Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Holcomb 2017
Holcomb 2017
Holcomb 2017
DOI 10.1007/s00383-016-4049-0
REVIEW ARTICLE
Abstract This review centers on the thoracoscopic man- November, 1939, two different babies in two different
agement of esophageal atresia (EA) and distal tracheoe- cities underwent an initial gastrostomy followed, at a later
sophageal fistula (TEF). The first thoracoscopic repair of EA date, by esophageal substitution [2, 3]. The first successful
was performed by Rothenberg and Lobe in Berlin in 1999 primary repair came in 1941 and was performed by Dr.
just prior to an IPEG meeting. Since that time, the largest Cameron Haight in Ann Arbor through a left thoracotomy
report describing the use of thoracoscopy for EA/TEF repair [4]. An anastomotic leak and stricture developed, and the
came in 2005 with a multi-national, multi-institutional ret- baby stayed in the hospital for many months, but only
rospective review from six institutions around the world. The required one esophageal dilation. She recovered unevent-
outcomes reported were quite good and very comparable to fully and led a normal life. Moreover, she had a son who
large series of open operations that had been previously was born with EA and a distal fistula.
reported. This review will describe a single surgeon’s tech- EA is really a spectrum of anomalies and a number of
nique for thoracoscopic repair of EA/TEF. In addition, fur- classification systems (Gross, Vogt, etc.) have been
ther controversies regarding the usefulness of preoperative described. However, it seems best to describe the anomaly
bronchoscopy, ligation of the distal TEF, and type of suture rather than to classify it. This review will center on the
used for the esophageal anastomosis will also be discussed. thoracoscopic management of EA and distal tracheoe-
Finally, there is a discussion on the advantages and disad- sophageal fistula (TEF) which is by far the most common
vantages of the thoracoscopic approach. variant in the EA spectrum of diseases, and occurs in about
85–88% of all EA cases. The use of thoracoscopy for
keywords Thoracoscopy Esophageal atresia management of infants with isolated EA (without associ-
Tracheoesophageal fistula Thoracoscopic repair of ated TEF) has been described in two recent series which
esophageal atresia Tracheoesophageal fistula can be reviewed [5, 6]. This paper is not meant to be an
exhaustive review of EA/TEF, but more of a focus on the
thoracoscopic repair of this condition.
Introduction The first thoracoscopic repair of EA was performed by
Rothenberg and Lobe in Berlin in 1999 just prior to an
The earliest description of a baby with esophageal atresia IPEG meeting [7]. The first thoracoscopic repair of EA and
(EA) has been attributed to William Durston in 1670 [1]. TEF occurred in 2000 and was performed by Rothenberg in
However, it was not until 1939 that a baby survived fol- Denver a couple of weeks before the IPEG meeting that
lowing operative intervention. On successive days in year [8]. In 2002, two series describing thoracoscopic
repair of EA/TEF were published, one by van der Zee and
Bax, and one by Rothenberg [9, 10].
& George W. Holcomb III In 2005, a multinational, multi-institutional, retrospec-
gholcomb@cmh.edu
tive review was published describing the use of thora-
1
Department of Surgery, Children’s Mercy Hospital, coscopy for EA/TEF repair in 104 infants [11]. This
Kansas City, MO, USA remains the largest report describing thoracoscopic repair
123
Pediatr Surg Int
Table 1 An attempt at comparing the current thoracoscopic series (Holcomb et al.) with previous reports using thoracotomy for patients
undergoing repair of esophageal atresia with distal tracheoesophageal fistula (Gross Type C)
Holcomb et al Engum et al Spitz, Keily Randolph Manning et al Yanchar et al
[11] [12] [13] et al [14] [15] [16]
(2000–2004) (1971–93) (1980–84) (1982–88) (1977–85) (1989–99)
of EA/TEF in the literature. In this paper, eight very Approximately 30% of patients in all these series required
experienced minimally invasive surgeons from six institu- at least one dilation, and the recurrent fistula rate of 1.9%
tions around the world collated their results to date. The in this thoracoscopic series was actually lower than any of
mean patient age at operation was 1.2 days, the mean the open reports. Similar numbers of patients underwent an
weight was 2.6 kg, the mean operative time was 130 min, aortopexy and fundoplication in these reviews.
