Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sir Marcial Report
Sir Marcial Report
The Promoting Action on Research INFORMATICS TOOLS THAT PROMOTE THE USE
Implementation Health Services (PARIHS) OF EVIDENCE AND APPLY KNOWLEDGE TO
framework helps define and measure key factors PRACTICE
leading to successful implementation and has been
widely used, including by Squires et al (2012) who Adoption of evidence is now providing access
designed strategies to implement resear based policies to a single clinical practice guideline or
and procedures. Webinar.
Shifted to understanding the conditions that
Dr. Marita Titler foster ongoing and lasting change once the
Leadership for AHRQ's TRIP initiatives and evidence is found and introduced, often using
has also studied the context in which EBPs are multiple implementation strategies.
translated. Important influences found include: Implementation strategies being used to apply
the evidence are also grounded in science.
(1) tne nature of the innovation strength of evidence)
and What will facilitate implementation and what will be the
(2) the manner it is communicated to nurses and barriers? Under what conditions is successful
physician (Herr et al 2012; Titler 2010; Titler 2011). implementation anticipated?
Dr. Carole Estabrooks describe the importance of Collecting data was challenging during this
considering the significant needs found in complex care study because the patients did not want to be
environments, such as nursing homes (Estabrooks com critical. But sustained improvement depended
et al., 2013). upon understanding patient perspectives about
the benefits and challenges of care
Dr. Cheryl Stetler coordination and home telehealth.
Stetler Model of Evidence-Based
shaped the evolution of EBP and also synthesized Understanding the influence of patient perceptions
literature on use PARIHS framework, including assured that expectations could be met. This facilitated
development of a companion guide to assist translation.
researchers using PARIHS
The PARIHS framework is widely used
internationally, including Bergström, Peterson,
The information explosion presents challenges to HIT supports EBP by making it easier to access
healthcare providers who seek new evidence on an and use evidence and evidence-based tools,
ongoing basis. such as automated reminders.
For some patients or sub-groups, multiple evidence- Later, these data may become part of the body
based tools may need to be translated at the same time of evidence used to update the next version of
or specific interventions from different evidence-based a clinical practice guideline.
tools tried together.
Poe, Abbott, and Pronovost (2011) used peer
Models help nurses create a cogent plan that coaches to build and sustain competencies
pulls these interventions together. needed by nurses using EHR in clinical settings.
Decision support now occurs within the context
of change.
Both satisfaction and confidence increased It includes automated templates for orders and
through the use of an evidence-based coach referral that link to reminders or other forms evidence.
intervention.
Computerized pathways, flow charts, algortihms, and
Ongoing diligence is needed to assure the critical paths are CDS tools that facilitate
timeliness of updates, the accuracy of input as implementation in ways that reduce errors and
well as the usefulness and safety of output promoter compliance.
" BACKGROUND: The slow and haphazard process of Summary points: "Guidelines are a way to support
translating research findings into clinical practice effective clinical practice; There is a growing body of
compromises the potential benefits of clinical research. literature on the factors that influence the effectiveness
Most quality improvement (QI) initiatives are based on of guidelines; Reference to these factors will enhance
the beliefs of decision makers rather than on the the likelihood of achieving the objectives of guidelines;
growing theoretical and empirical knowledge about The use of this series of reflective questions rooted in
organizational and provider behavior change. If future this literature will support the effective development,
QI activities are to improve the translation of evidence dissemination, implementation, and review of
into practice, they should be based on an guidelines. "
understanding of the different models and strategies
for implementing research evidence and the evidence Conclusion: "McKeown states: "Medicine must be
base supporting their use. Evidence-based medicine prepared to face the tests which are inescapable in
should be complemented by evidence-based private enterprise and which it is almost unique among
implementation. public activities in having evaded hitherto: Is our work
well done? Is it worth doing? and Does it pay its
THE EVIDENCE FOR DIFFERENT STRATEGIES OF way"40 The process that leads from selecting a topic to
IMPLEMENTING CHANGE: having an impact on patient care is complex and full of
A general framework for changing practice based on potential pitfalls. None the less, there is a growing body
theoretical perspectives and research evidence of research evidence on appropriate approaches. We
considers a variety of theoretical approaches and their have reviewed this literature and produced a series of
contribution to an understanding of provider behavior reflective questions to help incorporate this knowledge
change. The framework summarizes evidence from into practice. We believe that the potential for
systematic reviews of provider behavior change, which guidelines to influence the quality of patient care is
suggest the potential of several dissemination and considerable, particularly when aligned with the process
implementation strategies that are effective under of audit and quality assurance, in the setting of the
certain conditions. Passive dissemination approaches purchaser-provider interaction, and within an overall
are largely ineffective; specific strategies to implement culture of continuous quality improvement. "
research-based recommendations appear to be 6. Haynes RB. Using informatics principles and tools
necessary to ensure practice change. Multifaceted to harness research evidence for patient care:
interventions that address specific barriers to change evidence-based informatics. Medinfo. 1998;9 Pt
are more likely to lead to changes in practice. 1:suppl 33-6.
" Many potentially remediable factors streamlined methods of critical
are responsible for this dilemma in appraisal of research and by
research transfer, including defective centralization of these procedures for
continuing education for health the development of current awareness
professionals and patients; publications and cumulative "best
increasingly complex medical evidence" databases. The Cochrane
regimens; diminishing resources for Collaboration has revolutionized the
health care; and inadequate evidence summarization (systematic review) of
management. The principles and evidence. The internet has provided
procedures of health informatics can access to patients, practitioners, and
help overcome some of these barriers policy makers, alike. Direct-from-
to research transfer, particularly such patient automated data collection
evidence management tasks as promises to move the connection
retrieving, processing, summarizing, between evidence and practice to a
disseminating and applying evidence higher level. In all of these
for clinical care. Evidence retrieval has innovations, health care practice is
been improved by better indexing and most likely to be enhanced by
electronic search engines, by intertwining best evidence with best
improved access from clinical and informatics techniques. "
other settings, and by integration of
evidence into clinical decision support Michie S, Johnston M. Changing
systems. Evidence processing has clinical
been greatly accelerated by
behaviour by making guidelines interventions often involved
specific. BMJ. 2004 Feb complicated procedures and were
7;328(7435):343-5. always an addition to the provision of
guidelines. None of the studies used
"The problems of getting people to act the simplest intervention—that is,
on evidence based guidelines are changing the wording of the
widely recognized. An overview of 41 guidelines. We examine the
systematic reviews found that the importance of precise behavioural
most promising approach was to use a recommendations and suggest how
variety of interventions including audit some current guidelines could be
and feedback, reminders, and improved. ... "
educational outreach. The effective
TRANSLATION OF EVIDENCE
INTO NURSING PRACTICE,
EVIDENCE CLINICAL
PRACTICE GUIDELINES
AND
AUTOMATED
IMPLEMENTATION TOOLS
JEVANETTE A. VELACRUZ
JULIE ANN VILLAFLORES MARCIAL N.
MESIAS DE V, RN, MAN
CLINICAL INSTRUCTOR