incontinence following vaginal birth: A sys-
tematic review and meta-analysis. J Midwifery Womens Health
References 2015; 60: 37–47.
18. Nyengidiki TK, Nyeche S. Post-episiotomy morbidity
1. Leonid K. Perineal massage to prevent perineal trauma in amongst parturients at the University of Port-Harcourt
childbirth. Isr Med Assoc J 2008; 10: 531–533. Teaching Hospital, port-Harcourt, Nigeria. Niger Health J
2. Belihu FB, Small R, Davey MA. Episiotomy and severe peri- 2008; 8: 16–19. Available from URL: https://www.ajol.info/
neal trauma among eastern African immigrant women giv- index.php/nhj/article/view/90797. Last accessed 14 Oct
ing birth in public maternity care: A population based study 2017.
in Victoria, Australia. Women Birth 2017; 30: 282–290.
3. Shahoei R, Zaheri F, Nasab LH, Ranaei F. The effect of peri-
neal massage during the second stage of birth on nullipa-
rous women perineal: A randomization clinical trial. Electron
Physician 2017; 9: 5588–5595. Supporting information
4. Mikolajczyk RT, Zhang J, Tronendle J, Chan L. Risk factors
for birth canal lacerations in primiparous women. Additional Supporting Information may be found
Am J Perinatol 2008; 25: 259–264. in the online version of this article at the publisher’s
5. Okeke TC, Ugwu EO, Okezie OA, Enwereji JO,
web-site:
Ezenyeaku CC, Ikeako LO. Trends and determinants of epi-
siotomy at the University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital Appendix S1: International Consultation on Inconti-
(UNTH,) Enugu, Nigeria. Niger J Med 2012; 21: 304–307.
nence Questionnaire on urinary incontinence – short
6. Meister MR, Cahill AG, Conner SN, Woolfolk CL,
Lowder JL. Predicting obstetric anal sphincter injuries in a form” (ICIQ-UI-SF).
modern obstetric population. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2016; 215:
310.e1–310.e7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajog.2016.02.041. Appendix S2: Anal Incontinence Questionnaire.