k2s208 As Oxdidizing Agent PDF

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

Environ. Sci. Technol.

1999, 33, 2095-2099

Potassium Persulfate as Oxidant in like a dense gas and behaves like a fluid. Its density and
viscosity are reduced, and the Brownian diffusion is increased
Pressurized Hot Water (2, 3). The dielectric constant and extent of hydrogen bonding
are also reduced (4-7), resulting in increased solubility of
organic compounds and gases and decreased solubility of
JUHANI KRONHOLM* AND electrolytes (8). As the temperature in the subcritical region
MARJA-LIISA RIEKKOLA is raised, the properties of the water approach those in the
Laboratory of Analytical Chemistry, Department of Chemistry, supercritical region.
P.O. Box 55, University of Helsinki, For treatment purposes, it is not necessary to raise the
FIN-00014 Helsinki, Finland temperature up to 374 °C or further if complete destruction
of the organic compounds can be achieved at temperatures
below 374 °C. The main incentive for working below the
critical temperature is to save energy. With large-scale systems
Sub- and supercritical water oxidation are quite new consuming large amounts of energy, energy costs become
techniques for wastewater treatment. Temperatures must of critical importance. In addition, inorganic compounds
Downloaded by INDIAN INST OF TECHNOLOGY GUWAHATI on September 5, 2015 | http://pubs.acs.org

be high enough and reaction times long enough that are precipitated at temperatures higher than the critical
the organic compounds are completely oxidized into carbon temperature of water, so that working below this temperature
dioxide and water. The critical temperature and pressure may prevent the formation of insoluble matter and blockage
of water are 374 °C and 22.1 MPa. The primary aim of of the capillaries of the equipment.
the study was to determine whether potassium persulfate To ensure the effective oxidation of organic pollutants
is a feasible choice for oxidant in work clearly below into water and carbon dioxide, it is usual to add an oxidant
to the reaction chamber. Oxygen and hydrogen peroxide have
the critical temperature of water. Because potassium
Publication Date (Web): May 13, 1999 | doi: 10.1021/es9805977

been widely used with excellent results. For example, pulp


persulfate is water soluble, it can be added directly to water and paper mill sludges have been successfully purified (9,
containing organic compounds. Simple equipment was 10), and wastewaters containing phenol have been effectively
constructed for oxidation in high-temperature pressurized treated under supercritical conditions (11-13). Potassium
water, and oxidation of phenol, 2,3-dichlorophenol, and persulfate, which was the oxidant used in this study, is not
1-naphthol was carried out in aqueous environment at 75- a common choice but was of interest to us as an effective
340 °C with potassium persulfate used as oxidant. The and exothermic reactant. Besides oxidants, catalysts (for
pressure was adjusted to 25-45 MPa. The concentration example, transition metal salts such as CuO, ZnO, MnO2,
of the organic compounds was 1.0 mM, and that of the and V2O5) have been used under supercritical conditions to
oxidant was 1.0-10.0 mM. Study was made of the effects lower the activation energy of the reaction and thus enhance
the destruction rate (14-16). Catalysts have also been used
of concentration, temperature, and reaction time on
at temperatures clearly below the supercritical temperature
oxidation efficiency. The removal percentages of phenol to destroy phenolic compounds (17-20).
were good even at 115 °C. Concentration of the oxidant The primary aim of our study was to evaluate the feasibility
turned out to be a very important parameter. Also of using potassium persulfate as oxidant at temperatures
temperature and reaction time had an effect on the clearly below the critical temperature of water. Inorganic
results. There were some problems arising from the compounds are a problem in work in supercritical conditions,
formation of rust and from blockage of the capillaries of and at temperatures clearly below the critical temperature
the equipment. However, the blockage could be prevented of water, it may be possible to prevent the precipitation of
with use of a precipitant collector. inorganic compounds and the blockage of capillaries. A
second aim of the study was to construct simple laboratory
equipment allowing the destruction of organic compounds
Introduction reliably and safely at high temperatures and under high
pressures. Phenol, 2,3-dichlorophenol, and 1-naphthol were
The theoretical possibilities of hot and pressurized water for
chosen as the organic contaminants because all are common
oxidation reactions have been known for more than a century,
aromatic pollutants and information is available on the
but experimental and practical experiences were not widely
destruction efficiencies of closely related compounds in
reported until the 1960s. The research on sub- and super-
pressurized hot water.
critical water oxidation was first focused on temperatures
below the critical temperature and only later on the super-
critical state.
Experimental Section
Today, wastewater treatment techniques exploiting the Materials. Phenol (E. Merck, Darmstadt), 2,3-dichlorophenol
oxidation power of hot pressurized water offer a promising (Fluka AG, Buchs SG), and 1-naphthol (E. Merck, Darmstadt)
approach for converting organic substances into harmless were chosen as the model contaminants. Concentration of
compounds such as water and carbon dioxide (1). The critical each compound in water (distilled and deionized) was 1.0
temperature of water is 374.2 °C, and the critical pressure mM. The water containing the contaminants is afterward
22.1 MPa. If both or either of these values are smaller, water simply referred to as the wastewater. Potassium persulfate
is in the subcritical state. In the present work, where the (E. Merck, Darmstad) was added to the wastewater as an
temperature range investigated was wide (75-340 °C), the oxidant (c ) 1.0-10.0 mM). Two internal standards were
water is simply said to be pressurized and hot. used in sample analysis: m-cresol (Fluka AG, Buchs SG) and
The physicochemical properties of water change in the hexachlorobenzene (Sigma-Aldrich). Dichloromethane (Lab-
supercritical region. Above its critical temperature, water is Scan, Analytical Sciences, HPLC grade) was used as the
solvent in extraction.
* Corresponding author phone: +358-9-191 40267; fax: +358- Instrumentation. Figure 1 shows a simplified view of the
9-191 40253; e-mail: juhani.kronholm@helsinki.fi. subcritical water oxidation equipment. All the capillaries (1/
10.1021/es9805977 CCC: $18.00  1999 American Chemical Society VOL. 33, NO. 12, 1999 / ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY 9 2095
Published on Web 05/13/1999
FIGURE 1. Equipment constructed for oxidation in pressurized hot
water. The precipitant collector is described in detail in the area
bounded with a dashed line.

