Professional Documents
Culture Documents
R & M
R & M
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Introduction
The study under consideration has been conducted to examine the fundamental pricing
of equity shares in India. To achieve the desired objectives, there is need to apply
scientific method of research. Research methodology explains purpose and objectives
of the study, sample size, variables taken and sources of data, hypotheses framed and
statistical tools used for analyzing the fundamental variables. It needs to be deliberated
with all care and concern as any mistake in it may lead to offend the reliability and
validity of the findings. In this chapter an attempt has been made to design and define
the research methodology duly adopted to carry out the research study.
Problem Statement
51
Objectives of the Study
The main objective of the study is to examine the relationship between fundamental
variables and equity share prices. To achieve the main objective, the same has been
divided into following sub objectives:
Research Hypotheses
To achieve the above objectives, following alternative research hypotheses have been
formulated:
H11: There is significant relationship exist between equity share prices and the
fundamental factors i.e. liquidity, leverage, sales, growth, operating efficiency and
profitability.
H12: Fundamental variables i.e. EPS, DPS, DEQ, ROA, DP, Size, BV and PE have
significant relationship with the market value of equity stocks of automotive, banking,
energy, FMCG, infrastructure, metal and mining, pharmaceutical, technology and
miscellaneous industry.
H13: Market price of equity shares of listed Indian companies is dependent on the
fundamental variables i.e. EPS, DPS, DEQ, ROA, DP, Size, BV and PE.
52
Scope of the Study
To achieve the objectives of present study, the companies listed on Indian stock market
has been taken as the universe of the study and 200 companies which are constitute of
BSE-200 index as on June, 2013, has been taken as sample companies. The time period
is of twelve years ranging from the year April, 2001 to March, 2012 which comprises
the period of boom, recession, recovery, political turmoil, world economic crisis, high
inflation as well as low inflation period, highest and lowest crude oil prices etc. which
justify the period of study to draw meaningful conclusions from the study which may
be useful for the institutional as well as individual investor to make portfolios.
The present study is based on primary as well as secondary data to achieve research
objectives. Secondary data is collected from the respective websites of the companies,
publications of Bombay Stock Exchange and Prowess database maintained by Centre
for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE). The data related to various fundamental
variables and stock prices are of yearly basis i.e. collected from the financial year April,
2001 to March, 2012 respectively.
The remaining objective of the study is achieved by using primary data. The primary
data is used to know the investor’s perception regarding fundamental pricing. The
primary data is collected through a structured questionnaire that is administrated to the
250 equity investors of Haryana and NCR through email and through courier as well
personal interviews have been taken during the period of 2013-14. The questionnaire is
shown in Appendix- IV.
The rationale behind selecting BSE-200 Index as sample base is that these 200
companies account for a substantial share of market capitalization in Indian stock
market and reveal the performance of almost the entire business sector in India. To
achieve the objectives of present study, the sample of 124 companies is selected out of
200 companies listed on BSE 200 indices as on June, 2013. The companies are filtered
on the basis of two criteria: 1) the stock of the companies must be listed at least five
years from 2001 to 2012 on BSE 200 indices. 2) The data of all the variables, of all the
periods for all the companies must be available. These 124 companies has been
53
grouped into 9 major industrial sectors i.e. automotive, banking, energy, FMCG,
infrastructure, metal and mining, pharmaceutical, technology and miscellaneous
industry of India to identify the significant fundamental variables according to industry
basis.
Computation of Variables
To achieve the objectives of the study, equity share price is used as dependent variable
and company specific fundamental variables i.e. earning per share, dividend payout,
dividend per share, book value, debt to equity, debt to asset, current ratio, quick ratio,
return on asset, return on net worth, return on average capiital employed, cash flow
from operation, price to earning ratio, price to sales, size of the firm, total asset
turnover, net profit margin and price to book value are taken as independent variables.
A brief explanation and calculation of all variables are given below.
54
Dependent Variable
Market price of equity share is taken as the dependent variables in the study to analyze
the various fundamental variables of the company and to exmaine their affect on the
equity share price. The detail of market price taken in the study is given below:
Average price of the share has been taken as market price of the share in the present
study. It is calculated as follows:
Where, High Price = Highest market price during the financial year, Low Price =
Lowest market price during the financial year.
