Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ferguson (2006) Archaeology, Cultural Anthropology, and The Origins and Intensifications of War PDF
Ferguson (2006) Archaeology, Cultural Anthropology, and The Origins and Intensifications of War PDF
net/publication/273367168
CITATIONS READS
18 159
1 author:
R. Brian Ferguson
Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey
50 PUBLICATIONS 523 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
two books, Chimpanzees, "War," and History: Are Men Born to Kill?; to be followed by Hunter-Gatherer War in Tribal Zones: A Critique of the Hobbes-Darwin Synthesis
View project
All content following this page was uploaded by R. Brian Ferguson on 06 December 2016.
tD ITED BT
I W...e...". "",liln", th< ICCOnd dead. uf .rc...,..,I"8Y" diocovcryof ....... To
jIod", f...... ,lit moen' oa<Lcration of pubUnti(ln• ..,d te\<"",h lop;.:.. il !l«m.
«ft.in 10 become . "'.jot- 6dd of study (Bray ]986, Camw. 1m, Camun ... d
Ha,dln& 1999; ~urnn and Fnycr 1m, <>-sky andJum 1994, RI« and U-
ELl l..t 8f.TH N • .t JU;:US H AND M A JlK W . ALL EN Slone: 2001 : n>auk and ViYWI 19l!9). n.. ~ if no) k>ow:' whcthn. bo"
whither, .... -haroIos7 of war! How ...aJ archaeolopcal m.o.y and finding>
dndopl How will dwy.w..: ro..ublw..d inl<rcu In ",1Nnl ... duopoioc;] I
Whao: """" ioou<s,..;ll archaeoIosY ...... 1n.. pounri>I ""'oodi..1 iml-"' of aJ".
chIotoIosY is Fat. AI ... ..., in this >eIwn<. .,;min and 0C1'0tI rqional KqIIOII<"
""'.. is lI<m<:ndouo ~ vo.rUbiIi<y-in ........... m.." ...... Ioro(..... or
Uttlt ''' ........ ~ from raid. 10 imperial conquest. and In d.ufydiKinniv<
• pluto of mmW'l' ~. Thu mlliury nrUbm.,. pi' alone; .. imnri.oon ;n
maloriol cimunounca and _i.al ... d political otructufft, proridins abun<Un.
BOO matcrl.ol ro. thtotr on w t • ..,.. ... d <On><qu<n< .. of .... t. While ethnog-
im
... oporu '0 ftgh, .. And new i'~"'10 light ave,; :u>d cWm. <Iw: th.torim who fixw on Ewvpt. <>p«i>.lly Franc<:.:and provid •• n .1""", "",,","hd.ning romp;·
"""'. til< impotl2tl«of ronroct "denythc: ,,*timacyof«hnov"phyo!,~" !orion of dcWl«l bruulity. Akhough the: IV'-'" m2j0rity of thrir ni<lcnc:c i> from
( 199&21 ). the N«>l i.M. and b,«. ,h.,. ......-.pobtc <h .. >ioIe:nc< in... ...t.... ,i ...... when:
S,miW pooirions an: od""""'N by ocI><n fOIlowi ... K«Ie,·.I..d. !.cBLmc: ....h mdcncc is baing. with mooning...do .. thio: "n.. .heory d... onrf....
and Ri« (2001 :~) ope>l of"~ gcncnI n<>idanc< of"'" ,opk' of wu in .... tIm.- occurr«l in ,he Upper I'>lcoIithic _;'ba af th< 'lIb< occm, ",ri..:ly pbuoiblc.
poIog" U'a\ln (2001 >:573) 8'lC" from no","" til< genu",. t.d. of m ..n:h on in _ of.he ....... an' kYel. of oggrasion disphyd by p....nr-day hunring
d<.>m< .... .nd other "inl<maI' ~ among "",,·ouo< peopLes '" imply t/u, f"'Pul.>riono ...do .. thc: American Indian. (200s:21). Thil il porn.cIy the rypc
r.-.. an,hropologm' 1uY< nudicJ war: .nd d.iRU <Iu. "(. )h. ",arch lOr .... n<!i«. of .unpol.tion .M. chaptc. argues Win".
Lest.viol<n' w.y '0 organi'''' OU' _W aK.i" h.. Ix<n frui,Lest. All Ute <VMttoce Now ,hi, debar< Iu. been join«!. ."d complical.d.try> On.mein (2004: lO -
,ugg"" .Iu. p<a<cn.1 period. have ...... )'1 bc.:n pun<tI!,,«l by epi.oo .. of "":l'. IS. 41. 4). 98. In_180. 199). • founding ~gu .. in ,he .n,hropologyof W:lr. who
f... and 'iol,,,,,. (2001> :590). Lc Blmc (1m: 10. 1l) .... ,,' ,h >< ", he . ctu.1 ''II'''' ,Iu, ,h... were two ><Kiological ''''''ing f'<Jin<> of war. ·Ih. follOwing i<
lik.hh<><><l of .he.. being a prchi"oric inl<, ..1of.....-..1 hund,«l yt".". duro,;on • very <impl... "i""
of . complex "gum.n,: Roiding and .. "bu,h """. a n. ru·
wi"""', .ny .... ,f......"'. "".n," >nd foil""", Keele,:' dl,ml...! of <h. impar:t of ral o.ltg<OW,h of m ...·«"tcr«l. big.pme hun« ....!>o ......1.. ><Iy orproitcd
W."..., conracl .... ring "the colonio! impact expl.>n ..ion ><em. do.. '" being fo< <oop<mivc killi"$- Such "'If ...... d fOr ",iIlion. af ynr. and In> .>p<ciilly
.,,,!.on
I.>;d '" ...... Sevcral regil • .,. ntyi",d.gr<" of.... poicw.. .ho"" th< ';g. common in ,n.
P.alroli.hk. In """e oms.. 1.>... ohili '0 btoad 'pee''''''' fo<"f;.
nifKanc< of .h. """'P="'. arrir.d fOr indigef1O<U ..,,(or< ( !l.mfOnh Im~· ingbfOkc "I' ,ho, p""""mJ W>l dioappnn:d. "The abtcn<c of onr pruri<W th<
'17. Ill : t...mlx .. 2002:203: !.c1!Unc :u>d Rio« 2001:6, W..n:.r 2OO10:570{). _.-.,. .oubiUty hx pian. dome>tication ... occut-~ion could no<
K~" pooitioo. on thc: ubiquity.,( pn:h im>ric: ...arf>r< tw IK<:n oJIimwd :u>d luppen ..uh wu. Snded I>rm<nrould b'er uk< up ....... fo< int<an« to corurol
uUn to I new Ic-vd;" !.cB1anc with ~<f (lOD}). This boollOru.c. IIIOC"< ,rode I"0Il''''
bu,.t.ac that wv ..... poac,"'.!. <"I1>Iucion ... I ..... ...,.,jd .....
on .m-ot"l}<."d is h critical.,( culnmJ .."hrop%&i,..· ..... n:h.1hough ooout. For •• ,,,.. '0 <m<rg<. W>r mIlO< bt .bo<n. prior '0 the coruoIidation of
in 1"""" . r<jcca an <mplusis 00 Eun>pan ronu" (2003:6). I" thro«tic:tl
pcin. i, ,hn rhe ida of non·,ut<: J><opLes bei", ron,,"alionilU is I my~ :u_
al""""" ....,..
-",,",imal <hod<lom ..• wt. .. h "'" · i.... hoaIe ou....•
ul< I'ioIcnc. in in.. ma1 f""rloruJ wugks. rcp<<WoM and fnodL When ><a,c>
typka/ chim
guing .hl. P"I"'I.>,ion growth",d r<:tOUn:c depktion is ",Iu, h.. made .... '" .""'W. ,hey «in"""' ...... ."d wor .p.. ><I, ,h"",gh .. cond...,. 1Orrnari<>", ex·
common-I , i ...., hx lOod (2003:9). 1Iu, hypo<hcoi' i, no< ..b'.n, '" !hi, poocd 10 ,h.m. Among ,,;n.W>rring pmc h u",en. dorntS,;c" .., can 'P"..! fro m
elupt«. WhO! is "'y " lev"" h, .. is tho .... <lion of ,h. n.., uni ...... lityof .... r ,h.i, O,iginal .enl< .... ."d long·'ime form." can I..,n W>l try> in« ...... io" wi, h
'hroughou, ,h< .«lurological rerord (oe, .1", !.clllo"< .• hi • ....,Ium.). hu" ..... ,hOI' upl.oining the w.rf..r. af mmy non ·)ta ••• grioulrurali< ... Underly·
ing ,hi, ,h.ory i. O".rbcin'long..",.bli,hed pooi,io" ,fu, _ial org=in,ion
When ,he .. i... g<>od ,,<!urological pic,u", of any _iet}' on £",10. .ncre
.. al"""" .......,.. .be <Yid<nce of .... rfa .... .. We nt.d ro rocogniu >nd
fo< .onllic, .. ",.,.. i"'porum ,fun canllic, ..... ,.,.n:. '<IOU"" in gtnttating
.c«p< ,n. o<k. of .. nonpca<<ful JU" fOr <he enri .. time of hwrun m,· ~ .
Ot:,<rb<in·, po<irion .. ......, diflmn, from ,hOJC of Keclcy:and !.cBlmc. and
«n«. Though. thc: .. ~e rcrt.J.inly ,imes.nd pI.oca dwing ..... icn pna
pr< ...,I«I. "",,,,U. _h int<rludeo ...... .., Io.aw bt .... ,,-,.I;... d ..,d in·
......up. with min<:. in tha, it rocogniuo "".. are:u .......... ithou, 0I"2f fOr.....,
long pcnook The big dillmna oownn III ... that ............... pncric..:J by
!rcqu.n.. ... [ rc:diud <Iw: ~ Iud ...,,(.... in JJ ,im< pmods. .. .
hi.·....... h"",cn,:u>d cndins with. ohifi '0 more .. d<n...,.~. while
(200):7.'. <m9luois in orig>ruI)
l.ntl"""" .... ~: th.u ..... O«m> ab.uM in .... NeoIi.hic. :and ..... ,...,.
Ih< .dirorial lead in • nugWD< .. pooitioo of hio th<ois ..o,li: · Hunun. Iu", I 6... WIth more....w ~ (although ""'" of thc:m .... pcaccabk). Evidence
b«n •• - " <>the .... ,h..,... .ince th< d...., of .... r 'f'<Cic' (!.cBUn< 2003: 18). ~rdlnl th.u disrinction 1I'ill be noted .. i, ro ..... up.
Guil.&in<:u>d Zlmrni. {200S:",-~ ZO·Zz. 06- Z40 (m ....h <><igirul ZOOl ]) III >$I<r1i ng thc: deep :!Iuiquity of ...... both Onem.in ",d !.cBl""" ..ly he~.·
foU ...... Keele)' in .mplu":r.ing pn:hi>toric .ioIenc •.• nd porm.yins .rcluoologr ily on til< wort. ofRi<1wd Wungham",d ",h... (IC. Wibon and Wr>.nglu.rn
.nd .n.nropology •• having .<lificiaUy p.ofied ,h... rord. Th.y do not ...."
I 2003, Wn.ngh.m 1m) "" inICrgrotIp .icknce .mong chlonpan"'L !.cBI.nc
.hat.:ll p..hi.lOric peopl.. h,d war. bu, '<gu' ,h .. i, waf .ery rommon. They mJ Regl'''' (2003:86) orguc: "1f chimp.... <¢> have. fOrm of warfare. then it
,
1
,
,;, ~_ '''t-- ~, r~, ~ ,....I ... u,;z-.-J"'-f<_'f!!;" r;
c.n be l""'umeJ th.t .,.., fo' ••Hl .....lling .""" •..,.. ('urly homin;'!.' 0, protO· To " .... ",<en uk up the<!>I", ,h.t .."ltropology Ir.u ignor<J w;u. Th.n " ...
hum .... ) prob>l>l, do.! tOO. bccaux h"""n. and dumps.r< SO si ,nilu." indud ,ru.-fony run ago (h'5"son 1984> ,6). no< m<>r< ",«nd,. CompU.
In«w""p ,,,,I,,,,,, .mong <himpuu«t. and ill impli<a<ioru fo,- h,omon"Y. inga bibliogr~y of >IIb... n,loJ rn.~1 dixo"ion. of""", (i"dudi,,/!:
;,a ""., Wge .<>pi< ..... i<h i.~ua«d in abook I .... "',,'<endy pr<p>ring.ln tI... ~y) in 1987; ... qui. >IOUnd I.SOO .i"non.. benux the .. wos no <rul
wolk I ug... tI... the numbct of <himp...- ,n«'l""'P lriIlinp II» bea> ~ if..igh. (1'<rfI""'" ,..,th Fomgiw:. 1988). Th< lit<r.ntrc ~ grown by bps and
F"tod. that wh .... InNl .....,..n«n occu'. they pL"'sibly....,. be ...ri!:>u.d to bound, silK' then. Even Ott<rbcin' ( 1999) him••yof ""thropoIogiallC1C2t(h
<itaim"""".. <rUttd by ..«nt human 0<';"';"" ...d duo tht.. .. no h2>iJ "" on W1I \nJ romctIy .riticiuJ by Sporud (2000) and Whil<hc.d (2000) for
pm;<ing beh>Yionl conri"" i., of in.srOOJpIout 'poup ~iIi')' and kilIinc i" .... ~ <ntin: ...,.. of CW .. N .......h in,o 0I'2f and otha <oIloctiv.: Yioltntt
tnn>irion froon .pc <0 h..,....,. Thooe low.. nnnoo be di!CUJSt'd ~. <2<<p< <0
<>pin< tha, <himpanu< be ....... '" 1"""'..... li •• 1o support r... dtc pn<ti<cof w;>t in
lou"...,i.,·. di .. an, p.>ft.
An:.,..u.cu..mg the cloimp.vu« -.w. I.-Blanc and ~ r2i>< "" ide.
with nujo< oigoifia.nc<. "If wan_ ~ bo.n pm: of the hwrwI COR<iitlOfl r...
mot< dun. mmiorl J'H" (0 .... mm"", yan. dcpe""-in«on the run " -).
I
1
(and _ Fnguoon 2003). TdIUWr........ Ittum&rional ..hi",,,, tIororUtI.re
-looi:int fa, ~Is of ..... In ><Rh~. H= is hmr """ prominent
poIi<icaJ tci<rtri>. c~ ...,htopolop:al rfi<arch,
For dc.c.da. "'~'" " - bun .......in«. theor«icaJly ridt. Crt>-
piriaJly ..."'tonriol. and ..... hocloJoskaUy od(·."",<c body of .wi><icaJ
and nx-.dy ~...,h on tho "l"ion<hlp bawem W>r' and culrurc in
.., jun might bo .. kaod foe boh>Vion d... t mole ... W21iikc:" (2003,219-210).
Although oh<y I" on to qualify the ouppooition, tI... id.. succin<rly idrnti!ies
...we. ....let... and prt.indwuial""",hic .,....rm. (SnyOO Z002: II)
~hy the .nriqui.y of ...., it luch "" Impo<UJlt iJru<. AI ...d,. ""'" w!to ug... Hu ... th"'1'olo,,, ponr>)'<d .... by non ·..... pcopk< .. ~jlU" ri.....Jo<
I
for. human biolopcaJ prop<n!i'y foe ....,..., ciri"t! K«ky in "'pport (Fun · • pn< .... im I'n.....wt ... , Apin. thi, OR« "'U truc.lon~ogo. ""...diet (1959).
YO"'" 1995,26, G.. 2000,16~, low ZQO().lJ}, Pink<, 2OOZ:S6-S7, 'it'il"", Ch.>wI< and Coon ( 1942). Cod... (1m). lexh ( 196~). Mo.1inmo1w (1941).
199K341; W=gham 1999:18)-dcspi .. tl>< filet th .. K«I.y (19%:1$7-159) N.roII (1966)•....J No:W<'OIt\b (196(l). did .. y m.. primitiw: comb ....... largdy.
loim><Jf disavow. biology 01 "" .. Itv""t." Now the c;",k i. <ompl«<. While .hou,
ritual wi &K" conl<q~¢"",. s.,,,,,ral .. her <o,1y wri«n. oo....a. portrayed
,M" orch.. oIot!b<> »fob.b), would agr« ",'h Und"hiU (thiJ volwnc:) .b.. it wor ...I<.dly .. rio~, ...uggk Invol~in8.; ..I....."",a (Hunt 194O;J>blow 19W,
iJ mOf< prod",,;.. t~ f",~, on .It< <til... and """""lu.n«. <>f ....... ...10" "thrn
.ndklSly J.boting w,,«h., in........ K..1.ioKn« it . n inh<r=t p.r. of h~m.n
noture" - .h •• <l<b". il in<I.. ~k (0' arc/l.1rology. Like i. 0. n",. ,h< .",h:oco-
logiel r«<>rn i. « nt",1 '" thi< p<rennial <jlKlrion in \'(b«m rultw •.
I Lowit 1942: Sccay 19S3: Sw.deslr 1948).0 ...,bel" (Im,794-799}_who ori.
'iqu.. K« k y; hi.,o,y ui ,n. anthropology of ""' ••• ina«um •. and for h.,.-
ing <...« .1 hI> own "myth of the WHlrk< ""'S'" ( 1997)_d<><. ><knowI.dg< •
"myth of the p<"".1i.J1 ...
--I"
>g.: p<nb,ing 01 I"... 1980. Bu, be,id" 0I'0s< .arly
<1,..lon. I jw, 1i.,«I. h'I',owid •• no 'no .. re«n,
",ulg,lOing!lu' my'"
'IX' o( . nohropologiru pro.
to qu",ion tho pco«.blo inuga about "Buslrm.n.
T it t ANTH ROPOLOGY O f W~ R .. I< I) T H . 1$$".
Pygrni ... and Sonui' (1999:79~ -798). Exh of tl""" ..... i• • m*,. debate in
OPWUTU .NCONT"'CT
I i<><lf. ....J cann'" be ,,,,,,idored hot ..
In tho p~nt. tWO ""h,opologi<:tl 'p«;.I,,,. on wor and p<"". Reyn.
And.ropologiel Vi,ion.
(J99'US- S6) and Spons<I (2000,8)7}_ and only ,no.. <wo '0 my knowl.
Wh<ther orchxoloa;1," a 6dd.1us wiUfullytum<d 'W>}' froon evkIclK< of... r. I odg<-"'l'" ,/1.1, ""U.<.I...Iok.... by <omJW'U,..1y <soiliari1n non·... '<
leo"" to archxologi>u coeval ...... In m, !nding. it _ nri>bl .. CIurIy tht.. pcopt.........ld be I<I'"""od «>n«p<uaJ1y ftnm .he C1I<g<><)' 01"""......li.J.od by
\nJ ... iSt""" to .. knowk~ 0I'2f in .Ir.t Arn<ric1ot Southwc.o. (Solomno, thit .... pn<<k< of ""'" <tntraliud rnd hicnn:hical poIi<i<o (ohough "'" n«...rily
volum<). bu, ,h.i..... of p",histOtl< 0I'2f in tIr.t A"",rican s.",.heaK Ius bttn x - ......}. Sinc< the mid.196OI if no< .>..Ii.r. the n .. ....;on')' 01 ""thropoIogicoJ
ti~ly diocu>Kd r... IIUJI}' )'un (0,.. .• hi. YOIu ..... j. Widrout qt><>tion. ~.
! wri.ef> "'Y< ogre..,! , ..., """"'Il non' ''''. pcoplQ. "'21: _ ..,.., common and
tht.. is much mon< ~"" •.d inwm in .... t<>pi< to<by rIurt <ftft • dcade 'AIry <OttJ<'<]lK'nliaJ. both In ~.., and in io impaa on culrurn. f'eow if any
'I!O- My 6"" con«1'tl h... i, n", ",th ... ~. bu. hmr K.:d<ydwact<rl= WOlIId 6. ,he <.... lIetmurion on " .... 1Itf-'c CitnliuritM. w.. ja<ln. th.u "fa,
the """'''''anthropology of ",,,of the p.u< forty ~ the Iut Iifry)'<an. _ pc>pulM...d ><hobrty wor1:.1oaw ap;rccd rJu;: f"C'h;ru,ri<
~
,;. , R._ "'r-
......
wan,,.. ...... ""'. ""rnbs. u",ml"''''''''' ."d .. . a di>us< of <n-iliud JO<ietia
A. r.". my ""'" vi<w 011 .... , (N"'" ,hio .... I><<n ..,..l<.., i,,,,.). my lim pDf>.
impor...... ofb.-inging in ,oloni.Ji,m!lu, hod ro oIitn been ill>"'red. anJ ...
....."'...... of ,1M: burgeoning c-thnohis<oricl..,d rcgion.t litcruwa du, """"_
of·f•• ely do<wncn .. d ..or .. belnz hizhl]' ruponsi"" '" .... ngi"tl con .... cir·
[i>h<d ,..,.,"'!. (Fcrgu"'n [984b,Z69). 011 No.,h""", c.-. .... ~ ..... aplic· cum ... n.... 6", hiofO', ..... paracliynuinll, ...!...J<tl from anthropologiaJ
idy in JOPP"'" ofSwa<l<$h·. (1948) view oI'i, a, kth.J ..,uggk for .... 'cri.J goin. theory OR ~. The goal of'BIood of rhc len.....,,· (Ft"""", (990):u\d W....
>pirnf Cock,..·. ( 19S0) .;c... tha< it ..... cnnn<M"li&l,..;dt fc... n.1U.Jties. ;" tbt TnAJ Z- (ft"""",...d Whitdon.! 2000.0<1g. [992) """ focw '0
•.,..n;"" OR hiMorial~ 'o~n thoomially =ppinschc-io dimm-
Nonbwo. c.-. wuf.o .. _ .... pme ..• onr -dc.dlr "";""'~c.
Yon. and ........ ....t brdoint! 00. =- the foundaciOll for. ~ ",.tisOc ......
Sncak ....d<s. pi«h..! ... ,tIn....,buohes. ~ .uririonalnmpoignJ.
fOr ""ploining wu.
,rnchnow ""' ......... ~i< ,aiJtn,-th<>< .... ,.. fxu oflt&: room 1><.
for-. conu« '" -p"'ihation' in ,h. 186(1,. . .. W'n......... in Wg< put..