16 in. o.d.), the reaction chamber (Keystone Scientific


extraction chamber, V ) 5.0 mL), and the precipitant collector
(V ) 2.0 mL) were made of stainless steel. One high-pressure FIGURE 2. Removal percentages of phenol (c ) 1.0 mM) at four
pump (Perkin-Elmer Series 1) and a heating oven (Carlo Erba temperatures (115, 195, 275, and 340 °C) and three concentrations
Fractovap model G1) were used in this study, an ice-bath of potassium persulfate. Average reaction times were 1.4-2.5 min,
Downloaded by INDIAN INST OF TECHNOLOGY GUWAHATI on September 5, 2015 | http://pubs.acs.org

was added to cool the hot effluent, and a pressure regulator and the average pressure was 33-38 MPa (exact values in Table
(needle valve) was installed to adjust the pressure. 1).
A Hewlett-Packard model 5890 gas chromatograph and
a model 5989A mass spectrometer (EI, 70 eV) were employed
to analyze the compounds left in the effluent. The analytical
column of the gas chromatograph was a polar Nordion NB
351 (20.0 m, 0.2 mm i.d., 0.2 µm). The precolumn (2.5 m, 0.53
Publication Date (Web): May 13, 1999 | doi: 10.1021/es9805977

mm i.d.) attached in front of the analytical column was


deactivated with DPTMDS (1,3-diphenyl-1,1,3,3-trimethyl-
silazane). The injection mode was on-column.
Procedure. Most of the experiments were carried out with
phenol as the organic pollutant, and a few additional
experiments were carried out with 2,3-dichlorophenol and
1-naphthol. The wastewater, containing the added oxidant,
was pumped into the heated reaction chamber by means of
a high-pressure pump. In some arrangements, a precipitant
collector was installed before the reaction chamber to prevent
blockage of the capillaries. The flow rates of the wastewater
feed were adjusted to 1.9-5.4 mL/min. In this text, we prefer
the expression reaction time to flow rate because flow rate FIGURE 3. Removal percentages of phenol (c ) 1.0 mM) at four
is strictly related to the high-pressure pump, whereas the temperatures (75, 115, 250, and 340 °C) and three concentrations of
reaction time expresses the time the aqueous waste is potassium persulfate. Average reaction times were 1.2-1.5 min,
subjected to certain reaction conditions. Pressure and flow and the average pressure was 32-43 MPa (exact values in Table
rates fluctuated a little during sample collection (by about 1).
5 MPa on average), and the values given are averages of the
minimum and maximum values. However, pressure was kept
high enough to maintain water in liquid state.
Three effluent samples were collected under each set of
conditions (experiments with phenol). Each point in the
graphical presentations (Figures 2-4) represents an average
removal percentage of phenol. The relative standard devia-
tions of the replicates are noted in Table 1. After the samples
were collected at the outlet of the capillary, they were
