Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER 4 and 5 RESEARCH STEM 9
CHAPTER 4 and 5 RESEARCH STEM 9
A Research Proposal
Presented to
Zamboanga City
This chapter presents and analyzes the data gathered through the use of interview and test
questionnaire. The data were tabulated, analyzed, and interpreted with the use of statistical tests.
The specific questions raised in the statement of the problem were the bases of the order of
presentation.
RESEARCH PROBLEM 1: Does the lack of laboratory apparatuses have an impact to the
scientific skills of the junior high school and senior high school students of SJSFI?
Table 4.0 One Sample T-Test Statistics of the Impacts of Insufficient Laboratory Apparatuses to
the Scientific Skills of the Junior High School Students of SJSFI S.Y. 2019-2020
mean, standard deviation, and standard error mean of each skill. Also, it shows that Inferring
skill of the Junior high school students have a higher mean or average than the rest of the group,
while most have an equal mean value of 1.6250, which means that they have the lowest average.
Table 4.1 One Sample T-Test of the Impacts of Insufficient Laboratory Apparatuses to the
Test Value = 3
t df Sig. (2- Mean 95% Confidence Interval of
tailed) Difference the Difference
Lower Upper
Measuring (JHS) -7.973 31 .000 -1.37500 -1.7267 -1.0233
Inferring (JHS) -1.531 31 .136 -.37500 -.8745 .1245
Predicting (JHS) -6.524 31 .000 -1.12500 -1.4767 -.7733
Observing (JHS) -2.856 31 .008 -.62500 -1.0713 -.1787
Communicating
-7.311 31 .000 -1.28125 -1.6387 -.9238
(JHS)
Classifying (JHS) -7.072 31 .000 -1.37500 -1.7715 -.9785
Measuring (SHS) -10.933 79 .000 -1.27500 -1.5071 -1.0429
Inferring (SHS) -2.397 79 .019 -.36250 -.6635 -.0615
Predicting (SHS) -9.429 79 .000 -.88750 -1.0748 -.7002
Observing (SHS) -4.052 79 .000 -.43750 -.6524 -.2226
Communicating
-6.266 79 .000 -.82500 -1.0871 -.5629
(SHS)
Classifying (SHS) -10.351 79 .000 -1.32500 -1.5798 -1.0702
Scientific Skills of the Senior High School Students of SJSFI S.Y. 2019-2020
The table above shows the results of the one sample T-test namely t-value (“t”), degrees
of freedom (“df”), and significance level (“Sig. (2-tailed)”). The result above depending for
each scientific skill such as the measuring skill of the junior high school students can be
generalized and reported as t(31) = -7.973, p = 0.000. Due to the p-value being less than
percentage level of significance 0.05, it can be concluded that there was a statistically significant
difference between the mean score of the scientific skill compared to the test value of 3.0. Hence,
the null hypothesis was rejected. It can be also observed that the inferring skills of the junior high
school students have a p-value greater than the percentage level, meaning that it is not significant
and that the said skill was not affected by the lack of apparatuses since majority of the students
scored beyond the passing mark. However, based on the totality of the other skills from the
junior high and senior high school students, majority of their p-value is lesser than the percentage
error, and thus reached the decision to reject the null hypothesis. This implied that the lack of
laboratory apparatuses does have an impact to the scientific skills of the students.
Table 4.2 Mean Percentage of the Impact ofthe Insufficient Laboratory Apparatuses to the
Scientific Skills of the Junior High School Students of SJSFI S.Y. 2019-2020
Legend
The table above represents the mean percentage of the impact of insufficient laboratory
apparatuses to the scientific skills of the junior high school students. It shows that the mean is
11.75 while the standard deviation is 1.9576. The mean percentage is 48.9583 % and based from
the legend above, it represents a failing mark in which implied that the lack of laboratory
apparatuses has a negative impact to the scientific skills of the junior high school students.
Table 4.3 Mean Percentage of the Impact of the Insufficient Laboratory Apparatuses to the
Scientific Skills of the Senior High School Students of SJSFI S.Y. 2019-2020
Legend
The table displays the mean percentage of the impact of insufficient laboratory
apparatuses to the scientific skills of the senior high school students. It shows that the mean is
12.1125 while the standard deviation is 1.9369. The accumulated mean percentage is 50.46875
%. It also represents a failing mark based from the legend in which implied that the lack of
laboratory apparatuses has a negative impact to the scientific skills of the senior high school
students.
