Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Elitists
The Elitists
Politics must be understood in a more realistic on economics and management at the University
fashion of Florence.
Study of power and elitists groups who
1889- after the death of his parents, Pareto
controlled the decision-making process in the
changed his lifestyle, quitting his job and
society
marrying a Russian, Alessandrina Bakunina.
Manner in which power is obtained and
maintained 1893- he succeeded Léon Walras to the chair of
Interaction between the ruling group and the Political Economy at the University of
masses Lausanne in Switzerland where he remained for
Elitism the rest of his life.
belief that individuals who form an elite (a select 1906- he made the famous observation that
group of people with an intrinsic quality, twenty percent of the population owned eighty
high intellect, wealth, special skills, or percent of the property in Italy, later generalised
experience) are more likely to be constructive to by Joseph M. Juran into the Pareto principle (also
society as a whole, and therefore deserve termed the 80–20 rule).
influence or authority greater than that of
1916- Believing that there were problems that
others.
economics could not solve, Trattato di sociologia
describe a situation in which power is
generale (Mind and Society),
concentrated in the hands of a limited number of
Died: August 19, 1923, Céligny, Switzerland
people
sociological or political science analysis of elite
WORK: The Mind and Society
influence in society.
Presents the first sociological cycle theory,
centered on the concept of an elite social class
VILFREDO PARETO
Wilfried Fritz Pareto
Sections na ng “The Mind and Society” na
Born: 15 July 1848, Paris, France
binigyang focus sa book
Italian engineer, sociologist, economist, political
o 2027-every branch of human activity
scientist, and philosopher
each individual is given an index which
His father, Raffaele Pareto (1812–1882), was an stands as a sign of his capacity
Italian civil engineer and Ligurian marquis who o 2028- In the index of thieves if one says
had left Italy much like Giuseppe Mazzini and "So-and-so does not steal, not because
other Italian nationalists. he couldn't, but because he is a
His mother, Marie Metenier, was a French gentleman," we reply: "Very well, we
woman. Enthusiastic about the 1848 German admire him for his self-control, but his
revolution, his parents named him Fritz Wilfried, grade as a thief is zero."
which became Vilfredo Federico upon his family's o 2031-make a class of the people highest
move back to Italy in 1858. in their branch of activity and call them
Childhood- Pareto lived in a middle-class “elites”
environment, receiving a high standard of o 2031-divide it into two: Governing Elite
education, attending the newly created Istituto (w/ considerable part in the government)
Tecnico Leardi. and non-governing elite
1869- earned a doctor's degree in engineering o 2033- class champions: ex. Chess player
from what is now the Polytechnic University of do not open political influence for him
Turin (then the Technical School for Engineers). o 2034- Set two strata for the
Years after graduation- he worked as a civil population:non-elite and elite(governing
engineer and not)
o 2035- labels: ministers,lawyer, senators
deputies etc.
o 2041- intermix of population happen. o "residues"
o 2043- pay attention on: 1.) proportions - they are basic human motives
between total no. of group to members -the two main residues are: the
who do not possess the qualities instinct of combinations
requisite; 2.) velocity of circulation (creativity/inventiveness) and
o 2044- demand and supply for social group persistence
elements (conservative/security needs)
o 2053- Aristocracies do not last- History is o "derivatives"
a graveyard of aristocracies.
o 2054-Decay not in numbers only but in ideologies such as Christianity,
quality. democracy, and socialism
o 2055- governing class crashes to ruin and changing elements in human
often sweeps the whole nation. beliefs
o 2056- governing elite is always in slow Following the Machiavellian formula, Pareto
and continuous transformation states that the elites are able to manipulate and
o 2057- Revolutions came through control the masses by resorting to two methods:
accumulations: higher strata- no longer which corresponds to Machiavelli’s famous anti-
possessed residues; lower strata- thesis between the ‘Lions” and the “Foxes”.
possessed residues suitable o “Foxes”
The concept of ‘Circulation of elite’ can be elites abundantly endowed with
explained in at least two ways residues of the first class
o the process in which one elite replaces (Residues of combinations)
the other which includes the propensities
o the movement of people from non-elite in social groups to adopt flexibly
groups to elite groups and vice-versa. to environmental or situational
SOCIETY IS HETEROGENOUS- Pareto believed exigencies.
that individuals are born with different abilities capable of innovation and
and acquire different skills and aptitudes. experiment, prefer materialistic
In every society there are classes, therefore each to idealistic goals, but lack
society is heterogeneous. Such a heterogeneity fidelity to principles and use
takes place on account of mental, moral, physical strategies that vary from
and cultural reasons but helps in maintaining emotional appeal to
social balance and organization. unadulterated fraud.