Independent Variables
It can be very useful financial ratio for stakeholders of a company. Book value per
share has also a limitation as a valuation tool as it is based on the historical costs of the
assets of a firm. Ohlson (1995), Berger et al (1996) and Collins et al (1997) found a
significant relation between book value and market value of stocks.
Debt to Equity
Debt to Equity Ratio is a long term solvency ratio that indicates the proportion of
borrowed funds and owner’s capital in financing the assets of a firm. Debt to equity
ratio is also known as “external-internal equity ratio”.
55
Debt to Equity Ratio = Total Debt
Shareholders’ Equity
Both a very high and very low debt to equity ratios is not desirable. The general
proposition is: “other’s money should be in a reasonable proportion to the owner’s
capital and the owner should have sufficient stake in the fortunes of the enterprise”
(Khan and Jain, 2008). Bhandari (1988), Chan (1991), Mukherji et al. (1997), Tripathi
(2009) supported that debt to equity has the positive and significant impact on market
price of equity stocks.
Earning per share is a profitability ratio of a firm shows that how much of profit after
tax and preference dividend available to the equity shareholders on a per share basis. It
is computed as follows:
In determining market price of share, earning per share is usually considered as the
most essential indicator from the shareholders point of view. Basu (1983), Ou and
Penman (1989), Mukherji et al. (1997), Sharma (2011) found earning per share as one
of the strongest indicator of equity share prices.
Price to Earning
Price earning ratio measures the amount that investors are ready to pay for each rupee
of income. This ratio compares the market price of the firm with the earning per share.
It is calculated as follows:
The price to earning ratio is the important variable mostly used by the investors for
share valuation. Nissim and Penman et al. (2001), Tripathi (2009), Nirmala et al. (2011),
Sahoo and Chatterjee (2011) stated that price to earning is the significant determinant
of the stock returns.
56
Dividend per Share
Dividend per share is the dividend (including interim dividend) paid to the ordinary
shareholders per share. It can be calculated as follows:
This ratio helps in valuation of equity share prices. Gordon and Shapiro (1956) showed
the significance of dividends in valuing a firm’s market value at the time of formulation
of the Dividend Discount Model. Nirmala et al. (2011), Sharma (2011) also found
dividend per share has the significant impact on equity share prices.
Return on Asset
Return on asset measures the relationship between net income and assets. This ratio
shows how efficiently the management of a firm used its assets to generate income. It is
measured as follows:
Return on asset indicates that whether a firm is earning more with less investment or
not. Piotroski (2000), Wu and Xu (2006) and Venkates et al. (2012) also found strong
association between return on asset and price of equity stocks of a firm.
Dividend Payout
This ratio measures the relationship between the income related to equity shareholders
and the dividend paid to equityholders. It indicates that what percentage share of
earnings belonging to shareholders is paid out as dividend to them. It is computed as
follows:
This ratio can be compared with the trend over the years or an inter firm and intra
industry comparison would through light on its adequacy. Gurgul et al. (2006),
Chukwuma-Agu (2009) stated that dividend payout affects the market value of equity
stocks.
57
Return on Average Capital Employed
Return on average capital employed is an important profitability ratio of the firm that
measures the firm’s ability to generate profit from its capital employed in the business.
Average of opening and closing capital employed for the time period has been taken in
the study. Return on average capital employed (ROACE) is calculated as:
ROACE is used as a benchmark to measure the ability of the company to generate its
profit by employing the capital. Shobhana and Karpagavall (2011), Dabade (2012)
found ROCE as a fundamental determinant of stock prices.
Return on net worth (RONW) measures the profitability of the company in terms of
how much a company is earning profit with the funds invested by the ordinary
shareholders of the company. It is calculated as:
From the equity shareholders point of view, it is the most significant fundamental
variable because it tells that how efficiently a company is using their funds.
Price to book value measures the relationship between equity share prices and book
value per share of the company. It indicates that how much investor is ready to pay in
form of market price of shares for the firm’s net assets. It is calculated by dividing the
market price of equity shares by the book value per share.