Amons an~ the .. ..., Jisnificanc di!!"e .. ncn in " - the impo<t
of co[" .... ho. bc.:n conccpnoaliud 61ick ( 1988)-""" made the li.m broad
roo<<it <>on con,roI of v.J....,k mowccs. ..• U'.an ""+,
"""I]' to "'I""'"
K2fftn<n, on the i - . I"0f'00<'. q""",ioarivc dirjou>ction. be,W"" Iimi,..!
<ctrnKJ<liol tid .. "'......, omn to """ been ,ac. dc:spi.. the prominrn«
g;...... to thi. _ in nJ.nosr>phi<t. (Ft"""", 1m, Lll-134) <nmg< 6zh<in8 bcfon: conuct :md g''''''''.w ..... t... atta. I do "'" agee with.
cith .. hiJ g<ncr.t dunr:tcriurion. '" thc idn of. q.wi ...m brta -R<vc"ll"-
"That wud ,I", cit .. art~ tvid<n« '" cWm dw_ • war rompla wen' i, more ,n idiom d..n 0 C2U>< of¥,,,,, (FtT - I"Sa:J~ If. F<rgusort
b.w:k '" >bou, 1000 S.C.-. llh""", now 1 would po ......., 1(1 2200 B.C... ZOO5 ). En«mi"",'" ....."',.. """";m.. luppcn. """'" 1\0<1 ...... people..
I.... (..., bekrw). In .lion"..... the Ih<on:riaI .igroi~ ofWaum ",nu« .as in ,be -u,crn Grc>! PW ... (Bamfor'h. <hI' volume). and is ...marLbk evcn
(199'lHJII) n:pdUt, .... , by Amuon,'" p<OI>ks.l_: ·/'IS..,. i,.,wpuuhk alia ron ....... in ..... ruhtr n'rem< .... of the Maori (All<n, ,his volume).
1m rh.t, .....oju< uiJI.J ill AMo/U"'" i>rJ-,IH .m...J .j"~_. (omptw;. The posi. ion ~ by NcU WhiKhnd anJ mpdfio ..... Wencrn co,,·
in ,he otigin.ol), ,n" for Nonh ."" Sou,h Amerit>. "Even in the .b.eoc. of :my ..., g<ncr.tly ,.....!formd. (req""n"r in"n'ifird. HId oomcci ..... gmc ..... d war
",'c •• ",h_logy p<'O>"id<. "nmin.kobk nidt"". of...., >mOn~ ocdcnuty va· in .... n.i"" .rc.. we ..1I·,nb.:ol wn ••.·for ,h" rcuon. h 10 . miotili '0 Un '
["tic pc<>pko. """"01 ..... going b.o<k ,houun<\. of ye .... ( 1992: 113). Finilly.,prior critk.tly prot«< hillOn..I!y reco.dcd wa, In'tcm. in,o pm.im>ty. Any .!fo"
'0 tho public.."", of JI~, &fort Ci~J..I<1i"". [ (1997) hod <ompkfcd.., .... y ill <0 . .pl.in hio,on< .... ,ra..•houlJ i""Jud. hi.. oti< <ondi. ion •. • hh""zh th ... by
,..., con'''' p<riod pro<ase. Iud prolOwtdly B<5"n.. off«.. on indis=<>w d~iunt io whtthn Of no< W>f «;,ud befOr.t W<IU1'n contxt.Of bdO<-e ......
ptopIn u.d "'" an ..umHuDon of thooc ,ff<rtl i, _«I>ry in ""1""""1" '0 ..io<od. To my koo""'dp. no one in rnntcmpocuy .... hf<lPOlogy oup;g<JtI tIw:
"'" pot<~taC1 infonnnion to iUum""" f"'<CO"DCI wop oIlife..· Lombrn'. i. did not. Funha•• inc. I do no< J>O<i" quah, ..;,.. b.a1 in thc r...m 01 .....
(200z,l08-UI9) 0YUTicw ofNortJ. Am<rican _Iu<oIop:al...;o._ for wu befon: and ali" con"",. I = "'" .wpris<d to 6nd p.. hiHoric Ii..... tioru ..n,.
.,....... ,I>< nluc oI.n:h>«>logy h<aw< i."r.:.:.....
on £ lim< bc:fon: We><<m ,............h Of <ICed thc .ioJcoc. >lirr concac .. Nom. ......erican _h>eology
£wop<<>n .. pan';"'" roloni>li.m. and om.. procnoa "",.kcmI the ch;t.>«<t (and .... ybe boJond) ",nil in<:vitlbly had..! for • conk .."", htlcd ",""",ing
..nJ ,..j«.oryof """y indiw=n",,' A.-...rkan .od.,i ...• \I:',ll.,. (1001 b) .... dc· ILk< • 1250 A.D." <0 .ontp...,:uinly 0llfI\'''' "''''';w
.he and ...;o.>pt<:..! viokncc
..U.d ,h.......iv¢, ,"Iy >ruI conlinui,,!!. dixup<;on ."d dcnructi<>n of N..i .. In ,h< ,h,.. «nturin 0< 10 brxhting ..... w«. Bu, ."en.ion ohould >bo be
... ,1><,.;.'>11 l"'''Pk ..,d JOCkli .. on ,h. Sl'",i,h bo,derlands ofFloriw. And <v<n v<tn to .h. period from 14SO to 15so. or .... ,o.,k ifth .... ....... k.,..ningof
wl,h .11 ,he p"hi;roric ",.nl'" in North Am<Tic> •• m:cnt!y dct<ribod 'Il1dy by "",u.1 vlolen« in bc:fW«n .hi! rim, .nd.h<: ~ ....!f« .. of Eu"'p.,n,. Only
\'t'>.lx<1' (1.""'"",,i 2002, A9) of OV<T 4.~00 .kcl«onJ: .n:h.. ok>gy <>n I<"'''''ruCf b ·.10 of viol,n« f"'lIl b<h.>« :u,d th=gh con.
t . ., .... d <ould invc .. iga<o_lO. in".... e_wh .. h<:. changing kvell of viol.nce
found tha< ,h"", from .li., Ch'i!<oph •• Columbus l.ndcd in th< N<w
><eomp.>.ny \l;h"tn guo<I. filtering in through 'r><k n.. w..... I11 ... M"d)on.Jd
World lhowtd I .... , of ttau""tic injuries mom th>.n 50 ]><1'W't higher
(1979) did for fort.buildi"!! .....,.;,,«1 wi.h pro«>hisroric "",<land orad< '0 the
than thooc f'ru.n before the Europ<:oru armro. "Trawna.ti< Injuria do in·
r;t<;!ic Non/tw".. eo....
erfi$C «>1Ir sitlni!icantly. .... Th .... findings ""88"" ·N..;... Am<rican •
..__ ;n"",.. d ;n ......., viokncc ali« the Eu~..... orri • ..! rtun before. Orifi...
. . .. Walke. >aid th .. .Jthoush 1»" of thc inc~ inju'1 "' •• doubt·
........... from .ioInK, by whirc. thrrn!e1Ycs. I. ptcI>ably fl:1kcts .......ty
.... ,"'..,..·.....i .. >ioIen~
Bu, the ~ of WU " " ' " bo VU)' ntd"ul no< to.on8ae ~ prehio<ory
In North Amrnc:o Of...,...hcn ......ith.JJ prehi>wry. wt... _me>
1000. in "".,.. _nion< .Ju, ""hio<oric ....ru~ could be pretty taribk io the
>«1ft'I
All""," «>mmrnU rd." <0 NortJ. AIn<rin. The twO .hapun in th i. ""'WI>< .u,
"""" """ll>can. 'f""'ion of em we idrn <ify .., oripn of w ... Of .... ; , ......,...
,h.. focUI dlt«t/y on the im~ of'll:'<>«m "FW"ion mak< du: poin. fV<n bccn wirh ",1 l>I..,yhow conduded .Ju...... ;, a ~luiv<ly u.. human Invention
m<>rt fotc.fully. Th. 1>1..,,; ,.«, hi. wi.h ,h< fuU fins< of <on .." .If.«., ""'" (Ch ild< 1942; Fenilll985; O"Connclll99S; RC>p<1" 1%9. 1975, V.., dc. Dennen
piAn .... nlm.I •. econontje oPP'muniria, .oot.. ."d ,bovc .II. guru. They end,,· l?9S, 18(1- 214, Vond 1984, ll(1_lll ). 1am cu,,,,n.1y followins in rh,i, foon'<p~
".."" n.... i.. l«iopolitic,1 ch.nge ,nd r<"'o.king of <u l,u",1 theme .. kuling working on • global N' vey of Itcn .. ologiw .vi.un«lO....." from .ko .lIli...
,o.n uploo,on of w"f... ,"'t kill.d Wou. on ... hhd of .hoi. popul>fion in indic1tQ" up '0 .h, .dvm. ofhiotork>1 tc<oni!.
,hi,,~ ),<0'1 (AHm. thil volume). Propl .. of E." Af,;" "'cr. suppl;"! wi.h gum So wh" ii no .igru of w.... r< found in ...ly "".. rio.lll, i. oli.n ,,;d rh ...:th.
lOr dovlng:and ,he i",.y ,....d •. ic..J.ing <0 no< on!y maui .. mort.Ji.y ;n .aid.. sen« of <vidrn<. " "'" ",den" of .bom.:,: V.. ...... I.."" tc<ov"o.l>l. ,rxn,
bu. fo<wI dispw,."",nu:and ,co!ogic.J dennocdon. o.Iong ..i<h funinn:and lndimon of vioIenc •• or coIicaive violence. in ••"icm<n, ltId ili:ktal rcnwru.
d""'..... mad.: ...,..,. if""" =-l by thc...1wtga (K.uimba. thi. >O!ume). ....opons.l.IId ... how I>«n <CVi<wdruc...t.a.: (Fuguoon 1997,311-1Z6; r...m.
'!he poont oflrib.J.zonc dxo'1 ;, th .. ""?"~ in thc """"'" ... h...., colo· ben lOOU09-2U, lcBJ.ncwith JleKi.... 2003,S8-6-4). ilr"""" IhqohouJd bc
ni.li<m i. Irnplnsing. "",,<dod ... <hr< ""'''''' be •.r.... Of .. po .... ,...... of",,· VU)' "PJ>U""'.0 ....den of <hi>...tumc.. Y... the .... P'cndo.,lot .... tioru obou,
<OnW"l viole_ "",U ood ........ hiocotical r....... poooobly .............png coIIcc· ... icIc"ce. G....... tIy. the cWlUnJ pcn<t>« of ..... is """'" visible tfy" .....wn. of
.n.. viokn« "'" in~ted. Th>< ;, • "'*" diff.r«>« ","","n the .pprooch
ad ....... d h... :and th.u of Kccky. lcBJ.nc. Gu .... l'" :and urnmi •. O"..bcin.
>C1lI.I.1oIcnce (Arl<mh. <hi> ...twne). Fonib;ons. ......... rion. and ~
to inocc ... ibk Ioa,iuntall cnuilc-.. and ....ybc for>akcn when wu aioto bu,
• ...1 •..any Ofhe . .. ...ho <OnMu. to .k.criloc ..Ju>osnpItJC.lly reponed .... <hr< only .. low kv<1o (SoIomtro. Allen. ,h;, volu_). E• ." ... h......... is ;l\Ion.h~
•• ifi, ttpl'U<n...n ...rIC. ph ... of "",iCtIJ evol.,;On. h may be , .... ,.11 ;, no< • .,,~ tal ..... of """"iv< w=-milinS .od.J groups nuylad oIoviow .igru of war.
dnrn •• i<olly incfl:-a by <en,ac.-.h< OJ'P<>< irc m.y occu.-bu, , t..cl of im- ""..,in8 """...1><<1 .hould look .roon,d ,h. edga (11..,,,ror,h, Arltwh. Conn.n
p.>C' can"", bo .... m.d. .nd SUv<""in. ,hi • ..,Iurne). Sklctal mo.eri.J m.y be .bund.",. bu. uneum·
1<;, unf'mun ... rh .. tho qu<!tion odd, .... d In .<Ome I'«en •• «!urological ;ned f<." .r.l.u rn .... in ... Iy Chin. (Und.rhill. thh ",Ium.). i"t wnen ,kcl.",n.
>
"'" ... min<J. w... ig"l llww up. Of in .... No"h Am<n<'On Sou,h.... (Dye. ,hi. di>. from 34.000 S.c. '0 8,000 B.C. indud • •ipu of viokn« (&ch«hi « aI.
n>lum<), and in New Z.aland. wh.", violence is ",ry d= in. rot:>J ..... pI< of 1m, 137: G"il.iJIc and Zamm i, 21)05,50; K•• ky 1'1%:31; '-"rndon ",d Schild
...... , than • hunJ",J (A1k ... ,hi. \'OIum<). 198&61. i~) ( no< iJl<tudlngJ.bel Sahoba(>t N(>tth Ame,,,,, below). A, I=t one
1M", . nJ ott- <On'~nj unMrsun..l.bI, ....k. many ...h;orologist> ,<IIK- of tho.< is Mnulithic (Sh.>mu 1%) . !hac Sndo in .... ~c"'P'" of ,UI-
u rn to conclud. ,h", ,he"' ..... ,.. .....,"'Mn thO)' Snd f'><) ~ of W1L ctoI """in> ....",Wly "'pp"'" Ropt.', ••.tiu view_J<2la:",d in'crpcnorul vi-
Camion i> .tw." .... .;,«1 fOr an, Bi-.m ...... Wlu, 1arxu<;" thi>ch.pt<f i. that olence. bu, in cim"""or,ce. 'N'
could i",lude xcidtn ... non·lethal '''''agtoup
.....arty .bsenc. of C"tId<n« II ............. It i>. gloW p..... rn. and .. otodt.. ga; .... conJlrcu. individual hOnlicidc1. or U«tttiono. N.......Jenhal rem..ins romplin«
pt<>b><i", ....;gh,. Who< .. «fU.u, odJins. i> that uound the world oigru of ""'" the .illYrion. There b much skdmJ '=ma. bu, ......n,
no< lib: .Juc produced
cvnlnWly do appc>r. 'karty. and ,htn <Onlin ... ,~ time • .-.m whm thcTc by~ (6erg.<r >ndTrinkaullm) •..;", twOa«pIic>ru: ,ho putiillyh<al<tl
is no ""","""""ins imp""" ....... in the "'«WefJ' 0( oJl I'hysic:>I ,onuiru. The cu. awl; ORchc: nb ofShanid.&r III (50.000 B.I'.+ ). meh Trinhuo and lim-
compkv ab$enu of ...or iMin,,,,, .. fQlJo,o,d by ,h';, de... pcncn«. I.oohd ...."".n (1<Jn:6Z. n ) all ·the oIdm ca>< of hu ...... in"'pthWW violence
......,...
,,,,,,Iudt:.
.. ftum !hac 1'''' .... 'Ii ..... I this ....."'" olCYidcna:!hou1d be """' .. and .... ...Jyposoibk.-""""'« .... ~., and the =tn.t, id""tiftcd
"'t"" ".. evidence. Th... mpk .. c.opWmion i, that ...... dov<lop"'" of • ....n... healed tnm.« fn>m 0 bInIt-.mp.d obj«r "" chc: ""Pof ,IN: .brIl olSL uwre
I. <in:a 36.000 11.1'. (ZoIlikof< . .. aI. 2001). Then I«tru to be .. leu, ..... ck.r
Th. 11<:<' KCfion is • ...........,0("'" ....,.t, up 10 ... cur....." point. lhr"" ea· cue of carmi~ from ]00.000 11.1'. '0 ]20.000 B.I'. (Dc F1nu- 1m 1'1). and
.... '" ... in <>nkt. R .... the .........h brok< oIfbefOr. rompl<tins tIr. wei< ""'" ....n ,h. nrliu H _ _ _ <ira 780.000 B.P. arpan 10 be canni""';";';
"f Non/, America. and ........1 '''"';0.WUfld >InS renu;" '0 be do.... S<.:<>nd, nm.n.!n.,.J... .. oJ 1m). The {""'ou, K.... in> """.in,,,,",,, jvdg«l ,,,It indic·
thnc ... prdimiAuy lin.dinp: mo .. ..,....h and .. con<ider.uion i> anti<ip>t<d ";Y< of carmib.oti>m by Trinluu< (!'Its) ond Rusod (19117•. 19117b). bu, Wbi ..
for .11 "'gi<H> •. ThiN, ,hi, ,ummary is v«y .. ripptd down. le>.ving ou, <i<taik. (ZOO] ) .'ll.... ,I><)' >"',
J .. ing l....... and tnO$t dunution of tnvi""'''''''''1. Jcmogr;phic . ...a.I. ,...d<. Yet annib.h.m 40a fIOO n«UOarily ..un im.rgroup rioIcnc•. The d .... """"
. nd poIi,k.1 ""001' ....". AU ,ho, will come (! hopt) in • oogr' work. Thi' ",rn· ax of A........ ",nnib.Ii,rn (below) i, ~.,-.u "Il",.-indiC1fi"< of...,.,.. And
mary foro"" adu<ivtly on .~idtn« <"<gording ,t.. in"ptkm and •• rly devtlop- iinc. the poll,;"" olN..ndt ,tluJ, as hu",," .,.. :c,,,,,, O«m. inct<.. ingly dou bt·
m.nt of . iol.",.. ful (.nd ,hIt, toO ,,,.,, ·an,«wor' [Whi« lOO(),499J). ,h. ",I...n« of N. >n-
<kn hal beh,rion for II...... ""i"" i. qu ... I"".bl<. R.garding the rcplac<mrn'
of N.. nd",h.l. by II,,,,. ",piln!. ,hef< i. no physJcal .. idcn"" 10 support ,h.
oS.n ,uggc".d o«""io , ha.h .ook pI"" •• h r(K,gh vioi< n"". rather ,han ,hrough
,«1m. OI h« fo,m of COlllp<Ii'ion.
Th. Ea,li." Sign! ofViol, n<. Given the li.ni«d number and compl... n... of .. rly hum.n Or homin id
PopuLa, fIOOion> of the an'iqui,yof .... r .rill $<Om '0 reRu. Ardrey', (1961: 1966) . .Ictal «nuins. .nd the omoun' of 'numo rcpormi_""'" 'I'p:oumly hurn.n·
d"matic po" .. y.I,. ~.. d on D.rt·, (11'57,21)7) ·blood.b",p,m<r<d ••bugh« ,. indue.d. mo.. hOI, """" ",",ybc-p."C<N< of Paleoli,hic ,;.,len"" «main <nig-
gutt.d· vicw of our pal" Roptr". pioneering ",rvcy of I'ld,to«nc and Upper ","" ic. 1h< .oIwn< by Mart;n an<! Fnyu (1m: and IC. W. lkc 200Ja, ZoI·
Pokoli.hic <Yiden<c contradic .. d , .... view.• lrhou~ chc: .onduJed ·opocadic likofcr« oJ. 2002) nuUs a romp<lUn8cue foc ,h.... cd ro.orui.dc, ,h. cu .... n.-
intr~;ti< kiUingpt<>babI' ........ pi ... • in th.I .... , ptriod (1969:448). Sin" Iy ...p.ct.d i..... ofln""I'O<Ipviok ......uch .. dub ~gh"or domc.ti< abux,
,I=.. odd" io<ul. pr<>iouJly _.pted ..... of violence b.w bern .. corWdc....I .. . _ ... o( . .Ietal mo ....... DcWintJ prior '0 bwial or <rl>uri.oI .00 It....."
.nd «jc<tcd (BinfOtd and Ho ]98S: 80.>. and Ciochro<l 1001: linin 1981; Ury ptri ·mortcm tUtU and ..... .Juc hovt n...ning to do with. .ioLcnc.. t. i. poAiblc
1m,J,4, Whit< and T...n 1989. 19'91 ). No«hallcng«l (to my knowl.dge) is the u... """'" 0( chc: ...,.,..d ,numo "..". r.o... ;''''rgroup violcn.:.~ Ccruinly. It
P.JeoJithic ind,.;dual Skit..! lX <ion 36J)OO B.P.-OfI« bu, no longer <hough. is cquoJly poosibIc ..... non. of them did.
to be Ncandcrth.d (Armobc'lond II<Iftt·eol=. 1998:312)_finm Moun< G>t- Othe, claimc<l ..idt"", foc hkoIithic homicide or ...... it F"''''P<'>n en<: ....
mel with ......, >f>P<"'1O be .....u ,hnm ~ i", ",and hip (M.Co.m Thm: tcpt<><ntariono .. J>.c.h M.... ..,.j eo..p...luw Itnct wltich "f'P'"' ro go
and I(ci,h 1'I3l':74 -~). a.yo..J Ropt< ... Ie... ninc .itco &om Europe to In- UP'" (>t """"sh human·ltL: fa"", (Leroi·Gou ...... 1968:325. Im,or,o). To 80-
>
<Mchi. f.bbri .• nd Mukpl (1997,06). who «p«>dlXe dr,p,winp of ,M..: fitl· ,".n ... Si.e 117;, .dilfc.. n. ,tor)' 111<", we .. ",mi·",d.nury people. ol........1y
ures. II,. Ii.... "'A<"., ...... •lulU. T" Ktlly (2000: 1S2- I~J). ,.., of .... 'mag<> Ubekd Ep,p.>ko!i<hi< or M....J;,hi<. "'" ..,...r:d thou""" yo .... peopk of <he
• « '. P"",r,p,rd of >ponu""",, <I", ..,.,IU.:
Aie, ow<' ... bu. by h,,,\ofini,ion. no< Q.d.n <uhur< ....1 ..liM "" ... ~lh. ""'" fowL and ... ild gr>"'" on .he: Nil ••
wu. For LeIlbnc..;<I> R<p< .. (200H). ,hey u< "mdc""" of -.mr.: Gui· brood Rood plain. lhco< ...... bro.a.!'!p«ttum f'onsr ... "'" ~.lP"'" hili" ....
Ja."",, .nd Zornrni, (1005 : S2-~) odd ... h.. rcp1 ... n .. ,ioou >nd..., evMl<na of and .he:i. ""n 10 ............ to "''''' o«ur«<i .. <he Nil< cu' • nc-<I' 11"" ..,d
1iI1.np. For O".rbrin (z00.4,71-13). ,My u< proofolkilHnp. >nd "<he killinp .llffii... 'M .... Rood pWn (o - 19%;oi7- SO: Mirhn,. Rcya I99HJ-64).