The most capable in any grouping are the elite. o “Lions”
The term elite denote simply, “a class of the conservative elites in whom the
people who have the highest indices in their second class of residues
branch of activity.” Examples are the successful (Persistence of aggregates)
businessmen, artists, successful writers, predominates. They have faith
professors etc. and ideology; they display group
Pareto further divided the elite class into two loyalty and class solidarity; they
categories: gain and retain power by the use
o A governing elite- with considerable part of force.
in gov.
o A non-governing elite-rest of individuals According to him, every society has elite groups
According to Pareto the work and the role of the of different kinds. These elites, being the best or
elites are influenced by two types of factors excellent members of their classes are always in
which are always operative in every society. One a minority. But they are vital because it is they
type which is constant is called residues, the who determine the development or progress of
other type is derivations. every society.
According to Pareto, there can be also a Deputies of Italy. Taught occasionally
circulation of elites in the sense of being a at Palermo and Rome
process by which individuals circulate between
1896- Published: The Ruling class and became
the elite and the non-elite. This process of
chair of constitutional law at the University of
replacement takes place in two ways
Turin. He hold this position until 1924, when he
o gradual process of infiltration
settled permanently in Rome to occupy the chair
o violent revolution.
of public law at the University of Rome.
Pareto explains all this in terms of changes in the
psychological characteristics of the members of 1909- elected to the Chamber of Deputies of
the elite on the one hand, and those of the lower Italy, in which he served until 1919.
strata, on the other. Thus when the elite no 1919-Mosca was nominated life senator of
longer possesses the residues necessary for the Kingdom of Italy. He served actively in this
keeping it in power and at the same time at the capacity until 1926.
lower strata of society, the necessary residues
Died: 8 November 1941 (aged 83)
are sufficiently manifest then the declining elite
Rome, Italy
recruits new elements from the lower strata of
society and thereby restores its vitality. Or it may
WORK: The Ruling Class
so happen that an elite decaying in the necessary
residues is violently overthrown by the lower Asserted that contrary to theories of majority
classes strong in the requisite residues necessary rules: societies are necessarily governed by
for keeping them in power. minorities: by military, priestly, or hereditary
oligarchies or by aristocracies of wealth or of
Pareto: History is the graveyard of Aristocracy merit.
Mosca says that in any type of society at any
o history is accentuated with the elite class point of history, there are two class of people
since generation, who emerge, o a class that rule
dominate, fall into decadency and is o a class that is ruled.
replaced by non-decadent elites in Class that rule, contains a few number of people
society. Pareto has given a number of and possess all political power and privileges
reasons for mortality of aristocracy whereas the latter consist of large number of
which are un-graved in history for people and is subjected to rule of former and
generation and generation. provides essential instrumental for political
organization (Mosca 1939, p.50).
1. Aristocrats (mainly King and Emperor) were For Mosca, two political facts must be considered
engaged in historical wars which lead to in order to analyze the relationship between
degeneration of aristocracy. ruling class and ruled class.
o That there is always one person who is
2. The inheritors of aristocracy are not the leader of political organization
necessarily possessed with some inherent traits among the ruling class. This individual is
of that of their forefathers. They fall into not necessarily the person who holds the
decadence after few hours of glory. highest political position according to
law. Even he is not necessarily known by
GAETANO MOSCA everyone. This person, for example can
Born: 1 April 1858, Palermo, Italy be prime minister of king or president or
Italian jurist and political theorist the person makes the president to be
elected. Under certain conditions, this
1881- Mosca earned a degree in law from
supreme power can be in hand of more
the University of Palermo.
than one person.
1887- he moved to Rome and took a position as o That regardless of the type of the
editor of proceedings of the Chamber of political organization, pressures of
masses to ruling class and its policies. or at least upon the beliefs and sentiments of the
Therefore, ruling class, or the head of the particular portion of that group which hold
state, must be sensitive about thought political preeminence "(Mosca 1939, p.71,72).
and feelings of the masses to get their In fact ruling class like Pareto's elite strata consist
support, otherwise he cannot rule. For of two strata: (a) the highest stratum; and (b)
this reason, at least a large group from second stratum. The HIGHEST STRATUM IS THE
the masses is created to support the CORE OF THE RULING CLASS BUT IT COULD NOT
ruling class and the system (Mosca 1939, SUFFICIENTLY LEAD AND DIRECT THE SOCIETY
pp.50-53). UNLESS THE SECOND STRATUM HELPS. Second
LOGIC OF RULING CLASS: the ability to be stratum is the larger than the higher stratum in
organized easily and effectively. Minority is number and has all the capacities of leadership in
always organized; therefore, it has ability to the country. Even autocratic systems do have it.
overcome the majority. Not only political but also any type of social
organization needs the second stratum in order
FORMATION OF THE RULING CLASSES HAS A to be possible (Mosca 1939, p.404,430).