Table 4.4 Tabulation of the Scores of the Junior High School Students of SJSFI S.Y. 2019-2020
1 3 12 17 13 4
2 9 8 18 11 6
3 10 7 19 13 4
4 4 11 20 12 5
5 15 3 21 16 2
6 16 2 22 16 2
7 11 6 23 12 5
8 6 9 24 13 4
9 10 7 25 5 10
10 9 8 26 15 3
11 9 8 27 9 8
12 16 2 28 9 8
13 16 2 29 10 7
14 18 1 30 12 5
15 12 5 31 15 3
16 18 1 32 13 4
Table 4.4 presents the tabulated scores of the junior high school students along with their
ranking. The ranking ranges from 1-12 with JHS Student #16 being the highest with a total score
of 18 points out of 24, while JHS Student #1 is ranked the last with a score of only 3 points.
Table 4.5 Tabulation of the Scores of the Senior High School Students of SJSFI S.Y. 2019-2020
37 2 17 63 17 4
38 10 11 64 13 8
39 11 10 65 11 10
40 9 12 66 17 4
41 10 11 67 14 7
42 8 13 68 12 9
43 12 9 69 11 10
44 12 9 70 13 8
45 22 1 71 14 7
46 13 8 72 9 12
47 15 6 73 14 7
48 12 9 74 13 8
49 13 8 75 13 8
50 18 3 76 8 13
51 16 5 77 10 11
52 17 4 78 11 10
53 10 11 79 12 9
54 17 4 80 14 7
55 18 3
56 17 4
57 14 7
58 16 5
59 20 2
60 15 6
61 14 7
62 16 5
Table 4.5 shows the tabulated scores of the senior high school students along with their
ranking. The ranking ranges from 1-17 with SHS Student #45 being the highest with a total score
of 22 points out of 24, while SHS Student #37 has the lowest score of only 2 points out of 24.
The results showcased that insufficient laboratory apparatuses have an impact on the
scientific skills of the junior high and senior high school students as represented by their low
mean percentage and totality of the p-value of majority of each scientific skill being lesser than
the percentage error of 0.05. This low result can be affected by multiple factors caused the said
lack of apparatuses. Babafemi (2014) expressed that the use of laboratory apparatuses could not
be effective without properexposure to science process skills. The science process skills are
individuals should recognize central feature of an investigation is that if one variable can be
inquiry skills in addressing real-world problems through scientific investigations. However, this
facilities mostly affect it. Numerous surveys delivered information that inadequate availability
and utilization of laboratory facilities in the junior and senior secondary schools have major
effects in the teachings and learnings gained in school proving it to be a hindrance in academic
science process skills of the students. A similar study conducted practical laboratory activities
and has stated, “Results show that practical work has a significantly positive effect on learners’
performance. It has been previously reported that practical work (using apparatuses) potentially
improves learners' performance. Different types of practical work achieve different purposes.
There is practical work to achieve basic skills like: measuring, observation and recording, while
investigative skills include experimental design, analysis of data and drawing inferences”
scientific skills of the junior high school and senior high school students of Saint Joseph School
Foundation Incorporated?
Beaker 19 0.5937
Pipette 10 0.313
Cylinder 8 0.25
Crucible 7 0.2188
Microscope 6 0.188
Funnel 4 0.125
Syringe 2 0.0625
Table 4.6 Apparatuses Needed in the School's Laboratory Based from the Perspective of the
The figure above dealt with the Junior High School Student’s perspective on the
apparatuses needed to be improved in the wet and dry laboratory of SJSFI. Based on the table
above, it shows that the students wanted to recommend enhancement on common and basic
apparatuses in the school’s science laboratory. Figure 4.6 shows that the school needs a lot of
enhancement with regards to the advancement and improvement of the school’s wet and dry
laboratory apparatuses. Science laboratory affects the science process skills of the students. It
may positively affect the student’s skills when it is up-to-date and highly advanced (Halima and
Ngozi, 2015). However, it may also negatively affect the student’s skills when the science
laboratory apparatuses are inadequately available (Adeleye and Danjuma, 2015). Roth and
Roychoudhury (n.d.) investigated the development of science process skills in classrooms were
students spent most of their time doing experiments. Indeed, science laboratory is a unique
educational setting that offers opportunities for the development of students’ behavior that
constitutes science process skills, reasons why it should be in a quality of service and equipment.
