Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A State of The Art of DC Microgrids For Electric Vehicle Charging
A State of The Art of DC Microgrids For Electric Vehicle Charging
,(((
WK,(((,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ6LJQDO3URFHVVLQJ&RPSXWLQJDQG&RQWURO,63&&N6HS6RODQ,QGLD
,(((
WK,(((,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ6LJQDO3URFHVVLQJ&RPSXWLQJDQG&RQWURO,63&&N6HS6RODQ,QGLD
fault analysis [49]. The work in [46,50] addresses various results in non-linear V-I and P-V characteristic curves. There
communication based protection strategies for medium exists a unique point of maximum power, at any point of time,
voltage direct current microgrids. Apart from this, some work that varies with the change in irradiance or temperature. Thus,
has been addressed in literature based on decentralized a maximum power point tracker is desired to guarantee that
protection control strategies [47,48]. maximal power is extracted by a DC-DC converter in all
weather conditions [57,58]. To attain this objective a MPPT
III. MICROGRID BASED EV CHARGING STATIONS algorithm is designed to match the maximum power point with
The crucial part of operation of electric vehicles is the the operating voltage and current of a converter.
recharging of their energy storage unit. The process of
charging an electric vehicle is carried conductively or So far, numerous MPPT strategies have been observed in
inductively. Conductive charging make use of electrical literature [58-69]. They can be categorized as offline methods,
contact between the charger and charging port of the vehicle, online methods and hybrid methods. The work in [59] reviews
in order to transfer energy in the battery packs. Inductive the offline methods which include open circuit voltage
charging on the other hand uses wireless energy transfer method, short circuit current and artificial intelligence
through an emf coupling [52]. Conductive charging has methods, online methods which include perturbation and
already been adopted worldwide in the field of electric observation method (P&O), incremental conductance method
vehicles while inductive charging is still at initial stages of and extremum seeking control method and hybrid methods.
development. As far as the rated power is considered, the The perturb and observe (P&O) MPPT algorithm is the most
charging systems are classified as normal, medium and high widely used due to ease in its execution. N Femia et al.
power. They are also classified as slow, quick or fast charging proposed a P&O technique for MPPT in which the MPPT
based on their time of charging [3]. parameters could be modified according to the dynamic
performance of the specific converter [60]. Jubaer Ahmed et
The charging time span of electric vehicles should be as short al. proposed a novel method to enhance the efficiency of P&O
as possible as compared to the internal combustion engine MPPT by reducing steady state oscillations and eliminating
vehicles. Thus, it is obvious that EV penetration is coupled to the possibility of algorithm to lose its tracking direction [62].
the advancement of commercial Fast Charging Stations D.K Sharma et al. proposed a MPPT algorithm by increasing
composed by a number of high power points of charging [53- the number of perturbation steps to get closer to MPPT with
55]. The FCS presents two topologies, the first one is based on minimum possible oscillations [63]. Fathabadi proposed a
a common AC bus which feeds every AC-DC EV charger and novel MPPT technique under different shading conditions.
the second one is based on a common DC bus feeding The technique achieved a dynamic response with the
different DC-DC charger [55]. Besides charging a battery car convergence time of 12ms and an efficiency of 99.60% [65].
to 80% of its SOC in a considerably less time, fast charging Several other P & O MPPT techniques has been addressed in
also increases productivity and decrease operating costs. Also, literature by various authors. [12,60,61,64,66-69].
fast chargers are known to be more resourceful than
conventional chargers and charging with less overcharging
B. DC Bus Arrangement
increase the battery efficiency [56].
The application of DC bus was first reported by Traube J et al.