<on><", ..... p<aI: of <he h"m"", ...rh ... CUI .... oJ<h""", I>< ohm JUgat> do.,.
1"" Mldolk F..... ..... 11 ...
""l' r<pK><RI on anurion ..,he • .t..n b.at<k.
ObYiouIJy.a'O'<"" u..;,xopen 10 in'np ............ Laoi·Cow/utl ( 19680323-
32S) IUO th.mo .11 • 111m "run ~ ....... opnn." GinI_ (1962:.(63_464) 7IH MiJ.& E..Jt
IUO rwo of .... rn .................. ont of Wlopt<'Ir...i oa. ..... condudoo, "n.... lhiJ 1"" of the: world it ....,. ....U known through ....... '*'P<ol..,.,a.. In ....
~u .... dcpit' no fish. of ....., .plrut ...... or of ...... ~ .. <O<thIy foe. n.. M...,Ii<hie ...... N...m..... p«>pIr:. """j . ..,w,oary hun ..... pthc:ocn from 10.300
...,..,...... th .. mn,ln <h. bod ... of tht nu.ud or 1><".:IIe. ficu ....... 0Ngi< p.... B.C. to 8.SOO B.e.. Lc~ ",.. n.ive ..main.. in<iud",,370 carefully arulrud okc~
;.cults." Ei ..... <>pini"" I.. of <IXIr><. wnj«'lunl. For rwo fnoono, J..o..nn.l «om. Only """ """"",, ony - . of ... u...... ond "", ....... th_ nor ...}'thln,
btlit'« .1>< ..... iLrnj>I< .....on 10 ""."Ion ,he wnlelUW ,h... theso Ii.... rcpre.- 01 .. "'lIF'u mUiu.,. acriuru (1Idft<·Coh<n e, aL 1991,412. ·UO-441: H<nry
..... ...,. _ . of P"'i«ril< .. :011. ~1n'. dot< uuninxion 01 .... repracn .. tioru Im:376). Rope< ~ hn- ""kLc on <he PLciH«<n< ....t Uppe. Pal .... ithi<
(fu.-p><! pho."tI"I'h.ond d....;nl'- ... Gkdion 1%H62- ~67) obowJ <hat wi,h • "'"'rof..i<k""" i.n <he Middl< E.uo ( 197S). She: >«<pl<d ,he: Prnailin8
IIOrne lin .......... i"..,·i.... bu. oth<rs ... d«idedly cu •....! or wrfJ. Comf"K vie .. , .... , 01,. fin' <1<.. ""NIt"", of ..... i. ,he: initial woll of}<ri<ho. ci..,. n.oo
tIIu.o ,he .... ,gh, 1I"",..;m ""'""rated Y" ;P' hi",,,, 10'1" Vm< ..... h .... 8.e.. ol"-'gh .... ""'.. ,h", ,hi. u ,t..: 10k ,..;de"", In ,hel..cun, ~ until
Ni:lw (Ginlion 1%1:401-402). s..«>nd. in OIhe. ave .n. from 1.0 Roche:. La ........ ,h milknni~m ( 1971:301_310). SIn« ,hen. howner. B.a, Yooc:f(1986) Iw
ComMr<lIe..... d Abtl M"", •. ,irnlb. II"", I" ""e'. 'hrough.• nd 2fODnd .n· ''8\Ie<l 1"'....... ,;.. ly <hat ,hi. fin'....u ... m.lnl<ndcd for IIood ronrl'Ol .... <h ..
'hropomo'phk figu~. In ...yo th .. ~i •• "" !uggt,,;o., of proj«riln (GiM;M I th.n d.fe" ... [Oft> Koeky (19%:)8) .. knowledge> ,he ge" ....1.btcn« of ,.,,,
I962: 4~ 8. 4 ~9. 497). I'<.h.ps ,h ••"Itt .. pracn, .. ;o." .« of. ph y>iaJ ,hooti",. "iden«;" .h. Early N.olimit.• I<hough he,J"." ''''' <on,i&, the 'is''ifican<<
I"'.lup • • ,h,,,,,nit ""e. 0< pn .... p' ,hoy ... of ""","hin8 "'" "m"" ;m.gi ..... of ,h., fae •• i"" ..d .... tlng I, ••• cun...u, oddity.
l"<y do nOl P""'" .he "I"'n'" ofh"rn.n kUling ... nd ",,,.in ly "'" of w... Rol"" (197~,)10-311) . ur .. yd 18 .1 ... fto,. ,h • ..".en.h millennium .• nd
F", <vide"". of coIlroive viole"'e. or ""'. <he ,,,Ii... ""cop.oJ " .. ,.m.i", .h, .. il!ingd.im! fo .... r In ~ve o(,hem. She ..."duolu none .how """""Iu.i",
,he N ;le Silt tl7. nw ],btl S.h.b•. ""' y toughlye";nu,,d •• ,bom 12.000 II,P.. "id<",." t'oo- w." [ 'g"" ....<p. for C""JH""uk. in Turkish llru.oli. (6,2SO~
wh ... l.( of 5~ wdl' p,nc,wJ . kcle. on ........."",(",J "";,h ..on ••"ifocu 5.400 B,C.). wt..: .. ,he: ,",n of evklcMC - p',,",ulatly bu,iu. w;,n d'gg<" and
in",pen,J .. par .. of proj«1li<1 (\l'.nd""f 1%11:90- 9); \l'.ndoof .nd Schild mac.. (which Rope, d.xI not m<n!lon)-oloeo "'PI""" I" p..... ""e (~Il.",
19U,AI~- 824). lhi. io • " ... ""r!i«... lthou, """'in .... ion, .. th.. 1"" of.he: 1%7:68- 69. 201. 2O'jI). Th ... olde. Nrolld.i< unvacloru from norm<m I.. q.
Nd, "f'!'<'" to have b«n .b.ondon.d ooon.n .. (ao.. 19%,.(7- 50; Midan .. h~. """,.do,ing Roper. ""vcy. dudy ;nditor< ..... lh< url;'" i. Q<rmn
Roy<> 1992,63-64), n.. oohe:'''«prion:ollynrly""iJcn< •• omd nom """".m 0. .. (Bl)()-noo D.C.). ,,"h mac .. ....t cnl>'1I"d pro;.c,iLc poin .. (IX'.din.
A_nib, .. he: .. rod. or, "V'" In,.",..-.I.iokn<e bo.we<ft indi'l'id.w. or 199L6S. 68_69); ,t..: orhc: ... f.um fOtI8hly ........ W><l ,...n 1.11<......... i.n ont.
• kw p<CIf>k fro... p<rfIopo OJ nrIy OJ 10.000 !J.P.. ....t glOtlpd ...... from.bou. • ""io< dcfnu;n:....u. and In <he ......,......... >nd okcLcm.u in......u.ion with
6,000 8.P. H... .....J.no:....... to """,inu< ,he:,nf<u (T...... 'OO Chippin<W< •.,o.I....do (Kod_ok< 1989:27, Lloyd 1914:33). [,m 'hio ""'" and place ..
"",.
O"nboln (z00.4:73-74) <I, .. both e.... In "'PI"'" oIhu m.ory ,Iw~-
the: otTn of. ~ ..mof ~La, warf... "'"' hat <""rinucd down to .... pmo<n'
...,.
pm< hun, .......... _Irion """'r up .... , OJ m.,.""""! into ~ Rop<r' ( 19750317-.114) "'rver Indicot .. ..ponaI dilf• ..-:a in ,I>< .... h rna.
funsjns. n.. IIlISfl'ali&n.,... _LeI "'PI"'" hio"""';',1on "";,h bif;.f1"'" hun.· Lcnn ....... s.." .......... aruund brxl-.ljordon """"in with..." 'OW" of ....... bu,
.... ~ ,Iw ,he: ot • ....,... I Pft'S"'"'Ion from ....... Iishu to ~ <rIgag<'- .....d>tm Turby...d northm> 1nq ond Sy,;. have oncnI ckuly fOnlfiod Ioca·
->
-------------------------------------------------------------- -----
(l500- IOOOfWO B.C.) include 10 nW<' wl.h .irnUar "5"" of vioI.nco. monIy ccnrn,'",n of popul",,,,, .. and .band""m.n, of (>11K ....... Crc1ting' ''''' •C"'p'
from one "",,,ion (Q,.. ndorfSmid, 1m, .nd 0« Dye. ,hi, volume). Yet Ma- ty qU'ff«" (Cobb.nd Bu,l.r 2002). P...Jki .... i... " arc ... n ,hroughou,.1.e
n•• ( 199~:136) concl"d.. tIu., ..en I.... Archaic viokn< ... limi .. J ''''''p;orui So.oth...,. gi.ing ri.., to ,h. oophi"ie,,,ed chie9y .... of.rc recorded by.M Span_
ro ..,boequ.." p<riod!.. Wo •• Iehouglt by Ihc" i, .. i.n:d In ."........<1 form (Ande,..,.. 1~:139-ISS:
1h< II?oodl."d p.,;,..j .ft•• 1000 B.C. «&i"'''''l=c dodine in 'igN of >io- Dye 2002, Moneand!>lone 198.H 7]_283).
knco in ,t.. grat number of dtclmJ mnoUu un....hod (~ and Heiple
1IH C...,u nuN
19BI :~: Ma .... 1999: In). Bu • .-did no<diJapp=.h"fi""l>a.and Dye (tim
..........) "UIXd.nrf1l1: .. '~ad andtnd<mi<." E..... ...-.ongl-lop<w<{l I found .... infotnudon abou, ean, ri ..... ro. ,hio om. bu. 0 ... dcuiIcd ..... f'\<q
p«>pI<.......U,. c... ~.,.,.-fuI ,.-.dot.... wluc:apptarto b< tropIty;bJk of mnaim from T...... OkWoo ..... Now Muico. Kansao,...d CcIot-ado~
"'" fOw"l (0-->1<7 and Ikny....... I97S:~ s..m.n 19811). In .... rniddlrOh;" .Ia.. ""... of ..... (o...ky 19a9:01- W, o.."SIcyct a.I. 1989:116_119). By my
Valley .bou. A.D. 500, .h... ;. uhili from di,..n«I to n""hIed and dmnd· «Jun' £rum d.u e"'"" the .. Of< 173 indiold...J, from .u period. "" tIuough
.bk sl<a (Oancty 1991). 1t.. orrivoJ of <ht bow and arn>w ........ uoociuo;/ Woodland. and +41 from ,10, .... pru,iKOric (ali .. A.D. SOIl (f>g>n 1995, ]39]).
,nth mot< fiWnins in the ....... th =tury (N.......,. and Pyle 1m). and >ita Ofdu: Ii> ....... tho only indieuioo of.Iok .., doth i> "". _...;th.,....
in WC,HftltroJ lJIu.ou ..............y .igu of >riokncc: from 'M L>rc Il'oodl>nd hi..... '" tho had. or doc Loff ... if ..... includes indi.id...J. in mulriple burial,
umcon ( Mil""" 199'5:229). lhio Ions~ em.... proI>I<m< for Oncrbcin'. where """" indiv.d...J. ha.c .... b<Jd. d poinu. "'= ... 74 ..... of prob.tble
ocuurio of p<"'e beu.c OUlKturalIy conn<em:l '" brood·'f'«tnIm fOngns and YioIcn. dc:uh. in 0 ... ",. accomJWIled by dcliborate .;!loge dtwuction. Ali«
pw.t domc>tia.rioo. lh< Lat. An:kaic ..... rimt ofin<r<»i"fj and mor< ..,dod A.D. 1000. aIonf; "'. Mil>OUri and Min;,,;pp~ Mio.isoippw. ~plco AlITO\Ind.
«Iiance "" "'I1.UDc raoutca (Moln.. 1999:21). and m.lUbotqu<n, Woodlmd cd ~ .Ulogcs...;rh dl.<I... and p.>l.sodco, and buricd It lour on. chief..,;m an
P<:riod ,.w 1M domc,.;c.tion of "'mpwced and ",,,Bow ... (M"n..,." 1988: I~- ""'""'- ftI.1><e. There ....,' fun"'" nucleuion """"Plnied by >b.>ndonm<n<.r...-
13: w.t>on 1988:40-43). A.D. 13W (O'Brien .nd Wood 1998:288-292. 318-320, 331-333. 3H). fortin.
y" ,he emcrger>« of the M,,,i,,ippi.n ,...didon by A.D. 800/900 "UI shows alion.nd Mi,.i.ippian ",,".-..erion, «",IKd in,o nonk..,cm I""" from A.D.
"" Iy limite<! pr<p=tion, for .iokn, confl i.t .•1'houglo lOrn< .."d.ment Jd':mo<> 1100 '0 A.D. 1200 (Ak:x 2000: 134. 155. 182). but (uClh" "'''t in K:on ... ""d
>pp<" " e.rly .. ,he eigh'h con,,,.y (Mo,.., ond Mo .... 1983:237: Smith 1990). N ,b....h ,h'r< 0" no indh'ion. of Ii>«ili."i"". or d,k ... ivc I.,..';on, (K,.."..
In ,h. South..... ,. loa". by A.D. 900-IOSO .h"e.r< indk,uion, of .,,<kmK 19iO: 106. Ill, vr.del 1986: 1(0).
worf.." (Knish' >I,d St<pofLI itj, 1999: 10). A m'jo, i nc~ in nucleation. p;oli. O n.ct. peopl. exr. nJ,d ftom 1O",hwc,I(m Minn"ol1 ,htough 10000 0nd
•ading with IOphiltie",d d. f.n,;"" f..'ur<, ..... d •• " empty are .. b<,w«n «n- much of I>1i.. ouri .nd llI'nuj,.nd en.;ron •• ~., A.D. 1250. • nd <>p<ci,lIy .li..
"" b<gin ••n.. A.D. I!)SO (Gnmly 191!l1:91-9J: Miln .. 1999:123-124). "'im A.D. I3S0 ...comp.ni<d by fi"'ilicd .1'<$. ~d<",l '''"urna. .... d ,hundc.bicd ico.
,he .hicQy politi.. d",u ... d by Dye (,hio ""I"mej. Around A.D. 1200. war dub. nog"'l'hy whi.h in hi".".;., tim" i, :woci.«cd with w:u ehi.cf. (Alex 2000: 182-
come'" dornln ... ove, ,10, bow.",J .nOW." 10m in comb.<.round rn.jo. «n· 188. 200. 207~209: 8''''(0,,10. ,h i. volume: O·II.;. •• nd Wood 1998:345_347,
.. IS (Dye 2002: 128 ). In thc t .... l~h «n,ucy.• imiw der.",i"e eon<cnU>.,ioru.,. 3S7). Wh,;" '"' individual dtcle,on ..... _ 'i8n, of vioknce beli>... A.D. 12W
Ken in N.w York (CNpdelin< 19'93: ]91_Z01: T""k Im,3Uj and oround olu, o....wy
(1-IoIIill1On ... d 1994:351: Ol .... ..,d Ship","" 19940384). WOI>< ri .....
,,,,,e. in Virsinu.{Roundtrcc andTum .. 1991"179). wcnoroming.
Lot< Prehi"orie burial. y;.ld many inJi";duaL. wiolt cmb<dded pain .. and In ,t.. grncr.lly _<pie<! pic'''''.immignn'' r""" tJ.. C<n...! PI.in. "l<Ii.
ott.. .......... (Grunly 1988:87: Ri«hie 198(l,294). A"""nd A.O_ LJOO.l>wUk ti"" ........e<! n""hward. Inhi.111y wi.hou< forrine,,,,,,,,, <H" othn indk:u:ioru of
from lUinoi> of264 raul)' .ompktc .... kt"". in<]0<1< H with ,",eh inJ~ ...... 8u, in <he century ali" A.D. Uso, .... y and ,J.. P"'"1owJy ,nidcn, !nitW
(Milne< .. .t. ]9';II:Si13. S9<4). In a Michip """'C'rJ. nine: p<,.:e", oCindi-ti,d".. CooJe>«nt p<-opIc ~ In ,n'ier for, bul\ding. some d......,-..d ...1oik un.
oJ. """" ....... kthal ~ f""'u ........... ,Iy in fcnW .. .ho ..... y ...... bcro .... comcn><rion. Mmy, nun, -!hI ..""" indkuc: viole", d<:><L.. ",caninen. be.
apti ..........,..,...,gc. men .... noubIy .....dnrqrmcn,e<! ( Wdl1""", 1997:23. i"fj doc c.- Crn-k ..t<. con ...n,iofLllly d.c..I .. A.D. 13K ~. minimwn
3S-)8, W~l1ruon and V... W....... 19'9)']9}). 1n .... Cftla:a! MmmoppiiOhio of 486 individu.W ......b~ ..,e<! (H<>IlImon ..... Qw.ky ]99+. K2y 199'5:
aru ali .. A.D. I3W. (oom an oI ..aJy n,.d.... d baoc. men: _ • ..J.Ii,ion1I roo- Pringle 19'911,2039: wm.,. 1990: ~ 1m). &mforth"«>nniburion
-----
- "'"-'I, (~.......,.., •...J.(kt--'-+_'f"" II'<
[0 'hl",oIum< "'I""':' m.jo< ..,,<ion ohM••ic.... War is dc.« •.bIc /'rom A.n. ma>ISO«U' ,1'1<1 A.D. 127~(H.., 1990: 1.< 81."" Im,264-Vo.2fl(lC,),45-54:
1000 on, :u.oci...d w;,h I"";"ul,,, in,nnb of d<OUfh .. no< on< Ions period, UpJum.nd RU<! L989~ Rk. and lcllLonc', (2001) """'-of",.. moJia, ..-iu.
.nd c..,.. e.«n d... <~nno< b< opc<lfi<d mot. p.edxlr ,han in ,II. broad • <OfICen".,ion on Hohok.m . nd Sin'gn> ~n ...11 rol>CCfn the "n>t,.......
ncini. y 01' A,O. 1400. time: f'nm<. from the A.D. 1200. 10 ,h.
utly ]400.' (2001,2). when tlw: .. ;"
.... ..-, ....wIo"'. of ...., throushou. ,he South_. .J~ prutd<d by •
7ht 5.Nthrvnt .... turyofin< ......""'.n>loN. Hohobrn.m>. <00. om< at...ndol><d by the 1",.
A p"" dul h;u betn publiWd on "..hilU>ric....m.. in ,,.. Southwut. <>pO- faun •• nth em....,. (1'".... :and .uh 1989,119- 121; wilt ... 1989: 163). SoIomcto
dilly - . m.. pa>t drnd .. ... "1....·, book (1m) b tho....,.. rocn"........~ (<h" vulu .... ) do:ocribct .lmUM Inkn/.i~ .... ion of <onRIC! on tho Mogollon rilt\,
joinnI..,. a O<t of cut....did (Rk< .........BIanc 20(1). Oapi.. an ttknIi¥c /rom limioed indication> 01' ..... :om..
A.D. BSO.•" dnr inr<n>i6=ion in A.D.
.mi.. m:O<d. tho lim d ... ......,.,... of ...... 1haw '"" dom fro.., oownI «f\tU. UloO-ll:lO. foI ...... d I&tcr bt' ohan.olonno<nl, Fun"'.. _h. in ""ru._m
..... ft ... tho bopnnln,of ....u...... "'fIU'h ...,....,re. which <>«UfKd........d Chih.w.w.. the IattI< em,.. e.... G.. hd<o ..... bwn<d. with ~ bodic>
1500-1000 /I.e. ( Will. 1988, I~'). kI
am. 'II'cathrnlr.
_"'wac.... Unh, ori,hin <he AIwui
ea.c 1 ton, ..... rrnv"ru of....... 90 indiriduak....,.. i ( no< ill
..nd ckl,b.n« dottuctIon .. ohm ~ in A.D. I}<IO(R..onIooo >nd Spa-
.,.J 1989, 131- 1.J4). By lh ••ul, ~fInn<h •• ntury. ..!w r=uift"! of ,I>< entirely
of ..hom """,.tal... oomt mu ...... d, A... ir.c.. rb« <ltl. ori<ltin ~f 11. rc...-&ftI!<d population _mod 10 <"5"8" In Ieoo ..... mo...p ...... ..aJ..rn being
or be ....... SOIl B.e. ...... A.D. SOIl {Hwoo ...... Twna 199),161. 11O-17I,,J. pncricnl .....n Coc-..do lIriYtd (e.......... and H... 19'111,55-57; H u...,.j
<houtI" I...BIanc ( Im,) IOJ ..... <It;"f ..........0. O. one! t..a.nbc<. J2OO2,22O] Cte.tmrt Im:24 1_243; l<BIoM 1S>9'H64,3(5).
1"''' i, at •.... 0 . 4001·). lhr<cotllt. Bukt,mal<n II si ... may ..... betn .......·
c..... ond ,litre .,.. nu"",,,,,,, od><r.ig<. of Judly >iolcncc C",fllMw: Im, I40-
14~). Wusign' .x.:.tu.ln Ib,"'"n.".. , III (A.D. SOIl- 75O) ....... comtbad in The...'" nu""'l'OUS .. Jion. of .... ....,.Id .. lit .. KOO<l .........!o&ical d ... arc
~ •., •• freque ... )' in P",bIo I (A.D. 150-900). For MogoIloo proplt, thu..,.. :lVoi\ablc fOr «ntun.. Of .... n mUluni. bcfOt< ... y IUl!II"srion of war apptus.
0C>Jn< dm.\,;i>k hill"", m.1oo. before A,D, 600 .nd mOK indic>rion. of ...... Thi, i. 00 fOr ,lit Middk Eaot. Conn,] A.La, tho: IrrdD~ Chi ....... d Jap .... La ...
• Ite. A,I). 8SO: fi,.. Hohohm. ,h... "' "".hing """du.ioe fi,.. ..... until .... , hi .. in u<h o( ,h... .... ~ ...1utoIogin.l •• ;Jmc. of ...at bc<o ..... dca. and """ .