More so, the science laboratory equipment and experiments aid in developing thescientific
learning amongst students, and in cultivating deeper andprofound interest in the field (Akani,
2004). School science laboratory supplies play an important role in the advances and
technologies being made in the world. Many of the world-famous scientists and researchers
develop their life-long interest in science in their school science laboratory only where they
conduct their first science lab experiments (Brooks, 2001). Hence, if the school’s science
laboratory is sufficient, students will able to perform laboratory experiments with adequacy and
thus enhance their science process skills (Halima and Ngozi, 2015).
Apparatus No. of Response Mean
Beaker 24 0.3
Cylinder 22 0.275
Microscope 15 0.1875
Thermometer 15 0.1875
Pipet 14 0.175
Flask 14 0.175
Crucible 8 0.1
Syringe 5 0.0625
Dropper 4 0.05
Multimeter 4 0.05
Figure 4.7 Needed Apparatuses to Improve the Scientific Skills of the Senior High School
needed to be improved in the wet and dry laboratory of SJSFI. Figure 4.7 shows that the school
needs a lot of enhancement with regards to the advancement and improvement of the school’s
wet and dry laboratory apparatuses. As seen above, it shows some of the common and basic
laboratory apparatuses. There were some Senior High School students who want to recommend
advanced apparatuses that they never tried using due to unavailability and insufficiency. Science
laboratory plays a vital role in the students in Senior High School especially those who take core
science subjects. Due to the insufficiency of some laboratory apparatuses, some students have
not able to perform the experiment well and inferred the needed result that they predicted, thus
closely related to the quality of learning its students will experience (Gavifkr, 2015). The
school’s laboratory is a facility where students do hands-on work. Hands on or practical work is
important to the development of the students’ science process skills (Omosewo, 2006). In Senior
High School, there is an academic strand which often utilizes the school’s science laboratory.
subjects under its curriculum namely; Biology, Chemistry and Physics. Students from this strand
generally desires to take science and engineering-related courses in their tertiary level and plans
to have a career in the field of medicine, engineering or applied science, thus the development of
these science process skills is essential and is a part of their curriculum. Hence, the school must
invest in up-to-date and highly advanced science laboratory equipment so as to give birth to
highly skilled and competent scientific and technological labor force and to assure the country of
a great future in the field of medical sciences and technological developments (SEI-DOST & UP
NISMED, 2011).
RESEARCH PROBLEM 1: Does the lack of laboratory apparatuses have an impact to the
scientific skills of the junior high school and senior high school students of SJSFI?
Lack in laboratory
apparatuses can
negatively affect our
science process skills
because we cannot
perform some
experiments.
Impact of Insufficient
insufficient laboratory
There is a laboratory apparatuses can
apparatuses to the negatively affect
negative science process the efficiency of
impact. skills of Junior and the experiement
Senior High School and also our
students. scientific skills.
Students cannot
develop their
scientific skills if
they cannot
experience doing
experiements.
Figure 4.8 Impacts of Insufficient Laboratory Apparatuses to the Scientific Skills of the Junior
The figures above shows the perspective of the respondents on the impact of insufficient
laboratory apparatuses to the science process skills. Figure 3.0 shows the perspective of the
respondents of junior high school to the impact of insufficient of laboratory apparatuses to their
science process skills. Their response highlights the negative impact of insufficient laboratory
apparatuses to their science process skills as it can hinder them from doing experiments which
can help with the improvement of science process skills. Insufficient laboratory apparatuses
hinder doing experiments which is a factor in the development of science process skills. In
developing science process skills, experimental learning (i.e. allowing students to physically
interact with objects) is required. Students must be engaged in activities and perform
experiments which they can experience a variety of science process skills (Mustafa, 2015).
Students cannot perform experiments if a facility such as a school laboratory has an insufficient
laboratory apparatus. There can be experiments that is required for them to perform based from
the teacher’s curriculum guide but they cannot perform it because of the insufficient laboratory
apparatuses. Insufficient laboratory apparatuses can also affect the efficiency of an experiment
which can also affect the student’s science process skills. A laboratory with insufficient
measuring materials cannot perform experiments that requires measuring or have to opt for
alternatives and these alternatives can affect the results of the experiments and these alternatives
may not be efficient enough to enhance students’ science process skill, particularly in this
example, the skill in measuring. According to Omosewo (2006) a deeper understanding of the
science process can be achieved through laboratory activities, which encourages active
participation and serves to develop critical thinking. School laboratories cannot provide the
students’ needs with insufficient laboratory apparatuses as efficient science teaching needs well
equipped laboratories (Mulela, 2015). Lack in laboratory apparatuses can negatively affect
students’ science process skills as it hinders them from doing experiments that are too
complicated to understand when only taught in the class. Practical work or experiments was seen
as both effective in terms of learning and enjoyment of science (Petty, 2009). Effective in terms
of learning experiments promotes retention of the concept and develops the science process skills
Insufficient
Impact of
laboratory Insufficient
insufficient
apparatus can
result to lack of
laboratory laboratory
apparatuses to apparatuses
experience
the science can result to
which
process skills of low science
contributes to
Junior and process skill
the development
Senior High
of the science levels..
