Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Don't Overload Students - Assigning Too Much Work Discourages Learning (Stenger, 7-24-18)
Don't Overload Students - Assigning Too Much Work Discourages Learning (Stenger, 7-24-18)
2
ÿ5
935ÿ33
22ÿÿ2
ÿ12
9ÿ9
33
5ÿ
5
!!!"
339ÿ29
5939
3
299"9
" 3#2
$9
52
$
339%
i &'()ÿ+,-./ÿ+012
34ÿ)5'6ÿ-5785ÿ(94-ÿ:;:6ÿ<::=ÿ45ÿ(5=>ÿ-.3-ÿ)5'ÿ?:(-ÿ@.)49A3(()ÿ8639=:8ÿ3-ÿ-.:ÿ-.5'>.-ÿ5?ÿ:;:6)-.9=>
-.3-ÿ=::8:8ÿ-5ÿ<:ÿ85=:B
C:Dÿ6:4:36A.
E.--@4FGGDDDH-3=8?5=(9=:HA5IG859G3<4G10H1020G00++0JKLH+01+HK,M,NJOHP0Q&.RIS)S5Tÿ.34ÿ4.:8ÿ45I:
(9>.-ÿ5=ÿ-.:ÿ6:345=ÿ<:.9=8ÿ-.94ÿ?::(9=>ÿ3=8ÿ4.5D4ÿ-.3-ÿ5;:6(5389=>ÿ4-'8:=-4ÿA3'4:4ÿ=5-ÿ5=()ÿ3A38:I9A
4-6:44/ÿ<'-ÿ3(45ÿ-3V:4ÿ3ÿ-5((ÿ5=ÿ4-'8:=-4WÿI:=-3(ÿ3=8ÿ@.)49A3(ÿ.:3(-./ÿD.9A./ÿ'=4'6@6949=>()/ÿ.9=8:64
(:36=9=>H
X.:ÿ4-'8)/ÿ(:8ÿ<)ÿY5((9:ÿZ3((5D3)ÿ?65Iÿ[:D94ÿ3=8ÿ\(36Vÿ\5((:>:/ÿ4.5D4ÿ-.3-ÿ3(-.5'>.ÿ4-'8:=-4ÿD.5ÿ4@:=8
I56:ÿ-9I:ÿ859=>ÿ.5I:D56Vÿ36:ÿ45I:-9I:4ÿI56:ÿ<:.3;95'63(()ÿ:=>3>:8ÿ9=ÿ4A.55(/ÿ-.:)ÿ3(45ÿ-:=8ÿ-5ÿ<:
I56:ÿ3=]95'4/ÿ3=8ÿ6:@56-ÿI56:ÿ@.)49A3(ÿ4)I@-5I4ÿ8':ÿ-5ÿ4-6:44H
^_(-.5'>.ÿ-.:ÿ4-'8:=-4ÿ9=ÿ5'6ÿ4-'8)ÿD:6:ÿ3;:63>9=>ÿI56:ÿ-.3=ÿ-.6::ÿ.5'64ÿ5?ÿ.5I:D56Vÿ@:6ÿ=9>.-/ÿI54-
898ÿ=5-ÿ̀=8ÿ-.94ÿ.5I:D56Vÿ:=>3>9=>/ÿ=56ÿ898ÿ-.:)ÿ?::(ÿ9-ÿ:=.3=A:8ÿ-.:96ÿ(:36=9=>/aÿ43)4ÿZ3((5D3)H
^b:A3'4:ÿ.5I:D56Vÿ-:=84ÿ-5ÿ3A-4ÿ34ÿ3ÿ4-6:4456ÿ9=ÿ4-'8:=-4Wÿ(9;:4/ÿ-.:96ÿ<589:4ÿI'4-ÿ̀=8ÿ3ÿD3)ÿ-5ÿ6:4@5=8