the mean days of ventilation were 3.6, and the mean days
of hospitalization were 18.1. Sixty-seven patients under-
went ligation of the fistula using an endoscopic clip, Technique
whereas the fistula was sutured ligated in 37 patients. This
group of patients was fairly representative of the spectrum The baby is positioned supine on the operating table and
of EA and its associated anomalies as 26 patients (25%) the oropharynx is suctioned. My preference to perform
also required a laparoscopic fundoplication, seven under- preoperative bronchoscopy will be discussed. Following
went aortopexy (six performed thoracoscopically), four bronchoscopy, the baby is intubated and placed in the left
underwent laparoscopic duodenal atresia repair, and 10 lateral decubitus position (assuming the aortic arch is on
patients had imperforate anus. Five patients underwent the left side). The position of the endotracheal tube (ETT)
cardiac operations other than VSD/ASD repair. In this is not as important if high-frequency ventilation will be
group, two patients developed a recurrent fistula at utilized, although the ETT should not be in the TEF or right
3 months and 8 months postoperatively, and three patients main stem bronchus. If conventional ventilation will be
died. A 7-month-old died of necrotizing enterocolitis, a employed, it is best to position the ETT distal to the origin
10-day-old died of congenital heart disease, and a 3-week- of the fistula (if possible). This is more easily accomplished
old died of esophageal disruption at the time of intubation when the distal fistula enters the mid-trachea.
in the intensive care unit. A small roll is gently placed under the baby’s shoulders
The results from this series were very comparable to and left flank to enhance the right intercostal spaces. A
large series of open operations for EA/TEF that were 12–14 French catheter is then placed through the baby’s
published between 1985 and 2000 (Table 1) [12–16]. mouth and into the upper esophageal pouch, and the
123
Pediatr Surg Int
table is tilted slightly to the left in reverse Trendelenburg. mal esophagus. If the dissection is unusually difficult, a
The surgeon stands on the left side of the table with the proximal TEF may be present. Once the proximal esoph-
camera operator to his/her left. The scrub nurse is usually agus has been mobilized and is ready for anastomosis, the
opposite the surgeon at the level of the camera operator. distal fistula is then ligated and divided. (It has not been
The monitor is situated opposite the surgeon for optimal ligated and divided earlier in the operation because the
viewing. distal esophageal segment will often retract into the
The first cannula is usually positioned at approximately retropleural tissues during the dissection of the proximal
the eighth intercostal space in the posterior axillary line. pouch and can, on occasion, be difficult to find.)
This 4–5 mm port is inserted using a cut-down technique, The fistula can be divided in a number of ways. A non-
and a cannula with a blunt trocar is gently advanced into locking metal clip is the most common way. As will be
the thoracic cavity. This cannula will be used for the mentioned, a locking polymer clip, Hem-o-lok (Teleflex
telescope and camera. Usually, only a small amount of Medical Research, Triangle Park, NC), can also be utilized
CO2 insufflation is needed to decompress the lung if the for this ligation. In addition, the fistula can be sharply
high-frequency ventilator (HFV) is being employed. A divided and the trachea closed with one or two silk or
45° or 70°, 4–5 mm telescope is then introduced through Vicryl (Ethicon Inc., Somerville NJ) sutures. We have
the cannula and the thoracic cavity is visualized. At this utilized all these techniques.
point, the optimal location of the two working ports can Once the fistula is divided, the esophageal anastomosis
be determined. 3-mm cannulas are introduced at the 4th is performed in a similar fashion as with the open opera-
and 5th or 4th and 6th intercostal spaces in the mid- to tion. Ideally, the posterior row of sutures is tied after all the
posterior axillary lines as working ports. If needed, a posterior sutures have been placed. At times, it may be
fourth cannula can be positioned posteriorly and inferiorly easier to tie each suture before placing the next one. We
around the 10th or 11th intercostal space through which have utilized both intracorporeal and extracorporeal suture
another instrument can be introduced for additional lung techniques, and prefer the intracorporeal approach,
retraction, if needed. whereas others prefer the extracorporeal technique. Also,
The azygos vein is well seen, as is usually the proximal there does not appear to be an advantage for one suture
esophageal pouch with the silicone catheter in it, assuming versus another. My preference is to use 4–0 silk for the
that it is not high in the thoracic cavity. As the TEF has anastomosis, but others prefer 4 or 5–0 polydioxanone
been identified preoperatively at bronchoscopy, the sur- (PDS; Ethicon Inc., Somerville, NJ), or vicryl. Once the
geon has a good idea of where the TEF enters the trachea. posterior row of sutures is tied, a 6 French tube is then
Often, if conventional ventilation is used, the TEF can be inserted through the infant’s nares, across the esophageal
seen to distend with each ventilating breath. This is usually anastomosis, and into the stomach. I find this useful for a
not as well seen with the HFV. The azygos vein is kept variety of reasons including the ability to feed the baby
intact if possible. If not, it is divided with cautery. Once the through it several days following the operation if needed.