School students.
proces skills.
Limited number of
laboratory apparatuses
can result to lack of time
in performing an
experiment thus we
cannot predict what will
happen properly.
Figure 4.9 Impacts of Insufficient Laboratory Apparatuses to the Scientific Skills of the Senior
The figure above shows the perspectives of the Senior High school respondents to the
impact of insufficient laboratory apparatuses to their science process skills. This shows that
insufficient laboratory apparatuses have a negative impact to their scientific skill. Limited
number of laboratory apparatuses hinders them in finishing the experiment on time and thus they
cannot collect the data properly and make a comprehensive conclusion. Predicting is one of the
science process skills and they have to include their predictions in writing laboratory reports by
the end of the experiment and since they only have limited time in using an apparatus because
the apparatus is limited itself, they cannot record proper conclusions. Practical work encourages
accurate observation and careful recording to make a phenomenon greatly real; to arouse and
maintain interest and promote logical reason (Watson, 2000). If students cannot perform
experiments because of insufficient laboratory apparatuses, they can have lower science process
skills, for they do not have the chance to develop them. Practical work provides students with
better understanding about the concept which they can use to construct knowledge as they go
along as opposed to experiencing it only through print material (Mulela, 2015). Experiments also
increases skill proficiency in many areas, including thinking abilities (Mulela,2015). Students
also cannot practice or enhance their science process skills because of the insufficient laboratory
apparatus. Development of science process skills is mainly hands-on work and thus they have to
be continuously exposed to this kind of activity to continuously enhance their skill and their
overall performance as stated by Usmani (2011), students with a lot of practical experience are
much more likely to perform well than those with limited practical skills. Hands on work also
promotes the development of cognitive abilities such as; problem solving, analysis, generalizing,
evaluating and decision making (Tilva, 2003 &Mafumiko, 2006) thus having a laboratory with
experience which contributes to the development of their science process skills. Practical
learning is essential for developing skills of various kinds; manipulative, inquiry, investigative,
organizational and communicative (Mulela, 2015). Further research has also shown that science
instruction needs to consist of direct physical manipulation of objects, equipment and materials
methods that allow students to use hands, eyes, ears and mind in studying science subjects
enhance effective learning and students’ achievement more than the teacher centered methods.
Motswiri (2004), indicates that teaching science should reflect the following goals: provide
concrete experiences and ways to help students confront their misconceptions, provide
opportunities for data manipulations through their use of misconceptions and provide
RESEARCH PROBLEM 2: What specific apparatuses are needed in order to improve the
scientific skills of the junior high school and senior high school students of Saint Joseph School
Foundation Incorporated?
Microscope, test
tube, beaker, petri
dish
Apparatuses
Wash bottle, needed to be Test tube
burettes, added to clamp, iron
Graduated improvce clamp,iron
cylinder school stand, tongs
laboratory.
Erlenmeyer flask,
Florence Flask,
evaporating dish
Figure 5.0 Needed Apparatuses to Improve the Scientific Skills of the Junior High School
The figure above shows Junior High School student’s perspective on the apparatuses
needed to be improved in the wet and dry laboratory of SJSFI. Most of the students suggested the
most common and basic laboratory apparatuses. It is imperative for schools to have the latest and
high-quality science lab supplies these days. Science is different from any other subjects for it
needs students to look beyond books and conventional classroom teaching for them to be able to
understand its context. Effective learning of science involves seeing, handling and manipulating
real objects and materials, thus sufficient laboratory apparatuses is needed (Science First, 2016).
Moreover, science laboratory equipment allows students to perform experiments with adequacy.