extracted with dichloromethane (4 × 2.0 mL) and finally
concentrated to 2.0 mL by gentle nitrogen evaporation. Two
internal standards were used: one (m-cresol, added before
the extraction) to calculate the removal percentages of the
organic pollutants and the other (hexachlorobenzene, added
after the extraction) to calculate the extraction efficiencies.
The removal percentage entered in the tables is the amount
of compound that was destroyed under the conditions in
question. FIGURE 4. Removal percentages of phenol (c ) 1.0 mM) as a function
This was calculated as follows: of potassium persulfate concentration (1.0, 2.0, 5.0, and 10.0 mM)

[ ]
at four temperatures. Average reaction times were 1.2-1.5 min,
std1a and the pressure was 32-43 MPa (exact values in Table 1).
X1a
removal percentage ) 100 × 1 -
std1b is the peak area of the internal standard (m-cresol) added to
X1b the collected sample before extraction, X1a is the peak area
of the analyte in the reference sample, and X1b is the peak
where std1a is the peak area of the internal standard (m- area of the analyte in the collected sample. The reference
cresol) added to the reference sample before extraction, std1b sample was a sample treated at room temperature.

2096 9 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY / VOL. 33, NO. 12, 1999
TABLE 1. Oxidation Efficiencies for Phenol (c ) 1.0 mM) at Various Temperatures and Oxidant (Potassium Persulfate)
Concentrationsa
temp oxidant concn reaction time pressure removal RSD precipitant collector
exp (°C) (mM) (min) (MPa) (%) (%) in use
1 75 1.0 1.4 35 0 X yes
2 75 2.0 1.3 32 10.4 141.4 yes
3 75 5.0 1.4 37 3.3 173.2 yes
4 75 10.0 1.5 43 29.1 83.6 yes
5 115 no oxidant 1.4 33 12.5 86.9 no
6 115 1.0 2.3 35 23.9 89.7 no
7 115 1.0 1.4 37 7.3 105.9 yes
8 115 2.0 1.2 35 7.4 87.2 yes
9 115 5.0 1.4 40 99.6 0.1 yes
10 115 10.0 2.3 37 99.7 0.1 no
11 115 10.0 1.5 40 99.8 0.2 yes
12 195 no oxidant 2.4 34 8.1 125.9 no
13 195 1.0 2.3 38 59.6 22.0 no
14 195 10.0 2.3 35 99.9 0.0 no
Downloaded by INDIAN INST OF TECHNOLOGY GUWAHATI on September 5, 2015 | http://pubs.acs.org

15 250 1.0 1.5 40 41.2 6.6 yes


16 250 2.0 1.3 40 95.5 0.2 yes
17 250 5.0 1.5 38 98.9 0.1 yes
18 250 10.0 1.4 40 99.5 0.1 yes
19 275 no oxidant 2.4 35 0 X no
20 275 1.0 2.4 33 62.9 10.1 no
21 275 10.0 2.4 37 99.3 0.1 no
22 340 no oxidant 2.3 37 0 X no
Publication Date (Web): May 13, 1999 | doi: 10.1021/es9805977

23 340 1.0 2.2 33 65.4 2.8 no


24 340 1.0 1.5 35 40.9 9.7 yes
25 340 2.0 1.2 40 88.7 3.4 yes
26 340 5.0 1.5 38 97.0 0.3 yes
27 340 10.0 2.5 37 99.3 0.0 no
28 340 10.0 1.5 42 97.4 0.3 yes
a Reaction times, pressures, and removal percentages are averages (n ) 3). The reaction volume was 7.0 mL when the precipatant collector

was in use and 5.0 mL when it was not. An X means that only two replicates were performed under each set of conditions and that no RSD is
included.