56ÿ6:3A-ÿ-5ÿ-.94ÿ4-6:4456/ÿ3=8ÿ3(-.5'>.ÿ6:4:36A.ÿ.34ÿ4.5D=ÿ-.3-ÿ45I:ÿ(:;:(ÿ5?ÿ4-6:44ÿA3=ÿ<:ÿ.:3(-.)/
A.65=9Aÿ4-6:44ÿA3=ÿ9=8'A:ÿ=:>3-9;:ÿ@.)49A3(/ÿI:=-3(/ÿ3=8ÿ<:.3;95'6ÿ5'-A5I:4/aÿ4.:ÿ:]@(39=4H
X.:ÿ6:4:36A.:64ÿ4'6;:):8ÿ5;:6ÿ,/000ÿ4-'8:=-4ÿ-5ÿ8:-:6I9=:ÿ-.:ÿ65(:ÿ-.3-ÿ-.94ÿ3889-95=3(ÿD56Vÿ@(3):8ÿ34ÿ3
4-6:4456ÿ9=ÿ-.:96ÿ(9;:4H
b)ÿ34V9=>ÿc':4-95=4ÿ(9V:ÿ^05Dÿ5?-:=ÿ85ÿ)5'ÿ-6)ÿ34ÿ.368ÿ34ÿ)5'ÿA3=ÿ9=ÿ4A.55(Badÿ3=8ÿ^05Dÿ5?-:=ÿ85ÿ)5'
A5I@(:-:ÿ)5'6ÿ4A.55(ÿ3449>=I:=-4Badÿ-.:)ÿD:6:ÿ3<(:ÿ-5ÿ@39=-ÿ3ÿ@9A-'6:ÿ5?ÿ4-'8:=-4Wÿ(:;:(ÿ5?ÿ<:.3;95'63(
:=>3>:I:=-H
X.:ÿI:=-3(ÿ3=8ÿ@.)49A3(ÿD:((7<:9=>ÿ344:44I:=-ÿA5=494-:8ÿ5?ÿc':4-95=4ÿ(9V:ÿ^05Dÿ5?-:=ÿ85ÿ)5'ÿ?::(
4-6:44:8ÿ3<5'-ÿ)5'6ÿ3A38:I9Aÿ:]@:69:=A:Baÿ34ÿD:((ÿ34ÿ:=c'969:4ÿ3<5'-ÿ4-6:4476:(3-:8ÿ.:3(-.ÿ@65<(:I4
4'A.ÿ34ÿ.:383A.:4/ÿD:9>.-ÿ>39=ÿ3=8ÿ4(::@ÿ89eA'(-9:4H
f=()ÿNgÿ5?ÿ4-'8:=-4ÿ4398ÿ-.:)ÿ?5'=8ÿ-.:96ÿ.5I:D56Vÿ^;:6)ÿ'4:?'(adÿ9=ÿ@6:@369=>ÿ-.:Iÿ?56ÿ(:36=9=>/ÿ-:4-4/
@3@:64ÿ56ÿ@65h:A-4/ÿ3=8ÿI3=)ÿ:]@:69:=A:8ÿ4-6:44/ÿA5I@65I94:8ÿ.:3(-.ÿ3=8ÿ3ÿ(3AVÿ5?ÿ<3(3=A:H
01234516ÿ896
ÿ
43ÿ14ÿ26181
5ÿ1ÿ14ÿ
9
83ÿ685ÿ156ÿ94ÿ446ÿ544ÿ8ÿ14ÿ1
ÿ461
1446ÿ8986ÿ6
415ÿ
4ÿ
2ÿ6
293ÿ4ÿ3
5ÿ1ÿ
85ÿ449ÿ94ÿ
2ÿ84ÿ3
55ÿ853ÿÿ
3
8646ÿ45ÿ4ÿ3
54ÿ84ÿ89ÿ
ÿÿ
4
ÿ
!8643ÿ
5ÿ62
ÿ6123451ÿ4438
ÿ14ÿ4648
46ÿ6"4
29814ÿ181ÿ
4
ÿ
49
83ÿ
85ÿ8
12899ÿ91ÿ8
"46
56ÿ
8"8
1ÿ1
ÿ9485
#2ÿ6123ÿ624616ÿ181ÿ$61234516ÿ
ÿ84ÿ
49
8343%ÿ4&"445
4ÿ4ÿ94496ÿ
ÿ61466ÿ853ÿ
4
"6
89ÿ"
946ÿ94ÿ64815ÿ4838
46ÿ4&8261
5ÿ61
8
ÿ"
946ÿ853'
ÿ6944"5ÿ3(
29146
5
146ÿ)899
8
5ÿ8331
5ÿ1464ÿ61234516ÿ4"