...n.h «"'"'Y (...nl"". 1m,129- 149. l000,9~-9S, Ne11011 l000,3U-3Z7, tin"""~ For EgYP' .• 1I< ,,;.1011 de .. lopm.n ..1 pcrioJ 1,1..1ing. Eump< may be
SoIom<'o ,hi. ""Ium.). rno", rornpll,","'. with "",,... d In ...."".. 01' (""",ibly) <oIk«iv< .iol<ne. in
VInJ.,," .mong A~.·,i from A.D. 900 to A.O. USO/IZSO i, ambiguouo.nd ,he M«oIi,hi •. ." ini.I.1 and ' P!"'",ntly ",...ful.p"'" o{Neoli,hi. ,radi,ion,
....."",Iy e"",,,,,,wi,]. Although 0"" (rint!" Ioca,ion ...... fOnifi«l.bo., A.D. (wi'h 0"" .. ",b.W. <>«pd"" f'rorn luly). gi.ing ..... Y'0 • wid"p"'a.;I pm • ." of
900 ,I\d .b,ndono,1 .~ ... ma_re .bou. A,O. 1000 (Eddy 1974:81). in tho: w .. fare from the ~fth miU,nnium "".
«0, ...1..,..1 ofCt..<o.n An ..... 1<.It.,.. ,,,... Of' no Indlcatio<u of ...... ""8' NOflh Amotka I• • >t" h.nkr '0 .umm.Oli ••. wi.h dill',ren, and JOmttlmc<
t!" .. inS .1It ui....... o( . . .... Ct..<o· (...kton 2002:613_614). 1"<r< .... ...,.. conAic."'i! 're ...... in dill', .." ....... AI.1r.o.>u&h ,h....... f.....1)' <1<1y india.·
=r. ""n.Ie,,,"1 tr.lnw, .. peclally ILtnOng "",rn.n (Manin 1'197) and .igru of <io<u 01 >iokn«. In """" a.... ,lit...., .i,h... no .. t8ll""ioruof war in the .mi·
lwuul kiU~ ""«pn:.<d .h..... riuly .. eannibo.lUti< ,<1"'" ptrprtm«l..,. the: es< .....<ri.ol. .... ignt of 0I0I0: ...... hkk "I'P'" qui« Itm, .. d <omp:orcd '0 Ia«.
political <Ii .., orwyi,,,ond dilm<mbe •.,.,.n. of wireh .. (""lJnd 1998: D.tli"l! pn:hi"ori..i....... l.amb..... (20(2) review of ,he Nor<lt American li« ..,u .. in·
1798, Kuun« 1m: Twnn ...... T ~tn« 1m, w.J1u:. 1m). Noon<, ~ dico, ...,,", 11110 1'"".allu,ioon.pplit< .o "lIioru I h..... "'" 1<' fully IOC....:"«I.
..."" to quntion , ..... _ COMibal ..... oca" .. d, and ..... ohio .... _ in • I ......... """" in ..tvanc.. 01 ....... <Otnp ..... d1ocu ....... tha, the northern Not ...·
con.<D of ...... wat c.... .. oundo ou ... tho nrllut ..... 01. war p:o''''''' in Notth A"",oo •
Si"" of .. n.ioN-,M:ab.u\donrnm. of a..co. optninl-'f*el berwttD .bou. llOO B.C. ..... then ""'.;....... in pracri« down .., hi......, rimn ( ........
1""'1" """nd K'J'ft' .. - d......." In tht Cftuury:di.. A.D. 11W,I.ading..,<ribaJ an<! M&K""tf 1999:109- 210: Crbuloki 19'12: 1S6- IS7. 1"":80_BI • .l.to.. ond
nucle.u_ ...... ....,... ....n' lmo<hlf'dwdllnp........d A.D. 12<;0. Abandorunm< Erlanclton 19'12:11 ). AI,,,,,,,,,, I haw yn '0 SO ........... all .he m.u,rial fOr
of northern and """" ~ Arwui araa...d clu",.... of R1II>inilrfj """"" M........ma. South Amcrin (..,...hcd Of! below). A£ria. Melan.o4. and <he
,
Pac,f\c, my prelimin.., ..ad;"" ouw" 1;,,1. '0 <on".J"" ,hi. picture of , common ...... ,n. millenni •• nd on .... intcn.l6c-d wi.h W..... n COn"",. 1hcn i,
«Uti""l, ut< ......
S'''" of ....... m"uu"'IU of P.I ... (Lilton....J Tuggk ,hi. ,i« aU .!w:o< i<tucl 'OfiCther ",th • di ...... ion of Venn ... lan pn:MI<O<)" and the
volu,.,.) "ui New z..land (AikA. ,hi. vol""",)". coru,,,,m wi,1. ,h>'_ Y_mi.
Ahhoup <pi>o<k> of..... art po,.;bIe atI)' Ii .... In huO'Wl p«1ili.ory. th.n is
n"<Onoincing <Yidtn« of ooIluti ... in,.,gtOUp .ioJon« "", .im< bdOrc 10.000
)"".11 0fi0 «""<pI)cbd SaNb.a). a.nd in ItW>J' pru of .... world m""h mort ~ TN ' S" .UO o. W.... ..,P T C)T". £ TH NOC ..... " ' C i'1l•.SENT
crnt/y ttw. m... [ milo< ..... (.ide"", a.n be ,ud in d..1f<Tcn ....)"o and ......,.
wiD 1>01 bt <Otl..;nccd tN, w., .....bomt. Bu, J dunk i... difficuh to disogtn Why W.r lien.... Com"",,"
with the: >H<'ftIQn th.o tht ",UCOK< of ..... oM ito Inmu.ity. it "~nri2bIc. In thio cond.:.....d ... m .... ..,. of e.arty C\idtn., of ...... l !u.. "'" dionuoc<l tM
To .blm ,h., ·w.. h ........min« ... 1M! all h......... do," or' tIIn)I'W h..d .... In .... ,eri&I ond -at .on<iw:o of th.o ~Iop .... n.. I W;U "'" spcculo,. on d,tttt
JJtimc pciod>" is <Onmdic,cd by the ..;dmo .. eo ...... bu. tonn>J gtncnl faaon ...... impi;';',«1 ... ~00n0. which in
,."..,ch,. poin. of,.....,.>1 ....",.... ,hould be ,ha., .... n though tim.,. of nri.bk combi .... riono, mW: .... oripn and/or ,h. In, .... lili=ion of ..., motC
""'"' ........... 00III<'flIMS fOI ...... d by ri.-.of .... ....,. m.ovenJl.loo>g--<erm likely. (Moot of .......... dioaaucd in ..,.... de<2ilin FaJuoon 197n3.(-li7.)
,rmd was fur """" ...., O"ta rime, BaiJ.. m. ..idrn", I ......, pRO<J>,cd, dw One iJ I ohi6 '" oodcntuy ai".....,.-thoua!> "'" necc:ooarily >gicul.....-o<
>imp!< ron is >ppOmr! in ,hi. ooIu ...... In Pilill, ...... appan In the U<O<d >I'OWId .. Ie.... <0 in<ncucd dcpm<\cncc on lU.d ,im. Anodocr iJ ~ incraJintI
A.D.600. The M~ i>roupu ......... ,h <hem ... Now Zc:.tar.d. but .... ime"';· population ","'in I:Kood ua. .. T_",h< ... al,hough ,Itcoc "'m leu .. I.,..", in
IicdsrndY >I'OWId A.D. 1m In ,ho us. South..... th.:rc ....". 0<Vtttl Longmp .m... North Amcrian """""'.. dun in .n. Old World.... the dcwlopmm'
in ..... dc:",Iopm<n. lqi ....in& by )SOO 8,C., bu, ,he intensity of wv ..,<g«I in of ""W 'ankintJ and i........ing mdc•• IptCWly of ...,,,, good.-oIthotogh in
m. '!OO -600 yea!> bcfOn: con'><L Looklllfl" "",ire, tim£!, "" 0« in Ch,,.. ..... North Arncria ,h< ambirion. of thief, '" nuj<>r fa<to<' in .... I... r in.cruific:a·
,h.
beumo mon: <om, _ owr tho """ ... of Neolithic. and .. ill mon: <oml1lO<l <ion of war. A 6~h II .... de"dOI' .... n. of ""1,lln""u';",,. fo, bounding group<
in ,h.l:I"", U Agt. Ouaa I•• p.nicularly important ..... Ahhoough tM clup •.,. in connie .. Kelly (2000:.(.() and Boelun (1999:90-98) mike. mot. 'p'd6.
by R<dmond .nd Sp<nc.. in ,hi. volun .. picks "I' .round 700 II.C .... hen thn. d, im. ,h.. i. iJ , ... dn,lopmen. of ..gm.n,al kin,hip 'y""'" ,h.I( ,rubl...... r.
I..
wc ... ady ,,·.ning chid'!omo, Fl.n""" .nd M."·.,, (2003) begi n th.ir .nkle Rkc (2001) hOI found .upport ro,. that ide, In .h, American Soo,h,...... and
funM' Inck in tlmc: 'M 'im. f.. mc of 8000 ·2000 1I.e. I. chuac"riud by Fl.nn.,y .nd M..."", (2003) In O ...ca. Fin.lly. I ocrio". e<ologicol <<Y<<ooI.
·w",le.. "",i.,ies; .nd . ign. of .... fin. 'ppt'" .round IS'!O !I.e. bu, ... ,hcn involving clim". ch'Mg< "r . n, h"'l"'II"nlc ..""''''' d'Sl"1d.<lon. " often impJi ·
. lmn. ftum 1100 lI.e. «>800 II.C.-al,ho"gh Ot"rl>cin (2004: 12.3-126) quos· ..,«I in .... D<igln andlD< In"no,f;n,ion of WI ••
tiono ,lut .. rli" .. i,I.... e of..,... La'er I'«h;',o,y inJi .., .. much mol< w:u dun Th. g<M«al.""n« of th ... pcccondido". can opl"n why human popu·
utlier prehi.."..,.. I.. iotu did no' "".clop c.l,ural p...uiceo of war in .., Iier.imes. lIu, over ,he
Thi. i, ••• i....1roin,. '[hooc ..110 "''1'"'' "'.. in ,.,10.. . ima ... n.n evid.:ncc m~ler>n; ........ pn:cond,tiono be...,n, mOl, wid ..p .. "", and ... , UOfC in mon:
i. lIcking.n: n:[";n5"" ,..., _.l>ppinS bun. 0"" i. ,n.o<y .bou, ... hyWM oc· region> of .... worId. .. dcocribed in ,n. p'evioul .... ion. WIut happcncJ.ncr
cu ... 1~.n: J.sion, ond .. cotdl", '" 111>111. ..,..,. ..... r i. alway> up'''«I. t1u •• olicr ...... b<vn in diff.... n' ..... bu, before ,..... ,...rt ""y ...... 1/"OU1\d t(,
Th, 0< .... twi._ul"'" ... hieh n"", ,"'o<y i. <1" ..... - .. ,,1Inogr~ie ~ inR",,,,,< "'ingo l
rioru of war ow, tM p.u. 6~h"ndrt<l yu ... A ma"" point of ,h" dupo: .... W.. ",<UtI. Nut .n.om • ....u,. Of quldtly... II ..,..,.ti ..... ' .... 5inc<1 in
of COlt .... h oJw. 1l'CI.. rn con,••" r.. qttcndy kd '" in .. n.i6t<!.....nn,""""'8 p=bk> of ...."'hy (Schmookkr 1984). 1Iu. n .... " ..!ly•• p<Utl i. dod. through
~ pcopI<o. lit" ........... '1"Clucolop:al m:ood d.:monJtr.ra ;, oJw. pn:. """" combi ....;.,n of """ ..... .. intnln.....1 """"'!"'g c<><><liriorto. l},io iJ
historic .....n..... 8"" much --= In 10m p..h...".,.. /Mf- any oulSido ((ItIUa. >«n in ""tt..., oJready di-.lln Ch ..... . ilP" of war bcnme """"" com·
Thu ....... """"'I!,thnognphially obotrvtd pcopI<o" doubly u...pp~e f<>< mon through .... Oml.... t.-pNn Interaction sph<t.- ",d beyond (Clung
form"" op,ni<Mo. aboot. h........ i'y·. di"an, p.u'. 1980:270-271, l.iu 19%:264; Und.:,hiU 198'r.2.3I-2.3S. dW ooIumc). In.lap ....
_\><ough. by Immp .. /Tom Kon:.. bu, ,"'n optcao:l <htough the iobndJ
n.. ha' K<tion P""""" my idus-,.nwi., 'rnp;riaI ..ncnlizatiooo- war
>bou, how ..... do.clop,d ou, of • ...no.. ~, ~ why i, bcc:anv_ (&me. 1999,168·171, Furio 199I,}7·.( t, I....... u... 1996: 131 ). In f", 1'ntCfD
·nd mo« ..onhom Europ<. tl.< Ii... <uhiv.,,," .. pt..:cd hu""«'Vrhorcn 111<1 rho Ind .. ,.pan bt=nc: p'" <If the rndln. .... oftht Rg V.,u (Sinv> 19M:
m3d< "'" ..·,thou, d.. p<>«ful «muries of uri;'. oxp.urdins f..mtn (Andn· Srivur.,.. 1984). FI..aUy. >nci ..., $I:lU:S ~ .......... diJcam from their fron·
""" 1993:102: Bndky 199I:W-52.: Mere« 1988,89. 10.4. 1989. 1999). In tl.< rim. FtonI ,he ~ ... century A.D. Ronun. Ar>h ond ocher dnrundo ro. ">vd
«ntel' of Non!> Amcric:i. the Mi>sis>ippim p<riod O>W rh. rio< of nude:ned. ~ .......... of oioIm« .pradint! inhnd from ,It. .... ..,... of Afria (Ed!jCrton
fUnitiN ttnlo ........ oli •• .0..0_ 1050.111<1 .......... ...,.. C<'ll1utJ' 01 !WI> this p21' 1m 161, KusiI'rlN. .IIi, .... WD<: and "" Lo.<joy 1983). Sri Lanlu .. p<ri.n=i
tem ",read "",wan! in aU di=tiom (Oupd<lain< 199),ZQ(I-2(lI: Mon< and «f">,od. "'....... "" .....f .... rduod .., "'nmol of ,t.. Gp>ndrd Indw. 0<:=
hlon< 1983,2S6. 263-266: Round,_ ... dTu ....., 1998:278-230).0.. ,he Pa· mdt of tl.< n 'nth and .. nth ccnrurits A _I). (Gu ,,",wordana 2000: i'8-~). So the
<in.: Nonh ...... COut .......... complc:: Jcvdop«Iln ,he north pu.olly =rIC "'".ne< of .nck......... funhrr contribu.ed .0 tho prem'D« of....,- among
'" .hal"OCterit< "",'" di>p<n<d and 1m hi.",,,,hial """,n.. n grouP' (Amu and non· ..... p<epk •.
hI...,hn« 1999:209- 210, Coupl.nd 19118,207_2 12). And .. deKribed by AlIt" lh, .... m, ,he Europe:m ""pmoon. Over "'1. F.urol'u" .. p.... ioni.m,...,
(,hi> volume). 1..t<r Poly".,i", o<.&'ren Grticd. ""nlor <ompl<x . Iong wi,h m,," diSlUp'!i"" ... d ·wanMying· ,h.n th .. of .nci,n...... , (F'rgu",n 1993)_
<I><m '0 rI.'" 1s1",,<k So '''''n bef.", .1>............... btco,ning no.m'" in tv.. Wh ......""i'n' " .. <> would mol'< in,o con'lguow " ..,.lUbjec, '" • long hi>-
brooder ..... of ,he nib..! uni"",,,,. ._mou,
tory of in ....... ion. Eutop< .... ''''''Kd dist", .... and 0''''''. Doing
lb<n ,,·n.. harr<neJ """. <Utes .pp<ll«l! In d.. OIr. """..ofuI ...... <Up- ,ho, ......
this. ,hey In,rod,,,.d ...... di>ea.on. pIan'~ and ... im.1I I""1y dIsrupted
p.nocd colle<li ••• i.olo:nc. within !heir .dminj"':ltion. olt!>ough thi •• .ned rn con,..wd IV""I"- Europe=o had uade s-b "'"'...... in 5""' dt-m.nJ. .nd.
1""'''' (Ft'l""'" 1999:404-405)_ Thou ... indiadoru ,n., _1m, ...... «p<claIly 1..... In ,i-. mili....,. and ">n>pOrt>tion t«hnoIosr>rod tcchniqu<s
fum...,.j .. okno:. ""d ~ """"'8 " " " _ p«!pIa >tOW><! thom. 1hc: rise: >rod -n..-c.
oJ...t..ouId ,......... ionizc European apans-ionisu W«t "'" uniq ... in
faU of" .........Id '~If "'••",,ng wncs of ~ "The d... \opm< ... of the Zulu ... kinl""p"~ iabo<. bu ..... Y>SI . .,"'. of <hciropcnrions was. Tho ...... goes
...It w.,1011.:;to..cd by • ",=dins ..... i... reo<:cion of «rriblc ..;ole""". kn.own .. ro.- tlw: Europe... q..... lOr land ckarrd of p<"<ViouJ inlubiWlrs. All of th,,,,
tho "'fi<-. al,hough ,he growing European pmtnc. """ ...... pi.>.yo«I a role "'1'"" of European "p.oruionism ..... , "'" ~ ....... tlw -." fu ~nd
in ,hi, hom>< (CcW>ins 1988; H>m~'01"1 1m). The coil""", of T.."ih"""", fion,.,.~.,.;'" prtUdingony W<!ttm "I"", .... lhif ...... oflmpact N<~ Wki,,-
led '0 dtstabUit21kon and ..... ciu-oughou' nortit_ hI .. ico (Ndoon 20(0). In head >rod I ",II • · tribal ron,· ( ~ and Whitchr:wl2000). While W<><<m
,he A"dun highllJtd~ Ari:u,h (this volum<) deKribcl·"..,ln ..action.· of WH .on,.., dId no< "'''''''' k>d to mo«~. or de...,..,.,.". .... rfue_tom.ri"'"
op .. adinguu, from poli,ia/ «men through peril''''' ......... ~ ,h. opposit< oc:currrd._C>!>< studi., eollec .. d;n IJ:', in tbt Trib"f unt ....d
Rd .. ivcly ,ubi•. <tn' .......... ~ ,h. ""ure.. of .... r ..rli." hi",ori ... commonly mony o,h, ... I,.", li,,1e do.,b, ,h.. in ",.ny. m.ny pam of ,II< world. Europe""
...'" ,h .... Kivu ... urroundrd by firret · b.. b"i.n,· (Ferguson 1999:418-420). "I"n.ion .fter A.D. lWO 1«1 ' 0 morr w... mong non· ..... peopl ... befu... ny
·Ihi ...... . no< >Mffly idroLogicol p"*,,,iQn. Su, ,he<)!igin. of •..eh m,U,.rum.r< paclfying.lf.... se' in.
oboo:u ... How much wa.!.n im<fTul de",Iopmen. ! H"", ,nu<h from ...., ..im.. -
I".! l'rob..bIy ,h. bos. be. is ,Iw. pronounttd m,li ....., OIO< .. W;"" dtvdop<d A",»oni .... d ,t.. '(.nomam;
.. "".. ofLong·,erm rn"rxUon between eme'png ..... <u, ... ""d pcopIn <If To .....u this dJ ........... of ........oIosY. h"'oty.•nd ,he Ifmpotal inelt... in
,heir pcriph.tics.. It isd....................... ancitn....... commonl, foot.....! ....• wv ....... ""ilied >rod «>n<rtte. let ... «>mide.- ..... ......,.,. Amaaonw. p«>p ....
""6'n.." >nd ,rib.oiiution. >nd rnIi<t<d ...... •.....ri ... ,rib<. . . .<thn., sol- >rod p.otti<uJ.ufy tho y.........",j of ,t.. Upp<r Orinoco rtgion-longeoru;d.m:I
d....• to. omong ocher dtings, proj«. for« brrher in,o tlwi. hinrorlan ... dun • ryp< C1Kof pristine. prim<vaI....f.tn:. Iniw.l hiKori<:ol.-epotts from tlw:..,.....
cn<Ulllb«e<l SUk armies rouId IIWU!'< tcO .... mially (GoId"'rz and Findlow ... d IIt.Ojot rive .. 01 nortit-..em 50mh Ameria. doa:unem Wg< JalIunon...
19114). I, ...... __ • uk brr dur <hi<. .. last ........ Imeo, .p..:wI inreruM....,- to"" ~d u ,hiefdom .. wuaIly rcad~y obk to tlt-mooutr". ",bounri21
f....... "'"""~
m~'..". cop .... ~I,ia (I)cBocr 1981. 1~1I6; Medina 19}4, Morq 1nd M>rwin
M,iiton"", ....... over 'im .. r<pb<nI comp..... i" .. y .... n·miliwi"je on<>. 1974: Mym 1988: Wltilt"">d 1988). How long h>d mi. 1""'''' w,od! &no
In I'or" •• fttr 1000 B.C. >C>"<r:d :tpp.orutdy theocra, .. " ......... coo,!,....d. v.. ion. of major serdemen .. aIonS·d.c!OW« A~n and middle Orinoco, ,h.
inC<>l"l'<"""l<d .nd cultur:dly ".",!Vmt.d 'u~, ,It. moW of ",,,.,,ding mili,,_ w.,
r.,,« beginning around 2100 B.c.. an: re",,,bbly f... of .ign. (Rooocvch
rim (l'o1O.-..I:i 1987). Ali.<r <he decl ine of 'he ",I.,;vol, unmili .. ri,,;' H .... pp •. 1980). One good ><qLl<n<t<OmtS from, uibul1ry of ,h. Rio ApUff. which i .... f
>
,,,~, I ,,"-,,~, -1* '""_....J~"'_.,.,;.- «lI
fl""" inro ,... Clfinoco.• Iwu. SOO km f",m .on<e>er.o.l Y..,.".,.ml Land~ Her. f««d by the Europe." .." .... Ion .Ina: ,hoy bcc:om< '''Ket. of o<h .. !U!.;.e.
chkfdorru and .... , appear 'Of',he.- afi .. m.jo< popub,ion growth. alongci.· 1«k;ng<>p'iOQ ". ,...de 10th< Europ<.... ;n ,ho w. 1600s.