fistula is identified, the pleura overlying the fistula is The anterior portion of the anastomosis is then completed
incised and the fistula is gently mobilized. It is important to in an interrupted fashion.
be gentle in this mobilization to protect the vagus nerve After completing the anastomosis, attention is turned
fibers which are usually seen coursing along the trachea towards trying to separate the esophageal suture line from
and along the distal esophagus. Once the TEF has been the fistula closure on the trachea. Usually, these two sites
identified, it is my preference to next identify the proximal abut each other and an intact azygos vein often serves the
esophageal pouch to gain a better understanding of the purpose of naturally separating these two closure sites.
amount of proximal pouch mobilization that will be needed Other surgeons prefer to interpose pleural or retropleural
in preparation for the esophageal anastomosis as opposed tissue to separate the two closure sites to prevent a recur-
to proceeding with fistula ligation at this time. If the two rent TEF. A small silastic drain is then inserted through one
esophageal segments are close to one another, little dis- of the incisions and positioned near the anastomosis. The
section of the proximal and distal esophageal segments will 4–5 mm cannula site is closed with 4–0 and 5–0 absorbable
be needed. However, if the segments are widely separated, sutures, and either 5–0 absorbable suture or steri-strips
it may be necessary to dissect the proximal pouch high into (3 M Company, St. Paul MN) are used to close the other
the thoracic inlet to gain esophageal length for a tension- small incisions. The anesthesia is then terminated and the
free anastomosis. Such dissection can be performed with baby is transported back to the intensive care unit, where
cautery to gently mobilize the proximal pouch. It is the baby is gradually weaned from the ventilator over a
important to be careful with this dissection to not injure the period of hours to days, depending on the baby’s preop-
membranous trachea which is lying adjacent to the proxi- erative respiratory status.
123
Pediatr Surg Int
123
Pediatr Surg Int
The two main disadvantages of thoracoscopy include the Table 3 Selection criteria for thoracoscopic EA/TEF repair in rou-
fact that it can be a very challenging technical operation tine pediatric surgery
and the concern about hypercapnia and acidosis. Not all 1 Short-gap esophageal atresia
surgeons can perform a thoracoscopic EA/TEF repair, and 2 Birth weight C2000 g
experience is required. The good results in the literature 3 Cardiorespiratory stability/no major cardiac or pulmonary
have come from surgeons and institutions with consider- malformation (such as double outlet right ventricle, severe
able experience with this disease as well as approach. It bronchopulmonary dysplasia)
does not seem likely that one can become facile with this 4 BOne major associated malformation (such as duodenal or anal
atresia)
approach if one is performing a small number of thoraco-
5 Conversion in case of:
scopic EA/TEF procedures every year or every few years.
Intraoperative adverse events
Hypercapnia, acidosis and cerebral oxygenation are
Lack of progress for approximately 15 min
concerns for infants undergoing thoracoscopic operations.
Anastomosis under tension
In a pilot, randomized control trial, 20 neonates were
randomized to either open (five congenital diaphragmatic From: Dingemann and Ure [33]
hernia (CDH), 5 EA/TEF) or thoracoscopic (five CDH, five
EA/TEF) repair [29]. Arterial blood gasses were measured patients, we have used the HFV to facilitate stability during
every 30 min intraoperatively and compared by multi-level these thoracoscopic operations since 2007 [31]. With HFV,
modeling. For patients with CDH, the thoracoscopic the patient should not develop hypercarbia. Also, the lung
approach was associated with a significant increase in deflates nicely allowing excellent visualization, with the
intraoperative hypercapnia and severe acidosis. Interest- main problem being that the baby shakes from the oscil-
ingly, there was no significant difference in PaCO2, pH, or lating ventilator. However, the surgeon becomes accus-
PaO2 in the patients undergoing open and thoracoscopic tomed to this shaking and it is usually not a limiting factor.