58
Total Asset Turnover
Total asset turnover ratio measures the firm efficiency to generate its sales by use of its
entire asset. It shows how much a firm is able to generate its sales from each rupee of
the firm asset. It is calculated by dividing the net sales by total assets of the firm.
From the investors’ point of view, it is one of the most important fundamental variables
that affect the equity share prices of the company. Wu and Xu (2006), Martani et al.
(2009) found total asset turnover as a significant fundamental variable.
Size of the firm is the major fundamental determinant of equity share prices of the
company. Mostly investors want to buy shares of large companies due to their more
liquidity and marketability. From investors point of view mostly investment
opportunities are created by large companies as compared to small companies for
investors. The size of the firm can be measured in many ways, e.g. through turnover,
paid-up-capital, capital employed, total assets, net sales, etc. In the present study, size
of the firm is measured by taking logarithm of total assets.
Srinivasan (2012), Almumani (2014) examined the relation between size of the firm
and stock prices and found significant relation between both of them.
It is a firm’s financial leverage ratio that shows the relationship between total assets and
liabilities. It indicates the proportion of firm’s assets that is being financed by total
outside liability. It is calculated as:
It is one of the fundamental indicator of equity share prices because market value of the
firm is affected by it. Investors should consider this ratio at the time of making
investment in a particular firm. AI- Deehani (2005), Wu and Xu (2006) found debt to
asset as fundamental determnant of equtiy stock prices.
59
Price to Sales
It is a valuation ratio that helps in valuation of the stocks of the firm. It measures the
relationship between the share prices of the firm with its sales. It indicates the market
price to be found on each unit of a firm’s sales. In the present study, it is calculated as:
It is a firm’s profitability ratio expressed in a percentage form that measures how much
of each rupee of revenue earned by company is actually converted in to earnings. It is
the proportion of net profit and net sales of the firm. It is calculated as:
It is a fundamental indicator that affects the share prices. Every firm has its own pricing
policies and strategies that make them different from other firms.
Current Ratio
It is a firm’s liquidity ratio that measures the ability of the firm to meet its short term
obligation. It shows the relationship of current asset with current liabilities in the firm.
It is calculated as:
It is also a fundamental indicator that helps the investors while making their investment
decision in a firm. Investors can analyze the liquidity position of a firm by interpreting
this ratio.
Quick Ratio
It measures the firm’s ability to convert its current assets quickly into cash in order to
meet its short term obligation. It is the proportion of quick asset and current liabilities.
It is calculated as:
60
It is more useful as a fundamental indicator when compare among companies within
the same industry or compare over a period of time. Investors usually consider this ratio
to analyze the firm’s short term financial position.
Cash flow from operation measures how much a firm generates cash from its day to
day operations. It is the income of the firm that includes the non cash expenses such as
depreciation and excludes the adjustment of investments and financing. It is calculated
as:
Cash Flow from operation = (Earnings before interest & taxes + depreciation) - Income
Taxes
This section explains the statstical techniques that have been employed in the study to
analyze the data. Table 3.1 shows the classification of statistical tools according to each
objective. The research tools employed to achieve the purpose of present study are
explained as follows:
61
Brief detail of each of the staatistical tooll is as shown
n as follows:
Descrip
ptive Statisttics
It meaasures the linnear correlattion betweenn two variabbles. In the ppresent study
y, it is used
to meaasure the rellatioship am
mong all funddamental varriables takenn under study
y and with
the eqquity share prrices. It provvides us the ddegree of relationship beetween two variables:
v
Wheree,
n= Nu
umber of pairrs of variables
On
ne- Way ANOVA
The one-way
o anaalysis of variance (ANO
OVA) is a sttatistical toool used to ex
xamine the
hypoth
heses wheth
her there are any significcant differen
nces betweenn the meanss of two or
more independentt levels (usinng the F disstribution). It
I can be appplied on datta where a
depenndent variablle is metric and
a an indeppendent variiable known as factor haaving more
than two
t levels of
o treatment is categoriccal. In the prresent studyy, one way ANOVA
A is
used to
t determinee whether fun
ndamental variables takeen under study significan
ntly differs
betweeen demograaphic and in
nvestors relaated attributtes i.e. stockk market exxperience,
62
education level, occupation groups, family income groups, average holding period
groups, trading frequency groups, techniques used and various age groups or not.