",,,,,,,,ribcd >gri<u1t"",1 w.d, in ,h. ""''''''' >One bet ...... n 1owUn.! and And .." A Sp.n!sh cobt<".." In .... 1740. .. portal tha, :dong d.. Upp<' O rinoco. 00<
pcopIa (.. hen: .... , ..... altndy ...l1· .... bl!she<l)-...,...nd A.D. 5SCL Chiefdom! far from YlnOltUm; I>n<k local p<'OI'I<o ....... ·"..coful· <"""P' fO.. ,ho rcc<ndy
did not "P'J'<M "" the mi&lk QrinoC<l ""'~ AD. IIOQIIy A.D. 15JO and tho U1tnt1ffl: Cuaipu,..,..,._ ........ Ito" fa. ,I>< Portuguac_ who drdnurallocal
/in. hiHorialocCOU/\!I ftom thr '''-anN Mar th< Aput<, ~ chid'. lived populn;or'll (a1""""" the poosibUi,y of .,,"'Ponups< bw m.... bo: <on.i(l.
in 1.'1< fOnified v i . wi,h ..... N"'" ifTiprion 'l"'...... and """",.ere abI. ~ In dois OIXOUnt) (Cdi; I96S l,~. U:57, 289). By ,h .. time. the highbnd
'" ni>< ¥ring ro...:. ~ally ... udinS .. n tho.K.nd mm {ltooxnlt 1991; home of the: Yononuml w .. bang wgnal to,. sbv. moo. coming 110m n'U}' dt-
5pn>ccr 1998:1Z7-129; Sponc.. and Il<dmond 19~nm-U7). ",aion->nd <hey ..... '" Mill be"" Yiccimiud to,. n.idc" on • .....na I<2lr a crn·
.... ~h< .. " - min. 1ong.<><&I«cal hi"oriaI docu .... n... ......,;.1'1 .....,.or IrIOK t.. ... (1'0....- 1ns.:77- 82. 181-(86). The: SpMtw.....t.Iw...d
fo, V.ncmda and ...vi __ ...., ... I<',inl' much cleue, ~ of ..<CMiTC. the..- /in, au'P""' on tho u,.p... Orinoco in 1756. 0 - th< I><:J.' few r='o rh<y
intc1'COn ...... ed pc>lirial 'Y" ...... wid> ria .....h;"g ...... to d>. Andel. _th wi~ tho diminishill(lj C ... ip" ...... m, .. in,o 1>< . . YioIrn, <Of\8icu wido
to """ Amaron. and nonh do-ch .... Caribbe.n (Af"do.Ji......aand IMotd rnnnanI> of on« ,.,..cfuI ~b flOm d.. N<gro. wt.o ... '" lkring .... Po ..
CuriIJo 1':I'9oi; Chcmel.o 1993; Whi.ehead 1988. 1':I'9oi). War _ «ruinly an "'S"">" thert. a,. 1761. all th< ... r...., .. ""'" a<2ping thr &uop..n. by rnovin&
in,egraI JW1 of...... 'Y" ...... bu, how """ ..........aIru.c riw, chiefdoon< n:lucd to in,o ~ futrm. kavi", th< Orinoco and other rMn D<u!y abandoned
"""" mobile ~b of .... In,erior JUch .. Y."onumi-...n.tha in oyrnbiooio. (~ 1ns.,82- 8S).
conHict, or both- is .. p~' a vny "f"'n <pmiM. Wi,hin dcodes of Ii... AU carly KJ>OIUofYU>OINmi milingwarcom< ffOAl p<riodI of opccific and
ron""". <hex ..pooord pcopla w... inYOl .. d in mdiury ....u..nc. ro the £Urn- in ...... di .... rhan •••• itha " '&r&<" of 1I.....;d.. or in .iruarlon. of nurkod
1"'.... and """".ru..hac ....... norwcd in im""rial rivalnc. and oLavc .. <ding di.~ria in r=ndy inuoducod W.".m good. (Fcrguoon 2001). The bulk of
(Whitc ....d 1988:71 if, 1994. 2000), Even ....dy ...he ,ime of Har.. Sudm y~"".-...; m"fo'" (F,rg_ I99S.) ;, <kvoccd '0 druiJing rndrncr ,hat Y.·
(1928), marooned in 8 ....il in ISSO. wud...!y ..fleeted dc.:a.le. of ItUjo< Euro- nomami .... n 0.'" the pa" «n,ul}' 0. "'." «.ul .. of .. n.ion •• """,i . .. d wi,h
""... influence (Fcrguoon 1990:241). Theoe 'esionallodopolitical 'YO""" ~ un"'lual di,uibu.ion.of nul tool$ and OIh .. W..um """ufacou.n Y.noawni
d''''roytd .nd ,heir pcopla diminot(d wi'hin the fi .., cen,u,y or.., of con,.., of tho Orinocv·M ....cu". in ,h. mid·I%o.-,"" oubj«, ofCNgnon', (1%8)
(Hemmin~ 1~78:29_42; Whi,ehead 1994, (999). 10ngbofO« ... y :ulIhropolo . Y"M"'4m~: 7h, F;tr<' P~pl,_ ....... addi.ion.oUy . nff.. ing m.. , ive , broul·
gin ",... round '0 ,h.()<iu: ,hd, w..~ 'p«trum d;" "p';on uf ,heir liv .. n:1.«d '0 ,h. pn:oence of ",i.. ion.ri •• ."d
The .. h nolo~y of ..... N' .. Uod h...,ly on Ama:zoni.n <He" bu... no«d o,her ouuidrno. wh;"n di .. ctly .noour.tged ,hoi. un~!U.lJy high level of imc.·
•• dk" our ,heor.. kal p• ...Jigml ",l" l hillo,y ou'. When i, ;, brough, b.. k in. pet>On.l.ioI.nce (1'<'!\I$On 2000). lhi, i, quite dilfc«n, from L<Bu"c'. d.;",
~II of , he key c. ... upon whk h ,h.ory fuo been buil, hove boen obviou.oly, d ..· (.hi. volume) ,h.. Y.noma",! h.d c!tlonic w.,f... beca"", th.y Iud tuCh.d
flUtically im~tcd by 'h< W..... n in'ru$ion . E~rop<'''' d;rtC.al n."i .. p«>j>ko ,heir <>«ying ap.<i,y.
ro ....ck o,he .. who made ,rouble or .. ho .... « aIIk< of imperial rival~ 0. ro B....! on ,he conn=i"" of .1I1:nown figh,in! .0 .><errui f.. rors, and my
prod ••,,. pu",ho ..bIc npci_.". i<u' ro di • .dc and conquer. Ncwdio<.... im«· own h~tori<al ~ «con""""lon of ,hd. pre·"",] ",bo;,ocn<c .. more
ptc.al .. w;tchc .. fi k<I '0 figh,inS •."d Indiaru di.plx«l from one «gion ...... mobile.nd I"",.. don.if)' (!'ers""'" 1998). I o/f.r<d ,he "hunch" thar hefor<
""0 conA",. wldo <>th.n. 1Xc...,n good. "imuiual war .. ol.;<cu of plunde •. CoIumbu.. ...., ..t ...... , , , _ " ' ; <...,,,,,,";!in "".. "Iimi.al or CVCn """.
and a,..,.,J d"p"'''OVCI' ,.....Ie <Of\(roI (Fcra<uon 1990). Which bring> '" to , ... ...;"..". (Feeguoon t99S> ,~). BtcauI< Yanomami built no ....jo< "",clUJ'<>.
Y:u>omami sp«i6cally. w<d f............ impkm<n ... andconsum<d """ bon .. of thr;,dr..!. w. will nne,
10 ;, V<TJ'<Omrnon to ..... i , pi<! ,ha,""" In .he ... ;d·196Oo, y""""",,,,i I,ved know fO.. ...... ArdoocoIopcaJly. ,hoy;oK nrarly uwi.ibI .. Som.rim.<ll do ..,.,.
w...Ifcaal to,. "civiliUrion.· Thil is why thdt warf'.,.. ;, ... oft... do ...... '" ~ dn if due h"""h !iO"" 100 for. Bill nioing duo: poooibilif)' ;., I bdicn:. a ....,fuI
rcrn. the hu ...... condition .. i, .. i"od in our ...,Juriorury paoc. 80th pn:miIc: caution fa. ....... who would f'«'iK< ow..,...ph;" .... IUmrru imo d ....... ,
and <0<1< ......... .,.. ...,. wn>ft&. Y....,.,..",i ha .. been indirccly and dio=ly"{. pn:hiHorJ·
,
as va" conjuncture< of vari.ble. "'im ruwumi>.l ..u...t "'"",omy. It .1.., .n.bl ..
CoNCLUSION
• ,hco"'iruly <orui ... n. In'egration of.n .nonnow numb<. of linhge. be·
Th. w.u, il ~OI ",h<th.. Ih ... w .. w:>.r b<furc <i.;Ii",lion. No .. riou. «hoi" <w«n war..,d lOei.'Y' A .. ern' artkk (m gmon 1999) io. rompilarion of th ...
.loub« tI.., ,he« W2<. The i.,.,. io how to oxpl.in "" , both 'p«ific wm ""d Iinhgu in • 'Y".m.. k rom porioon of w '" ."d oocicty omong no"· ... « pcoples
P""
w" in S.".",I .u of 'he "um.n ""n,li, ion. 2nd how «hnology ond .«..... v;.·a·vi. among:ond. n•• nd mcdi<v>! ..." .. MOfc "",«marie comp.ri..,ns of at-
<>logy c.tn join forres in ,hi. que". For th_ indigonow p«>ples ""« cli,,,,,t <luwIogiC'OJ oL .. wim .ne"n, and m<diev>.l " .... could bring new pc"pce<iVd
p/>y>kaliy. ,«hnolog"'Uy. <CODOmkally. ""d mili,.nly from up ....;""i" £0. '0 qu<>OOn' rueh.., ' ho« "Wl in m i. volume.
rop<, .ho n«d to figure \11:'0.<.", contx' in'o explm .. ion of 1""'-'''''_' w,r For in"lUlu, 0,,. s.... r>.li ... ';"n from ,h...... h... i• •h.. w:o.. do<. no, .1·
... m. dem.nu,),. AIT~logy n.. ,Ii< ahili')' <0 invc"iv« ~·con,,":t !inK$, '""')'I leod '0 pobticaJ ro""'ioL,;"n. I, <= .nlOre< 0< !cod '0 ("'gmcnta.ion ..
.nd to wi.n ... ,h. circe" of contxt from ill .arli... pI=n. 8u, th .. i. only the ",dl. lha< iJ no rurpri .. from ,Ii< pcrsp<e<ive of .nci .... , na, ... whcrc unifi ... ,ion
b<ginning. Arch .. oJo,sy <-.til in,,,'iga" , he ,nili .. ry ,ffect. of anci<tl, " .... on ""d bruk.up frcqumdy >.1,..... « ovc< «nrun... Lc81mc (,hi. volume) o/fen a
propl,' .round them :ond okmg thd. tndc rout ... Arrharology C2n .ddr... the now and in ..",,,ing hypotn..i. ,h .. ronoolida.ion of '''''' poIi'i .. form«1y ..p •.
qu ... ion ofltow .nd why wor sp.-...l ou,..... ,,!! from its ori~n.ol «n ..... no.. iu ra, ..l hy buff... ron .. con 1<..1 ' 0 • much larger .nd more pote". polifY ,n"" ito
practn and dIDo,ati"" ch.nged ove, !im•.• nd ,,'lu, f.ocron .on.rib"wl ' 0 iu fonncr pc«~ Som. """" in 'hi' 'olum<, "p«i.Uy .hat "f Mon" AlWn, .. <m
g<n.,i. in ,Ii< 6", pi"" •. '0 ,uI'P"" thi. idea. though othe ... ,uch 2< the uppc. Beliz< Rive, v,'[I,), .nd t li<
Arrharologyond «IInOiogy mould ;oin, ",It..c .ppropriate. in 'hCO.J< A ro- frontier be ......" A"'c",d T......... <mpiru.ww" te.. v"""cy at pc<iphcri ...
bo" 'hwry of ..... f ,flo,., td be "'pahk of .. pt.i" ing ,h, orig; n. of .... ,. i" ,nrufoc· Mo« ~ncruly. m. romp"""'" of,ribal penpl ..... d . nd.n. , ..... (F.:rgu.on
m.>tion in European ,ribal zen", and <v<rythins in b<tw«n . Rcg>rding North- 1m) nu.keo the poi", du. ",Ii< op= b<tw«n" polities i. "'y,hing but . mpty.
",..t Uus' w.. f:tr•• I d..... kopcd (I984b). p""con,,,,, mod<l "'" ground<d It io highly ond ,..ri.bly p.... m.d at 1..01. of infra"rucrur<, "ruo:.u«. :rnd .u·
war in gwgnphi< .nd tcmpor.oJ v>ri .. i"", ofcri,ical '" w; "mee «OOuf«S. Wi ,It pcr"",,,u,,,.
pom·""n'><t "';><>pUt.tion. ,Iw modd DO Iongtr appli.d Y.. W>J" w=, on. uri· looking .. >J>cirn, mrco quickly ,<v<.1. b.. ic .. ri ..ioru in politic>.l 'u.on·
ably.• nd in "'m. c>oe> qui .. in 'cmivdy. Those ..mOOn' in pr.ICri« can ~ u - omy and ronoolioLOOn. Th.. old.. dio!in<t;':'n b«w«n "tri,ori.1 conqu." IUld
pl.i".d prim.rily 2< <lrOlu '0 i......... ",wli<, or pro6, from ,nd< in \"('co«m hcg<moni< domin.rion i•• "«.... ')' ... rtinS poin' , bu. no< n.. rty . uflici.n.
'0
good .. or fe.d "'" ol.v< tnd< which arned., "",<oc' but go< wnne 1...... An Ii>< undemanding miliurily baKd in'egration. Rd.. ,ion. betw •• n domin:rnt and
apl,n,,;':'n of North .... " Co." .... rf.'"mu" .".nd '0 bo,h :u-chawlogy""d IUbordina .. «n'", ,...y >.long scaleo ,h .. r.tnge from .!l i",,«. mrough domi·
h""".y. nation, to inrocpontion;:ond from =de. mrough <ribu!C. ' 0 " . .,ion. Otten
Th.u "tody "'... n .lfor' to c...... I ..""". theory of war .. u... ,;"n •• irn<d ",.",i,i"", occur ... pu'!' incremrntal proc_ ,..the.than a lud"'n "",n •.
.. expl.ining whi,It grou!'" .. rook. ",hklt group,.rc .. txk.:d, pcri<HI. of in- Th .... hi6. m.y be diflictol, to di"inguiu, =h><Ologic.l1y. bu, ,h. po .. ibili,i..
"!o" ...... , fld peri<Hl. of pc..: •. A S<>m<wlut modilUd. gu;dy eloho"u<d. and , hould b< kr:p' in mind while fr' ming hypoth ..... Furtli<t, no< only do poIi ri .
•vowedly «i<ntine .." ion of.Ju< 'pp"",h '"'" dcvclop<d lOr the Y"""m>.mi c..t cen' .... grow. they a1", d<din, in "''''l!m, ond one of ,h. recu''''''', ,h.m..
UK (Ferg""''' 1!?95o:21- SS, ond ... Jonu 1!?98, S,,,,I 1!?98). For ,h. No"'h ...... .mong "",i<n' " .... i. ,h. gtadually inc .... ing au,onomy of ",fu, w.,..,one<
COO". eI pWw;':'n of prehio'''''' ~ w:u much moe< broad·b.mn dun tIu, righ,1y dornin.>«d sub·politico.
ofhi""ricaJiy oo..t.. d ... nu. in p'n b<"", .. ,h ........ mIlCh less .rclueology c..c. in thio ...tum. show ton>< v.narion. of conoolioLtion (>.I though pigeon.
ro go on in 'he early 1980.. But w< " " n.... "pee< the urn. "'!Oil of ><qu<n<d holing ..... i. ottcn «nUOUl)' from tribal i n tho n""ow "' .... of political unifica·
."tough ."hae"log y " .hrough h;"o<y. and tlut 1'<""" proOl<m for the", .. iaJ tion .... i.hou' «n«, Ot pfOI>O<Ul«d h"<>"'hy (ouch .. ,Ii< nonhom rt.in. :ond
unific.tion . Somh ....... lOm.rimc.), 'hroug. >J\ '''''y of .mal l.nd t.rgc <h .. fdo m. (2< in the
O n. w.y .0 b.ing ,h. lo"g 'p'''' of p«hi.",'1 rog«"" wi,h h;" o'1 i, So\!,he..,. P.lru. New Ze,Jond .• nd ..,,<m Arrie.). mrough equ.l!in"'pen·
'hrough • prog=nmatiruly modified "«"ion of culturu m.> .. ri.li"" (Fergusoo dm' 0< ,1Ul1ted/ron.solid...d "ra,ified peer poli,ies (.. wi,h M.l"). '0 ,.nom
1995b,30-32). Thi. m<HIific .. i"" p"' ...... ,h. poir.cipl. of infrutnKrural d<. for"" of np=<ion;'" ...... (.. in M.';eo, the And ... -and Chi .....). Thi •• how.
,crmini.m but in • n""·",duc.ion;,, ....y. StructUf< :ond ,upc"''''':!'''''''' ... n "'" eoruolid,,;':'n must be ... n ... ,h "", ·dim.nsioou1 p""' .... wi,,, m, .xi •
•
<Jf p<rW'OI' ;ellnins~ I.,....,. Again onJ ogaln ... hots in ,hit book Iu... To recosni...... .....a.n, beginning is '0 e""".pn<aJiu the poo>ibili" of. future
.... n«l ,Iu, w" ...w,
<O'1O • of <hidly (Of hW-) poIi'ia1 .. nbitions. And ie <n<I '0 war. s... "'" canoo< deal ..,do the origin< of ..., if ... «>ntin ... ro praj •
i> mo>c 10'11""..... KI .mpltui«. ,Iw oJl thooc dlO<llJlioru <Jf milil2<J IUOCCU "' obKrvarions ffom rt«IIdy oI>o<r-vro indigenous pc:opIn Nclcw..nb tIuuugr
confOmnS ~ onJ of the kgitiautinfj .!feet. of milit>rimc ic","'S'.phy. tim<. Tho.;.. «pow«! """ iI that the <JriWn >nd • ...,. devdopmen. of .......
in-.o/vt hioran:hiaJ ortanlr""""u ""tin.. ,he .......·makins poIi". ~ is "" in· ihould be .pproach..! in ilS......, time, >nd ilS-.o tnmf- not bliJlkemJ by the
utnalJex,.maJ di.l"",ie in hi<r.orch.ical poIirics. nhnop-aphie p ..... n~
It mOUt.oo be cmpt..>izro chac ~ i. "",.ok. J'<im< ....... ' in political dc..I- N,,-....... "'8&<,..
ti"", in <hi> roIWD<, .... thor> ...... <1 c/w..he wars dory "".
"I'm.n,. ~bny "''''' cul",,,,1 ,pheres arr .ngag«!. &enu .. ,his ""JUtn. i• .bow: cov<",d had <h",. kind.of ....... , mugglt """" impotran, prod",,,,, ••nourcn,
oocin", ,Iu, p""'ticM war. i , may give 11\ unb.Jan.<d pi.,ure Gl ..... impor- 'M ,,"bi'io'" Gl pol"klI leaden. and Ioca! ",1",raJ bdief! whieh provide b",h
t""'" In ,hat ptoC<II. E•• n in ,n..,.... h.,..,,ho.. au .... ri.,i"". in ,he .igni6. jultifi..,ion and an imp"l .. ,oward Wat. In d",ing t wi'" ro highligh' <hi. <on -
.ao",o <>f "''', wi.h And,an 'Ute c:xp.mklni... appu. ing,ignific:cndy Ie" .iolm. "n,u" whl<h I belie.. would be I<cond.d by • &" .. nI.1lty o,he •• rclw:ologi,,,
than M,~t1c.n . El"wh"" ,h." m.y be '''''''8''n, """ien..... '" wi,h li,tIe ...d cul.um .nthropologi!U.
if.n y w.n..... \"('at i.......lr olw.ie IlU<crW COrKern" fil ..r«! '''rough an internal/en«·
P'''' ..... ,1y I (1994:101_1O4) ,ugg<><,d ,Iw .... and 1"'0« may ~ odf- no! poll'",", 'Y""". I"'thcd a!<>ng by...J ..... that......,.,'"'8' ",IIi"";,m. In di.....
.,,,,ro..i"5 ,.ndencies .mieh ramify throushou' 1Oci<ti<>. 00 c/w. ~couJd be con' ..... .., rhooe biolopcal aplanacioru that ... reinforced by • ....--furrvu·
.1 ....... " ... m.]iwioti< and ~Ie tnjcaorieo .........d complct;". ComiJcf- bx~ view. do" .. tnpIe. communlcabI< conduokln ""' impl;"';"'" fo<!.ow
.Iion« ancien< and medkval!lUt« (Fcrgwoon 1999:4(0) added the ida chac .. ~nd<nund ..... in the ....tId ro<by. from 00..:aJ1td ·,thnlc conJIi<t>," to 'cr·
....... ia "'"'r.liW.,. in the cncn. to wh;ch the irutiru ....... of poIiticaJ. miliury. ..,..;,.", >nd ,he wu in l""l ( Fetgmon lOOi). If_ W2n. KI urwI<t>und all <hi>
and rd;pow Itad ...... ip .... 1<pHlIM. Of Ilniftcd. T.iling >.II of thio in ar. . . . vioIcn«... ahouJd bcpn by identifrins wJ.o iI all.... chc <hoa, wlw an: their
t1w, 011< ... if no 01'1'. oinpc poth """,«I ,...., I'ornu<ion. 0.... pi JhouJd be to matcriaJ >nd poIitial inr=sa. and how do they ..lcctiwIy <mpkry oW""'" i<l<nri-
.I"""",. <Ompo",i.. poli'iesl oociologJ ofhi .....dtiaJ in«'W"""P reb,;oru. .ieI, JyrnboU, and nlun in Itading people inKl ..... In my tHim>.t<, <h .. ~_
Th.otc «>rUiderin5 m... i.... co might benefi, from • ,ex, :and .... ,.... i• ...,.of.. "war i. in "'" blood' -i> <he criticallmplic>tion Gl .......... u<JutoIosyof W2r.
'en con.i<kred, Go" .... ld·. (1979) """,iv<....y :cn,h",poIo&ical ..uJy of brad.