EA/TEF repair. In another study, mean blood pressure, With the use of the HFV and proper positioning of the ET
FiO2, arterial oxygen saturation, and cerebral oxygen sat- tube, the lung remains deflated and adequate operating
uration were continuously monitored in 20 neonates space is achieved. The duration of the operation is not as
undergoing thoracoscopic EA/TEF repair [30]. Although important because the ventilator is able to remove the CO2
there was a decrease in arterial saturation and an increase very efficiently and hypercarbia does not occur. Assuming
in arterial PCO2 following intrathoracic CO2 insufflation, a healthy 3–3.5 kg infant, initial HFV settings are a mean
these changes did not result in significant fluctuations in airway pressure of 13–15 cm of H2O, a DP of 30–35, and
cerebral oxygenation throughout the procedure. The an FiO2 of 70%. The FiO2 can usually be weaned to 40% or
authors concluded that insufflation of CO2 to 5 mmHg so after 10–15 min. If the shaking of the baby becomes
during thoracoscopy for EA/TEF seems to be safe in problematic, the Hertz can be decreased from its usual
neonates since cerebral oxygenation was preserved during initial setting of 11–13 to 8–9 (1 Hz is defined as 60
their procedures. breaths/s). A respiratory therapist accompanies the baby to
Because of concerns about hypercapnia and acidosis, the operating room and manages the ventilator during the
and the fact that anesthesia can be difficult in these operation. Therefore, for this reason, we rarely perform
123
Pediatr Surg Int
123
Pediatr Surg Int
20. Borruto FA, Impellizzeri P, Montalto AS et al (2012) Thora- 28. Lawal TA, Gosemann JH, Kuebler JF et al (2009) Thoracoscopy
coscopy versus thoracotomy for esophageal atresia and tra- versus thoracotomy improves midterm musculoskeletal status and
cheoesophageal fistula repair: review of the literature and meta- cosmesis in infants and children. Ann Thorac Surg 87:224–228
analysis. Eur J Pediatr Surg 22:415–419 29. Bishay M, Giacomello L, Retrosi G et al (2013) Hypercapnia and
21. Durning RP, Scoles PV, Fox OD (1980) Scoliosis after thora- acidosis during open and thoracoscopic repair of congenital
cotomy in tracheoesophageal fistula patients. A follow-up study. diaphragmatic hernia and esophageal atresia: results of a pilot
J Bone Joint Surg Am 62:1156–1159 randomized controlled trial. Ann Surg 258:893–900
22. Gilsanz V, Boechat IM, Birnberg FA et al (1983) Scoliosis after 30. Stolwijk L, Keunen K, Benders M (2014) The effect of Co2-
thoracotomy for esophageal atresia. AJR Am J Roentgenol insufflation on cerebral oxygenation in thoracoscopic repair of
141:457–460 esophageal atresia in neonates. Arch Dis Child 99:A401
23. Chetcuti P, Myers NA, Phelan PD et al (1989) Chest wall 31. Mortellaro VE, Fike FB, Adibe OO et al (2011) The use of high-
deformity in patients with repaired esophageal atresia. J Pediatr frequency oscillating ventilation to facilitate stability during
Surg 24:244–247 neonatal thoracoscopic operations. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg
24. Jaureguizar E, Vazquez J, Murcia J (1985) Morbid muscu- Tech A 21:877–879
loskeletal sequelae of thoracotomy for tracheoesophageal fistula. 32. St Peter SD, Calkins CM, Holcomb GW 3rd (2007) The use of
J Pediatr Surg 20:511–514 biosynthetic mesh to separate the anastomoses during the thora-
25. Goodman P, Balachandran S, Guinto FC Jr (1993) Postoperative coscopic repair of esophageal atresia and tracheoesophageal fis-
atrophy of posterolateral chest wall musculature: CT demon- tula. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A. 17:380–382
stration. J Comput Assist Tomogr 17:63–66 33. Dingemann C, Ure BM (2013) Minimally invasive repair of
26. Bianchi A, Sowande O, Alizai NK et al (1998) Aesthetics and esophageal atresia: an update. Eur J Pediatr Surg 23:198–203
lateral thoracotomy in the neonate. J Pediatr Surg 33:1798–1800 34. Dingemann C, Zoeller C, Ure B (2013) Thoracoscopic repair of
27. Frola C, Serrano J, Cantoni S et al (1995) CT findings of atrophy oesophageal atresia: results of a selective approach. Eur J Pediatr
of chest wall muscle after thoracotomy: relationship between Surg 23:14–18
muscles involved and type of surgery. AJR Am J Roentgenol
164:599–601
123