1ÿ8ÿ45489ÿ98
ÿ
ÿ8985
4ÿ5ÿ14ÿ946ÿ4495ÿ94ÿ14ÿ5443ÿ1
ÿ
64
"9415ÿ14ÿ
4
ÿ
4ÿ4585ÿ5ÿ6
89ÿ"6
89ÿ853ÿ461
814ÿ8
1146ÿ181ÿ
293ÿ62""
1
14ÿ499*45ÿ
+4
26ÿ4648
ÿ86ÿ896
ÿ6
5ÿ181ÿ86655ÿ1
ÿ2
ÿ
ÿ
85ÿ356ÿ16ÿ4,4
145466ÿ853ÿ445
84ÿ1ÿ
2514*"
32
14ÿ-9489ÿ.261ÿ4
8264ÿ61234516ÿ84ÿ3
5ÿ
4ÿ
ÿ3
4651ÿ485ÿ14ÿ84
8
12899ÿ94855ÿ
4
!21ÿ81ÿ
85ÿ148
46ÿ3
ÿ84ÿ624ÿ181ÿ14ÿ8665ÿ45
2ÿ
ÿ1
21ÿ261815ÿ853ÿ
49
835
61234516/
0ÿ)899
8ÿ5
146ÿ181ÿ85ÿ
ÿ866543ÿ1
ÿ61234516ÿ6
293ÿ84ÿ8ÿ
948ÿ"2"
64ÿ853ÿ45411ÿ853
6
293ÿ4ÿ346543ÿ1
ÿ
291814ÿ94855ÿ853ÿ3449
"451
04ÿ896
ÿ624616ÿ14ÿ
99
5ÿ1"6ÿ
ÿ1535ÿ14ÿ1ÿ8985
42
01234516ÿ853ÿ148
46ÿ6
293ÿ454899ÿ895ÿ5ÿ14ÿ346
"1
5ÿ
ÿ14ÿ"2"
64ÿ
ÿ
4
ÿ4181ÿ6ÿ61234516
6
293ÿ4ÿ894ÿ1
ÿ3451ÿ14ÿ"2"
645
48
46ÿ6
293ÿ5
1ÿ6"9ÿ
4
*
,ÿ
4
ÿ86ÿ
"9414ÿ
ÿ5
"9414ÿ7
4
ÿ6
293ÿ4ÿ5
"
8143
ÿ219943ÿ5ÿ14ÿ9466
5ÿ1
ÿ8
91814ÿ14ÿ94855ÿ4&"445
4
01234516ÿ853ÿ148
46ÿ6
293ÿ4584ÿ1
414ÿ5ÿ
*
5612
15ÿ
4
ÿ86654516ÿ5ÿ62
ÿ
*
5612
1
5
61234516ÿ
85ÿ3451ÿ8
26ÿ86ÿ1
ÿ293ÿ2"
5ÿ853ÿ4&"853ÿ14ÿ94855ÿ
ÿ8ÿ1
"
ÿ
ÿ
5
4"1ÿ6ÿ896
ÿ"
346
""
125146ÿ
ÿ61234516ÿ1
ÿ5ÿ14ÿ614516ÿ
4811ÿ
291289ÿ86ÿ
ÿ94855ÿ853ÿ
251ÿ866416ÿ1
14ÿ94855ÿ"
466
3
21ÿ88554ÿ01454
411"62''
"45
9944643282'5
43'821
'88554'5
88554ÿ01454ÿ6ÿ8ÿ6
53
5*8643ÿ44985
4ÿ14ÿ853ÿ.
258961ÿ1ÿ4&14564ÿ4&"445
4ÿ
45ÿ899
156ÿ94855ÿ853ÿ3449
"451ÿ046ÿ"81
2989ÿ51446143ÿ5ÿ14ÿ"6
9
ÿ
ÿ94855ÿ853ÿ
14
5
9
ÿ6ÿ
855ÿ14ÿ8ÿ4ÿ9485ÿ74ÿ81
946ÿ84ÿ445ÿ481243ÿÿ14ÿ946ÿ
ÿ3!-ÿ832
81
5
012ÿ456789
7ÿ
9
ÿ212
ÿ7ÿ1ÿ279ÿ
ÿ12ÿ
7ÿ0992ÿ77292782