1250_ IOSU B.C.
N OTfi l
And,n, .nd m,di ...1 " .... ,ugg<" o,her cI.m,nu ,10" could be. P"" of
,hi' poli,iaJ ooclology (obo ... And, ..ki 1%8, On"bein 2004). How much I. 1.<BIan< ... i.h R'JIi_ (2003,124) md K«lcy (1996017) .. I,- on ... h.. ""I,y ,.lis
is i"'<rna! produ<fion ,... ranged '0 IUppor. ,""i,,, ond/o, ... «>"""1"'""" ',ho ........, ,.1 Upp<.- P.JoollmJc ",",«<ria ofc...:'-looow· .. "'I'!"'" ,ho d.<p"'.
of military .u~'io"! To wlu, degt~ .... ,nili"'1 organi..,ion, 1'''' '0 Ul< clqul', .f ....... S;"" rbclf por<<>yats of rbc...-...ln, dm... ~-hun,,",,,,,,
in ",he, kind, «Iobor' Docs mUiurr .dmiJIi",uion 1f'U' dc: .. lopmcn, Gl.
li,er.« burnl>Ct"aCJ! Ate th"" COIIImon utd eli« f"orca (Of ""'" ti<n than
WI) . ....l how doa that:uticulatc..,th domt.ti< jlr~_rn. cnrnr'<-
H_
qool ....,.,d~">e. i, 1s lmp<'£W>' "" ronJid<r rhooc d.I",. 'f'in>< ....... nc ..idmo:< on<!
inu, .. ,
_icc
fOr rbc 6ndinp from I't<d-'....d rbc , ...... d..umlti, .. ofOolnl
I. n...-.l 1'>"'-
"'" ,h.", milil2<J Misto<,OCi<s, and is upw>r<l mobiIi,y imo them posoihIc1 Do Ktdty (~ _ """ " - .. pl)-. -.; ..... loy "' ...... oroidcn<c <Jf _ _ moro-
ow, ....,.a.JIJ cnonial w..n.c.. on ..J.d, ......, '" by .... Joo~'7 <Jf _
toId,,,,Iu.v. t(jlflUrn 00mc by >=<Jft, or ore dory fnaunding p~!
Arc ...... ie ooIc!i.n- .... iu of ",1Wr>lJY disn..«iv< pcopI<>_in<orpo<a«d ;"'0
... ~ for ..... buriooIr <Jf men. .."....,., and eh.ilJrcn_tbao ..,..,.. <onIIicn - '
Iargc: .,mia1 Na< oJl of thex =r be arbject ,o ... ~ In....n.. tion. but dum. ..." _ . HiU"'; WiJrm.n (2001, md .. ......, in "''''''''' .............
~In ~ ...twt<V""I"<Jf....., _ ond<hill"n-.t.r "'""' ___
the <JI'<>'ioru m<u, Ii", be nis«! ro find ..... "" •.
i.,. """<Jf...... iol ~]..,.. bc. .. dottJ co 1>«'0'«11 ~.ooo...J U.ooo.,.... aso:
DiJcnt.ngling <hi> snarled ,hicket of ou\>.lI.y II. L>bor foe g........ io ... Gl L,&Unc ond Ropoc ... (2001,124) prorid. rbc ""'" .....""'" ~,1I<\OOIiOn of th.x fi..J.
"'hoi ..... Ono ".p .... mar pi:" " firmly now i. ,Iu, ..... ... ~L>, prac'ice, .....
""~ ... r.rrins ..... DoIni V",,,,,ic,'
. , • ""1.lln"I'"'io,,. h.ul" hrpnning. ifi, hod • beginning, <h.n .... f is not ""
i",.iobl... p.mio .. of . i,h ... hum... " n"", or ,h. . .'u'" <>f.... i...1" ' ".nco. 111< ...,II·k"",," ·,tiilt;<· ,om",<d of. ""y I"", ''''''''U« obrlouoly """p",d
by m",y f.",~1co. ';m~ .. to tho I""lu<>i< lo"ghou_ .."""..!cd by """'" ;nWJ«
--------------------------------------------------------
'morno«>. '!he """" M f l ........ ,_okd bot. wall '" r...:. 01--" bon<>. Tho< """""'" doim r..
oioknc ......... DW.i V""""i<. _ ..",_d
~ br K<dey Of
Topi<olIy "'" _ "'barrier ~ .-I .d."",,,,'.....,. -'" "'" -W for cId<no<. lc8lon<. Kl .... (1IIl7:llS). ia 1m inrti.l «JKN< _ tho ,t ............. ~"Tho< «-
""u ......... oimulDp .. hori.h • • .,oIIp<Opi<J>l-din .......... . - .. th< .....
• _ _ _ bern m....d .. [loW V~ <>p«WIy _ ......... J .....""'-. .
......01. dud!,..... ....Fu.th.......,.
..... 0I1Uo r...ed do><J,."
k deep ...... DV xur. hip "1'''' tho~ "'I'P"'"' .... <Oft<m-
of .... NO<, _ . loci '" rht <01 . . . . . .. d..r
rNln. • .......a... 01 ......... _to... --" to .... had. h io...t.;ldp ... .......
ouIa in "'<It priM<-.Id do< f...... dioeooc ............ _ Th<y«>Ulcl_ bcrn
.... pol<_;.on. pit« of. -.d """""" dw ..... pIxuI """' .... bod ... and burned.
""" «>I1.,...l.uo ..... bodl<J ($Yobod.. .. .d. 19'16:64. ~ ~ 1OO3).
blIocI in • f.Oled """"""'" hun<. hot &.d. _ .>tfut .. «n.w,. _ pIomibk. AI for .... """'" ! .... 01 ~ <iml br lc8t.no: ... <h Jt.a:t- (lOOj). ...... is_
Thi. '\olU",' .... Io<;ahod on • high point of land_ hilll p«I'i<I< • p>d obi .Id.· brJ< ............. nodt. . !ik<.Iong\>oo>< .. DoW V..""""<.onJyomall """ 01 """" ~-s
_"lIy "'"'''
r... .. opeu-th-= .... ..... .....,.,.. 01 ,II< '""", AI_ """"1
Ii"" 01 "iJ<n« f""....n= I would "1'«' to lind fo< .h" 'rr< offor.!!". h.u t...n
m d......", aI~ " DV L "",01 th<.. ..... _",!. F...". for ....... '""", ~" .!o
no< know it'd,... "". C<Io'I""'l'"'ory "" ...,...."w """yp ....... _m. 'yj~' io '!'«Ilia·
i<ko,]1i«I " Do]n; V"''''' k<. 'ion, In ml, <qIo>n .•om<>u"h Urrc' ?,t.cli,hi< ,""", .... .,. o,,,li"tJ (not ....tIed) in
'wn<> 01" bon,:, ••••d, "on< dc",rib.d "DV !. b.licT«l '" h." b..n """,,"«I lOr .boo,
L..BJ.nc ar.d ReJi"'" (2003) do 00< <il< ""y ",1<" ..« In .uppon of <I,... <h .... ,m,,,"
,;."". buI ,...,. ... mto .. ", en KJi".. (1%2). "'~ ."""""nc, do NPf'O<'"""" of thti<
<wO,...... How<Ytt. ,.... of' DV H_ ,", "",,;00 of,... 'riple bu.lai - "I'I"" <Y<n """"
.r<"P"""l" no 0<1<1".... ""'" _ ...........t ...... <11. AJu....p. ......... 1>'1" dcpool..
<41 ..... Mldlr\olUl .........h ...... &Il&/y>i< Jw occwml ..... th<o.. '\lIIuo ... .,.,.. 'u,,.,..
of""""""'" Ioon« ........ ....t ""'" Mo........... """"'h,h.,,.,,., ,k ... ........ no ..... ·
~'np<Ji "'- . ;«<! ........u"."')1 01 '"7 _ .. '"7 01 m. ~ AlrtooosJ> ern< poll <l00InI V<><fIfIitt
Thn< 10 ..... bwW .. Pt.dm.oru.<ttiauttd to clot. _ l7J1O(1 B.P. to H.OOO al'.
.. ,..,. of. ""'1 """...,...... '" """"P'''''''' h _ "",...,..1 in 1194. """' .... cr...k
..on. """"~'" _ ofbnd. iD""""io< .. I... i'" io<" k. 1bo ""'" b "" m. ........
."... <I • ..,.."...... ~ ....... ..tlq-Iiloc .............. I01 ........... pdroIoI,
....r.o.t.of......... lht ~" _ ' - t dt ... <>t«Ibrbrick mdm....t ~""".u~
..... - W .... .........,....durinr; WoM_l~ Whot ... ~ abo.. 1'mI_;, r.-
r o _ ......... ..u., ..... ,......If...-,.-.......I"' ..............tu-ios_.,.;m
midotI.. ofDolni V.-O«..u....,.-W "-Iud '0<10_ ...... ~nI< Urthtruplilll
""'..,.... of the ....... 'P">< n.. _ r.. 104 ~l.S .... iadoodi.c'-"" 0111_20 (Sd.odo"'" ,",,1~147. I SI-I~ ~ . - - i <...... 200).
indioiodNk 12 of ....... <hiloltrn, alI---' br""" Ii..-- .... (AII...,...,-)on<s
1986'ISl- ISJ..onpop...cd>pp<ndio<nUJ 1l:~ .. aL 1,*62.141.Wi). n..,.;,
... ""_ .. _. _ _ tI>n< ,..fkiNJ ... """ ~m.I '" tilt _ _. •
Jiri s.d>od.>. htl;.-.u !Iw <h,.. rcpmom. -, "",I<rn of gt>doul oJdirioM 01 bod;.;.
,,;th,n .Iong-«"" bwi.J .....: H, l»><> th4 «><><"""'" on ,I>< f"" ,.... P",d"""" Iw "Ibn,,- S, E. •• nd E. 8, 1'<<<,,,,". 197';' E..<_ion of. M..oIithi< c.-"<J .. V«l·
•di><m bed "'" ;"" .... .,.." <hltto"., wi ,h 00 I)' pon"" of. te.. bod;o, In """"'" i< order, hock. D<nm>..Jo.. "".. Jlr<h.tokti'" 47, 1_lS.
Thi> I, In "f'OXIg ron" ... ro ,he al""", compl<1< burW. of DcJnl Varon'=<. . , . l"'pl)'· "k •• L. M . 200(1./.... , ~,"" p"", low> CirJ ' UniY<ni<rof l.,...I'Koo.
i"li,hu ,adiu bod ... WHO dJ.""bcd while odd"" "'w ona" (~,o",,"""i""ioII Au.-th""",~ r. In&. n..~..w. -J th. T"'.u .... ~_ Mi'''' .. u,,...
P.I....I;.
10(3), lhi>cao bot ..... brCOftlfWi"l ..... dlav... of,hc I'r<dn>oool ...... v>'" U>d p/>o<o ""-111 c-.mJ £Mnrt. o"foo;l, CIo=o<Io<o ~
of tho OV uiplc bu,;,,) ;" Soobod. <t .d. (I'J%, 168-169). M.oo buO.!. ,..... MHo kJ0"'l- " ...... K. M• ...d H.D.G. Mu<'-'. I~. "'""""'... Hood a, o..ss, n..;._.
hlshl7 "nLWy. 'P_~. Nn..Yod.,ltwtoooandH""""
1IIn< ~ no ...... b.W .. DoW V""""". 0< Po""', 1IIn< ~ _ ...... burioI 01 "'" Ao.dcro<ft. N. 1m c oljdl C-poof' tho Fwo.lllaka Cook .... In ~;.~th.
...... and an indiriduoJ 01 .....hamUo«! or<. bu, _ ~ r.....l< (OV Il. 14. I';. P4.. %!II"""'~;' v...-f. «l,ood..,S. ..... and II.~ 100-103.
........ u.6OO&,. KIiau. 1m). "'""_ indrvId..a .....laono. and _ICtr«r«l ~, 1bo """Sorio:cJ oINoocha" ~
.."....,.. (Sladd « .d. ZOOO). Some skuL, ........ "'"' 01 OV 16 (~ ..... VIal A"""'-. D. G. 19M. n. 5, .010 ~a...p-. I'tJib<MGMttIll'" Uk""""
1991 o.\Uj " - ....II d,.. . .~ """"""",,.,.;<h noto-kdW ~ (*'-I: wUh """'" ..... S-....... T. _ _ ,~of ~
J>O*d<pooI,;oo.,I~) (- ' « . d . 19'16:147: s.obod.a. ~ -...-"",. AftdtNi. S. 1961. ,.,J..., ~ -' s.ot? II<.k.!ty, 1.Inl«ni'1 oICaliii>mia.
..,. 1(0). Erik Trinhu. clw-.a.ru... tho ..... "p«t<"/ ",I.- boom .. on tho hr>J. <hot.
, .• ( .....I..I ,..,.] h.o .. b«n ...,..,«1 for more .run ...«k Of 00. I d.o . - lind ....... ""l'
<Mol",,,,!: of i"''''l''''''''') rioIcl>«- ;uo' F""'.J .....p I;""" (pc""".! communic";""
2(0)),1.. "'''1'''- i. DV II . .,.;m . IK.kJ '''''' d.:pt.. ,"", on I" forehead (Ttinluw ..
• 1.2000,1119). W1w,Y<t ""'. go"II"'" ,h<x It< . " I""opk killtd br!>low, '0 .... hc.d.
A""'bu,,, '- U>d " . lIclftr·CoI>o:>o. 1m. .n.
Ao:I...,.. II. . 1961,.Ifiia" GAn.t. N<w Yorke DdI.
~ 1966. n.. Tnn..n.J 1"'1"""'i"" Nn.. Y",k: "<Iomcum.
U>d N.."dc.w.: Il<thinki"ll , .. I.e-
""';". Moldlt P.lroli,hi< Hominid,. In N"""'....J' • • , 1>101<", H."""" i. Wi"""
A" ... ,.iood 0,. T, Alw.o..... K. AoIti..od O. B...y.,..f)Il-311. N,,.. -':'""k, rk"um .
~
Atmt..uriL J. S. lri&>t.i • .",j f . F.,><b<,n., 1'I'H. New EviJrn.:, ofr..hiowri< Arrow 8,iJp.,ni. S. D, 1m. Mi"',,,,, ,h.n,),. I'<o! (An EJg<""'i"!.ooIt .. I,i,h S"'D2< As<
Wound, in tit. l.. ri .... ""nlruub.l.I<n<.ou.....!""'nwI {o,~ 4,ll~_2ll. s-,-.l,). In MM",.! If..... ,· .]"Iuni.t"'" S'ud;" of If{" ."'/ )1',",,,,,,• .J it«! by j.
A"" ... .JUD<o<Z' N• ...J H. SKud Cutillo. 1m. Th. 1m.,..,. of eo.......,. "" Con"",· eo ........ ~S - U S . G"'s-' Crnl",", p<=-
1"""1' I nd~""", !'<of.... of tit. Gul .... Sh"ld, 1 .. Sy=m of on-., ~ 8olk><k. P. Y. 1m. o.:.n tl.. Rr>Iltyof A"" ... I Viokn« 1'rov< ,II< My'" of A"UI,i C ... •
In"<dq><..d.nc<. In ,t... _..,. I.~ f- M",,? .. ,iN l'mA'. edl'..l by A. niWi,,,.. In D«yhm.l A"""", Viol"",. edl,ed by P. Y. 8oUo<l. 31-S!. s"",. F.,
Roos<¥<I,. S~-78. T"<>",,, Uniwnjl,of Ali""," ""' ... NM, HRM 8ooh.
B.d",hl. L. P·F, Fabbri...-.d F. M.Jksn. 1~7. An A""",·<;.u,.d L.,;oo ... Lu, lJppn- Cumon. J, (<<Iioor). 1m. M.1<ri.J H. ,..-, A~''''' Snd,,, 0/ 11;', "." V;.ko".·•.
P.kaIhi. K Hum"" P<"I~ c... ....,
An'~ lI, lJI- I.j(J. GJ..,_ , Crui,h"" 1'<....
!U",fo"h. O. 8. 1m, lod~w !'<ofk.l..!.i&<-... Viok",,, Pr«on"", 1II'arfu< OR c........ J.. ..-.d A. HMdin&- 1m. EpiIogu< , 11>< FUN" Study of A"""'", W.,f.,,,,. In
,I>< No"h Am<ri<>n G .... I'bi .... M.u. Z~,9S-l1s. A..a- II."...., A~.J fI,,,.,,;.,, . .Jittd by J. c........ . nd A. H,nii"ll.
Bul... , G, 1981.1''';"" ...."""""1 .. 1;....,.-. Cambrid!!,,' Cunbrid!!" Vnlm->" l' ~. HS- 11O. I'i>o<n;, Mtll. I) K, 5um>o Publbhl"51.td·
!Urn«. G. LIm. 11>< Hi>< 0/0''';;''"",,-;. f .." ,J, .. : 1h< k~ t{a.;~•. KImt.
"""f4.<" New Yod, llwn<s.",j Hoo""",
&t.yood". O. 19S6. Th< Will< of}<rid... , An Al"....m. In"<p<rtatioo. c.."", Anu,...
,.t.v Z7cl~7_ 162.
&,Iwn, A, L 1~S9. 1IH-~"" ,hoi""" 1""""'- N<w Yod, Grov< p..".,
-
Oupon. N. 1%11. );,. _ _ 1h< r"", PtopJ., New 1'»<10;, HoI,. RiM" .... ..-.d Win·
~, K. 1986. n.. A~ t{Ma,.' 0,;,.., N...- Hmo, Y.k Un;.... "lty ""'."
0...,.1<1.1»<, C. 1m. Th< s"!<nwlnoo..oftl.. Ptth~ 1",<1""'>"" A Slow ... R>pid
T"",f"""""",,1<--'ofA.~..Ar<~ 11,!7J_l(l1,
II<tfc,-CoI.< .. A.. L A. Sh<t""L .",j 8. ~ 1991. N<w 8iolop:.1 D... r.,.. II>< Ch>pmon. J. 1m. 110< Orifin> ofW.uf... in ,h. Ptthu.<XJ' ofc.nmd .,.J r.""n En·
r-;""ti .... Popul ...,., in br.d, In 1"" N.'"fi.u< CoI",,,;../h< u-t. edl«d byO. &to rop<. loA",;"" W""",,: A"~" Pmp«6w>.edittd by 1- eo""",.",j A. HuJ·
f.oo F. R. \~ I ". ~l1 _ 'H . Anft A<bo!, MI, In",,,,,ional M~, in r..h ...
y..... i", 101_1-1 1. I'ho<M ),1111, UK Su,,,,,, r.blbhi"l l<J.
'0" , Oupp-\<, E.. U>d C- S, Coon, 19U. f'rl~ ofAnl~. N...- yo,k, H.n,y Hoi!,
lI<n<dic" R. 1 ~9. Th< N"",.! Hb,,,,,yofW.. , lnM A"~., w... , 1h< I~ Ch<rn<b.1- l'l';l')' 1h< 1t'..... J."kt1U of/h< B'Jw"~A""''''''.- As."" 0/5,.". Au"in,
{ 1b.1h IJhWi(/. edl"d by M..'V"" M<>d. ~-3B2. ",,",0'" H ough'on ),[;jf]a-.. Vniftnlty ofT..... ""'".
B..g... T, D.. .",j E. Trinb.... Ins. P"""" ofT"""",,"""'"i tl.. ~J--l Child.. v. G. 1~1 . w.. in Podobtori< SoIini ... ~.. !lnnn.U, 116_1.18.
of.I~'ti<" ,y i""" n«I-8SZ • a.,... A. E. I9%. N.., .. a..-"t'" n.. PkUto<....· HoIO< ..... T"",I,ion In Nonl..." AI·
BinfQ,d. '-..-.d C. " . H... 1985. Taphonomy ... ViIUl>«' ZhooI<wdiM. "11>< eo.. ,Ia. In H _ "',.. buI of tJ.. la oW' 1h< ~ of tJ.. ~H.i«,",
Hom< of8<ij"" M,n"! a.m-.1.f.~'D U,'l}-oj'l. T.."',.... '4i,t</ by L G. 51 ....... 8. v. &;b, n, J M. Ed>""-'. .nd D. R. y""",
Blick, J. 1983. G."",id.J W.,f.... In TfiW SoIinin .. , R<>ul, o£Ew-opt-....ind..«d Cul· 4J _60. N...- YO!lt, Pl.n" ...
'''''' ConII;.,~ MJ. 1J,6~--67\l. Cobb. C. R."..[ B. M, 8o,h 2001. Th< V",,"", QIwu' R.-ri<i"J, r.. .. Mi,.iosippl. n
I!oa.<. N.. ....! R. L Ci<xlun. 1001. Th< Xn<"Jlnl of-""liOS M..... N-to~ """"Y. Ab.ndorun<n, of tl.. l<>wt.- 01.;" Villq< ~_ A.,'i"iIf' 7,621--641.
),h",h.oj6-SL Cobbi",.J 1'188, Th< Mf«:.n< .. Al ibi, 'Ihoush<>"" Dh!u1onl.nd Mbolom"...p""",1
lI<><h m.C- Im.H"""",,iJ< "'" FHru, 1h<E..«._ of~' 1ltI.._ .CunbriJs<, { Ajrl<." /-6umy 19,48';'_ Sl~.
1U... ni Uni,..,,,'1' "" ... CooJ< ... H. I~IO. I-)';";",,..;,b ~IJ: A Stouly of I(...J;.II Pott."h,"t .... JJ~>fo>-<
&..11. I.op< •• M. c.. S. A. J......... Brob. ~. 1- A, Ortrp V.tkt. Ins. T, ...... iun, '" J7"l1-I9JlJ. s..ttk , UniY<nit)' ofW. ,), ingK>ll P.....
Sroo .. "-5" s.,,,I,,,,,,",, In ,I.. lb."," """;n,.Lo, A'5" Cu)"" .. Prr<mi;"l' of Ih< Comund..·ll·<>«fTn>p. T. S.. ...J R. R. N<w<U. I~ 1>idoI1,tt;" T""""" V.",_M .