TABLE I: CHARGING SPECIFICATIONS They proposed a DC bus to connect the photovoltaic array, the
Level AC Power (kW) DC Power (kW) energy storage unit and the electric vehicle battery pack along
Level 1 1.9 kW (120 V@16A) 36kW (200-450V@80A)
with the dc powered circuitry [66]. The implementation of DC
Level 2 19.2kW(240V@80 A) 90kW(200-450V@200A) bus in comparison to AC bus leads to enhanced system
Level 3 >20 kW (TBD) 240kW(200600V@400A) efficiency and reliability. Furthermore, it reduces the
TBD-To be determined necessary stages needed for power conversion, thereby
A. Renewable Energy Sources reducing the losses and simplifying the control algorithm
A photovoltaic system employ solar panels each consisting of [12,67,68]. The DC bus provides fault less management of
a number of solar cells which generate electrical power. Solar energy and encourage the prospect of integrating more
cell is the fundamental element in photovoltaic solar panels renewable energy sources [12].
and works resourcefully at low ambient temperatures. It is an C. Power Electronic Circuitry
electrical power source device which convert light energy
The selection of power electronics circuitry for charging of
directly into electric energy by photovoltaic effect [2,9,30].
electric vehicles is based on various factors like ratings of
Solar photovoltaic has specific benefits as a power source current and voltage, power losses during switching operations
since its operation does not generate any kind of pollution or
and several other dynamic characteristics. These devices
harmful greenhouse gas emissions, once installed it show
should be highly efficient to enhance the charging facilities of
simple scalability in respect of power needs. Also, silicon is
electric vehicles [70-72]. Figure 2 describes the various power
available in abundance in the earth’s crust. The power
electronic devices needed for the electric vehicles.
efficiency of a solar cell vary negligibly with the growth in the
temperature [54]. This variation in temperature and irradiance
,(((
WK,(((,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ6LJQDO3URFHVVLQJ&RPSXWLQJDQG&RQWURO,63&&N6HS6RODQ,QGLD
,(((
WK,(((,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ6LJQDO3URFHVVLQJ&RPSXWLQJDQG&RQWURO,63&&N6HS6RODQ,QGLD
[9] Hammerstrom, Donald J. "AC versus DC distribution systemsdid we get [28] Elsayed, Ahmed T., Ahmed A. Mohamed, and Osama A. Mohammed.
it right?." In Power Engineering Society General Meeting, 2007. IEEE, "DC microgrids and distribution systems: An overview." Electric Power
pp. 1-5. IEEE, 2007. Systems Research 119,pp. 407-417,2015.
[10] Lotfi, Hossein, and Amin Khodaei. "AC versus DC microgrid [29] Barklund, E., Nagaraju Pogaku, Milan Prodanovic, C. Hernandez-
planning." IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid 8, no. 1 pp. 296-304,2017. Aramburo, and Tim C. Green. "Energy management in autonomous
[11] Huang, Yu, Jing Jing Ye, Xin Du, and Li Yong Niu. "Simulation Study microgrid using stability-constrained droop control of inverters." IEEE
of System Operating Efficiency of EV Charging Stations with Different Transactions on Power Electronics 23, no. 5, pp.2346-2352,2008.
Power Supply Topologies." In Applied Mechanics and Materials, vol. [30] Kanchev, Hristiyan, Di Lu, Frederic Colas, Vladimir Lazarov, and
494, pp. 1500-1508. Trans Tech Publications, 2014. Bruno Francois. "Energy management and operational planning of a
[12] Planas, Estefanía, Jon Andreu, José Ignacio Gárate, Iñigo Martínez de microgrid with a PV-based active generator for smart grid
Alegría, and Edorta Ibarra. "AC and DC technology in microgrids: A applications." IEEE transactions on industrial electronics 58, no. 10,
review." Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 43, 726-749,2015. pp. 4583-4592,2011
[13] Kakigano, H., M. Nomura, and T. Ise. "Loss evaluation of DC [31] Tan, K. T., P. L. So, Y. C. Chu, and M. Z. Q. Chen. "Coordinated
distribution for residential houses compared with AC system." In Power control and energy management of distributed generation inverters in a
Electronics Conference (IPEC), 2010 International, pp. 480-486. IEEE, microgrid." IEEE transactions on power delivery 28, no. 2,pp.704-
2010. 713,2013.