concentration of the oxidant to obtain good results (see


Figures 2-4). It was evident that by increasing the concen-
tration of potassium persulfate from 2.0 to 5.0 mM and further
up to 10.0 mM the oxidation efficiency was improved.
Potassium persulfate is an inorganic salt, soluble in water
(5.3 g/100 mL, 20 °C) (21) that begins to react strongly and
release oxygen when the temperature is raised to 100 °C. The
FIGURE 5. Some oxidation reactions of phenol, 2,3-dichlorophenol, reaction is strongly exothermic.
and 1-naphthol. In practice, inorganic compounds are present as Possibly not all the oxidant present is available for
salts or ions in aqueous environment. The reactions in the figure oxidizing phenol since there will always be small amounts
are highly simplified, and no intermediate reaction products are of impurities in the water even though the water is distilled
presented. and deionized and all the reagents are of high purity. There
may also be a number of side reactions occurring simulta-
neously before the final products appear, and this could lead
Results and Discussion to increased oxidant consumption. When the concentration
Figures 2-4 present the oxidation efficiencies for phenol at of potassium persulfate was below the stoichiometric re-
different temperatures and different concentrations of quirement (0-1.0 mM), the results were poor even when the
oxidant. Table 1 gives the numerical and exact information temperature was raised to 340 °C. The results demonstrate
on which the figures are based. The theoretical ratio of oxidant the importance of the stoichiometric requirement of the
to phenol needed to convert all the phenol into carbon dioxide oxidant.
and water is 7/4 (see Figure 5). Note: The reactions presented The temperature, reaction time, and pressure employed
in Figure 5 are theoretical because no intermediate products are of great importance. The temperature must be high
are included, and only the initial and final products are shown; enough to increase the exothermic energy to values able to
the main reason for presenting the figure is to indicate the break down the chemical bonds and to produce activation
stoichiometry of the reactions and thus the equivalent energies high enough for the desired reactions. In some cases,
amounts of oxidant needed for the oxidation process. The the removal percentages of phenol were a little lower when
ratio 7/4 means that a potassium persulfate concentration the temperature was raised. The real reason for this is unclear,
of 2.0 mM should be stoichiometrically high enough to oxidize but these observations are statistically nonsignificant. Water
all the phenol (c ) 1.0 mM). has itself some ability to work as an oxidant (22), but it is not
A good removal percentage was obtained when the clear why the oxidation efficiency decreased with increasing
concentration of potassium persulfate was 2.0 mM and the temperature when no oxidant was used (Figure 2). In theory,
temperature at least 250 °C (see Figures 3 and 4). When the pressure may influence the results through altering the
oxidant concentration was increased to 5.0 mM, results were density of water, so that an increase in pressure (at constant
excellent even at temperatures as low as 115 °C. A temperature temperature) increases the density and the number of
of 75 °C was clearly too low, and 1.0 mM was too low a molecules colliding. It has been observed in another study

VOL. 33, NO. 12, 1999 / ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY 9 2097
potassium persulfate is reduced in the oxidation process,
TABLE 2. Removal Percentages of Phenol, 2,3-Dichlorophenol, and some potassium and sulfur compounds are released.
and 1-Naphthola The color was strongest at temperatures of 195-275 °C and
temp reaction time removal got lighter again at 340 °C. Investigations by others suggest
exp compound (°C) (min) % that corrosion in oxidation processes in water at high
temperatures may be strongest below the critical temperature
29 phenol 250 3.3 99.5
(26, 27). In addition to this, we observed that the reddish
30 phenol 340 5.0 97.6
31 2,3-dichlorophenol 250 5.0 98.4 brown color intensified when the concentration of the oxidant
32 2,3-dichlorophenol 340 5.0 99.6 was increased. Corrosion and color formation may be heavily
33 1-naphthol 250 5.0 94.4 dependent on the oxidant, and our observations do not apply
34 1-naphthol 340 5.0 96.3 beyond systems in which potassium persulfate is the oxidant.
a Concentration of each compound was 1.0 mM, and concentration Several investigations have shown that ordinary stainless steel
of the oxidant (potassium persulfate) was 10.0 mM. The pressure was is not the best choice for work with water at high temper-
≈45 MPa. Relative standard deviations are not included because only atures. Better choices may be Inconel 600, Inconel 625, and
one effluent sample was collected under each set of conditions. Hastelloy C-276 (28, 29). In preliminary investigations that
we carried out with Inconel 600, rust formation was clearly
(23), where results under pressures of 188 and 278 atm were less, and the samples were cleaner.
compared, that pressure influences the destruction efficien- Rust formation and the precipitation of inorganic com-
cies of phenol clearly at 360-440 °C, but the influence was pounds caused some problems when the precipitant collector
Downloaded by INDIAN INST OF TECHNOLOGY GUWAHATI on September 5, 2015 | http://pubs.acs.org