CLOSE RELATION WITH THE LEVEL OF The MEMBERS OF THE RULING CLASS SHOULD BE
CIVILIZATION AND THE TYPE OF SOCIETY. Ruling RECRUITED ALMOST ENTIRELY FROM THE
class under every condition try to DOMINANT, MAJORITY GROUP IN THE SOCIETY.
reproduce itself particularly by domination on If the society has a number of minorities and if
political forces like power, wealth and the ruling this rule is not followed due to weaknesses of
class tends to be come hereditary. In fact, dominant group,
descents of ruling class members have a high life political system can meet serious political crisis.
chances to have the traits necessary to be a The same thing occurs when there are
ruling class member (Mosca 1939, pp. 60-61). In considerable differences between in the culture,
general, prior to democracy, membership of and in customs of the ruling class and subject
ruling class was not only de facto but also de classes (Mosca 1939, p.105,106-7).
jure. In democracy, de jure transfer of political WEAKNESSES OF DOMINANT GROUP IN SOCIETY
possession to descendants of ruling class AND ISOLATION OF LOWER CLASSES FROM THE
members impossible and not legitimized but it is RULING CLASSES CAN LEAD TO POLITICAL
now de facto. UPHEAVAL IN THE COUNTRY and as a result of
Historically, RULING CLASS TRY TO JUSTIFY ITS this upheaval subject classes' representatives can
EXISTENCE AND POLICIES BY USING SOME have places in the ruling class. Because when
UNIVERSAL MORAL PRINCIPLES, SUPERIORITY isolation takes place, another ruling class
ETC., lately, scientific theory and knowledge like emerges among the subject classes that often
Social Darwinism, division of labor is also hostile to the old ruling class (Mosca 1939, pp.
employed for the same purposes. Mosca 107¬ 8).Furthermore, due to reciprocal isolation
particularly rejects these two theses to use of classes, the character of upper classes change,
in political purposes. To Mosca, at a certain level they become weak in bold and aggressiveness
of civilization, ruling classes do not justify their and richer in "soft" remissive individuals. On the
power exclusively by de facto possession of it, same track, when there is fragmentation in the
but try to find a moral and legal basis for it. This society, new groups form and each one of them
legal and moral basis or principles on which the makes up of its own leaders and followers.
power of the political class rests is called Besides these revolutions are another source of
"political formula" by Mosca. The formula has a replacement of ruling class (Mosca 1939,
unique structure in all societies. "The political p.163,199).
formula must be based on the special beliefs and When Mosca compares the political systems, he
the strongest sentiments of the current social says that communist and socialist societies would
group beyond any doubt managed by officials and he
sees these Regimes as Utopia. On democracy, he
says, although gradual increase of universal published in 1911; its title in English is
suffrage, actual power has remained partly in Political Parties: A Sociological Study of the
wealthiest and the middle classes. At the same Oligarchical Tendencies of Modern
time, for Mosca, middle class is necessary for Democracy. In it, he presented his "Iron law
democracy, and when middle class declines, of oligarchy"
politic regimes in democratic countries turns to a
plutocratic dictatorship, or bureaucratic 1912-He attended the First International
dictatorship. (Mosca 1939, p.391). Eugenics Congress, where he delivered a
Ruling class has a responsive character to social papaer entitled "Eugenics in Party
change in the society and there is a close relation Organization".
between level of civilization and character of
ruling classes. According to these two Michels was considered a brilliant pupil of
complementary propositions, it can be said that Max Weber, who began publishing his
ruling class is subject of social change rather than writings in the Archiv für Sozialwissenschaft
actor of it. For example, change in division of und Sozialpolitik in 1906 and appointed him
labor from lower to higher and change in political as co-editor in 1913, but they disagreed over
force from military to wealth have changed the Michels' opposition to World War I.
type of state from federal to bureaucratic state
(Mosca 1939, p. 81, 83 ). There it seems that 1928-He then became professor of
Mosca admits a linear social change in history, as economics at the University of Basel,
opposite to Pareto. Switzerland, a post he held until 1928.
As seen, Mosca's theory is basically based on
organized minorities' superiority over 1924- he joined the Fascist Party, led by
unorganized majority. This organized minority Benito Mussolini, former director of the
consists of ruling class, but for Mosca it is not Italian Socialist Party's newspaper "Avanti!".
necessarily mean that always interest of ruling
class and subject classes are different. To him ,in 1928-he became professor of economics and
contrast they coincide many times. He saw the the history of doctrines at the University of
future of socialist system by saying that it will be Perugia and occasionally lectured in Rome
governed by officials. Died: May 3, 1936, Rome, Italy