[14] Xu, C. D., and K. W. E. Cheng. "A survey of distributed power [32] Kim, Jong-Yul, Jin-Hong Jeon, Seul-Ki Kim, Changhee Cho, June Ho
system—AC versus DC distributed power system." In Power Park, Hak-Man Kim, and Kee-Young Nam. "Cooperative control
Electronics Systems and Applications (PESA), 2011 4th International strategy of energy storage system and microsources for stabilizing the
Conference on, pp. 1-12. IEEE, 2011. microgrid during islanded operation." IEEE Transactions on Power
Electronics 25, no. 12, pp.3037-3048,2010.
[15] Chakraborty, Arindam. "Advancements in power electronics and drives
in interface with growing renewable energy resources." Renewable and [33] Jiang, Quanyuan, Meidong Xue, and Guangchao Geng. "Energy
Sustainable Energy Reviews 15, no. 4,pp. 1816-1827,2011. management of microgrid in grid-connected and stand-alone
modes." IEEE transactions on power systems 28, no. 3, pp. 3380-3389,
[16] Hammerstrom, Donald J. "AC versus DC distribution systemsdid we get
2013.
it right?." In Power Engineering Society General Meeting, 2007. IEEE,
pp. 1-5. IEEE, 2007. [34] Katiraei, Farid, and Mohammad Reza Iravani. "Power management
strategies for a microgrid with multiple distributed generation
[17] Asad, Roozbeh, and Ahad Kazemi. "A quantitative analysis of effects of
units." IEEE transactions on power systems 21, no. 4 pp. 1821-
transition from ac to dc system, on storage and distribution systems."
1831,2006.
In Power and Energy Engineering Conference (APPEEC), 2012 Asia-
Pacific, pp. 1-5. IEEE, 2012. [35] Su, Wencong, and Jianhui Wang. "Energy management systems in
microgrid operations." The Electricity Journal 25, no. 8,pp. 45-60,2012.
[18] Guerrero, Josep M., Poh Chiang Loh, Tzung-Lin Lee, and Mukul
Chandorkar. "Advanced control architectures for intelligent [36] Zhang, Li, Tianjin Wu, Yan Xing, Kai Sun, and Josep M. Gurrero.
microgrids—Part II: Power quality, energy storage, and AC/DC "Power control of DC microgrid using DC bus signaling." In Applied
microgrids." IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics 60, no. 4, Power Electronics Conference and Exposition (APEC), 2011 Twenty-
pp.1263-1270,2013. Sixth Annual IEEE, pp. 1926-1932. IEEE, 2011.
[19] Justo, Jackson John, Francis Mwasilu, Ju Lee, and Jin-Woo Jung. "AC- [37] Fletcher, Steven DA, Patrick J. Norman, Stuart J. Galloway, Paul Crolla,
microgrids versus DC-microgrids with distributed energy resources: A and Graeme M. Burt. "Optimizing the roles of unit and non-unit
review." Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 24,pp. 387- protection methods within DC microgrids." IEEE transactions on Smart
405,2013. Grid 3, no. 4, pp. 2079-2087,2012.
[20] Biczel, Piotr. "Power electronic converters in DC microgrid." [38] Meghwani, A., S. C. Srivastava, and S. Chakrabarti. "A non-unit
In Compatibility in Power Electronics, 2007. CPE'07, pp. 1-6. IEEE, protection scheme for DC microgrid based on local
2007. measurements." IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery 32, no. 1,pp.
172-181,2017
[21] Xu, Lie, and Dong Chen. "Control and operation of a DC microgrid with
variable generation and energy storage." IEEE Transactions on Power [39] Salomonsson, Daniel, Lennart Soder, and Ambra Sannino. "Protection
Delivery 26, no. 4, pp. 2513-2522,2011. of low-voltage DC microgrids." IEEE Transactions on Power
Delivery 24, no. 3, pp. 1045-1053,2009.