almost negligible at the temperatures used in our study (at was not connected. To avoid blockage of the capillaries, we
temperatures below 340 °C and where water was still in liquid occasionally adjusted the pressure regulator so that the flow
state). This is why we believe that the differences in pressure rate was momentarily increased and the pressure decreased.
in our study do not have a remarkable effect on destruction After this, the pressure regulator was readjusted to return to
efficiencies. The pressure effects on rate for elementary the original pressure. In some of the experiments the
reaction steps are pressure dependent according to transition precipitant collector was installed in front of the reaction
chamber (see Table 1) allowing the inorganic matter to be
Publication Date (Web): May 13, 1999 | doi: 10.1021/es9805977

state theory. The pressure effects on rate constant are


governed by the relationship collected at the bottom of the collector. This arrangement
prevented the capillaries from getting blocked, and there

[ ∂P ]
∂ ln kx
T
)
-∆V+
RT
was no need for pressure adjustments. We would conclude
that, even when the reaction temperature is clearly below
the critical temperature of water, a precipitant collector needs
where ∆V+ is the activation volume and kx is the rate constant. to be used to ensure constant flow. The diameter of our
Some additional studies were carried out with 2,3-dichloro- capillaries was small (1/16 in. o.d.) and use of capillaries of
phenol and 1-naphthol (see Table 2) to determine whether larger diameter, 1/8 in. o.d., for example, might have reduced
these compounds could be removed as effectively as phenol. the problems with inorganic compounds.
Only one effluent sample was collected under each set of Outside of the problems noted, the organic pollutants
conditions, so relative standard deviations are not included were effectively destroyed and no hazards arose. Despite
in the table. Concentrations of these compounds were 1.0 rapid drops in pressure, there were no leaks in the joints of
mM, while the concentration of potassium persulfate was the capillaries. Further investigations will be made with
kept constant at 10.0 mM. The removal percentages of these materials more resistant to corrosion than stainless steel and
compounds were good too, although the reaction time was with a two- or three-pump system delivering the organic
relatively long (3.3-5.0 min) because the precipitant collector matter and oxidant to the reaction chamber separately. Also,
was not used and there were problems in increasing the flow capillaries with larger diameters will be used to prevent
rate due to blockage of the capillaries. blockage. Further investigations with potassium persulfate
Phenol, 2,3-dichlorophenol, and naphthol were collected as oxidant should be made to determine the effects of
quantitatively; in other words, no compounds were found in temperatures between 340 and 400 °C, an increase in the
the capillaries or in the reaction chamber when they were potassium persulfate concentration beyond 10.0 mM, and
eluted with dichloromethane after the oxidation process. It the use of a wider range of reaction times. It would also be
can be concluded that the oxidation process and not the loss worth trying to improve the oxidation efficiency by adding
of these compounds was responsible for the high removal potassium persulfate in hydrogen peroxide.
percentages. We conclude that the removal percentages of
phenol, 2,3-dichlorophenol, and 1-naphthol are very good Acknowledgments
when the parameters (oxidant concentration, temperature, Financial support for this study was provided by the Maj &
and reaction time) are correctly adjusted. Raising the Tor Nessling Foundation and the Jenny & Antti Wihuri
temperature up to 340 °C is not necessary to achieve good Foundation.
results if the concentration of oxidant is 5.0 mM or higher
and the reaction time at least 1.5 min. Literature Cited
Catalytic oxidation of phenol has been studied on many (1) Li, L.; Egiebor, N. O. Energy Fuels 1994, 8, 1126.
occasions. Temperatures between 100 and 200 °C have been (2) Franck, E. U Pure Appl. Chem. 1970, 24, 13.
widely used, and the reaction times required to oxidize phenol (3) Dudziak, K. H.; Franck, E. U. Ber. Bunsen-Ges. Phys. Chem. 1966,
effectively have usually ranged between 5 min and 1 h (17, 70, 1120.
(4) Quist, A. S.; Marshall, W. L. J. Phys. Chem. 1965, 69, 3165.
18, 20, 24). Faster reaction times have been achieved at (5) Kalinichev, A. G.; Bass, J. D. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1994, 231, 301.
temperatures lower than 100 °C, but the catalysts were (6) Mizan, T. I.; Savage, P. E.; Ziff, R. M. J. Phys. Chem. 1996, 100,
heterogeneous (19). We found no need to employ a separate 403.
catalyst because potassium persulfate worked effectively as (7) Gorbaty, Y. E.; Kalinichev A. G. J. Phys. Chem. 1995, 9, 5336.
oxidant. (8) Connolly, J. F., J. Chem. Eng. Data 1966, 11, 13.
(9) Modell, M.; Larson, J.; Sobczynski, S. F. Tappi J. 1992, June, 195.
Water is highly corrosive at high temperatures (25), and
(10) Blaney, C. A.; Li, L.; Gloyna, E. F.; Hossain, S. U. Innovations in
at 115-340 °C, the samples collected at the outlet of the Supercritical Fluids: Science and Technology; ACS Symposium
equipment were dirty (the effluent was reddish brown). Series 608; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 1995;
Another source of color and also of inorganic matter is that p 444.