SI.<tI, t·• ..,.-_ itfrtti"t ofIh< P.lt.p.uhho A-wI_. 6$_72. _Jon.o. a1 ...d ChronoIopal Tm>dt In W_m Ew-opt-. In i'r«ndl"t of II.. 4th ~
S..dky. R. 1991. Th< I'>tt<m o£aw-.g. '" Bri,on mnu."", In~' P-. F.-.. M"",'"lt{tJ.. Pm.,.~~, MIJJUM'TA• .......,... 19~, .Jlt«! byG. T.
"",•• '" ,~, .<lit«! by T, £",10, 44_7\l. N... y."l, c.mb.i<!s< U.u...m'1' Pr-. ... Hmtmd ...1 W.RX I'<rizon ..... 70_76. lIn«h •.
Il.-..i ... C- K. 19'8!. Thdf. ",,,,..- "'" Il."td'.f. ,. . . . . . . .. dfouur CAw 7:; ' ""!'. Coo-di<,. G. I~ Binourt< Prdtlot<><""'" Anioul .... Hum.i .... __ A...... <H> P!'Oj«-
Cn"""" I)n;..mty o£o.""", P<=- BuIkri"'" s..;."
,..... c,.... ..... III ~ "-'1• .-,., IO _ 1 2~2_48L
H")'. w.. (..l;,,,,). 1986. W"P'''''1'.,.r w.. r. ". II..ut .f~ 18(2). CoupUnd, G. 1~88. 1II>zfu...-.d Soli:.! Cornpk>l,y "" , .. No"h,..., Coo>t. I" OJ"""
Il"'n ...... M. U 1991. H,oI!b.nd Di""" In ,he M;d<ik ,nd l/pp« hieoIM;., ofSo<o-h- i" ~" a.m-., ~ P""",;,,,,, «lim! by D. ct.1« and lI. C. ViYi ...
wt",m F.-.n«. Vnpubli<h<d Ph.D. du.......,.., D<putm<"' of An~y, N...- 2~_11 4. C:.!5"'J" \In iY<nlty o£ C>l5"'J' A"'~ ......",jorion.
Y",k Unl .....:ty.
-
C,,""" , W .. ..-.d J. H.. ~ 1m. I.... ,hon 1>1«" "'" Ey<' £>id.n« fo.- """,",Inori<
--------------------------------------------------------------
./tJ ~_",-
o.i.I"d.:.r.t in Nonh.m NtwM.. _1n CJMfiI-.-l~,• .... , _ Eddr. F. W. I.,.• . PDp-laDon l);oIoaoior, in "'" N..w~, Oiotna. Nrw Mal«>
""""" bJ E. M. 1I.c<Io>o.J, 4)-61 (;>,......u.. Um....;ty I'rno oIRorida. ond Colorado. ___ """""" )9, 7S-114.
CJbohll.J.5. IY'J1.A G........u.IIori.JG,_..I H _ R.....;.,.,.,/ ~~ ~ ErIJrr- R. B. 1972. V......,. in f. ... Afri<- TriI.rI Sao.6n. Ja CJJ.r_ V..«w. ...
~ -
'" &of" c.;.,.,b;,.
N<><,h"", eo,.",l" I.
c-.t p,n,;.,..,.
to.
H.I~ Qo<h«. c.-I .... .\I....... olCP'iliza.
n....,.,. W. 5. mz. Vill.og< Oripu In c.n.,al Oft." Th< JI. ... 1n and r",pI~of ~ F. L Hm ..... ....J .J. I. Vepo. ~ ",,-W'-'durioa "'-h"''''T1n <he
Rran, MiddltanJ L.ou: Wood4ncIIkoutd..In c.Jb.r.J I~io Coo_, """" lb<rian _u..oLo wit!. Roped to So.. ....... ....., _ Lorifto-. 1+wMIi"l' -I<k
/pJ .~"dx MU.OIw PJ0, ... "••11'1'101. F.Sr.m.n. U _17. MCj.4. Sp«iaI IX" E-.,-. ~"""w<{.. r.u.,,* !'D ~. 141_IU. ""«dona.
P'P<' - . 7. Kmt. OH, llw KNot s.- Un;"""" "-- f>pa. B. M 1m. m.nn.t ~ _ .. 1Jr. ~ -I. C...-. Nnr Yorl.,
1Nl,,,,. J. A. 1m. M ... w-............
me t:x<-. of 'FMC.... IJI .... ,,-.me_ ~~~
50.>, ........ ' ; _ 4 0 ,1. ~ loo,731-1Sl. F.s<.J. 0 ....... R.(I!;..-r,- (...u. ....~ 1975. .",.~H,..,<{Afr.,.. 11010_1;-
Don, It 1957. 7h< o.~ CJ"", ".,,_~ 1'> ..."""," ~I,moinof IN u./;.,. T.- to,. SOl) AC N<... York, ~ UniYmol.,. """'"
,II< T,,,,,,,,:..! Muo<um, No. 10. brri>, W. W. 1999. s-wI r_ ..... 8.ri<rI T........... I""";,, ... ~.J ,j,,~
t>.IIoc" W. 1981. Bull"" l<>n<. in !I,< Cult"r..! u"",,Y of Abor;~;1Ul A"'..."" .... An Lth- <{,I ..._;..""". Hoo<>1ul., Unl.." ltr0f H""';·i 1'.<".
"""i><ori<;>l Appo>o<h. A_"" AIt"""" 0<;,)6-1-)77. ~ 199\1.)"1""'" J}OO.I. U........ S«i"';,, tb.A.anu • ..JM~ U......... A' ...
_ _ 1986.1'd1q< mol Produ<,1oft in "'" Amu.oo>. A V;"'- ""-ch .... Co..;!", of .... ,/xMrJ;,.".__ Eo..,..•• ..,1 M _ _ «Ii.«I by 1(.IlulI.. b>n<!N. R-ruorin,
lJc.raIi &.in. r....... hnL 'u..IJA~ 18,1l1-2"-. 47_70.~, c",.«" FO. Hdlmk Smd;a ..... HMYUd Un .....;.,.".,.,
Jlwh_ T""I"'"_
';",nI;,rd..,.S.G ...... uodS.~_
F.<poon. R. B. 1983. ~_ ..... 1laLrrui_ EIdwio&< OIl "" Nor di ..... c-... In
~
n..~<{Po/;&J~;,,~~_ ,I'I7'I "' ...
<{_"-=- F+
"...no ~So><...,.
';......s-.,.nld.dbyE. Toakrr. ID-IU W../oi_O.<:':
Did,'" I). N.• C. G. Mr.. 9..1(. Ba.-on....d G. H. D<>ran. 1981. ""Orbi ..1 Root...d UJ ... by 11.. B. F.~,...".. 1_81. 0rUnd0, A..d.mi< P.....
fh<tu", from <he £"/1 A.. ~.i< of HorMl •. j'u","" <IPm.,..,J..J.o 2, 16'_170. ~ InOb. A Ilo-......... ion of II>< c...r.. of North ...... eo....
W.. £. ... In U""P""
D" hM........ P. M. 1m.. F""I""...d F......... in W,,,·c. .. r>l Ad... I" 1/• • "";,, T....".. Col""".""/ &_""".,.• dl .. J by R. B. ~""'" 267-llll. O.w.do, A<><km;';
J~. "'i«<l by M. Zv<kM 121_ m .. c.mbnde<' c-.hridF \.I"_r "'-. "-
~ 1!n6b. The u.. M<ooIirIIi< 0IId "'" T" " _ <0 Food 1'100""",,, In E..um E.o. ~ 19'Kl Blood of"'" \.c.iodo.vr, _ ..... COlI ... , >n<! ",uf_1n An,..""ia.A-n,
top<. In 1I"~rI'" T....-.edloodby ~1. Z........ J09-120. c.ml>ncIp,~ 00>< E' 'l"" 17{Z), m _U7.
UooJ...,.;ty p"",. ~ 1912. Tribol ~s-.+ "-'-"
266(1), lOll_II}.
~ 1"'- W... ...d I'no:... M _ E.orop<.In._U:..Jo..'~ ~ 191'\' _ WodoioCo1lid<,11><CoI-bion ~ ill Global "" ..... 0"'-
~n.o, _ by.J. c..m....on.J A. ~ 73 ..... Phoorni. 101 .... UI(, Sunon _f'<>rq IO(I),I- Il.
Publi<ll"" Ltd. - - - . 19'H.11>< G.....,. c-..um<..
"(W, r. An AtnHonI..,Pmpo<,;... ill s...J,-
D....... 11.. 191.J. Th.1AJ -I"-lI> ••u.4s<: ~;. Ilftr-p..~"" tb. ~~,., IV II;'" .f.....,.••• ,;.,.lP"',..,;_
ed,"" by S. P.Il<p •• ...1 11.. L Down.. IS-ilL
1m lI.e J>rin«"'." J>ri.",on UnN""i.,. 1'=0. ~"'" rA , G9rJon ....J B.. ock.
Oro. O. W02. W.uf.« in <he P""o/,I"""" Sooth.. ". lWO_1700 In S",...o c...tArIT ~ 1m.. YA""....,.,' 1141<": A I'r>IJlit.1 11""'7. 5""" fe. NM, Sch<><>1 of A."tlnn
..
• ..J C«",i<s: A~.J Pm~,_ <IN PnHohUt4ri< S-rhuJl. t<!"t<! by C. /I. ~.-
W.-...J M. A. It«.. 116_141. T""'....... , Un~;,( AJ.ho..,. Pm.. ---. ~!nfn.tn><fWal o.«"";nkm. In Stin.«.loWtrlAii' ... . ..J... St-9<{GJ.
Oyoon.JL H. 1981.1'>tod.p a......, in doc Snody of do< Indo. Cml~. in 1M,.. ......
" ..,«lim! by M. F. Morphy ..... M. MugnlH. .!.l-J&. c.w..w., ~ ""'"' of
,... c-& "a..1 C-,.,.,..,..,"'s-
Ddh;, o.Ioed ..... IRH I I'IoW ....
1'mf«-. <dim! byG. L .......... IS_~lt. N.w
~ I'l'n Vdmoe...d Il'JooIn ........,.,.In TnrJJ.JT_: V.w-uJWMjm",
tIN Hut. ,dil<d b:o O. L. M.rcin ...d l), W. Fa ,..,. 311- 3SS, l=ghom'. PA, G<>«Ion Gilij. E S. 196\. En".,. J. lltit.m. A"",;ww (3 book,). T..."J,t«I and ",,1in>in... Y'rudy
...d8",.. h, by A. To .. " c. ..." ,lIihl.,.""" d< I.A,·'OOnia No<ioolliJe III Hi,ron..
~ 19'98. Wh,,,,,,. H'l'P'n<d '0 ,h< S""", I\g<! $,«l Tool ..... YUIOn',rn, Hi"oo ' GoIdb.,~. N. J_ .",j f.J. Findlow. 1984.A Quan'i'''i .. An.Jy>l, of R"""n Mi/; ...yOp .
<Ill Erok>gy, In A""""",
in H~",;,'" £ubg. <di,<d by w. IW". 287-312. New Yo,k, m .';"O, in 8ti ...... rir<> A.D. ~l ' 0 2l8.In II:..}",. ru,~ ... 4"" En_""",. «ij,<d
CoIwnoo Un ; '~"i'y Prt ... b:o R. JI. F,'ll""'" 3S9- 3l!S. Odando , Ac..rkm" I'm<-
~ 1m. A P=<ligm fo< tho S,ody ofW",...d S<><"'1' In lV., ~!i«in] in A.dnr, eo.,..-.Id. N. K. 1979, 1IN Trlb<t -IY.ht..b: A SiKuI4tJ -I';" fiLl;,;,'" "WK.",,J I~
.m.J .If";;,"", 1I'Mk . AsiA, tIN MtJ;",."",,~1t, E""'!<, ..JM_ _ _. , N ;t<d J:., K. IlSfJ _10SO ac.E. )'!"ylnoll. NY, Orb;"
R,.lhub .... N. Ros<ru«in, 389_£7. W""inf!""" D.C. """ Cambtidg.-' C.n", fu, Gourrn«h, P. I9%. Mi.fu""", Tdlm. 7ht N ... Y,,*,".lIpriIS,96_100
H,Ii<nk Srudi«. di"ribut<d by HuvuJ Un;.""i'y l'r= G"rnl,-. R. M. 19811. ConAkt.nd M'n« in ,h< £.""n Woo.Il...J.. ln In"?,,,""""'''
~ woo. A s....g.- I'.ocount"" W,",m Con ... , .",j ,h< Y,no""m i w.,. C<:><npk<. In C""",, Cb..tw in tb. F"",,,,, W""""'''''' dO';"l tb. r.." 1l:..JI..nJ Pm..;.• d i t«I by R.
lV., ;" tIN Tn"'l L.m,-, £'f,mJi"t $t4t",mJ '.dip",,,, 1I~,fon, (S<r:ood rr""il'lf,), W, Y,""~ 8 ~-n Columba" Dqrmmcn< of An'~. O~io S""" Uni""'i!),.
<dit«! J:., R.. S, p,rgtl""" . nd N.1. Whi'<h<>d. 19'9_127. s.."" 1'<. NM, School of Gu i!.'",-1-. and 1- Zunm it 200S. 11M Ontim "W"': V""un" ,. M'"ory. ,ru"l>.t«! by
Am<,k,n !I.e,u uh Pt< ... M. J-k,,,,, ~bld,"- MA, al ..kwdl.
~ 1001. 10.000 YUH of T"hlll W.,fu,. 11M p .....1 _ I ,,,. In"'~ ,.,,;'"" G"".~.. o:Ia/t •• R.A.LH. 2000. C""'Iu,,,. ,nd R.csi",..,., ~"o« . nd S"t< E-.p>ru;"n_
8 (Jp. 4-S. i"" in w lr Sri Lmhn Hiorory. In 11;"- ... tIN Trt~1 z."., Exp..nJi"!, S"" ",."J I""it"
- - . 2003. 1""<"h,,,ion, Violtnt Coo~j" ,nd Control of ,f!< S" ... In 1IN SI"".Id",. '""'" W"'.fon. «i;,<d by R.. O. I'<'g"""' ...d N.1. Whlt<I><><I. 61_81. 5=" F,. NM,
"'" .m.J Violma, PoI;ri<ol o;,;"'P"'u . ;" tIN Po.t·C.u II;'" UIJ./J. <dit<d by R., B, School of Amori<lit !I.e.." " h rr., ...
mgu"'". I_I%. Nt ... YotI' R,oo,kd&<. (;upt•• s. P. Im ..~ -I£win Cn.tr.l All... and tb.1ndW. &rJm4"J.. 2 ..,J •.
~ 2001, TtiboL ·Ethnk; and GIobIll Wm. ln 1IN~-I&..I,,"t GJ.l../C..• N<... Delhi, Jl.R . Pu bl;,I.~Co 'l'o..tio!L
}lim. , dit<J b:o M, fi t2dulf litd C. $'OUL w"tport. CT, Pr"'S" H.. ,,1- 1m. w,rt.,,,,nd tl>< EvoI .. ion QfT,iWi !'oJ«it, in me P"hi"otk Soo,"_".
l'<'I\u""" R. II" ..;,h I. E- Forngt.". 1981l- 1h<A""'~'IW"': A ~, N<..- In 1INA"'~ ofW",", «li«d by }. Hi.... l7l_IS9. o.mbtio4< ' Cambr;dS' Dni-
Yo<" 1", H",y FWik G"8I!,ni><int fuunJ..,;" n. """i'y P", ...
I'<'guoon. R.. B.. >oJ N. l. Whl«h<>od («l iro<<J. 2000. w.o, i. lh< TM..l Z'n', &p.md. ~ 1999. Thr O~in>ofW., o<nd Ethnk VioI<",,'. In Mnml W"'.fon . Am-oI.pal
i"l S",m .n.i fnJilP"" w.,,ju-t (St<ond prin'ing "ith ..... ""faa). Sur .. F,. NM , P"'f""'",. ,d".d by J. c.""", and A, H.ud;ns. 11_24. Phoenix Mill. UK, SIm on
Schoc.l of Am<,k .. Ro"",h Pt< ... Publ''''inS l<d.
",,,,• .,.1• • C .... ro, M. C. 19'9S. I..... in f',rl,w,ry. o.fon/, abck..d L H.... J".nd W. Cream<!. 1m. \1:'.,.("" """"S ,Il< Pueblo", Myrh, H i""",•• nd Edu~ .
Fornando.-J. h Y, 1- C. Ok •• I. ~...,;lJ. ~U. 1999. H"""'n o."" ihill ;rm in d' e '","y. Eth • ..,,,1ory ~+. nl- 26J.
&mo,,,",,,,,,,,
ofH"""", E""._
Early Pki"""''' of Europe (G 'an Dolin•. Si<m. doe A"PU<"'L ~ Sp>in).J>.",'"
37 ,191_622.
F,mn. A. 198~. tht O>-;fi., oflt;.,., Fr.",,.. S,-, Ag< ,."I=mJ" tb. G"",. N.... Yorl,
H • ., ilron. C. (. J irot). 19'9S. 1IN MI" ''''' Aftmowh:
Umuni'yofN.... 1'm<-
o.&ttt ,. s..utbr...
Afrom HiJlory.joIunn<Sbti'g' Wi,,,,... ,,,,," d Un;v«'i'y r,.,., and Pit""".ritili,.'1I '
Th>"", .nd Hod,.,n. I·b"; iog. A. 1999. \1:'"f.,,,,, A Delining Ch,,""t<ri,ri< "fll"",,, Ago Europer In A",,,",
Fiu.. P. R., ,"d S. K. Fioh . 1989. Hohobm W.rf." from • R,gion>! P<r<p«ti'<, In CJ· 11~'fi"': A~.I Pmf<'''''''. <d it«l b:o J. c."""" and A. H,rJins. IS7_ 17~,
to",;" C""j/i(t .. C."..~, A"h~i<.1 /'mpH';"'" , dttod b:o D. C. lb<.uk and B. C. Pho<nix Mill. UK, Sut,,,,, 1'ub1;,I.inf! L<d.
\'jvj .... 112_129. c..Jp'Y' Th< Univ<ni!)' ofc..Jgary A~ A..",UOOn. H<mminS. J. 1m. lid WId, 1IN u.qo", -I,IN e""ilw. ,I_w • . C1mbrirlg<. ~IA,
Rannt,y. K. V.. IUId J. M..-cu<. l OO}. Th< Origin ofW.~ 1>:"", " c D.>.", &om And.n, H..-r.onl Un",,";!)' rr. ...
M"ko. Pr.<nJml' -I"" ~ .lwJ"", -1$&""" 1<»' IWHSOS. Hen",. D.O. 1981. Pt<'W'<ul,u,1ll S.d.."i",,, Th. N"ufi ... E.nmplo. In f',rl,;,,,,,*
F",..,. D. W. 1m . Ofr.e-r: f.id<"cd",. M,.... ithk M=oo:r<, In TrowbltJTint<t.- Vi"""" fiJm,,... GAt","",: Th, ~".jC..J_f C"""hit,. <di,<d by T D. Prk< and }. A.
.m.J l1~oj;',< in ,'" r.Jt,«i;,«i b,- D. 1. Marti • ....! D. W. mY'"', 181 _1HI. L.nght>rn<. S"",n. J.65- 3S-t OrI>nJo, A<><kmk p"""
PA, c....d"", and B,..,h. H ilL p_ .",j). Wikr=n. If}(J2. ~ .IW"" tht ""huol"l.' -IAgm"" ".JD<-
Fuk"l"_ f. 19'98. Wom<n ,nd ,h, E..,Jori"" of World !'oJi'k ~ ~ .iffo1'" S<pt<m- ftnM. CIurk""", SC, T.",p"',
b.,/Oc,""'"'. 24_40. Holl;'oQn. S. L.",j D. W, (h.-,]'y. 19'9 • . o...u/<>gyof tho Foy Tul"", Sit<, Irnplk..io",
C". A. woo. Th, 0..,= .n.! O'igin' of· Printiti", W.rf... · , Rtp1r '" f<rgu",""A.,b r. fot w..r. ... du,ing me Inirial Middl, Mi.oouri Voriur,. In ShIrl.1 Bi.J.v in tho GTm'
~.J fb.<rt,rry 7), 16H6 ~, p",;"" Mifm'u" U;,'fo .., H-""h. ""J S.hWl,"". <dit«! b:o D. W. o...lry and R. L.
G itd", .. S. 1%1. 1'" Et=Jl f'rr<mt: 1h< S",",";,,!' -IArt. N... Yorl , P,n"""". jan ... .4S- JS3. w..hin~ron. D,C Sm i,h"",ian I""i,.,;"n P"". •
1
H..... G. 194(1. n. W... of"" " . . , A St...J:, ofl~ T..,{, t.,t.-. M.d......, of- M-.hi& a.tJ-. tdi.. d br V. j. ((niSI" J<. and V 5o~ L-lS- Wa>h·
U ";"""y cI W'.... ""'"", WtJ!"" D.C,: Sonl,h_ian I ...IM;"" r.....
Ii..... W. B_ and C. G. T......... I"J. R..I;,.~ .... ·G .... ~., 1II;'tthniII'. KoId, r L 1W1. 1h<N..... pClolliurion, AnO" ....... 11:0 1lw~~~
F... <:-7 """ i.. Rc<ood on.. ~, VioI<ft<L III ~.; 8' ' +.., P.,... </c.-J ,t,;",«1;,.,j br ,. L KoId, ¥!i_unitt A•......k. NY, M.E. SIwp<.1n<.
, . . ... /WQ 1I~·G... 'WJr•.!;..,...~... «Ii...t lor V. Atklt>t. 143-191. Sal, KoUln ..... 0.. and M. Ni'oId! . 1m. N<oj,dLi< E",I".",,, in G,..k M><nIo.tio,
~ Ory. trl', _ cI\.atL.d ~ ......_ V .......... NC!q.v\oltnt A","" ofT.. n-uI Do--. In _ _ W.J-: A..
- . . K. 1"'- ~;.,-, N.w ~ .. Io..!- Em ,bOt. ......,.,ho, .....'*tkJ ,........... «111..1 br J. ea........... A. H..d"'5. It_". Pho.rrw. Mil.
~cllu...;·I""'" UK , SoonootNol. . . . W
.J.oI>I<>.. J. 1'15(1. 11< 0.,.- .. I'I.»u 1""'- T",* , , - - . _ _ ~ KozIoo,.li. 50 K• .,." s...w. " ~ PPN Noo/i,ki< Site .. ~ ...... ~
Society ~\onov"'" s-k '"
J-b><tL, T. 1r.6. 1lw T......... </~ " H,..,</~I. ; ',.; ... hbt-.,..".