[22] Lago, Jackson, and Marcelo Lobo Heldwein. "Operation and control-
oriented modeling of a power converter for current balancing and [40] Park, Jae-Do, and Jared Candelaria. "Fault detection and isolation in
stability improvement of DC active distribution networks." IEEE low-voltage DC-bus microgrid system." IEEE transactions on power
Transactions on Power Electronics 26, no. 3, pp.877-885,2011. delivery 28, no. 2, pp. 779-787,2013.
[23] Akshatha, S., C. N. Arun, V. S. Abhijith, and B. G. Fernandes. "A [41] Pramudya, I., Umer A. Khan, J. Y. Koo, and B. W. Lee. "Modelling and
unified AC-DC microgrid architecture for distribution of AC and DC evaluation of low voltage DC circuit breaker for the protection of DC
power on the same line." In Applied Power Electronics Conference and microgrid." In Condition Monitoring and Diagnosis (CMD), 2016
Exposition (APEC), 2017 IEEE, pp. 430-433. IEEE, 2017. International Conference on, pp. 295-298. IEEE, 2016.
[24] Lasseter, Robert H. "Microgrids." In Power Engineering Society Winter [42] Dhar, Snehamoy, R. K. Patnaik, and P. K. Dash. "Fault Detection and
Meeting, 2002. IEEE, vol. 1, pp. 305-308. IEEE, 2002. Location of Photovoltaic Based DC Microgrid Using Differential
Protection Strategy." IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2017.
[25] Lasseter, Robert H., and Paolo Paigi. "Microgrid: A conceptual
solution." In Power Electronics Specialists Conference, 2004. PESC 04. [43] Bayindir, Ramazan, Erdal Irmak, Fatih Issi, and Naki Guler. "Short-
2004 IEEE 35th Annual, vol. 6, pp. 4285-4290. IEEE, 2004. circuit fault analysis on microgrid." In Renewable Energy Research and
Applications (ICRERA), 2015 International Conference on, pp. 1248-
[26] Mohamed, A. Ghareeb, T. Youssef, O.A. Mohammed, Wide area
1252. IEEE, 2015.
monitoringand control for voltage assessment in smart grids with
distributed generation,in: IEEE Innovative Smart Grid Technologies [44] Yu, Ming, Yi Wang, Lirong Zhang, and Ziguang Zhang. "DC short
Conference (ISGT), pp. 1–6,2013. circuit fault analysis and protection of ring type DC microgrid."
In Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (IPEMC-ECCE
[27] Dragiþeviü, Tomislav, Xiaonan Lu, Juan C. Vasquez, and Josep M.
Asia), 2016 IEEE 8th International, pp. 1694-1700. IEEE, 2016.
Guerrero. "DC Microgrids—Part II: A review of power architectures,
applications, and standardization issues." IEEE transactions on power [45] Monadi, Mehdi, Catalin Gavriluta, Alvaro Luna, Jose Ignacio Candela,
electronics 31, no. 5, 3528-3549, 2016. and Pedro Rodriguez. "Centralized Protection Strategy for Medium
Voltage DC Microgrids." IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery 32, no.
1,pp. 430-440,2017.
,(((
WK,(((,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ6LJQDO3URFHVVLQJ&RPSXWLQJDQG&RQWURO,63&&N6HS6RODQ,QGLD
[46] Yuan, Chen, Mohammed A. Haj-ahmed, and Mahesh S. Illindala. [65] Fathabadi, Hassan. "Novel fast dynamic MPPT (maximum power point
"Protection strategies for medium-voltage direct-current microgrid at a tracking) technique with the capability of very high accurate power
remote area mine site." IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications 51, tracking." Energy 94, pp. 466-475,2016.
no. 4, pp.2846-2853,2012. [66] Traube J, Lu F, Maksimovic D. Photovoltaic power system with
[47] Habib, Hany F., and Osama Mohammed. "Decentralized Multi-Agent integrated electric vehicle DC charger and enhanced grid support. In:
System for Protection and the Power Restoration Process in Microgrids." Proceedings of the 2012 15th international conference on Power
In Green Technologies Conference (GreenTech), 2017 Ninth Annual electronics and motion control conference (EPE/PEMC): IEEE. p. LS1d.