2098 9 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY / VOL. 33, NO. 12, 1999
(11) Gopalan, S.; Savage. P. E. Innovations in Supercritical Fluids: (23) Thornton, T. D.; Savage, P. E. AIChE 1992, 38, 321.
Science and Technology; ACS Symposium Series 608; American (24) Lin, S. H.; Wu, Y. F., Environ. Technol. 1996, 17, 175.
Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 1995; p 338. (25) Mitton, D. B.; Orzalli, J. C.; Latanision, R. M. Innovations in
(12) Shanableh, A.; Gloyna, E. F. Water Sci. Technol. 1991, 23, 389. Supercritical Fluids: Science and Technology; ACS Symposium
(13) Koo, M.; Lee, W. K.; Lee, C. H. Chem. Eng. Sci. 1997, 52, 1201. Series 608; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 1995;
(14) Ding, Z. Y.; Aki, S. N. V. K.; Abraham, M. A. Environ. Sci. Technol. p 328.
1995, 29, 2748. (26) Takahashi, Y.; Wydeven, T.; Koo, C. Adv. Space Res. 1989, 9 (8),
(15) Krajnc, M.; Levec, J. Appl. Catal. B: Environ. 1994, 3, L101. 99.
(16) Ding, Z. Y.; Aki, S. N. V. K. L.; Abraham, M. A. Innovations in (27) Gloyna, E. F.; Li, L. Waste Manage. 1993, 13, 379.
Supercritical Fluids: Science and Technology; ACS Symposium
(28) Downey. K. W.; Snow, R. H.; Hazlebeck, D. A.; Roberts, A. J.
Series 608; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 1995;
Innovations in Supercritical Fluids: Science and Technology;
p 232.
ACS Symposium Series 608; American Chemical Society: Wash-
(17) Pintar, A.; Levec, J. J. Catal. 1992, 135, 345.
ington, DC, 1995; p 313.
(18) Fortuny, A.; Ferrer, C.; Bengoa, C.; Font, J.; Fabregat, A. Catal.
Today 1995, 24, 79. (29) Alekseev, A. B.; Averin, S. A.; Geferova, M. N.; Kondrat’ev, V. P.;
(19) Atwater, J. E.; Akse, J. R.; McKinnis, J. A.; Thompson, J. O. Shikhalev, V. S. J. Nuclear Mater. 1996, 233, 1367.
Chemosphere 1997, 34, 203.
(20) Maugans, C. B.; Akgerman, A. Water Res. 1997, 31, 3116. Received for review June 12, 1998. Revised manuscript re-
(21) Karamäki, E. M. Epäorgaaniset kemikaalit; K. J. Gummerus Oy: ceived January 22, 1999. Accepted March 26, 1999.
Jyväskylä, 1983; p 320.
(22) Yang, H. H.; Eckert, C. A. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1988, 27, 2009. ES9805977
Downloaded by INDIAN INST OF TECHNOLOGY GUWAHATI on September 5, 2015 | http://pubs.acs.org
Publication Date (Web): May 13, 1999 | doi: 10.1021/es9805977

VOL. 33, NO. 12, 1999 / ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY 9 2099

You might also like