Wire gauze,
Droppper,
Microscope,
Multimeter
Test tube,
cylinder,
thermometer,
flask,
thermometer
Figure 5.1 Needed Apparatuses to Improve the scientific Skills of the Senior High School
The figure above dealt with the recommended laboratory apparatuses that the Senior
High School thinks that is need to be added and improved in the school’s laboratory. The
students’ scientific skills are established through science experiments and hands – on activities
that are done in the institution’s science laboratory. The student’s science process skills are
dependent on the students learning on their hands-on tests. However, there were negative effect
seen on the student’s scientific process due to unfulfilled laboratory hands-on experiments and
because of the unavailability and insufficiency of the laboratory apparatuses. Numerous studies
have been conducted regarding the lack of laboratory apparatuses and equipment, and its impact
in the learning processes of science-based subjects. In Halima and Ngozi’s (2015) study, the data
gathered from numerous surveys showcased that inadequate availability and utilization of
laboratory facilities in the senior secondary schools have major effects in the teachings and
revealed the poor performance level of students in science-based practical activities as it has
been proved that with higher utilization and availability in laboratory facilities and equipment, it
will result to having a higher number in passes and less failures in schools, and the lower the
utilization and availability rate, the higher the failure rate will be. Adeleye and Danjuma’s
(2015) study stated that insufficient laboratory paraphernalia results in students having negative
attitude towards the given subject specifically Physics and other science-based subjects which
impacts their performance level negatively. This negative and ineffective approach is often not
the result of the teacher’s teaching strategy, but because of the shortage of instructional
materials. Other impacts caused by the lack of laboratory equipment are circulated on graduating
students specifically STEM students as it will provide them difficult situations in ever pursuing
courses due to the lack of scientific knowledge and poor performance level that will limit their
qualifications in colleges if ever they are not exposed to laboratory activities and do not utilize
the said laboratory well enough - a reason why there should be an advance enhancement with the
This chapter presents the summary of the study, findings, conclusions, and
recommendations.
SUMMARY
This study was undertaken to determine the impacts of insufficient laboratory apparatuses
to the scientific skills of the junior high school and senior high school students of Saint Joseph
School Foundation Inc. It investigated the negative and positive impacts when data were
variable as scientific skills. It further probed the needed specific apparatuses to improve the
scientific skills of the Junior High School and Senior High School students of Saint Joseph
This study answered the research question on the basis of the hypothesis which is
insufficient laboratory apparatuses do not have an impact to the scientific skills of the junior high
school and senior high school students of Saint Joseph School Foundation Inc.
This study employed a descriptive mixed-method research design. The respondents were
the one hundred and twelve (112) junior high school and senior high school students of Saint
Statistical tools used in this study included one sample t-test, mean, standard deviation,
Junior High School and Senior High School students of Saint Joseph School Foundation
Inc.
The lack of laboratory apparatuses has a negative impact on the scientific skills of the
junior high school and senior high school students of Saint Joseph School Foundation Inc.
enrolled in school year 2019-2020. Results showed that most of the scientific skills of the
respondents were affected based on their result scores and answers from the interview
questionnaire as most of the students responded in either not having enough hands-on experience
in the laboratory or the said experience is not linked to their chosen career path. Only one skill
from the junior high school students is not affected by the lack of apparatuses which is their
inferring skills, however majority of the skills is affected along with the skills of the senior high
school students. Also, even though the senior high school students have a higher mean
percentage than the senior high school students, it is still a failing mark based on the percentage.
Therefore, the scientific skills of the junior high school and senior high school students of Saint
Joseph School Foundation Inc. are negatively affected by the lack of laboratory apparatuses.
2. On the Apparatuses Needed to Improve the Scientific Skills of the Junior High School
and Senior High School Students of Saint Joseph School Foundation Inc.
The apparatuses mostly needed to improve the scientific skills of the Junior High School
and Senior High School Students of Saint Joseph School Foundation Inc. based on the results
were the basic apparatuses such as test tubes, cylinder, and microscope. Specifically, most of the
laboratory experiments. Others responded in microscopes because most of the apparatuses were
not updated and do not function properly. Generally, the specific apparatuses needed have to be
in good condition and also have a sufficient amount in order to improve the scientific skills of
the junior high and senior high school students of Saint Joseph School Foundation Inc.
CONCLUSION
Based on the findings of the study, the insufficient laboratory apparatuses dohave a
negative impact to the scientific skills of the Junior High School and Senior High School
As a result of the findings and conclusions of this study, the following are hereby
recommended:
1.