IEEE, pp. 358-364. IEEE, 2017. 5-1-LSd. 5-.,2012.
[48] Rahmani, Mohiyeddin, and Mostafa Goodarzi. "A new controller for [67] Piagi, Paolo, and Robert H. Lasseter. "Autonomous control of
frequency protection of an islanded microgrid." In Power System microgrids." In Power Engineering Society General Meeting, 2006.
Conference (PSC), 2015 30th International, pp. 118-122. IEEE, 2015. IEEE, pp. 8-pp. IEEE, 2006.
[49] Xu, Meng, Tingru Meng, Guibin Zou, Jian Zhang, Xia Lin, and Jingjing [68] Starke M., Tolbert L.M., Ozpineci B.AC vs. DC distribution: A loss
Yang. "A centralized protection and control scheme for microgrid." comparison. In: Proceedings of the transmission and distribution
In Power and Energy Engineering Conference (APPEEC), 2015 IEEE conference and exposition, 2008T & x00026; D IEEE/PES: IEEE; p.1–
PES Asia-Pacific, pp. 1-5. IEEE, 2015. 7, 2008.
[50] Yuan, Chen, Mohammed A. Haj-ahmed, and Mahesh S. Illindala. [69] Techakittiroj K., Wong pai bool V. Co-existance between AC-
"Protection strategies for medium-voltage direct-current microgrid at a distribution and DC distribution: in the view of appliances. In:
remote area mine site." IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications 51, Proceedings of the 2009 international conference on computer and
no. 4, pp.2846-2853,2015. electrical engineering ICCEE'09s: IEEE; pp.1421–25,2009.
[51] Li, Huimin, Weilin Li, Min Luo, Antonello Monti, and Ferdinanda [70] Padmanaban, Sanjeevikumar, Ersan Kabalci, Atif Iqbal, Haitham Abu-
Ponci. "Design of smart MVDC power grid protection." IEEE Rub, and Olorunfemi Ojo. "Control strategy and hardware
Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement 60, no. 9,pp. 3035- implementation for DC–DC boost power circuit based on proportional–
3046,2011. integral compensator for high voltage application." Engineering Science
[52] Yilmaz, Murat, and Philip T. Krein. "Review of battery charger and Technology, an International Journal 18, no. 2,pp. 163-170,2015.
topologies, charging power levels, and infrastructure for plug-in electric [71] Al-Sheikh, Hiba, Ouadie Bennouna, Ghaleb Hoblos, and Nazih
and hybrid vehicles." IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics 28, no. Moubayed. "Modeling, design and fault analysis of bidirectional DC-DC
5 pp. 2151-2169,2013. converter for hybrid electric vehicles." In Industrial Electronics (ISIE),
[53] Biczel, Piotr. "Power electronic converters in DC microgrid." 2014 IEEE 23rd International Symposium on, pp. 1689-1695. IEEE,
In Compatibility in Power Electronics, 2007. CPE'07, pp. 1-6. IEEE, 2014.
2007. [72] Lai, Ching-Ming. "Development of a novel bidirectional DC/DC
[54] Pearce, Joshua M. "Photovoltaics—a path to sustainable converter topology with high voltage conversion ratio for electric
futures." Futures 34, no. 7,pp. 663-674,2002. vehicles and DC-microgrids." Energies 9, no. 6, 410,2016.
[55] Yong, Jia Ying, Vigna K. Ramachandaramurthy, Kang Miao Tan, and [73] Rivera, Sebastian, Bin Wu, Samir Kouro, Venkata Yaramasu, and
N. Mithulananthan. "Bi-directional electric vehicle fast charging station Jiacheng Wang. "Electric vehicle charging station using a neutral point
with novel reactive power compensation for voltage clamped converter with bipolar DC bus." IEEE Transactions on
regulation." International Journal of Electrical Power & Energy Industrial Electronics 62, no. 4,pp.1999-2009,2015.