Independent-Samples t-test
Independent samples t-test is a statistical test used to compare the means between two
independent groups of independent variable on the same continuous, dependent
variable. In the present study, this test is used to examine the hypotheses that
fundamental variables taken under study do not significantly differ between male and
female investors.
The frequencies procedure provides statistics and graphical displays that are useful for
describing many types of variables and percentage analysis is used to form a
contingency table from the frequency distribution and represent the collected data for
better understanding. In the present study, investors demographic and investment
related attributes are shown in the form of frequency and percentages.
Factor Analysis
Multiple regression models are the statistical analysis which is used to examine the
relationship between dependent variable with two or more independent variables. The
value of adjusted r square is used to see how much variance in dependent variable is
explained by combination of independent variables. The value of F- test signifies
whether model is fit or not and t-test value helps in identifying significant independent
variables at 1 percent, 5 percent and 10 percent level of significance. In the present
study, a linear multiple regression models have been employed to identify the
63
significant fundamental factors of the market price of equity shares. The common
equation of multiple linear regression models is:
Y = b0+b1X1+b2X2+b3X3+………+bnXn
b0 = constant
Levin-Lin-Chu Test
In the Leviin- Lin Chu test has been employed to test the statonarity of panel data.
Levin, Lin, and Chu (2002) proposed a panel unit root test for the null hypothesis of
unit root against a homogeneous stationary hypothesis. In step one, the ADF
regressions are implemented for each individual i, and then the orthogonalized residuals
are generated and normalized. That is, the following model is estimated:
The two orthogonalized residuals are generated by the following two auxiliary
regressions:
After that, the ratios of long-run to short-run standard deviations of are estimated.
The ratios and the long-run variances as denoted as and , respectively. The
64
long-
65
run variances are estimated by the HAC (heteroscedasticity- and autocorrelation-
consistent) estimators and the ratios are estimated by . And then, the panel
test statistics are calculated.Levin, Lin, and Chu (2002) propose the following
adjusted t statistic:
Panel data includes cross-sectional data (data collected on several units at one point in
time) as well as time series data (data collected on one unit over several time periods)
has been used in the study. Panel data regression is employed to examine the
relationship between equity share prices and fundamental variables. The market value
of equity stock (MP) is taken as the dependent variable while price-earnings, book
value, earnings per stock, dividend payout, dividend per share, debt to equity, size of
the firm and return on asset are taken as the independent variables. Fixed Effect and
Random Effect regression Model is used and R2 and Adjusted R2 values were measured.
Finally, a Hausman specification test has been performed to compare the fixed and
random effect model. The significance of the regression co-efficient pertaining to
various independent variables has been examined by applying t-test at 1%, 5 % and
10 % level of significance. The following regression model has been developed for the
purpose:
Where, αit = constant term, PE= Price earning, BV = Book value, DP = Dividend
payout, DPS = Dividend per share, DEQ = debt to equity, Size = Size of the firm,
ROA= Return on asset and eit = error term, i = individual firm, t = time, b1, b2,
b3………..b8 = regression coefficient of independent factors (the partial change in
market price per share due to one percentage change in independent factor while other
things remain constant).
The outcome of the present study will help in better understanding the pricing
techniques and fundamental variables related to pricing of equity shares. The study
66
would benefit the society in various ways. It helps the individual as well as institutional
investors in gaining knowledge regarding various fundamental variables that affects the
stock prices and investors can earn extra normal profits by making profitable
investment strategies. Now investors need not take their investment decisions on
speculative basis, they can predict stock prices with the help of these fundamental
variables in simpler way and can take their rational investment decisions in equity
market. The study would also beneficial for corporate management in making their
financial and business related policies. Management of a firm can enhance company
earnings and financial position by increasing the market price of the shares. The results
of the study may also be useful for the stock market authority as they can avoid any
unexpected calamity in the stock market and can control investment strategies and can
also evaluate the extent to which the stock market may need to be rehabilitated. The
study would also beneficial for the government in formulation of better economic
policies and good economic policies help in enhancing the financial performance of the
whole economy. The study will give theoretical as well as practical knowledge and
experience to the researcher and academicians regarding the significant fundamental
variables and their affect on equity share prices that would open new areas in future
research.