1~ , ~ _3l.
Rl« and 5oA.ulll ..... 1· ... Sok ...... C;." U. ......i<yofUw. .......
Lado. Eo 1~ Th< N..... cI"'u.~__'".... _CM.troIJ,L&~_iIJ,.
...<1 .......,. R<yon.jN . . . ofr..u ~ 16. LS7_176. ~11aop<. C. 1"'- ( .... ill £<Irn. 1< *"" W....... H<lL 1b.N,,,, y",* T"..,..
.......
~Iy. k. c.lOUO. IIA11mSo.:ittM"""_o.;,;.
o{Iv. •. Atut A.bo<, u...........,.clMi<!t.i·
•••
Kli-.II. I9Q. Th< r""
c;-..t.pbIocl... '1>P« NtGIoohi< ........ s..
1 .... ,\I.!dI. ...... ~A. 1961. T_ </~;/... N<wY""', HonyN . ............
-
w...p. ..... i.. M<......... C--T-.ltU..o~:A.. ' ', •••V '4-_of ~ 1m. 1lw a..- </w.,-. An: do J...... _ to hIMoIttlnt c.- P"m-c.
s-. c:Jt."J """"""" ",,;,.,j ..,. If, j. e.ut->d oo.d G. k. Wdloy. AI. a....o: Combridt<' C-...... Urt...,.;., .......
t..,.;.,0."'1. 1lw E#m ofMil.t c--, l1-1J.d1i-t Q.Iroo,r. 5<""', ~
~ m7. ~ Tripi< 8otrioI ' - .... \Jpptt PaIooI,""" clOoW _ •. ~ .... ' i alS"a..,,,,-,aplo_6.
•• k~J--,J </H_~ 1601Jl-alS. u... L "'" s.,_~ P" ....... ChIndono V.,IaIoU."and .... 0.. I p .. n, clt:.dr
KftltIw. V,l-J<.andV. P Sup ui.1o. "". ~N<wH......,.of_ I...... ~ s..... ... NonhOoio.o.J--,Jofh 1 I ';rcJ.' .... "",OI~W-!8I.~
---------_._- .
SM ~.-"'J--
1Jord.s. ""'- 1"~1{,1" ; '_·., ........ NewYool, l1.a.M>-.d Hodoon. ~ 1999. W.wt.u. to. Pr.hioo..n. and F...ty H...ori< E........ Notth ~J-nul1{
...,....,. C O • ....J K. G. Hripr.. I'lSL Tho .......,....,[F<ac ...... ;., Slcln.ol PupuIotioo." .to,. . . . .J Rn-d.7, IOS- I5I.
wi"' ...1:.umfI< &- .... ut.b.n Sit.. 0..-. c-..,. 011. _J-nul1{ Mil ...., Go It. [. Andrnooo. ..... V. G. StttidL 1991 . 1Il'...-f_ .. t... Prdoit<..n.IIl'"",_
~A~~,u<J·~ I. C-... W...... ~~'S&j.8].60).
~.'.I9UT~ .. ~"lH'-71{ su-, .. A;w.<.W '"'tF Io'oIIl.. S,), 1m. o,.,8i« and ~_ .. Spa.oish Pr<h-,., lh< RlII< ..rw..r-
Coonbridp \J!IiY<nity Pr-. ;., So.i«aI o..doptwn, £rom .... L.",o" 1'"",,1, '" Third Mill<al_ I.C ;--1-1
IRw. 8obbI. 1000. II-Iy s,.",~: A ~ L.M M _~. ~, ,~~](H-J1.
......... "" lJo,l .... ity!'.ft.. M....,. R.....dD.1>tuwit<. tm.1IxG......,,,.I{<lNS-...... An> ~.",
L>«n!U". ). 2001. -""-' R<...J Soon< T",th In 'Nobk s..-w Myth.' 1ht Il..o;~p.o LirlJui><i<. <>0. 11. Vi< .....
I ..... April I!. A~. M.,.... 0. F. and p, .... Mot><, 1m A..b..""'v of<INC""...J MiuWi".· I./ky. ,*". Yo,k,
M"'tx.n.l.l. G. I~". K""",.p F.., N.h4 • .J HM. ';' s",. SM."" (/,,..,. M,,',/, c.J.... An<I. ..I<P_.
..... 11;"wk.1 &,.."h""d A"./pll ojS,",,,,,,,,{ (/....... ,. 0."...,,, Narinftol M"",,,,, M_ M. L..... d J. M. Erland"",. 1992. Fum, R<~ I\od......! o.r.ru, .. SIt<>, 11><
oI'M"", Antj,qui 'y ofW"f... ...,." ..... N",th P.<i/k Coon ofN""h A"""., .. A",'-' A~·
/o-Wo.-..u B. 1941. "'n
"'"hropologi<ol ......!yoio ofW". A_""-"",,,J ;fSM..t.p ~ 19{1}.1).9(I.
4Mll-SW- ~h_ P.). I'IS8. L-W-nand.smknwmand~ l<o T,oaporaI I'<Np«tin.
M""",, D, l. 1997. ViooIno« ApI .... w.,...., in .... J..1'I>c. RMr V.!ky(A.D. 1000-- '" ho ....,....-I{C<b-~'" tl.tE-t.... If' 'l.,I,J..by .... t..z" IIWJI.,.J
1,lOO). In T....u"J T-.· V,./nou-J IVory... ..... "....,«IiffiI by 0. I.. M..... ...d 1mM.«L«<I by R. 'IIV. 'Ima, 1_rl. ~ 0.,..- ofl\n<lu-opoloc. Ohoo
D. w. Fr.,..... 4~7'S.~, Goodooo ..... J:Iondt,. s. ... u........;.,.
M....... D. L.....d 0. w. FraJ<r (edl"",,). 1997. T...JI.tJ T_' I:ow.... uJ IVory... .. .'oIywn. T. I911.SrWoIt CoM.<uandSaciola..,._ ........... yali ....... Pm.. £.h , .
...,ll,rn·rn
.... 1'..... ... ""••_ , Goodooo aM 8t<a<1o.
M<c.-.. T, O. and II.. t:.;do. l~l'I. Tho s-.. "* M.ft of Mow..- c..-L 0d00d, N..... R.. 196'. 0.... M......, 0=0'4 .... 0.... 1 Tnt ....""'" )jl}. 14 . lJl,
""'.....
M~ f. 1999. Tho Inm.! xi<rr<"" E"",,,,,,,",, ~pdoII. ...d AIIa/y1io of AIMric., A v..... from c..,raI Arlun..o.A_..,...,
N......,. M .. "'" I;. """" 1999. lh< Adoptio«,,( "'" IIo<f and ""'- ;., Eam... NottJ.
~:H)-1U
.... K<M<'O'Id; M", HWIWI R<nuiN. PukN... N.m...l Porl< __...<t.llpo. s.rnu. i'II«<IIIam.) • ..d R..Ds, Y-. 1994. Sa.... -J Ci,.;!i"';"" .. 0, ... I~ S, 0..-
JIO"I"",/bruI<wi<lI~.hun. w., -J ~ T~-" P.,., VI !>Ii!<"", T«• ...uc,
M~ _J .~. Cam.
Medi",. J. 19,}-O, '1/M /)i~ I{.... A-..... ""..4;",,, ,/H .f",••, I{nvr r;.,~ t.r.lp, CAm],.;,lp Uni..,.ity Pt=.
J. c"......p1."" OIJ,.. ~ . H Hc.'",", edl, ... '8. 1.<'. ,,,",1,,0<. New Yorl;, a
N<i""" A. 1000. AJW<Pioo. w.. £..... ....d "'" 5p«-..to(,l\o M.oo.menc.n Too;,""' .
Aln,rian erov>ph i<ol Soci<'y. •• Tb. "~h.u.J"D I{ &:1....11_ _ , R,/i' ...., W...forr. """ &<ho>tl" A""" tIN
MdJ...".J. 1%1. c"ul H,.,..: A N..J;,h.. T_I. """'...Jill. New Yo.-lt, MoG ..... Hill
~ 1m 1"NHl.mk I{<lNN_F.d.~,Th ....... ....d lludoon.
ms. tumt.Iodon Hill Donrt. Enpand. In liMIMNm ~ lNfoun .. ....
,......
.1_... SMH"'-t -J &,-J. edl",. br M. ~ BoulcItr, Un; ..... I'y Pr... of
M..... , R.). N<w<omb. W. W. """ T........ on 1J...J.,m~.,[W'" '" F.-,.;. d.tJri. .... <{CJ-
N..b... I{H ....... ~.editrd brC au,.... P. T~C ~J.c.rd..oo. and M. /oW- _ : ho ~I{&JMA. I»i".ed~ed byG. Dole and R.. CMn< .... W·JJ6, New
d<-. T,'.t7. o.r."d, llrimh. ..... h I g' allUpom. l."'......;oo.& sma -I03( 1 ~ rod;,-n-... c.-dI.
19t9. Tho woo. Ddro.", ill Ill........ Eutofo. hn II, Tho ... ~ [ ..;, M • ..d 0. KoUinidoa. 1m. ThoSymbol .... oIV ......... l'.l.DaI~
~
d<ftc .. _1U~1_ 1I .
- . 19'19. ,"" Ori&i- oi 1Il'..r..--. in "'" Sntuh 1""'- I. ",....... 1I16f-. ~
Ni .... • . J
of"'" L.",o" ....... "*.......... G<..i«...,..,..,..,.. ...
~t.Jm.J H_: .-/nf
s-4t>I{WIr-J I~._ by). c......... rl4·19'I, G"'t--: Cn<"""" Pr-.
' pw
¥J I'mI«'--' odoted br J. c..- and .... I~ 10-1$6. """'""" !>till UK, 0'8rim. M.)..MO!W, R.. Wood. I99L 14tJl","",} I{M-. C h ",", u..;......,;".
s-o.,.....,........ 1...t. oI'M.-p,....
Mldan<.a.y..... '8. 1m. 11>< hJn-,l{fopI:" " <IN Fl... £tn<i.o"''' <IN Fint PIw- 0'C0ru0<1I.~, L. I~ RJ.1{.... s.-.JH-.o: 1ht &nIJ -J 0.""-111:"-. N<w
...... O:tr."d, 81",kwdL rod;,o.r-I Un""""r Prao.
~!~ kr. D. 1~8S. J.looIoIy and .... H,,__ c;.~-..-..jH""""A.~J Ar· 01 ..... s. L.. and P. Sltipm.ut. 1994. Cu.tmub.tId "","-"" .. T.." .... n' of &cler..
,b..-" t ,H ..7L 1\....,.. "'" ,l\o North.m PWn '" S!<InJ 1J*'v" ,/H G.... , 1'1.",,: Mi.!""u...
Mil .." G. R. 1m An o.«olop<.IP=p<<<i.. .", P,.~i"ori< w,,(.,., In RrtN-1Ap- W""",." }I",111, ."d .1..Jr,4"na, edit..! by D. W, Ow~.y ..d R. L Jut".. 377- 3!r1,
fI'OM'' ' ' M""..."AouIyW. ,dl"d by L A.II<"_12l ·244. N.w y",., Pknum. Wmi"""". I).C., Sm l,h"",;.. ,",,;,",;0., I't<... ~
". ~ _ r"t""" .~,c.IJ-I~,.-IJ.o.y... .../I... f -of II" <IV
00s00J. R. 1m. 11:'+";,.,, L..u _ AI" "'No.4~. BA~ 1.. , .... ,"-1 R........... j.c....,.J P. ~l Spo«l ~. Th< Rui< ofWuf.. ......... O'"Iopi ... ~,ofSum.
s..;" 6'1-1. O>fo,d, HoJ ..... Boob. Iti<n«hir-o .. c.u Granda.. Chih.olu. _ In c.u-.. .. c-jhn' c.........fF.
o..cndotfs.i .... /01. 19'r.. o..u.IopcaIlnoJinoiono ofWuf......... ""IW< hriod of ~~~,..w.t \:or0. c. n....-...! a.c. V-,...., I.\O_mc.lgovr.
.... '«'....... T.......- v.n.,. la T...MotIl-' Y,",,--' Ifpt.. .. IIKI'os. Th<u..-...,.of~~"-ia!ioa.
.d, .... by O. L.. MartUo ..... O. W. F.--.r<r.l4 1- l6S. """"",-, Go.dooo ond _ _
On<t!><1 •• K. 1999. A H<><O<!' of~ QO 'll'uf..... A.. ~. ~ A.
~" • 1''' 10H94_1JO'S.
H:.r. .f.. " I
"'""". 'A,
!.''"
".,.... S. 1m A Mod< of o-u...-. .o.p,.-• .., 0rpnII«I VIoIM<t-. la StaJ:,i>oor
.,...w...
P, •
GonIon ond fI<n<!..
.di.... \:orS. p. R.y<u on<I R. E. 0--. n---'s. Uos-
~ zoo.;.H.W"'-&f.o<.c..u.p.'itu"",Tn.. A&M ........ RI«. C, E. 1001. Wufott...! Mo.<;.. '" m. Sol, and GIl.o &>oJ..,. ofc....nl An..,.... In
Owm,. D. W, 198'1. The H'''''''1 of B;"',,~ Rc".«h in ,he S"",I-..m G.... ~ L-JK.,..... Cur St..Jin .. p,J,~ ":,+.. , td,,,d \:or G. f.. Ric<...! S. A.
Pl .. n" In F_ am, to ('~, A,./xJ.p<./ 0 - . ; - "',;,. S.",M~ Gmu 1..<81.,,,,. 289_ln. Sol, I..>h Of)" Uni...,.."y o( Utah r-.
,>1..,.,.
"H"d by J. L.. HoI;,,.n, R. L Brook., J. S. H ,y<. D. W. 0"''''1. R, L Jon, .. Rk •• G, IL. and S. 1.<111>"" (edi'on). 2001. v..J~ I..~: Cur S'''Ji'' .. f'rrl,h...4-
M, K. M.. w.u.o M. H, ~I.nh<",- IlJ-JJ6. OkI.hom. A«heoIop:.! s.,,'WJ' of .... 11 ;,1<...., S.I, IA< O'y' Un;.."i" ofUt.h Po=<.
U~I •."i,y of QI.loho"", ..... ,I-.. lou;,i .... 5ut, t)nl .. "ky. wlrll .... Arun ... A~
,h,oIop<.J Su<vcy, .....
lIJ"h ... W. A. I~SO. '/k A"IM";'V " Nrw "'* St.". H.t,rioon, NY, H,1bo! Hill
o,.,ky. I). W• ...J H. E. Btrr,......,. ~ Ettuoovop/>"' ..... A"~ I.Ok_ of Robb.}. IW/. V""""",...JGmd< ... E..dy lWy.la 7;-..IIUJTI-.- ~-' w+-
~in .... s.,., ...... "m
l/1oi.... s..m.. T_ _ ~31,4 I-'1l ..... AoJt.<dimtbjoO. LM.rt ....... D. W.F..,.... 111_144. ~.PA 'Gordo..
o....Iqo; O. W.a R..l.J>nq(edi ...... ~ 1':1')01. SbINJ a..Ioot.. ""G.uI/'£tw.' ~ ...:I""'..,'"
'I~. HNk/" -'~. \l'''''~ D.C, s..1m-w-I_ ....... I'oopn. M. 1"'- A Sur..".ofm. Enob.~J;,o-Inuah......, KiD ......... 1'1<....,.,...., c",..
~ 1000. Bi0fnPh7 in .... _ ~ TriI .... Storyol M<ioN U- ..... " - .... A>l' , ' v IO,4V- 4S9.
pi<>. SMorlj< A _ a n...-n"'f ~,......,./I'dnuy. ~-~ ~ I91'S. &id<..of'll'.n- inm. Na. f.ooN r.- Io.ooo-4..lOOB.C.1n Uiir.Jt.
0.""," D, 'II. lot. K. MMb, ..... M. H.Mmhrin. " " ......... SIo<Ir<.oIs.-p.. ....... C-.,.J~td;o,d \:or M. A. NmIohip. 0. Gt.<no....:I A. ~ Z9\I---
so........ C.... PlamLIn _ a....-,.c ..~", . "",,~o...-of"" :1014. Th< I ., Mouo....
s-.w." G,,~ rt.1"1. ,d,....
\:or J. L Hofnu,., It. I.. 1Iooob,}. S. Hay>. 0, W, Ow>- ~.A. I9*l PM •• •. p,,' " ;. M.iuoJM_ So""" _ AI-t"" A _
ky. R. L J>na. M. K. M...... ""' M. H. M>nht;n, III - Ill. 0I0:W>0<t». A",hc<>Iq;cal •• J~ Nnoo Yod,""..J.m .........
Soot..,. of,1-.. UnMr1<f)' ofOklohorn. and ,he Loooi,; .... s..... Uniftnj,}\ ..'m. .... ~ 19'91. ,.,.. ~ </rh..i,......., ~'" A1<~ ... M"",,, 1J.uU.
Arb" .. , A"~ s",-.,,~ /J",uJ. Orlondo, Acad=" 1'=0,
Pin .. " S. lOOl. '1h< &... S/.z", Th, Mod"" DmW '"11._. N".", N, ,, Y",,", Pen· Rotmtl,,, •. H. C. and f. R.. Turn.dJl. I9\lS, Th, E"".don of ,lie "",""'un r.r.. ..""'"
", In. CM,fOknt ... Vi.p.i>.. In Chi,P.,,,,.,,J CIMfi.i"'J .. liN A",",,~. , di«d by E. M.
['"ph,"" M. 19\1.. Th< CoII>p>< of ""S",n (;m li... _ .. ,lie End of ,lie l..>c, a"", .. Redmond. I'S-Z%. G..... ,.~ .. , Uno"";" p",_ of Florid..
...... In 1IJ< O>rfowllli""""", ~''? '"l:J.nf<,ediK<! br 8, Coni"". m - .\03.. _ 1lo<wJ.M. M .. M. L....... .uwI K. K~R (M'''''), 1987, c.....
."J _,e-.y j~ Ih<
)M, O>.{Otd lJniv<t1iry ........ " ... ;"'/IIWJ. C-~ . Combridp Univ<nity P", ...
I'wonkI. S. 1m. lh<o<""1 n Mili"""", Th< Sipiliann of,,,, eo- v.u.,. i. u... ~ ~l 1m•. _ s..v.:.p ill m. Kr ..... Hontinid Cou.,rioft. ,_""jofmwl
~ fMlySt- Fonn.tion. bo. 1IJ<~-J Do "'of"'~.t..s..!, .. of"""A",',
I 'V7hl'n-m
.,-
tdi..dbrj.lh... S.-.b. andT. -.li.15-»'N.w Yod, C. t . . . Un;";"
S,..kn, H. 1921. H.w, S1.J, • . Th< r"" s.." </I/it C4".i'l' ISS7. M. L<,,~ ,,..,,daror. ~ I~. v.rut"" I" s..,J......" dun.. ,he Lon!, ..... !'<,iod ofNorthem Chi.....
l<:>r>J<:,n, R_ .. ci3< ..... SO<l~ A>"~ Pm!"'';.... 31""_22!.
s...L D. [m. W"f.", ......t We.t<nt M ...."f.........., A c- s<uJy ofbpl>nWon in Aft· up ..... s., and P. F. ltN. 1919. 10;;''''''5,11< 5<".""", of.........,; w.rf.". In CJJ,~", I.
throrololy. {>/,"-fI<J <I~6S~·667. C+,. C• .-..~,J~tiwt,<dI'<dbyo.C. Th<zukand S.C VI> .....
a...;u- """
St. .. , G. 1\/9... E<onorny. !\i,..... ond ........ ift UbP.I M.oopot.o ..... In 19- 16. c.Js.or1' The U.;..n;'yofColpry A«~ """"iatiott.
~ $usn I. "" N_ f""" n,. O'r"~ DJa-kt-f~. <dictJ by G. Uty. W. 19';1\1. Wu"'S"/t...,, n.o!JOn-i., foi'" H..,,"
C.. W...... _J .. "" W.,{J.
51';ft.."J M. S. Il,.othm.n. 3S-oK M..Ji>on, WI, ............ y"'- New york, Viki ...
SYObodo. J., v. i.o«k. oN f.. Vl«k. 1m. H"""", - . . f.m.-J If"", no. P~ V....xc DrnMn. J.M.(;. I99'S- 1M Orip_ <I IV", (1 .........j. C""'"",'" "'" Nedwr·
<I~. N<w YorI!, PIcnoom,..... t...do, Otlpt ,.....
s...t.od..J.,.."J E. V ...... [\/91. lA _ I I . Sqoo.lnoo< do o..tn. V - i « (DV XVI ~ v...cL.s. 191... W.. ...J " 'uf...... Al<"-"opJ--/-fA.J1ro I ',d ~
Td_. I, .... It.lJI>. ... I '>:r.,"9StJUo-3U.
s....I. .... M. 1941. ~toa._iot~
~ ,1l.-'JJ,.
w..ru.... "-... ......
~ ,;-.,J<lh! i 'I!:J
j,L16-0.!.
~ tm_""' .. uf..... In_Wml-,~/"".,_<d;,<dby
s-- hIo(;,hl.t; L..J.
J. c.r ..... and .... "'..... ~1_72. "'-iI Mil. UK,
T..... p_ ...d C Oippio><W<. 19M. A......i... ~ W......, a....p., o.pitlioo .. vL.p. lm"<!Woori<~""In£ou"p<.~hIj i ''I!:/ I '''l-IM.
ofF""<iA5 in .... fW<k A" 01 ,o\mIi.uo t - l N.T . C-"+,lr,L ':V,;-.,J YL. ~_ C. IIooniII<. J. c-tin. 0. HocIm.., Eo l>Ioh.... r. ~ G. BdIuomim. ...d
4(2.,111-14 M. lInn<o. 19I6. c-.ibol ...... doc NcGIid..c. s.w-llH.II-4l7. " ...
W.Ji.<f. P. L 1001 • . A 8"",,~ l'<top<C'''' on .... Ita-, o/"Vl.oI.ncc . .An."",
Rmnrl{. ~tbt.fJ." JO,S73-S96.
.• ,~, r-..!