Systems 64,pp. 300-310,2015. [74] K.-I. Hwu, T.-J. Peng, High-voltage-boosting converter with charge
[56] Dickinson, Blake, and Jay Gill. "Issues and benefits with fast charging pump capacitor and coupling inductor combined with buck-boost
industrial batteries." In Battery Conference on Applications and converter, Trans.IET Power Electronics 7,no.1,pp.177-188, 2014.
Advances, 2000. The Fifteenth Annual, pp. 223-229. IEEE, 2000. [75] Changwoo Yoon, Joongeun Kim, Sewan Choi, Multiphase DC-DC
[57] Ashique R.H., Salam Z., Ahmed J.An adaptive P & O MPPT using a converters using a boost-half-bridge cell for high-voltage and high-
sectionalized piece-wise linear P-V curve. In: Proceedings of the 2015 power applications, Trans. IEEE Power Electronics 26 (2),pp. 381-
IEEE conference on energy conversion (CENCON); p. 474–79,2015. 388,2011.
[58] Rawat R, Chandel SS. Review of maximum-power-point tracking [76] M. Nymand, M.A.E. Andersen, High-efficiency isolated boost DC-DC
techniques for solar-photovoltaic systems. Energy Technol ;1:pp.438– converter for high-power low-voltage fuel-cell applications, Trans. IEEE
48,2013. Industrial Electronics, 57,no.2,pp.505-514,2010.
[59] Reisi, Ali Reza, Mohammad Hassan Moradi, and Shahriar Jamasb. [77] Shareef, Hussain, Md Mainul Islam, and Azah Mohamed. "A review of
"Classification and comparison of maximum power point tracking the stage-of-the-art charging technologies, placement methodologies,
techniques for photovoltaic system: A review." Renewable and and impacts of electric vehicles." Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Sustainable Energy Reviews 19, pp. 433-443,2013. Reviews 64,pp. 403-420,2016.
[60] Femia, Nicola, Giovanni Petrone, Giovanni Spagnuolo, and Massimo [78] Lucas, Alexandre, Fausto Bonavitacola, Evangelos Kotsakis, and
Vitelli. "Optimization of perturb and observe maximum power point Gianluca Fulli. "Grid harmonic impact of multiple electric vehicle fast
tracking method." IEEE transactions on Power Electronics 20, no. charging." Electric Power Systems Research 127,pp.13-21,2015.
4,pp.963-973,2005. [79] Dharmakeerthi, C. H., N. Mithulananthan, and T. K. Saha. "Impact of
[61] Killi, Muralidhar, and Susovon Samanta. "Modified perturb and observe electric vehicle fast charging on power system voltage
MPPT algorithm for drift avoidance in photovoltaic systems." IEEE stability." International Journal of Electrical Power & Energy
transactions on Industrial Electronics 62, no. 9, pp.5549-5559,2015. Systems 57,pp.241-249,2014.
[62] Ahmed, Jubaer, and Zainal Salam. "An improved perturb and observe
(P&O) maximum power point tracking (MPPT) algorithm for higher
efficiency." Applied Energy 150,pp. 97-108,2015.
[63] Sharma, D. K., and G. Purohit. "Advanced perturbation and observation
(P&O) based maximum power point tracking (MPPT) of a solar photo-
voltaic system." In Power Electronics (IICPE), 2012 IEEE 5th India
International Conference on, pp. 1-5. IEEE, 2012.
[64] De Brito, Moacyr Aureliano Gomes, Luigi Galotto, Leonardo Poltronieri
Sampaio, Guilherme de Azevedo e Melo, and Carlos Alberto Canesin.
"Evaluation of the main MPPT techniques for photovoltaic
applications." IEEE transactions on industrial electronics 60, no. 3,
pp.1156-1167,2013.
,(((