Any research study will be constrained in scope by some natural restrictions due to the
choice of the research design, sampling procedure, statistical tools and present study is
no exception of it. This study has considered only those companies as sample size;
those were part of BSE- 200 index. Out of 200 companies, only 124 companies have
been selected as final sample due to non availability of data. The findings of this study
could only be generalized to companies alike to those that were included in this study.
The analysis of study is based on only twelve years data and to make generalizations of
dependence, data should be over about 20-30 years. This research study is confined to
limited number of company specific fundamental variables only though there is more
such type of variable, economy and industry related variables associated with the study.
The objective based on primary data is restricted to the opinions of the equity investors
on sample basis in Haryana and NCR only and hence this cannot be taken to reveal the
view of all equity investors all over the country. The research study is also affected by
the different opinions of investors at different times because of their psychological
67
personality. In addition to it sample size of respondents is also small, due to busy
schedule of investors they could not respond to the questionnaire even after repeated
reminders.
Chapter I: Introduction
References
Basu, S. (1983), “The relationship between earnings’ yield, market value and return for
NYSE common stocks,” Journal of Financial Economics, pp.129-156.
68
Chukwuma-Agu, C. and Chukwuma Agu, (2009), “Behind the Crash: Analysis of the
Roles of Macroeconomic Fundamentals and Market Bubbles in the Nigeria
Stock Exchange”, Paper for Presentation at the African Econometric Society
Conference, Sheraton Hotel, Abuja.
Dabade, T. (2012), “A Study of Various Factors Influencing the Share Prices in India,”
retrained from http://www.artipot.com/articles/1127514/a-study-of-various-
factors-influencing-the-share-prices-in-india.htm
Gordon, M. J. and Shapiro, E. (1956), “Capital Equipment Analysis: The Required Rate
of Profit”, Management science, Vol. 3, No.1, pp. 102-110.
Jain, P. K., and Khan, M. Y. (2008), “Basic Financial Management”, Tata McGraw-
Hill.
Levin, A., Lin, C. F. and Chu, C. S. J. (2002), “Unit root tests in panel data: asymptotic
and finite-sample properties”, Journal of econometrics, Vol. 108, No.1, pp. 1-24.
Martani, D., Mulyono, D. M. and Khairurizka, R. (2009), “The effect of financial ratios,
firm size, and cash flow from operating activities in the interim report to the
stock return,” Chinese Business Review, Vol. 8, No.6, pp. 44-55.
69
Nirmala, S. P., Sanju, S. P. and Ramachandran, M., (2011), “Determinants of Share
Prices in India”, Journal of Emerging Trends in Economics and Management
Sciences, Vol.2, pp.124-130.
Nissim, D. and Penman, S., (2001), “Ratio Analysis and Equity Valuation: From
Research to Practice”, Review of Accounting Studies, Vol. 6, pp. 109-123.
Ou, J., and Penman, S., (1989), “Accounting Measures, Price-earnings ratio, and the
Information Content of Security Prices”, Journal of Accounting Research, Vol.
27, pp. 111–43.
Sahoo, P. K. and Chatterjee, A., (2011), “The Price-Earnings Ratio and The Equity
Returns in India”, Journal on Banking Financial Services & Insurance
Research, Vol. 1, Issue 3, pp. 1-12.
Shobhana, V.K. and Karpagavall, R., (2011), “Determinants of Market Price of Shares
of the Select Banking Companies Listed at Bombay Stock Exchange”, South
Asian Academic Research Journals, Vol. 1, Issue 3, pp. 8-23.
Venkates, CK., Tyagi, M. and Ganesh, L., (2012), “Fundamental Analysis and Stock
Returns: An Indian Evidence”, Global Advanced Research Journal of
Economics, Accounting and Finance, Vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 33-39.
70
Wu, W. and Xu, J., (2006), “Fundamental Analysis of Stock Price by Artificial Neural
Networks Model Based on Rough Set Theory”, World Journal of Modelling and
Simulation, Vol. 2, No. 1, pp. 36-44.
71